Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 11 hours ago
Caldey Island has released a statement expressing ‘profound sorrow’ for the ‘suffering endured by survivors’ following the release of an investigative podcast into allegations of historic abuse at the monastic island. Significant changes made to safeguarding arrangements in recent years at Cadley has been highlighted.
‘Dark Island’ a new eight episode podcast commissioned by BBC Radio Wales explores a series of historic disturbing events within the close-knit community of monks living on the island off Tenby.
Caldey remains a popular destination for visitors and day-trippers.
The series (now available to listen to now on BBC Sounds) is presented by investigative journalist India Pollock, nine years after she first reported on the story for the BBC.
Since then, she has continued searching for answers as to why a series of allegations of sexual abuse and assault involving monk Father Thaddeus Kotik went unreported to the police; how one of Crimestoppers' Most Wanted, Paul Ashton, was able to evade capture while living on the island for several years; and the other unsettling stories buried in the sand of the island's past.
Following the podcast’s release, in a statement, Allison Parkinson, Safeguarding Lead at Caldey Island said: “The testimonies of those who suffered abuse on Caldey Island are deeply moving and painful to hear. We are profoundly sorry for what happened to them, for the terrible suffering they have endured, and for the failures of those who should have protected them.
“Listening to survivors describe their experiences, and the lasting impact on their lives, brings home the devastating human consequences of abuse. These are not simply events from the distant past.
“For those who suffered, the pain, trauma and sense of betrayal can last a lifetime, affecting their families and those they love.
“We are deeply saddened by what we have heard in the BBC podcast. We know that speaking publicly about such painful experiences takes enormous courage, and we are grateful to those who have found the strength to share their stories.
“We also recognise that hearing these accounts may be distressing for other survivors, including those who have chosen not to speak publicly
“We cannot change what happened, nor can any apology take away the suffering that has been caused.
“But we can acknowledge that suffering, listen with humility and compassion, and accept our responsibility to ensure that the lessons of the past are never forgotten,” she continued.
©Video: BBC Wales

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:01Next tonight, a woman has spoken out for the first time about an alleged sexual assault by a monk who
00:07lived on Caldy Island off the coast of Pembrokeshire.
00:11Brother Titus, who denies the claims, is also accused of sexually assaulting an island employee, as well as giving women
00:18naked photos of himself.
00:20The allegations are in a new BBC podcast, Dark Island, written and presented by our social affairs correspondent, India Pollock.
00:30More than 50,000 people visit this tiny island each year.
00:34Caldy is owned by a small group of Cistercian monks, a denomination of the Catholic Church.
00:39Natalie Roberts was a regular visitor from the early 2000s.
00:43She doesn't want to appear on camera, but features in a new podcast called Dark Island.
00:48A monk called Brother Titus gave naked photos of himself to Natalie.
00:54She didn't know how to take it, but felt she couldn't complain as he was a monk.
00:58But she was stunned when, on a walk in 2016, she claims that Brother Titus sexually assaulted her several times
01:06over her clothes.
01:07I was so angry when I got to the other side, because I knew this was an absolute violation.
01:12You know, this wasn't spiritual, but this was his opportunity to just do that.
01:17I think the worst thing it did, India, if I'm completely honest, it took away my whole spiritual belief in
01:24Catholicism.
01:25Brother Titus denied the allegations, saying a woman who feels rejected can become very vicious.
01:32He said the pictures weren't sexual, but he'd reflect on his behaviour.
01:36Brother Titus also allegedly groped a former employee of the Abbey and made unwanted sexual advances.
01:43When confronted, it's claimed he said she was lucky to receive sexual attention from him and that she would lose
01:49her job if she complained.
01:51Titus again denied the allegations, saying the employee had made them up in the hope the monastery would pay her
01:58to keep quiet.
01:59The claims were investigated by police, but there was no further action.
02:04He's since been asked to leave the island and lives in another monastery.
02:08These allegations aren't the first time the order has made the news.
02:12Another monk, Thaddeus Kotick, was able to abuse children there over four decades in plain sight,
02:19because that abuse was not reported to the authorities until after he died.
02:23I'm very sorry for what they went through.
02:27And I would like to take the occasion to apologise for what they have gone through for the pain and
02:36the suffering.
02:37And since I became an abbot, I took safeguarding as my priority and I put everything in place so that
02:47it wouldn't happen again.
02:48Now, Father Jan says people who stay have to have criminal record checks and provide original identification.
02:55That was recommended after three other serious offenders also stayed on the island,
03:00including one man described as one of the most dangerous sexual predators in Britain.
03:05We asked the highest authority in the Catholic Church, the Pope, here at the Vatican in Rome, for a statement.
03:11They referred us elsewhere.
03:13We did get a reply from the head of the Cistercian Order, the abbot general, Don Bernardus Peters, who's also
03:19based here in Rome.
03:21He said he had profound regret for the abuse that took place on Colby Island
03:25and that safeguarding was a fundamental responsibility of each individual monastery as well as the order as a whole.
03:33Now, there are renewed calls for a police investigation into the abuse that took place by Kotick,
03:39with some saying that's the only chance left for the survivors to finally have justice.
03:46India Pollock with that report.
03:48And you can hear more on this story in the podcast series Dark Island,
03:52which is available to listen to now on BBC Sounds.

Recommended