Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 2 days ago
ESPN senior college football writer Heather Dinich checks in with The Morning Shift to break down the unprecedented fallout from the Brendan Sorsby legal decision. They discuss why trust in the sport has completely evaporated and what comes next for the locker rooms trying to navigate this disaster.

Georgia AD Josh Brooks isn't playing games. They debate his massive decision to ban the Dawgs from scheduling Texas Tech and whether a wave of major Power-4 programs are about to follow Georgia's lead.
Transcript
00:00I don't know if I would say people are going to lose interest, but I think mistrust is at an
00:07all-time high.
00:08Well, and Heather, the AD at Georgia, Josh Brooks, he forbid his teams from playing Texas Tech.
00:14How many other schools, I mean, some are coming forward already, how many other schools do you think are going
00:18to have this stance?
00:20A lot. I mean, the Big Ten is expected to discuss it here in the next couple of days.
00:28And in terms of a league-wide mandate to not schedule them in any sports in the regular season, according
00:36to my colleague Pete Thamel, that is significant.
00:40I mean, I think the one thing that came out of this that's positive, and I tweeted this yesterday, was
00:47the overwhelming consensus throughout college athletics from coast to coast that this is wrong.
00:53And maybe it spurs Congress to act quickly, because if anything's going to change, that's what has to happen, and
01:03it has to happen quickly.
01:05I was in D.C.
01:06I've been to the summertime. It's the off-season. I've been to the White House. I've been to the United
01:11States Senate.
01:12You know, like, what's spring football? I'm in D.C. That's what I'm doing.
01:16I mean, like, this is crazy.
01:20If you're there this weekend or next weekend and catch a UFC fight, the thing for me is, would anyone
01:26boycott or, you know, just not show up for their game this year against Texas Tech?
01:31Because, you know, there was some supposed—you never know what you're reading anymore online, if it's real or not, but
01:37reading some Big 12 schools were anti-playing them as well.
01:40And would any of those teams just say, you know what, we're not going to do it, or would that
01:44then breach TV contracts, and then you have a whole other bunch of issues that arise?
01:52Right. That's where you do need general counsel in the room to answer that question.
01:56And I don't know the answer to that.
01:59I think the threats are real because emotions are so high, but actually following through with it is certainly another
02:06question.
02:07I mean, one of my colleagues texted me yesterday.
02:09He said, you know what I would read?
02:11I would read a piece answering the question how the College Football Playoff Selection Committee would view a team that
02:17has all wins out of forfeits in their league.
02:21And I was like, that's a great question.
02:24I don't know what's going to happen.
02:25So here's the other thing, too, guys, is the NCAA is appealing this, right?
02:30I mean, it was like 4.30 yesterday that the NCAA filed its appeal.
02:37So while I think it's absolutely right for a lot of people to be upset about this in college athletics,
02:45I also think we need to take a deep breath this morning and see what the outcome of all of
02:51it is and how it shakes out.
02:53But in a way, it's like a great red flag for everybody to wake up and do something.
02:59Hanging out with senior writer for USPN, Heather Denich.
03:03Heather, one of the reactions we've had this morning, and I'm curious to get your take, and maybe you've had
03:08conversations with colleagues, maybe you haven't.
03:10I would really love to know how much attention the NFL, the NBA, Major League Baseball, because what we think
03:18is a college football problem right now is really not.
03:21This becomes a sports problem, this becomes a sports book problem, and this becomes a judicial issue.
03:28And I'm curious if you've had any conversations with anybody that are looking at NFL, NBA, professional sports leagues and
03:33saying,
03:33we better look pretty closely on what's going on here.
03:38Not necessarily at those levels, but you are right.
03:42But the difference is those freaks in professional sports hold their athletes accountable for things like this.
03:49I mean, there are rules, and they enforce them.
03:54The NCAA's hands are tied here, which is the whole part of the problem for the NCAA in general, as
04:01we talk about eligibility transfer, I mean, gambling, all of it.
04:07And this is, is gambling and sports betting an issue at every level?
04:13Yeah, it's an issue in high school.
04:15I mean, my brother-in-law teaches high school.
04:17I can tell you there are kids in his class who are betting on how many clouds are in the
04:22sky today, you know?
04:23So that's where we are as a society.
04:27Like, it's real at every level, everywhere.
04:31But the NCAA can't do anything about it with this lawsuit.
04:37We'll see what the appeal does, though.
04:38I can keep going back to that.
04:39Heather, how can anyone have rules?
04:41How can anyone have rules if the, if when you get caught, you, you know, and I thought, I think
04:47Nicole Auerbach wrote about this, but the mental health side of it and say, well, there's no accountability.
04:52And then some random judge in a, in a county near you that maybe sides with you or likes what,
04:59who you play for says, you know what?
05:01They're right.
05:02The men, this, this is, this is bad for their mental health and they can do whatever they want.
05:05I mean, how do you have rules?
05:06How do you, how does anyone have rules with this kind of, uh, world?
05:10Well, that's why the commissioners have spent so much time and money, millions, millions, millions of dollars, so many hours
05:20trying to lobby Congress for federal legislation.
05:24That's why, because at some point you have to have the government step in and create those rules because the
05:34NCAA isn't able to enforce its own.
05:37It needs antitrust protection.
05:38I mean, that's, but I mean, guys, look, this, this goes back to forever land with the NCAA putting itself
05:47in this position.
05:49The lack of leadership for decades in college athletics is why it is where it is right now.
05:59I mean, let's not cry woe is me for the NCAA here, which is made up of all of the
06:04schools, right?
06:06So it put itself in this position.
06:08I'm not saying that what happened is right by any stretch of the imagination or excusable, but they're here for
06:15a reason.
06:15So what has to happen now is leadership at the highest levels.
06:19And I'm looking at you, Big Ten and SEC, you formed this joint advisory commission, you know, a couple of
06:26years ago to try and assert some leadership in here.
06:30Can't make a decision on the playoffs.
06:32Can't make a decision, you know, and, and Congress can't save everybody from everything.
06:36So at some point the parents in the room have to speak up, you know, so it's just, that's kind
06:43of where it's at.
06:44The whole thing's a mess and it's an uncomfortable spot.
06:47But like, I believe deep down inside that all of these people are trying to do what's best for college
06:53athletics.
06:54I do believe that.
06:55Is money at stake?
06:57Yeah, absolutely.
06:58Everybody wants more money.
06:59Everybody wants more power, blah, blah, blah.
07:00But when you talk about the Greg Sankey's and the Tony Petitie's of the world, and even the politicians involved
07:06on both sides of the aisle, they want to fix this.
07:10I truly believe that.
07:11And that's what I'm clinging to.
07:12We are joined by senior college football writer for ESPN, Heather Dinnich, on the morning shift.
07:18And we've been talking about, you know, the big reactions that these schools are having to Texas Tech.
07:24They're saying they won't play them.
07:25Everyone's kind of talking big right now, as you mentioned.
07:27We've still got to wait to see how it shakes out.
07:29Given how united everyone is about the decision that came down yesterday, where do you think it could shake out,
07:36too?
07:36What do you think the actual outcome could look like?
07:41That's a good question, too.
07:42I mean, the NCAA could win the appeal.
07:45Swirsby could be ineligible.
07:48Here's a wild idea.
07:49What if Texas Tech said, man, the backlash to this is really big.
07:54We're just not going to play them.
07:56What if the NCAA says, go ahead, you can play them, but you've got to forfeit those games?
08:01I asked the NCAA yesterday if that's a possibility, and I'm still waiting on that answer.
08:06So, you know, I think it could go a couple different directions.
08:09When I go back to the Congress and the federal legislation, if that's going to happen, it has to happen
08:17super fast.
08:18Because the senators go out of session.
08:20Congress is out of session in August.
08:22It's an election year.
08:24So if they don't mark up that bill in July with the Commerce Committee, the Commerce Committee would have to
08:30vote on it.
08:31But their vote would send a poll throughout the Senate of whether or not they should take it seriously.
08:36And if the Senate passes it, they need 60 votes, then maybe the House does it, then you get some
08:42movement.
08:43But I'm telling you guys, I know how this works in D.C. because I live here.
08:48And it's a long shot.
08:51But maybe this will fuel the fire a little bit.
08:54Real quick before we let you go, Heather, you brought up Texas Tech, possibly.
08:58You know, just crazy thoughts that, hey, what if they're like, hey, the backlash is too much.
09:02You brought up the NCAA.
09:03What's the Big 12's role in all this?
09:06Does the Big 12 have any power at all?
09:08If all the other member institutions say, hey, we're not going to stand for this, does that kind of force
09:12Texas Tech's hand?
09:15It could.
09:17I mean, Brett Yormark, the commissioner yesterday, issued a statement that they're going to talk about this with their membership.
09:26I don't know that the Big 12 could issue any separate punishment, if that's what you're asking.
09:34We've seen that happen.
09:35We've seen it happen with the Big 10 in Michigan.
09:42So, it's certainly possible.
09:44But in my head, I'm also like, if the NCAA can't do this, how's the Big 12 going to do
09:49it?
09:51Such a rough thing to wake up to and talk about today.
09:55Heather, we appreciate you hanging out with us always.
09:58And always appreciate your opinion on things like this.
10:01All right, guys.
10:01Thanks so much for having me on.
10:03There you go.
10:03Heather Denich.
10:04Thanks so much to Heather for joining us today.
10:06I am so curious about her idea if Texas Tech would just be like, look, we're just not going to
10:11play you because it's been too, too much.
10:15Yeah, that's exactly why I wanted to ask about the Big 12 because those are the ones that are really
10:21you have to schedule.
10:22Like the non-conference things and the Josh Brooks, like, okay, do away with that.
10:25The Big 12 games, that's where your TV contract is.
10:28That's where all the other stuff comes in.
10:30And I'm just curious how those other member institutions feel.
10:32So it's got to be –
10:33Well, that's what she told me is they got to have counsel because there's a breach of contract in there
10:39with the TV deal.
10:41And you could cost the whole league whatever, I don't know, billions of dollars, I guess, if that's where their
10:47TV deal is.
10:47I'm not sure what the Big 12 TV deal is.
10:49I know it's the third largest of the power four.
10:54There's going to be a lot of conversation around this topic leading up to college football.
11:01It's going to be uncomfortable at the same time the whole way through.
Comments

Recommended