00:00Transcription by CastingWords
00:30Pero may mga nagsabing, hintayin muna hanggang maging final ang desisyon ng Supreme Court.
00:37Lalo't may nakabimbin pang apila dito. Nakatutok live si Sandra Aguinaldo.
00:42Sandra?
00:45Mel, patuloy nga ang tinatalakay ng Senado ang impeachment case laban kay Vice President Sara Duterte.
00:52Matapos nga yung desisyon ng Korte Suprema na nagsasabing ang constitutional,
00:56ang Articles of Impeachment kaugnay nito.
01:00Ang bungad nga po dyan ni Sen. Rodante Marcoleta ay dapat i-dismiss na ang impeachment case.
01:06Inilatag ni Marcoleta ang mga ginawang hakbang ng Kamara sa impeachment ni Duterte na hindi umano naaayon sa kanilang sariling impeachment rules.
01:18Halimbawa ang pagkakaroon ng tatlong naon ng impeachment complaint bago pa man mapirmahan ng sapat na bilang ng kongresista ang ikaapat.
01:26Hindi ito nirefer sa Committee on Justice at hindi rin umano isinama sa Order of Business.
01:32Ang impeachment complaint po ay parang sinaing na niluto ng House of Representatives.
01:39Hilaw po eh.
01:40Kayo po ang nagsimula ng mali.
01:41Hindi naman po sinasabi ng Korte Suprema na kailanman ay huwag kayong mag-impeach, huwag na kayong mag-pile.
01:47Ayusin nyo lang po eh.
01:48Yun lamang po ang gustong mangyari dito.
01:51Ayusin nyo.
01:52You want to impeach the Vice President, do it in the right way.
01:55Ani Marcoleta nagsalita na ang Korte Suprema na walang jurisdiction ang Senado kaya dapat nang i-dismiss ang impeachment complaint laban sa Vice President.
02:06Unanimous din daw ang desisyon kaya tingin niya mahirap nang magbago ang desisyon ng Supreme Court.
02:12The Supreme Court has already spoken.
02:15The last arbiter of law.
02:17It says the complaint is unconstitutional.
02:21It's void of in issue.
02:23It's violative of due process.
02:26The Senate never acquired jurisdiction over this.
02:29It is immediately executory.
02:31On that note, Mr. President,
02:34I respectfully move that impeachment complaint be dismissed.
02:38Agad itong kinontra ni Minority Floor Leader Tito Soto.
02:42Punto niya,
02:43nag-file ng motion for reconsideration ng House of Representatives sa Supreme Court
02:48at pinagkomento pa nga ang Vice Presidente.
02:52Panong niya,
02:53ano ang kanilang gagawin kung na-dismiss ang reklamo tapos ay magbago ang desisyon ng Supreme Court?
02:59Panukala ni Soto,
03:00We shall wait for the resolution of the MR.
03:04Please, let us allow and give chance to the Supreme Court.
03:08to rectify its decision,
03:10which contains clear and blatant errors
03:13for their sake
03:15and for the sake of future proceedings.
03:20Let us not dismiss forthwith.
03:22And in that light,
03:27considering the motion of the gentleman to motion to dismiss,
03:32I move to table the motion to dismiss.
03:35A motion to table is a higher president than a motion to dismiss.
03:39Punto naman ni Sen. Panfilo Lacson,
03:42wala sa rules ng Senado,
03:43ang motion to dismiss na hinihingi ni Marcoleta.
03:47Sinuportahan din ni Nalakson at Sen. Auntiveros,
03:50mga miyembro ng minorya,
03:51ang panukala ni Soto.
03:53Nowhere in our rules can I find a provision
03:57on a motion to dismiss
03:59as submitted by the Honorable Gentleman from Tarlac.
04:04Neither is there a suppletory application of the rules of court
04:09to offer space for such motion to dismiss.
04:14We should exercise extraordinary prudence
04:18in this matter of transcendental importance.
04:21Yung sagot dun sa tanong ng good gentleman mula sa Tarlac
04:24that in fact,
04:26the Supreme Court has reversed a unanimous decision
04:31in a lot of instances before.
04:33Tinalakay naman ni Sen. Alan Peter Cayetano
04:36kung bakit hindi ginawang prospective ng Supreme Court
04:39ang desisyon nito para ipatupad na lang
04:41sa hinaharap at hindi sa kasalukuyang kaso ng bise.
04:46Sinabi kasi ng Supreme Court
04:47na void of initio to.
04:50Sabi ng Supreme Court,
04:51there was never an ask,
04:53ibig sabihin,
04:54void of initio.
04:56So wala tayong i-dismiss.
04:58The question now is,
04:59if it is void of initio,
05:01why did the Supreme Court
05:04not apply the doctrine of operative fact?
05:09Komento naman ni Sen. President Jesus Codero,
05:13baka mas mainam na i-archive na lamang ang reklamo
05:16sa halip na i-dismiss.
05:18It is the position of the chair
05:20subject to the wisdom of the plenary,
05:22Your Honor,
05:23that given the Supreme Court decision
05:25that the Senate never acquired jurisdiction over it,
05:32that the proceedings and the articles of impeachment
05:35were null and void ab initio.
05:37Indeed, there might not even be anything to dismiss
05:42and the procedure would be more properly to archive
05:47similar to what we have done in the past
05:49so that these proceedings will still be made part
05:52of the Senate's records.
05:54Mel, sa ngayon ay nagpapatuloy
06:00yung palitan ng posisyon dito ng mga senador.
06:04At sa pagkakataong ito, as we speak,
06:06ay ang punto ng kanilang diskusyon
06:09na ay nakatuon doon sa panukala
06:11na i-archive muna itong impeachment case
06:15laban kay Vice President Sara Duterte.
06:18Mel?
06:19Maraming salamat sa iyo, Sandra Aguinaldo.
06:21Altyazı M.O.
06:26Altyazı M.K.
Comments