As Trump, Xi and Putin take centre stage in an increasingly complex geopolitical landscape, is the world witnessing the emergence of a new global power order? #AWANIGlobal examines the shifting alliances, strategic rivalries and diplomatic manoeuvres shaping the future of global politics.
Transcript
00:07This is Awani Global with me, Nailah Huda.
00:09The global geopolitical landscape is undergoing a significant shift
00:13as world leaders navigate intensifying rivalries, competing interests
00:18and an increasingly uncertain international order.
00:21And from the recent ASEAN Summit in Manila to the ongoing APEC Summit in China,
00:26diplomacy has taken centre stage at least in this part of the world
00:29with trade, regional security and strategic partnerships high on the agenda.
00:34But perhaps the most significant development is the high profile trilateral engagement
00:39involving US President Donald Trump, Chinese leader Xi Jinping
00:44and Russian President Vladimir Putin bringing three of the world's most influential leaders
00:49into the same diplomatic equation.
00:51And against the backdrop of the war in Ukraine,
00:54tensions in the Middle East and growing concerns over nuclear security,
00:59global trade with tariffs,
01:00what does this conversion of major powers mean for the future of international relations?
01:06And where does ASEAN stand as the global balance of power continues to shift?
01:11And to unpack these developments, their implications for the region and beyond,
01:16joining me in the studio as always, Dr. Julia Ragnifad, Senior Lecturer
01:19at the Bachelor's Program in Philosophy, Politics and Economics
01:22at the School of Law and Governance, Taylor's University.
01:25Julia, it's always great to have you back on the show.
01:28How are you? Thank you.
01:29Thank you for having me and it's always a pleasure to be here.
01:31Yeah. A lot to unpack. Of course, a busy, busy week for us in this part of the world.
01:37But perhaps we can start off with the ASEAN Summit in Manila.
01:41What do you think were some of the more significant outcomes?
01:44Do you think we managed to deliver on the commitments that we said we were going to deliver?
01:50I'm, you know, of course, looking at Myanmar, the code of conduct south of China Sea.
01:57What do we think?
01:58I don't want to sound pessimistic, but it doesn't seem that much has been achieved.
02:03In the best traditions of diplomacy and hosting of a summit,
02:08the President of the Philippines proclaimed that there are a few achievements indeed
02:18and that's how it should be.
02:21But if we go one by one, these achievements that were declared, they don't seem much.
02:29I think the major achievement, President Marcus Jr. said,
02:36was the Digital Economy Framework Agreement,
02:39which we also discussed last year at the ASEAN Summit here.
02:44And, yeah, that's the agreement that regulates regional digital trade rules,
02:50cross-border data flows overall,
02:52supposed to encourage the digital economy across borders within ASEAN.
02:59Also, there was another agreement with regards to trade and economy,
03:04which is AI-powered MSME growth.
03:08There was a declaration adopted on this, on micro, small and medium enterprises in Southeast Asia
03:15to accelerate how artificial intelligence is used and how it encourages this sort of trade.
03:23But to speak about South China Sea code of conduct, there was some hope,
03:29although I think it was minimal, that it's going to be adopted under the leadership of the Philippines.
03:34And we've heard some optimistic note from the Foreign Minister of the Philippines
03:41that it's up to 80% ready.
03:44I'm not sure how this assessment is done.
03:46I think the devil, as per Pareto law, is in those 20% that obviously the parties disagree on.
03:54And the declaration on the code of conduct was concluded in 2002.
03:59So it's over 20 years that these discussions have been taking place.
04:03And there are a few factors barring the parties from coming to a mutual conclusion.
04:10And one of them is that ASEAN members are not really united.
04:15They need to be more proactive in this area.
04:19It's mostly Malaysia, Vietnam and the Philippines who are pushing for that agenda,
04:27for the most interested party, the claimants for this important body of water.
04:35What would help is if the other members supported them on the pushing for the code of conduct.
04:43But China, as we know, prefers to interact with everyone on a bilateral basis.
04:48And this is how they divide and rule mechanism.
04:52We see it here in action vis-a-vis the code of conduct as well.
04:57So I don't think we should have expected much from it.
05:01And expectedly there is no result on that front.
05:06We've heard the apologies from President Prebovo on the haze that Indonesia had to cope with
05:14and couldn't stop from spreading for about four months.
05:18That was affecting all of us in the region.
05:21There are no exact data, no exact numbers on how many people,
05:26what's the actual death toll from the haze pollution.
05:28But nevertheless, it has taken a significant toll on us and the damage to the health of the population,
05:36the economy, that some people were even shifted to work from home kind of mode in a number of countries.
05:46There is no progress on that too besides this apology,
05:50besides all the trolling that took part before that Indonesia not only sends haze but also oxygen across the region.
05:56The agreement on the trans-boundary haze pollution center that was supposed to be established in order to prevent the
06:08situations from happening
06:10or at least to help curb the effect, that's also reaching nowhere so far.
06:17It requires only six members of ASEAN to ratify the agreement in order to be enforced,
06:23but we only have three of them who actually ratified fully, Malaysia included by the way.
06:30But the others are not there yet and we might be able to explain it also by the vested interest
06:39because Indonesia became the place where regulations are not tight enough.
06:44So some companies prefer to, maybe for some it's with government vested interest, prefer to invest there
06:53because exactly the regulations enforcement is this loose or non-existent.
06:59So at the governmental level when they get together there's also no appetite to push for this trans-boundary haze
07:08pollution center to be fully established so it could monitor.
07:12That's, I would say, I would say it's a choice to leave this gap, this lacuna where some shady affairs
07:20could continue to happen.
07:22Not as many tangible outcomes as we had hoped there would be.
07:26And I guess on that note, similar situation when it comes to the Myanmar question.
07:31But I guess there has been a bit of a shift in ASEAN's approach or at least it hasn't been
07:36exactly unified, right?
07:38Acting I guess more bilaterally among ASEAN member states when it comes to the Myanmar conflict.
07:43And now Myanmar sort of reconsidering or signalling a possible reconsideration of its relationship with ASEAN.
07:52Do you think this, you know, shift in ASEAN's approach, is it working or is it should go back to
08:00alienating Myanmar?
08:03What do you think?
08:04That's interesting. The junta leader of Myanmar basically, currently of Myanmar government, he gave a three-hour speech in parliament
08:14in Naipido condemning the, in particular, three members of ASEAN.
08:20He left it blur, he didn't name those countries.
08:23The three countries of ASEAN who are blocking Myanmar's reintegration.
08:27For now, the summit confirmed that Myanmar remains blocked from the high-level meetings.
08:34It doesn't mean that Myanmar officials are not attending at all, but it's at the level of civil servants.
08:40The leader of Myanmar and the military-appointed foreign minister are not allowed to visit these high-level meetings.
08:50But for the others, like director general for the foreign ministry of Myanmar, they can visit.
08:55And also all the side meetings and other ASEAN meetings in other areas, Myanmar is also allowed.
09:02So we could say that there has been deliberate reintegration indeed of Myanmar.
09:09And a lot of those restrictions, they remain just formal while the ASEAN members try to engage with Myanmar.
09:18And there is also a vested interest, I'm sure, about support of Myanmar's reintegration back to ASEAN and closing, basically
09:27closing the eyes on whatever is happening there, whatever chaos is still predominant there.
09:33And those who would prefer to prevent Myanmar's reintegration.
09:40And I guess those three countries that I mean online refer to, they are indeed supportive or standing on the
09:49position opposing Myanmar reintegration.
09:51But economically, by the way, also we are trading with Myanmar and that's fair not only about Malaysia, but other
09:59members.
09:59I think in particular the ties are strong between Vietnam, Laos, Cambodia and Myanmar.
10:05But for Malaysia, I just checked, it's 2.8 billion ringgit of bilateral trade, which is not small considering what
10:13the conditions are.
10:14And we are exporting quite some things and materials to Myanmar.
10:20So de facto it's actually happening.
10:23While the five point consensus reached nowhere, there has been no progress whatsoever.
10:29But it remains to be seen if there is a desire by any parties to keep fueling up the events
10:38in Myanmar.
10:39And the position to push ASEAN towards taking a particular position vis-à-vis Myanmar.
10:47We want to move from ASEAN to the APEC summit in China.
10:52And of course, what's been the centre of the attention is the trilateral meeting between Trump, Xi and Putin.
10:58An unprecedented meeting and particularly significant.
11:02But what do you think it tells us? What does it signal about the changing dynamics between these three major
11:09powers?
11:09What should we look out for in this part of the world?
11:13Here also, I think it would be prudent to manage expectations and not expect much from this meeting.
11:19The meeting would be, in my mind, highly performative.
11:26And the three are, well, basically they are coming to APEC summit, let's not forget.
11:33So it's grounds where they are all meeting, although all eyes are glued to the meeting of the three.
11:38And I think for Xi Jinping that's particularly important, hosting these two leaders, bringing them together.
11:45When we were talking about the possibility of presidents Trump and Putin coming for ASEAN summit in Malaysia,
11:53there was the same expectation of sort of a pride of bringing these two great leaders together,
12:00two leaders of great countries together to talk and try to mediate or at least be this mediating platform between
12:08them.
12:09Other than that, there are no huge agreements or any agreements or even memorandums of understanding that we should expect
12:19from that.
12:21They are meeting, some of them are coming to define the existing circumstances,
12:27like for example, the ICC orders for the arrest of Vladimir Putin.
12:31It's also there and I think some media are particularly focusing on that.
12:38For Trump, I think there might be an illusion that there is a deal to be struck with the two.
12:47There are a few matters on the agenda like denuclearization or some new sort of agreement on nuclear arms control
12:57regime,
12:58which absolutely crumbled by now and that used to be bilateral between Russia and the United States or USSR.
13:06And the United States also to talk about Iran, maybe partly to talk about Ukraine, although everything that needed to
13:14be said has already been said.
13:17And maybe even see that if Donald Trump could try and drive the wedge between the two, between China and
13:23Russia.
13:24So that's also particularly striking that President Putin arrived there earlier than Trump and met with President Xi in order
13:33to...
13:33There was not much information what transpired at that meeting, but probably in order to coordinate their positions on how
13:41to deal with President Trump when and if he tries to drive a wedge between the two.
13:47But at the same time, the two are meeting him, we could ask the question then why meet him at
13:54all, why to organize this meeting of the tree.
13:57Although they also did not confirm that there are bilateral meetings taking place between Xi and Trump or Trump and
14:03Putin.
14:05But also, well, on the side of the United States, maybe there is not much positive in terms of agreements
14:14or diplomatic settlement of ongoing conflicts that the two would expect.
14:18Because again, everything that needed to be said has already been said, but you can't discount that there could be
14:26certain damage, diplomatic, political, geopolitical damage coming from the United States.
14:31So I guess the decision is we better meet and maintain the semblance of a diplomatic process.
14:38The talks are going where they are going, maybe nowhere, but there is some process.
14:45And as long as it's going, there is no reason to increase hostility in the relationship.
14:50As you said, the details are not really clear.
14:53And just looking online, a glimpse of it, a lot of the observers have had to rely on sort of
15:00coded, you know, handshakes and poses and power plays.
15:05That's, of course, very common amongst these leaders.
15:08But for transparency's sake, the audience should also know that we are recording this on Thursday.
15:13And at this moment, the meeting is still underway and not much is being revealed at this point in time.
15:19But it is set to focus on Ukraine, on Iran, as well as AI.
15:24But if I can just switch gears very quickly here, I think it's also interesting to look at what this,
15:30you know, this meeting, the APEC summit and the ASEAN summit, all of these diplomacy efforts, what kind of strategic
15:39interest might this pose to Trump?
15:41Because I think it might be interesting to draw some parallels with what's happening back home in the US, of
15:47course, on the heels of the recent midterm elections, where Trump hasn't been doing very well, a lot of backlash
15:54towards his campaigns.
15:57What do you think Trump might want to bring home here, might want to signal to the domestic audience back
16:03home?
16:04Because I think if we were to look back last year, the ASEAN summit, Trump very clearly wanted to play
16:10this role of the peacemaker, however well that played out.
16:13But this time around, what do you think are some of the strategic interests that the US might want to
16:17look at?
16:18This time around, it might not be about bringing peace exactly, because again, we had the US invoice Kushner and
16:27Witkoff already having talked to President Putin and having participated in negotiations on Ukraine in Abu Dhabi, which also led
16:38pretty much nowhere.
16:40So Putin might just reiterate the demands, which are now even about bringing NATO back to the borders, to the
16:50presence of 1997, which is more compared to what Russia has been demanding from before.
16:58It means it feels more comfortable on the battlefield and advancing on the battlefield, although it might be, to some
17:07observers, it might be slow.
17:08But that's a personal feeling and this government's feeling, they feel very comfortable there.
17:15So there's no need to change position and there is even a room to make it more demanding, to increase
17:22these demands.
17:23Recently, I think, besides the midterms that we observed in the United States, where it was a votum of mistrust
17:31to Donald Trump, although he said he's not on the ballot.
17:36There are also domestic problems indeed that were not dealt with very well, like that the whole system of air
17:44traffic control was put on hold and the flights could not depart across the country.
17:50And then some service, the internet service providers, the software was not working, including Microsoft.
18:00So all this was attributed, interestingly, not to hybrid hostile attacks by the enemies, but simply to the infrastructure, which
18:09means not enough attention has been paid to it, not enough money has been invested.
18:13But at the same time, how much money was spent on the foreign wars.
18:18In my mind, one win that Trump could try to take home is to push for the arms control, the
18:28new arms control regime with a tree.
18:31And indeed, the problem with the previous situation, with the previous arms control regime was that it used to be
18:36mainly bilateral.
18:37And for the US, it has been for quite some time important to bring China in the fold of it.
18:45But for China, that's not an option, although China already is a holder of much less of nuclear warheads than
18:53Russia and the United States.
18:55Fun fact that Russia for a few years has been occupying the first place in this.
19:00It used to be the United States, and indeed Donald Trump would say that the United States is number one
19:05nuclear power until someone corrected him.
19:08Then it turns to be Russia, but the difference is maybe a few hundred of nuclear warheads.
19:14Not all of them are also active, as in prepared to be quickly deployed.
19:18So the idea was that, yes, we discussed the new global order and what needs to be done, maybe in
19:25terms of spheres of influence as well.
19:27Something that Trump and his new military doctrine was talking about when he just came to power with his new
19:37team.
19:42But also bringing China into this fold and putting Russia to number two place and then China would be number
19:53three.
19:53But China has been actually increasing production of nuclear warheads.
19:58And until China is on par with this, too, no such thing is going to happen.
20:02And there's not much leverage.
20:04We could think that Taiwan could be a leverage.
20:06And indeed, Trump withheld the arms, the weapons package that was already approved by the Congress.
20:14And he just held off on transferring it to Taiwan before his previous meeting with President Xi.
20:21But I don't think he would be able to hold this off much longer, being under the pressure of military
20:28tech complex as well.
20:29So that would be probably the only leverage that he could use here.
20:33I don't think the two would go for it.
20:35My idea was that maybe he saw something or somebody advised him to resort to replicate something like Washington Treaty
20:45of 1922,
20:46where the major powers agreed on the distribution of naval power between them.
20:52But that also didn't work out quite well because Japan was also in the period between the two world wars.
20:59Japan was one of those and it contributed to the desire, to the revanche sentiment in Japan because it was
21:06quite limited.
21:07So why would China put itself in the same position and limit its nuclear arsenal?
21:13You know, it's basically also comes to the three gentlemen and Trump in particular wanted to talk about whose is
21:21bigger.
21:22Arsenal, nuclear arsenal, of course, I'm talking about.
21:25It does boil down to this gentleman's war, as they say.
21:29And just to wrap things up, where do you think, you know, with a lot of attention being drawn to
21:37these three powerful leaders,
21:39the personal relationships that we're so closely observing,
21:44bilateral deals being striked between these major powers,
21:47where do international institutions, multilateral frameworks, diplomacy,
21:52where do these stand when we're seeing global affairs being more and more shaped,
21:58or at least that's what it's being portrayed like in the media,
22:02more and more so centered on these personal relationships and power plays?
22:07Personal relationships matter and these little indicators of who stands where on the photo also.
22:14By the way, we also saw Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim coming to the three leaders
22:19and standing right behind President Xi on the family photo, I think.
22:23So we are indeed paying attention who stood where, how many, who held whose hands or whose elbow.
22:29Who got the most handshakes, who stood next to someone's wife and whatnot.
22:34Indeed, that matters for diplomacy.
22:37But I think the trend that we need to watch, to look out for is regionalization.
22:43The emphasis on regionalism, more on the international global organizations.
22:49So we've seen more activity in the organizations like Shanghai Cooperation Organization
22:56or BRICS with more members applying for it.
23:00And for ASEAN itself, it is probably the moment to rethink certain things and mechanisms,
23:08maybe even, and I expressed it before in different forms, maybe even to rethink strengthening the cooperation,
23:16the coordination on certain matters like on HACE control, which has quite significant effect on all of us,
23:24on the economies, the South China Sea.
23:27And to move from association towards more from alliance, strengthening cooperation,
23:32including in the area of security and defense.
23:37So I think most of it will be happening in the regional level.
23:41We've seen it also in examples of other pacts and agreements like Mecca Pact appearing out there.
23:49So we see that in various regions, the regional actors or regional leaders,
23:55claimants for the position of regional leader are unwilling to put all eggs in one basket anymore.
24:02And they would prefer, especially understanding that the global hegemon is not as how it was put by one of
24:09the foreign ministers,
24:11agreement incapable, incapable of agreement.
24:14That's time to diversify various partners and see where gains could be made.
24:20I think it was demonstrated quite vividly by President Macron's visit to Malaysia and to Cambodia.
24:28The recent one, and overall, him paying, France paying a lot of attention to Southeast Asia,
24:34to Middle East actors also diversifying their agreements like the Mecca Pact that I mentioned.
24:39And there are some others in terms of production of weaponry between some of the Middle Eastern countries.
24:46So these are quite interesting trends that we are observing with the retreat of global organizations
24:52and of course of the global hegemony with more of a multipolar world emerging.
24:59And I think what we've discussed, the three leaders getting together in Shenzhen, in China,
25:06is not about what something put as akin to Yalta conference of 1945 at the end of the Second World
25:17War.
25:18They are not going to split the world into spheres of influence.
25:22But that's a kind of a constatation of the fact that these changes are happening.
25:27And this is just one point, one discussion out of probably many that they are going to have of what
25:35changes are going to happen in the world.
25:37And there is plenty of space for smaller states, for middle powers and small countries to also have their say
25:44and have their leverage.
25:46Because it's their time now.
25:47Yeah, so what's certain is that the state of the global affairs will continue to remain uncertain for the time
25:53being.
25:54But interesting times for us to continue to observe how this might play out.
25:59Thank you so much for sharing your thoughts.
26:01I wish we had more time, as always, to explore more of these questions.
26:05Thank you once again to Julia Rognifar, Senior Lecturer at the School of Law and Governance Dealers University,
26:10for sharing some of your thoughts on ASEAN Summit to the APEC Summit in China.
26:16And of course, most popularly, the trilateral meeting.
26:20What would be some of the outcomes or I guess the more pessimistic outlook here is there might not be
26:27much of it.
26:28But interesting anyway to observe how this might play out over time.
26:33That is all on Awani Global with me this week. We'll catch you next time.

Recommended