- 3 weeks ago
Category
📺
TVTranscript
00:30Gonna miss you, Mum. Gonna miss this place and all. I'd be with Matthew in here if I didn't think he'd immediately divorce me.
00:45Hey. I'll be around for a brew every day, I promise. Nothing's going to change.
00:52Well, it will, love, and that's exactly as it should be.
00:56Oh, I couldn't be happier for your love.
00:59He is a good man. He'll look after you.
01:03I don't need looking after Mum.
01:04I don't need looking after Mum.
01:07I don't need looking after Mum.
01:09I don't need looking after Mum.
01:13He'll look after Mum.
01:15You can find him.
01:19I don't need looking after Mum.
01:20Let's do it.
01:50Cosme, do you want me?
02:20I've been looking so long at these pictures of you
02:41That I almost believe that they're real
02:45I've been living so long with my pictures of you
02:51That I almost believe that the pictures are all I can feel
03:15Come to bed, love
03:21You need to get some sleep
03:23You're joking
03:23There's not a chance in hell I could sleep
03:26What are you doing?
03:38Making a list
03:39Everything the police done wrong
03:41I got wrong
03:42Since the moment I reported them missing
03:44They've got to start taking us seriously
03:48Are you sure this is actually going to get us in?
03:52Look, if I don't do it now, I'll forget
03:54And I don't want to forget
03:55These people need to be held to account
03:58Don't tell me what I can and can't do
04:11I want to know why you failed to find my daughter's body
04:14You've got to stand, Mrs Ming
04:15Yeah, I want you to find her killer
04:17And I also want to know why the press are reporting that it was you who found her, not me
04:21Are you still there?
04:24Mrs Ming?
04:25Oh, for God
04:25Yes, it is
04:26I'll call you back in a minute
04:28Oh, fine
04:29God
04:29They're going to call me back
04:31Aren't you angry about this?
04:36I just...
04:38What?
04:39You just what, Charlie?
04:42I think you're wasting your energy, that's all
04:44Well, what other choice do I have?
04:47What else am I supposed to do?
04:52Hello?
04:53Mrs Ming?
04:54Er, yeah?
04:55If you can be here in half an hour, the DCC can see you
04:57Yes, yeah, we can be there
04:58Okay
04:59Fine, thanks
05:00See you then
05:00Right, we've got a meeting with the Deputy Chief Constable
05:03Will you come with me, please?
05:06Of course I will
05:06Don't worry, I will do all the talking
05:08That's what I'm worried about
05:10On behalf of all of us here at the Cleveland Constabulary
05:16I'd like to offer you both our sincere condolences
05:19No, we don't want your condolences
05:21We want answers
05:23I want to know who killed our daughter
05:32It's been less than 24 hours, Mrs Ming
05:34You've not given us a chance to put things right
05:37How the hell can you put things right?
05:39Now that this is a murder investigation
05:42We've assigned you a liaison officer
05:43Any problems, questions, anything at all?
05:46You're fobbing us off
05:47Quite the reverse, Mr Ming
05:48We're exploring every avenue of inquiry
05:52Er, you should be aware that we're talking to Mr Hogg
05:56Wait, Matthew?
05:58We brought him in for question
05:59No, no, you're barking up the wrong tree
06:02Matthew would never hurt our Julie
06:04This is just another police cock-up
06:06I'll be adding that to my list
06:07You can be sure about that
06:08Will you send in DS Breithwaite?
06:12Yes, sir
06:13I can believe that guy
06:15I can believe it
06:16Mr Ming
06:24Mrs Ming
06:25Mark here will be your family liaison officer
06:29No, no, I want the open ground and not the monkey
06:31I am so sorry about your daughter, Mr and Mrs Ming
06:35This must be very difficult and frightening time for you both
06:38Difficult?
06:40Our daughter's been murderers, this is hell
06:42I didn't mean to suggest that
06:43Well, then think before you open your big mouth
06:45Sorry
06:47Look, we want to know what you're actually doing
06:52Because from here it looks like you're sitting with your thumb up your arse
06:55Where have you been, Daddy?
07:08The police just wanted to talk to me, that's all
07:10But I'd done nothing wrong, so
07:13They've just let me go
07:15Can I still live with you?
07:19Yeah, of course, Mayor
07:22Stay with me in a week
07:25And then you'll stay with your nana and your granddad at the weekends, the same as before
07:29We'll find a nice new place
07:33Okay
07:34Okay
07:36I wish I'd never to stay here with us that night
07:41Why didn't I nag her more?
07:42No, you can't think like that
07:44She was old enough to make her own choices
07:46They told me that you were in the next room
07:53What?
07:57The police
07:57When they spoke to me and they said that your version of events were very different to mine
08:03What do you mean?
08:05According to them
08:06You told them that it was me who asked you to take the bath panel off because I thought there was something behind it
08:12But I didn't
08:15I don't understand
08:17No, I know, it's just bullshit
08:18They're just
08:18They're trying to play you off against me
08:21Bastards
08:22I told them that you would never hurt her
08:25Yeah, I know, I know
08:26I just
08:29Who could have done this to her?
08:32I'm sorry, I have to retire
08:50Jesus, please
08:53Music was everything to Julie
09:06She was to listen to all the new wave bands
09:12And new romantic music
09:14She was a shy girl
09:17But once she was out on that dance floor
09:19All her usual inhibitions just seemed to vanish
09:22I can see her now
09:25Spinning round
09:27Like nothing else
09:29Like nothing else about it
09:32If Julie liked her
09:39You were a friend for life
09:42And that's what she was to me
09:45Not just my daughter but a friend
09:49My best friend
09:51We'd speak here every day on the phone without fail
09:56Often several times a day
09:59Even if we'd literally just seen each other
10:01Sometimes it'd drive me potty
10:06But right now I'd give any...
10:08Sorry
10:12I promise you, dear me
10:24We'll get the bastard that killed her
10:28I promise you that
10:30Hello?
10:53Hello?
11:02Will you come in?
11:04Where?
11:05To meet the FLO.
11:08What's that?
11:09Family Liaison Officer.
11:12Oh, right.
11:14I just feel like we should be holding the feet to the fire, you know?
11:18Have you seen this?
11:19I don't think them people in there have got the intelligence...
11:22They've got an update for us, apparently.
11:26Go with that, my love.
11:30Jesus Christ, Charlie, do you know what?
11:32How can you do that?
11:34Do what?
11:35Just block it all out.
11:38I'm not like you.
11:41You know that.
11:44Charlie, please.
11:45What?
11:46We are either in this together or we're in trouble.
11:48Charlie.
11:49Just leave me alone.
11:53I want you to know I'm keeping a record for everything.
11:55All the balls, ups, the lies, inconsistencies, and I'm putting them into a letter.
11:59An official complaint.
12:02If that were you, I'd be doing exactly the same thing.
12:07I heard you just found out Julie's cash card and watch in the loft.
12:12That's right, yes.
12:14And a diary, too.
12:16A diary?
12:16It's just unbelievable.
12:19What the...
12:19What the hell were the forensics team doing all that time?
12:22Playing sodding bridge?
12:23I am aware things haven't been handled very well on our side.
12:27Oh, that's one way of putting it.
12:30Explain to me how all those trained officers spent five days in that house and not one of them found my daughter's body.
12:35Yeah, I'd be angry, too, Mrs. Me.
12:39And after the experience you've had, I get why you're mistrustful of me.
12:44You can be straight with me.
12:45I want you to be honest with me.
12:46I need to be updated on everything, okay?
12:48Look, I can't promise you that, I'm afraid.
12:53But there'll be no bullshit.
12:55You have my word on that.
13:01They said you had some news.
13:04Name the rest.
13:06What?
13:08What?
13:08Who?
13:09Some lads from the local rugby club became relevant to our inquiry.
13:13We were able to eliminate all but one of them.
13:19We found Julie's keys under the floorboards of the house where he's lodging.
13:26I've seen this fella before.
13:28Oh, we didn't see now, Mrs. Me.
13:38The morning she went missing, I was round here.
13:40And he was sitting here at this table we were showing.
13:43Cool as a cucumber.
13:44Right, okay, if it was him, would he not want to get as far away from him as possible?
13:50Maybe they've got the wrong bloke.
13:51Was he staying here the night she was killed?
13:54No.
13:54He lives on the next street along with another lad.
13:57That Lee Watson.
13:59Not anymore, he doesn't.
14:03Sorry about your Julie, Mrs. Me.
14:07What else can you tell me about this mate of yours?
14:10It's not me mate.
14:12Not anymore.
14:14Why's that then?
14:17Sean.
14:18He went to school with Matthew Hogg, why don't you ask him?
14:30He's in this gang with some others from the rugby club.
14:35They're always causing trouble but he's the worst.
14:39I mean everyone's terrified of him but no one does speak up.
14:42How do you mean?
14:44He's...
14:47He's got tons of violent assault charges.
14:51Short fuse.
14:52Vicious temper.
14:55He's a nasty piece of work.
14:57Do you think he killed our Julie?
14:59I don't know if it was him.
15:01I don't know if it was him.
15:04I don't know if it was him.
15:08They don't even be thinking about him.
15:16It's him, Anne.
15:17We're confident we've got the right man.
15:18The blanket Julie was wrapped in.
15:22Yeah?
15:25They found someone else's DNA in it.
15:27It's been analysed and we're hopeful of a match.
15:30And if there's not one?
15:32It would make things significantly harder for the prosecution.
15:37Is there enough to get him without a DNA match?
15:40It's hard to say.
15:42But to be frank with you Ed, the defence will use anything they can to pull apart the evidence.
15:46Listen, I don't want to intrude, but have you thought about getting any help?
15:56What do you mean?
15:58If you like, I can put you in touch with a psychologist for both you and your husband.
16:02No, no, I don't...
16:03Therapy can really help, Anne.
16:06You've been through a terrible trauma, you both have.
16:12I can't get rid of the smell.
16:13I can't get rid of the smell.
16:16It's in my nostrils.
16:19Every time I fall asleep, I see the bathroom.
16:21I see the body under the bath.
16:25Every time.
16:30Yeah.
16:34It'll take a while.
16:43He thinks that therapy can help us, Charlie.
16:47I don't think I can do it, love.
16:49Like, how?
16:53I don't know.
16:57I can't...
16:59I don't know.
17:00I don't know.
17:07I don't know.
17:09It's a big mess.
17:11It's a big mess.
17:12I don't know.
17:42Morning, Graham.
17:44Morning, Mrs. May.
17:45There you go.
17:58The police complaints authority have responded.
18:01Listen to this.
18:02It is unbelievable.
18:03The deputy chief constable has said that valuable lessons have been learned.
18:08And that although he does not consider that the officers concerned were guilty of neglect,
18:11he is disappointed with their performance.
18:13But he does not think that formal disciplinary charges should be brought.
18:17I mean, it's a whitewash, Charlie.
18:18It's all a bloody whitewash.
18:22It's not forever.
18:25No, no, no.
18:25John, please sit down.
18:26You're taking all of our energy just to stay sane.
18:29I have nothing left to give.
18:32You haven't thought this through.
18:33Please let me just say what I need to say.
18:39If it was me, if I was the one who found her, I couldn't have managed.
18:47I'm barely managing now.
18:49It's always the same.
18:54You resenting me for the way I deal with things.
18:59Me blaming you for resenting me.
19:02It's like we're stuck in...
19:06What's the word?
19:09We're caught between heaven and hell.
19:11Packaging.
19:12I don't know how we get through this.
19:19But us being apart might be our best chance.
19:25Please.
19:25Please.
19:52Please.
19:53Please.
19:54Please.
19:55I don't know.
20:25I don't know.
20:55Thank you for coming in, Anne.
21:13Of course. What's going on?
21:15We've heard back from the lab about the biological samples on the blanket.
21:20The DNA is a match.
21:22Does that mean what I think it means?
21:24It means we've got it, Anne.
21:25Are you seriously sure?
21:27I'm 100%.
21:28No, I'll go further than that.
21:31I'm 110% sure.
21:34Trust me, I'm a god.
21:55I don't know.
21:56I don't know.
22:20All rise.
22:46Detective Gravely, how did the defendant first come to your attention?
22:50There were a number of men, at least six, who were all friends from the local rugby club.
22:56They came into our inquiry as TIE suspects.
22:59TIE.
23:01Trace, interview, eliminate.
23:03We were able to eliminate all of the persons of interest except for the defendant, whose alibi at that time had fallen through.
23:12We then searched the house on Clarence Avenue, where he was lodging at the time.
23:17Why was the location of his lodging so important?
23:21Clarence Avenue is just two streets away from Julie's, which meant he had both means and proximity.
23:30Did you find anything during this search?
23:33Yes.
23:34We found Julie's missing keys, which were hidden under the floorboards behind a brick.
23:38Thank you, DC Gravely.
23:45Can you tell me what you found on the blanket which Mrs. Hogg's body was wrapped in?
23:50Well, first there were the yellow and black acrylic fibres.
23:53Nine in total.
23:55And what's the significance of these fibres?
23:58They matched the fibres found on the rugby jersey, worn by the defendant on the night of the murder.
24:02Was anything else of significance found on the blanket?
24:07Yes.
24:08Several human hairs and a small amount of semen.
24:11How can you be sure that these belonged to the defendant?
24:14Samples were taken from 21 men known to Mrs. Hogg.
24:19DNA profiling has ruled out 20 of these.
24:22The only sample that matched the DNA on the blanket was the defendant's.
24:25This is a key ring, taken from a set of keys, found by the police under the floorboards of the defendant's lodgings.
24:37Were you able to obtain any prints from this?
24:40Yes.
24:40We found two prints.
24:42One from the right thumb and one from the right forefinger, both of which clearly matched the defendant's.
24:48Thank you, Miss Mudd.
24:49Now, you say that you found two of my client's fingerprints on the key ring.
25:00That's correct, yes.
25:02But those weren't the only fingerprints you found on the key ring, were they?
25:07No, there were several other fingerprints on it.
25:10None of which matched my client's, did they?
25:14Well, it's hard to be certain.
25:16Because of the overlapping, it's been impossible to...
25:19A simple yes or no will suffice this morning.
25:23No.
25:24Now, as far as the hair and the semen, you say that DNA profiling has ruled out everyone except my client,
25:32which clearly implies that the biological samples in the blankets were his.
25:36But the truth is, you can't actually be 100% certain of that, can you?
25:42Not 100%, no.
25:44But the chances...
25:45Furthermore, the yellow and black fibres could have been found from any matching rugby shirt, could they not?
25:53From any of the rugby club gang or, well, anyone else who happened to be wearing that jersey on the night in question?
26:00Yes, but there's...
26:01Thank you, Miss Mudd.
26:02No further questions?
26:03My lord, with your permission, the prosecution would like to warn the members of the jury about the graphic nature of the images they are about to see.
26:18Dr. Zunter, what was the most likely cause of death in your professional opinion?
26:23Some form of asphyxia.
26:24Strangulation or suffocation is my best estimation.
26:29Is it possible it could have been an accident?
26:31Based on the other injuries on the rest of the body, I would say almost certainly not.
26:36These injuries sustained?
26:38Could they have been caused by sexual intercourse?
26:41Absolutely not.
26:42How can you be so sure?
26:43They were the result of extreme, undeliberate violence, in my view.
26:48Most probably an act of mutilation after death.
26:53Thank you, Dr. Zunter.
26:55No further questions, my lord.
26:58Defence, your witness.
26:59Now, in your evidence, regarding the cause of death, you're saying you're not certain how Julie died, correct?
27:11I've already outlined the most likely explanations.
27:14The subtle signs of these hypotheses have been obscured by putrefactive children.
27:17Do we or do we not know the cause of death?
27:21Not for certain.
27:22It would be fair to say, would it not, that because of the failures of the police, your job as pathologist was rendered impossible.
27:33I wouldn't put it quite like that, no.
27:35Then tell me, would it have been possible to establish a cause of death had the police found Mrs. Hawke's body when they spent five days searching her home?
27:46It would have been much more likely.
27:50Thank you, Dr. Zunter.
27:52And what was it about the smell that caused you to worry?
28:14Well, having worked in the hospital for 20 years, I think I knew deep down what it was.
28:20But I was just praying, please, God, please don't let it be Julie.
28:27And as you leaned across the bath, you say that your knee pushed against the bath panel.
28:33Yes.
28:34I appreciate this isn't easy, Mrs. Nink.
28:40But as you put your hand behind the bath panel, was it your left hand or your right hand?
28:47Um, I don't know, sorry.
28:50Um, with my right, my right, I think.
28:54Are you certain about that?
28:55What does it matter?
28:59I found my daughter's body under the bath.
29:00What are you asking me?
29:03I know this isn't easy for you, Mrs. Nink.
29:04I can't tell you how important it is for the court to hear.
29:09Can you tell us what you found when you pulled back the bath panel?
29:14Even though she was wrapped in a blanket, I knew that it was her, by Julie.
29:27The smell was unspeakable.
29:31It was in my lungs, it was everywhere.
29:36It still is.
29:37I'm so sorry, Mrs. Nink.
29:40It must have been a terrible thing to have to go through.
29:45Yes, it was.
29:46And the fact that it should never have happened must be especially galling.
29:51No, sorry, I don't...
29:52Well, if the police had done their job, then you should never have had to go through it, correct?
29:57I will never forgive them.
30:03And nobody will blame you for that, Mrs. Nink.
30:05It does make you wonder what else they've got wrong in this case.
30:13You kept asking for more and more detail.
30:18I know, I love.
30:22You know, I was watching him today, and I imagined it.
30:27I had a gun.
30:30And I kept thinking if I just pulled it out now while no one was looking and aimed it right at his head.
30:35And then, bang, he'd be gone.
30:38Simple as that.
30:41Would it be worth it?
30:44A life sentence, I mean.
30:46Honestly, I wouldn't care.
30:50I would.
30:55The worst part's over now, love.
30:57Maybe once he's behind bars, maybe we could start fresh, you and me.
31:12I'd like that.
31:13Mr. Fowler, how did you know Julie Hogg?
31:30Well, neighbours.
31:31Been friends for years.
31:34It was more than that, though, wasn't it?
31:35How long had you been in a sexual relationship with Julie Hogg?
31:44There's such a...
31:45Mr. Fowler?
31:49A few years.
31:50On and off.
31:52Now, Mrs. Hogg was a rather promiscuous young woman, wasn't she?
31:57I don't know.
31:57Yeah, I suppose so.
32:01In your statement to the police, you said loads of lads have been with her while she's been married.
32:10The unmatched prints on Mrs. Hogg's keyring, are they yours, Mr. Fowler?
32:15No.
32:15You're certain of that?
32:16100%.
32:17I'll never touch them keys.
32:18Well, I suppose, given what you've just told us about Mrs. Hogg's sexual appetite, they could belong to...
32:25Well, any man in a 50-mile radius.
32:27My lord, that isn't a question.
32:29Mr. Fowler, you should know better than that.
32:33My lord.
32:36Were you with Mrs. Hogg on the night she went missing, 15th of November?
32:40No.
32:41Well, we weren't together no more.
32:43Can you tell us why it ended, your affair?
32:48May I remind you, Mr. Fowler, that you were under oath?
32:54We had sex a few months ago.
32:57I don't mean just me and Julie.
33:00To be clear, when you say we, you are referring to my client, the accused, is that correct?
33:08Yep.
33:08And for the avoidance of doubt, you and my client both had sex with Mrs. Hogg a few weeks before she went missing in her house.
33:18That's right, isn't it?
33:19Yep.
33:21No further questions.
33:22How dare they speak about her like that when she's not even here to defend herself?
33:38Why is it even necessary?
33:39Muckraking through her.
33:41Personal stuff like...
33:42We don't even know it's true.
33:43They're just dragging her name to the mod.
33:45It's...
33:45It's cruel.
33:48They're always trying to make out that she was asking for it or something.
33:51Well, they didn't know it like we did.
33:54So let them say what they want to say.
34:07Did you know?
34:12Some of it...
34:14But I didn't believe it.
34:15How much?
34:21I heard she hung out with the lads from the rugby club sometimes.
34:28It wasn't my business, ma'am.
34:30You should have told me.
34:31No.
34:33No, it wouldn't have been fair.
34:34I don't give a shit about fair.
34:36If I'd known, maybe I could have made her see sense.
34:39Maybe she'd have listened to me.
34:42Maybe she wouldn't.
34:43She was always the one who needed me, see?
34:51At least I thought she did.
34:54Where?
34:58What do you think about your daughter's best friend?
35:00Is your daughter an infomania?
35:01How dare you?
35:02That's a disgusting thing to say.
35:03Leave us alone.
35:04Stop saying things like that.
35:05You just want to hear your side of this is me.
35:07Do you blame yourself?
35:08Anne, did you know what you're doing?
35:09Can you tell me why Julie Hogg's house keys were found under the floorboards of your lodgings?
35:13I was framed.
35:15You were framed?
35:15You can't seriously expect anyone to believe that, can you?
35:19Why not?
35:20You can't trust the police.
35:21Well, your fingerprints were found on her keyring.
35:26Not just mine.
35:27There were other people's on it, too.
35:28All right, let's go back a stage, shall we?
35:33After you were ejected from the rugby club for trying to engage in a sex act with a stripper,
35:38you got in a fight, resulting in a cut to your face.
35:43You were totally inebriated, blind drunk, weren't you?
35:46So what?
35:48All of us were.
35:49Yes, you and Sean Fowler then went back to a friend's house where you watched a pornographic film.
35:57You then went to hospital, where just after 1am, your wound was stitched.
36:02Just after 2am, you went back to Mr. Fowler's, but just 20 minutes later, still drunk and dangerously aroused,
36:09you left with the words,
36:11I'm just popping into Julie's.
36:13That's a lie.
36:14I never went there.
36:15When Mrs. Hogg refused your sexual advances, you became violent towards her, didn't you?
36:20I never... I wasn't there.
36:22You were so full of rage, you killed her.
36:24I told you, I never even went round to Julie's, so I...
36:27Your fingerprints were on her keys.
36:29And like I said, I'm being framed.
36:32Your hair was on the blanket she was wrapped in your semen, too.
36:35In a drunken sexual frenzy, you murdered Julie Hogg with extreme and deliberate violence.
36:42Didn't you?
36:43I didn't do it. I wouldn't.
36:44Oh, you're falling to pieces.
36:46Because you really did murder this poor young woman, didn't you?
36:49No.
36:50Look at you. You're shaking.
36:51No, I'm not.
36:52You're shaking.
36:53No, I'm not. I didn't kill her.
36:55Okay, I...
36:56I didn't.
36:57I just...
36:58It's half past four.
37:02Um...
37:02I'm going to adjourn until tomorrow morning.
37:05No.
37:05No, no, I wouldn't.
37:06Uh, ladies and gentlemen, if you could...
37:08The person was about to crack.
37:09...collect your things.
37:11No.
37:11He rushed to go for his teeth, sir.
37:12I would remind you not to discuss the case with anyone outside of your 12.
37:19I'll see you back here at 10.30 in the morning.
37:24He was on the ropes.
37:26Why the hell did the judge adjourn us?
37:28He's let him off the hook.
37:29Look, it is frustrating, but it happens.
37:31Look, half an hour long I might have done for him, but in my experience, judges are nothing if not punctual.
37:37Look, hang in there. It's nearly over.
37:42Have you seen the papers?
37:46I have, yes.
37:48How dare they talk about her like that?
37:50Like she is the one on trial.
37:53And yet they just refer to the monster who murdered her as a plain old father of two.
37:57It's a bloody disgrace.
37:58Some of those details might have come as quite a shock to you. I'm sorry.
38:02Did you know?
38:05I did, yes. I was trying to protect you on.
38:09You didn't know her, Mark.
38:11They didn't know her.
38:13I did.
38:15She may have been careless with her affections, but she was my little girl who loved to dance and dress up.
38:20That's who she was.
38:25I should have been honest with you. I'm sorry.
38:28At 7.30 on the morning of the 16th of November, Mrs. Ming arrived at her daughter's house with her grandson, Kevin.
38:43If you say so.
38:46According to evidence already heard, you didn't get back to your lodgings until after that time, did you?
38:52And given the unlikelihood of you wandering the streets of Billingham unnoticed, it is in fact the case that you were still in the property when Mrs. Ming arrived, isn't it?
39:00Oh, my God.
39:03I told you.
39:05I was never there.
39:07Mrs. Ming might consider herself fortunate she didn't have a spare key.
39:11If she did, she might have been murdered as a potential witness.
39:13My Lord needs unsubstantiated allegations.
39:16I'm inclined to agree, Mr. Whitburn. Do move along.
39:19As my Lord pleases.
39:20Mrs. Ming, on the night of the 24th of November, a police alarm was activated in Julie Hogg's house.
39:26You entered the property that night, didn't you?
39:28I told you.
39:30I was never there.
39:31You needed to move Julie's body somewhere safer.
39:34You thought it best to make it look like a burglary in case you were seen, except you didn't get time to move the body, did you?
39:40The police arrived before you could.
39:42I never entered that house.
39:43Not on the night she died, and not since.
39:47I'm telling you, them keys were planted.
39:50Planted?
39:51By who?
39:52Passing the news.
39:55The Guildford Four.
39:57Birmingham Six.
40:00When police are desperate, they do whatever they need to.
40:13You must decide what happened in that house in the early hours of November the 16th, 1989.
40:24The Crown must prove that Julie died from an unlawful act.
40:30And that the defendant's intention was to kill or cause serious harm.
40:35Well, you need to be certain, beyond all reasonable doubt, about both of these things, if you are to find the defendant guilty.
40:51Your decision must be based solely on the evidence.
40:55Any personal objections you might have regarding Julie's behaviour or character must be put aside.
41:10How can it take them this long to decide?
41:14It's not unusual to go into a second day, apparently.
41:17Oh, I can't, I can't bear it, Charlie.
41:20I was wondering, if you might stay here with me tonight.
41:31I haven't got me toothbrush.
41:34Don't be daft.
41:36Of course.
41:50May you awake.
41:54Can't sleep.
41:56Me neither.
41:59Keep going over everything in my head.
42:02The whole trial.
42:05Sam.
42:08Will you hold me, please?
42:17Just hold me.
42:20Can your foreman please stand?
42:37Well, surely you haven't gone three weeks without appointing a foreman.
42:43I'm happy to do it, my lord.
42:45Having been informed that you cannot reach a unanimous verdict, I will accept a majority verdict.
42:55In this case, one upon which at least ten of you are agreed.
42:59Have you reached such a verdict?
43:00Please answer yes or no.
43:04No, we haven't.
43:05Yes!
43:08Then I have no choice but to discharge you from your duties.
43:12Mr. Whitburn, my lord, will the Crown be pursuing a retrial in this case?
43:16Yes, my lord.
43:17And the Crown will be pursuing a retrial.
43:19Very well.
43:21The date will be set at due course.
43:23This trial is hereby adjourned.
43:26All rise.
43:27I can't go to bed again.
43:33I can't.
43:34No, I just can't, Johnny.
43:39No, again.
43:41Hold up.
43:42Are you trapped?
43:43I can't do it.
43:45Shh.
43:46At least you're doing something else.
43:48I want you to leave.
43:49Oh, yeah.
43:51I can't.
43:52I can't.
43:53I can't.
43:54I can't.
43:54I can't.
43:55I can't.
43:55I can't.
43:55I can't.
43:55I can't.
43:56I can't.
43:56I can't.
43:56I can't.
43:56I can't.
43:56I can't.
43:56I can't.
43:57I can't.
43:57I can't.
Recommended
49:42
|
Up next
38:34
54:35
21:33
47:43
43:17
4:25
27:04
21:40
47:04
43:41
43:56
43:48
43:50
46:14
52:53
53:19
19:52
47:28
43:10
41:31
Be the first to comment