[ENG] EP.10 Beyond the Bar (2025)

YourTV

Watch [ENG] EP.10 Beyond the Bar (2025) - YourTV on Dailymotion

Transcript

00:04:31Yes, yes.

00:04:33I am.

00:04:36I am.

00:04:37I am.

00:04:39I am.

00:04:41I am.

00:04:44I am.

00:04:49I am.

00:04:53I am.

00:04:56You don't know what to do.

00:04:58I don't know.

00:05:00Yes?

00:05:02I'm sorry.

00:05:06I'm sorry.

00:05:10I'm sorry.

00:05:12I'm sorry.

00:05:14I'm sorry.

00:05:20I don't know.

00:05:23I don't know.

00:05:28I can't remember.

00:05:30I've heard it, dear.

00:05:31I know you've seen it.

00:05:33You've seen it, too.

00:05:35You've seen it in my life?

00:05:36You've seen it.

00:05:37You've seen it in my life, too?

00:05:39You've seen it in my life.

00:05:41You've seen it in my life.

00:05:45I've seen it in my life.

00:05:47If you don't know what the reason is, it's probably the case.

00:05:51But it's the case of a joint.

00:05:53And we have different different kinds of joint.

00:05:55Both of them?

00:05:56The case of a joint joint is from the U.S.

00:06:01And then?

00:06:02So...

00:06:05What's your relationship with?

00:06:08How much?

00:06:10Because you are going to run out for a murder?

00:06:12Why?

00:06:13What's your name?

00:06:16I'm not sure how it works.

00:06:20He's got a lot of money to get out of it.

00:06:23And now we're going to be able to get out of it.

00:06:30We're going to have a great deal.

00:06:33So we've had a lot of fun and fun.

00:06:37We're going to get out of here.

00:06:43...

00:06:48...

00:06:50...

00:06:55...

00:07:00...

00:07:05...

00:07:07...

00:07:12How many people are going?

00:07:13I got two friends.

00:07:15First one, I'm going to ask you to ask myself,

00:07:19and I will ask you guys.

00:07:24I'm so sorry.

00:07:26I'm so sorry.

00:07:28I'm so sorry.

00:07:54I'm so sorry.

00:08:00또 왔란다.

00:08:18최 변호사 왔나 보네요.

00:08:22응.

00:08:41벌써 향기가 다 사라졌네.

00:08:52아이고.

00:09:02아이고.

00:09:04무슨 일 있습니까?

00:09:14무슨 일 많죠?

00:09:16우리 팀 문제가 뭐라고 생각하십니까?

00:09:24뭐 특별히 문제가 있어 보이지는 않습니다만.

00:09:28우리 팀은 너무 드라이에요.

00:09:30너무 드라이해서 사막도 우리 송모티랑 비교하면 오아시스라고 불러야 될 정도입니다.

00:09:34그렇습니까?

00:09:35그렇습니까?

00:09:36우리 팀도 회식도 좀 하고 그래야 되지 않겠습니까?

00:09:40회식은 지난번에 했잖아요.

00:09:42뭐 설마 1년에 한 번만 하시려고 하시는 건 아니죠?

00:09:44그리고 지난번에는 심지어 변호사님 참석도 안 하셨잖아요.

00:09:48알겠습니다.

00:09:50회식 가시죠.

00:09:52그럼 말 나온 김에 오늘 하시죠.

00:09:54뭐 팀원들 시간 괜찮다고 하면 그렇게 합시다.

00:09:56회식도 업무의 연장선상이니 단 한 명도 빠진 사람 없도록 하겠습니다.

00:10:00너무 강요하진 마시고.

00:10:02에이, 자주 하는 회식도 아닌데 한 명이라도 빠지면 김세입니다.

00:10:04특히 그 허민정 변호사는 지난번에 참석 안 했으니까 이번에는 꼭 참석하는 걸로.

00:10:12네, 심지어 변호사님 참석도 안 하셨잖아요.

00:10:14알겠습니다.

00:10:15회식하시죠.

00:10:16네, 그럼 말 나온 김에 오늘 하시죠.

00:10:17뭐 팀원들 시간 괜찮다고 하면 그렇게 합시다.

00:10:19회식도 업무의 연장선상이니 단 한 명도 빠진 사람 없도록 하겠습니다.

00:10:22너무 강요하진 마시고.

00:10:23에이, 자주 하는 회식도 아닌데 한 명이라도 빠지면 김세입니다.

00:10:27특히 그 허민정 변호사는 지난번에 참석 안 했으니까 이번에는 꼭 참석하는 걸로.

00:10:31왜 그렇게 보십니까?

00:10:36아니, 뭐 지난번에도 그렇고 허민정 변호사가 이 팀워크에 대한 책임감이 느슨해지는 것 같다는 생각이 드니까.

00:10:50동기지만 동기로서 동기이기에 가끔하게 한 점 내줄리려고 하는데요.

00:11:00어떻게 생각하세요?

00:11:04장소 정해지면 공지해 주세요.

00:11:06네.

00:11:08바로 진행하겠습니다.

00:11:10진짜 죽었어.

00:11:16손질은 아니고요.

00:11:20바로 들어, 바로 들어, 바로 들어.

00:11:25바로, 바로, 바로, 바로, 바로 바로, 바로, 바로, 바로, 바로.

00:11:28세례, 세례.

00:11:30네.

00:11:32Бог, Бог, Бог, Бог.

00:11:34Good morning, everyone.

00:11:38I rather eat this.

00:11:39What?

00:11:44Eat this is for dinner.

00:11:46I gotta eat this.

00:11:49All this is good.

00:11:51I wanna eat this little egg.

00:11:53All this good!

00:11:54I'm eating this little egg.

00:11:55I'm really good with the egg.

00:11:57I'm eating this egg.

00:11:59And I'm eating this egg.

00:12:01I'm eating avance.

00:12:03Let's go!

00:12:08Then...

00:12:09Can we go ahead?

00:12:10Yes, it would be good, I would be fine.

00:12:12Then let's go for a minute.

00:12:15Yes, it's a good time.

00:12:17Oh, I really appreciate it.

00:12:19Let's go.

00:12:21I can't eat it.

00:12:23It's all good.

00:12:25It's a good time.

00:12:27It's very good.

00:12:29There's a lot of tea, too.

00:12:31Yeah, you're the middle.

00:12:32Yeah, you're the middle.

00:12:33I'll take you.

00:12:34Yeah, you're the middle.

00:12:35Yeah, yeah.

00:12:36Yeah, you're the middle.

00:12:37I'm gonna get you.

00:12:46What's wrong?

00:12:50I'm a little bit nervous.

00:12:53It's fine.

00:12:54It's been a long time since you've been in jail for a long time.

00:13:00It's been a long time since you've been in jail for a long time.

00:13:08I'm just thinking about it.

00:13:12It's been a long time since I've been in jail.

00:13:22And I'm just a long time since I've been in jail.

00:13:32I'm a lawyer.

00:13:36And she's been in jail for a long time.

00:13:41I'm just an average of 2,000 dollar.

00:13:45I'm not sure.

00:13:49I'm just saying I'm not paying for the money.

00:13:53It's only 2,000 dollar on it.

00:13:56But I'm only a 5,000 dollar.

00:14:00I'm only a 10 dollar or 20 dollar dollar.

00:14:03That's not true.

00:14:05That's not true.

00:14:09Then...

00:14:11Then...

00:14:13It's not a lie.

00:14:17It's not a lie.

00:14:19It's a lie.

00:14:21If parents get up, they'll go with a little bit.

00:14:26It's a lie.

00:14:30It's a lie.

00:14:32It's a lie.

00:14:35It's a lie.

00:14:38It's a lie.

00:14:40Maa야, 한번 고심해 볼게요.

00:14:53자, 자.

00:14:542차 갈까, 2차?

00:14:55네, 2차!

00:14:562차는 무슨 2차야.

00:14:58회식은 깔끔하게 저녁 먹으면서 반주하고 끝.

00:15:01정없다, 정없어.

00:15:032차 갈 사람 여기, 여기 붙어라!

00:15:05끝!

00:15:07난 취해서 먼저 간다.

00:15:09잘 먹었습니다.

00:15:11가만 보면 정말 정없어, 정없어.

00:15:15아유, 재미없다.

00:15:17나도 갈래.

00:15:18응?

00:15:19잘 먹었습니다.

00:15:20가보겠습니다.

00:15:21정없다, 정없어.

00:15:22그래, 정없다, 정없어!

00:15:23재미없어!

00:15:24재미없어!

00:15:25저도 가봐야 해서요.

00:15:28그럼 내일 봅시다.

00:15:30아유.

00:15:31아유, 아유.

00:15:32아유, 나도.

00:15:33최 변호사는 잠깐 저 좀 보죠.

00:15:35네?

00:15:36아, 네.

00:15:42그렇다면 2차 갈 사람!

00:15:44자, 이거.

00:15:54이게 뭐예요?

00:15:56쌍둥이들 옷 좀 샀어요.

00:15:58아, 감사합니다.

00:16:00그리고 법인에서 조건이 맞는 소속 변호사들한테 시장금리보다 낮은 전세대출을 지원해줘요.

00:16:06수수평가 통과하고 소속 변호사 되면 지원받을 수 있게 도와드리겠습니다.

00:16:10아, 네.

00:16:12지원받으면 쌍둥이들이 좀 더 편하게 쉴 수 있는 곳으로 이사하면 좋을 것 같아요.

00:16:18신경 써주셔서 감사합니다.

00:16:24아, 가장이라고 수수평가 점수를 후하게 줄 수는 없어요?

00:16:29아, 그럼요.

00:16:30알고 있습니다.

00:16:31그렇지만, 살다가 기댈 어른이 필요하면 다른 데서 헤매지 말고 저 찾아오세요.

00:16:42네.

00:16:44감사합니다.

00:17:06아, 어딜 들어와?

00:17:07아, 목말라서 그래.

00:17:09아, 야.

00:17:11맥주 한 잔 더 할까?

00:17:15맥주 있어?

00:17:16나 완전 취했고, 난 잘 거고, 넌 갈 거고.

00:17:21그럼 물이라도 한 잔 줘.

00:17:23아, 두고.

00:17:24I don't know what you're doing.

00:17:47Well, you're a friend of your sister.

00:17:52Why?

00:17:53Why not?

00:17:54I don't care.

00:17:55I think it's mine.

00:17:57I don't care.

00:17:59I don't care.

00:18:00I don't care.

00:18:02I'm a bitch.

00:18:03I don't care.

00:18:04You're an aunt.

00:18:05And my aunt.

00:18:06She won't 100%.

00:18:08I don't care.

00:18:08It won't go?

00:18:09Not a girl.

00:18:10She won't?

00:18:11I don't care?

00:18:12Well, you don't have any other things?

00:18:15I'm not going to be like this.

00:18:24Then, I'll do it.

00:18:28I'll do it.

00:18:29I'll do it.

00:18:30I'll do it.

00:18:31I'll do it.

00:18:33I'll do it.

00:18:35I'll do it.

00:18:37I'll do it.

00:18:38I'll do it.

00:18:39I'll do it.

00:18:40I'll do it.

00:18:41You look Karina,EO가 지금 사랑하는 사람 누나야.

00:18:43누나를 두고 다른 사람이랑 결혼하라는 게 말이 돼?

00:18:54너.

00:18:57놔줄게 아까워.

00:19:01그래?

00:19:06그럼 우리 취한 사람들이 하는 거 하자.

00:19:08뭐?

00:19:10It's a mistake.

00:19:21It's a mistake.

00:19:24It's a mistake.

00:19:40To be continued...

00:20:10To be continued...

00:20:40To be continued...

00:21:10To be continued...

00:21:40To be continued...

00:22:10To be continued...

00:22:40To be continued...

00:23:10To be continued...

00:23:12To be continued...

00:23:14To be continued...

00:23:16To be continued...

00:23:18To be continued...

00:23:20To be continued...

00:23:22To be continued...

00:23:24To be continued...

00:23:26To be continued...

00:23:28To be continued...

00:23:30To be continued...

00:23:32To be continued...

00:23:34To be continued...

00:23:38To be continued...

00:23:40To be continued...

00:23:42To be continued...

00:23:43To be continued...

00:23:45To be continued...

00:23:47To be continued...

00:23:49To be continued...

00:23:51To be continued...

00:23:53To be continued...

00:23:55To be continued...

00:23:57To be continued...

00:23:59To be continued...

00:24:01To be continued...

00:24:03To be continued...

00:24:05To be continued...

00:24:07To be continued...

00:24:09To be continued...

00:24:11To be continued...

00:24:13To be continued...

00:24:15To be continued...

00:24:17To be continued...

00:24:19To be continued...

00:24:21To be continued...

00:24:23To be continued...

00:24:25To be continued...

00:24:27To be continued...

00:24:28To be continued...

00:24:29To be continued...

00:24:30To be continued...

00:24:31To be continued...

00:24:32To be continued...

00:24:33To be continued...

00:24:34To be continued...

00:24:35To be continued...

00:24:36To be continued...

00:24:37To be continued...

00:24:38To be continued...

00:24:39To be continued...

00:24:40To be continued...

00:24:41To be continued...

00:24:42To be continued...

00:24:43To be continued...

00:24:44To be continued...

00:24:45To be continued...

00:24:46To be continued...

00:24:47To be continued...

00:24:48To be continued...

00:24:49To be continued...

00:24:50To be continued...

00:24:51To be continued...

00:24:52To be continued...

00:24:53To be continued...

00:24:54To be continued...

00:24:55To be continued...

00:24:56To be continued...

00:24:57I'm going to go.

00:25:04I'm going to sleep.

00:25:09I'm going to sleep.

00:25:14SAYS

00:25:24NEVER BELONG TO EMOTION

00:25:28GREE.

00:25:28누가 이기는지 보자.

00:25:31HUBI NO사님 찾으세요?

00:25:33NOW?

00:25:34O...

00:25:35O, KEEEY.

00:25:36O, UNELTO WEBIN...

00:25:37나가셨나봐요?

00:25:38NEY,

00:25:38TABHANG TEFAM 가셨는데

00:25:40NEHEL은 사무실 오신다고 하셨어요.

00:25:42OK.

00:25:42Yes?

00:25:44Yes, please.

00:25:46Yes.

00:25:47I'll send you a memo.

00:25:49I'll send you a memo.

00:25:50I'll send you a memo.

00:25:52Yes?

00:25:53Yes?

00:25:54Yes?

00:25:55Yes.

00:25:58There's a lot of a lot of cash.

00:26:01If you have a tax return,

00:26:04it will be a call option.

00:26:07So that's not true.

00:26:09I mean, the first question means...

00:26:14On top of the company,

00:26:17I think it's a big difference in the last year.

00:26:19I mean, this is not fair.

00:26:22So that's really a big difference in the stock market.

00:26:24Well, I think that's a big difference in the stock market for a lot of people to learn about the market,

00:26:29arlo?

00:26:34It's a long time ago, because it was a year ago, and it was a long time ago, and it was a long time ago.

00:26:48But it was really the president of the U.

00:26:51You didn't MTO statement.

00:26:54You had the extraordinary benefit of the community, so he knew he was a partner with his wife.

00:27:00He told me he was a very good guy.

00:27:02But he was a member of the UNHAI on his wife.

00:27:06And he was a member of the UNHAI.

00:27:12So, he wouldn't be able to find his wife and her wife-in-law.

00:27:14Because he was like, I don't want to take a chance to risk it.

00:27:20That's right.

00:27:21The stock of cash is not enough to get into account.

00:27:27But it's not the assets I don't have to do.

00:27:33Then it is OEM.

00:27:36But if the stock of cash share is not enough for you?

00:27:40The

00:27:44business plan is a

00:27:44business plan, and the

00:27:47company is a

00:27:48business owner.

00:27:50And the

00:27:51business plan is a

00:27:52business owner, and

00:27:54the company has

00:27:55been a

00:27:56business owner.

00:27:57But

00:27:59there is a

00:28:00conflict

00:28:03on the

00:28:04way.

00:28:05That's

00:28:07It's hard to find a way to find a way to find a way to find a way to find a way to find a way to find a way to find a way.

00:28:15It can be done with you some way to find a way to find a way.

00:28:23Okay, so, you're fine.

00:28:25I'm going to go to my mother's dinner and go to school.

00:28:29Yeah.

00:28:31Okay, I'll see you later.

00:28:33Okay, I'll see you later.

00:28:48You're going to be a girl who killed her?

00:28:52How could you do that?

00:28:54How could you do that?

00:28:55How could you do that?

00:29:00It's what's your fault.

00:29:01What happened?

00:29:02What happened to you?

00:29:03What will you do?

00:29:04What the fuck was your fault?

00:29:05What's your fault?

00:29:06What the fuck was your fault?

00:29:09Right, exactly.

00:29:30It didn't work.

00:29:32You're not supposed to.

00:29:44When I get into a room, they go.

00:29:48Yes.

00:29:54What about you?

00:29:57Okay, I'm sorry.

00:30:02I'm sorry.

00:30:04I'm sorry.

00:30:05I'm sorry.

00:30:06I'm sorry.

00:30:07Okay, so he's killed.

00:30:09Oh...

00:30:11I'm sorry.

00:30:14I'm sorry.

00:30:15I'm sorry.

00:30:17What's wrong with you?

00:30:22I'm sorry.

00:30:24I was looking for a woman's interview.

00:30:27I was thinking about it.

00:30:30I was thinking about it.

00:30:32I was thinking about it again.

00:30:35My dad asked me about it?

00:30:37I was thinking about it.

00:30:41I was thinking about it in the past.

00:30:45You know what I'm thinking about it.

00:30:49I don't think so.

00:30:51And my mother, you have no hope for me?

00:30:56I'm like, mom is a dumbass, and she's a bad kid.

00:31:02She's a bad kid.

00:31:06She's a bad kid and she's a bad kid.

00:31:12She's a bad kid.

00:31:14Perhaps I won't be an adult.

00:31:18I can't believe in my royal family.

00:31:23You can't believe it.

00:31:23I can't believe it.

00:31:30I can't believe it.

00:31:33Maybe it is something I can't believe it.

00:31:39What's your name?

00:31:41Why?

00:31:42I don't know.

00:31:44I'm sorry.

00:31:48I don't know why, at all.

00:31:52Or...

00:31:54...

00:31:59...

00:32:04...

00:32:06...

00:32:10I don't know whether you are going to follow a department yet.

00:32:21But there is no court that answers.

00:32:31I don't know how to become a part of this.

00:32:35I'm not going to be a responsibility for your actions, but I'm not going to be a responsibility for your actions.

00:32:43What do you want to do?

00:32:48I'm going to be a court-making trial.

00:32:54Yes?

00:32:55I'm going to be a crime-making trial.

00:32:58I'm not going to be a crime-making trial.

00:33:05I will be a crime-making trial.

00:33:15I can't believe it's a crime-making trial.

00:33:20But I can't believe it's a crime-making trial.

00:33:25If you have a crime-making trial, I could be in the seat of the room.

00:33:29I'll be going to be a crime-making trial.

00:33:34I'm going to be a crime-making trial.

00:33:37I'll beєta to mow that won't take a long time.

00:33:41I can't believe it.

00:33:42I'm not going to be a crime-making trial.

00:33:44I can't believe it.

00:33:46I can't believe it.

00:33:49I can't believe it.

00:33:51I can't believe it.

00:33:52I'm sorry.

00:34:01Are you okay?

00:34:19Yes.

00:34:22Thank you very much.

00:34:28Okay?

00:34:29Is it okay?

00:34:30Is it okay?

00:34:31Yes.

00:34:32I'm already done.

00:34:34I'm sorry.

00:34:35Thank you very much.

00:34:39Is it a victim of the victim?

00:34:42Yes.

00:34:43Is it a victim?

00:34:44Yes.

00:34:45Yes.

00:34:46When I was a victim, I didn't remember it.

00:34:49I was a victim right away.

00:34:52Yes, I was taken for a my entire school.

00:34:55And then someone was a victim.

00:34:58We were murder.

00:35:00Yes.

00:35:01Yes.

00:35:02She is a victim of murder.

00:35:05She is a victim of murder.

00:35:07It's a victim of murder.

00:35:10Your inner responsibility?

00:35:11Yes.

00:35:49괜찮아요?

00:35:58아니, 도로에서 그렇게 막 뛰어들면 어떡해요?

00:36:02뭐 하는 거야?

00:36:03다친 델 없어요?

00:36:05안 부딪혔고 문제 안 삼을 테니까 그냥 가세요.

00:36:08아니 학생, 저게.

00:36:10아, 참.

00:36:18안 돼.

00:36:19안 돼.

00:36:21안 돼.

00:36:24Oh, my God.

00:36:54Oh, my God.

00:37:24너희 씨과 네 엄마랑 얘기할게.

00:37:28오늘 당장 학폭 열어서 피해 학생 보호 조치하고 가해 학생들 전부 퇴학시킬 겁니다.

00:37:36그리고 형사고소와 손해배상 청구도 진행할 거예요.

00:37:44이래서 워킹맘은 안 돼.

00:37:46정보가 이렇게 느려서야.

00:37:48그 피해 학생 이름 김소윤이에요.

00:37:54얼굴은 몰라도 이름은 들어봤죠?

00:37:58김소윤.

00:38:00네, 그 전교 1등 김소윤.

00:38:03그대 따님 내내 1등만 하다가 그의 전학원으로 계속 성적 떨어지죠?

00:38:10자기 딸 경쟁자인 줄도 모르고 누가 누굴 돕는데.

00:38:16지금 그걸 말이라고 해요?

00:38:20잘 들으세요.

00:38:222학년 사방 강요민 어머니.

00:38:24내 딸은 퇴학 못 시켜요.

00:38:26이사장 딸이라고.

00:38:30무슨 소린지 알아듣겠어요?

00:38:44아, 그리고 우리 집 가온이 당하고는 살지 말자예요.

00:38:50우리 학폭위에서 망신당하면 그 분노가 따님한테 돌아가지 않을까?

00:38:58방간보단 방조에 가까웠죠.

00:39:02엄마는 결국 나서지 않았으니까.

00:39:06저도 그 사건을 그냥 그렇게 흘려보냈어요.

00:39:10얼마 지나지 않아 김소윤은 자퇴를 했고 최소윤은 바로 미국으로 유학을 떠났어요.

00:39:18어떻게 이해를 잊고 살았을까요?

00:39:22저는 제가 방관자로서 책임이 있다고 생각합니다.

00:39:26그래서 지금이라도 돕고 싶어요.

00:39:30본 사건은 제가 주도하고 싶습니다.

00:39:34구술 변론도 제가 하고요.

00:39:36형사소송 처음일 텐데 괜찮겠어요?

00:39:40네, 할 수 있습니다.

00:39:44네.

00:39:46감사합니다.

00:39:52대표님은 사람을 끌어당기는 힘이 있으신 것 같아요.

00:39:58제가요?

00:40:00그런가요?

00:40:01아니, 그럼요.

00:40:03사실 사람이 너무 완벽하면 오히려 매력이 좀 벌해질 때가 있는데 대표님은 모든 걸 다 가져주면서도 묘한 여백이 느껴진다고 해야 되나.

00:40:19그런데 그 여백이 오히려 더 큰 매력을 만들어내는 것 같아요.

00:40:25어떤 여백일까?

00:40:29뭔가 채워지지 않는 듯한 그런 여백.

00:40:35그래서 제가 채워드리고 싶은 그런 여백이요.

00:40:45저희들과 함께하는 것 같아요.

00:40:47저희들과 함께하는 것 같아요.

00:40:49저희들과 함께하는 것 같아요

00:40:51저희들과 함께하는 것 같아요.

00:40:53저희들과 함께하는 것 같아요.

00:40:57저희들과 함께하는 것 같아요.

00:40:59저희들과 함께하는 것 같아요.

00:41:03저희들과 함께하는 것 같아요.

00:41:07저희들과 함께하는 것 같아요.

00:41:23변호인, 다시 말씀해 주시겠어요?

00:41:26피고인의 무죄를 주장합니다.

00:41:28그게 무슨 소리야?

00:41:30어떻게 무죄야?

00:41:32내 딸이 살해 다녔는데!

00:41:35정석, 정숙하세요.

00:41:39변호인, 살인죄 무죄를 주장하는 것은 이 사건의 전체적인 맥락에서 피고인에게 매우 불리하게 작용될 수 있습니다.

00:41:47그 점 충분히 고려하셨습니까?

00:41:49네, 그 점은 충분히 고려하였습니다.

00:41:52그러나 본 사건에서 피고인의 행위는 법적으로 살인죄에 해당하지 않는다고 판단합니다.

00:41:58살인죄는 주관적 요소와 객관적 요소가 동시에 존재하여 성립합니다.

00:42:03다시 말해 죽이고자 하는 의식과 죽이려는 행동이 동시에 일어나야 되는데 본 사건에서는 그러지 않았습니다.

00:42:11간단히 예를 들어 설명해 보겠습니다.

00:42:13A라는 사람이 B를 죽이고 싶다고 생각을 했지만 실제로 아무런 행동을 하지 않았다면 살인죄는 성립하지 않습니다.

00:42:21다음 날 A가 마음을 바꿔 B를 죽이려는 의도가 사라진 상태에서 실수로 무언가를 떨어뜨려 사망에 이르렀다면 이 역시도 살인죄는 성립하지 않습니다.

00:42:33그 이유는 의식과 행위가 동시에 일어나지 않았기 때문입니다.

00:42:39피고인 김영미의 경우도 마찬가지입니다.

00:42:43첫 번째 행위인 둔기로 피해자를 가격했을 당시에는 상해의 고의가 있었으나 이로 인해 피해자는 사망에 이르지 않았습니다.

00:42:51두 번째, 차량 충돌로 인해 피해자가 사망에 이르게 된 사고는 어떠한 고의를 가지고 행한 것이 아니라 예측 불가능한 상황에서 발생한 사고였습니다.

00:43:03따라서 이 사건은 두 가지로 나누어서 판단을 해야 됩니다.

00:43:07첫 번째 행위로는 상위죄를.

00:43:09두 번째는 교통사고 처리 특례법에 따른 치사 혐의로 다루어야 됩니다.

00:43:14알겠습니다.

00:43:16검사 측.

00:43:18공소사실 변경하시겠습니까?

00:43:23재판장님, 검찰은 피고인이 둔기로 피해자를 가격한 행위가 명백히 살인의 고의를 가지고 있다 판단하여 기존의 살인죄를 주의적 공소사실로 유지하겠습니다.

00:43:35다만, 법원이 살인죄 성립 요건을 충족하지 못한다고 판단할 경우를 대비해 예비적 공소사실로 살인미수죄와 상해치사죄를 추가하고

00:43:45나아가 상해죄 및 교통사고 처리 특례법에 따른 치사 혐의도 포함하겠습니다.

00:43:51변호인.

00:43:52공소장 변경에 이의 있으십니까?

00:43:54이의 없습니다.

00:43:58이거 이젠.

00:44:02질러났으니 이제 결정적한 방을 찾아야죠.

00:44:06But I'm going to do it all well.

00:44:09I'm going to do it all well.

00:44:12It's not that we can't do it.

00:44:14We can't do it all well.

00:44:16It's like a good result.

00:44:18It's a good result.

00:44:20It's a good result.

00:44:22It's the fundamental reason for the statement.

00:44:24If you're looking at a good result,

00:44:26it's not just a good result.

00:44:28Yeah, I understand.

00:44:31I have a long time.

00:44:33Let's go.

00:44:38Today...

00:44:39What was it?

00:44:41...

00:44:42...

00:44:43...

00:44:44...

00:44:45...

00:44:46...

00:44:47...

00:44:48...

00:44:49...

00:44:50...

00:44:51...

00:44:52...

00:44:53...

00:44:54...

00:44:55...

00:44:56...

00:44:57...

00:44:58...

00:45:01...

00:45:02...

00:45:03...

00:45:04...

00:45:05...

00:45:06...

00:45:07...

00:45:08...

00:45:09...

00:45:10...

00:45:11...

00:45:12...

00:45:13...

00:45:14...

00:45:15...

00:45:16Thank you very much.

00:45:46She's like, what's wrong with me?

00:45:52And then she's like, what's wrong with me?

00:46:16I don't know what to do with him.

00:46:31This is what I'm saying.

00:46:46Oh, hey.

00:46:50Oh.

00:46:57Hey.

00:46:58We're not going to go where we're going at this house.

00:47:00Why?

00:47:01It's so sweet.

00:47:03Guys, we're getting to go in these meetings.

00:47:05We're getting to come here.

00:47:06We're getting to go in this place.

00:47:07This place is not here.

00:47:11No.

00:47:12Oh, what do you want?

00:47:14I got it.

00:47:18Oh, I'm sorry.

00:47:20Sorry.

00:47:22I'm sorry.

00:47:24I'm sorry.

00:47:26I'm sorry.

00:47:28I'm sorry.

00:47:30What are you doing?

00:47:32What?

00:47:34I'm sorry.

00:47:36What?

00:47:38You're an excuse.

00:47:40You're an excuse.

00:47:42You're going to get away.

00:47:44But I'm sorry.

00:47:46You're not you.

00:47:48You're a fool.

00:47:50You're a fool.

00:47:52You're out for me.

00:47:54I'm not sure.

00:47:56I'm not sure what.

00:47:58I'm tired.

00:48:00You're lazy to take the job,

00:48:02and now it's not just any clothes.

00:48:04There's nothing to do.

00:48:06Oh no.

00:48:07Go get that...

00:48:09Dad I bought you?

00:48:11Oh....

00:48:12I want you to just...

00:48:13You're wrong...

00:48:14I'm fine.

00:48:15I want you to thank you.

00:48:16Don't be kidding me.

00:48:17I want you to go to your costs.

00:48:21You're not...

00:48:22Why are you guys most of all these boys?

00:48:28No.

00:48:29Why are you talking about this?

00:48:30Yes.

00:48:30She's a big one...

00:48:31No.

00:48:32What the hell.

00:48:33I'm not the guy.

00:48:33I don't know what he's doing.

00:48:35I'm sorry.

00:48:38What's your problem?

00:48:40What's your problem?

00:48:42What are you doing?

00:48:43I'm here.

00:48:45I'm here.

00:48:47I'm here.

00:48:49What do you do?

00:48:51I'm here.

00:48:53I'm here.

00:48:57I'm here.

00:48:59No, we're just going to go into the room.

00:49:01I'll go first and take a break.

00:49:03I'll go first and take a break.

00:49:05I'll go first and take a break.

00:49:14Why are you taking care of me?

00:49:19I'm here to help you.

00:49:21Why are you taking care of me?

00:49:23You're taking care of me.

00:49:25You're taking care of me.

00:49:29I'm here to help you.

00:49:36You're taking care of me.

00:49:39You're taking care of me.

00:49:40You're taking care of me.

00:49:41I'm here to help you.

00:49:43You're not asking me.

00:49:45I know.

00:49:47You're asking me for a reason.

00:49:49Because they're no one's been hurting.

00:49:51You're asking me for one reason?

00:49:53You're not hurting me.

00:49:56I don't know what to do, but I don't know what to do.

00:49:59I'm going to tell you what to do.

00:50:03Mom.

00:50:11Why?

00:50:13I don't know what to do.

00:50:15What?

00:50:17I don't know what to do.

00:50:32I'm going to go.

00:50:36I'm going to go.

00:50:41I'm going to go.

00:50:57You're pretty.

00:51:00I don't know if I didn't know what to do.

00:51:03I'm just going to come out here.

00:51:09You know, you've got a lot of work, right?

00:51:14No, it's not.

00:51:16It's been a long time.

00:51:18But I think I've worked a lot.

00:51:23When I first went to M&A, I was really hard to learn about it.

00:51:30I'm sure it's Korean, but French is what it is.

00:51:35Right, right.

00:51:40Right, right.

00:51:41So, I was able to listen to it.

00:51:45And I was able to listen to it and listen to it and listen to it.

00:51:52It's a good way.

00:51:57No, it's not.

00:52:05It's a good way.

00:52:32So, so...

00:52:34You can't take pictures?

00:52:36You can't take pictures?

00:52:38Yes, I was taking pictures of it.

00:52:42It was a lot of work.

00:52:44You're not going to take pictures of me.

00:52:46You're not going to take pictures of me.

00:52:48I'm going to meet you at the hotel.

00:52:52Oh, so?

00:52:54Then I'll talk about it.

00:52:56You don't want to take pictures of me when I was at the hotel.

00:52:58I'm sure it's a good way.

00:52:59I'm sure I went on a ballot spot.

00:53:01Go ahead.

00:53:02Let me know.

00:53:03Why did you decide to take pictures of me?

00:53:04It's a really good way.

00:53:05By the way, I'm sure.

00:53:06Well, I couldn't be not.

00:53:07You don't want to take pictures of me.

00:53:10It's a really good way, huh?

00:53:11Okay, let's go.

00:53:23What are you talking about?

00:53:25There's a lot of people who have been in the past.

00:53:29They're going to be able to take care of themselves.

00:53:31They're going to be able to take care of themselves.

00:53:33They're going to be able to take care of themselves.

00:53:35They're going to take care of themselves.

00:53:40How about you?

00:53:42As far as you can within your story.

00:53:44In terms of saying.

00:53:46You're going to have to turn a little closer to yourself.

00:53:48You're going to take care of yourself, you know?

00:53:50So, we're going to take care of yourself.

00:53:52Just one opportunity we need to take care of yourself.

00:53:55What do you think is enough?

00:53:57My name is quite a little earlier about the hotel.

00:53:59We have to talk to him.

00:54:01What's your name, the manager?

00:54:04Well, you're going to take care of yourself.

00:54:05You know?

00:54:06That's not right.

00:54:07So, he's a friend.

00:54:09The actor is a person who does a lot of work.

00:54:11If he gets the chance of getting the job, he does not hits it.

00:54:15Just like a thick one...

00:54:17What about a woman?

00:54:20What about a woman, her husband, her husband, she's not alone.

00:54:24That's how we talked about for him.

00:54:27And he's like, he's not enough.

00:54:29What...

00:54:30I mean, she's like a woman?

00:54:32I think it's different.

00:54:33The way it's fine is to go.

00:54:36If it gets to the top of it, it's all fine.

00:54:39I don't know.

00:55:09This is the case.

00:55:39What is the claim?

00:55:43What is the claim to him?

00:55:49So, I'm going to be able to get out of it.

00:55:56And I'm going to get out of it.

00:56:02And finally, I'm going to get out of it.

00:56:06And after that, I was going to get out of it.

00:56:13I must admit that the case is the case.

00:56:16The spy is the case.

00:56:19It's the case.

00:56:28You should minimize the case.

00:56:33I can't afford to stop the case.

00:56:36I could minimize the case of the case.

00:56:41When I was in high school, I had a chance to go to the car.

00:56:45The car was a normal way to drive.

00:56:48But the car was suddenly in the middle of the road.

00:56:52The road was on the 4th line,

00:56:55and the road was very dangerous.

00:56:58The road was in the south,

00:57:00but the car was in the middle of the road.

00:57:03It's easy to change.

00:57:06It's not easy to change.

00:57:10I need to see you.

00:57:11I need to find out how to do it.

00:57:13I need to know that I can find out.

00:57:15I need to know that I need to know.

00:57:16I need to know that I need to know.

00:57:21It's a little bit better.

00:57:26The location of the family's house is a part of the area,

00:57:31and this location is located on the side of the street.

00:57:36Tango 현장은 보행자가 건너기 위험한 왕복 6차선 도로임에도 불구하고

00:57:42피해자는 무단횡단을 선택했습니다.

00:57:45뿐만 아니라 피해자는 사망 전 6개월 동안 해당 술집을 34번 방문하면서

00:57:51매번 동일한 방식으로 무단횡단을 반복했습니다.

00:57:562번 결과 둔기로 인한 외상은 생명의 지장을 주지 않은 뇌진탕이었고

00:58:01The accident was the accident accident accident due to the injury.

00:58:07The accident was a accident.

00:58:08Now, my daughter's death is my daughter's responsibility?

00:58:12What does it mean?

00:58:15You are not supposed to be a patient.

00:58:18If you're going to put a mask on, I'm going to take a shower.

00:58:22No!

00:58:23No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no.

00:58:31The case of the crime is a crime and a crime is a crime.

00:58:38The case is a crime, not a crime, but a crime, and a crime is a crime.

00:58:541

00:58:582

00:59:002

00:59:061

00:59:102

00:59:132

00:59:162

00:59:192

00:59:23I'm going to be a person that I'm going to tell you about this.

00:59:28He was a person who was a serious school violence.

00:59:33And he was a person who was a victim of the victim.

00:59:40What is that?

00:59:42I was going to show you a video of the school violence.

00:59:48.

01:00:18I'm going to prove it to be a victim.

01:00:25I'm going to prove it to be a victim.

01:00:28I'm going to prove it to be a victim.

01:00:30What?

01:00:31My daughter is dead.

01:00:33What are you doing?

01:00:35What are you doing?

01:00:37What are you doing?

01:00:39I'm going to prove it to you.

01:00:41You're a murderer.

01:00:43Why?

01:00:46Why are you turning away?

01:00:50Kimi, youpt live now!

01:00:52Don't let nothing!

01:00:55Don't let it down!

01:00:59It's time to show you.

01:01:01Investigation!

01:01:02Stop!

01:01:04재판장님, 영상은 공개하기 전 피고인의 트라우마를 최소화하기 위해 영상상영 중 피고인이 눈 가리개와 소음을 차단하는 헤드폰을 착용해도 될런지요?

01:01:16네.

01:01:18허락합니다.

01:01:22You can listen to music and listen to him.

01:01:26Oh, my God.

01:01:52Oh

01:01:55Oh

01:02:02Oh

01:02:04Oh

01:02:06Oh

01:02:08Oh

01:02:10I'm

01:02:12Oh

01:02:20Oh

01:02:22What do you want to do now?

01:02:25Oh...

01:02:29It's...

01:02:30Now the school of the school of the school of the school of the school of the school of the school, in the past, will show you.

01:02:43No, no, no, no, no, no, no.

01:03:13피고인 김영미는 중학교와 고등학교 1학년 동안 전교 1등을 놓치지 않았던 총명하고 성실한 학생이었습니다.

01:03:29그녀는 친구들과 어울리며 웃고 미래를 꿈꾸던 평범한 소녀였습니다.

01:03:35만약 그 잔인한 학폭이 없었더라면 오늘 이 법정에서 피고인으로 서 있는 것이 아니라 사회에 기여하며 자신의 역량을 펼치고 있었을 사람입니다.

01:03:52어쩌면 제 자리나 재판장님 옆 배석판사 자리에 앉아 있었을지도 모릅니다.

01:03:59재판장님, 피고인의 범죄는 결코 합리화되거나 용서받아서는 안 되며 마땅히 그에 상응하는 처벌을 받아야 됩니다.

01:04:11그러나 형벌로만 이 사건을 마무리하게 된다면 우리는 또 한 명의 삶을 잃게 됩니다.

01:04:19법은 형벌뿐 아니라 교화와 재사회화를 통해 새롭게 기회를 제공하는 역할을 해야 합니다.

01:04:26피고인 김영미의 범죄는 단순히 개인의 비극이 아니라 우리가 외면했던 사회적 책임의 결과입니다.

01:04:35그녀의 갱생을 돕는 일은 단지 한 사람의 인생을 구제하는 것이 아니라 우리가 외면했던 사랑과 책임을 되찾는 길이며 더 나은 사회로 나아가는 발판입니다.

01:04:48저와 같은 방관자들, 즉 피고인의 고등학교 동급생 84명이 작성한 탄원서를 제출하겠습니다.

01:04:54재판장님, 이 자료들과 탄원서를 양형 판단에 신중히 고려해 주시길 간곡히 부탁드립니다.

01:05:08피고인 김영미가 새롭게 삶을 시작할 수 있도록 다시 한 번 기회를 주십시오.

01:05:12피고인 최후 진술해 주세요.

01:05:20피고인 최후 진술해 주세요.

01:05:31잘못했습니다.

01:05:34깊이 오해하고 있습니다.

01:05:38주시는 법, 달게 받겠습니다.

01:05:41I'm sorry.

01:05:51I'm sorry.

01:05:55I'm sorry.

01:06:09The first thing is that the police's opinion is that the police's opinion is

01:06:16not a single person's opinion.

01:06:19Therefore, the police's opinion is not a single person.

01:06:26First, the police's opinion is that the police's opinion is

01:06:33.

01:07:03I'm sorry.

01:07:05I'm sorry.

01:07:07I'm sorry.

01:07:09I'm sorry.

01:07:33I'm sorry.

01:08:01이게 뭐예요?

01:08:03최소연 핸드폰에 있던 학폭 영상이랑 사진.

01:08:07이 휴대폰을 아직 가지고 있었어요?

01:08:10응.

01:08:12결국 돌려주지 않았어.

01:08:16참고에 있더라.

01:08:18양형에 도움 될 거야.

01:08:22지난번에 네가 했던 말.

01:08:25엄마, 그건 지금의 내 나이, 내 경험치, 그리고 내가 알고 있는 모든 걸 가지고 각오로 간다면 더 현명한 선택을 할 수도 있겠지.

01:08:37하지만 그때의 나로서는 그게 최선이었고 바꿀 수 없는 결정이야.

01:08:47왜냐하면 모든 결정의 중심에는 내 딸, 효민이에 대한 사랑이 있었으니까.

01:08:59그 사랑이 변하지 않는 한 과거로 돌아간 들을 같은 결정을 내릴 거야.

01:09:05그래서 후회 안 한다고 말한 거야.

01:09:09근데 네 말 듣고 나니 처음으로 후회가 되네.

01:09:21혼자 알아서 할 수 있는데 왜 나서요?

01:09:41혼자 알아서 할 수 있는데 왜 나서요?

01:09:49뭐 하세요?

01:09:53깜짝이야.

01:09:55혼자 님.

01:09:58아니, 자리하고 있는 줄 알았는데?

01:10:00요 앞에 치킨집에 다들 모여 있어.

01:10:04무슨 일 있어요?

01:10:11안녕.

01:10:14머리가 조금 무거워서요.

01:10:18근데 변호사님은 왜 퇴근 안 하시고?

01:10:21일이 좀 남았어요?

01:10:23아, 나는 머리 지킬 겸 종종 올라와요.

01:10:27좋네요.

01:10:28뭐가요?

01:10:30그냥 다요.

01:10:32여기 뷰도 분위기도.

01:10:34그리고 생각지 못하게 변호사님을 만난 것도.

01:10:39다요.

01:10:45오늘 재판, 제가 본 재판 중에 손이 꼽힐 정도로 훌륭했어요.

01:10:51정말요?

01:10:52인간은 먼저 직관적으로 판단을 내리고 그다음 논리적인 근거를 만든대요.

01:11:03그래서 직관은 신의 선물이고 이성은 그에 충실한 종이라는 얘기가 있죠.

01:11:08이번 변론은 직관적이면서도 판사에게 논리적인 근거를 기술적으로 잘 제시했어요.

01:11:17감성과 이성의 균형을 잘 유지했고요.

01:11:20잘했습니다.

01:11:21변호사님도 잘하셨어요.

01:11:26뭘요?

01:11:30소송으로 상처를 치유하려는 의뢰인을 만나면 상처의 내면을 봐요.

01:11:39선입견을 걷어내고 본질을 봐요.

01:11:43나에게 정의란 내가 지켜야 할 사람들을 지켜내는 거예요.

01:11:48도구마이 같은 난쟁이들처럼 생각하지 말고 넓게 생각해 봐요.

01:11:53변호사님은 훌륭한 조각가예요.

01:11:56어수들의 서툰 부분과 부족한 부분을 조금씩 깎고 다듬어서 스스로 몰랐던 가능성을 끌어내시잖아요.

01:12:05그런 변호사님이 만든 조각상 중 단연 최고의 작품은?

01:12:12이진우?

01:12:16강효민?

01:12:18닝도.

01:12:22자주 좀 웃으세요.

01:12:24웃음 아껴서 뭐 하시게요?

01:12:26네, 그럴게요.

01:12:42감사합니다.

01:12:45칭찬이랑

01:12:59다시마

01:13:00No matter where we are

01:13:06You make me whore

01:13:11In your love I turn sorrow

01:13:15When the world feels cold

01:13:21You held me close in your arms

01:13:25With you I will save no more tears

01:13:30How are you?

01:13:35How are you going to death?

01:13:37How are you?

01:13:38You can do the best of all of your rules

01:13:41You don't care what?

01:13:42You don't care what?

01:13:46You are what?

01:13:47Give you a hand

01:13:48Why are you complaining?

01:13:49You made a lie

01:13:51You made a lie

01:13:52You made a lie

01:13:52You made me feel

01:13:54You made me out of the way

01:13:56So, what about you?

01:13:58This is a lawyer

01:14:00There is a lot of people who are going to find the police.

01:14:02I'm not going to sit down.

01:14:03I'm going to call the police officer.

01:14:05I'll find the police officer.

Category

Transcript

Recommended