- 6 weeks ago
This special broadcast covers the political confrontation in New Delhi following the detention of Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi and other opposition leaders by Delhi Police during an eight-hour dharna outside Akashvani Bhavan.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:01Good evening, you're watching NewsTrack with me, Maria Shakil.
00:04Dharna and final detention.
00:07After more than nine hours of dharna, the standoff finally has come to a head.
00:12Congress leaders were detained as police moved in to clear the protest site.
00:17As the long-running confrontation between the opposition and authorities escalated,
00:23leader of opposition Rahul Gandhi was dragged and taken away and put inside a police bus.
00:28Yes, the detained leaders were subsequently taken to Kingsway camp,
00:34bringing the day's protest to an end, but raising a bigger political question.
00:38What next? Will Rahul Gandhi resume his satyagraha tomorrow?
00:43While we ask this question, a piece of breaking news which has come in,
00:47which is leader of opposition Rahul Gandhi has taken to X and he has said,
00:51the remnants of democracy have been dragged into the effort to shield the traitors of democracy
00:58a reckoning will follow and not a single traitor will be spared.
01:04How is the BJP looking at all these developments?
01:07Let me go straight to senior BJP leader and former union minister Ravi Shankar Prasad,
01:13who is joining us live.
01:15Mr. Prasad, the question is, why shouldn't Rahul Gandhi be allowed to protest?
01:20Isn't this his right as a leader of opposition?
01:28Who has stopped him from protesting?
01:31But are you protesting or you are creating chaos?
01:35You are creating anarchy.
01:38Remember, he is not in politics because of his particular charm or ability,
01:45but because of his parentage, the son of a prime minister, grandson of a prime minister,
01:50great-grandson of a prime minister.
01:52He sits on dharna in front of the house of the prime minister without permission,
01:58the most security sensitive area.
02:01Today also, for the whole day, he unleashed a log jam in Delhi.
02:08Let me give you a parallel analogy.
02:11We are opposed to them.
02:13But there was a dharna in Mumbai.
02:15It took place.
02:17People delivered their speeches and completely dispersed.
02:21Here, it is not a question of protest.
02:24It is a question of creating a log jam.
02:30My way or highway?
02:32Let me ask you three questions straight away.
02:34Kindly give me one minute time.
02:36You say we would like to meet the chief election commissioner with 300 people.
02:42Though there were hardly 50, 60 people.
02:45No Samajwadi there, no S there.
02:47But what you wanted to do inside?
02:51Create mayhem there?
02:52Like Mr. Kejriwal did with the left-hand governor's house?
02:57That was their intention.
02:59And the second, Maria, it is very important, larger question.
03:04They want to revert to ballot paper in place of EVM.
03:09That means you know you are from Bihar.
03:12They want to win by booth capture, by stamping the ballot paper, by putting ink in the booth,
03:21ballot boxes, and preventing the Dalit, the OBC, and marginalized in the rural area from exercising their franchise, as they
03:29have been doing.
03:29That is the real reason.
03:32They lost in Bihar.
03:33They lost in Delhi.
03:36They lost in Haryana.
03:37They lost in Maharashtra.
03:39They lost in Bengal.
03:40And lo and behold, in Kerala, their home minister has said, we have won because of SIR, because all the
03:47dubious voters, which the leftists have got in two dead, have been removed.
03:53So what to say?
03:55Mr. Prasad, I am going to...
03:57And one thing more.
03:57That is very important.
03:58Yes, sir.
03:59Please go ahead.
04:01Yes, go ahead.
04:02Go ahead.
04:02Sir, you know, since you say that Rahul Gandhi is an anarchist, when you were in opposition, sir, you also
04:09held a very prominent role when the BJP was in opposition.
04:13At that time, Mr. Prasad, you were also holding street protests.
04:17At that time, the Congress did not call you anarchist.
04:24The reply is very simple.
04:25We are doing a street protest.
04:28Police came, arrested or they got arrested.
04:31Finish.
04:32We did not hold Delhi to ransom.
04:34Did we show one particular footage of our activism during the Manamohansting government in spite of stinking corruption?
04:43Did we put Delhi to a halt?
04:46No.
04:47Therefore,
04:49What is the big thing?
04:50You are going to die every time.
04:53But you are going to die every time.
04:55You are going to die every time.
04:56You are going to die every time.
04:57The government is going to die every time.
04:58You will die every time.
05:03In democracy, Maria, arrogance of your family connections does not give results.
05:13And Rahul Gandhi is reluctant to recognize that.
05:17And let me say on your channel today, Rahul Gandhi is not only anarchist, he is utterly irresponsible.
05:25And let me give you one example why I am saying so.
05:29There have been great leader of opposition from LK Advani to Atal Vyari, Baj Pei to Ram Manohar, Lohia, to
05:34Sonia Gandhi, to Indra Gandhi, to Sushma Swaraj.
05:38Have you heard any point in time, they behave, he is behaving?
05:42You have got the right to protest?
05:45That's the point I am trying to say.
05:47Mr. Rahul Gandhi is not able to instill the confidence and popular support for his party.
05:54How many seats he got in Bengal?
05:56Two.
05:57How many he got the seats in Assam?
06:00Below ten.
06:01How many seats he got in Bihar?
06:05Two.
06:06So, this is your seat, Mahatma, Maria Shaqeel.
06:09Sir, but…
06:10And that's why you have been standing up.
06:11But, sir, are you not worried?
06:14Rahul Gandhi, try.
06:18Mr. Prasad, then are you not worried that, you know, of course, the BJP has been winning multiple elections.
06:25But protests of this nature can create doubt in the minds of the voters and the citizens
06:31about the legitimacy of the entire electoral process.
06:39I am very sorry.
06:41That's what they want.
06:43And that's what the minions of Rahul Gandhi want from across the border.
06:49Remember, all his comments are highlighted by Pakistan TV.
06:53Rahul Gandhi, you know what he has been saying in America, who organized his programs there,
06:58you know it very well.
06:59But people will respond to it.
07:02And the more Rahul Gandhi speaks, the more we'll be able to expose him.
07:08Because we have not to work very hard to expose Rahul Gandhi.
07:11But I'm on a larger question.
07:13And the larger question is this.
07:15What are you doing, Rahul Gandhi?
07:17You are the leader of opposition.
07:20Does it behove your conduct?
07:23I'm quite sure, Maria, even the Congress people are not appreciating it.
07:27Even they are not appreciating.
07:29Now let me speak a little about, sir.
07:33The Supreme Court in the May judgment has clearly stated, and student of law, let me tell you,
07:38that SIR is recognized in the Representation of People Act and the Power of Election Commission.
07:45And this 13 crore hangama which they are doing, crores of people are found to be dead.
07:51Many are found to be resident, not in their particular constituency.
07:55Many crores were found to be voters at more than one place, which is prohibited in law.
08:00Therefore, if someone has been left accidentally, corrections can be done.
08:04But you cannot do it, why Mr. Tejasfiada was not there?
08:11Why Akhleshada was not there?
08:14Why DMK was not there?
08:16The so-called, their maha gadbandhan.
08:19Because they are also not reconciled to this dogged arrogance of Rahul Gandhi,
08:26the way he is seeking to berate the election commission.
08:29Recently, Tamil Nadu elections took place or not?
08:31But did Mr. Vijay's party win handsomely or not?
08:35That is the point I am trying to highlight.
08:38You just won Kerala.
08:40Your home minister is saying, Mr. Chalitala, that we won because of SIR.
08:45These are issues which are important.
08:48We will be exposing Rahul Gandhi.
08:52And my friend Sudhanshu just raised an important issue in Delhi.
08:55I am in Patna, Madhya.
08:57Where were the great legal eagles of Rahul Gandhi?
09:00Mr. Chidambaram, Mr. Abhishek Manu Singhvi, Mr. Vivek Tankha, the great Mr. Kapil Sibbal.
09:07Where were they?
09:09That is itself an indication as to how much support he has.
09:14But Mr. Prasad, you know, what happened in the Supreme Court yesterday,
09:20what we are seeing is that the BJP has come out in defense of the election commission.
09:24The Supreme Court is raising very serious questions with regards to Form 6,
09:30that it did not really approve any modifications of Form 6.
09:35The election commission seemed to have given a completely different version.
09:39Aren't you, you know, as a former law minister and also a lawyer, senior advocate of the Supreme Court,
09:47how do you look at what the observations of the EPEX Court has been with regards to Form 6?
09:56I will reserve my comment till the final determination by the Supreme Court.
10:00There we should notice.
10:03And the hard fact remains that they have pointedly rejected their contention for a stay of the function of Ganesh
10:10Kumar.
10:11The order of May, I am following the date, is quite clear, very elaborate order.
10:17And by the way, Maria, who went to Supreme Court?
10:20All the opposition parties went to Supreme Court.
10:22I know for sure Mr. Venugopal was the petitioner there.
10:25Mr. Raja was the petitioner there.
10:28Mahua Maitra was the petitioner there.
10:30And many jholawalas who are always go to a drop of a hat.
10:36They were there.
10:37And all the legal eagles argued their cases.
10:39The Supreme Court gave the order.
10:42And since you have asked me in the context of my legal background,
10:47should we forget the Supreme Court, because of apprehension of Mamata Banerji,
10:53appointed judicial officers to oversee the elections of Bengal.
10:57And all, and they were also browbeaten.
11:00Can we forget it?
11:02These are quite evident.
11:05Let us await the Supreme Court final order.
11:08Okay.
11:10Okay.
11:10I want to say, Maria Shakil, I want to say something with a big adab.
11:14And I know this in Hindi.
11:18If we have to die, we will die.
11:22Die.
11:23We will die.
11:24We will die.
11:25We will die.
11:26But those who have been repeatedly rebuffed by the people of India in elections after elections
11:32cannot control the polity of India to the coiters of Supreme Court.
11:37I mean every word of it.
11:40Yes, election must be held in a proper manner, fair manner.
11:43If there is something wrong, it must be addressed.
11:46But this whole aspect, and since you have invoked my credentials as a senior lawyer,
11:52I know your legal background in your family, let me flag one more issue to you.
11:56The Supreme Court has repeatedly held that when election process is started, you cannot challenge
12:04it midway except by election petition after the conclusion of the election.
12:10What is happening?
12:11What is happening?
12:12At every drop of a hat, they are running the Supreme Court.
12:15All right.
12:16If you have got the highest respect of the Supreme Court, we will see about it.
12:19But there is enough to say about the hollowness of this whole claim.
12:26And last submission to you is, for the sake of your viewers, the kind of language they are
12:34using against Janesh Kumar, against the election commission, it is a constitutional body.
12:40You know it very well.
12:42Be it the CVC, be it the Supreme Court in the Raphael case, be it the army chief, what
12:49kind of language they use.
12:51We all know it very well.
12:52Is it fair, is it just Rahul Gandhi, he keeps with a, moves with a pocket in the constitution,
12:59constitution means pocket, but he is most disrespectful to the constitutional institutions.
13:06My last question to you, Mr. Prasad, the election commission of India, and this is with regards
13:10to what their, you know, press release just few minutes ago says that the ECI is claiming
13:17that it could not accept the request of meeting the opposition MPs because it was unusual.
13:24Wouldn't it have served it better if the poll panel made an exception in order to be seen
13:30as accountable to India's elected lawmakers?
13:33These are elected MPs, sir, just as you are.
14:04My reply is very simple.
14:06Therefore, the police did the wisest thing by preventing them from going.
14:11Otherwise, who knows what would have happened inside the commission office and even to the
14:17chief election commissioner.
14:18The intention was very clear.
14:20And by the way, you must remember, they said that come, let Mr. Gyanesh Kumar come and meet.
14:26He's speaking constitutionally.
14:27Institutionally, even in parliament, we cannot summon the chief election commissioner.
14:34He can come before any particular parliamentary committee of law, etc., etc.
14:38But no, in the parliament, he cannot be called.
14:41So, ye koon samjhai hunko?
14:44Samajnyen ko tayyaar hotham na?
14:45That's the point.
14:47All right.
14:48Ravi Shankar Prasad, senior BJP leader and former law minister, really appreciate your time.
14:52Thank you for joining us and sharing your views.
14:55And before we proceed further, let's also take a look at how this capital showdown over
15:01the chief election commissioner unfolded today.
15:10Gyanesh, it's done, bro.
15:12With these posters in hand, Rahul Gandhi led the opposition's march towards the election
15:18commission's office.
15:20Barricades were in place.
15:22Police deployment was heavy.
15:24And then came the visual that dominated the protest.
15:27Rahul Gandhi perched atop a barricade, waving the tricolor as cameras clicked.
15:34A message that he was not backing down.
15:37Several India bloc leaders were eventually detained, including the Gandhi siblings.
15:43But Rahul Gandhi had other plans.
15:45Before being taken into a police bus, Rahul, along with Priyanka, suddenly dashed towards
15:51the reception entrance of Akashwani Bhavan, catching everyone by surprise.
15:57After that, the Gandhi siblings were seen sitting under a banyan tree.
16:03But after more than eight hours of dharana, the standoff finally came to a breaking point.
16:09Congress leaders were detained as police moved in to clear the protest site.
16:18Leader of opposition Rahul was dragged and put inside a police bus.
16:24Moments later, visuals showed Rahul Gandhi peering out through the window of the bus
16:30with a heavy police presence surrounding the vehicle.
16:35The detained leaders were subsequently taken to Kingsway camp.
16:42Before being detained, Rahul Gandhi accused Prime Minister Narendra Modi,
16:48Home Minister Amit Shah and RSS Chief Bhagwat of hijacking the country with the CEC
16:53through what he caused, vote chori.
16:56Rahul alleged that those responsible will face action for what he caused, treason.
17:22For the opposition, this is no longer just a political protest.
17:26They say it is a fight for democracy.
17:29They say it is a fight for democracy.
17:59They say it will vuelve.
18:00Oh, that's because of this, Trumpard刚 wrote it in a lignan t
18:03, and Trump, the leader of the NTS 됩니다 had also become a Impact in后 CEC.
18:34The BJP, however, has hit back.
18:37It has accused the Congress of echoing narratives allegedly pushed by foreign powers and anti-India
18:43forces to undermine India's constitutional institutions.
19:13It has to be said that the government has no trust in the court, its rules in the election of
19:28the country.
19:57The only question now, what next?
20:03With Mausumi Singh and Piyush Mishra, Bureau Report, India Today.
20:31She said and insisted that Gyanesh Kumar must resign.
20:35Let's listen.
20:59And let me bring in Anmol Bali who joins us live.
21:02Anmol, what exactly is happening?
21:04Have Rahul and Priyanka Gandhi and other Congress MPs been released now after the detention?
21:13Maria, all the Congress member, parliaments and leaders, those who were detained by the
21:17Delhi Police from the Kashwani Bhawan have been all released by the Delhi Police.
21:22Currently, I am here outside the Kingsway Camp complex.
21:24Where in the visuals, I will ask my camera person to show you that how Congress Party workers
21:28have gathered here from the various corners of the national capital.
21:32And I am also joined by a few Congress Party workers, IYC, President Uzey Banu Chhib is
21:37with me.
21:38So you have been protesting today.
21:39We have seen that you have protested for more than eight hours and later you were detained
21:43by the Delhi Police.
21:44And clearly, police have said that they won't be letting you protest and reaching the election
21:48commission.
21:48So it was my first experience today.
21:51I detained eight times today.
21:53Jabb bhi detain ker'te tè, phir am bus se bhaar nikala tè, thoi hort baar detain kiya.
21:56Lekin, yeh jho mرضi ker nai, áaj Rahul ji nai bata diya.
21:59Desh jhukne wala nai hai.
22:01Yeh jho vote shor gaddar hai, unko jayel mein jana pade ga.
22:04Narendra Modi Shah bhi usko bacha nai saktet.
22:06Or áaj woh halfak nama maang raa tha, áaj woh chupkar baita hoa hai.
22:10Áaj halfak nama maang nai aata na, aay toh thay, ghanish halfak nama dhenne.
22:15Kaan chupkar baita tha.
22:16Or, eek chiz or.
22:18Dilllhi police ko mein yeh kihana chahata ho.
22:20Áaj hamarhe protesters peaceful protest kar rye thay, hap nne unko maara, unke saad violence
22:24kiya, reporter ke saad kiya.
22:26Hamid Shah hamayshah ke liyeo hominister nai rhenne waala hai.
22:29Jis dhin Hamid Shah haute ga, humari sarkar raayegi.
22:31Jo log abhi crime kar rye ha, violence kar rye ha, unke oper puri karwa hi hogi yeh
22:35Dillli police ko mein bolna chahata ho.
22:36Áage vi aap jab aasei kohol.
22:37Let me bring in our next newsmaker who's joining us live.
22:41Dr. Sayyad Nasser Hussain is a member of parliament of the Congress party.
22:45Dr. Hussain, really appreciate your time.
22:47Rahul Gandhi has been detained after he held protests for nine hours.
22:51What was seen as unprecedented, clearly.
22:55India bloc stood united as well.
22:58The Congress is demanding the CEC's resignation.
23:02But what is the end game?
23:04If Gyanesh Kumar does not resign,
23:06what is the opposition's next constitutional or political step beyond protests?
23:15Maria, it is now very clear that whatever Mr. Gyanesh Kumar has done,
23:20it is a crime against democracy in India.
23:23It has been done on the instruction of someone who is abohim.
23:26We want to know who is the asli vote chore.
23:30Who was getting his vote chore done through Gyanesh Kumar.
23:34So our demands are very clear.
23:35Mr. Gyanesh Kumar should go.
23:38SIR should be scrapped.
23:39All the names that have been deleted in the SIR process should be back in the voters list.
23:44There should be a high level inquiry through which we need to get to know as to who is the
23:53person,
23:53who is the authority and whose instruction that Mr. Gyanesh Kumar was acting and was implementing this conspiracy.
24:00Who is the asli vote chore is a moot question.
24:03And also, this EVM business which we have been raising from last 10-12 years continuously,
24:12even the EVM should go, we should be back on ballot paper.
24:15These are our demands and we stick to our demands.
24:18It is just not the Congress party.
24:21It is just not India bloc.
24:23It is just not opposition parties in the parliament.
24:27It is also the Jensis, the youth, the Kisan, the Aam Admi of this country
24:34who is up in arms against Mr. Gyanesh Kumar and the asli vote chore.
24:37The CEC so far has shown no indication that he will step down.
24:42So what happens if he simply refuses?
24:44Will Congress then escalate this into a sustained nationwide movement,
24:50seek parliamentary action or take the battle back to the Supreme Court?
24:56Mr. Dharmendra Pradhan had not shown any signs of resigning.
25:01Nobody thought he will put down his papers.
25:03Nobody thought that the India government will take back the three black laws,
25:10that is anti-form laws that were brought in by the government.
25:14They had to take it back after 14 months of sustained agitation
25:20and movement by the farmers of the country.
25:22So this agitation will be escalated.
25:25Already it is escalated.
25:26Different, you look at what is happening in Mumbai.
25:28You look at what happened in Bangalore, Hyderabad.
25:30You look at any important state capital in the country,
25:35the Jensis are out, the political parties are out.
25:37Today you have seen around 250 to 300 MPs from the opposition
25:43marching on the streets of Delhi.
25:45So the same way, we will go back to our constituencies,
25:48we will organize agitations, we will organize protests
25:51and it will be an endless sustained fight to save our right to vote,
25:57to save our democracy.
25:59Dr. Nasser Hussain, this is ultimately about the special intensive division
26:02and credibility of the election commission itself.
26:05Because if the opposition believes the electoral roles have been compromised,
26:09is demanding one resignation enough?
26:12Or are you then seeking a complete institutional course correction?
26:19See, we have been raising this issue for the past 10 years.
26:24It started with EVMs, then it started with Oachori.
26:27Even the friends in media did not believe there is something called Oachori
26:31happening in this country, Oachori did happen under various names.
26:35It was Sansat Chori, it was MLA Chori, it was Government Chori,
26:39it was Satta Chori, it was Seed Chori,
26:41it was elected MPs Chori within Lok Sabha and Raj Sabha,
26:46and it was Chori's of the political parties, Chori's of the symbols.
26:52You have seen what all kinds of Chori's that were happening just for the people,
26:57those who are there in power to continue to be there in power,
27:01they did all kinds of Chori's.
27:02Ultimately, it is not we, we have been exposing them.
27:06It is the two election commissioners appointed by Mr. Narendra Modi,
27:10appointed by the NDA government,
27:11that have exposed the Oachori that is happening in the country.
27:16So, it is not just about Oachori,
27:19it is not just about electoral rolls alone.
27:22It is not about just Gyanesh Kumar alone.
27:24As I mentioned earlier,
27:26we need to know who is the Asli Oachor,
27:29which are the forces that were instructing and acting
27:34behind Mr. Gyanesh Kumar
27:35and making him do all these things,
27:40making him implement the conspiracy,
27:43which they were hatching.
27:44So, we need to know that person,
27:47we need to know that force,
27:48that political party,
27:49that is one.
27:49Second thing,
27:51Mr. Rahul Gandhi,
27:52who is leading this movement from the friend,
27:54Mr. Rahul Gandhi,
27:55who has been raising this,
27:57he was the first person to raise this issue
27:59in the country about Oachori.
28:00So, people ridiculed him,
28:03people tried to snub him,
28:05people started calling him names,
28:07they called him anarchist,
28:08they called him whatnot.
28:09But now,
28:10everyone in the country believe
28:12there is some sort of Oachori happening,
28:14there is some sort of misuse
28:16of the constitutional body is happening,
28:18there is some sort of misuse of autonomous body
28:21as we have seen CBA, EDIT happening in the country.
28:24So, we need a systemic change,
28:26we need course correction,
28:27we need to rebuild the credibility
28:29of our constitutional institutions,
28:32which the people of this country
28:34have built painstakingly
28:36over a period of 75-80 years in this country.
28:39So, we need to strengthen them,
28:41make them more credible,
28:43bring about changes
28:44and do the course correction.
28:45It is a lengthy battle,
28:46but Congress has taken up two insults
28:48to lead from the friend,
28:50Mr. Rahul Gandhi and Mr. Malik Arjun Khargi
28:52are leading from the friend,
28:53I am sure we will win this battle,
28:55we will do the course correction,
28:56we will do the systemic correction,
28:58we will see to it
28:59that the democracy
29:00and the right to work
29:02with the constituent assembly
29:03and the freedom fighters
29:04of our country
29:06gave it to us,
29:07gave it to the people of this country,
29:08is protected and saved.
29:10Yes, Dr. Nasir Hussain,
29:11I agree that Rahul Gandhi
29:12has been consistently raising this issue,
29:15but the BJP is saying
29:16that you have raised this bogey
29:18because you have been rejected
29:20by the people of this country
29:21in election after election,
29:23and that is the reason
29:24why vote chori
29:25is being raised
29:27because you are not able
29:28to get votes of the people.
29:33Who is saying this?
29:34The illegal Prime Minister,
29:36the illegal cabinet,
29:38the illegal members
29:39of the Bharatiya Janata Party
29:40who have been elected
29:42illegally
29:43through vote chori
29:44for the past 10-12 years.
29:46So, you mean to say
29:48we are losing the election
29:50because there is vote chori
29:52and then we sit quiet
29:53and we don't raise this issue.
29:5513.5 crore people
29:57in this country
29:59are disenfranchised
30:00just because
30:01they are not ready
30:03to vote to Bharatiya Janata Party.
30:05What is the difference
30:06between the ruling bloc
30:08and the bloc
30:09that is there in the opposition
30:10in terms of percentages?
30:122%, 3%, 4%.
30:14How much percentage of vote
30:17will generally be there
30:19between the winning
30:19and the losing combinations?
30:212%, 3%, 4%.
30:22And how much is
30:2313.3 crore voters?
30:26They amount to about
30:2715-16% of the vote.
30:29So, you do 15-16%
30:30of the vote chori
30:31by in the name of
30:33cleansing the electoral rolls.
30:35Then you win the election
30:37illegally,
30:39unconstitutionally
30:39and then you sit in power.
30:41you gain authority
30:44through that
30:45and then you start
30:46blaming the opposition
30:48because they are
30:48losing the election.
30:50What can be the biggest
30:51threat of the country
30:52and what can be the biggest
30:54threat of the democracy
30:55and what can be the biggest
30:56A couple of more questions,
30:58Nasir Hussain.
30:59The Supreme Court
31:00has refused to
31:01entertain the petition
31:02of suspension
31:02of the Chief Election
31:03Commissioner.
31:04How do you view that?
31:09See,
31:10people are fighting
31:11in our country
31:12there are checks and balances.
31:14People resort to
31:17different channels
31:18to air their grievances.
31:20They are doing
31:21some are going to
31:22Supreme Court
31:23some are going
31:24some are writing
31:25to the political party
31:26some are
31:27lining behind
31:28the opposition parties
31:29Genzies are fighting
31:30their own battles
31:32farmers are fighting
31:33their own battles
31:34different people
31:35different sections
31:36of people
31:36are fighting it differently.
31:38We are a political party
31:39we are MPs
31:41in the opposition
31:42it is our duty
31:44and responsibility
31:45to see that
31:46the right to vote
31:48the right to vote
31:49is protected.
31:51I would just like
31:52to remind you Maria
31:52when most of the
31:54developed countries
31:54in the world
31:55were having
31:57limited suffrage
31:58were having
31:59limited franchise
32:00at that time
32:01India thought of
32:02having universal
32:03adult franchise
32:05so this
32:06this
32:06this right
32:07that has been
32:08given by the freedom
32:09fighters
32:09by the constituent
32:10assembly
32:11needs to be protected
32:12our fight is political
32:14our fight is
32:15for to
32:16to protect
32:17and save the right
32:18to vote
32:18our fight is
32:20to see that
32:21there is no
32:21two class of citizens
32:23in this country
32:23our fight
32:24to
32:25our
32:25our fight
32:26is to see that
32:27sab ko barabari ka hak
32:29mele
32:30our fight
32:30is to see that
32:32that everyone
32:33are same
32:34even the prime minister
32:35or even the last person
32:36standing in the line
32:37have the right to vote
32:39and they both have a single vote
32:40that is
32:40that is our fight
32:42and will definitely
32:43win in this
32:43so what
32:44what will constitute
32:45success for the congress party
32:48politically
32:48a rollback of SIR
32:49which is the special intensive revision
32:51restoration of all deleted names
32:53and inquiry into the election commission's functioning
32:56the CEC's resignation
33:00see as i mentioned to you earlier maria i have listed you our demands that is on one side
33:07but in one of your questions i answered that there need to be there need to be a systemic
33:14change we need to do course correction we need to see that everything is put back in order
33:20we need to have free and fair elections in this country we need to see that right to vote is
33:25protected
33:25we need to see the people those who sit in the election commission are neutral impartial unbiased and independent
33:33okay
33:34it's an autonomous body
33:35nobody needs to be dictated from anywhere and nobody needs to work according to somebody else vincent francis
33:43we need to have a system in place which was like something that was created by the people of this
33:49country
33:49through the constituent assembly through various government through various legislations
33:53we need to bring back that credibility to the election commission
33:56and also we need to say not even one
34:01legal voter is put out of the electoral list
34:04we need to bring back that system
34:07all right dr sayyed nasir hussain really appreciate your time thank you for joining us and sharing your views
34:12a piece of breaking news coming in now
34:14the armadmi party which did not join these protests of the india bloc will join opposition protests
34:20at the ceo office in delhi at 1 pm in fact armadmi party leaders will join congress left for other
34:28left
34:28parties and other delhi based parties protest on the issue of alleged vote chori amadi party has said now
34:35that on wednesday we will hold a protest outside the delhi ceo's office
34:39against vote theft we have called upon our workers supporters and members of the party
34:45to participate in large numbers so that's what the armadmi party's strategy is now
34:53remember armadmi party did not join the protest the india bloc protest today which was led by rahul gandhi
34:59now they are looking at parallel protests which they'll be holding against the ceo
35:04the delhi ceo because their concerns are likely to do with uh delhi elections
35:10amit bhardawaj is joining me on the phone line so armadmi party skips the protest today of india bloc
35:16and now we'll be holding another set of protests tomorrow
35:20uh yes that's the national protest is concerned of india bloc the armadmi party gave it a myth but possibly
35:27is this an afterthought tomorrow there is uh joint protest by several of uh aboriginal parties in
35:35delhi including the congress party the left parties over what they are calling vote chori and uh delhi
35:41uh armadmi party president uh sarah bhardwarja said that the armadmi party will be joining the
35:48protest outside delhi's ceo office so this is delhi dc office uh where the app will be joining the
35:55multi-party protest opposition protest and will be happening at 1 pm tomorrow the campaign is
36:01obviously centered around the election irregularities and uh the sir process which is being carried out
36:08in the national capital where we know for a matter of fact that one third of the total voters in
36:13delhi
36:14which is uh one out of every three voter in delhi uh were deleted in the drafts world and further
36:20another set of voters were uh sent uh logical discrepancies notices uh so now uh united front
36:28as far as delhi is concerned by the opposition parties amadmi party congress and the left parties
36:32will be staging this protest tomorrow at 1 pm but amit before i let you go so amadmi party uh
36:39will also have
36:41the congress and other parties join this protest and what about the national protest which is being
36:45led by rahul gandhi so will delhi be witnessing multiple protests tomorrow uh so uh this particular
36:53uh protest is uh you know on the issue of delhi sir and what virtually i say opposition parties are
37:00terming it but tomorrow whether the congress party is going to stage another set of protest uh remains
37:07unclear right now but yes i can certainly tell our viewers that this particular week for the national
37:12capital and the national politics is going to be quite heated up because we are india bloc and the
37:18opposition parties are already you know in process of uh uh strategizing uh of of of uh process or you
37:28can say further uh pressure tactics on cc gyanish kumar who uh cc gyanish kumar on the partijanta party as
37:36well and uh that is so we will see more happening uh by friday this week i can certainly
37:42tell us all right amit thank you uh so much for joining us joining me on the show now harish
37:50salve
37:50one of india's most eminent constitutional lawyers and former solicitor general of india and he joins
37:56us to decode the supreme court's latest intervention in the sir controversy and the larger questions it
38:02raises about the election commission's powers and autonomy mr salve unprecedented protest by rahul
38:09gandhi and opposition demanding resignation of the cc you know the developments which have happened in
38:14the last few days as well with regards to the election commission the functioning of the body
38:18and also the developments in the supreme court let me begin by asking you has gyanish kumar's position
38:25become untenable
38:29i am really baffled at what is going on in india i mean i understand political parties need to remain
38:37in in the front in the limelight scream sharp and often in in the political narrative all over the
38:44world not just india i've increasingly truth becomes a serious casualty uh it started with
38:53that indian express uh semi-article raising some questions and maybe some decisions were not unanimous
39:02the three of them have sat together and said our decisions were unanimous now either you're saying
39:07all three of them should be believed or you're saying all three of them should not be believed it
39:13can't be that i do not believe gyanish kumar when he says they were unanimous the other two are very
39:18nice
39:18people they are also saying it was unanimous but i don't i believe them but i don't believe them so
39:24you
39:24know this is it's it's all become very political secondly it's a very simple thing the matter
39:30is uh in court a reply affidavit will be filed they will show all the records because i unlike
39:39political parties who are not in any way answerable for wrong statements the election commission when
39:51it issues a press communique under the authority of the three commissioners if it makes a wrong
39:57statement that without more will be ground for removal of all three so for the present why not
40:04i believe them and i don't and the political parties have their own reasons their own aspirations
40:10they are gathering people to scream and shout which is fine which is a part of democracy at least shows
40:16one thing that indian democracy is alive and kicking mr salvi i'm looking at what the cji said
40:22uh that any modified form 6 has not been approved by us
40:29the cgi has now said any modified has not been approved by cgi has said nothing the cgi will say
40:39whatever he has to say in a judgment you know this ridiculous principle of picking observations in the
40:48course of course of a dialogue between the judges and lawyers must stop the somebody said
40:56something has been approved the cgi says we have not we will see because we have not approved anything
41:01modified we will see it will see the papers will come before them the election commission has made it
41:09clear they are not saying anything is modified what they are saying is that they were not limited to
41:15seeking additional information so you know this is this is a legally complex situation it is not a
41:20one-liner saying the cgi has said have you read his order his order says issue notice returnable on
41:27fixed for so-and-so hearing that is what he has said but mr salvi you know since since you're
41:33raising
41:34that i i just want a little more explanation on that or clarity
41:41but mr salvi you know observations and court please these are not political parties making speeches
41:49these are judges they are entitled to ask questions they're entitled to make observations lawyers are
41:56entitled to tell them no sorry you have a wrong impression you have a right impression here are the
42:00papers this is what you've done this is not what you've done what's the problem do we have something
42:05happening in the next week that we must set the uh this narrative on fire and make so much noise
42:11you can't wait for three weeks till the affidavit comes and the supreme court decides see we have to
42:17bring the rule of law back it can't be the rule of the streets and like some people are saying
42:22that
42:22we don't believe in rule of law we believe in rule of streets then then i have i have i'm
42:27i i'm not in
42:28the i'm unable to deal with that vocabulary that others deal with if you talk of rule of law the
42:34rule of
42:35law is there is an allegation that a constitutional institution has functioned contrary to law who's
42:40going to decide that under our constitution the courts the highest court of india has taken
42:44cognizance they're going to deal with it in two weeks three weeks four weeks in the meanwhile must
42:49we have this cacophony which permanently damages in public perception the impression of all institutions
42:56it what question which is being raised with regards to form six isn't it a legitimate one
43:05the entire question around form no question can't you wait for four weeks till the supreme court sees
43:13the revised form six does there are legal nuances the form has not been changed asking for additional
43:22information in order to supplement the information in the form six is not a change in form six is the
43:29argument of the ec there may be an answer they may be right they may be wrong we will know
43:34shortly
43:35in the meanwhile must every anchor of every tv channel sit there like a supreme court judge and
43:41hear arguments on both sides and decide i also quote what the supreme court said that we can always
43:47a nalani decision does supreme court have to say that don't we all know it that's what i'm saying
43:57don't pick on observations the supreme court see whenever you tell the supreme court grant me an
44:03interim order it happens in the smallest of cases if somebody is being is some my house is under challenge
44:09and i file a suit saying protect my house the court says no i today i don't want to pass
44:14an injunction
44:15if there is any transaction i can always analyze that's a standard dialogue in a court
44:20when you are declining an interim injunction you say heaven won't fall if there's something we can
44:25always analyze don't don't attach so much political consequence to normal uh conversation which takes
44:33place a normal legal uh conversation which takes place in a courtroom it happens all the time
44:38you ask for an injunction you ask for an injunction if tomorrow i say uh stop uh maria from running
44:44a
44:44particular show and they just say well in the show show is three weeks okay if she says something
44:49wrong we will correct it later i we can always know what happens so that's a normal uh discussion in
44:56a
44:57in a interlocutory process but don't say chief justice said we can and of course you can and
45:02the supreme court can annul anything which is in the format of uh in the legal format
45:08mr salve today you're visibly angry with all the questions being asked with regards to the functioning of the eci
45:18you know i am i am i am really worried let the politics go on let the vocabulary of politics
45:26go on
45:26when you start destroying constitutional institutions and with relentless attack on the integrity of
45:35constitutional institutions without a scintillow today there is an article by indian express which has
45:42nothing more you have a denial by the election commission and everybody is saying we believe that
45:48rag and we do not believe the three election commissioners i think that's a sorry state of
45:54affairs i feel strongly about so sir sir tell me if the supreme court finds that decisions were taken
45:59without unanimity or majority in terms of the election commission can it retrospectively invalidate those
46:07decisions the supreme court's powers are untrammeled it will do what is the right thing to be done
46:17under the constitution the supreme court is never powerless there is no fait accompli but it will do
46:23the right thing but let me tell you if the decision were indeed not unanimous it is a very strong
46:31indictment not only of the chief election commissioner but of the other two commissioners
46:38let's just go back a bit why were three why was it made a multi-member commission
46:43because there was one particular election commissioner mr t session who was very popular
46:49very popular because he ran roughshod over politicians but two more members were added and
46:57it was made clear by the supreme court it's a three-member commission if three of them are there each
47:02of them
47:03has a responsibility to make sure the that decisions are either unanimous or by majority if they have sat by
47:12allowing the chief election commissioner to do what he likes he may be overbearing like mr sasha but
47:19they have been guilty of serious dereliction of duty now i don't understand the the the argument that
47:26they are very nice people he's the bad man you got it upside down so tell me the supreme court
47:33has so
47:34far refused to suspend the cec and has sought the response of the election commission of india does that
47:40tell us the court is drawing a very deliberate line it will scrutinize legality in the procedure
47:45but will not remove or suspend a constitutional functionary merely on allegations
47:53see there is the supreme court has shown that it is not affected by the noise and din of politics
48:02and i'm proud of my supreme court for that yes since there is a matter of of of such serious
48:09allegations against the institutions sometimes not because you doubt the institution but you
48:15want to validate the institution that the court says all right we will have a look at these allegations
48:20because ultimately we do not want the way the politics of this the way this noise has been
48:26generated we do not want this institution to be under a cloud let us have a look if we find
48:31they've done
48:31anything wrong we will set aside their decisions but if they've done nothing wrong we will give a
48:36judgment saying that they have done nothing wrong that's the right process in a rule of law
48:41and that process is acting now what's the use of i mean it's all right here for politics it is
48:48necessary to be seen on the front page and to hold the city of and the traffic to ransom by
48:55blocking streets etc that's all right that's a part of politics i'm not a politician i don't appreciate
49:01that but politicians i believe have to do that for a living so that i understand but honestly
49:07can't we wait for four weeks must we debate this every day must we what happens tomorrow
49:13what happens to the reputation of these three if tomorrow's hubrib got said these allegations are
49:17nonsense the damage would have been done my last question to you and here's the difficult institutional
49:24balance mr salvi you have argued that constitutional institutions must not be judged by personal
49:31standards but if the supreme court finds that the institution itself did not follow the law
49:38does judicial intervention then become not an encroachment on ecis autonomy but the very mechanism
49:45that protects constitutional autonomy
49:51let's be very clear the highest thing which can be done under a constitution is amending the constitution
49:57right then you have legislation and then you have institutional functions the legislature these
50:04are co-equal institutions the legislature the elected executive the judiciary and the election
50:11commission commission these are co-equal institutions each is supreme in their own sphere the supreme court cannot
50:17second guess on how to run elections but the job of the judiciary is to make sure all the other
50:24institutions
50:25act within legal bounds their policies are for them their legality is for the court so if the supreme court
50:33finds
50:33there is anything illegal illegal means not not in a in a derogatory sense anything which is not
50:40strictly in accordance with the law in the constitution in the functioning in any action of any institution
50:47the supreme court will deal with it and will say so and if tomorrow i can understand if the supreme
50:54court tomorrow
50:55says there have been a raft of decisions which are illegal then that may be a good ground to say
51:02well if a body
51:03has been acting so irresponsibly or been decided acting in a particular manner and have been found
51:10to be acting in a particular manner then are they should should the personnel be changed so but that is
51:18not for
51:18the supreme court that under our constitution is for parliament to do if you allow it to run
51:25mr salvi always a pleasure listening to you sir thank you for sharing your views and giving us clarity
51:31on the legalese and the constitutional view on the developments which have been happening appreciate
51:36your time thank you so much that's all from me on this edition of news track thanks so much for
51:40watching
51:40this edition of news track
51:41you