• 7 minutes ago
The K&C Masterpiece debated if the Cowboys made the right move taking play-calling duties away from Christian Parker, whether Jared Goff is truly underrated, and more in this edition of NFL Overreaction or Reality.
Transcript
00:00Prescott in the gun, back, strong pass rush, slant to the end zone to Pickens.
00:04Has he got it?
00:05He got it.
00:06Touchdown, George Pickens.
00:08Can't see masterpiece right here on 105 Through the Fan right now.
00:12It's time for NFL Overreaction or Reality, and we will start with this.
00:20Overreaction or Reality, the Cowboys did the right thing with this CP move.
00:32Reality, because you're right, you can't just keep throwing the same thing out and expecting different results.
00:40If you think this is going to, like Stephen has told us many times, we aren't going to do something
00:44unless we think it makes us better.
00:46They think this is going to make them better.
00:49They thought hiring Christian Parker would make them better.
00:51I did too.
00:52I did too.
00:54I did not know he was not prepared.
00:56I also understand that there are some limitations regarding some of the personnel on this team.
01:01That's tough.
01:02And how you adapt to that really does validate whether or not you survive.
01:10Adaptability is the biggest deal, and as a defense, as a coordinator, you've got to be able to adapt to
01:15what you have personnel-wise.
01:17So maybe Pettin, who has had a little more experience, can adapt in that way.
01:23And so I think it was the right thing to do.
01:26I am kind of curious when it comes to the decision of keeping him in the future, because they saw
01:33something in him enough to hire him.
01:36And do they still see some of that in him, and can he fix it?
01:40By the way, should we point out, it feels like so did most of the rest of the league.
01:45It feels like for people in the know in football circles, this hiring was pretty well praised.
01:54Schottenheimer wasn't getting any calls to be a head coach anywhere.
01:58I meant for CP, I'm sorry.
01:59No, no, you're right.
02:00But I'm pointing out, that's, like, the Joneses are traditionally known for hiring people that...
02:06True.
02:07Who's really trying to hire that guy?
02:08Right.
02:10And so this one was one of those where they said, yeah, we'll make sure this one's done.
02:15So yeah, you're right.
02:16A lot of people around the NFL, lots of people giving high praise to this.
02:20So we were fooled, and I guess they were too.
02:23Or maybe he's just not ready yet.
02:27NFL overreaction or reality to you, Mr. Walker?
02:29The Cowboys made the right move with CP.
02:33Reality, guys.
02:34I mean, look, let's just be honest.
02:36He's from Philadelphia.
02:37He came here to sabotage Dallas.
02:39Oh, man.
02:40That's a really good point.
02:42Hold on.
02:42I've seen that video of him and Dak when Dak walked up to him and asked him.
02:47No.
02:48It's very obvious, right?
02:49I remember that video.
02:51It was a behind-the-scenes video, Kevin in the tunnel.
02:53He came here to successfully sabotage us.
02:56And him and Lamar owed him.
02:58I mean, look, I just think that's all it blows us down to.
03:01Look, it's reality.
03:02You have to make a change, and sometimes it doesn't matter who it is.
03:06You just – and look, I think the writing was on the wall with what Jerry said on our program
03:11this week.
03:11I think it also – when Schottenheimer called the defense inexcusable or whatever the word – unacceptable was the word
03:18he used, I believe.
03:19I think a change had to be made.
03:22And, look, Schotty's feeling the pressure.
03:23He's got to do something.
03:24And if it was his call, I think that it was going to be Christian Parker either way.
03:28I want to go back to what he just said there because after the game, Schottenheimer goes, we're going to
03:34go watch all the film and make a decision.
03:37Right.
03:38And I was like, hold on.
03:39Did y'all not watch all the film beforehand?
03:41Or did you see what happened in the game?
03:42Have y'all not been watching all the film this entire time?
03:44And he's like, I've got to try and get this offense prepared.
03:46I can't watch all their film.
03:47That always makes me wonder about adjustments, right?
03:50When a coach says, we've got to go back and watch the film.
03:53And I was like, what were you basing your adjustments in the game on then?
03:56The film that we had watched before.
03:58Okay.
03:59And then we didn't have any adjustments to do because we didn't expect that.
04:03You think they go back and watch the film and be like, oh, wow, that really is – that's really
04:06bad.
04:07Yeah.
04:08Man.
04:08You want to fire this guy.
04:10I actually – sometimes I do.
04:12Most of the time I think that's just a cover.
04:14But every once in a while I think they're like, holy freaking crap, is that what happened?
04:18Like I think of the Kyle Whittingham thing in Michigan where they were like, yeah, we're not going to fire
04:23our offensive coordinator, but we're going to watch the film.
04:25Watch the film and then fire them the next day.
04:27Yeah, because they saw something and they were like, oh, never mind.
04:29Like this is an AI video, right?
04:30There have been six quarterbacks in NFL history with at least 300 passing yards and three touchdowns in 25 games
04:43in their first 11 seasons.
04:46Okay.
04:46Drew Brees, Dan Marino, Patrick Mahomes.
04:51Heard him.
04:51Her cousins.
04:52And Aaron Rodgers.
04:54The sixth one –
04:56Almost all of those are champions.
04:57Exactly.
04:58The sixth one is the focus of this statement.
05:02Overreaction or reality?
05:03That would be Jared Goff, and Jared Goff is underrated.
05:10I feel like nobody ever talks about Jared Goff.
05:12As one of the best quarterbacks in the league?
05:14Like even top 10.
05:15I feel like people are like, eh, I don't know.
05:17Half his 60-yard touchdowns are dump-offs to Jameer Gibbs.
05:21Hey, still counts in the stats.
05:24This is a very interesting thing.
05:26I think underrated is a good conversation based on where you rate him.
05:31I don't consider him a top five quarterback.
05:33I don't either.
05:34But I consider him in the top 10.
05:36I do too.
05:38And I think that I'm not picking him to win me a championship unless I have the team built.
05:46I, you know, coming out – coming into the draft, I was like, dude, I'd do – I would make
05:51sure if I get a chance to take Jared Goff, I would.
05:54I was like, he's going to be gone before you get there because you had the Miles Jack and Jared
05:58Goff situation there, which never even happened.
06:02But I was like, 20 yards downfield, this dude throws dots.
06:06And now you have him on an offense that he really understands.
06:10Ben Johnson talked about this recently.
06:13Whenever Caleb Williams went down, he was like, look, I know how to make an immobile quarterback a good quarterback.
06:19So, is he in the right system?
06:22Yes.
06:23He wasn't – Sean McVay felt that he couldn't do any more with Jared Goff.
06:27Right.
06:27And maybe he broke Jared Goff a little bit, but Ben Johnson rehabilitated him, built the right system around him,
06:34has a good offensive line in front of him.
06:36He does his job very, very well, but I'm not picking him to go be a Josh Allen ever.
06:43But I don't think underappreciated because I think he is rightly appreciated.
06:48NFL overreaction or reality to you, Mr. Walker, Jared Goff is underrated.
06:54Yeah, I agree with a lot of what Corey said.
06:56I think it's an overreaction.
06:59I think he's properly rated by most who have a conversation about him.
07:04He is around that 15 to 10 mark, somewhere around there.
07:08You could probably get a consensus about 12.
07:10Yeah, I was going to say, I feel like 15 is kind of disrespectful.
07:12I was going to say, I think you could probably get a consensus about 12, probably no lower than that.
07:17And it's just that he's exactly what the Lions have needed him to be, which is a game manager to
07:23get the ball to his playmakers, whether that be Jameer Gibbs, Amon Ross, St. Brown, or the tight end position
07:29in Sam Laporta.
07:30But he's not a rushing quarterback, so he doesn't get thought of that often other than, you know, maybe you
07:36could think of it in the Matthew Stafford perspective.
07:39But even he makes throws on the run, and that's just not really Jared Goff's game.
07:43So I would say he's properly rated.
07:45NFL overreaction or reality.
07:47Oh, I'm sorry.
07:48Yeah.
07:48You think Jared Goff's underappreciated?
07:50I do.
07:51Like, I'm just going to use that as an example.
07:54I know you moved it up to 12.
07:56I feel like 15 is disrespectful.
07:58I even think 12 might be low.
08:02No, I think top 10 is right, but I feel like too often he might get thrown into top 10
08:08because people ran out of quarterbacks to think of.
08:11And they didn't actually put him in the top 10.
08:13They're like, I guess I'm out of people.
08:14Not y'all, but I'm just saying, like, in general.
08:16Maybe you're saying the kids, like, khaki Kev, don't respect.
08:19No, no, no, no.
08:19I think he is solidly in.
08:21I think he is a top 10 quarterback.
08:24I do, too.
08:25I just don't think enough people do think that.
08:27But perhaps I'm wrong.
08:29Overreaction or reality, sticking with quarterbacks, the Falcons should bench Michael Penix Jr.
08:35He has been a mess as of late.
08:39His QBR, 21st in the league.
08:42You look at that game against the Chiefs.
08:44It was bad, bad, bad.
08:47You look at that game against the Bengals, not too much better.
08:50And obviously the atrocity from a sports perspective that was Tampa Bay is better off, forgotten by everyone.
08:56Metro City.
08:58Um, for who?
09:01Tua?
09:03Dalton?
09:04Anybody else?
09:05Jack Strand?
09:06You have a chance to win this division.
09:09The whole division has a chance to win this division by losing.
09:13Exactly.
09:15Um, no.
09:17Okay.
09:17I disagree.
09:19Overreaction!
09:20Oh!
09:21Bonus question.
09:23Rick Bonus.
09:24You think Michael Penix can be a quality starting quarterback in the NFL?
09:28Oh, no.
09:30Overreaction.
09:31But I just don't, I'm not going to Tua to try and save this thing.
09:35And, uh, I'm not going to Andy Dalton either.
09:41Andy Dalton might win a couple games.
09:44He can.
09:45That's what he does.
09:46I have invested in Michael Penix to be the quarterback.
09:51I need him to learn on the field.
09:54I can't, I need him, this isn't a Christian Parker situation.
09:58This is a situation where I need him to get better on the field.
10:02And I also, this is if I'm the GM and I invested in him.
10:05I also need to go ahead and reassess, do I have the right people around him to make him that?
10:10And if not, we're going to have to do this thing a different way.
10:14Mr. Walker, we go to you.
10:15Overreaction to reality twofold.
10:17Not with Tua.
10:18The Falcons, or whoever, the Falcons should bench Michael Penix.
10:22Bonus question, you think Michael Penix could be a quality NFL starting quarterback?
10:27Answering your bonus question first, I think he can.
10:31I don't think we can completely write the book on what Michael Penix is going to be.
10:36Look, this is really his first year in the reins as an NFL quarterback.
10:40And despite what he has in his history of health, which by the way, I don't know if y'all
10:44heard,
10:44he has the best knees of anybody on earth, apparently.
10:47It's still one of the greatest quotes ever.
10:49I still think, you know, I still think that we could see a progression from Michael Penix.
10:54And it's not like the Falcons are all around the best football team and they're helping him out in the
10:59highest degree.
11:00Hasn't he gotten worse since last year?
11:02Well, here's the thing.
11:04Another thing, to Corey's point, who's going to play?
11:07I mean, even if Tua's not banged up, he's banged up.
11:09And Andy Dalton, Jack Strand, whatever have you.
11:13You might as well just let Michael Penix go out there and progress.
11:17Or regress all the way.
11:19Or regress and take advantage of that.
11:21At least that'll tell you that Michael Penix is not your quarterback if nothing can be done.
11:27Okay.
11:27All right.
11:27And then you've got to go draft a new one.
11:31Obviously, I understand that philosophy.
11:33All right.
11:33One more for you because I posed this question to Gbag yesterday in our cross.
11:37Overreaction or reality?
11:38The Jags are better than the Bengals.
11:41Now, I realize on October 4th, they beat the Bengals.
11:45We're a month and a half removed from that.
11:47Joe Burrow has just gone into unbelievable mode.
11:50He's completed 79.5% of his passes for 409 yards and four touchdowns in that last game.
11:59He's been on an unbelievable roll.
12:01So, overreaction or reality?
12:03The Jags are better than the Bengals.
12:08I'd really have to dive a lot deeper into some of these things for me to have a true feel
12:14on this.
12:17Just watching the Bengals right now and the way their offense works, it's still more productive, I think, than the
12:24Jaguars.
12:26Oh, no.
12:27Wow, actually.
12:3030.9 points a game for the Bengals.
12:33Yeah.
12:3329.9 points a game.
12:36That team is good.
12:37And then on the defensive side, I don't think the Bengals are as good defensively as Jacksonville.
12:43I really don't think that having...
12:45Maybe quite a bit.
12:47Yeah, having watched them in Jacksonville, I've had them as my fantasy defense this entire time.
12:52Now, what the hell were they doing letting the Titans in that game?
12:55Nobody knows.
12:55Or is that just foreshadowing for what the Cowboys are up against?
13:00But at this moment, I do trust in a tight game, Joe Burrow making the play that matters over Trevor
13:10Lawrence.
13:11Okay.
13:11Right now, I do.
13:14But I don't know if the Bengals could force Trevor Lawrence into the problem.
13:18I do think that the Jaguars can, so I'll say yes, that is reality for the time being.
13:26A couple quick things I'm going to throw it over to you, Mr. Walker, to finish up.
13:30Nick Sirianni said Joe Milton will start against the Steelers, and Wandale Robinson is in fact going to be out
13:37for the season per Robert Sala.
13:39Now, we finish up with you, Kevin Walker, overreaction or reality?
13:43The Jags are better than the Bengals.
13:46Yeah, I think that's reality.
13:49Bengals' defense is significantly worse in most defensive ratings that you look at.
13:55And the Jaguars are not that far off of the Bengals' offensive progression.
13:59I think they're only 20 points or so below the Bengals as far as points per game.
14:05And they've played a lot of similar opponents in the AFC, so I really do think the Jaguars are better.
14:11But to Corey's point, with two minutes to go in the game, you might take Joe Burrow if that is
14:18what you need as a game-winning touchdown.
14:20But maybe Trevor Lawrence has progressed.
14:21I think the Jaguars are better overall.

Recommended