• 7 months ago
A ground report from West Bengal's Bhabanipur captures the mood of the voters as the stage is set for the prestige battle between Trinamool Congress supremo Mamata Banerjee and BJP candidate Suvendu Adhikari.
Transcript
00:07Oh
00:19Helicopter land
00:30Let's go!
02:13The heat and dust of an election, souvenirs for a political journalist.
02:26It is a summer of aspiration, allegiance and antagonism.
02:38A summer that will etch Bengal's political future.
02:46The path to it, unpredictable, difficult to navigate, full of blind turns.
02:55A battle of prestige, honour, retribution, where one hopes political history repeats itself,
03:04while the other attempts to change the hand of history.
05:50?
05:51?
05:51?
05:52?
05:52?
05:52?
05:53?
06:02?
06:03?
06:03?
06:03?
06:03?
06:03It's a problem.
06:04It's a problem for children.
06:08For children?
06:09Yes.
06:10Is everyone getting the scheme or not getting the scheme?
06:13Yes, we get the scheme.
06:14Who will be?
06:16Who will be?
06:18Who will be?
06:19Who will be?
06:19Who will be?
06:20Who will be?
06:20Who will be?
06:27Who will be?
06:32Who will be?
06:34What's your name?
06:36What's your name?
06:38Manju.
06:39Manju, what do you call?
06:41You sell the goods.
06:43How do you sell the goods?
06:45How do you sell the goods?
06:48Tell us.
06:50We don't know anything.
06:52Do you like it?
06:55Or do you like it?
06:57Tell me.
06:58I don't know.
07:01Who is this?
07:02It's not the same.
07:04It's not the same.
07:05What do you do?
07:06I'm talking about time.
07:07Why?
07:08Why do you pass the goods?
07:09When will the goods go to the goods?
07:11When will the goods go to the goods?
07:12It will go to the goods.
07:13It will go to the goods.
07:16The goods go to the goods.
07:17What do you recommend?
07:22Is theä»¶ of the goods?
07:25This.
07:29What's household food..
07:35Is it something?
07:37Cosutta food?
07:38Is there anything?
07:38all of us should receive money from the people.
07:45What happens to the people?
07:47What do you do to the people of the people?
07:49No.
07:49But no.
07:50How are you?
07:51Do you get people from where they are?
07:54Who you are?
07:54We are also.
07:55Do you also get people from where you are?
07:56Sure.
07:57Would the people like the people...
07:58How do the people get money from where you go?
08:00If you go to where you go.
08:01I go to the doctor.
08:03The doctor?
08:04Yeah.
08:05He is a doctor who had the drugs.
08:06How does it feel?
08:09We are very good.
08:11If we are working here,
08:12then we will have money.
08:15Let's take care of it.
08:16Let's take care of it.
08:18Who should come back?
08:20In the government?
08:21Do you want to come back?
08:23Do you want to come back?
08:24Do you want to come back?
08:24Do you want to come back?
08:25Do you want to come back?
08:27Do you want to come back?
08:38Do you want to come back?
08:39It feels so warm.
08:42It feels so warm.
08:46We are taking care of it.
08:46It feels so warm.
08:47It feels so warm.
08:48We were faint in Delhi.
08:49We came from Delhi.
08:53Do you speak Hindi?
08:56Do you speak Hindi?
08:58Do you learn from where?
08:59Where do you learn from Hindi?
08:59Do you learn from here?
09:01Here is a good thing.
09:02What do you find?
09:03A may not.
09:06We are in Tangna.
09:07You are Bengali.
09:09Do you warm Hindustani?
09:13Dearinhos, you should perform Bengali.
09:14Oh you are Bengali?bourida.
09:18You are optimist.
09:18How are those Bengali
09:19countries? How do your app?
09:19They are beaten from digestion.
09:22Are Bengali countries such as
09:23Bengali countries? That's Bengali countries.
09:26They are Sri Lanka.
09:291-10 months ago?
09:321 second.
09:34Your mother is in Delhi?
09:37We have lived there.
09:38Your mother is in Delhi.
09:42Do you like Delhi or Kolkata?
09:44We like it in Kolkata, but the reason we like it is in Delhi.
09:48Did you like it?
09:50Yes, I like it.
09:51It was hot or cold?
09:52It was hot, the time it was hot.
09:54There wasn't so much heat on these people.
09:57How are we, at this time?
09:58It's very hot at this time.
09:58How much heat is there?
10:00This is not so hot.
10:03I'm talking about what we call from Delhi.
10:05What do we call?
10:07I'm telling myself that our people stay quiet.
10:12If you are saying this emotionally, that's good.
10:14That's not for you.
10:16Yes, that's good.
10:18I'm talking about this as a little bit.
10:21You're saying what?
10:24What did you like?
10:28I like your mother.
10:28Very good.
10:29For a child's sister, she is saying, come here.
10:31And she won't go.
10:33She won't go, my daughter's little girl.
10:34I love her.
10:38I love her father.
10:41I love her dad.
10:44Your father is here.
10:46Don't you want her?
10:47Don't you?
10:49Because she'll love her.
10:50When will they come from?
10:52Mody will come.
10:53You just got one...
10:56It changed!
11:00Mody will come.
11:01Didi will come?
11:02I didn't know.
11:04Didi will come.
11:04Didi will come?
11:05Didi will come.
11:06Joy Sera.
11:09Joy Sera
11:10Joy Sera.
11:13Is he just speaking the right way or enjoying it?
11:16No.
11:17Is he too didi?
11:29it's a great time to be a woman in Bengal it's that time when the Bengali woman matters most
11:38that time when her vote could be the difference between triumph and failure and the BJP is going
11:48all out to rule that very vote in its manifesto the BJP has announced
11:563,000 rupees monthly financial support to women 33% reservation in government jobs dedicated
12:05police battalion and Durga security squad for women's safety separate squads for
12:11self-defense free HPV vaccination and widespread breast cancer screening
12:30all of this to counter a slew of schemes that Manta Banerjee has ruled out for her strongest vote
12:38bank women
12:46look at Bhandar 1500 rupees to general category 1700 rupees to schedule cost
12:54kanyashree an annual scholarship of 750 to unmarried girls and a one-time grant of 25,000
13:02on reaching 18 years rupashree scheme a one-time financial grant of 25,000 for families for the
13:11marriage of adult daughters above 18 years of age self-help groups for micro lending financial
13:18independence free diagnostic services and health checks for women in government facilities
13:28Mamata Banerjee has cultivated and nurtured the woman constituency and post-poll surveys make that clear
13:38distinction 2021 when Mamata Banerjee won 49% of the women's vote against the BJP's 37%
14:16Cenobha Banerjee won 11週 1.ха
14:18When friends spend their jobs on Bhandari 1. David train them down from the embodies
14:22very close to the women's gel then did not come
14:23bad until school
14:28What do we do?
14:30We have done so much in the hospital, so we have a lot of value for you.
14:35What value is it?
14:37It is the value that we can go on the road.
14:40DJP says that RGC is not safe today.
14:43No, that is a lot of things.
14:45We say a lot of things.
14:47But one thing we say is joy.
14:49Sato Sati, Jubo Sati, Kornasri, Lokkir Bhandar,
14:53What do we do?
14:54We all do.
14:56We all do.
14:58We all do.
15:13Not just women, but the didi image,
15:17accessible, combative street fighter,
15:20has helped Mamka Banuji connect across class lines.
15:24Intense personal loyalty from party cadre
15:27and an ability to directly connect with the voters
15:31while overcoming ideological or institutional setbacks.
15:45Mamka Banuji never quite ever does a road show.
15:49It's a padhyatra where you can see tiny frame,
15:53waving her hands, folded hands, hoping that Babanipur
15:58will give her another chance this time around.
16:10Mamka Banuji now faces Shubindu Adhikaru
16:14from her constituency of Babanipur.
16:18The SIR impact on her constituency is also being closely watched.
16:23The total number of voters that have been deleted from Babanipur
16:27stand at 50,000.
16:3050,000 was the margin that Mamka Banuji won Babanipur
16:35in a by-election after losing Nandi Gram.
16:39In 2024, general elections, if we extrapolate data
16:44of the assembly leads across West Bengal.
16:47From Babanipur, the TMC was leading with a margin
16:51of a little over 5,000 votes, with 50,000 deletions.
16:56And the 2024 data, how will Babanipur vote this time,
17:02what will be the result, remains to be seen.
17:06.
17:45Mamata Banerjee has cultivated a potent following of being the Bengal ki beti, 71-year-old wearing
17:54chappals, walking through her constituency, facing a battle of her lifetime.
18:25For those who don't know, Neerja Chaudhary, very, very senior journalist, she is in Bengal
18:29covering the election and someone, Shikha Mukherjee, who got the last election bang on, where most
18:34of us were wondering what's going to really happen, yes.
18:37He came on the 90s, going back to Delhi today, he's been fascinated, this time.
18:43Biggest observations?
18:44This election is about Mamata Banerjee.
18:48Mamata Banerjee is a phenomenon, the like of which we've not seen, I don't know whether
18:53she'll win or lose, because what I hear, again and again and again, it's a 50-50 election.
19:0050-50 is something like a, you know, Nara, that you hear in different parts.
19:05So, and yet I would also say that there is a greater undercurrent for change than I had
19:13thought.
19:13I found that I stuck to this.
19:17In Bhavanipur, where she's standing, Calcutta, and in 24 Pargana South, which is supposed
19:24to be TMC's stronghold, and I went into villages there to get a sense of what rural women think.
19:31I think there also, it has been dented, and people I asked here, very near where she lives
19:36in Calcutta, her home.
19:39Bhavanipur.
19:41Women, what is the difference?
19:44I talk to women who are going to go for the BJP, and of course those who are solidly with
19:50her in the slums and areas around.
20:00women who voted for her earlier, may now shift.
20:058 will shift or 2 will shift?
20:088 will shift.
20:08I am exactly repeating the words.
20:11So out of 10, 2 women can shift?
20:121 or 2 women is the way they put it.
20:15But I would still say because she is the buffer and standing there preventing what could have
20:28been a tsunami.
20:29It is hard.
20:31And there is no anger against her.
20:33They will say, okay, even those who are voted against her will say, yes, we are getting the
20:39lucky bandha, Yojana, 1500 rupees.
20:42But actually, if you look at it, what she's giving, she's taking away through inflation.
20:48If you look at the fact that the BJP's manifesto offered women 3000 rupees, double what she's
20:56given.
20:571500.
20:59There is no traction for it.
21:03Why?
21:04It's a question because, you know, the Maharashtra polls swung on the basis of the extra
21:10250 rupees.
21:11But that was already being given.
21:12It was money in hand.
21:14Here it's a promise.
21:15Here it's a promise.
21:17So if you look at it that way, are women investing all that different?
21:24That they don't need the money?
21:25No.
21:25I don't agree.
21:28I think there is a kind of loyalty factor.
21:33You still think it's there?
21:35Where loyalty to Maharashtra is not transactional.
21:39It's not votes for cash.
21:42Okay.
21:42So I think that the, that a bulk of her women's vote is still with her.
21:50The minority vote, not 100% of it was ever with her because it was, it went to the Congress
21:57of the left to a certain extent.
22:01That vote has consolidated behind her.
22:04But this time there is, it's a very, very interesting play that we are seeing.
22:10The Congress is going to eat up some of that Muslim vote.
22:14Secondly, they talk about the party.
22:16They are very unhappy with it.
22:18And safety of women is an issue.
22:21Many women have articulated that.
22:23And again, and again, and again, joblessness.
22:27We don't get, our children don't get jobs.
22:29And the economic distress.
22:31And there, more needs to be done.
22:33So those are things.
22:34But at the end of it, you know, it's not one, two, three, these reasons.
22:38At the end of it, Mamta ko dekh liya for 15 years, maybe let's try.
22:43So that is legitimizing the BJP in a way it wasn't respected even five years ago.
22:50In the rural belt, in areas where there is a dominant Hindu vote, and where the Muslim
22:55vote is less than about 27%.
22:56And these are the areas, at least in the first phase, where the TMC hopes to do well.
23:01Deerbhum, East Midanapur, West Midanapur, Bakura, Purulia.
23:06Where you can see that, and the campaign is that much more polarizing there.
23:11So where a Suvindu Adhikari in Bhawanipur will speak very differently.
23:16And the kind of speech that he gives in a Nandi Gram.
23:19Nandi Gram, his speech, other than Jai Shri Ram, begins with why Muslims will never vote him.
23:23And then you need to outvote the Muslims.
23:25And Muslims in connotation of Mamta Banerjee here.
23:28You see now that being normalized?
23:32Do you see that happening?
23:33That polarization, yes.
23:33Because last time it didn't happen.
23:34That polarization has, is the effect of the opposition, of the BJP being the opposition
23:43for five years.
23:44Of course that polarization has now reached that level of confidence.
23:48That is their brand.
23:51Accepted by the people.
23:52It was rejected earlier.
23:54You know, that is where Bengal becomes very confusing.
23:57Even to me.
24:00Because, you know, at one level there is this, the Muslim is our enemy.
24:06Outvote the Muslim.
24:08You're turning West Bengal into West Bangladesh.
24:11Which is Suvindu Adhikari's favorite line.
24:14Favorite line.
24:15And all of that.
24:16Miss Choudhury, final comments.
24:19You, nobody has the edge right now.
24:21It's still up in the air.
24:23It could go either way.
24:24That's what you're going to say?
24:25Yes.
24:26You know, if one wanted to be cautious.
24:28Yes.
24:30Otherwise, your instinct tells you, given the way things are stacked, that she would make it.
24:37She would make it.
24:38She would make it.
24:39But that's, you know, again, something to stick your neck out and say this.
24:47What, a very interesting part of it is that like Tamil Nadh, she's also playing on the anti-Deli sentiment.
24:55True.
24:56And, you know, sub-nationalism around fish and rice.
25:00Nukkad meetings are, you know, talking about this.
25:03Enough, as you say, to have Anurag Thakur come and counter it.
25:07Plus they don't have a face, a Bengali face they can market out there.
25:13And here she is such a tall leader at the end of the day.
25:17A Bengali leading from the front.
25:20So I think all these things are, the BJP may have to do a little more.
25:25But what they have achieved already is phenomenal.
25:30It's phenomenal.
25:33This is an unpredictable election.
25:35Will the cult of Didi endure?
25:39Or is Bengal ripe for change?
25:42History stands testimony that entrenched dominance isn't permanent.
25:48The fall of the left in 2011 is only but a reminder.
25:53But is it time just yet?
25:56Or not?
25:58We'll only know come the 4th of May.
26:18What is the reason you are today?
26:22New Bengali.
26:34The white kids are going to be black after we are done with this coal mine.
26:38The white kids are going to be black after we are done with this coal mine.
26:53The white kids are going to be black after we are done with this coal mine.
26:56That means it's very noisy.
26:57You look great.

Recommended