- 4 hours ago
Category
📺
TVTranscript
00:11Police emergency, what's the location?
00:14Bar, train station, perry bar please.
00:18In a puppet phone box.
00:24There's blood everywhere.
00:26I've just been raped and attacked.
00:31Oh, put the shit out of me.
00:37I'm bleeding everywhere.
00:39Okay, stay on the line for me.
00:41I've got officers coming to you, please don't move.
00:48I'm bleeding everywhere.
00:49I'm bleeding everywhere.
01:12I'm horrible.
01:30In North Birmingham, a woman has reported being attacked and raped in a public phone box
01:36in the early hours of Saturday morning.
01:41While she's taken to hospital for treatment, a forensic investigation gets underway.
01:49This was a really, really brutal and vicious attack.
01:54You don't expect someone to be raped in a telephone box on a busy road in the early hours
02:00of the morning.
02:01She's gone out for a night out and she's not safe to walk the streets.
02:07So, the telephone box is where the actual incident happened, isn't it?
02:10I mean, it's a real vicious attack.
02:11It's horrific, isn't it?
02:13Yeah.
02:14At one o'clock-ish in the morning, how busy is the traffic and how well is it lit as
02:19well?
02:19You don't know, do you?
02:21So, I think we've swapped the offence location.
02:25I'll have a look just to see if we can get any cellular material.
02:28Yeah.
02:29It's very brazen to do it out of the open.
02:33I'm amazed that nobody saw or stopped.
02:39Crime scene coordinator, Joe Ward, directs a detailed examination of the phone box, looking
02:46for any evidence that may help police identify the attacker.
02:53There wasn't anything to do that right there.
02:59Any public telephone box can cause some issues.
03:04Members of the public use that phone box.
03:06There'll be their DNA, as well as obviously any fingerprints as well.
03:11And that's kind of contaminating the scene, as such.
03:15You can already see initial marks here.
03:17Yeah.
03:17When they appear to be in blood.
03:21The blood in the phone box is mainly contact marks, so someone that's bleeding or has got
03:26blood on them actually making contact with the surface.
03:29There's a bit there and there's a bit inside here, so on the side of that you want to look
03:33in some more.
03:34Yeah.
03:34We know the victim is badly beaten, but there's the offender bled.
03:40As the victim managed to fight back, whose blood is it?
03:46We really need to identify quickly who is responsible for this offence.
04:03Where the phone box is, it's the bushes either side.
04:06If the train station is here, it's that phone box just after.
04:13Detectives from the Specialist Rape and Sexual Assault Team gather for an urgent briefing.
04:19Right, morning everyone.
04:20So what we know so far, we had a lone female leaving Wetherspoon's public house where she
04:25was brutally raped and attacked inside the phone box.
04:29So obviously what we know is when, we know where, the main focus of this this morning
04:35is who, who the male is that has attacked her.
04:39This attack on our victim is what we call a stranger rape.
04:42There's no relationship, don't know each other.
04:45It's just a straight grab off the street.
04:47I'd say that they're rare.
04:50But with all stranger rape, the biggest challenge is we've got to connect two people who seem
04:55to be not connected in any way.
04:56And we've got to get those two people, we've got to put them in the same place at the same
05:00time.
05:01Adele, I know you've been with our victim.
05:04I understand she's got some horrendous injuries.
05:06Are you able just to give us a bit of brief on how she is?
05:09She's coming across so strong, but I think she is in shock.
05:13What are actually new injuries?
05:15So visually you can see all from the face.
05:18She's bled quite a lot hasn't she?
05:19Under her eye there's a big cut, erm, that's quite deep that is.
05:24Your priority really is your high and low vaginal swabs as well as the, the, the pants as well.
05:30I mean you can all appreciate anybody who's wandering around those streets capable of doing what he's done.
05:35We've got to focus everything on getting this guy in right now.
05:40He's committed a horrendous act, I can't predict what he's going to do next.
05:44Every day that goes by that he's not caught, the risk to the public is obviously increasing.
05:56After receiving hospital treatment, the victim is brought for a detailed forensic medical examination.
06:03The victim is so brave to come forward and report this incident.
06:09Are you okay?
06:10I'm just going to raise your gown a little bit.
06:13When dealing with the rape case, the victim themselves are actually classed as a scene.
06:20We advise, you know, not to wash, not to go to the toilet because we can get forensic evidence from
06:25them.
06:25DNA from intimate swabs or from clothing.
06:31If you're uncomfortable at any point, tell me and I will stop okay.
06:37You're doing really well.
06:39Understandably, the victim has gone through something so horrific and so traumatic and we have to work at their speed.
06:48Now I'm just going to take samples.
07:04Now I'm just going to take the samples.
07:16It's just the tip of the swab.
07:16But also cellular DNA.
07:18As the offenders actually touch the victim's clothing, I'm hopeful, but there's never any guarantees.
07:28The next priority for detectives is to get a full account of the attack from the victim.
07:53We know how stressful these are.
07:56The victim's gone through a traumatic incident.
08:00We are asking somebody to sit down in front of a perfect stranger and talk about the most traumatic experience
08:06of their lives.
08:08But it's important for us to get the account from that victim really early on because there's bits that she
08:13can add that we can never get from anywhere else.
08:27I think I'm just trying to absorb what happened to myself.
08:32Yeah, of course.
08:35I want to give a gift to a friend whose birthday it was at the pub in Peribor.
08:52I can see she can't open her eyes.
08:55They're all bruised.
08:57She's got a broken nose.
08:59When you're looking at her injuries, the level of violence used, reliving it and talking through it, you can just
09:06exacerbate their trauma.
09:07So you've got to guide the victim.
09:12I felt someone grab me.
09:14Where?
09:16Sorry, where did they grab you?
09:17They grabbed me from behind and pushed me in the phone box.
09:21He had his arms around me.
09:23He was pushing me as well.
09:30And with one hand, he took my skirt and my leggings down.
09:36And then I'm trying to move, but then he's continually, like, hitting me, hitting me on my head and my
09:43face.
09:45And he raped me.
09:49Have you felt any ejaculation?
09:52I don't know, to be honest.
09:55Everything just happened.
09:59During any of these, has he spoken to you?
10:03He did just say shut up or something like that.
10:07But he did have, like, a foreign accent.
10:11Like, Middle East, Kurdish, Romanian.
10:14Yeah.
10:33I think she's done incredibly well.
10:39She was able to tell us his height.
10:43She gave us his accent of where she believed he was to originate from.
10:47This can sometimes be a bit subjective, but that's the only information about the suspect that we've got at this
10:54time.
10:56It was a really good starting point.
11:07There's a bit there, and there's a bit here.
11:09There might be some more on the inside.
11:13After swabbing the blood in the phone box, the forensic team hunts for any fingerprints that may have been left
11:20by the rapist.
11:23The fact that the rapist happened in a confined space gives a small chance that the suspect may have touched
11:29the telephone box as he's committing that offence.
11:31What we'll be looking for is, is there any fingerprints in blood?
11:40There needs to be some more here, but it's not the best policy.
11:50To improve the visibility of any prints, investigators apply chemical dyes that react with proteins found in blood.
12:04I can definitely see a color change here.
12:12There's a few good ones there.
12:17And that one there.
12:19And then you switch detail on the inside.
12:21They identify a cluster of fingerprints on the outside of the frame.
12:26Originally, the fingerprints were very faint when we had taken them beforehand and appeared to be in blood.
12:32But with the diary agent, to actually bring out the contrast,
12:35which should be better for identification purposes for the fingerprint bureau.
12:41Photos of the enhanced prints are fast-tracked to the fingerprint bureau
12:47to check against the police national computer.
12:51Is this the biggest mistake he's made?
12:54Because this could be what identifies him.
13:06CCTV, where are we in relation to the CCTV?
13:10Axon links have been sent for the actual camera footage from One Stop Shopping Centre security team themselves.
13:18The footage is actually going to go to 4am, because their camera's pretty good and it gives a whole overview
13:23of the area.
13:26Birmingham is swamped in CCTV, but it comes with its own challenges.
13:31There is a lot of cameras around traffic, routes, buses, things like that.
13:37Potentially hundreds of hours of footage.
13:40You can never make any guarantees in terms of what you're going to find.
13:47Digital media investigator Rob McKinnon is tasked with scrutinising CCTV of the area around the crime scene.
13:56You do need to be patient, you need to have attention to detail,
13:59because you may be looking for one thing, but you need to record what else you see,
14:03because anything could end up down the line being relevant.
14:09To narrow down the victim's movements on the night, detectives are dispatched to the pub she left moments before the
14:17attack.
14:20So, at the minute, we've just got an entrance foyer camera, then the middle area camera.
14:25OK.
14:27Quite often cameras, especially older cameras, the night footage will be of much lower quality.
14:33It makes it much more difficult to do things like spatial recognition,
14:37makes it more difficult to get an image that would be suitable for release to the public.
14:41Is there a camera by the fruit machine?
14:44It's not the greatest one, there's that one.
14:47OK.
14:49You get differences in colours, so the way that the pixels sometimes blur together during movement
14:56can make it difficult to identify what is actually happening.
14:59Do you reckon you probably have better footage as well, best to clear it in there?
15:03Out of push.
15:13Looking at multiple cameras, Rob focuses on a key timeframe between midnight and 2am.
15:22We're aware that the victim came from the pub before the offence.
15:29That gives us a starting point.
15:31So, we can look at CCTV that covers that area to identify when it is the suspect and the victim
15:38are first to become aware of each other.
15:43Is this the side of the train station?
15:45Yeah.
15:45This is far away from the spoons, isn't it really?
15:48No, it's just on the side of the road, yes.
15:50We're looking for people that are acting the way that doesn't make a lot of sense.
15:54You know, people standing around by themselves, maybe watching.
16:00So, this is at 1.26.
16:03He hangs around for a few more minutes.
16:05At this point, the victim is still in the weather's boots.
16:11Rob homes in on a man.
16:13But he wanders off up here.
16:17And tracks him loitering between the pub and the phone box.
16:21The victim comes out.
16:27Crosses the road towards the station.
16:32And at about 1.43, St. Noah walks up this way.
16:36Which is the time when the victim is going towards the station.
16:41What she doesn't know is that he goes around the corner and waits.
16:52He walks away.
16:54This is our victim.
16:56You know, walking in the same direction.
17:00The next camera shows the attack taking place.
17:10I'm presuming he has been waiting around the head.
17:18It's the worst footage I've ever seen.
17:22It's the level of violence and the continuation of that violence.
17:27You can't get emotionally involved in every single piece of footage that you watch.
17:33But there's some that will stick with you.
17:35And this is certainly one that will stick with me.
17:38I tend to try and channel it almost into that determination to find whoever it is that's done this.
17:47You see him run back past the same camera.
17:51After the attack, the offender runs out of range of the street cameras and disappears.
17:58I can honestly say that in 24 years of policing, I've not watched a piece of footage that has impacted
18:06like this has.
18:08But as horrendous as the offence was, we have to take positives from his brazenness and his violence because hopefully
18:16he's left the forensic evidence that he may not necessarily have left should it have been more of a thought
18:22out or controlled attack.
18:25Despite having CCTV of the attack, the image is not clear enough for police to identify the offender.
18:48With no identifiable CCTV, detectives are hoping the bloody fingerprints from the phone box may provide a lead.
18:57It's a digital photo of ridge detail associated with blood on the exterior of the phone box.
19:05But first, examiner Mick Killeen must compare the prints to those belonging to the victim to eliminate them from the
19:14enquiry.
19:21So the first distinctive characteristic we see is a ridge that's flowing and ends what we call a ridge ending.
19:28And then the ridge ending appears in the same formation sequence in the victim's set of fingerprints.
19:38From that first characteristic, there is one intervening ridge, then a further ridge ending, and then another intervening ridge, and
19:48then another ridge ending.
19:54There are eight ridge characteristics in the same formation sequence appearing on the crime scene mark and on the fingerprint
20:03form.
20:04So I'm satisfied that this is an identification against the victim's set of elimination prints.
20:1824 hours after the attack, and with the rapist still at large, Joe and Emma meet for an urgent review
20:25of the case.
20:31So I just want a bit of a summary of what's happened since we last spoke.
20:36So, the fingerprints from the telephone box have come back.
20:39A lot of them were insufficient detail, but one came back and was eliminated to a victim.
20:46Went and dried blood swabs from the actual phone box.
20:50The assumption is really all that blood is going to be hers.
20:53All the intimate samples have already been submitted, and we didn't get any positive DNA result from them.
21:00We're obviously waiting for the DNA to come back from the punch from the victim.
21:06I was really hopeful that we'd find some DNA or fingerprints, but the results are all negative so far.
21:14We're against the clock.
21:17I am feeling the pressure because this man is a danger to the public.
21:23He really is.
21:306.30, let's get the very latest local news for Birmingham now with Sean Moore.
21:37ERNB News.
21:37The police are investigating a rape and assault in Peribar.
21:41West Midlands police were called to Warsaw Road in the early hours of Saturday morning following reports that a woman
21:46had been raped.
21:46The man's described as having a slim build and wearing tracksuit bottoms and a hoodie.
21:51Anyone with information is being urged to come forward.
21:59Detectives Emma and Adele have now received CCTV from the pub the victim was in before the attack.
22:07So this is the foyer looking out, so people entering into Wetherspoons.
22:13So we can see faces.
22:16They need to scan through hours of that evening's footage to see if they can spot the man in a
22:22dark tracksuit seen committing the offence.
22:29I know that she's in the Wetherspoons pub.
22:32What I don't know and the questions I need to ask is where is he coming to all of this?
22:36Is he drinking in the pub?
22:38Has he seen her in there before?
22:39Has there been any previous contact between them?
22:41We can see sort of what clothing he was wearing at the time.
22:44The attack gives us a starting point.
22:49There's some guys hovering around here.
22:56This guy looks like he could be our guy.
23:02Same tracksuit, same trainers.
23:06A man matching the description given by the victim enters the pub just after midnight.
23:13That's our guy who's come straight in.
23:16He's looked at the male toilet.
23:18Then he's gone straight into the female toilet.
23:22So he's gone into the women's toilet?
23:24Yeah.
23:24Let's see how long he's in there for.
23:2610 seconds.
23:2915 seconds.
23:32He's coming back out now.
23:34And he's gone into the men's?
23:35Yeah.
23:39He's just peering, watching the bar area.
23:42What's he looking for?
23:47Is his hand?
23:48His hand's on his crotch.
23:52I'd say he's masturbating there.
23:55It's really disturbing, isn't it?
23:58I think he's getting himself excited at the thought of attacking.
24:02That is predatory behaviour.
24:09Emma and Adele closely monitor the men's movements as he hangs around the toilet area.
24:18Hold on, is that our victim?
24:26He's coming back in.
24:27He's coming back in.
24:27He's not even looking or trying to go to the men's this time.
24:30He's gone straight into the women's pool.
24:38She's just exited the toilet.
24:43He doesn't know that.
24:44He still thinks she's in those toilets.
24:48I think he's followed away into the toilet.
24:55It's really terrifying to watch that.
25:00He's targeted her.
25:05At 1.20am, the man can be seen exiting the pub.
25:10Shortly before the victim leaves.
25:13So I'm happy from the footage that we've watched now.
25:15We've got some really good imagery that we can use for press release for public.
25:19And also between the officers.
25:23The images of the man wanted in connection with the rape are circulated in a force-wide alert.
25:29I've got an image.
25:31Yeah.
25:32I'm going to send this through to you.
25:35And urgently released to the public.
25:39If you've got it in you to rape somebody, my opinion is the chances are that that's just a one
25:44-off.
25:45So we have to catch that person before we're able to do it to anybody else.
25:58Rach, do you want to just come over and have a look at this CCTV?
26:02Yes.
26:02It shows our suspect actually punches the bus stop.
26:10While reviewing CCTV for any further forensic leads, Joe has spotted the suspect shortly before the attack.
26:21This actual telephone box here is where our victim was raped.
26:25And he gives it a real hard punch.
26:28And he might have even cut the skin.
26:30Yeah.
26:30The offender, he's clearly got some anger issues, the way he was walking.
26:36And he's really punched this bus stop quite hard.
26:40He may have cut himself, so there may be blood on the bus stop itself.
26:45I'm thinking forensic opportunity straight away.
26:55So when you look at CCTV, you can see him punch around this area.
27:01So I'm going to kind of swab this area in the middle here.
27:06Coordinator Rachel Hughes is sent to swab the bus stop for any trace of skin cells left by the offender's
27:14punch.
27:16Unfortunately, there's no trace of any blood at all.
27:19So hopefully he gets some sort of cellular material from there.
27:24This bus stop is obviously open to the elements.
27:26With it raining, there's a possibility they could wash away evidence.
27:30Time goes on, DNA deteriorates, so, you know, time is the essence really.
27:46One of our own officers has recognised a potential suspect from his patch that he covers.
27:54A known offender, who closely resembles the circulated CCTV image, has been identified by a police officer.
28:03So we're just doing some intel checks on this person now.
28:07He was interviewed in relation to an assault with intent to cause serious harm.
28:13At the end of 2019, again then, a malicious wounding.
28:17The end of 2017...
28:21..interviewed again for another assault with intent to cause serious harm.
28:25So there's a history of violence from this person.
28:30And the victim states this was such a vicious attack, so that matches.
28:39He had me from behind and continually hit me with blows to my face and my head.
28:49So when he's hitting you, what's he using?
28:52His hands.
28:53Again, when he says hands, are we talking?
28:56What are sort of fists?
28:57Fists, OK.
28:59It happened really fast, so it's like my head is a bit fuzzled.
29:05Again, I'm sorry.
29:10We've got images of him on our systems.
29:14There is a striking resemblance in relation to the image.
29:19The hair on the top, the same, similar age.
29:22Everything is pointing that this is potentially our suspect,
29:26so I think it's really important that we get him straight in.
29:30We've got to act fast.
29:31We're not going home today until he's in custody,
29:34because we cannot have that man walking around these streets a second longer.
29:43An arrest team heads directly to the suspect's address.
29:58Police!
29:59Police!
30:01What's going on?
30:01For what?
30:04For rape.
30:04For rape?
30:06Are you being serious?
30:07What have you done for rape?
30:08Are you serious, bro?
30:11That's a big allegation, you know?
30:14I'm the one who needs to be my D.W.
30:16Right.
30:17Rape, you know?
30:20Come on, boy.
30:22We're waiting for forensics.
30:24I think if we do a search of the premises, try and locate whatever we can find.
30:29In my opinion, he holds quite a likeness.
30:31Yeah, it's a strong.
30:32It's a strong likeness.
30:41It's a strong likeness.
30:43Two and a half days after the rape, police have a suspect in custody.
30:48What have you been asked for?
30:50Brave.
30:53This isn't mine.
30:56Is there proof of this?
30:57Have you got proof of this?
31:04Yes.
31:05Joe Ward, crime scene coordinator.
31:06Hi, Joe.
31:07It's Adalia from Rasa.
31:08So, I'd like to speak to you in relation to the guy that we've got in custody already.
31:13So, yeah, we need to hopefully come up with a bit of a forensic strategy.
31:17Yeah.
31:18When we get a suspect in custody for a sexual offence, what we're looking for is any trace of DNA
31:24that belongs to the victim.
31:25She's okay.
31:26The offender is caught on CCTV, which is circumstantial because the picture may not be clear or people view CCTV
31:34differently from person to person.
31:36So, I'm really conscious of trying to get as much forensic evidence to provide that link between the suspect and
31:42victim.
31:43Obviously, because she was punched quite a few times, I'll get the oversized photographs.
31:47The palms and the backs of the hands will do, like, her fingernail clippings and also kind of scrapings as
31:54well.
31:54Her DNA under his nails underneath.
31:56And it may be that even though he's washed his hands, there still may be some kind of blood still
32:00underneath his nails.
32:01And I presume you're doing the sexual swabs, are you, don't you?
32:05Yes.
32:05They're going to be done all day, don't you?
32:06Yeah, he's in a dry cell and we're going to complete all of those with the medical staff at the
32:11custody.
32:11Brilliant.
32:18While the suspect is held in a dry cell to prevent him from washing away any evidence, tests are underway
32:26to forensically connect him to the attack.
32:32First, we're just going to photograph the underwear as they've been received.
32:40What we're looking for is any trace of semen, because hopefully we would be able to get DNA from the
32:47actual semen.
32:48Or there may be some cellular DNA that's transferred from his hands where, you know, he's touched the underwear and
32:54pulled the underwear off.
32:58Forensic examiner Jamie Lee Knight starts by testing for skin cells.
33:03That the suspect may have transferred from his hands to the underwear.
33:10We're going to mini-take the outside waistband, because the offender has grabbed the victim from behind and pulled their
33:18clothing down.
33:19And we're just looking to target any areas that the suspect might have come into contact with.
33:28Now that the cellular has been taken, we've gone to screening for semen.
33:35So I'm just making sure that the item is wet enough for any semen staining that's present to be transferred
33:42to the blotting paper.
33:45Next, the blotting paper is tested for the presence of semen.
33:50If acid phosphatase is present, we'll get a purple reaction to come up on the blotting paper.
34:06This purple indicates the presence of semen. That's a very strong positive.
34:12I don't know.
34:21While the underwear will undergo further testing to look for the offender's DNA...
34:28...detectives are preparing to question the suspect.
34:35I've got a lot of questions that are going to be asked of him. Our suspicions are that it's him.
34:39It's on him to tell us where he was, to prove to us that that's not him that's committed that
34:44attack.
34:50I would like to read out a prepared statement.
34:55I vehemently deny all of the allegations against me.
34:58I was not present at the scene of the alleged assault and rape.
35:01I'd never met this person in my life.
35:04Although I do not recall where I was on Saturday, I was not near Perry Bar train station.
35:11I will now be answering no comment to all questions put to me.
35:18I appreciate that statement, but obviously we've got some further questions that we need to answer.
35:25I'll show you some CCTV captured from the Wetherspoons in One Stop in Perry Bar.
35:34Do you recognise the magnet there?
35:37No comment.
35:37Is that you?
35:38No comment.
35:41Is there anybody that you were with that could verify where you were and that you weren't there?
35:45No comment.
35:48So you say this, this is the case of mistaken identity, of you can't tell me what you're doing.
35:54You can't offer me any names of anybody that will be able to verify your whereabouts.
36:01It's hard to believe.
36:03I don't know, it might just be my opinion, but it's hard to believe that you can't remember what you're
36:06doing on Friday night.
36:07Is there any reason why you wouldn't want to remember that?
36:09No comment.
36:11No comment.
36:15If someone goes no comment, I think what you're hiding, if you're innocent, why have you not given an account?
36:23Why have you not told the officers where you were so that they can then check that and this would
36:28all be over?
36:35I don't think at this point we've got enough to charge, so we're now relying on the forensics to take
36:40us further forward with him.
36:42With the suspect refusing to answer any questions, detectives have 24 hours to charge or release him.
36:56So I'm just going to cut a strip out of this top layer.
37:01At Eurofin's laboratory, Jamie Lee concentrates on the section of underwear which tested positive for semen,
37:09in a bid to find any sperm heads containing the suspect's DNA.
37:16We tease apart the fibres, so basically if there's any sperm heads trapped within them,
37:24just making sure that when we put our reagents onto them, it's the best possible chance of them being released.
37:33A centrifuge machine is used to separate the more dense sperm particles.
37:46Next, Jamie Lee adds a dye to stain the sample.
37:50If any sperm heads are present, they will turn red.
37:58It's really faint.
38:03There's 80 to 300 million sperm heads in an average ejaculation.
38:11But on this slide, I can only see a single sperm head.
38:20Forensic science has come on massively since I joined.
38:25From needing quite a large amount to obtain a DNA profile, you know, you need a pin head size.
38:32But in this case, we've got one sperm head and it's a difficult process.
38:39So I'm really hoping that the scientists can actually still work with that
38:42and be able to achieve a DNA profile that matches this person in custody.
38:51While the single sperm head is fast-tracked for DNA extraction and profiling,
38:57Joe reviews evidence from the suspect.
39:04So this is the male that is currently in custody for the rape offence.
39:10Just looking through the photographs that were taken earlier today.
39:17The discovery of CCTV showing the offender punching a bus stop has prompted her to focus on his hands.
39:26When you're punching a hard surface with some force as well, which it was clear from the CCTV,
39:32he really did punch it at force.
39:35What I would expect to find is some visible injuries to the hand and it was his right hand.
39:41He's also punched the victim several times.
39:44And again, I would expect to find some swelling or some bruising.
39:49On the left hand is what appears to be old scarring.
39:55But there really isn't any visible injuries whatsoever to the right hand at all.
40:01So that's a little bit concerning.
40:09Do you know there's some issues with lack of injuries?
40:12Yeah, we've obviously...
40:13From the level of injuries that she's got and how many times he's actually punched her,
40:18I would have expected some kind of injury to his hands.
40:21Certainly his right hand, which is used, and there's nothing at all.
40:26The victim states to me during her interview that it is definitely either Kurdish, Romanian,
40:33she said that type of accent.
40:35Having listened to the interview, the guy they've just interviewed,
40:38unless he's put on an accent the whole way through it,
40:40he definitely did not have an easily put on an accent.
40:42There's just a few things now that are just starting to give me concern about the guy in custody.
40:47So we've got someone in custody, and at this moment we haven't got anything but an identification to put him
40:53there.
40:54It's a really difficult position to be in.
40:56What we need is forensics to say,
40:58yep, we've found some DNA,
41:01we've got the right person in custody,
41:03or say it's not him.
41:06With the 24-hour custody clock to charge the suspect running out,
41:12detectives are granted a 12-hour extension to carry out further enquiries.
41:28So the first footage we've got after the offence, he starts to walk up Birchfield Road.
41:37With the suspect giving no account of his movements, Rob is trying to further pinpoint where he went after the
41:44attack,
41:44by widening the CCTV search radius to three miles from the phone box.
41:50It's a very manual, very time consuming part of the job.
41:55We've recovered hundreds of hours of footage that needs to be reviewed,
41:59using a track and trace principle, where we identify where somebody goes off camera.
42:03And then he crosses over onto Harry away.
42:09We then try and find the next camera on that route.
42:13The next footage we've got, he appears on the left-hand side walking up towards the right.
42:23And then, a few minutes later, a second male wearing a green jacket, walks in the same direction.
42:30Rob has discovered footage of what appears to be the suspect with another man,
42:3515 minutes after the attack.
42:39We're not sure of the identity of the second male,
42:42but obviously we know that he wasn't involved in the actual offence,
42:44because we've got the footage of that and that shows that this male was acting alone.
42:50You can see that there's some movement on the left-hand side.
42:54These two males are our males that we've been tracking.
42:57Now in the corner of this footage, you can see there is a dark-coloured van.
43:01It looks potentially blue.
43:04And the lights turn on and the doors seem to open and close.
43:08And at around 2.40 in the morning, the van lights turn on and it drives away.
43:19So we now know that 55 minutes after the offence, the suspect is driven away.
43:24Right now, we need that blue van, that's what we need to find,
43:27because that is our main link now between the suspect and the offence.
43:33Using automatic number plate recognition,
43:36the van is tracked from the time the offender drives away
43:40until later that same morning.
43:43Have you got it?
43:45We've got the vehicle anyway.
43:48Let's have a look.
43:52After identifying the van's number plate,
43:55detectives are able to link it to an address.
43:59I've picked on to this person,
44:03who is Cornel Gabriel Philly Patch.
44:08He matches the description.
44:11Do you not think his hair is a bit...
44:13No, I think when you look at the hairline,
44:15on the moving footage,
44:17it matches the hairline now.
44:23Right, so we've now got a name?
44:25Yeah.
44:28Police have now identified a second potential suspect.
44:3221-year-old Cornel Philly Patchy.
44:38We've got a name, we've got an address.
44:41He's driving that van straight after that attack.
44:44It's only circumstantial at this stage,
44:45so we need to get him in as soon as possible.
44:52Despite police already having a man in custody,
44:55an order is issued for Philly Patchy's immediate arrest.
45:02Police!
45:03Police!
45:04Police!
45:05Open the door!
45:08Open the door!
45:09Open the door!
45:10Open the door!
45:10Open the door!
45:15Open the door!
45:15Open the door!
45:17Nothing's clear!
45:18What have we got?
45:19Is that a man?
45:20Yeah, yeah.
45:23Got you under arrest on a speech of right.
45:25Stand up.
45:26Turn around, sit down.
45:29What's your name?
45:31Huh?
45:31Pardon me.
45:43Three and a half days after the attack,
45:46Cornel Philly Patchy is brought into custody to be questioned.
45:53What's your name, please?
45:58This is this house.
45:59They gave me in the holding cell.
46:02So, Cornel, yeah?
46:03And the offence is...
46:05Right.
46:07OK.
46:07What language would you like to speak in?
46:09Romanian.
46:09Romanian.
46:10OK.
46:12What do you do for work?
46:18The arrest of a second suspect
46:20presents senior investigating officer Emma Watson
46:23with a unique dilemma.
46:25I've got two suspects in custody.
46:28Only one of them can have committed the offence.
46:31That first suspect,
46:33I don't want to release him
46:35because I'm still not confident that it isn't him.
46:39The fact that police officers identified him
46:41and I know he's a violent offender
46:44and we need to protect the public from a potential rapist.
46:48What with Cornel Philly Patchy,
46:51I've got a name that's Eastern European
46:53and victim describes him as Eastern European.
46:56The accent, that fits.
46:59Face fits.
47:00The CCTV.
47:02But without that forensic evidence,
47:04I can't say that it is him.
47:07Let's go.
47:08Hello.
47:13Police now need to capture any potential DNA evidence
47:17which may link Philly Patchy to the victim.
47:21Open your mouth.
47:25Even though it's a few days after the offence,
47:28there are still opportunities
47:30to get forensic evidence from him.
47:33It may be that he's not washed his clothing since the offence.
47:36He may have not showered.
47:40Flip your hand over for me.
47:45Intimate swabs will also be analysed for any traces of the victim.
47:53Have a look at your hands, please, sir.
47:58These little marks here, can I photograph those, please?
48:01Yeah, I...
48:03Yeah, I...
48:03I appreciate...
48:06I'm not stupid, you know.
48:08No, I'm not either, but...
48:09Take the picture and that's it, take the picture, that's it, take the picture.
48:12You can take a picture, no problem.
48:14OK, let's look at this.
48:18On the suspect's hands, there are visible injuries which are encouraging.
48:25So he's got to explain those injuries.
48:31Just in that room, OK?
48:40Can I ask you to state your full name, please?
48:44Cornel.
48:46Filipachi.
48:48You were arrested for the offence of Ray.
48:53Where were you the late night of 17th of January and early hours up to 7am the 18th of January?
49:00No comment.
49:01So that evening, did you visit a Weatherspoons public house?
49:06No comment.
49:09No comment.
49:10So the footage there shows where I believe it is yourself...
49:13...hitting female three times to the face and the head.
49:16Is that you in that footage?
49:18No comment.
49:20Did you drag her to her phone box?
49:22Did you pull her underwear down?
49:26Did you vaginally rape this female?
49:30No comment.
49:32Does this kind of thing excite you?
49:34You're preying on vulnerable lone females on the street.
49:39No comment.
49:41I'm just so frustrated that the best evidence that we've got at this time...
49:46...is only circumstantial with the CCTV.
49:49Just can't get clearing off CCTV to identify which ones commit the offence.
49:57Unless forensic tests come back conclusively linking one man to the attack...
50:02...detectives may have to release both suspects.
50:18A specialist laboratory has been attempting to extract DNA...
50:22...from the single sperm head found on the victim's underwear.
50:28PHONE RINGS
50:31Joe has been sent their report.
50:40Good morning, Senator Russell. I'm Watson speaking. Can I help?
50:42Hi, it's Joe.
50:44I've just literally received the update from the lab...
50:48...with the results of the underwear.
50:49Yep.
50:51A single sperm head was observed.
50:54But that's come back inconclusive.
50:58The sample's too weak.
51:00Oh, God. Right, OK.
51:02It's quite disappointing, really.
51:07I was hopeful for a positive result in a name.
51:10But, um, fingers crossed they're further testing from the cellular DNA...
51:14...and get us a result.
51:15OK.
51:17This feels like a massive setback.
51:19The process of extracting sperm head from semen is tricky...
51:23...and we're not getting the results through.
51:25Um, you know, and that really worries me at this time.
51:30With police lacking a forensic link to either suspect...
51:34...and an approaching deadline to release them...
51:38...one last test remains.
51:49A full DNA profile has been extracted from skin cells...
51:54...on the underwear touched by the attacker.
51:58So, we've had a clear major, which is matching the female...
52:03...and then you've got these additional components...
52:05...which indicate only the presence of one more person.
52:10Senior reporter Charlotte Hargreaves...
52:13...now checks to see if the profile matches either suspect.
52:17So, we can do a direct comparison to the DNA profile of the, uh, initial suspect.
52:25So, here, he's a 21.227.
52:29And coming to the, um, crime stain result...
52:32...and there's no 21.2 and there's no 27.
52:36This area, he's a 14.215 here.
52:41And then if I go onto the crime stain, there's no 14.2 or 15.
52:48This individual has not contributed DNA to this result.
52:54Charlotte is able to show that DNA from the first suspect...
52:58...is not present on the victim's underwear.
53:01Next, she moves on to examine DNA from the second suspect.
53:09So, you can see that this 16 does match Cornell Sillapache.
53:16Again, we go to the next area, 13, 16.2.
53:21So, you can see that those two DNA components are represented here.
53:26All the way through, you can see that all of his components...
53:30...are represented in these smaller ones.
53:35So, in my opinion, Cornell Sillapache's DNA profile...
53:39...does match two DNA components present in the climb stone.
53:44Analysis of these findings shows that the DNA result...
53:49...is a billion times more likely to be from Cornell Sillapache than not.
53:56Hello, Jo, you all right?
53:58Yeah, not too bad, thank you.
53:59Erm, I've got some really, really, really good news.
54:02Oh, really?
54:03The samples taken from the underwear...
54:05Erm, they've obviously been compared...
54:08...and it's actually matched Cornell Sillapache.
54:11So, really, really pleased.
54:13Oh, that is brilliant. I should go brief everyone.
54:16No, brilliant. Thanks ever so much for letting me know.
54:18And I'll just brief everyone, let them all know...
54:20...and then I'll get back in touch with you about what we do next.
54:22This is the forensic evidence that we were waiting for...
54:25...that has tied it all together.
54:28To get the news in that you've got the right person in custody...
54:32...it can't be anyone else.
54:34To be able to go tell the victim...
54:36...that we've got him...
54:37...it's just such a relief.
54:41So, you're fitting to be released, yeah?
54:43Oh, she's a veteran.
54:45So, give me a signature in that box, please.
54:49But the other side of it is...
54:50...is that we were able to clear an innocent man.
54:54To be able to say, forensically, it wasn't him...
54:56...means that I can release him.
55:00Most important is we will be able to charge a dangerous offender...
55:03...because forensic evidence now, there's no denying it.
55:06There's no arguing with it.
55:07He cannot account for why his DNA is in her underwear...
55:12...other than he's committed the offence.
55:24Okay, so Cornell, you will be charged...
55:27...with the offences that have been authorised...
55:29...by the Crown Prosecution Service.
55:32So, the first offence is an offence of rape.
55:36The second charge is one of GBH with intent.
55:41You will be aware of how serious these charges are.
55:45Is there anything else that you want to...to say?
55:49No.
55:51There's lots of emotions that go through your head.
55:54I think the level of violence that was used...
55:57...really put an urgency on it.
55:59The officer will take you back to your cell now.
56:02I certainly didn't feel that he had any remorse...
56:04...or any regret about what had happened.
56:07The important thing now is the person that we believe...
56:09...is committed this offence is off the streets.
56:25I'm as confident as I can be we've got a strong case...
56:28...and I'm hopeful we can get it across that line.
57:00BLOWING
57:01years uh reduced to 10 on his his early guilty plea so great work all done really good evidence
57:08oh that's brilliant news really really pleased that um we've obviously got justice for the victim
57:14this case for me has been a bit of a roller coaster um you know i was quite concerned at
57:20one point that um we weren't going to be able to get any dna from the underwear um so it's
57:25a massive
57:28relief forensics was crucial in this investigation it put a violent and dangerous male behind bars
57:37the evidence was that strong that cornell has felt you know he had no alternative but to plead guilty
57:46of course we can't forget the most important person in all of this and that's how it's in
57:51it can't be easy and i know you never get over something like this but i can just
57:55hope that this is the start of her rebuilding her life and her future
58:25is
58:30is
58:31is
58:41is
58:48is
58:49is
58:49is
Comments