• 5 months ago
Transcript
00:00This is so tough.
00:02This city loves the Giants.
00:04This city loves Giants baseball.
00:06I love Giants baseball.
00:08And there are a lot of individuals on this team right now
00:13who I really enjoy rooting for, and I want to see this turn around.
00:19But there are things at times where it gets to be bigger than winning and losing.
00:24I feel terrible for Logan Webb.
00:26I really do.
00:28Honestly, that's the top of my list on the sympathy card.
00:34Logan has pitched his butt off.
00:36Logan has only gone to the playoffs once.
00:40He deserves better, and the whole organization is going in the wrong direction
00:45as he gets older.
00:46So I really feel terrible for him.
00:48But this stuff yesterday, this is cancerous stuff.
00:55It's cancerous stuff, and it just puts a whole black mark on the whole thing for everybody.
01:01And if you're driving around today and you don't know, I'm telling you, this is MLB Network stuff.
01:07They're not doing shows about, so, you know, the Braves are pretty good.
01:13I mean, Arise, great story.
01:14That's for the All-Star.
01:16Four in a row for the Marlins, Bob.
01:18Let's go back to you.
01:19No.
01:20They're like, look at Rafi freaking Devers.
01:22Right.
01:23By the way, you want to hear what it sounds like?
01:26I do.
01:26Listen to Ken Rosenthal on foul territory.
01:29Inexcusable.
01:30You cannot do what he did yesterday.
01:32It was basically insubordination.
01:35And I know fans will say, well, what about the manager?
01:39Why won't the manager bench him?
01:40Why won't Tony Vitello erupt at Devers?
01:43Not so easy to do when the player is owed more than $200 million.
01:50The major league manager has only so much power.
01:53So here we are in this situation.
01:56The Giants, of course, are in sell mode.
01:59Yeah, they'd love to trade Rafael Devers.
02:01Ha, ha, ha.
02:02Good luck with that.
02:03And I was amused by the MLB.com headline on this story today in which it said,
02:10Giants clear the air after Devers tries to wave off Pinch Runner.
02:15There was no clearing of the air.
02:17Devers did not comment after the game.
02:20Another bad look for him.
02:21And here are the Giants.
02:23They're going nowhere.
02:2415 games under .500.
02:26Only a game and a half ahead of the Rockies for the worst team in the National League.
02:32Good luck figuring out how to fix that particular mess.
02:37That's what it sounds like.
02:38They want to trade him ha, ha, ha.
02:40Ha, ha, ha.
02:41Right.
02:42Give him the ha, ha.
02:43Not the ha, ha.
02:44Not the coming ha, ha, ha.
02:46It's an important third ha.
02:47Yeah, the third ha makes it super comical.
02:50So, yeah, they would love to trade him.
02:52And I can't help but think about, like, how this gets resolved.
02:56And so you've got Devers, who has seven years plus left.
03:00He's untradeable.
03:01And you've got a manager who clearly can't manage because he's too young.
03:06He's too new, and so he can't do what needs to be done.
03:09You've got a president of baseball ops, Buster Posey, who's never done the job and is patently not doing very
03:16well.
03:16And you've got ownership that is building buildings and buying theaters and probably is not that consumed by what's going
03:24on.
03:24And so it looks to me like a ship that is just completely rudderless.
03:29It's not sinking, but it's just kind of sitting out there in the sea of mediocrity.
03:34And so, like, what's the solution here?
03:38That's the puzzle.
03:39Right.
03:39There is no solution.
03:40There's no easy answer to that.
03:41So you fire Tony.
03:42Okay.
03:42And then you replace Buster.
03:44Yeah.
03:45Okay.
03:45What does that do?
03:46Well, you still have Rafi.
03:47And, like, is Rafi suddenly going to play for a new manager and not be somebody who is a malcontent?
03:53Well, yeah, I don't.
03:54There is no quick fix here.
03:57In my opinion, at least, there's no quick fix here.
04:00And, you know, Ken has a point, as I said.
04:02No, this is the end of the innocence.
04:03But I'm not going to disagree that this is a difficult situation for Tony Bitello, especially early in a career.
04:11This is hard to figure out what to say to a microphone.
04:14People aren't going to like it.
04:15You know, they want a pound of flesh.
04:17They want Tony to come out and go to the microphone and be like, we're not going to have that
04:20crap around here.
04:21And then, you know, then there's consequences to that, too.
04:26I just want to keep stressing to people, we don't know what happened behind closed doors.
04:31And we often don't.
04:33So this idea that, oh, they just laid down and nobody said anything to Rafi, I don't know that.
04:39I don't know that.
04:40But I will say this.
04:42You know, if Rafi Devers is making hundreds of millions of dollars and is a very accomplished major league hitter
04:50and the Giants organization doesn't feel like Vitello is in a position to go have a loud, hard conversation, gee,
04:59can you think of anybody who can?
05:01Anybody in the organization have the cachet?
05:04Ooh, ooh, I have an answer.
05:05Let's go to Dan Dibley.
05:06Maybe a guy who's won three World Series and might be ticketed to the Hall of Fame, Buster Posey?
05:12Ain't no damn question he's going to the Hall of Fame.
05:14And you're absolutely right.
05:16If Tony can't do that, Buster can.
05:20I don't know if he did or if he didn't, but that you're the president and you're the badass and
05:28you have every ability to go over to Rafi and say, we're not doing that here.
05:33Now, Rafi can just as quickly be like, well, the 300 milli is guaranteed, so what are you going to
05:40do about it?
05:41Right.
05:41Pobo.
05:43Well, and, you know, well, maybe it does go that way, and then the problem gets even bigger, but for
05:51those who go, oh, this is no big deal, this is a huge deal.
05:56It is emblematic of so many things going on behind the scenes, and I can promise you the discomfort level
06:04inside that organization right now is at its absolute highest.
06:08As it should be, because, I mean, you've got the talent to be better than 15 games below, and as,
06:14I mean, the cut you just played, Kenny Rosenthal, you're a game and a half ahead of Colorado?
06:19Are you kidding me?
06:21You've got three, you have four guys, rather, in your lineup who are making nine figures.
06:25You've got one of the best pitchers in baseball.
06:28You've got a number two in Robbie Ray, who's really good.
06:31You should not be 15 games below 500.
06:33So what's the deal?
06:35Is it the manager?
06:36Yeah.
06:36Yeah.
06:37Is it the president of baseball ops?
06:39Yeah.
06:39Is it your stars?
06:40Yeah.
06:41Is it your culture?
06:42Yeah.
06:42Is it your defense?
06:43Yeah.
06:44It's all of it.
06:45Your team is an absolute, unmitigated mess.
06:49You left out the bullpen.
06:50Well, I mean, fine.
06:51Yeah.
06:51They deserve to be in there.
06:53No, they should.
06:54They deserve to be in there.
06:55And what's his face?
06:56Didn't he give it up on Friday?
06:58Henches.
06:58Oh, yeah.
06:59Old Sammy.
07:00Yeah.
07:00And I'll be honest, like, I want the Giants to win, but when he got into the game on Friday,
07:07I'm going to be totally honest.
07:09Just be authentic.
07:10Would you?
07:10When he started to struggle, there was a part of me, not a small part, a bigger part than
07:16I wanted it to be.
07:17I was happy.
07:19Old scripture, Sam.
07:24I wasn't happy.
07:25I wasn't happy, but there was part of me that-
07:28I wasn't surprised either.
07:29Well, the fact that that happened, I was like, okay, I'm glad it was you.
07:33Let's go to the phones.
07:35But first, I promise to let you know about this opportunity, and you do not want to miss
07:39it.
07:39We really, really can't.
07:41We're so excited about this.
07:43Do you want to win a round of golf at the beautiful Silverado Resort in Napa?
07:50I was just there last weekend.
07:51My gosh, the golf's incredible.
07:55And play a round of golf there with one of us, six hosts, here at 95.7 The Game.
08:03Here's what you need to know.
08:05We're giving you the chance to play golf with us on Monday, July 13th.
08:10Each host is going to be paired with a winner, so there will be six winners.
08:15All you need to do is submit a 30-second or less video of your golf swing in your best
08:23golf gear and explain why you want to play a round of golf with us.
08:30So we need the why, we need the fit, and then we need the swing.
08:35Go to 95.7thegame.com, submit your video, do that, and who knows, you might be playing
08:43a round of golf with us at beautiful Silverado in Napa, Monday, July 13th.
08:48Can't wait.
08:49It's going to be good.
08:50It's going to be real good.
08:51All right.
08:53Skills in Vallejo, lead us off.
08:54Hi, Skills.
08:55Thanks for calling.
08:56What's up?
08:58Good afternoon, Willard and Dibbs.
09:00I am glad you two are there.
09:01I wanted to talk to you about this whole Devers thing.
09:03Let's go.
09:04And Rich Urelia said he'd never seen this happen before, and I didn't catch the entire
09:10morning roast today.
09:10I didn't catch the show after that either.
09:12So I don't know if anyone's brought this up already, but in 2004, future giant Jose Guillen,
09:17then of the Angels, pulled this exact same stunt that Devers pulled on Mike Socia.
09:22Socia wanted to pinch run for him late in the game.
09:24Guillen lost his mind.
09:25He threw a fit.
09:26He packed the full dugout, and the Angels wound up sending him home for the rest of that season.
09:30And in the playoffs, I think this was in August or September of 2004, and then they wound up
09:34trading him.
09:34So in his case, in Guillen's case, what Anaheim said was that later on it was a culmination
09:39of a bunch of things that had been going on with Guillen that led to the decision of sending
09:42him home.
09:43But I don't care if it was the first time that Devers has ever stepped out of line.
09:47You do not ever show up to manager if you disagree with his decision, ever.
09:51And I don't care how wrong you think he is.
09:54You're the employee.
09:54He's the boss.
09:55I don't care if Vitello wants to pinch run Courtney Cox, Brian Cox, Nicky Cox, the late
10:00Bobby Cox for Devers.
10:02I don't care.
10:03What you do is you respectfully jog off the field, and you voice any issues you have with
10:08Vitello in his office, period.
10:10And if you're Vitello, you certainly don't try to make excuses for him, and you don't
10:13try to deflect the whole thing.
10:14That's another story.
10:15I'll close with this.
10:16When Devers came here, as we recall, he left Boston on not such good terms.
10:21And he said, he told the press or whoever, that he would do whatever the Giants wanted
10:25him to do coming here to the Bay Area.
10:28So now on top of being a bad example for Eldridge and the other young players on the team, and
10:32on top of being an underperformer for most of his time here in the Bay Area, he's just
10:36demonstrated that he's also a liar, and that it's all about him and not the team.
10:41So in my opinion, screw him.
10:42Thanks, boys.
10:42Yeah, skills, strong comments.
10:45The only difference there, and I just looked up Jose Guillen's deal with the Angels.
10:49Right.
10:49Two-year, $6 million deal.
10:51And I looked up the actual situation where it was September 26th, and he was suspended
10:58without pay by the Angels.
10:59And Mike Socia was the guy who played in the bigs, and he had managed in the bigs already,
11:05and so he's not a guy who was making that much money.
11:08And I do think that the bigger piece of it is the Tony Vitello part of it, where he's
11:12doing all this for the first time.
11:14Whether it's like, catch the bleepin' ball, or it's Willie Adamas, or it's now this, and
11:19it's Pride Night, and it's like taking Logan Webb out when you probably should have left
11:23him in.
11:23All these things he's going through, and everything when you're a first-time manager is going to
11:28be scrutinized even more.
11:29So Tony V is in a spot where he can't win, and already it's not even July, and he's faced
11:35like six or seven hot buttons.
11:38Seriously.
11:38Well, and that's all baked into the stew.
11:41You know what I mean?
11:42Like, I get stuck on this a little bit, and we'll talk it out, but I hear people when they
11:49go, oh, well, Tony's brand new.
11:51Like, he's not in a position to handle things like this.
11:54Well, then you shouldn't have hired him.
11:56Right.
11:56Because this is the job.
11:58The job is to be the leader.
12:00The job is to have respect within the clubhouse, and command and demand that.
12:06And yes, you have to come in and earn that, and that's not an easy thing to do.
12:11And so I understand and agree that Tony has been put in a really hard spot.
12:17Who knew that a lot of his best players wouldn't perform?
12:20Who knew that they would lose this many games?
12:23And so learning on the job should have been and could have been a lot easier if they'd
12:27won more games.
12:28But you didn't get, like, think about it.
12:31You brought in a brand new out-of-college manager, and then you didn't give him a bullpen,
12:38and you gave his highest, like, you gave him his highest-priced player you would know by
12:44now is a little rough around the edges as far as a clubhouse teammate.
12:49Right.
12:49So you give him all those things, and you go, boy, he's not in a position to handle it.
12:54Well, you put him in that position.
12:56So there is some on Tony, and there is certainly some above Tony.
13:03And I hate speaking about this as if it's already a foregone conclusion that it was the wrong move.
13:09But the way it's played out, it definitely was.
13:12I don't know if it's going to change, but in this moment, to assess the situation in any other way
13:20is disingenuous.
13:21Right.
13:21He's either bad at it or not equipped for it.
13:25And either one means wrong move, Skip.
13:29And it could be both.
13:30And honestly, like, I think about what happened today where Dusty May from Michigan is going to be the new
13:35coach of Dallas.
13:36And you've got Cooper Flagg, who is your young star.
13:40And you're a college coach, and he is now going to be second year into basketball.
13:44And so you can kind of build around him because you're used to coaching people like him.
13:50Yaxel Lendenborg, the Michigan player, is older than Cooper Flagg.
13:54So Dusty May goes into Dallas now with the Mavericks, and he at least is going to coach mostly younger
14:00people.
14:00And he can, like, build with a team that is a year or two years away from doing whatever.
14:06But you had Tony Vitello come into this team with Chapman and Adamas and Devers and Logan Webb and Robbie
14:12Ray,
14:13like, veterans who've been around baseball for a long time, and now you're supposed to come in and, like, impose
14:18your will?
14:19It's impossible to do that.
14:22But it's impossible, I think.
14:24Wouldn't it be fun, like, just let your mind run for a little bit.
14:27Wouldn't it be fun if when the Giants landed last night and maybe they get to the ballpark tomorrow
14:36to start their series against the Athletics, and when Rafi arrives at his locker,
14:42just Boach and Dusty are sitting there.
14:46Oh, come here.
14:49We'd like a word.
14:51You can't do that.
14:53Keep your index finger down.
14:55And I know life doesn't work that way.
14:56This is not a movie.
14:58This is actual life.
15:01But, boy, somebody's got to do something.
15:04Somebody has to say something.
15:06You cannot just leave this completely unchecked.
15:11You can't do that.
15:13You can't.
15:14I mean, he can't do what he did, and they can't just let it slide.
15:18And I'm sure they won't.
15:20It doesn't mean what they say is going to get through to him, though.
15:23But he didn't even speak post-game.
15:25Like, you had a chance to, whatever you do what you do, and you wave your finger, and you're mad,
15:30and you yell in the helmet, and then you dodge Jace Tingler in the dugout, and you go down there,
15:35and you're really mad.
15:37Okay, take a moment, cool off, and then go to the media and talk about how, you know what,
15:42it was heat of the moment, and I lost my cool.
15:44And, of course, Jonah Cox is faster than me.
15:46He has two steals.
15:47I have none.
15:48I haven't even tried this year.
15:49And, you know, Jonah Cox, maybe he should have tried to steal whatever he didn't.
15:54But, yeah, I lost my cool, and, you know, Tony was right.
15:57He could have totally defused this with a post-game presser.
16:00Sure.
16:01But he doesn't speak.
16:02That's not Rafi.
16:03Right.
16:03I don't have any confidence that Rafi even feels that way.
16:06But what is Rafi?
16:08Like, what do we know of Rafi?
16:09Well, who was it that, why am I already blanking?
16:14It was Jesse Rogers, right?
16:16He can hit, but he can't lead.
16:20Right.
16:20And he said that before the weekend.
16:24Nice call, Jesse.
16:25Yeah.
16:26Nice call.
16:26And, I mean, we have other calls from, like, a year-plus ago
16:30when they actually made the trade,
16:31and people weighing in on how, you know, maybe Rafi wasn't that guy.
16:35Well, Eric in Walnut Creek says he's one of them.
16:37Let's go to Eric.
16:38Hi, Eric.
16:39What's going on?
16:40Thanks for calling.
16:42You know, this is going to be a two-part call.
16:44You're not going to like the first part.
16:45Second part's going to make you hang up,
16:47because I was right about something a couple weeks ago,
16:49and you guys were wrong when I said that Devers don't want to be here
16:53when we were talking about Triple Valley
16:56and how the organization is focused on making the ballpark fun
17:00and the fact that we can't get boppers here
17:03and make them happy because of a number of things.
17:07And I just knew from his body position, the way he was acting,
17:11he just didn't want to be here.
17:13And then we just see this thing spill over,
17:15and it's a bad concoction.
17:18Johnson, Buster, Vitalo, it all doesn't work.
17:21We got this terrible log jam at first and at third.
17:24I feel really bad for Casey Schmidt,
17:27because I would hate to be all over the place.
17:29And, you know, who orchestrated this whole thing?
17:32I do blame Buster on all of this.
17:35Vitalo's in a very weak position.
17:37We got two tiers of players.
17:39We got the untouchable veterans that he can't lecture.
17:42Then we got this great cast of characters of Jung-Hoo and Arise
17:47and, you know, Schmidt and Eldridge, and I feel bad for them.
17:51And, you know, the manager is supposed to meld those two kind of tiers
17:54of players together, and he can't do it.
17:57And there's really no place for us to go.
18:00Buster's got to be a maestro.
18:02And, you know, the other thing I want to say is Greg Johnson's the problem.
18:06He's very happy.
18:07He's very content.
18:08You guys said this earlier.
18:10He's focused on developing properties.
18:12He's focused on Franklin Templeton.
18:14We could be the 14th largest payroll, you know, in the league
18:18and then have these three guys we can't move
18:21because we're paying them so much money.
18:23I mean, I'm happy that finally the fan base is rising up,
18:27going like, this might be too much.
18:29Let's not focus on Baby Yoda night and Panda outfits.
18:32We got to fix this thing now.
18:34It's not fun anymore.
18:36It's not about the ballpark.
18:37Eric, thanks.
18:38It's good now.
18:38Yeah, Eric, thanks.
18:39Appreciate it.
18:40I don't think your call was as controversial as you thought it was going to be.
18:43I think that's right in line.
18:44The one thing that you're victory lapping on, you may well be right.
18:49I don't actually know that we've got a final answer on that.
18:55I'm not going to – one thing I won't do,
18:56I'm not going to act like I'm in Rafi Devers' head
18:59and that I know that he doesn't want to be here.
19:02And, in fact, you kind of made it about the ballpark.
19:05Like, yesterday wasn't even a home game.
19:07Like, does he not like Tony Vitello?
19:10Does he not respect Tony Vitello?
19:13I think that you can probably start to make that judgment
19:16because what he did yesterday was flatly disrespectful.
19:20And it was disrespectful toward Tony Vitello.
19:23That's what I mean.
19:24Yeah, and no one else.
19:25Well, I think it's disrespectful to the teammates.
19:28Like, it's definitely disrespectful to Jonah Cox to be like,
19:31shoo?
19:32You shooed a teammate?
19:33He comes out with the oven mitt on ready to, like, run the bases,
19:36and he stopped, and then he stopped again.
19:39And, like, he's getting shooed by Rafi Devers.
19:42He's doing the okey-doke.
19:43Well, and he's also thinking, like, should I go away?
19:45Like, I've been shooed by Rafi.
19:48I probably should leave.
19:49But, I mean, you've been announced.
19:51Like, you can't leave.
19:52Yeah, you're not allowed to even not go, right?
19:54So there's all that.
19:55So I think that you can make the inference that Rafi does not fully respect
20:01Tony Vitello in a healthy way.
20:03Does that mean he doesn't want to be a Giant?
20:05Maybe.
20:06Maybe.
20:06I have no idea.
20:08I have no idea if Rafi Devers does, quote, doesn't want to be here.
20:12I know that everybody is real, super frustrated.
20:18Some of it, though, for their own doing.
20:21Like, that's not an excuse.
20:22Right.
20:23You know, they're losing.
20:25Yeah, none of them will like work right now.
20:27They stink at baseball.
20:28And that's what they do for a living.
20:30And that's where the frustration normally would lie,
20:32but I do think that there's more of it where you've got a young manager
20:36who's never done it before.
20:37He's never been in pro ball.
20:38And so if you're a vet and you don't like the way that things are being done
20:42and you're losing, you can get that frustration to come out in many other ways.
20:46And I don't know.
20:48We talked about this a long time ago.
20:50Like, how could Tony Vitello possibly lose his job after one year?
20:54And I do think the one thing that I have said all along is if you lose the clubhouse.
20:59And something like that shows me that maybe, I mean, you haven't lost the whole clubhouse,
21:04but that act was, to me, a player saying, no, no, Skip, I've been here longer.
21:11You're not taking me out.
21:12It's troubling.
21:15It's getting more believable.
21:16Yep.
21:17Your take is getting a lot more believable.
21:20The idea that the Giants would cop to the embarrassment and fire a manager a year after this happened
21:26sounded ludicrous to me a few weeks ago.
21:28It's getting more believable.
21:30Especially when you think about, like, what's the fix?
21:32If it's broken, and I do think it's broken, you're 15 games below, like, what's the easiest
21:37and the cheapest way to fix it?
21:39It's not trade Rafi or Willie or Matt.
21:42It's get rid of the manager.