00:00for anand ram logan the privy council's decision brings an end to years of legal and political
00:06criticism surrounding the 2011 state of emergency the judgment was based on appeals brought by
00:12dominic pitilal earl eli and ashmeed mohammed who challenged the constitutionality of the
00:19emergency declared by then prime minister kamala pisan besasa on august 21st 2011 as well as the
00:27validity of emergency powers regulations the privy council upheld the declaration and the
00:33regulations on the central constitutional issues ram logan says the ruling vindicates the decision
00:39to act in the face of what he describes as an imminent threat to public safety they condemned
00:45her and said the state of emergency was unconstitutional and illegal it would lead to
00:51an avalanche of litigation that would bankrupt the government well today the privy council ruled in
00:59favor of attorney general john jeremy and the state and found that the state of emergency was
01:06constitutionally proper and lawful ram logan who served as attorney general at the time recalls
01:12the circumstances that led to the emergency including brutal killings escalating gang violence
01:17and intelligence pointing to an immediate threat to public safety he says the judgment also represents
01:24a major achievement for the current attorney general who led the state's legal defense
01:30this is a significant judgment that vindicates the innovative and resolute leadership of the
01:36attorney general at a time when the state is called upon to make full use of its lawful constitutional
01:43powers to pull the country back from the brink of lawlessness mr jeremy deserves full credit
01:51for his leadership in securing this victory in his written statement ram logan also points to the
01:57privy council's finding that there was ample evidence of the sudden and extreme outbreak of
02:03widespread brutal violence in august 2011 the board recognized that national security decisions may
02:10involve intelligence that cannot always be disclosed publicly while emphasizing that the responsibility
02:16for assessing threats rest primarily with the government and law enforcement agencies subject to
02:23constitutional scrutiny ram logan says that reasoning has implications for the government's current
02:29approach to violent crime we are today still confronted with brutal killings escalating gang violence and
02:37serious threats to public order law and safety the government has no choice but to invoke the full weight
02:46authority and power of the constitution which is the supreme law in order to try and rescue
02:54trinidad and tobago he argues that the judgment supports the use of strong legal measures provided the
03:00constitutional requirements that the constitutional requirements are met this judgment will give significant
03:07power to the government to do what is necessary to protect law-abiding citizens to ensure that public safety is
03:15not further compromised we are the brink of a precipice and dangerous times require drastic legal measures
03:23this judgment will give judicial endorsement and support for draconian drastic serious measures to be taken
03:32when it is reasonably justifiable in the public interest bearing in mind that the rights of citizens must be
03:41balanced against the need for public safety law and order however the ruling was not an unqualified victory for
03:48the state it allowed the appellance challenge concerning access to legal counsel and restored compensation of
03:55fifty thousand dollars each to earl eli and dominic pitilal the board also made clear that the
04:01circumstances of an emergency must satisfy a strict constitutional test the former attorney general is now
04:08calling for political unity in the fight against crime
Comments