Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 7 weeks ago
The developer cut the project by roughly eighty percent — fewer buildings, one gas plant instead of two, more distance from neighbors, a pledge to use less water — and Pinal County, Arizona voted it down anyway, 4 to 1. On the same day, a Kentucky town of under a thousand restarted an annexation that would put a hyperscale campus outside county zoning, an Illinois county banned data centers outright until 2027, and the U.S. government closed a $1.9 billion loan to restart a dead nuclear plant so Google can run its Iowa data centers. Here's what actually happened.

COMMUNITY — The Pinal County Board of Supervisors voted 4-1 to reject Vermaland's proposed 3,300-acre data center campus south of Eloy, which would have been the largest data center project in Arizona. The developer had scaled the plan back from 59 buildings and two gas-fired power plants to 11 buildings and one plant, moved the facility several miles from the nearest neighbors, pledged reduced water use, and brought in an economist to present revenue projections. It did not change the outcome. Supervisor Jeff Serdy said he voted the will of the people: "When 90% of the people are against it, I'm going to vote the will of the people." Supervisor Rich Vitiello said the project carried too many unresolved questions and no identified end user, adding that data centers need to go where there is water and power. Vermaland argued a closed-loop cooling system would limit water use; Yale's Kenneth Gillingham notes closed-loop trades water savings for higher energy consumption. Arizona already hosts roughly 160 data centers with four dozen more under construction or planned.

COMMUNITY — The city of Burgin, Kentucky restarted its annexation process for Panattoni Data Centers' proposed hyperscale campus after an earlier attempt to annex more than 1,000 acres was voided. Annexation is the crux: it would place the project outside county zoning rules entirely. Activists say the developer is running advertising camp

Category

🤖
Tech
Transcript
00:00In Arizona, a county board just voted down what would have been the largest data center project in the entire
00:06state,
00:08and the developer had already cut it by 80% trying to save it from a Kentucky town of 900
00:14people to a fishing city on the coast of Maine.
00:18The same question keeps landing in front of local officials.
00:22More and more of them are answering no.
00:25We start in Pinal County, Arizona, south of the city of Alloy,
00:31where a 3,300-acre campus would have been the largest data center project in the state.
00:38The developer, Vermiland, saw the opposition coming and tried to negotiate.
00:43It cut the plan from 59 buildings down to 11, from two gas-fired power plants down to one,
00:50moved the facility several miles from the nearest neighbors,
00:55pledged to use less water,
00:57and brought in an economist to talk about revenue.
01:00None of it worked.
01:02The Board of Supervisors voted 4-1 against Supervisor Jeff Serdi put it plainly,
01:08when 90% of the people are against it.
01:11He votes the will of the people.
01:14Supervisor Rich Vitiello said there were simply too many ifs,
01:18maybes and buts,
01:20and no end user.
01:21Arizona already hosts 160 data centers,
01:25with four dozen more planned.
01:28That kind of local veto is now drawing attention from the very top.
01:33In Bergen, Kentucky, a city of under 1,000 people,
01:38officials are restarting an annexation process for Panatoni's proposed hyperscale campus after an
01:45earlier attempt to bring in more than 1,000 acres was voided.
01:50Annexation matters here,
01:52because it would let the project sit outside county zoning rules entirely.
01:57Activists say the developer is running advertising campaigns while avoiding face-to-face meetings,
02:03and organizer Bethany Correa is calling for third-party expertise to write the zoning ordinance.
02:10Then the president weighed in,
02:13posting that communities opposing data centers will end up backwards and poor,
02:18and that curbing their growth will kill the golden goose.
02:21Governor Andy Beshear disagreed,
02:24saying this is an intensely local decision,
02:27and that the area is going to choose whether it wants them.
02:32And some communities are choosing to shut the door entirely.
02:36In Lake County, Illinois,
02:38the county board voted to ban new data centers across all unincorporated land.
02:44Effective immediately,
02:46with the moratorium running until May 11, 2027,
02:50the ordinance amends Chapter 151 of the county code,
02:54And it does something quietly important,
02:57it writes an actual legal definition of a data center
03:00into the books,
03:02covering both stand-alone buildings and multi-building campuses.
03:07That definition is what county staff will build permanent regulations on over the next eight months.
03:13And if those rules land early,
03:16the board can lift the pause early.
03:18The planning,
03:19building,
03:20zoning and environmental committee had recommended the measure unanimously just days before the
03:26full board took it up.
03:28Lake County is one of the fastest moving jurisdictions in Illinois on this issue.
03:35Not every fight is over farmland.
03:37In Eastport, Maine,
03:40a company called Deep Green Holdings wants to put an AI data center underwater.
03:46Submerged in the Western Passage,
03:48using the cold Atlantic itself as the cooling system,
03:52residents are not persuaded.
03:54The city is holding a public hearing on two citizen-initiated ordinances,
03:59one of which would permanently ban large-scale data centers outright.
04:04The planning board already recommended adopting that ban,
04:08while dismissing a second measure that would have required voter approval for major projects.
04:14Citing a conflict with the city charter,
04:17a resident coalition called ECHO is petitioning the city to seek intervener status in the federal
04:23permitting process.
04:25The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission accepted Deep Green's preliminary permit application in
04:32August that allows study,
04:34not construction,
04:36and has since accepted a similar filing for Alaska's Cook Inlet.
04:41Every one of these projects comes back to the same problem,
04:45where the power comes from.
04:47And the answer this week came out of Iowa.
04:50The Department of Energy closed a loan of up to $1.9 billion to NextEra Energy to
04:56restart the Duane-Arnold Energy Center,
05:00a 615-megawatt nuclear plant that has been dark since 2020,
05:06when a derecho with winds near 140 miles an hour tore apart its cooling towers.
05:12The restart is underpinned by a 25-year power purchase agreement with Google,
05:18which takes the output for its Iowa data centers,
05:22with Central Iowa Power Cooperative taking the remainder.
05:26NextEra is targeting commercial operation in the first quarter of 2029.
05:31Pending Nuclear Regulatory Commission approval,
05:35an economic study puts the benefit to Iowa above $9 billion over 25 years.
05:43While the federal government finances the supply,
05:47local governments are busy writing the rules.
05:50In Spring Hill Township, Pennsylvania,
05:53supervisors approved a temporary ban on data center and power plant applications while they finish
05:59two ordinances that would restrict both to conditional uses in industrial zones.
06:06The setbacks are specific, 200 feet from any property line,
06:11400 feet from a home,
06:13and greater distances still for power plants.
06:16A companion noise ordinance caps sound at 55 decibels during the day and 45 at night.
06:23With additional limits on low-frequency vibration,
06:27solicitor James Tomasi says the rules are necessary because current zoning lets data centers in
06:33through special exceptions with no clear restrictions.
06:38The trigger was Nadara's interest in 800 acres near Gans.
06:42Votes were pushed to September 17th to satisfy state notice requirements.
06:49That same instinct showed up twice in one night in South Carolina.
06:54In Mount Pleasant,
06:55Town Council took up a 120-day moratorium on data center requests,
07:01meant to buy staff time to close a loophole that could let hyperscale facilities into light.
07:07Industrial Zones
07:08Mayor Wilhaney says the town has to act before the applications arrive,
07:13and that hyperscale centers will not be permitted here.
07:17The PAWS is also designed to separate genuinely large facilities from small business data.
07:24Operations that carry none of the same load.
07:27Meanwhile in Jasper County,
07:29one of the fastest-growing counties in the country,
07:32leaders took up a first reading on their own PAWS.
07:36Covering data centers,
07:38cryptocurrency mining,
07:40rezoning requests,
07:42permits and incentives,
07:43officials there say they need time to find out whether existing infrastructure can carry the
07:50electricity and water demand at all.
07:53But for every PAWS,
07:55somewhere is still saying yes.
07:57Kearney, Nebraska,
07:59a city of about 33,000 people,
08:02spent more than a decade courting this industry,
08:05and it is about to land a campus called Tech One Crossing.
08:10The developer,
08:11worldwide mission critical,
08:13would replace an existing 100-megawatt cryptocurrency mine with a facility drawing 3.
08:20168 megawatts,
08:22more electricity than Kearney,
08:24Grand Island and Hastings consume combined.
08:27Kearney is one of the first cities in Nebraska to pass a zoning ordinance written specifically for
08:33data centers with restrictions on noise,
08:38water use and energy,
08:39and the developer has applied for a conditional use permit under those new rules.
08:45Phase 1 targets completion in late 2027.
08:49Full capacity would not arrive until roughly 2030.
08:53It is a bet placed in the middle of a state pulling the other way.
08:58Thanks for watching.
09:00If you found this useful,
09:02subscribe,
09:03leave a like,
09:04and drop a comment,
09:06it helps us cover more of these stories.

Recommended