Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 3 months ago
ITL debates whether loading up a roster with stars actually leads to Super Bowl championships and whether the Texans have reached the point where they should be considered an NFL superteam.

Category

🥇
Sports
Transcript
00:00A piece that was written in ESPN by Bill Barnwell, I thought it was very interesting, asked the question,
00:05do super teams in the NFL win for real?
00:08And I thought this was real interesting because, you know, it feels like you have a super team this year
00:14in the NFL, in the Los Angeles Rams, right?
00:16Like, this is one where it felt like they already had the best roster in football, and then they were
00:20just like, you know what?
00:21Should we get the best player in football for the best roster of football?
00:24And then they went and traded for Miles Garrett, you know?
00:26And they might not be done.
00:28Yes, because I am sick of this slow walk towards Aaron Donald playing football.
00:33Like, just say it, right?
00:36He had the tryout so he could actually wear pads and helmets when he was out there practicing,
00:39and then we get the glib things from the coaches where it's like, oh, I mean, if that's happening, we'd
00:44really be excited.
00:45Just do it.
00:46Just say it.
00:47No, I'm with you.
00:48Just do it.
00:49What's stopping you from doing it right now?
00:51Just do it.
00:52But he did an interesting, I guess, experiment here in taking some of the biggest, I guess, super teams, quote,
01:00unquote, in the NFL
01:00and seeing how they ended up resulting in that season.
01:06And the metric that he used here I found was interesting, John Lopez.
01:09The way that he determined a super team was who had the best Vegas odds
01:14and then who had the biggest gap to the rest of the NFL to start the season.
01:19And then that was then considered a super team in his mind.
01:22That's fair.
01:23Are there any other way?
01:24Because that's not kind of how I thought about a super team.
01:27That is exactly what I want to get to.
01:28First and foremost, I did want to let you know, the way that he did this,
01:31he listed off a few teams as the super teams.
01:34Because I do want to circle back to that.
01:35I think that is really the heart of the conversation when we get there.
01:38But the 2017 Patriots is one, I mean, they had an 11.5% gap between them
01:45and the next highest odds getter in that year.
01:48They lost in the Super Bowl to the Eagles.
01:50The 07 Patriots, remember Randy Moss joining them?
01:52Yeah.
01:53They are one of the super teams that he has.
01:55I think that's probably a fair way to go.
01:56They lost to the Giants in the Super Bowl.
01:58The 96 Niners, San Francisco 49ers, does that feel about right for you?
02:02Yes.
02:03They lost in the divisional round.
02:05The 2002 St. Louis Rams, we're talking, you know,
02:07greatest show on turf, moving on.
02:10They missed the playoffs that year in 02.
02:1397 Packers, they lose in the Super Bowl.
02:171990 San Francisco 49ers losing the NFC Championship game.
02:22Sensing a theme.
02:23That's kind of interesting.
02:2308 Patriots missed the playoffs.
02:26And the 95 Niners lost in the divisional round.
02:30The 2021 Kansas City Chiefs losing the AFC Championship game.
02:35I found this to be interesting, right?
02:36Now, the 94 Niners do win a championship.
02:40There's one or more team that I'm missing here that also,
02:43the 2018 Patriots win a championship.
02:46But, I mean, of the, I believe, 14 teams that were significant,
02:51or sorry, 15 teams, two of them actually win the Super Bowl.
02:54And a handful of them make it to the Super Bowl.
02:58Is that what you would have expected?
03:01I don't know how he, I'm not altogether in on the way he is characterizing these as super teams.
03:09Sure.
03:09Because, to me, a super team is one kind of like what we're seeing right now.
03:14That you go out and acquire, like, Pro Bowl and All-Pro players that are already established.
03:21Or you've developed them and they have multiple Pro Bowls and Pro Bowl players.
03:27It's kind of like what we see in the NBA.
03:29Yeah, oh, they're a star and now they're going to this team.
03:31Well, then, how do you then classify, if that's the case, like the Golden State Warriors,
03:35where that was homegrown Super Team?
03:37Like I said, or you grow your own that become multiple year Pro Bowlers or All-Pro.
03:43I thought you was, I thought they was going to bring up, what was that Philly team?
03:47That 2011 team when Vince Young called it the dream team?
03:51Yes, yes.
03:52That's what I was thinking about.
03:54We all know Vince was doing a little wilding there, right?
03:56Hey, he said it.
03:57I guess somebody else in that locker room said the same thing.
04:00I think we around here enjoy Vince Young, but we know he was wilding then, right?
04:03Yeah, he was wilding.
04:05But I was thinking more like the 98 Vikings.
04:09See, but they, not really, they didn't go out and acquire a bunch of big time.
04:15You know, free agents.
04:16But the Rams are ones like, I'm thinking like in NBA terms.
04:20Sure.
04:20You know, in NBA terms.
04:21They were good.
04:22They developed some Pro Bowl.
04:24So I would almost use the methodology would be like how many, they're a super team.
04:30If going into that season, they have this many Pro Bowl players.
04:33Let's set it up then.
04:34This many All-Pro players.
04:35And they acquired this many Pro Bowl players or veterans or whatever.
04:39Let's set it up then.
04:40What are the criteria in my, because I did.
04:42Like when I just saw super teams in the NFL, I was like, wait, what constitutes that?
04:45Because there's not, that's not a common parlance that we use when talking about the NFL.
04:49And I appreciate what he was going for, which is just like a team that is a runaway favorite.
04:53But that doesn't necessarily correlate to super teams.
04:55So what does?
04:56You're laying out a certain number of just like All-Pro, Pro Bowl type players, right?
05:01Is there any consideration for coaching as well, right?
05:04Like, do you have to have incredible coaching as well?
05:06Because if we're just going All-Pro, Pro Bowl type players, could the Texans not be in a place
05:11where you start considering them as a quote-unquote super team?
05:14Yes.
05:14Yes.
05:15To that end, I saw Bleach Report, which is not the most, you know, not the most credible,
05:20I guess, resource to use in any different circumstance.
05:22But they put together a top 10 list of the most stacked rosters.
05:26That's the word that they used.
05:27I don't know exactly what you want to do with that because they didn't give their methodology.
05:30However, number one on their top 10 is these Houston Texans.
05:34And I don't think we talk about it as like this is a stacked team all the way around.
05:38We kind of talk about that with the defense.
05:40Yeah.
05:40But would you not then take that to look at and go, the Texans actually are a super team?
05:45Or what else would be missing from you to say that?
05:48Yeah, I think more weapons, super weapons, proven pro bowlers.
05:51Now, I know they brought in David Montgomery, but, you know, on the offensive side.
05:55Collins.
05:57Well, that was a developed one, yes.
05:59Schultz.
06:00For sure.
06:01No, I don't think it's necessarily outrageous because the defense is such, is so stacked.
06:06But that's just not, I think you have to kind of just like, it feels like, it's a super,
06:11like when the Rams brought in Matthew Stafford.
06:13All right.
06:14You know, they already have Aaron Donald and they have, you know, all these players.
06:17And now they're bringing in Matt Stafford.
06:19Now they're bringing in all these other guys, Miles Garrett, and maybe bringing back Aaron Donald.
06:22Well, you know, I think you could talk about teams.
06:26What's another one with a big time off season acquisitions, plural.
06:3007 Patriots is the one that I go to where you, where you go, wait a minute.
06:34Yeah.
06:34Is that Randy Moss's music joining the Patriots?
06:37Yeah, yeah.
06:37But I think also, and it's right, I kind of alluded to it.
06:40I do wonder if the thing that would, the thing that doesn't hold me up personally from going
06:45the Patriots are, sorry, the Texans.
06:47Wow.
06:47What a Freudian slip.
06:48The Texans aren't a super team.
06:51It's offensive coordinator right now.
06:53Because I think also, football more than basketball, I'm required to have all my talented players
06:59put in the opportunity to succeed by my play callers.
07:02Yeah.
07:03And if I'm talking about the 07 Patriots, I know that there's offense that is really well
07:08situated there.
07:08You talk about these Rams and I go, yeah, Sean McVay is dialing it up.
07:11I don't have that same confidence as of right this moment that that is what you're talking
07:15about, especially on the level of, this is another addition to what we're doing here.
07:19It's not just that he's there calling plays, but this is a guy that I know adds into the
07:23win probability if I was going to somehow break it down person by person on the staff
07:27and in the room.
07:28And so that's the thing that would probably hold me back more than anything else is feeling
07:32like, what is this offense?
07:33Is it well realized?
07:35And is it something that adds to the, you know, Nico Collins of the world, the CJ Strouds
07:41of the world, the David Montgomery, so on and so forth.
07:42But you're not wrong, but you also are in the weeds a little bit.
07:45Like super teams to me, and I think the more just casual fans or onlookers is the players.
07:53Like you, you got a super team, you know, you've, you've got studs, but you're not wrong.
07:57I mean, yes, that's, that's what's lacking.
07:59I just feel like it's, it's some of the names on the roster and you think, look at the defense.
08:04They went out and got a very established pro bowl in Daniel Hunter, you know, and back,
08:09you know, a couple of years ago.
08:10Now they've developed Willie Anderson and their own cornerback.
08:12We know, we know the players.
08:13You talk about adding, I mean, and it's not just that they drafted to this team, which
08:17you could talk about that, right?
08:18Kay McDonald being, jumping in defensively.
08:21They did go acquire Reed Blankenship, who was a Super Bowl winner.
08:24Like they literally went and got a dude who already had a ring.
08:27If you wanted to do this, you absolutely could do this with the Texans as this is actually
08:31a super team and maybe we need to talk about them as such.
08:33Yeah.
08:33And certainly on that side of the ball.
08:35And I think that's why it's not being talked about as much because the, the story is just
08:39as big on the offensive side about what they might or might not be.
08:43As it is on the defense, what they are, you know, and then that, and I think that's
08:47counterbalance.
08:48And it's, it's silly because we had already talked about this in the, in the terms of
08:53this is a team that has Super Bowl expectation, not just Super Bowl hopes.
08:58Cause I mean, there are, you can't, if we're being honest, you can't say that all 32 teams
09:02really and truly have Super Bowl hopes, but they have Super Bowl expectation now.
09:08Yes, they do.
09:09And I think that it starts within themselves, right?
09:11They talk about the, the, put a bull on a ring, which still eludes me, even though I
09:14understand what they mean, right?
09:15Like your Super Bowl ring that has a bull on it, which means that you were the champion.
09:19It still sounds weird to me, but that's, that's the expectation.
09:22And I think that comes from clearly the way that they've built this team.
09:26But for some reason, my brain does not go to super team.
09:28Maybe it's just being so close on the ground to the deficiencies or whatever.
09:32And maybe it's because there's just one side of the football that is so clearly still
09:36needing to demonstrate its capability to do this consistently and at that level.
09:41But yeah, we're probably talking about something that is somewhere close, if not already embodying
09:46what you could probably reasonably say is a super team in the National Football League.
09:50Yeah.
09:51And I think that that needs to, we probably need to represent that or, you know, meet that
09:55a little bit closer with the way that we talk about them.
09:57So, but the Rams, you know, they do check all the boxes.
10:01Yeah.
10:01You know, for, for, for what, well, you know, what's funny consider, I started looking at
10:05the Rams roster this year and in a way there, there's ways where you can go, oh, this actually
10:13isn't as, this isn't as stacked as I would have wanted to say when I looked at it, where
10:20well, I mean, offensive weapons is where, is where it, um, kind of gets a little funny
10:27to me.
10:28Really?
10:28Yeah.
10:29How so?
10:30So, all right.
10:31So when we talk about the offense, like clearly Matt Stafford himself exists as some level
10:36of weapon, right?
10:37But you get what I'm saying.
10:38We go to Pook and Nakua, Devontae Adams, right?
10:41I'm good with that.
10:42That's enough?
10:43Like, it's just.
10:43And Jordan Whittington?
10:46We'll see about that.
10:47I was like, come on, man.
10:47We'll see about that.
10:48I was like, Figgy, I said Pook and Nakua, Devontae Adams, he's like, and Jordan Whittington.
10:53And Jordan Whittington.
10:53I thought we were being serious here.
10:55I thought we were being serious human beings.
10:57But look at their, look at their backfield.
10:58That's what I was going to ask you.
10:59Like, how do you then, because Kyron Williams has been good.
11:02Blake Corum has been a little disappointing, if I'm going to be entirely honest.
11:05Does Kyron Williams strike you as like super team running back?
11:08I think they have the assortment of running backs.
11:10Blake Corum did get better as the season progressed last year.
11:13He's better late in the season.
11:15But no, I, like it's hard.
11:18Here's the other thing about super teams.
11:20There still are salary caps.
11:21You know, there still are, you know, there's restrictions.
11:25And with the salary cap to have Adams and Nakua and Matthew Stafford and two running backs
11:30that you can count on, that's good enough for me on offense.
11:33And then, of course, we know what they have on defense.
11:34And their offensive line is good.
11:37Well, their offensive line is, yeah, solid.
11:38I give you that.
11:39But then I bring that back home and I go, then we can't talk crazy about the wide receiver
11:44room in the ways that we kind of have.
11:46I think they still might need another wide receiver.
11:48I mean, you've got Nico Collins, who's definitely there.
11:51If Higgins is demonstrating the way that he is, you go, Nico, Higgins, a tight end that
11:56you can trust, probably two, if we're talking about Dalton and Foster, before we even get
12:01to what Marlon Klein is, and two running backs that have demonstrated themselves to be capable.
12:06And David Montgomery historically has demonstrated himself to be even more than capable.
12:10There you go.
12:11So you're saying the Texans have as good an offense as the Rams?
12:14No, clearly not.
12:16But what I'm saying is, especially because I was the one talking about the offense and
12:19the play call, and you were like, I'm in the weeds.
12:21If I'm in the weeds and we're not considering that, what are we doing here?
12:24No, no, no.
12:25I didn't say you were wrong.
12:25I said you were right.
12:26I just think that when you talk about super team, people are talking about the players.
12:31Like, you got studs.
12:33And I think that's where, you know, offensively, you can't quite say that yet.
12:38I think that there's enough studs on this where I think that the offense probably needs
12:41to be held to that certain level of account.
12:44Like, you're on a super team.
12:46Act like it.
12:46Well, sure.
12:47I don't disagree with that either.
12:49But they don't.
12:50I mean, they don't have the pelts on the wall.
12:52They don't.
12:52Yeah.
12:53They don't.
12:54Yeah.
12:54I mean, that's absolutely fair.
12:56I don't really care about that right this moment, I'll be honest.
12:59I really and truly don't.
13:00So, yeah, man.
13:02Obviously, the Rams are going to be the team that people are concerned with, the teams that
13:05people are looking at.
13:07Texans need to operate as such, right?
13:09Like, behave as if you are, what is it, the dress for the job that you want?
13:13Well, hey, man, dress like and act like you are a super team.
13:17Because, I mean, by certain metrics or by a lot of the metrics that you have, even if
13:21you don't check all the boxes, you're right there.
13:23And you need to show up as such.

Recommended