- 11 minutes ago
Shan, RJ, and Bobby broke down the brutal loss to the 49ers in this edition of Star Up, Star Down. They discussed the defensive collapse, Caleb Downs, debated Dak Prescott's performance, and more.
Category
🥇
SportsTranscript
00:00At the Dallas 25, and Purdy, under center, will toss it left to Black.
00:05There's a big hole, and Downs couldn't bring him down.
00:08And then he broke another tackle at the 10, and Black goes streaking into the end zone.
00:14Kalon Black.
00:16Downs and Durant, I think this is the second time this year.
00:19I don't know what the bowling pins are that are.
00:22I think it'd be, you know, on the left side of the lane,
00:25because this is the bottom left side of our television.
00:28But this is the second time this year that those two pins were lined up right in front and behind
00:36each other
00:36and got bowled over.
00:39I believe the back left is a 7 pin.
00:41Is it?
00:42Yeah, 7 or 10. One of the two.
00:44Yeah. Well, it was not a 7-10 split.
00:47They got rolled.
00:48That was my most embarrassing play.
00:50It's hard to rank the embarrassment.
00:52I don't know whether the Debo, the Kalon Black from a physicality standpoint,
00:58or the CMC against Vaughn.
01:01I don't know how to rank the humiliation of the three.
01:05And you had it all in one game.
01:06I didn't see the Debo play live.
01:09I had, like, literally just gone to the bathroom.
01:10I was like, start of the drive, I'll be fine.
01:12So I had just gone to the bathroom.
01:13And while I was in there, I heard the crowd roar.
01:15And I was like, okay, well, San Francisco did something good.
01:17You mean, no, you heard the crowd roar.
01:19That's the Cowboy home game.
01:21Yeah, but no, it was a road game yesterday.
01:24California, California, very bad place.
01:26Exporting to Texas, it was on display yesterday.
01:27That was, I've never seen it be majority in other fan base.
01:30I've seen it 50-50.
01:32I've never seen majority.
01:33Kalen Black, and RJ's wearing his San Fran colors today.
01:39FC Dallas.
01:39I think that's his other team's colors.
01:41Kalen Black.
01:42Yeah, their colors are why I can't wear this color anymore.
01:45Or Kalen Black destroys Caleb Downs and Kobe Durant to make it 24-16.
01:53And got to give a star down to Caleb Downs coming off arguably his best game of the year.
01:58You know, there's two issues.
02:00Well, the one main issue with Caleb, even when he's the rare defender that's there
02:06and knows his assignment and responsibility, he's just going to be too small
02:10for some of these one-on-one collisions.
02:12So, he can be there assignment-wise and still get run over by a monster in the National Football League
02:19because that's just what God gave him.
02:21But yesterday, he got trucked by Black.
02:25He held George Kittle.
02:27I thought he had a missed sack opportunity on the big McCaffrey catch.
02:34He did not have a great follow-up to the Indy game.
02:37No, he was – and I don't even want to give him a total pass on just being too small
02:40because, like, we've seen him already this year, like, stand up bigger running.
02:43He stood up Derrick Henry in one play.
02:45Like, we know he can do it.
02:46So, to me, that says you were just bad form tackling.
02:48Like, you didn't just square it up.
02:50You were trying to blow somebody up, and you got bowled over.
02:53Black embarrassed them.
02:54It's that little gif of the little Jeep toy running over the kids in the yard.
03:00And that's the second time I think it happened to him and then Durant.
03:03I – if former Cowboy Bill Bates was watching that game, he had some flashbacks
03:09of Herschel Walker running him over.
03:10That's exactly what that reminded me of.
03:12It was – that was a very, very – look, he was my first star down that I had written
03:17down.
03:17I had it early on the game because, you know, first – one of the first plays of the game,
03:22they sack Purdy, and he gets called for a defensive hold.
03:25So, instead of, like, second and 15, you know, you already have a fresh set of downs.
03:30And it's already putting you – it's like, okay, here we go.
03:33And you can't be giving these teams, you know, extra plays.
03:36And the McCaffrey 74-yarder before half, third and eight.
03:41I saw Caleb fly in there.
03:43I needed to see the replay to see if it was a total Ezraku-esque missed sack.
03:47But it felt like he could have been more disruptive getting his hands on Purdy.
03:51And that resulted in the 17-16 lead.
03:55And I thought the Cowboys were actually, you know, get a stopper.
03:58You get the ball back again to do more damage before halftime.
04:03But star down Caleb Downs, even though he was in position for some of them.
04:08But he got bowled over.
04:10He got rolled.
04:11Yeah, I mean, it was –
04:12And then Black put it to Quinnen Williams.
04:14He popped Quinnen in pass protection.
04:17Then a third and two CMC in the fourth for 14 yards.
04:21These are all the things I had for my Caleb Black, Caleb Downs summary.
04:25Yeah, I mean, it was just – there's so much about this yesterday.
04:28It's a little overwhelming to figure out where to start when you talk about how bad this was.
04:33It's like –
04:35It's like the Cowboys' defense stays so far away from the play
04:40that it's hard to give a star down assignment-wise.
04:43It's like, I don't know who to blame for the Debo reverse.
04:48And I don't know who to blame for the McCaffrey pass where Purdy rolled right.
04:53That's how horrific they are defensively.
04:55It's like they're playing so they don't get put in star down in isolation.
04:59Then it's biggest star down yesterday.
05:02Then it's Christian Parker.
05:03Yep.
05:04That's it.
05:04And it's funny.
05:05We were standing around talking after, like, near the end of the game.
05:07And it was one of those things where I was asking people, I was like,
05:13who's this going to really stick to tomorrow?
05:15Like, because I'm always curious whenever they lose.
05:17Like, I've got my own thoughts.
05:18But then I started asking around some people just like,
05:19who do you think this sticks to tomorrow when they lose games?
05:22And sometimes it's Dak, sometimes it's Shoddy, whatever else.
05:25Because the easy answer is Parker.
05:27And yet, unanimously, it was Shoddy.
05:30This is going to stick to Shoddy.
05:31And the whole reason was where it's like, yeah, it may have been the defense,
05:35but he's got himself in such a hole that until they just start winning games,
05:40he's going to get it.
05:41He's going to be the one who it sticks to.
05:43I think this is Parker 1A, and then there's some 1B for Shoddy.
05:47I think if this game was game 13, 14, 15,
05:52I think we have a real chance of Christian Parker not coming back.
05:56As is always the case with the Cowboys,
05:59you've got to go ahead and get your easy rebound against Tennessee and Philadelphia
06:06so that they can prop Christian Parker back up
06:12because they do not want to make a change because of all the change.
06:15I was ready to talk about Christian Parker.
06:18You watched that first half.
06:19I was like, Christian Parker deserves a ton of praise for getting them ready
06:23and having an answer here to stop the run game and different things like that.
06:27And then it just, it crumbled in such a fundamentally basic way
06:33that it's like, man, that's really hard to say anything other than
06:37you're not coaching them the right way.
06:39Most yards allowed at home in team history,
06:45touchdowns of 70, 74, and 66.
06:49The Cowboys have allowed multiple scrimmage touchdowns of 70-plus in a game
06:54for the first time since 2008.
06:57Week 16 against the Ravens.
07:00That was what, Choppy?
07:01What game was that?
07:03Week, it was the Rio game, week three.
07:05No, it was last game at Texas Stadium.
07:07Oh, that one.
07:08It was those two.
07:09The Cleveland game, that was the second game we talked about yesterday
07:12in the press box was that Leron McClain running 70 yards
07:15after you just closed the gap.
07:17Did Purdy finish at 80%?
07:19He was at 80% at one point in time.
07:23Close, 22-28.
07:24In this game.
07:2522 of 28.
07:2778.6.
07:28And Jerry Jones, after the game,
07:31was asked about his confidence level in Christian Parker.
07:34Again, this is, it's what it is.
07:39He's a young coach.
07:40It's in his first year of coordinating and basically calling the plays.
07:47And so you would have to say that you would hope you could win games
07:53like the last that we've lost.
07:55And I'll weigh his early times.
08:02I've been with teams that had some pretty good coordinators that ended up
08:06on defense that ended up winning Super Bowls.
08:09Christian Parker, to me, by far, R.J. gets the biggest star down.
08:14If you're going to talk about coaching, like not even close with Parker
08:19over Schottenheimer.
08:20And then Jerry, as a follow-up, was asked,
08:22do you need to make changes?
08:23I keep getting these messages from Tolos.
08:25Well, this is it.
08:27This is the game.
08:28They'll fire him after this.
08:29If they don't make a change, all hope is lost.
08:31I'm like, guys, they're not firing anyone right now.
08:33They're not firing Schottenheimer or Christian Parker today or this week.
08:39Jerry was asked about it.
08:40Well, of course, it's glaring that they've made those kinds of yards.
08:48And the way we were tackling in the first half,
08:55we didn't continue that for the second half.
08:57That bit us.
08:59And then they caught us in that blitz on that last big play.
09:03So all of that was there.
09:05They're a good team.
09:06We were going to have to play better than we certainly played in the second half.
09:10Star up, star down, brought to you by Wild Fork Foods, your elite game day grilling.
09:15You know, it is Parker with the star down.
09:18Shoddy gets some for some things that he did.
09:22I did not understand not going for two down when you cut it to 38-31.
09:29If you go for two, you make it a five-point game.
09:31So you protect yourself because it's 345 to go.
09:34You protect yourself from San Fran kicking a field goal and making it nine points.
09:38That is a must-go-for-two in that situation.
09:43That is not a point after.
09:44That is a must-go-for-two.
09:47And it's like, start out little things like that.
09:50Little things that cost you games.
09:53And this obviously didn't, it was moot, right?
09:55Because San Fran had that, you know, they somehow got Von Miller on CMC.
10:01So it didn't matter.
10:03But little things like that.
10:05I was sitting here watching this first half.
10:07Like a Pickens taunt?
10:09The Pickens taunt.
10:10What do you say?
10:11What a dumbass freaking play.
10:13What a dumbass play.
10:14What do you say to a player when they've beat you the entire, when they're beating you?
10:18Now, I know he won his individual matchups the entire game.
10:23But what do you say to a player when they've been, like, dog-walking you on the scoreboard of the
10:28second half?
10:29You're down 14 with 125 left.
10:31What are you saying?
10:32And you point right at him.
10:33I just want to know, like, what is that?
10:35What is the phrasing that's there?
10:38Because that doesn't make any sense to me.
10:40Turpin's return.
10:41Little thing, Bobby, that you were texting us about at the end.
10:44It's near the end.
10:45They're going to lose, like, in all likelihood.
10:49But it's, like, one of those things where it's like, all right, there's this much time left.
10:51I was standing there talking to Todd Archer.
10:53And it was like, I don't care how deep into the backfield this goes.
10:57He should return it.
10:59Like, they should tell Turpin, hey, whatever it is, grab it.
11:01Try to do something.
11:02Just try to figure out something.
11:03Give us a good decision.
11:04I have a higher hope for him making something happen with a return than two plays back there on your
11:10own 10.
11:10Yeah.
11:11And then if he gets 15 yards.
11:13And time burned off the clock.
11:15That was the other thing.
11:16So I said, we were sitting there talking about it.
11:17I was like, I'd let him return it.
11:18And Archer's like, well, yeah, you got to do something.
11:20And I was like, no, this is Cowboys.
11:22He'll let it drop, and he'll let somebody down it and waste five seconds.
11:26And then Todd laughed, like, could you imagine?
11:28And then it lands, and he's like, what is he doing?
11:31Like, why would you just let it sit there?
11:33And the 49ers are like, all right, we won't touch it.
11:35We'll just wait a little bit until it's time to down it.
11:38Went down to nine.
11:38Went down to nine seconds.
11:39That's what he wanted.
11:40He wanted to just go down to nine because he's nine God.
11:42But this is a little thing like that.
11:45It's a dumb thing.
11:46And, God, he's in start down for him, too.
11:48Not that he matters enough, but, God, he is a dumb player.
11:51And the drop he had, the flat drop.
11:54I mean, it looked like he just swatted away his first pass.
11:56He was like, uh-uh.
11:57And then late in the game, they're going, let's call a go-route for Kevontae Turpin
12:01with somebody six inches taller than him covering him.
12:04It's just stupid play after stupid play, and it's getting exhausting.
12:10877-881-1053.
12:12Frankel and Frankel injury attorney text line for star up, star down.
12:15Also, I think it needs to be considered, at least, that when we're talking about the
12:19cover zero blitz with Vaughn Miller on him, since when some good things have happened,
12:24you've already got fans saying, this is the effect.
12:26It's got to be him.
12:27The cover zero blitz stuff is very likely Mike Patton.
12:30That's very likely a Patton influence of just, hey, you should have this ready.
12:34Not that he called it there, but that the influence is there.
12:37Zero blitz is definitely more of a Patton type of thing.
12:40It's not typically been used by Christian Parker.
12:42They used zero blitz in the first five weeks five times.
12:45So, like, one a game, basically.
12:47They've used zero blitz since Patton got here in the five games, six, since they've used
12:52it ten times.
12:53So, they've used it two more times per game.
12:55This was the second most they've used in a game.
12:57They did it three times yesterday.
12:58They did it four the first week Patton was here.
13:01Which I don't have a major problem with.
13:04Try something.
13:05If you're not going to get there.
13:06Now, yesterday, we can give a star up to the defensive line.
13:09Star ups a little bit later on in the show.
13:11But, you've got to have the second part of it with who's going to cover and be responsible
13:16for Christian McCaffrey.
13:19And you don't want it to be the 38-year-old running in open space.
13:24What type of game did Dak Prescott have?
13:25Do you have him in a star up or star down category?
13:29I don't have him for either.
13:32And this blew up into another fight from very frustrated and angry Cowboy fans afterwards.
13:38Someone sent me a meme.
13:40I laughed on it trying to say and signify it was a joke.
13:43But Dak Defenders, the Dakheads, did not take it as a joke where he was like sitting in
13:48a throne as the king of garbage time.
13:50Because this was, what, a 38-19 game to start the fourth quarter.
13:57Was that the score?
13:5738-19, but Dak ends up with five touchdown passes, 343, 30 for 51, and a QBR of 85.
14:08You got Schottenheimer afterwards saying, maybe the greatest competitor that I've ever been
14:12around.
14:13The Dakheads sitting there on social media saying he's the only reason that they were still
14:18in it.
14:18How can you blame him whatsoever?
14:19Put the offense on his back.
14:21The gritty, the gritty performance from No. 4.
14:25And then you have the other side, you got the Dakheads, and then you have the other side
14:33who are saying, typical, typical garbage time stuff.
14:36Watch these fancy numbers that he puts up.
14:39Did either of you have him in star up or star down?
14:42Choppy?
14:43Actually, I had him kind of in the middle.
14:47More so star down, though.
14:49He was a little off.
14:51He was just off.
14:53Early on, I mean, some of his throws were sailing a little bit.
14:55They were a little ducky.
14:56He started, oh, he and Lamb started together 0 for 4.
15:00It was way off.
15:02Yeah.
15:02Way off.
15:03He was 7 of 17 in the first half.
15:05He had two big plays to George.
15:07Just 7 yards to any other receiver.
15:10I likened it.
15:11I was trying to come up with a comparison.
15:12I thought of like...
15:13And again, he had 16 points in the first half.
15:15Yeah.
15:15He scored 32.
15:17Sure.
15:17And he ended up scoring 40, but...
15:18I thought of like a pitcher who didn't have his great stuff and had to find a way to battle
15:22through and get you 6 innings still.
15:24And I was like, that's kind of the game Dak had.
15:26He didn't have his best stuff.
15:27He tried to battle to get you some, you know, to keep you in it.
15:30But we've seen Michael Jordan have terrible shooting nights.
15:33He finds a way to get to the free throw line 20 times, and he scores 30, you know, on
15:37five field goals.
15:38Like, you're not always going to have this idea in sports that you're always going to
15:42be...
15:42And you're not saying he's MJ.
15:43I'm not even remotely coming close to saying he is Michael Jordan.
15:47Okay.
15:48He is probably deserving of being a star down.
15:52He did not have his best day.
15:55That's okay.
15:56You're not always going to have your best day.
15:57He tried to figure it out.
16:00It didn't work.
16:01He was a little bit off.
16:02He's a definitive down.
16:04Oh.
16:04Like, when the game was within seven points yesterday, he was 8 of 19 for 111 yards.
16:10He wasn't good when it was close.
16:11When they got blown out, he then started doing something a little bit.
16:15But when that game was within their reach, he was not good enough.
16:18It was too inaccurate.
16:21It was...
16:22He was too consistently not putting them in the right position at the line of scrimmage when
16:26it was a game.
16:27So, no.
16:28He's a star down.
16:29Pei-Pei?
16:29Star up, star down with the Dak discussion?
16:33I'm going to go neither for him.
16:34I mean, it was like he was okay.
16:35He had pickings a few times early on the game.
16:37He was all right.
16:38But, yeah.
16:38He wasn't as best.
16:39And then, yeah.
16:40I think he's the king of garbage time stats, too.
16:43Those were garbage time stats.
16:45They absolutely were.
16:45I mean...
16:45No doubt.
16:46I had the spread of nine and a half in one of my three bets.
16:50And I was like, Sam Fran, are you going to step up here?
16:52Are you going to try to do anything defensively?
16:54That was a lot of...
16:55You can still say he fought.
16:57And you can still say he was trying to be a gamer while saying it was a lot of garbage
17:02time stats in the fourth.
17:03Man, is it me or do these teams start to play that pre-vet defense really early in these
17:10games, man?
17:11Yes.
17:12Like, either they think these things are over when they're not.
17:14I don't know what...
17:15The Dak-Lamb connection coming off of last week against Indianapolis was just off.
17:22And I was worried CeeDee was going to go into pouty mode, but there was a near interception
17:28with Greenlaw.
17:29CeeDee doesn't have his first catch until...
17:32Again, with us, it's either or.
17:35Is it all pickings?
17:36No Lamb?
17:37All Lamb, no pickings.
17:39You're not allowed to do both.
17:41Right.
17:41Can't have both.
17:42So, 650 in the third was CeeDee's first catch.
17:45650 in the third.
17:47He took the huge hit from Mustafa.
17:50That was a shot.
17:50Tolos were calling for a helmet-to-helmet.
17:52On that, where Tom Brady...
17:54Tom Brady, he gets off on helmet-to-helmet and vicious stuff.
17:57He's like, let the quarterback get killed.
17:59Let him play.
18:00Let's just hear the sound of that.
18:02Yeah.
18:02Helmet.
18:03That's what he would say during his career.
18:04Let the quarterback get killed.
18:06Destroy him.
18:07Yeah.
18:08Dak was off with CeeDee on a third and two.
18:10That third and two play that I thought was thrown low to Lamb.
18:14That was a big play and a big miss in the game.
18:17I had neither as well.
18:19I didn't have a star up.
18:20I did not have a star down.
18:22I went with neither on it.
18:23But this ignited the fan base and the Tolos over garbage time versus gamer.
18:29Dak, after the loss.
18:31I mean, it's easy for me to say, yeah, just because I'm such a present, present person.
18:35And this is what's on me.
18:37And this is what's on my mind and where we are now.
18:40But if I truly had to go back and look at it, I'd probably not say that.
18:44You know, I think it's much tougher.
18:45If you're asking me, when we don't do it, we're supposed to do.
18:48And, you know, thinking about the Tampa Bay game or, you know, another game when we've
18:52had an opportunity and maybe even the Ravens that don't capitalize on it.
18:56Right.
18:57But this one, yeah, it sucks, especially, you know, right now and how it feels.
19:00And bad job by me.
19:01He was asked, was this the toughest loss of the season?
19:04Listen, a Dak carryover topic was scrambling on fourth down or scrambling on the play in
19:14which some thought he should have picked up a first down with his legs.
19:17Yeah, he could not.
19:18We all were thinking in the moment, like watching it live, like, why didn't he run?
19:23And then we were all looking up at like the in-house feed and you could see really quickly
19:26like, oh, Fred Warner was going to destroy him.
19:28This was fourth and two after being off with land.
19:32This was the third and two that he missed.
19:34He threw low to CD.
19:35You're down 31-19 in the third.
19:39And a lot of Tolos were like, just go ahead and take off.
19:42When I saw Bobby showing us a different view, maybe we should run this on the fan cam as
19:46well, Twitch and YouTube.
19:48We cannot.
19:48Okay, we cannot.
19:49Yeah.
19:49NFL copyright, trademark stuff.
19:51Yep.
19:52The views that I saw at the replay, I thought Fred would have killed him.
19:55Yes.
19:56I thought Fred would have taken his head off.
19:58When Dak is going to release the ball, like when his arm goes back, he is five yards from
20:04the first down and Fred Warner is two yards from the first down and he is like full head
20:10of steam running.
20:11He is.
20:12And he is going to just literally take Dak's head off if he runs.
20:16He is one step away at the time of this throw from like, he's one step away from like a
20:23Ruffy
20:24the Passer.
20:24Like that kind of a hit.
20:26He is barreling down on him.
20:28There's no chance.
20:28So then after that, McCaffrey has his 16-yard run.
20:33I wrote that final nail until the comeback in the fourth quarter.
20:37But the 16-yard run made it 38-19.
20:40So for Dak Tolos on the fan text, Franklin LaFranco fan text, up, down, or neither.
20:468-7-7, 8-8-1, 1-0-5-3.
20:49In that instance on those two, by the way, I'm going to start down to shotting.
20:54Just get in, you know, whatever 23, 13 personnel, whatever else you want to do.
20:59And then you just run the ball twice.
21:02Like, that's what I want to do.
21:03It's two yards to gain.
21:04So this is two straight weeks now where he's gotten aggressive and thrown it down the field.
21:09And I think there was basically two yards to go.
21:12And you did text or tweet you were not a fan of the call.
21:15Yeah, just run the ball twice.
21:16Like, I mean, you haven't been gashing them.
21:18But you've been, like, just steadily kind of been able to pick up.
21:21You're not getting blown up in the backfield every time you run the ball.
21:23So you were running the ball well enough that, to me, you would have two cracks at it.
21:28Just try to pick it down.
21:29Pick it up on the ground and then get back into your game plan.
21:31But, I mean, that was a 31-19 game at that point when that happened.
21:34If you continue to drive down the field, you score.
21:36It's a much more manageable game.
21:37I think in post-hut you're going to take that back tomorrow.
21:40I think.
21:41My initial memory is the play was there.
21:45The play was open.
21:46They didn't execute it the way that they should have.
21:49I don't remember saying, oh, my God, you should have gone ahead.
21:52Because, again, I've been calling for them to not be so predictable and conservative in those situations.
21:57I understand what you're saying.
21:58I'm not vehemently disagreeing.
21:59But I think you'll go back and say that was open.
22:02That was there.
22:03I think it was open.
22:04But, to me, it's like there's too many things that can go wrong in that situation if you're trying to
22:08roll out and throw the ball.
22:10Or do I have to just run it and just say, we've got guys to be able to create space.
22:13Because I had Schottenheimer on the precipice.
22:15Artolo's weighing in on Dak.
22:17Oh, some of the Dak defenders are out.
22:19Like, what do you want him to do?
22:20Give up.
22:21If he had come back and they had won the game, would they still be garbage time stats?
22:26Minshew did the same thing against this team.
22:27They wound up winning.
22:28I mean, you know, three drop picks had nothing to do with, you know, Dak.
22:32The defenders just dropped him.
22:33So, that was an anti-Dak.
22:35I don't think of it as garbage time filling, necessarily.
22:39But it also, like, it's not some impressive thing that I'm like, oh, yeah, he played really well yesterday.
22:45He didn't play well when it was close.
22:46That's the problem.
22:48Dak on the fourth and two.
22:51And whether he thought about running.
22:53My eyes are completely downfield.
22:55Obviously, I feel Fred.
22:56I know where Fred is.
22:59I think there's a defensive end or another player to my left that's also closing in.
23:05It was more about the concept.
23:06It was more about what I was seeing downfield and what I was trying to attack.
23:10More than thinking, you know, this guy's going to take my head off.
23:13But I think, you know, if I tried to run, yeah, it would have been a car crash.
23:16Hopefully, you know, I may have could have gotten it.
23:18But initially, I liked my chances downfield, what was there.
23:23And unfortunately, the play didn't happen.
23:26I feel like a character that's a lot of stuff.