• 11 months ago
On this Special Report, the focus is on the political turmoil in West Bengal following suspended Trinamool Congress (TMC) MLA Humayun Kabir's launch of his new political outfit, the 'Janata Unnayan Party'. The move comes days after Kabir laid the foundation stone for a replica of the Babri Masjid in Murshidabad, sparking a fierce debate on communal polarization ahead of the 2026 Assembly elections. Senior Journalist Shikha Mukherjee observes, 'Humayun Kabir has made his point very clear. One, he's going to construct a masjid and it's going to be a replica of the Babri Masjid.' The programme features a heated debate between BJP National Spokesperson Radhika Kheda, who denies any BJP involvement, and Political Analyst Monujeet Mandal, who alleges a conspiracy to divide the minority vote.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Babur was an invader. Babur was not Indian. He invaded India in 1526. So in 21st century India,
00:07is it pure vote bank politics that a mosque is being built in his name, in the name of a cruel
00:13invader? And is there merit in RSS Chief Mohan Bhagwat saying the construction of a mosque in
00:18the name of Babur will only widen the rift? And it's not in the interest of either Hindus or
00:24Muslims in India. What should one make of Humayu Kabir, the suspended TMC MLA who's floated
00:30his own party, now targeting both the TMC and the BJP and Mamata Banerjee, insisting that
00:35all of this, all of this is aimed at dividing the minorities and that minorities should
00:42stand united. Will this impact Bengal elections? Joining me on India First is Radhika Keda, representing
00:49the Bharatiya Janata Party. Monajit Mandal is a political analyst, will also give us the
00:53Trinamool Congress thinking. Shikha Mukherjee is a senior journalist. Tushar Gupta is a political
00:58analyst and journalist. Monajit Mandal, why does the Trinamool Congress see the construction
01:03of a Baburi Masjid in Bengal as a BJP conspiracy when Humayu Kabir was a TMC MLA till his suspension?
01:10The BJP says thousands would not have come for this mosque foundation or prayers unless there
01:17was state approval.
01:22I think you do not probably know the history of this particular person by the name of Humayun
01:28Kabir. He left TMC before. He joined the BJP, joined TMC again, was defeated. He came back
01:36to TMC. Yes. And I believe he should have been accepted by TMC at that point of time. But
01:43he profusely apologized to the party, including the, you know, the supreme of the party. And
01:50because of that, I think he was taken back. This person for the last one year has been singing
01:56the tunes of the other side of BJP.
02:00We know in this country that BJP has got some B teams like A M I M which are also known as
02:08a kind of vote Katoa parties. Similarly, BJP wanted to have a person like Humayun Kabir
02:15as a vote Katoa party. Last year also, I mean last election also, they had one particular party
02:21which is completely laughed by Suvendodhikari, that is ISA, which was also actually people
02:28say and allege that it's run on BJP's money. I am also charging on this television, on your
02:35show, where does the money come from as far as this person is concerned? We get to hear,
02:41in fact, this is a political charge made by the Trinamul congress as well, that Hemant
02:47Biswasarma provided 10 crores of funds. Is it true or not? How much money, where is
02:53ED now? ED CBI? We will support it. Sir, that's a very grave charge you are leveling.
02:58You are saying, you are alleging that Hemant Biswasarma, the Assam chief minister is funding
03:05the Babri Masjid in Bengal. Is that your allegation, sir? But on what basis?
03:08This is political, that's what I am saying, this is political charges people are making
03:13in Bengal and this should be inquired into. And in fact, you see the money floating, money
03:19floating in caches. Where is your ED? Where is CBI? Where does the money come from? The crores
03:24of funds is almost, you know, almost, you know, running like papers. Sir, you are saying there
03:33is no tacit approval of Mamata Bangarji for the construction of a Babri Masjid. Let me
03:38get, let me get Radhika Kheda, let me get Radhika Kheda to respond to this. Radhika Kheda, that's
03:43a very serious charge. Okay. Sir, Radhika Kheda, that's a very serious charge that's being
03:48leveled. The Trinamul congress sees this as a BJP conspiracy with BJP funding according
03:54to the TMC and supporters, the construction of a Babri Masjid in Bengal.
03:58Jai Shriram. And BJP, even in its worst position, will never be funding a mosque being made,
04:05let alone Babri being made again. Let me make this very, very clear on your show today.
04:09Gaurav, that as many Babri they will make, they will be the first Babri as well. This country
04:14is not done by Babarnama. Having said that, in Bengal, what we are witnessing today are two
04:19parallel strategies that are being destroyed by the ruling dispensation and it's indeed
04:23Thakbandhan. One, manipulation of the ballot. Two, manufacturing communal flashpoints to divert
04:28attention because that is what they thrive on. Now, the so-called Babri Masjid that they are
04:33making, it is not accidental. It is timed, it is designed and it is electoral. Was he sleeping
04:38all these years? Why did he not announce it earlier? Let us be absolutely clear on one thing.
04:42The Ayodhya issue is legally, constitutionally and finally settled by the Supreme Court of India.
04:47There is no dispute left to resolve and there is no grievance left to educate. But attempts
04:52are now being made in Bengal to resurrect the imagery, the symbolism and the language.
04:56And it's not about religion. It is categorically and clearly about polarization for votes.
05:00Because Mamata Banerjee is seeing her ground being removed from right under her, the carpet
05:05is just being pulled out because the votes are cut out of all Ghuspaitiyos. So she had no other
05:10option left because that is the vote bank that she depends on. So this is a call even to the Ghuspaitiyas
05:15and everyone and to polarize the whole thing. She has nothing to talk about when it comes
05:19to women's security. She has nothing to talk about her industrialization.
05:21That's a grave counter-charge. There is a grave counter-charge. On the aspect of Himant
05:25Visma Sarma and the allegation leveled by TMC, I want you to respond to that but in just a moment.
05:29Mohanujit Mandal, before I bring in Shikha Mukherjee and Tushar Gupta, you want to quickly
05:33respond to the fact that this is a TMC tactics, a ploy to polarize elections and ensure that all the Muslims
05:41vote for the same ecosystem as the BJP puts it.
05:45Mr. Gaurav Sravant, I believe you know the history of BJP's rise in this country
05:51as a political party. BJP rose to powers and prominence by demolishing Babri Mohsjid.
05:57So what suited their kinds of politics? That's the binary, that's the polarization that they thrive on.
06:03Till 1982, till 1982 and late 1980s, nobody could understand that BJP would come to power in such a way.
06:13And it's only because of that famous Ratajatra taken by Mr. L. K. Adbani and who was being rather
06:19fanned by the present Prime Minister, Mr. Modi used to sit in front of Mr. Adbani almost,
06:27looking at the feet of Mr. Adbani, fanning him like that, doing the Ratajatra, you can also get that
06:33photographs in your archive. That is the famous Ratajatra that made BJP what it is today.
06:39So this Babri demolition, now it's a reconstruction of the quote unquote Babri, not even in terms of
06:45you know what is happening in architecture, but even in terms of virtual construction of Babri Mohsjid,
06:51those images will once again help BJP only. There are researches, not just in India,
06:56but across the globe on these, the communal politics, communal polarization, who stands to gain?
07:02BJP, UP.
07:04Okay, Radhika Kheda also quickly respond before I bring in Sheikha Mukherjee. Radhika Kheda quickly in 30 seconds ma'am.
07:10Are you speaking to me because the audio is very bad?
07:13Yes, Radhika Kheda.
07:15You know, let me make this very clear to the TMC spokesperson, the Bahaar Ke Janata Party
07:19does not need religious flashpoints to win elections. Our work is enough. We are doing enough work,
07:24which is why we are decimating the Indi Thakbandan everywhere, whether it is the local body polls,
07:29it is the Vidhan Sabha polls or the Lok Sabha polls. We don't need to bank on religion to win elections.
07:36that is what we have been winning on for the past 11 years. And you are not able to decimate us.
07:42So you are trying this very old book ploy to create a fear, to create fear in people, to create a divide amongst people.
07:51Because like I said, Mamata Banerjee has nothing to offer. No industrialization, no jobs, no women's security.
07:57She has failed as the home minister. She has failed as the woman chief minister. She has failed every daughter of West Bengal.
08:03She has always banked upon the very thing that she has resigned in Lok Sabha during the Congress government
08:09and through papers on the speaker's face for saying that she is in Bengal.
08:13Today she is standing and imagine a chief minister of a state standing and saying, I will see how anyone is sent back to Bangladesh.
08:20Let me bring in Shikha Mukherjee. Let me quickly bring in Shikha Mukherjee into this conversation.
08:25Shikha Mukherjee, in a secular state, any individual can build any religious place. But to name it, Babari Masjid.
08:33Do you see suspended TMC leader Humayun Kabir creating trouble in Bengal?
08:37What is your reading of the timing just before assembly elections, madam?
08:42I think that is, Humayun Kabir has made his point very clear.
08:47One, he is going to construct a masjid and it's going to be a replica of the Babari Masjid.
08:54Why? Because he thinks that that is the one way of consolidating a Hindu, a Muslim vote, which he wants to represent.
09:05But he's named his party Janata Unnan Party.
09:08In other words, he doesn't want a specifically AIMIM kind of label.
09:15So he's hoping to cash in on, A, a consolidation of the Muslim votes in Muslim majority districts or in Muslim majority constituencies.
09:28And B, he's also trying to create a kind of non-communal label for himself so that he can attract other voters.
09:40And look at how he has done it.
09:43The reconstruction of the Babari Masjid event, that event on 6th of December, it was straight out of the Ayodhya playbook.
09:56You had people carrying bricks, which they had made in their villages to contribute to the foundation laying stone.
10:04You had this kind of people coming in and chipping in with their donations.
10:12Then you had the kind of mass Quran reading.
10:17So everything is a kind of public performance to galvanize the vote bank he thinks is up for grabs.
10:30Whether his thinking is right or wrong remains to be seen.
10:34But he is talking about a Muslim vote bank.
10:37And he's talking about winning 90 seats and turning himself into a kingmaker in West Bengal politics.
10:46Now, if these are his ambitions, then obviously there has to be a partner in crime.
10:54And the partner in crime would be any party which gets around 70, 60 seats, because then it would be halfway mark.
11:05And that kind of makes it very interesting.
11:09He cannot align with the normal Congress if it gets however many, if it gets a minority of the seats.
11:15The chances of the Congress and the CPM getting any of that number is out of the question, which leaves him with only one partner.
11:23Now, which is the BJP.
11:25Very interesting.
11:26And this is a very strange calculation.
11:30So in other words, what was being spoken of earlier is that in West Bengal, Humayun Kabir's move is as much a kind of communal polarization,
11:46communal consolidation effort, as is the BJP's entire narrative on the Ghusbetya, the demographic change, how the infiltrators have added population and all of that.
12:01To weigh in on this, because that's a very interesting perspective that you've raised on this issue.
12:05You know, because Babar was an invader.
12:07Babar was not Indian.
12:09Is it just insensitive or downright divisive to construct a masjid in Bengal in the name of Babri?
12:16Can we recreate fissures in society?
12:19The BJP says it cannot happen without state support.
12:22But there are those who say that ultimately this will only benefit either Humayun Kabir or the BJP.
12:28Or can it also benefit the TMC, Tushar Gupta?
12:31Tushar Gupta.
12:32Good evening, Gaurav.
12:34Look, if you look at the West Bengal electoral dynamics, if I pick up the elections of 2019, 2021, even 2024 for that matter,
12:41the best case scenario for the BJP has always been attaining a 40% vote share.
12:46But interestingly, Mamata Bangalji starts with a vote share of 35 to 40% because she has successfully consolidated the minority vote.
12:54We may not like it, we may argue against it, but it cannot be denied that the TMC starts with a 35% vote share purely and purely
13:01because the minority or the second largest majority in Bengal will not vote for the BJP
13:07and the Congress is not forced to be reckoned with any longer in Bengal.
13:11Now, if Humayun Kabir's antics are to be taken seriously,
13:15we are looking at a potential party which can cut through the TMC vote bank, the primary TMC vote bank.
13:21Now, if I look at the election of UP, Bihar, Madhya Pradesh, even Rajasthan in the past, even Uttarakhand for that matter,
13:28I have realized that the second largest majority in India, it works in law.
13:33It works very strategically, Gaurav, even Maharashtra for that matter,
13:36in the assembly elections and the Lok Sabha elections, which were just three months apart.
13:40You had Muslims voting for different parties, but they were voting together for one party in a particular election.
13:46So, in one seat, they were voting for the Congress in the Lok Sabha election, but in another assembly election,
13:51they were voting for some regional party, but all the vote, lock, stock and barrel went to that one party.
13:57So, if you're questioning that will Humayun Kabir be able to cut through Mantab Anerji's primary vote bank,
14:03I don't think so. And this is where Mohan Bhagwat's statement about unity of Hindus in Bengal becomes very, very important.
14:10You pick up the last three, four elections, it's always this eight percentage point gap between the BJP and the TNC that becomes a deciding factor.
14:18A couple of percentages point here and there, and BJP's totally off the mark as it happened in 2024 also.
14:27Though they had a respectable 38% vote share, but they lost six Lok Sabha seats compared to 2019.
14:33So, at the end of the day, the Hindu vote that the BJP is unable to get in Bengal, that is the Achilles heel in their entire electoral campaign.
14:41And this is the bridge they really have to cross in the upcoming assembly polls, if they can do it well and good.
14:46But if they are hoping for Humayun Kabir to break through the TNC vote bank, I would advise them against it.
14:52Okay, because Mohanujit Mandal, Mamata Banerjee and the TNC want minorities to stand united.
14:58And they are saying so in as many words and claim Humayun Kabir and Asaduddin Oesi of the AIMIM,
15:04as you also pointed out, you know, they are being seen more as vote cutters.
15:08The BJP is trying to divide the Muslims, is that the apprehension that the Muslim vote, if it gets divided, could mean trouble for the TNC?
15:17Let us just assess the situation politically. I am not talking about the legal issue.
15:24The matter went to the High Court. The High Court categorically stated that someone can build a mosque in a private land.
15:30The state can't do anything with that. That's the clear verdict from the High Court.
15:35Now, look at the political situation here. When Jagannath Temple was being inaugurated and it was being built,
15:41look at the kind of narrative BJP ran. They have again filed a PL against inauguration of Jagannath Temple,
15:49saying that this was Mamata Di's own, you know, this was taken from the state exchequer.
15:55But right now, there is not even whisper. When there is a mosque being built, there is no political challenge to this.
16:04I want to see BJP challenging this mosque, the way they challenged Jagannath Temple in Diga,
16:10which has now become one of the vibrant tourist spots in the country.
16:14Look at the footfalls after the inauguration of Jagannath Temple in Diga in the last one year.
16:19BJP, there is no political whisper. As it were, they are pandering to this mosque being built up. Why?
16:25Because they want polarization. Because they want the votes to be divided.
16:30But people of Bengal, Hindu, Muslim, Christian, irrespective of their religion,
16:35they know that they vote only for development.
16:38BJP tried the race in the last seven, eight years to divide.
16:41Mamata Banerjee wants Muslims to stand united.
16:44Mamata Banerjee wants Muslims to stay united. Mohan Bhagwat wants Hindus to stand united.
16:50So is the polarization already happening on communal lines in Bengal?
16:54Gaurav, I have a very simple question to ask Mr. Monajit Mandal over here.
16:59Should Babri Masjid be made or not? Yes or no?
17:04Can he please answer me? I will continue after that.
17:06Simply, simply no, no, no and no.
17:10Then why are you starting? Why have you not arrested that man?
17:13So many people are collecting over there.
17:15How can you do that?
17:16Of course, if someone is making it, Mr. Mandal, I didn't speak over you. Let me complete.
17:20Let me complete. If a man, let me complete.
17:23I'm very fine.
17:24Let me complete, Mr. Mandal, let me complete.
17:26I asked you a question, you gave me a reply.
17:28If you believe, like I do and like my party does, that Babri Masjid should not be made,
17:34what is stopping Mamata Banerjee ji to arrest that man?
17:38A, you took weeks to first throw him out of your party.
17:41First, you checked the temperature.
17:43Is this going to affect or help her politically or not?
17:47Then you waited for that and then after that you took action against her.
17:51Second, if he is trying to create communal tension, she has every right and authority to put a stop to making that.
17:58Let me complete. You can answer after that. You spoke well before me.
18:02She has every right and authority as the chief minister and home minister of the state to go on and arrest him and stop that masjid from being made if it's going to disrupt the communal harmony of the state.
18:12But no, she wants that to be made because she wants communal harmony to be disrupted.
18:17The same way that she wants to stand as a protector of the Rohingyas and of the Bangladeshis was crossed over.
18:23That is a fact.
18:24Ma'am, you made a point. Okay. Mr. Mandal wants to respond. Go ahead, sir.
18:27Probably she did not listen to my argument.
18:30The legally there was a case filed.
18:32The court has clearly stated someone is building a mosque on his private land.
18:37So, the court will say if communal harmony is being created in the elected courts?
18:42Ma'am, let him complete his point.
18:43Are you saying court will be agreeable to that?
18:45He can name it Babri.
18:46He can name it Arunba.
18:47Did you go and put your stand in court?
18:49Did the government of West Bank all say this in court that this is disrupting communal harmony?
18:54Ma'am, he can name it Arunba.
18:55Did your government say this in court?
18:57Did Mata Banerjee say this in court?
18:59Now listen to the answer. What is your problem?
19:01Have you given this in court in writing that this will disrupt communal harmony and it should not be paid?
19:06Please show me a paper where Mata Banerjee says that it should not be made.
19:09That's own, but that don't, we are very sure that would not disturb the communal harmony in this country or the state, not the country, in the state, it will not.
19:19Has Mata Banerjee gone and told the court and no, we believe it should not be made?
19:24Why don't you, why don't you invest into the sources of funds?
19:27Show me the papers.
19:28How much, how does this person getting the funds?
19:31How much money is floating in the air?
19:33Take out the game.
19:35Please, that is why you can arrange this land.
19:39Someone is building a temple.
19:41Someone is building a mosque.
19:42Someone is building a mosque.
19:43You can challenge it not only politically, but legally you cannot challenge it.
19:47Have you gone to court?
19:49Have you said this in court?
19:52Has the Mata Banerjee government gone to court say that these can't disturb the communal harmony?
19:59Let's bring down temperatures for a moment.
20:03Shikha Mukherjee, if the AIMIM and Humayu Kabir, as all indications are, are to formally tie up, as reports seem to indicate,
20:13does that spell trouble for Mamata Banerjee in places like Malda, Murshidabad, Beer Bhoom or North and South Dinajpur or even some places in South Dinajpur?
20:20They tried it last year also completely unsuccessful.
20:23They tried it last time also in 2021.
20:26Completely unsuccessful.
20:27Okay.
20:28Ms. Mukherjee.
20:29Yeah.
20:30Well, if it actually happens and the campaign actually reaches a point.
20:38I mean, there are so many ifs along the way.
20:41And the campaign has to pick up some kind of momentum for a Muslim vote bank, which has, over the years, tended to align with the ruling party.
20:57Yes.
20:58The campaign that we have seen, it aligned with a large proportion of the Muslim vote aligned with the CPM.
21:07Then, before that, it used to vote with the Congress.
21:10Yes.
21:11And these votes have shifted depending on who is the ruling party.
21:17Now, why would a Muslim population in West Bengal, which feels itself to be in a precarious situation, want to vote with a Humayun Kavir, who is not likely to make it to power, with AIMIM, who is also not likely to make it to power, and quit it.
21:36So, they will weigh up the risks and benefits.
21:40Okay.
21:41And we will see how it progresses.
21:43Number one.
21:44Number two, I have a small question for the person from the BJP, or rather a piece point of information, which may soothe her very overcharged sentiments, which is that there are two Ayodhya temple replicas coming up in West Bengal.
22:04On the day that you had the Babri Masjid foundation stone being laid, there was another temple stone that was being laid, and that was for an Ayodhya Ram temple replica.
22:14And this is the second time over that it has happened.
22:17Therefore, this polarization and both the locations of all these three new places of worship are Mushidabad.
22:29So, apparently, it is Mushidabad where the entire drama is going to play out, and then the anticipation is that there will be a ripple effect.
22:42I think this is all known.
22:44And hence that question on Malda, Mursidabad, South Kolkata, I will take that to Tushar in just a moment.
22:49But Radhika, you want to quickly respond to that?
22:53Gaurabh, because of the audio, I could not hear a word of what she was saying.
22:56So, Ms. Mukherjee said that there are two replicas of the Divya Bhavya Ram temple that are also coming up in Mursidabad.
23:03So, if that's, you know, good, why is the Babri Masjid bad perhaps?
23:07Well, I don't know.
23:08I don't know. She's a very senior journalist and she's, I'm sure she has read about Babar much more than I have.
23:14She's been on this earth for many more years than I have.
23:17And I'm sure that she knows that Babar was an invader who raped our women who created havoc in the country.
23:24He ensured that people's religion was converted and all the drama that he did.
23:29He was an invader who destroyed Indian Sanskriti and our religion.
23:32And if she is okay with his Babri Masjid being made, then Lord save the country.
23:37Absolutely. And comparing that to Lord Rama's mandir is very unfortunate.
23:41For anyone who is well educated to know the difference between Babri and Ram.
23:45Yes, can I quickly bring in Kishar and then I'm coming to you, sir.
23:47Kishar TMC says Humayu Kabir is an agent of the BJP.
23:50Though Shah Nawaz Hussain sees Humayu Kabir as an agent of the TMC working at TMC's behest.
23:56Family of the TMC.
23:58You know, the point, the interesting thing is Humayu Kabir is an agent of nobody.
24:05He might be playing double sides, but he is benefiting none.
24:07Look, West Wing Hall is different.
24:09People don't realize it's a state with two majorities.
24:11Normally we are always dealing with one majority and another minority in every state.
24:15But West Wing Hall is two majorities.
24:17One majority that works end block towards the TMC
24:21and one majority that is still not gravitating towards the BJP.
24:24So, whatever Humayu Kabir does, until the first majority, the Hindus do not go towards the BJP,
24:30the election will swing Mamta Panip Ji's way.
24:33And again, it needs to be emphasized, Muslims tend to work lock, stock and barrel.
24:38They understand where their vote is getting divided and they do not fall for it.
24:42That's about it.
24:43Okay.
24:44Okay, so let's see which way the voters, you know, decide and vote.
24:49And we'll be tracking that story very closely.
24:51I want to thank all my guests.

Recommended