- 10 months ago
ITL kicks off the show with a franchise-defining question for the Texans: do you extend C.J. Stroud right now?
Category
🥇
SportsTranscript
00:00Let's talk about C.J. Stroud now in this context with a little bit more clarity,
00:03even though there is still a little emotional drainage happening here.
00:07The simple thing is, we talked about it, C.J. Stroud's going to be here next year,
00:10but where do we move forward with C.J., I think, is the conversation.
00:14We know he played bad.
00:15He seems to know, at least to some degree, that he let down his team
00:18and he played some level of bad.
00:21You know, reasonable minds apparently can disagree.
00:23But where do we move on from here?
00:26And we start with, obviously, the big question that people have been kind of tossing
00:29a little bit, even before this season, which is, do you extend C.J. Stroud?
00:33So I'll throw that to you, John Lopez.
00:36You know, year three or after year three is typically when, especially for quarterbacks,
00:40but rookies, you start looking at, do you give them the extension?
00:43And just for clarity purposes, you can either right now, this year,
00:48well, going into the offseason, you can either pick up the option, the fifth-year option.
00:54Well, I mean, I think the fifth-year option is one of those things.
00:57Do you like the quarterback just generally, or are you ready to get out of it?
01:01Because if you don't pick up the fifth-year option, you're saying,
01:03we're just trying to get out of this as soon as we possibly can.
01:06Right.
01:06But you can pick up the fifth-year option or extend him.
01:10And quarterbacks who are known, you know, considered to be a franchise.
01:16If you are a starter, your fifth-year option is picked up.
01:20It is picked up.
01:21But they're also extended.
01:23They're all extended.
01:24And my answer to that, Reggie, this is the easiest question we'll have all day.
01:30Absolutely not if you extend him.
01:32No chance.
01:34Zero percent chance you extend him.
01:36You can't do it.
01:37You just can't.
01:38I mean, we know what the story is.
01:39We know, you know, the quote-unquote decline that some people are calling him.
01:46He's not going to like it.
01:47You know, there are repercussions.
01:48I'm not sure.
01:49I think that this is also easy because from a David Molligata standpoint that is C.J. Stroud's agent, I don't know that they want to do the extension at this given point.
01:57I don't know that it behooves them to do it.
01:59Yeah, they don't want to do it right now because they're probably leaving a lot of money, possible money on the table.
02:05But it's hard for me to, for them not to look at that offense like, man, what are y'all doing to our quarterback right now?
02:11So, what you're saying, because I think my counterpoint to what you guys are saying is, while that may be true, there's also the possibility that he has a worse season next year.
02:21Yeah, but they don't believe that.
02:22No, I understand that.
02:24But there's a possibility.
02:25They have to consider it, whether they believe it or not.
02:27Or, honestly, maybe this is C.J. Stroud.
02:30Maybe right now that's what he is.
02:32And whether they're, you know, C.J. Stroud, I'm, you know, the guy, David Molligata, he's the guy.
02:37They have to consider it or he's not doing his job as an agent.
02:40I mean, sure, I'm not saying that there's no consideration.
02:42That has moved on from pretty quickly.
02:45Molligata wouldn't be his agent if he did not believe that C.J. Stroud was capable.
02:48C.J. Stroud clearly believes in his abilities to the point where it annoys some of us on the outside hearing the ways that he's like,
02:54I still, you know, I still feel like I played a good second half and I still think I have good play in him.
02:59And to be fair, I do think that he has good play within him.
03:03And get that has become more of a question over the last, you know, weekend of football and such,
03:08or actually the last couple of weeks of football, really.
03:11But from their perspective, you're very much in a not even difficult bet on yourself circumstance.
03:17And David Molligata, he has been in circumstances where with notable clients, they have bet on their clients.
03:23He has done this a lot of times.
03:24It would behoove them, especially with them having the belief in him as not just being a good quarterback,
03:30but probably being a great to elite one.
03:32And again, I'm saying the belief that they have to have in that camp.
03:35There's no way that you walk into signing an extension coming off of what was a very bad two games.
03:40Probably what you could say is two worst games for your client as a pro.
03:43I think there is a way.
03:44I totally disagree with you on that.
03:46And the reason I do is two things.
03:49Number one, even if they're, you know, leaving some money on the table, which they would be, you know,
03:55if he has a great season next year, but you have to consider what if this is bad?
03:59And it's not necessarily CJ's fault.
04:00What if the fit is bad?
04:02We've seen the fit does not work.
04:03And if the fit is bad, getting the extension now is not the way that you'd want to do that.
04:07No, here's why it is.
04:08Because, like, if it doesn't work out next year and he doesn't like it and he takes a step back,
04:14you might be leaving some money on the, you know, imaginary money at this point on the table right now
04:19by not signing an extension.
04:20But if you do sign an extension, for a quarterback even coming off of C.J. Stroud's struggles,
04:26what's the floor of that contract?
04:28$50 million bonus?
04:30A hundred and, let's say, five years even, if you just want to shorten it up?
04:35Five years, a hundred and...
04:37I think five years would probably be standard.
04:39I don't know that.
04:39Whatever.
04:40Let's say five years.
04:44$80 million?
04:45I don't know.
04:46I mean, that's a lot of money that he can absolutely get right now, including a $50 million bonus.
04:52So, I think they are sort of, you know, have to consider, you know, taking an negotiation right now.
04:59From the Texans' perspective, no way.
05:01No way you do it.
05:02I think that they're actually both on the same page.
05:03But ultimately, I think we land on the same place, which is C.J. Stroud playing on the fourth year of his rookie deal.
05:09I imagine you pick up the fifth-year option because, again, he's been starter quality.
05:13And I know that we're in the moment where you've seen him be really bad in the last couple of games.
05:19You look over the course of the season, and he was just about at the, you know, maybe the bottom of that top third of quarterbacks
05:25when it comes to a lot of different performances statistically this season.
05:29And ain't nobody trying to hear that.
05:31I get it.
05:31But you have to be realistic about this.
05:33He is starter quality.
05:34And so, you pick up that fifth-year option, and you try and situate this better for him to be better next year.
05:40But that is the question, then, that we get to.
05:42How do you make C.J. Stroud better next year?
05:43Yeah, it is the question.
05:45And I think there's a lot there that C.J. Stroud, here's the other thing.
05:51He may not want to be here.
05:55I mean, we have to face that.
05:56I've been saying that for a long time, man.
05:58If they're not surrounding him with the right pieces.
06:01And the right offense that he likes.
06:02Yeah, the offense, yeah.
06:04And remember who his agent is.
06:07Yeah.
06:07Reggie, it seems crazy because, you know, they drafted him.
06:11You know, he's got this fifth-year option.
06:13He's made his money.
06:15You know, the fifth-year option would be, what, $26 million to $28 million?
06:18Somewhere in there.
06:20But he may not want to be here.
06:23He, you know, making decisions on his own, too.
06:26Yeah.
06:27All right, I'll take you to C.J. Stroud.
06:29There's a lot of things that were said by C.J. Stroud, by D'Amico Ryans yesterday.
06:33In fact, we didn't know that C.J. Stroud would talk.
06:36This is somewhat unusual for this to be the case, to be entirely honest.
06:39But we heard from C.J. yesterday.
06:41And I thought it was a very interesting conversation with him.
06:45I definitely felt like it was insightful in some ways.
06:49I did not feel like we were just getting the same mold from C.J.
06:52But this was C.J. specifically when he was asked about the possibility of this Texans offense
06:57growing under Nick Haley.
06:58Yeah, definitely.
06:59You know, I love Kels.
07:00You know, I think, you know, there's growth.
07:01And, you know, in our relationship, there's growth.
07:04And, you know, his ability to call play is growth.
07:06And, you know, D'Amico trusted him.
07:07So, you know, whatever, you know, our coaches decide, you know.
07:10And, you know, I love Kels.
07:12And I'm rocking with him, you know, however long he's going to be here.
07:15I throw this up here because you asked, you know, what if he doesn't want to be here?
07:19And now, if he didn't want to be here, I don't know that he'd get out here and specifically,
07:23you know, telegraph that.
07:24However, how do you read the way that he answers that?
07:27Saying that he loves Kels, that he feels like Nick Haley has progressed in his ability to
07:31call it, and in D'Amico Ryan's trust of him.
07:34How did you read that?
07:35But right in the middle there.
07:36Right in the middle.
07:37Yep.
07:38He said, whatever they decide.
07:39Yep.
07:40Man.
07:41And I think, I mean, that's, that is interesting to say the least.
07:45You know, by, and maybe it's an editorial statement, you know, kind of a subtle way
07:51from, you know, he said the right things and then he goes, whatever they decide.
07:54He doesn't like this offense.
07:56In my opinion.
07:57But I don't think it's his, the fit that he likes.
07:59I don't think it's the style that he likes.
08:01But it's the style that won this to lump it.
08:05You know, he kind of had to just take his medicine and do what they asked him to do.
08:08The other part is, you know, you can compare him to Trevor Lawrence when they, when they
08:14extended him, he, it wasn't the extension that, that it wasn't anything other than getting
08:22a new coach that could fit him into the right offense for him that made him flourish.
08:27The money didn't have anything to do with it.
08:29We know that because he didn't play well when he got the contract still it's, it's the system
08:34fitting him.
08:34And then the money looks smarter.
08:36I mean, you know me, I'm, I'm very much on the, or in the school of thought that circumstance
08:40matters a great deal when we talk about quarterbacks and I understand the people that go elite
08:45quarterbacks, you know, are able to make it work even without the circumstance.
08:48All right, let's maybe, let's get to the place where we go.
08:50CJ Stroud is not elite.
08:51I'm willing to concede there.
08:53Do you, is the only option elite quarterback?
08:55Cause I imagine you'll be waiting for a long time.
08:57If you're only looking for elite quarterback, there's ways to do this without an elite quarterback.
09:01Now, again, I'm not immediately trying to give CJ Stroud any ground here.
09:06We still are figuring out what bucket we feel most comfortable placing him in, but even
09:11if he is not going to fit in the elite quarterback bucket there, you know, there are really, really
09:16good quarterbacks, great quarterbacks, even that are not elite quarterbacks, but in the
09:19right circumstance can do a lot of stuff.
09:22So I think that that's going to be an interesting thing to talk about.
09:24We will have a conversation about that today on this program about, is this the right circumstance
09:29if you are going to get the most out of CJ Stroud, but yeah, I, you talk about him not
09:34liking the system, if I'm being entirely honest, I don't know if I like the system for him
09:38per se, at least not as optimal.
09:40It does feel like, I think what I did with for Lawrence, that's the example I'm saying.
09:46I think the CJ Stroud, the better system for him was the system that, or at least the Shanahan
09:52system in its, in theory, I don't know that Bobby Sloak was the right practitioner for
09:57it, but you're in a place where now the conversation will be at some point and we'll have this,
10:01I think at noon, how do you, how do you, how do you navigate that?
10:05Because you have a first year coordinator who did develop this year.
10:09Was it enough?
10:10And do you have enough options to move away?
10:12Let's get into that.
10:13Cause there's something I want to add to what you just said.
10:15We, we, we will get into that as we continue along here in the loop on sports radio, 610
10:19a Tuesday here as we, as we continue to parse through all the things that happen with your
10:24Texans as we welcome to off season, man.