00:00Transcription by CastingWords
00:30Transcription by CastingWords
01:00Transcription by CastingWords
01:02Transcription by CastingWords
01:12Transcription by CastingWords
01:14Transcription by CastingWords
01:16Transcription by CastingWords
01:48Transcription by CastingWords
02:16Transcription by CastingWords
02:18Transcription by CastingWords
02:20Transcription by CastingWords
02:22Transcription by CastingWords
02:24Transcription by CastingWords
02:26Transcription by CastingWords
02:28Transcription by CastingWords
02:30Transcription by CastingWords
02:32Transcription by CastingWords
02:34Transcription by CastingWords
02:36Transcription by CastingWords
02:38Transcription by CastingWords
02:40Transcription by CastingWords
02:42Transcription by CastingWords
02:44Transcription by CastingWords
02:46They are colored yellow or they are colored pink or they are Marcos loyalists.
02:55And the former President Rodrigo Duterte, by deduction, the former President Rodrigo Duterte,
03:05they are called me.
03:07So they label the Tanan Duterte as Juan Duterte and then we are anti Duterte all the way.
03:14Para sa GMA Integrated News, Marisol Abduraman, nakatuto 24 oras.
03:22Gaano kaposible nga ba ang pagbaliktad ng Korte Suprema sa isang unanimous decision
03:28gaya ng ruling nitong nagdeklarang walang visa ang impeachment complaint
03:32laban kay Vice President Sara Duterte.
03:35Nangyari na raw ito ng makailang beses, sabi po ng ilang legal experts.
03:39Pero may nagpunto rin nangyayari nga.
03:42Pero bibihira, nakatutok si Maki Pulido.
03:45Unanimous ang desisyon ng Korte Suprema na sabihin itong walang visa ang impeachment complaint
03:53laban kay Vice President Sara Duterte.
03:55Kaya sabi ni Sen. Rodante Marculeta sa deliberasyon ng Senado na nag-archive sa reklamo,
04:01imposibleng magbago pa raw ang desisyong ito ng Korte Suprema.
04:04Ito pong ganitong klaseng desisyon, talaga pong wala na pong kaduda-duda
04:11na kahit po mag-file pa tayo ng motion for reconsideration.
04:15We are hoping against hope.
04:17It is as if we are wishing for the moon.
04:20Pero sabi ni dating Supreme Court Senior Associate Justice Antonio Carpio, hindi ito imposible.
04:26May mga kaso ng kahit pa unanimous desisyon,
04:29binabaliktad ng Korte Suprema ang sarili nitong desisyon.
04:32Isa dito ang 2016 Supreme Court ruling na pansamantalang nagpatigil
04:37sa field testing ng Genetically Modified Organism o GNO.
04:41Ayon naman kay Atty. Alan Panolong, presidente ng Integrated Bar of the Philippines,
04:53totoong may binabaliktad na unanimous desisyon pero bihira lang daw ito.
04:57There are instances that the court reverses itself, no?
05:01But it is very, very seldom po, no?
05:07Sa paghinging baliktarin ang desisyon ng Supreme Court,
05:10sinabi ng Kamara sa kanilang motion for reconsideration
05:13na malinaw sa house records na ito'y pinagbutohan sa plenaryo
05:17at matapos itransmit sa Senado,
05:19pinagbutohan namang i-archive ang mga naunang impeachment complaint.
05:23Isa kasi sa pinagbatayan ng Korte Suprema sa kanyang desisyon ay news report
05:27na hindi raw pinagbutohan ng plenaryo ng Kamara
05:30ang articles of impeachment bago itransmit sa Senado.
05:33Sa pahayag ng ABS-CBN, nilinaw nilang wala silang sinabi sa kanilang ulat
05:38na naitransmit sa Senado ang articles of impeachment
05:41ng hindi napagbutohan sa plenaryo ng Kamara.
05:44You don't even have to be a lawyer.
05:45A lawyer student would know that you don't cite news reports to establish a fact.
05:50You go to the official records.
05:52Sinabi rin ang Korte Suprema na nalabag ang due process
05:56na hindi binigyan ng kopya at pagkakataong sumagod si Vice President Duterte.
06:00Bago daw ang requirement na ito, sabi ng Kamara,
06:03dahil walang nakasulat na ganyang proseso sa 1987 Constitution.
06:07Kaya sabi ni Carpio kung ganito ang gusto ng Korte Suprema,
06:11dapat ipatupad sa mga susunod na impeachment complaint,
06:14hindi sa mga natapos na.
06:15The Supreme Court imposed this new requirement retroactively.
06:20How could the House have complied with this new requirement
06:26when it never existed when the House took up the first four complaints?
06:31May mga nagsasabing sa desisyon ng Korte Suprema,
06:34pinahirap nito ang paghahain ng impeachment complaint
06:37na kontra sa nilalayo ng 1987 Constitution.
06:40I think the Supreme Court should reconsider because the rules that they provided now,
06:48the new rules, will practically make it impossible to file an impeachment complaint.
06:53The highest form of integrity is to correct yourself if and when you are wrong.
06:58Ang IBP sinabing bagamat ang hindi pagsangayon sa pasya ng Supreme Court ay hindi masama,
07:03dahil ang dissent ay mahalaga para manatiling buhay ang demokrasya.
07:07Nagbabala ito laban sa pagkwestiyon sa otoridad ng Supreme Court
07:11dahil ito ay nakakahina sa pundasyon ng ating legal system.
07:14We support for the decision because when the Supreme Court decides a case,
07:21especially when it involves issue on constitutionality,
07:26it is not asserting its superiority over an equal branch of government,
07:31but it is simply invoking the constitution.
07:34Para sa GMA Integrated News, Mackie Pulido Nakatuto 24 Horas.
07:39Nilinaw ng Supreme Court na hindi unanimous
07:43ang daging desisyon ng Korte Suprema sa kaso ng League of Cities.
07:48Taliwa siyang sa sinabi ni Sen. Risa Jontiveros
07:51ng halimbawa ang natura-ihalimbawa ang naturang kaso
07:56para patunayang pwede pang i-reverse ang isang kaso
08:00kahit pa unanimous ang desisyon ng unbank.
08:04Sa gitna yan, ang diskusyon ng mga senador nitong Merkules
08:08kaugnay sa impeachment complaint laban kay Vice President Sara Duterte.
08:13Tinanggap naman ni Jontiveros ang pagkakamali,
08:16pero mayroon pa rin unanimous case na ni-reverse ng unbank
08:21gaya ng kaso kaugnay ng pagkwestiyon ng isang grupo
08:25sa mga trials ng mga genetically modified eggplants.
08:30Pwats!
Comments