Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 1 week ago
New York put a moratorium on large data centers this summer. It starts at 50 megawatts. The project 30 miles north of Manhattan needs 45 — and it is moving forward. That five-megawatt gap is where a national fight is now being decided, one council chamber at a time. Here's what actually moved.

COMMUNITY — A data center 30 miles north of New York City is moving forward despite a statewide moratorium, because it needs 45 megawatts and the ban starts at 50. Gov. Kathy Hochul's executive order applies only to facilities requiring 50 MW or more, and DataBank's Orangeburg project sits just underneath that line. Residents protested outside Orangetown Town Hall on Tuesday. Dave Rosen, co-founder of the Bi-State Datacenter Crisis Coalition NY/NJ, says the core problem is that these facilities sit next to residential areas and next to Lake Tappan. This week Orangetown passed its own moratorium and then exempted the DataBank project because it is already in the approval process, which drew outrage from residents. DataBank says it uses no evaporative cooling and takes no water out of the reservoir. Opponents are now pinning their hopes on Sen. Kristen Gonzalez's bill, which would set the threshold at 20 megawatts; Hochul has until the end of the year to sign or veto it.

COMMUNITY — Demonstrators returned to the Utah State Capitol to oppose Stratos, a proposed data center development in Box Elder County spanning roughly 40,000 acres and powered by its own natural gas plant. The projected draw is about 9 gigawatts, close to double what the entire state of Utah consumes today. The site sits inside the Great Salt Lake Basin, a watershed already in ecological crisis after decades of diversion, and opponents argue the basin has nothing left to give. The project is backed by investor Kevin O'Leary. Protesters have delivered a petition with more than 7,000 signatures to the governor's office demanding independent reviews and a genuine public comment period, while the Box Elder Ac

Category

🤖
Tech
Transcript
00:00New York put a moratorium on large data centers this summer.
00:04The project 30 miles north of Manhattan needs 45 megawatts,
00:09five short of the line where that ban begins.
00:12And that gap is where this entire fight now lives.
00:17We begin 30 miles north of New York City, in Rockland County,
00:22where a data center is moving forward despite a statewide moratorium.
00:26Governor Kathy Hochul announced that moratorium last month to considerable fanfare.
00:32But the executive order applies only to facilities requiring 50 megawatts or more.
00:39Databank's Orangeburg project would use 45 if its planned expansion goes through.
00:45Five megawatts under the line.
00:48Residents protested outside Orangetown Town Hall on Tuesday.
00:52Dave Rosen, co-founder of the Bi-State Data Center Crisis Coalition,
00:57said the biggest issue is that these facilities sit next to residential areas and,
01:03most importantly, next to Lake Topan.
01:06This week the town passed its own moratorium,
01:09and then exempted the databank project because it is already in the approval process.
01:15Residents were furious.
01:17This databank, for its part, says it takes no water out of the reservoir at all.
01:24That same frustration carried protesters up the steps of the Utah State Capitol.
01:30Their target is Stratus,
01:32a proposed data center development in Box Elder County spanning roughly 40,000 acres and
01:38powered by its own natural gas plant.
01:41The projected draw is around 9 gigawatts.
01:44That is close to double what the entire state of Utah consumes today.
01:50The site sits inside the Great Salt Lake Basin,
01:53a watershed already in ecological crisis after decades of diversion.
01:58And opponents argue that basin does not have an extra drop to give.
02:03The project is backed by investor Kevin O'Leary.
02:06Demonstrators have delivered a petition carrying more than 7,000 signatures,
02:11demanding independent review and what they call a genuine public comment period,
02:17while a separate referendum group works to put the project's fate directly in front of county voters.
02:25That kind of pressure is now translating directly into local law.
02:30In Elkhart, Indiana, the city council voted 9 to nothing at a special meeting to impose a moratorium on both
02:38data
02:38centers and battery energy storage facilities.
02:42The pause runs until December of 2027.
02:46And for that entire period, the city will not accept applications for either type of project.
02:52What makes this one notable is who supported it.
02:56Mayor Rod Roberson stood with the council rather than against it,
03:00saying he stands right with them,
03:02and that this is not a complete rejection of data centers.
03:06His framing was that the city needs time to understand what these facilities actually mean for the
03:12community before it begins approving them.
03:21Georgia delivered a similar answer and delivered it in silence.
03:26The Coetta County Board of Commissioners voted unanimously to deny the rezoning application for the
03:32data center known as Project Oak.
03:36Developers had already scaled their request down to a 255-acre parcel,
03:41apparently hoping a smaller footprint would land better with the board.
03:46It did not.
03:47Commissioners listened to the developers.
03:50Listened to residents who had organized themselves under the banner stop Project Oak.
03:55And then, without any discussion at all among themselves,
04:00voted the petition down.
04:02After the vote, the developers said they would take resident feedback into account
04:07before deciding what comes next.
04:09Under the county's own zoning procedure,
04:12they will have to wait a full six months before they are even permitted to reapply.
04:18And the reason so many of these local fights keep landing on cost brings us to Virginia,
04:25where regulators just moved the bill.
04:27The State Corporation Commission ordered Dominion Energy to develop a tariff that directly assigns
04:33transmission costs to the large customers who make that infrastructure necessary in the first place.
04:40In practice, that means a mandatory contribution in aid of construction,
04:46applied to direct connect facilities,
04:49covering both the substations and the transmission lines that link them to the grid.
04:54The case grew out of Dominion's request to recover roughly $1.5 billion through
05:00its Rider T1 charge.
05:03The commission approved an amended allocation factor and cut the proposed monthly increase for a
05:09typical residential customer from $2.90 down to $0.94.
05:19The pressure on the grid is only half the story.
05:23Water tells the other half.
05:25And in New York's Finger Lakes it is being told on a shoreline.
05:30Opponents of a proposed 300-megawatt artificial intelligence data center on Cayuga Lake
05:36are gathering at Salt Point Natural Area in Lansing,
05:40pressing Governor Hochul to sign legislation restricting large-scale development.
05:46The project belongs to Tara Wolf and the coalition fighting it.
05:51FLX Strong argues it would carry environmental, quality of life,
05:56and economic consequences across the entire watershed.
06:00The gathering is part of a statewide tour organized by State Senator Kristen Gonzalez and the group
06:07Food and Water Watch
06:09Moving from town to town
06:11Building pressure on a bill the governor still has not committed to signing
06:17State legislators are taking notice
06:20And in New Jersey one of them just got a signature
06:23Governor Mikey Sherrill signed legislation requiring data centers to report their water and energy
06:30Used to state regulators every six months
06:34Operators will have to disclose total energy consumption
06:37The energy used for cooling and for information technology equipment
06:42Peak water use per day
06:44Where that water comes from
06:46And what backup power supplies they hold
06:49The Board of Public Utilities then has 30 days to publish that information on its website
06:55And to keep it updated
06:57This matters because data center operators have generally treated those numbers as trade secrets
07:04Sherrill signed the bill at the South Brunswick Public Library
07:08And her line was about as direct as it gets
07:11She will not let these developers operate in the shadows
07:16And the money behind all of this has not slowed down for a single moment
07:22JPMorgan Chase has begun early outreach to lenders on a $5 billion debt package to fund an
07:28Artificial Intelligence Data Center build out for Volta Infra Holdings
07:33If that name means nothing to you
07:36That is very much the point
07:38Volta is a new artificial intelligence cloud company that closed $300 million in
07:44Venture funding earlier this month
07:47A round that valued the whole business at $2.4 billion
07:52Now a major bank is assembling debt worth more than twice that valuation
07:57Just to build the physical footprint
08:00Communities are voting on moratoriums measured in acres and megawatts
08:05And capital is moving in billions
08:07On a timeline that answers to no city council
08:12Thanks for watching
08:13If you found this useful
08:15Subscribe
08:16Leave a like
08:18And drop a comment
08:19It helps us cover more of these stories
08:22Please
08:22Please
08:22Please
08:23Please
08:23Please
08:26Please
08:27Please
08:27Please
08:27Please
Comments

Recommended