00:00Initially, the Memorandum of Understanding between the U.S. and Iran had two objectives, to stop the fighting and to
00:06lead to the reopening of the Strait of Hormuz.
00:09It also, beyond that, set very broad, very vague parameters for talks on a range of more complicated issues.
00:16The challenge, however, is that because of the vagueness of the terms of the MOU, it was largely inevitable that
00:24there would be disagreements between the two sides,
00:27that there would be disagreements on the interpretation of the vague terms, and that what was meant to be a
00:33ceasefire would, in fact, not lead to a cessation of the violence.
00:37That was predictable, and that is pretty much exactly what we've seen since then.
00:42The framework agreement between the U.S. and Iran that was reached in June is very vague in terms of
00:47several aspects of its content.
00:49First of all, it procrastinates by punting down the road for future talks on all of the major issues.
00:55And this is not just symbolic, because it meant that the very deep disagreements between the two sides were not
00:59resolved by the agreement itself.
01:01On the shorter-term issues, especially the issue of not only how and when would the Strait of Hormuz be
01:07reopened, but who would control it,
01:09what would be the modalities for ensuring security and the free passage of maritime shipping in the strait,
01:16it was very vague, and both sides have very clearly been interpreting the agreement differently.
01:22Iran interprets the framework as implying that it can exercise a serious degree of control on shipping in the strait,
01:30whereas the U.S. is interpreting the agreement as implying that Iran must allow for the freedom of navigation in
01:38the Strait of Hormuz.
01:39The vagueness plays an important role in catalyzing the resumption of hostilities,
01:43in the sense that it creates significant space for the two sides to disagree on shipping in the Strait of
01:49Hormuz.
01:50But the vagueness, in many ways, is the surface, it's the tree.
01:54What remains significant deeper, more significant in a deeper way, in terms of explaining the resumption of hostilities,
02:02it goes beyond the vagueness in the framework agreement,
02:06and is explained more by the much more serious disagreements between the two sides,
02:11on Iran's nuclear program, on regional security in the Middle East,
02:16on Iran's missile program, on its drone program, on Iran's support for violent and terrorist groups throughout the region.
02:21And these are all issues that the framework agreement of June simply kicked down the road.
02:28It was entirely predictable that the ceasefire would be very incomplete, very fragile,
02:32and that there would be spikes in violence, and that is exactly what we're seeing now.
02:37If or when there is a reduction in the violence that we are seeing now, as of mid-July,
02:43as long as these deeper issues are not resolved, that violence will simply return at a later point in the
02:49future.
02:50Trump, in recent days, has said on multiple occasions that, from his perspective, the ceasefire is done, that it's over.
02:57It is significant that he's saying that, because it does represent how difficult the situation has become.
03:04That being said, we have very clearly learned, after a year and a half of Trump's second presidential administration,
03:10that President Trump can say something and mean something else.
03:13He can say something and do the opposite at the same time.
03:18So when he says that the ceasefire is over, he partially means it,
03:21in the sense that it expresses his skepticism towards the ceasefire,
03:24which I think pretty much everybody shares.
03:26But at the same time, he has also said that he is open to continuing negotiations,
03:30even if only indirectly, with Iran.
03:33So from that perspective, if we take a couple of steps back,
03:36the ceasefire is absolutely in a fragile and difficult position,
03:40but it is not necessarily over.