- 2 days ago
Yes, Judaism(s) were and are something you never think about.
Category
đ
LearningTranscript
00:00Um, what is a schism?
00:02A schism is a split.
00:04It is a formal division within a religious or social body over a point of doctrine or practice.
00:11People who share a common heritage and a deep history can still find themselves on opposite sides of a divide.
00:17The long and complex history of the Jewish people is marked by several such splits.
00:23Some of these divisions were born from geography, separated by mountains, separated by rivers.
00:28Some were the result of historical accidents, like the rise and fall of empires that scattered people across the globe.
00:36The nature of God, the meaning of scripture, the correct way to live a holy life.
00:41In this essay, we will follow a clear timeline of these major schisms.
00:46We will begin our journey in the ancient world, with the earliest political and religious fractures,
00:52and travel forward through the centuries.
00:54The Second Temple World, bustling, contentious.
00:58The birth of Christianity, moving away from Jewish roots.
01:03Intellectual debates that challenged rabbinic authority.
01:06Spiritual revivals that reshaped regions and culture.
01:10The modern era, enlightenment and emancipation, defining new splits.
01:15Each story is a human story of conviction, conflict, and the search for meaning.
01:20This is not about choosing sides.
01:23A schism is more than an argument.
01:25It's a community redefining itself.
01:28Fault lines reveal core values and anxieties of their time.
01:32Examining these divisions shows Jewish resilience and adaptability.
01:36One tradition, many expressions, each responding to its day.
01:40These splits are central to Jewish survival and evolution.
01:44Understanding them helps explain the Jewish world today.
01:49Orthodox Reform Conservative, Hasidic Kariti.
01:52They are the living legacies of past debates.
01:56Different paths at critical junctures.
01:58Tracing them back helps us appreciate contemporary diversity.
02:02Unity isn't uniformity.
02:05The tapestry of Jewish identity is woven with many colored threads, each thread telling part
02:10of a 3,000-year story.
02:12Long before the theological disputes of later eras, the first major split in ancient Israel
02:18was political geographic and deeply personal.
02:22After the death of King Solomon, his son Rehoboam ascended the throne of a united kingdom.
02:26The northern tribes, burdened by heavy taxes and forced labor, approached the new king.
02:33Lighten our load.
02:34Rehoboam ignored his elder advisors, answered harshly.
02:38He'd be tougher than his father.
02:41That political miscalculation fractured the kingdom.
02:44Ten northern tribes broke away to form the kingdom of Israel.
02:48The southern tribes, Judah-Benjamin, stayed loyal to Rehoboam, forming the kingdom of Judah.
02:54The First Great Schism
02:56Two distinct political and religious centers emerged.
03:01Judah's capital, Jerusalem.
03:03Religious life centered on Solomon's temple.
03:06Set up religious sites at Dan Bethel.
03:08Installed golden calves to stop pilgrimages to the southern capital.
03:13The rivalry deepened and lasted centuries.
03:15The kingdoms clashed, developed separate histories and prophetic traditions, until Israel was conquered
03:21and exiled by Assyria in 722 BCE.
03:26From that northern remnant, the Samaritans emerged.
03:30They claimed descent from Ephraim Manasseh.
03:33They view themselves as preservers of the ancient Israelite faith.
03:37Their center is Mount Gerizim, not Jerusalem.
03:40Their scripture, only the first five books, the Samaritan Pentateuch.
03:45They reject the later prophetic writings central to Rabbinic Judaism.
03:49A theological and cultural wall grew between Samaritans and Jews of Judah.
03:54Jews returning from Babylon to rebuild the temple viewed Samaritans with suspicion,
03:59and practicing impure worship.
04:01That distrust calcified into a lasting schism.
04:04For millennia, Samaritans maintained unique rituals and community.
04:08A small living testament to the first division among the children of Israel.
04:12A split born of geography and politics became a deep religious separation.
04:17Two peoples with a common ancestor, walking different paths.
04:22The period of the second temple lasting from roughly 516 BCE to 70 CE,
04:28was a time of immense creativity and internal conflict within Jewish society.
04:32With the temple in Jerusalem rebuilt and serving as the focal point of national life,
04:38a vibrant and often contentious marketplace of ideas emerged.
04:42This was not a monolithic community, but a diverse society grappling with major issues.
04:48The influence of Greek culture, the tension between the priestly class and the common people,
04:53and the looming shadow of Roman imperial power.
04:56Four major groups came to define this era.
04:58The Sadducees were the establishment.
05:06They were largely composed of the wealthy, aristocratic, priestly families who controlled the temple and its rituals.
05:13Their power was tied to the temple institution.
05:16They tended to be more accommodating to Hellenistic and later Roman powers to maintain status and social order.
05:23Theologically, they were conservative, accepting only the written Torah as authoritative,
05:29rejecting the growing body of oral law.
05:32They denied the resurrection of the dead and the existence of a spiritual afterlife.
05:37In contrast, the Pharisees were more rooted among the common people.
05:42They were scholars and teachers who championed the oral Torah.
05:45A vast collection of interpretations, laws, and traditions, passed down through generations.
05:51For the Pharisees, holiness was not confined to the temple.
05:55It could be achieved by anyone, anywhere, through meticulous observance of Jewish law.
06:01Their emphasis on study debate and application of law to new situations allowed Judaism to be portable and adaptable.
06:08The intellectual and spiritual tradition of the Pharisees ultimately survived the temple's destruction and evolved into rabbinic Judaism.
06:18Two other groups represented the extremes of the spectrum.
06:22The Essenes were a pietistic and ascetic sect who believed the temple establishment had become corrupt.
06:28They withdrew from mainstream society to live in communal settlements such as Qumran near the Dead Sea.
06:34There they pursued ritual purity, prayer, and study.
06:38The Dead Sea Scrolls, discovered in the 20th century, give us a window into their beliefs and way of life.
06:45On the other end were the Zealots, militant nationalist groups advocating violent rebellion to overthrow Roman rule and restore Jewish independence.
06:53The revolt ended in catastrophic failure and the destruction of the Second Temple in 70 CE.
07:00That event forever changed the course of Jewish history.
07:03Within the same turbulent environment of the late Second Temple period, another movement began that would result in the most consequential schism of all.
07:13The first followers of Jesus of Nazareth were Jews.
07:17Jesus himself was a Jewish teacher who preached in synagogues and taught from the Hebrew scriptures.
07:22His disciples were Jews who followed Jewish law and worshipped at the temple in Jerusalem.
07:27They saw him not as the founder of a new religion, but as the long-awaited Messiah of Israel.
07:33In its earliest days, the movement was simply one of many Jewish sects existing within the broad and diverse framework of first-century Judaism.
07:42The initial debates were internal Jewish debates about the identity of one man.
07:46After Jesus' death, a critical debate emerged that would set the stage for the split.
07:52The question was about the law.
07:54Must non-Jewish converts known as Gentiles follow the entirety of Jewish law?
07:59Circumcision, dietary rules, Sabbath observance?
08:02Some original followers, led by figures like James in Jerusalem, insisted they must.
08:08They saw the movement as the fulfillment of Judaism, not its replacement.
08:12However, another influential leader, a former Pharisee named Paul, argued passionately that faith in Jesus as the Christ was sufficient for salvation,
08:21and that Gentiles should not be burdened with the full yoke of the Torah.
08:25This was a radical and controversial idea.
08:29This internal Jewish debate was a turning point.
08:32Paul's missionary journeys were incredibly successful among non-Jewish populations across the Roman Empire.
08:37As more Gentiles joined without adopting Jewish practices, the community began to look and feel distinct from the wider Jewish world.
08:46Over time, theological positions diverged more sharply.
08:50Followers of Jesus increasingly emphasized His divinity and His role as a universal Savior.
08:57The destruction of the Jerusalem Temple in 70 CE accelerated this separation.
09:02Rabbinic Judaism focused on law and text for survival, while the growing Christian movement defined itself more and more in opposition.
09:11What began as a disagreement over practice and inclusion slowly evolved into a full-blown schism.
09:17The two communities developed separate scriptures.
09:20Christians added the New Testament to the Hebrew Bible, separate leadership structures, and separate core theologies.
09:26The parting of the ways was not a single event, but a gradual and often painful process of separation.
09:33This theological schism would reshape the religious map of the world,
09:37creating two distinct faiths that shared a common origin and a long, complicated, and often tragic history of interaction.
09:45Section 5. The Word Alone.
09:49The Rise of Karaite Judaism.
09:51Centuries after the dust settled from the splits of the Second Temple era, a new internal challenge arose,
09:58focused on the source of religious authority.
10:01By the early Middle Ages, Rabbinic Judaism, the written Torah, the Tanakh, the Oral Torah, the Talmud,
10:09and other Rabbinic literature dominated Jewish life across the Middle East and Europe.
10:15The Rabbis held immense authority as the sole interpreters of this tradition.
10:19However, beginning in the 8th century in Baghdad, Karaism emerged offering a radical alternative.
10:26The Karaites rejected the divine authority of the Oral Torah.
10:29Karaites advocated a return to direct reading of the Hebrew Bible as the sole source of religious law.
10:36Anand Ben David and other thinkers argued the Talmud was a human invention,
10:40a collection of Rabbinic opinions elevated to divine status.
10:43They encouraged individual interpretation, every person obligated to study the text to determine God's will.
10:50A profound schism over textual authority, pitting plain scripture against Rabbinic interpretive tradition.
10:57This theological divide led to real differences in practice.
11:01Karaites rejected Rabbinic Sabbath rulings they spent the Sabbath in darkness,
11:05and cold Rabbinites allowed pre-lit fire.
11:08Karaites had different dietary laws, marriage rules, festival calendars.
11:13These distinctions created social and religious boundaries Rabbinite communities often viewed them as heretics.
11:19The movement flourished for centuries, spreading to the Middle East, to North Africa, and to Eastern Europe.
11:25At its height between the 9th and 12th centuries, a significant portion of world jury may have been Karaite.
11:31They built centers of learning and produced commentaries and legal codes.
11:35Numbers declined over time, but Karaite communities survive today with a major center in Israel.
11:41Between the authority of the written text and the authority of its interpreters.
11:46Not all schisms are born from slow-burning theological debates.
11:50Some erupt like a volcano, fueled by messianic hope and charismatic personalities.
11:55In the mid-17th century, the Jewish world was reeling from the Chmielniki massacres in Poland and Ukraine,
12:04left communities desperate for redemption.
12:07Into this environment stepped a charismatic Kabbalist from Smyrna, Sabbatai Zevi.
12:12In 1665, with the help of his prophet Nathan of Gaza, he declared himself the long-awaited messiah.
12:19The news spread like wildfire across the Jewish diaspora, from Yemen to Amsterdam, igniting a mass movement of unprecedented scale.
12:29Thousands of Jews became fervent believers, including prominent rabbis and wealthy merchants.
12:36They sold their homes, abandoned their businesses, and prepared to follow their messiah to the Holy Land.
12:41The movement was characterized by ecstatic acts of penitence, prophetic visions, and the joyful overturning of certain rabbinic laws.
12:50For a brief, intoxicating period, it seemed the exile was over.
12:55The schism was not between two interpretations of law, but between believers who thought redemption had arrived and those who remained skeptical.
13:03The entire Jewish world held its breath.
13:06The movement ended in 1666.
13:09Faced with an ultimatum from the Ottoman sultan, Sabbatai Zevi converted to Islam to save his life.
13:16The vast majority returned to traditional Judaism.
13:19A significant minority refused to abandon their faith.
13:23They developed theological justifications for his conversion, descent into impure realms to redeem hidden sparks.
13:30These Sabbatians often practiced Judaism in public while secretly maintaining their beliefs.
13:35The underground movement left a deep scar on the Jewish psyche.
13:40Rabbis became suspicious of Kabbalistic mysticism and cracked down on deviations.
13:45The controversy had a long, bizarre afterlife.
13:48In the 18th century, Jacob Frank claimed to be Sabbatai Zevi reborn.
13:53He led a nihilistic cult in Poland and ultimately led his followers to mass conversion to Catholicism.
13:59The Sabbatian and Frankist episodes show a schism born of personality and eschatological crisis.
14:06They are a dark reminder of the disruptive power of false messiahs.
14:10In the 18th century, in Eastern European lands, scarred by the Sabbatian disaster, a new spiritual movement arose to reshape the Jewish cultural landscape.
14:19This movement was known as Hasidism, founded by Israel ben Eliezer, the Baal Shem Tov, master of the good name.
14:28He taught God's presence could be found everywhere and that anyone, regardless of scholarship, could commune with God through joyful prayer, heartfelt devotion acts of loving kindness.
14:40Hasidism emphasized emotion, sincerity, the spiritual potential of everyday life, offering an alternative to dry, academic, rabbinic study.
14:51The Baal Shem Tov's teachings spread rapidly.
14:53Poland, Ukraine
14:54Galicia
14:56Especially among the poor and less educated, who felt excluded from Talmudic elites.
15:02The movement centered on charismatic leaders called Rebis or Tzadikim, the righteous ones seen as spiritual intermediaries to God.
15:11Hasidic life was vibrant and communal storytelling, ecstatic singing-dancing.
15:16It wasn't a rejection of Jewish law, but a re-infusion with mystical meaning and fervor, a cultural and spiritual revolution to warm Judaism from within.
15:25This revival met fierce opposition from the rabbinic elite, especially in Lithuania, a stronghold of intense Talmud study.
15:34The opponents were called the Misnagdim, literally, the opponents.
15:38Their leader was Rabbi Elijah of Vilna, the Vilna Gaon.
15:42The Misnagdim viewed Hasidism with deep suspicion, fearing its emotionalism recalled Sabbatean dangers.
15:49They objected to elevating the Rebbe to high spiritual authority, seeing that as a challenge to community rabbis and textual authority.
15:58They also criticized changes in Hasidic prayer rites and the perceived neglect of rigorous, day-long Torah study.
16:05The conflict was bitter and intense.
16:07The Misnagdim issued bans of excommunication, forbidding intermarriage and even business dealings.
16:13Books were burned, communities were torn apart.
16:15The schism was cultural, Lithuanian intellectual, text-based piety versus Hasidic emotional, heart-centered devotion.
16:23The last great schism in our timeline, arguably the one with the most profound impact on contemporary Jewish life, was a product of the modern era.
16:32The Enlightenment in the 18th century and the political emancipation of Jews in 19th century Western Europe created unprecedented challenges and opportunities.
16:42For the first time, Jews were invited to leave the confines of the ghetto and participate fully in civil, economic, and cultural life.
16:52This new reality prompted a fundamental question.
16:55How could one be a modern German, or a modern Frenchman, or an American citizen, and still be a faithful Jew?
17:02The answers to this question created a deep and lasting rupture.
17:06In Germany, a movement sought to harmonize Judaism with modern aesthetics and philosophy.
17:11This became known as Reform Judaism, which introduced radical changes.
17:16Services were shortened.
17:17Prayers were translated from Hebrew into the vernacular.
17:21Musical instruments, like the organ, were introduced into the synagogue.
17:26Reform thinkers reinterpreted Halakha as historical guidelines, not divine law.
17:31They rejected a personal messiah and the hope of returning to Zion.
17:35These dramatic changes were seen as a betrayal of tradition by many.
17:39In response, a counter-movement insisted on the full authority of the written and oral Torah.
17:45They took the name Orthodox Judaism to signal commitment to traditional faith.
17:50Orthodox communities resisted changes to liturgy, prayer language, and strict Halakha observance.
17:57This was a cultural and ideological schism, integration versus tradition.
18:01Soon, a middle ground appeared.
18:04Conservative Judaism sought to conserve tradition while allowing gradual evolution.
18:09It accepted Jewish law as binding but open to contemporary rabbinic interpretation.
18:15The result?
18:16The major denominational streams that shape Jewish life today.
18:20This schism was about balancing ancient faith with modern identity in a world of freedom and choice.
18:25As we have journeyed through three millennia of Jewish history, a clear pattern of causes for these schisms emerges.
18:33Geography has often played a silent but powerful role.
18:36Communities separated by distance develop under different influences.
18:40Local customs harden into distinct traditions.
18:44As with the Samaritans, historical accidents have acted as catalysts.
18:47A king's foolish pride.
18:50A devastating massacre.
18:52The fall of an empire.
18:54These events forced communities to make choices and diverge.
18:58Most profoundly, theology and law sit at the heart of enduring splits.
19:03People passionately debated the nature of God's word.
19:06The authority of leaders.
19:08The correct way to live a life of faith.
19:11These divisions range from the political break of ancient kingdoms to modern denominational streams.
19:16They have fundamentally shaped Jewish identity.
19:20They are not mere historical footnotes.
19:22They are the fault lines of contemporary Jewish life.
19:25The prayers said in synagogues.
19:27The customs observed in homes.
19:29The very sense of what it means to be a Jew.
19:32All influenced by past conflicts.
19:35Schisms created new communities.
19:37New theologies.
19:38New cultural expressions.
19:39Judaism is not a single, unchanging monolith.
19:42It is a dynamic civilization in constant dialogue and debate.
19:47Splitting has been key to adaptation and survival.
19:50This long history reveals a core tension between unity and diversity.
19:54Each split marks a moment when pressure from a new idea, a historical crisis, or a cultural shift became too great for the old framework.
20:02Yet through it all, a sense of shared peoplehood and a common foundational text have often persisted, creating bonds across divides.
20:11The story of the split is also the story of endurance, by creating space for many ways to interpret a shared inheritance.
20:19We must remember one final thing.
20:22A schism is not always a final, irreparable break.
20:26Some divisions lasted millennia.
20:28Others softened over time, worn down by shared experience.
20:32The story of Jewish schisms is a map of human choices in profound change.
20:37A reminder that faith and identity are living, evolving things.
20:42The history of Jewish division is a testament to the enduring, complex, vibrant conversation at the heart of Jewish life.
Recommended
27:59
|
Up next
6:57
3:41
0:45
1:27:52
1:24:20
4:21
7:39
0:59
5:12
12:01
4:34
2:22
Be the first to comment