Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 6 days ago
Friday, June 6th, 1913

Court Officials Worried Over News Growing Out of the Phagan Murder Mystery.

It is understood on good authority that the grand jury has been called upon to make a searching investigation in the apparent "leakage" in the detective department, which has enabled the newspapers to publish every important development in the Phagan murder mystery before such development had, often times, been brought to the official attention of the solicitor general's office. It is said that certain court officials deemed the matter of such importance that they called the attention of the grand jury to it in the hope that the responsibility might be properly placed and a repetition of the "leaks" prevented.

It is a matter of history that as soon as some new angle to the case developed it was given the widest publicity, and the case of the state, in all its details, is today known to the attorney for the defense as thoroughly as it is known to the solicitor general.

Don't Blame Reporters.

No blame is attached to the newspapers for printing the news. Court officials recognize that that is the province of a paper but they deplore the apparent ease with which the news has been secured.

The policy of Solicitor Dorsey has been one of absolute silence. To all reporters he has stated that he had nothing to give out.

Not so with the detective department. Hundreds of readers of the newspapers have learned of new angles in the Phagan case before the detective department had had time to bring the matter to the official attention of the solicitor general. At the present time the average man on the street has an intimate knowledge of the facts on which the state will base its case against Leo Frank. He knows just what witnesses will be called, just what they will testify, to just what affidavits will be presented and if he has kept a scrapbook, he has copies of these affidavits in his possession.

The surprising thing about the whole conduct of the case is the fact that there will be no surprises.

To go back and recapitulate: The fact that the Fomby [sic] woman had made a sensational affidavit leaked out shortly after she had affixed her signature to it. The ink was scarcely dry before a newspaper reporter had seen her and she had given him the substance of its contents. Following close on the heels of this came the publication of the affidavit itself.

Conley's Confession.

Next came the sensational confession of James Conley, the negro sweeper, employed at the National Pencil factory who stated that he had helped Frank dispose of the body and Conley had not recovered from the sweating process when an afternoon pink extra contained flaring headlines stating that he had made a confession. That night The Constitution reporter had little difficulty in getting the details of the confession. The subsequent publication of the affidavit bore out The Constitution's story of the morning before.
Transcript
00:00Grand Jury Probes Detective Leaks, Atlanta Constitution, Friday, June 6, 1913.
00:05Court officials worried over news growing out of the Fagan murder mystery.
00:09It is understood on good authority that the Grand Jury has been called upon to make a searching investigation in
00:15the apparent leakage in the detective department,
00:17which has enabled the newspapers to publish every important development in the Fagan murder mystery
00:23before such development had, oftentimes, been brought to the official attention of the Solicitor General's office.
00:30It is said that certain court officials deemed the matter of such importance that they called the attention of the
00:34Grand Jury to it
00:35in the hope that the responsibility might be properly placed and a repetition of the leaks prevented.
00:41It is a matter of history that as soon as some new angle to the case developed it was given
00:46the widest publicity
00:47and the case of the State, in all its details, is today known to the Attorney for the Defense as
00:53thoroughly as it is known to the Solicitor General.
00:56Don't blame reporters.
00:57No blame is attached to the newspapers for printing the news.
01:01Court officials recognize that that is the province of a paper, but they deplore the apparent ease with which the
01:07news has been secured.
01:09The policy of Solicitor Dorsey has been one of absolute silence.
01:13To all reporters, he has stated that he had nothing to give out.
01:17Not so with the detective department.
01:19Hundreds of readers of the newspapers have learned of new angles in the Fagan case before the detective department
01:25had had time to bring the matter to the official attention of the Solicitor General.
01:29At the present time, the average man on the street has an intimate knowledge of the facts on which the
01:34State will base its case against Leo Frank.
01:37He knows just what witnesses will be called, just what they will testify, to just what affidavits will be presented,
01:44and if he has kept a scrapbook, he has copies of these affidavits in his possession.
01:48The surprising thing about the whole conduct of the case is the fact that there will be no surprises.
01:54To go back and recapitulate, the fact that the Fomby woman had made a sensational affidavit leaked out shortly after
01:59she had affixed her signature to it.
02:01The ink was scarcely dry before a newspaper reporter had seen her, and she had given him the substance of
02:07its contents.
02:08Following close on the heels of this came the publication of the affidavit itself, Conley's Confession.
02:14Next came the sensational confession of James Conley, the Negro sweeper employed at the National Pencil Factory,
02:20who stated that he had helped Frank dispose of the body, and Conley had not recovered from the sweating process,
02:26when an afternoon pink extra contained flaring headlines, stating that he had made a confession.
02:33That night, the Constitution reporter had little difficulty in getting the details of the confession.
02:38The subsequent publication of the affidavit bore out the Constitution's story of the morning before,
02:44but recently Manola McKnight, a servant in the home of Leo Frank, was arrested.
02:49She, too, made an affidavit.
02:50A police commissioner, it is definitely stated, prevailed on Chief Lanford to give out this affidavit to the afternoon papers.
02:57There were three typewritten copies of it, and it was promptly turned over to the reporters.
03:01Police official talks.
03:03A prominent police official who has had no direct connection in the Fagan case said to a Constitution reporter,
03:09There is no one who likes the newspaper reporters better than I, and I have always been ready to give
03:14them any legitimate news,
03:16but I do not believe in trying a case in the newspapers.
03:19It doesn't convince a jury, and it does not bring about convictions.
03:23Suppose that a general on the eve of an important battle sent a courier out with a flag of truce
03:28bearing plans of his fortifications,
03:30and explaining just what line of attack he intended to make.
03:34How many battles would he win?
03:36Nary a battle.
03:36It's the same thing in working up evidence which is to be used in a murder trial.
03:41Unless you hold something in reserve, unless you catch the other side unprepared,
03:45you stand a mighty poor show of accomplishing anything,
03:48especially where the case is one in which circumstantial evidence plays an important part.
03:53Just what steps the grand jury will take will be looked forward to with interest.
Comments
VERDICT VOYAGER
Creator
#MurderofMaryPhagan

Recommended