• 1 year ago
Albert Breer breaks down why the Minnesota Vikings could be a Super Bowl contender if rookie QB J.J. McCarthy develops into a top-10 quarterback, noting their roster upgrades, especially on the offensive line. He pivots to a broader discussion on sack statistics, relaying Sean Payton’s belief that sacks are primarily a quarterback stat tied to decision-making, processing speed, and pocket presence. Breer warns that Drake Maye’s high sack numbers in joint practices are concerning, even factoring in the Patriots’ poor offensive line.

Image courtesy of USA TODAY NETWORK

Category

🥇
Sports
Transcript
00:00How good is Minnesota?
00:02How much of that should be taken into the equation?
00:04And then we'll get into what you learned from these dual practices.
00:09Minnesota's loaded.
00:11A lot of where Minnesota's going is going to come down to the quarterback.
00:14I think that goes without saying.
00:16And what they wind up getting out of J.J. McCarthy.
00:19But that roster and where they're at
00:23and what they've been able to build for Flores now on defense,
00:27because we already know how good their offense is,
00:30and then the primary problem with their offense last year
00:32was their offensive line,
00:33and they signed Will Fries and Ryan Kelly from the Colts
00:35and draft Donovan Jackson in the first round
00:37and are getting Christian Darius off back.
00:38They got rid of Garrett Bradbury, which was addition by subtraction.
00:41But they wanted to get bigger and stronger
00:43because they got pushed around by the Rams in the playoffs last year,
00:46and they got bigger and stronger at center.
00:48They got bigger and stronger at guard.
00:51I would, if J.J. McCarthy can be a top 10 quarterback,
00:57is that fair to ask?
01:02And it's a lot.
01:03No, I mean, it is.
01:04But they're going to set it up in a way.
01:06Like, look at the level of play Kevin O'Connell got out of Sam Darnold last year.
01:10Who's better physically, Sam Darnold or J.J. McCarthy?
01:13Sam Darnold.
01:14Yeah.
01:14I mean, I think that those guys, and I think we forget that sometimes
01:17when you line these guys up.
01:19Like, no, that guy was a third overall pick for a reason.
01:23Everyone liked him.
01:24I mean, everyone liked him.
01:25When the Jets writers all thought he was good and then he was ruined.
01:28I think he's going to be good in Seattle.
01:29I think that what's happened with the Jets is evident with Geno, too, right?
01:34Like, there's obviously been some things that have gone wrong there.
01:38But, yeah, Minnesota is a really good team.
01:40Like, Minnesota, if J.J. can play like a top 10 quarterback,
01:45they could get to the Super Bowl.
01:46I think they're that good.
01:47Okay, so, you know, if you're dominated and you've been, I'm sure,
01:51to, you know, dual practices, a ton of them.
01:54If you get dominated in those practices, how much of that is you're trying things
02:01that you wouldn't normally do in a game?
02:02How much is it that it's practice conditions?
02:04How seriously do you take teams' performances?
02:07I think, like, it's the intent of the practice,
02:09and the coaches will work together on this stuff.
02:12And that's one of the reasons why they like using these more than preseason games
02:19because you can rig the whole thing to see what you need to see.
02:22And so I'm going to put, like, there might be a practice
02:24where I'm trying to build guys up.
02:26And then there's other practices where I'm going to try to test guys
02:28and see how far I can push them.
02:30So, like, there's definitely different intents for, you know, different practices.
02:36And when you're doing two of them the way the Vikings and Patriots did,
02:39there could be two different intents for the two different days for the coaches.
02:43The one thing that concerns me, and I wasn't there, obviously,
02:46but the one thing that concerns me is the continually high sack number.
02:52And it's not just the offensive line.
02:55It's also Drake.
02:56And I just, again, like, I think Vrabel is going to be able to get them
03:01to, like, get their head above water to a 7-8 win level.
03:05I had a really interesting conversation with Sean Payton about this.
03:09About the Patriots?
03:10No, about quarterbacks and sack numbers.
03:12Okay.
03:12And he and I talked for a half hour about it.
03:17He was adamant.
03:18The sack is a quarterback stat.
03:20He's like, everybody wants to blame the line for it.
03:22He's like, the sack is a quarterback stat.
03:23You know who was never sacked?
03:24Peyton Manning.
03:25Drew Brees.
03:26Tom Brady.
03:27And he was explaining to me how that number is how they got to Bo Nix.
03:33Like, he looked at their top two quarterbacks in that year's draft.
03:37And he told me this last summer, right?
03:40And then we had this conversation again this summer.
03:42But last summer, he said to me, the best two quarterbacks in the draft were Jaden Daniels
03:45and Bo Nix.
03:46And that was his assessment before either of them had played a game.
03:51How would he know?
03:52No, I'm just kidding.
03:53But he said one of the key stats, and they had all these different numbers, but he said
03:57one of the key stats is sacks.
04:01He said, I had my analytics guy go back and look at the last 30 years of quarterbacks.
04:07He said to the analytics guy, find me a guy who was sacked a lot in college, who then wasn't
04:13sacked a lot in the NFL.
04:14He said, couldn't find one.
04:15Well, that's bad news for Shador.
04:17Well, remember Russell Wilson, he got sacked all the time in Seattle.
04:23And I think Carroll was like, that's not, and I think it pissed off the offensive line,
04:28right, because he was drawing plays out and not getting rid of the ball.
04:32Well, because it's the quarterback's job, and...
04:35We had a big on-air argument about that, by the way.
04:37And Peyton's argument on this, and he knows more about quarterbacking than almost anybody,
04:42was here's what the sack tests.
04:44The sack tests quarterbacks' movement, quarterbacks' instincts, quarterbacks' ability to process
04:49what's in front of them, ball out.
04:51And it was really interesting listening to it, because it was like, the great quarterbacks
04:56had the instincts and the processing ability to adjust to whoever's in front of them.
05:02And if you're taking a lot of sacks, the reality of that is a lot of people are going to put
05:07it on the line, but I think it's on the quarterback.
05:10And sacks are devastating, because it's penalty, loss of down.
05:16It's worse than a penalty.
05:18It's almost like a personal foul.
05:20But at the same time, there are certain things outside the quarterback's control.
05:25The Patriots' offensive line was far and away the worst in the league last year.
05:29Didn't give any quarterback a fighting chance.
05:31I think Sean Payton's theory is predicated upon at least a mediocre offensive line.
05:36Sean Payton, okay, so here's the other thing.
05:39They had the same offensive line in 23 and 24.
05:43Russell Wilson, Bo Nix.
05:46They cut their sack number in half.
05:49But Denver's offensive line was far better than what the Patriots had.
05:54So let's bring it back.
05:55I'm not putting it on Drake.
05:56No, but let's bring it back around to what I'm saying.
05:58What you just saw with Drake May these last two weeks of joint practices, he's taking a
06:04lot of sacks.
06:04I'm telling you, it's probably the majority is not his fault.
06:08It's an alarming number, though.
06:10And that's my point, is the number is relative to your offensive line.
06:15Okay?
06:16There's no question about that.
06:17Like, how good your offensive line is is going to affect the sack number.
06:22But what Sean said to me really kind of got me thinking about this because it's like you
06:28would never see Tom Brady or Peyton Manning, even at a young age, have an alarmingly high
06:34sack number, right?
06:35Correct.
06:36Even if, like, and we saw Peyton Manning play behind some brutal offensive lines.
06:40We saw Tom Brady, like, when they had injuries.
06:43They lost four left tackles in one year.
06:45Right.
06:46But was the sack number ever really high?
06:48No, it wasn't.
06:49It wasn't.
06:49Now, he'd get the crap knocked out of him sometimes, and it would affect the way he would
06:52play.
06:53And sometimes he'd turn the ball over as a result.
06:55But, I mean, if you look over the course of his career, and we could pull it up if you
06:59want, like, there was never a really high sack number.
07:03I just, like, listening to Sean talk about this, it was like an awakening for me because
07:09I was like, you know what?
07:10It's right.
07:11Like, I never, like, I never thought about, but it's right.
07:14And so he did this.
07:16Then they did this separate study.
07:17The Broncos did.
07:18And they looked back at their 23 season.
07:20This is before they drafted Knicks in 24.
07:22And they looked at, they were not a good offense in 23.
07:28And they looked at their drive efficiency on drives where they didn't take a sack, with
07:32Russell Wilson as the quarterback.
07:35And on drives where they didn't take a sack, they were actually slightly above average as
07:40an offense.
07:41Okay.
07:41And this was an offense that was the bottom of the league.
07:43So if they could just avoid taking a sack, that put them over the average.
07:48So it's just like an interesting thing to look at where, look, I don't think anybody's
07:54sitting here telling, I'm not going to tell you that the Patriots are going to roll out
07:57a great offensive line this year, but Drake has to play within the context of what's in
08:03front of him.
08:04Okay.
08:05And it's not just Drake may in a vacuum playing quarterback the way he would play.
08:09No, you've got to play to the team that's around you.
08:12And so I think that's one thing that's going to be interesting this year is watching him
08:16and seeing, is he taking a lot of sacks?
08:20Because he has to have the awareness to know what's in front of him, have the internal
08:25clock to understand how much time he's going to have given what's in front of him, be able
08:32to process everything in front of him fast enough to get the ball out in time so he's
08:36not taking sacks.
08:37Well, that's also on Josh McDaniels to call right plays to make sure that he has receivers
08:41open in a second and a half.
08:43Yeah.
08:43Because that seems like that's what he's going to be dealing with this year.
08:46Yeah.
08:47So, but I, I just think it's an interesting thing because I like looked at that statistic
08:50and this is right after, I mean, again, like maybe I'm the prisoner of the conversation
08:54I just had with a really smart person, but like I, it, it kind of, when I look at that
09:00number now, I'm kind of looking at that number.
09:03Chris, go ahead, Chris.
09:05Yeah.
09:06What's going on?
09:06Uh, it's funny when you were bringing up for, uh, staff statistics, uh, had me thinking
09:12to pre pre draft Jane Daniels and Drake may or borderline identical, uh, at 6.04, 6.05.
09:21Okay.
09:21And Caleb Williams is the worst, uh, almost 8%.
09:24So that take on Drake may taking too many sacks, um, with a patchwork offensive North Carolina,
09:31no real skill players, uh, Drake, I think ranked three or four.
09:35Uh, so he was right there at the top.
09:37Okay.
09:37Okay.
09:38I bet.
09:38I, I'm just saying it's something I had my radar up for now, like, you know, in general
09:42and Caleb was the one that was, I know it was alarming, um, for the Broncos when they
09:48were looking at it.
09:49Yeah.
09:49And regardless of what the actual numbers are, the fact remains that Sean Payton before the
09:54draft told you that he had Jane and Dan or for, for the season at Jane and Daniels, his
09:59Bo Nix as his top two quarterbacks and the reasoning for it.
10:03So whatever he saw in film, I mean, that was the reason he gave you.
10:07And then we saw what happened is they were the two best quarterbacks last year, even though
10:11Caleb Williams wasn't bad.
10:12And if you look at some of the losses that Chicago had, like they should have beat Washington
10:18when they played them.
10:20Yeah.
10:20That was ridiculous.
10:20That was ridiculous.
10:21I mean, that was that real.
10:23Yeah.
10:23Where there, where the defender for Chicago was, was yelling in the crowd and had his arm
10:30is back to the play.
10:32I don't understand how that happens.
10:34All you got to do, talk about having too much of your phone in your hand.
10:38Like he couldn't, he had the ADD.
10:40He couldn't, he couldn't focus.
10:42It was one play, one play and you're off over here.
10:45And yeah, just like, just, you have to focus for, you know, five seconds.
10:48Like you just, I think I could be in that position.
10:52I could see myself losing it real quick about Caleb Williams.
10:55He had a decent year last year.
10:57The bears fell short of expectations, but his offensive line is much better this year.
11:02Or are the, the expectations for him as high as they should be?
11:07I, like, I think the expectations internally are just for development there.
11:12That division is impossible.
11:14I think I told you guys, he looked pretty terrible the day I was there.
11:17And I, you know, I, I talked to Ben Johnson about it and, you know, his explanation was
11:23we're feeding him through a fire hose right now.
11:26And the way they, they're doing it there is just give him everything right off the bat.
11:33And then over the course of camp, we'll narrow it down.
11:36We'll see what he can handle.
11:37We'll see what he can't handle.
11:39And then we'll, we'll streamline it to the point where we have an offense when we get to
11:42week one, um, which, you know, like, again, like in that market where everything bears
11:48is so scrutinized is gonna bring the, the, the heat on the outside.
11:54Now, Ben made this point to me too.
11:56It's like when we were doing with this, with Jared Goff, it didn't look that way because
12:00he's a veteran quarterback, but he had bad days.
12:03They just weren't magnified this way.
12:05Cause he wasn't, you know, he wasn't Caleb Williams in Chicago, you know?
12:10And so, um, I think the, the, I'm fascinated to see what it looks like around Caleb Williams
12:16and what he looks like in Ben Johnson's offense.
12:18And, you know, again, Ben Johnson came up under Adam Gase and we've talked about how
12:23Adam Gase, the, one of the big problems with Sam Darnold early in his career was Gase was
12:28trying to play him like he was Peyton Manning and Sam Darnold just isn't that guy.
12:32And so now it's a test of Ben Johnson who had a veteran quarterback in Jared Goff in Detroit
12:36was able to do a lot.
12:37Can you be as good if you're forced to scale it back a little bit because you've got a
12:42younger quarterback who isn't quite ready to handle all of it.
12:44And you know, Adam Gase, his whole strategy for that team was I'm going to lock myself
12:48in a room with Sam Darnold and everyone else can take care of everything else.
12:52Like apparently Adam Gase was not exactly present.
12:55He was hyper-focused on Darnold.
12:58Well, I think it was a great example though of like what happens when these guys, when
13:04it's like your offense kind of winds up superseding like what's best for the player and what's
13:10best for the quarterback.
13:11And it's like, no, this is my system.
13:14Well, it's not going to do you any good if the quarterback's not ready to run that system.
13:18And I think Adam would tell you this now that like Sam, Sam came out, like Sam was very raw
13:25coming out of USC.
13:26He was just sort of a big athlete playing quarterback, you know, and had to be developed and it was
13:31going to take time.
13:32And, you know, Gase had like record-breaking success with Peyton Manning.
13:37And then he gets to Chicago with Jay Cutler and Cutler's a very smart quarterback for all
13:41of his problems.
13:42Then goes to Miami and Ryan Tannehill's a few years into the league and then he's got
13:45a rookie in Sam Darnold or a second-year guy in Sam Darnold with the Jets who again is
13:50just this big raw athlete and you're trying to run your, quote-unquote, your offense and
13:56the guy's just not ready to do it.
13:59You know, and so Sam needed to be, that was one of the things when Sam got to Carolina and
14:03then went, especially when Kyle got a hold of him in San Francisco was like, no, no, no.
14:06We're going to slow you way down.
14:08We're going to scale way back and we're just going to kind of try to get you playing fast
14:11again.
14:12And, you know, now you see the result.
14:14He looks like a different player than he did a couple of years ago.
14:16And for the latest from the Sports Hub, download at 98.5thesportshub.com.

Recommended