00:00Impeachment Complaint
00:30Inayos na ng Senado ang wording ng musyon para sa pag-archive ng impeachment complaint laban kay Vice President Sara Duterte
00:48nang subukan pa ni Senate Minority Leader Tito Soto na pigilan ang butuhan.
00:53Nag-motion siyang ipagpaliban muna ang desisyon habang may nakabin-bin pang motion for reconsideration sa Supreme Court.
01:02Pero tinanggihan ito ng nakararaming Senador kaya natuloy ang butuhan.
01:06My God have mercy on your decision.
01:09I move to transfer the articles of impeachment to the archives. I so move Mr. President.
01:15Ang resulta, 19-4 pabor sa pag-archive ng impeachment complaint.
01:20Kami lang sa pumabor sa Senate President Jesus Codero, mga Duterte allies sa Senadora Amy Marcos,
01:27Senador Bato de la Rosa, Bongo at Robin Padilla, pati ang miyembro ng minoriya na si Senador Migs Zubiri.
01:34Let history, Mr. President, record that in this moment, we chose the Constitution.
01:40We chose the rule of law by defending the integrity of the Supreme Court
01:44and maintaining the system of checks and balances under our Republican system of government.
01:49To the House of Representatives, I say, do not allow yourselves to be used for the blind hatred and ambition of a few
01:56who did things haphazardly, gravely abused their discretion, and violated due process rights under the Constitution.
02:05The Senate is not your playground.
02:06Kesa, inaatupag ninyong palitan ang pinili ng taong bayan, binoto at minahal.
02:15Bakit din nyo nalang palitan ang tao, kayo naman lang ang pumili?
02:23Ayaw paawat ng iba sa kaka-flex.
02:27Ano kaya kung yung speaker nyo nalang ang paltan nyo?
02:31Naging tagabantay na lamang sila nang humihiyaw na dambuhalang sanggol.
02:39Ginawa ng bonjing na armas ang impeachment.
02:44Bumoto man pabor sa pag-archive ng impeachment complaint, may hamon si Senador Erwin Tulfo sa Bise.
02:50Ang boto kong ito ay hindi para iabswelto si VP Sara Duterte.
02:57Kung tunay po na walang kasalanan si VP Duterte, dapat siya mismo ang manguna sa pagbubukas ng lahat ng dokumento,
03:08paggamit ng budget, at mga hakbangin niya bilang pangalawang pangulo at kalihim ng DepEd.
03:15Walang dahilan para umiwas kung malinis po ang konsensya.
03:23Ang apat naman na hindi po mabor sa mosyon,
03:27sina Senate Minority Leader Tito Soto,
03:29at kasamahan sa minorya na si Senadora Riza Ontiveros,
03:33pati ang mga miyembro ng mayorya na sina Senador Kiko Pangilinan at Bam Aquino.
03:37Anything that will make it easier for a public officer to evade accountability should be opposed.
03:46Madismiss man natin ngayon o ma-archive ang articles of impeachment,
03:52mas mahirap i-dismiss o i-archive ang daing ng mga tao sa pananagutan at katarungan.
04:01Ang boto na no ay hindi nangangahulugan na hindi natin nire-respeto ang pasya o kapangyarihan ng Korte Suprema.
04:14Lalo-lalo na't hindi pa ito pinal.
04:17Hintayin lang ang final decision.
04:21Kaya katakataka kung bakit kailangan magkaroon ng archiving.
04:32Nag-upstay naman si Senador Panfilo Lacson dahil gusto raw niyang hintayin ang final ruling ng Supreme Court.
04:39In-archive ng Senado ang reklamo alinsunod sa ruling ng Korte Suprema
04:43na null and void ang impeachment complaint sa simula pa lamang
04:47dahil labag ito sa one-year bar rule at may mga hindi nasunod ang kamera sa proseso.
04:53Ano nga ba ang ibig sabihin kapag sinabing na-archive ang articles of impeachment
04:57ayon sa ilang Senador para itong itinabi na pwedeng ilabas o buhayin muli.
05:03Pero para sa ilan, misto lang patay na ang impeachment.
05:07I know for a fact, once it is archived, it is dead.
05:11Yes, it's dead but it's not really buried.
05:14But yes, it's dead.
05:16In effect, because it's in the archive,
05:19but sabi nga ni Justice Ascuna pwede na mahugutin pa ulit kung magbago ang Korte Suprema.
05:25Pag in-archive, kahit hindi pa patay, napakahirap ilabas sa archives.
05:31Kailangan pa mag-majority vote.
05:33Pag sinabi ng Korte Suprema, we are reconsidering the decision,
05:38eh di po buhayin ulit. Napakasimple naman nun eh.
05:40Para sa GMA Integrated News, Sandra Aguinaldo nakatutok 24 oras.
05:47Kinwestyon ni House Speaker Martin Romualdez
05:49sa kanya'y pagmamadali ng Senado sa pag-archive ng impeachment case
05:53ni Vice President Sara Duterte.
05:55Lalot, hinihintay pa ang desisyon ng Korte Suprema sa apelan ng Kamara.
05:59Sinagot din niya ang mga batikos na ibinato sa kanya
06:02at sa Kamara ng mga Senador.
06:04Nakatutok si Tina Pangaliban Perez.
06:05Sa ginawang pag-archive ng Senado sa impeachment,
06:12sabi ni House Speaker Martin Romualdez,
06:14inilibing daw ng Senado ang Articles of Impeachment
06:17laban kay Vice President Sara Duterte.
06:20Sabi ni Romualdez,
06:21hindi daw ang paghahain ng impeachment ang minadali,
06:25kundi ang paglilibing nito.
06:27Yan daw ay kahit pa hindi pa pinal ang desisyon ng Korte Suprema
06:31na nagsabing unconstitutional ang Articles of Impeachment.
06:35Sabi ni Romualdez,
06:37aktibo pa ang kaso
06:38at hiningan pa ng Korte ang mga respondent ng kanilang tugon
06:42sa motion for reconsideration na inihain ng Kamara.
06:46Pero pagpuna ni Romualdez,
06:48binaturaw sila ng mga personal na pag-atake at akusasyon
06:52at pangmamaliit sa kanilang constitutional duty
06:55para palabasin paglalaro lang ito sa kapangyarihan.
06:59Hindi lang daw ito unfair,
07:00kundi mapanganib din
07:02dahil pinahihina nito ang tiwala ng publiko
07:04sa checks and balances sa isang demokrasya.
07:08Sabi kasi ng ilang Senador,
07:10pamumuliti ka at pagkontra lang kay Duterte ang impeachment,
07:13puntong pinalagan din ang iba pang kongresista.
07:17The family name is just accidental.
07:22Alam po natin yan
07:23at kailangan po as public officers,
07:25we need to make ourselves accountable.
07:29Kung pinayagan lamang po kami ng Senado
07:32na mailatag yung mga ebidensya sa impeachment trial
07:36at wala po kaming napatunayan,
07:39siguro po pwede po nating masabi
07:41na ito'y pamumuliti ka lamang.
07:43Justice! Justice! Justice for the people!
07:49Ang pag-archive ng Senado sa impeachment complaint,
07:52sinalubong ng mga protesta ngayong araw.
07:55Boom!
07:56Binatikos din ang ilang mamabatas
07:58ang ginawang ito ng Senado.
08:00Bakit sila nagmamadali?
08:03Hindi po ibig sabihin
08:04dahil immediately executory,
08:05final na.
08:07Kasi nga,
08:08meron pang motion for reconsideration.
08:10Nakakahiya ang desisyon ng Senado.
08:12They chose to surrender their independence
08:14and willfully abandon their constitutional mandate.
08:17Today, the Senate decided to become a Duterte Senate.
08:21These Senators will go down
08:23in our Philippine history
08:24as cowards, no?
08:26Mga senaduwag.
08:28Matapos ang aksyon ng Senado sa impeachment,
08:31handa na ba ang Kamara na mag-move on
08:33at hintayin na lang ang February 2026
08:36para maghain ulit ang impeachment complaint
08:39laban sa Bise?
08:39Antayin po muna natin ang resulta ng MR.
08:45Para sa amin,
08:46hindi pa po tapos yung laban.
08:48Para sa GMA Integrated News,
08:50Tina Panganiban Perez,
08:52nakatutok 24 oras.
08:55Kahit na-archive na sa Senado
08:57ang impeachment complaint,
08:59sabi ng kampo ni Vice President Sara Duterte,
09:01masyado pang maaga
09:03para masabing patay na ito.
09:05Kaya handa raw sila
09:06sa anumang kahinat na nito.
09:07Nakatutok si Marisol Abduramas.
09:13With 19 affirmative votes,
09:164 negative votes,
09:181 abstention.
09:20In the matter of the impeachment trial
09:22of Vice President Sara Zimmerman Duterte
09:25to the archives,
09:27the same is hereby approved.
09:30Hindi raw inaasahan ang kampo
09:32ni Vice President Sara Duterte
09:33ang desisyon ng Senado
09:35na i-archive o isang tabi munang
09:37Articles of Impeachment
09:38laban sa Vice.
09:39Pinuri ang mga pahayag
09:40ng mga senador sa sesyon kahapon.
09:42Pero kahit naka-archive na,
09:44sinabi ng tagapagsalita
09:45ng defense team ng Vice
09:46na hindi pa rin daw
09:48masasabing patay na
09:49ang impeachment.
09:50I think it's too early to say
09:51kasi nga may MR pa
09:52and we don't want to preempt
09:54the decision of the Supreme Court
09:56on the motion for reconsideration.
09:59Ano man daw
10:00ang kahinat na ng Articles of Impeachment,
10:02handa raw ang defense team ng Vice.
10:03I'm really not so familiar
10:05doon sa mismong rules ng Senate.
10:07So, pero narinig nga natin kanina yan
10:09na posible namang mabuhay.
10:11Sa atin naman,
10:12we're ready for any eventuality.
10:13I-dinekla na ng Supreme Courts
10:15na unconstitutional
10:16ang inihay impeachment's complaint.
10:18Ngayon,
10:18nakatutok daw ang kampo
10:19ng Vice sa paghahanda
10:21ng komento
10:22na hinihin ang Korte Suprema
10:23para sa motion for reconsideration
10:25na inihain ng Kamara.
10:27Para sa GMA Integrated News,
10:29Marisol Abdurrahman,
10:32nakatutok 24 oras.
10:36May tuturing na raw
10:37na dismissed
10:38ang impeachment complaint sa Vice
10:40nang i-archive ito ng Senado
10:43kung pagbabasihan
10:44ang desisyon ng Korte Suprema
10:46ayon sa isa sa constitutional framers.
10:49Pero ang tingin naman
10:50ng iba pang law expert,
10:52pwede pa iyang buhayin
10:54sa pamagitan ng tamang mosyon na
10:57nakatutok si Mark Salazar.
10:59Thank you once again.
11:03Ngayong in-archive na ng Senado
11:05ang impeachment complaint,
11:06ano ang mangyayari
11:07kung katigan ng Korte Suprema
11:09ang motion for reconsideration
11:11at payagan ng paglilitis
11:13kay Vice President Sara Duterte?
11:15Tinanong namin ang mga eksperto
11:17sa constitutional law.
11:18The Senate can always retrieve
11:21the articles from the archives.
11:24It is without prejudice
11:26to bringing it back
11:28if necessary.
11:30Natutunog siya ng deep sleep siya ngayon
11:32sa Senado hanggang buhayin siya
11:34ng isang tama na mosyon.
11:37Pero may ibang punto
11:38si Attorney Christian Monsod,
11:40isa sa mga framers
11:41ng 1987 Constitution.
11:44Tinukoy niya ang mismong desisyon
11:46ng Korte Suprema
11:47kung saan,
11:48nang i-archive ng camera
11:50ang tatlong naunang impeachment complaint,
11:52itinuring ito ng Korte
11:53na dismissed.
11:54Sabi ng Supreme Court,
11:57pag in-archive,
11:59it amounts to a dismissal.
12:03Well, I don't know what they say.
12:05But if you follow the Supreme Court decision,
12:08the Supreme Court said
12:09that when it was archived,
12:11it amounted to a dismissal
12:14of the charges.
12:16At kung paninindigan naman
12:17ng Korte Suprema
12:18ang desisyon nitong
12:19unconstitutional ng impeachment complaint
12:22laban sa Vice,
12:23bukang refining po
12:24ang susunod na mangyayari
12:25sa House of Representatives.
12:27Whatever is the ruling,
12:28the final ruling of the court,
12:30I would say
12:32we should abide by it
12:33because that is part of the law,
12:35the land,
12:36and that is our system.
12:38Kung ano man na magiging pasya
12:40ng Supreme Court,
12:41may mga kwestiyon sa tila
12:43butas umano sa desisyon.
12:45Una,
12:46paano daw nasabi ng Korte Suprema
12:48na nalabag ang one-year ban
12:50nang iakyat ng Kamara
12:51sa Senado
12:52ang fourth impeachment complaint
12:54matapos nilang i-archive
12:56ang tatlong naunang complaints.
12:57Malinaw kasi na
13:00inunang desisyonan ng House
13:02yung fourth complaint
13:05bago pa nila
13:07dinesisyonan naman
13:09yung tatlo pa
13:10na complaint.
13:14Paano yun maging
13:15bar dun sa
13:16pang-apat na complaint?
13:18Nauna nga
13:18inaksyonan ng House
13:20through a plenary vote
13:23yung
13:24pang-apat na complaint.
13:26So yung logic
13:27medyo
13:28questionable na.
13:31Isa pang tanong,
13:32maituturing bang
13:33initiated
13:34ang tatlong naunang
13:35complaint
13:36kahit hindi ito
13:37na-refer sa isang
13:38House committee?
13:40Sabi ni Retired
13:41Associate Justice
13:42Adolf Ascuna,
13:43binago ng kasalukuyang
13:44Supreme Court
13:45ang naunang
13:46interpretasyon
13:47na initiated
13:48o nasimula
13:49ng isang impeachment
13:50proceeding
13:51kung ito ay
13:51na-refer na
13:52sa isang komite.
13:53The interpretation
13:54we gave in
13:55Francisco
13:56versus
13:57House
13:58is the one
13:59that was
13:59modified
14:01in the present
14:02case
14:03because in the
14:04present case
14:04the Supreme Court
14:06said that
14:06the three
14:08complaints
14:08were initiated
14:09even if they
14:10were not
14:11referred to
14:11the committee
14:12because they
14:13were archived
14:14and later on
14:16with the
14:17lapse of the
14:1719 congress
14:18they were
14:19terminated
14:20and dismissed.
14:21Sa ibang
14:22parte
14:23ng
14:23SC
14:23decision
14:24hinahanapan
14:25din
14:25ng due
14:26process
14:26ang
14:26Kamara
14:27dahil
14:27hindi
14:28raw
14:28pinasagot
14:29muna
14:29si Vice
14:30President
14:30Sarah
14:31bago
14:31inakyat
14:31sa Senado
14:32ang
14:32complaint.
14:34Isa
14:34raw
14:34itong
14:34bagong
14:35kondisyon
14:35ayon
14:36kay
14:36Munsud.
14:37Kung
14:52anuman
14:52daw
14:52ang
14:52desisyon
14:53ng
14:53Korte
14:53mahalagang
14:54natalaka
14:55ito
14:55ng
14:55komprehensibo
14:56at
14:57naipaliwanag
14:58ng gusto
14:58sa
14:58publiko.
15:00Hindi
15:00nagsagawa
15:00ang
15:00Supreme
15:01Court
15:01ng
15:01oral
15:02arguments.
15:02Sana
15:03may
15:03wrong
15:04oral
15:04argument
15:05dito
15:05sa
15:05MR
15:06upang
15:07mapaliwanag
15:08sa
15:08ating
15:08mga
15:09kababayan
15:10kung
15:11ano
15:11talaga
15:12ang
15:13dahilan
15:14na
15:15hindi
15:15pwede
15:16itong
15:17kasalukuyang
15:19articles
15:19at
15:20ito
15:20ay
15:21medyo
15:22pumasok
15:22dun sa
15:23one-year
15:23ban.
15:24Bakit?
15:25Bakit
15:25na ban yan
15:26na hindi
15:27naman
15:27refer
15:27sa
15:28committee?
15:28Bigyan
15:29ng
15:29pagkakataon
15:30ng
15:30House
15:30to
15:32hear
15:32their
15:32side
15:33in an
15:33oral
15:33argument
15:34kung
15:34bakit
15:35hindi
15:35pa
15:36initiated
15:36dito
15:37by
15:38the
15:38time
15:38they
15:39adopted
15:39their
15:40own
15:41complaint
15:41hindi
15:42pa
15:42initiated
15:42itong
15:44tatlo.
15:44Para
15:45sa
15:45GMA
15:46Integrated
15:46News,
15:47Mark
15:48Salazar
15:48nakatutok
15:5024
15:50oras.
15:52Mismong
15:53si Vice
15:53President
15:54Sara
15:54Duterte
15:55naman
15:55na nagsabing
15:55tuloy
15:56ang paghahanda
15:57ng
15:57kanyang
15:57kampo
15:58sakaling
15:58may
15:59mga
15:59impeachment
16:00case
16:00pang
16:00isang
16:01pa
16:01sa
16:01kanya
16:01sa
16:02inaharap.
16:02Pero
16:03ang
16:03disisyon
16:03ng
16:03Senado
16:03sa huling
16:04impeachment
16:05case
16:05na
16:05tinalakay
16:06nito,
16:07kailangan
16:07anyang
16:07irespeto.
16:09Nakatutok
16:09si
16:09Jandy
16:10Esteban
16:11ng
16:11GMA
16:11Regional
16:12TV.
16:17Emil,
16:18kailangang
16:18respetuhin
16:19ang
16:19disisyon
16:20ng
16:20Senado.
16:20Yan
16:21ang
16:21pahayag
16:21ni
16:22Vice
16:22President
16:22Sara
16:23Duterte
16:23matapos
16:24i-archive
16:25ng
16:25Senado
16:26ang
16:26articles
16:26of
16:26impeachment
16:27laban
16:27sa
16:28kanya.
16:28Matapos
16:33dumalo
16:33sa
16:33Misa
16:34ng
16:34Pasasalamat
16:35para
16:35sa
16:35Kadayawan
16:35Festival
16:36Celebration
16:36ng
16:37Davao
16:37City,
16:38humarap
16:38sa
16:38media
16:38si
16:38Vice
16:39President
16:39Sara
16:40Duterte.
16:41Sabi
16:41niya
16:41tungkol
16:41sa
16:42pa
16:42siya
16:42na
16:42Senado
16:42na
16:42i-archive
16:43ang
16:43impeachment
16:44complaint
16:44laban
16:44sa
16:44kanya.
16:45Kinahangla
16:46na to
16:46respetuhin
16:47ang
16:48role
16:48sa
16:49to
16:49ang
16:50Senate
16:50of
16:50the
16:51Philippines
16:51din
16:52sa
16:52to
16:53ang
16:53nasun
16:53o
16:53sa
16:54to
16:54ang
16:54demokrasya.
16:55So kung
16:55mauna
16:56ang
16:56desisyon
16:57sa
16:58majority
16:58sa
16:59members
16:59of
17:00the
17:00Senate
17:01everyone
17:01must
17:02follow
17:02and
17:03respect
17:03that
17:05decision
17:05of
17:05the
17:06Senate.
17:06Pero
17:07magpapatuloyan
17:07niya
17:08ang
17:08kanilang
17:08paghahanda.
17:09Kinahanglan
17:09panghandaman
17:10ang
17:10tanan
17:11na
17:11posibleng
17:12maitabo.
17:12So
17:13possibly
17:13wala
17:14takibalo
17:142026,
17:152027,
17:162028
17:17na
17:18ay
17:18mga
17:18magfile
17:20na
17:20impeachment.
17:22That
17:22will be
17:23another
17:23opportunity
17:25to answer.
17:27Nakipagkita rin
17:28si VP
17:28Duterte
17:29sa kanyang
17:29legal team
17:30at sa
17:30petitioners
17:31na nagsulong
17:31sa dismissal
17:32ng impeachment
17:33sa isang
17:34Thanksgiving
17:34celebration.
17:35Ayon sa
17:36Facebook
17:36post
17:36ni Davao
17:37City
17:37Counselor
17:37Atty.
17:38Luna
17:38Acosta
17:38na isa
17:39sa mga
17:39petitioner,
17:40kailangan
17:41pa nila
17:41maghahain
17:41ng
17:42komento
17:42sa
17:42motion
17:43for
17:43reconsideration
17:44na
17:44inihain
17:44ng
17:45House
17:45of
17:45Representatives.
17:46Anya,
17:47kumpiyansa
17:47sila
17:47sa kanilang
17:48legal
17:48arguments.
17:49Sinagot
17:49rin
17:50ni
17:50Duterte
17:50ang
17:51sinabi
17:51ni
17:51Palace
17:51Officer
17:52Attorney
17:52Claire
17:52Castro
17:53na meron
17:54silang
17:54impormasyon
17:54na pumunta
17:55umano
17:55ang
17:56visa
17:56ng
17:56Kuwait
17:56ng
17:57walang
17:57travel
17:57authority.
17:58Dapat
17:59dilita
17:59mag-propagate
18:02o
18:02misinformation
18:03and
18:04fake news
18:05and
18:06there's
18:07no
18:07truth
18:07at all
18:08na
18:09niya
18:10to
18:10cooperate
18:11without
18:11a
18:12travel
18:12authority.
18:18Emil,
18:19matapos
18:20ang
18:20misa
18:20na
18:20pasasalamat
18:21ay
18:21dinaluhan
18:22naman
18:22ni
18:22Vice
18:22President
18:23Sara
18:23ang
18:24pagtitipon
18:25ng mga
18:25barangay
18:25officials
18:26sa Davao
18:26City
18:27dito
18:27sa Result
18:28Park.
18:28Emil.
18:29Maraming
18:30salamat
18:30John D.
18:31Esteban
18:31ng GMA
18:32Regional TV.
Comments