- 3 months ago
On this episode of RealTrending, Tracey sits down with veteran executive recruiter Stephen Kowalchuk to unpack why succession planning for brokerage owners can’t wait. With so many independent owners now in their late 50s and 60s, Stephen explains that the industry is heading into one of the largest generational ownership transfers we’ve ever seen. Add recent market volatility and aggressive consolidation from regionals, nationals, and private equity, and you get an environment where owners who haven’t planned often end up selling on someone else’s terms — not their own.
Stephen breaks down what real succession planning is — and what it isn’t. It’s not just naming your son, daughter or a favorite manager as the heir apparent. It’s about building a deep leadership bench, creating an operating structure that doesn’t revolve around a single charismatic owner and giving yourself three to five years of runway.
Finally, Stephen gets tactical about protecting your agents, culture and valuation through transition. He also reframes M&A and strategic partnerships as proactive tools in a long-term succession strategy, not last-ditch exits.
For owners who’ve done little to no planning, his next-12-month playbook is straightforward: identify realistic future leaders, obtain an objective valuation, and start documenting how the business runs and why key decisions get made. In his view, succession isn’t just an exit plan — it’s a continuity and value-creation strategy for the entire organization.
Here’s a glimpse of what you’ll learn:
Succession planning protects the value of your brokerage; it’s not just about retirement.
Start planning three to five years out so you have time to develop leaders and clean up the business.
Naming a successor—especially a family member—isn’t a plan unless they’re prepared and supported.
If everything runs through the owner, the business is harder to transfer and usually worth less.
Agents fear uncertainty more than change, so clear, early communication is critical.
Clean financials and early legal prep prevent deals from falling apart.
M&A and strategic partnerships can be proactive succession tools, not just last-resort exits.
Documenting culture, processes, and decision-making helps transfer judgment, not just titles.
An objective valuation shows you what you’re really trying to protect and grow.
In the next 12 months, owners should identify future leaders, get valued, and start writing the plan down.
Related to this episode:
Tracey Velt’s LinkedIn
https://www.linkedin.com/in/traceyvelt/
Stephen Kowalchuk's LinkedIn
https://www.linkedin.com/in/stephen-kowalchuk/
Corporate Management Advisors
https://cmainc.com/
Want more from Tracey? Don’t forget to subscribe to Real Estate Daily.
The RealTrending podcast features conversations with the brightest minds in real estate. Every Monday, brokerage leaders, top agents, team leaders, and industry experts join us to share their secrets to success, trends, and the
Stephen breaks down what real succession planning is — and what it isn’t. It’s not just naming your son, daughter or a favorite manager as the heir apparent. It’s about building a deep leadership bench, creating an operating structure that doesn’t revolve around a single charismatic owner and giving yourself three to five years of runway.
Finally, Stephen gets tactical about protecting your agents, culture and valuation through transition. He also reframes M&A and strategic partnerships as proactive tools in a long-term succession strategy, not last-ditch exits.
For owners who’ve done little to no planning, his next-12-month playbook is straightforward: identify realistic future leaders, obtain an objective valuation, and start documenting how the business runs and why key decisions get made. In his view, succession isn’t just an exit plan — it’s a continuity and value-creation strategy for the entire organization.
Here’s a glimpse of what you’ll learn:
Succession planning protects the value of your brokerage; it’s not just about retirement.
Start planning three to five years out so you have time to develop leaders and clean up the business.
Naming a successor—especially a family member—isn’t a plan unless they’re prepared and supported.
If everything runs through the owner, the business is harder to transfer and usually worth less.
Agents fear uncertainty more than change, so clear, early communication is critical.
Clean financials and early legal prep prevent deals from falling apart.
M&A and strategic partnerships can be proactive succession tools, not just last-resort exits.
Documenting culture, processes, and decision-making helps transfer judgment, not just titles.
An objective valuation shows you what you’re really trying to protect and grow.
In the next 12 months, owners should identify future leaders, get valued, and start writing the plan down.
Related to this episode:
Tracey Velt’s LinkedIn
https://www.linkedin.com/in/traceyvelt/
Stephen Kowalchuk's LinkedIn
https://www.linkedin.com/in/stephen-kowalchuk/
Corporate Management Advisors
https://cmainc.com/
Want more from Tracey? Don’t forget to subscribe to Real Estate Daily.
The RealTrending podcast features conversations with the brightest minds in real estate. Every Monday, brokerage leaders, top agents, team leaders, and industry experts join us to share their secrets to success, trends, and the
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00If you're a broker owner or even a team leader, have you thought about your succession plan?
00:04If not, you should. You should be thinking of it now, no matter what is going on in your life.
00:11And today on the podcast, I have Steven Kowalczyk. He is an executive recruiter with CMA and the
00:16managing director of the firm as well. And he offers some really important insight into
00:21some of the best laid plans of succession planning, some mistakes that brokers are making,
00:28and then some tips on really finding the right person for that position. So enjoy the podcast.
00:45Steven, after all these years, you're finally on the podcast.
00:49Finally on the podcast. Good to see you.
00:52Just down the street on the podcast.
00:54Yeah, it's a nice local podcast. Two different buildings, but local podcast.
00:59That's right.
01:00And beaming nationally too, right?
01:02That's right. So we're going to talk all things succession planning for brokerage today. So
01:09why do you feel like succession planning is becoming even more urgent for real estate broker owners
01:16right now?
01:18So I think there are really three forces that are coming together at the same time. First
01:27is demographics. As you know, Tracy, many independent brokerage owners are in their late 50s or 60s or
01:36beyond. And we're entering the largest generational transfer of brokerage ownership I think that our
01:42industry has ever seen. Secondly, the market over the last several years, right? It's exposed something
01:52important. I think that what it's exposed is firms with deep leadership benches seem to have weathered
01:59the volatility much better than those that don't, unfortunately. So, and also, I think the ones
02:07where every major decision flew through one individual was extremely problematic and it highlighted
02:14that. And then last, but certainly not least, is this incredible consolidation, right? It's the larger
02:21regional firms, the national brands getting rolled up, private equity. They're all looking for
02:28opportunities. Everybody's looking for opportunities. And owners who haven't planned their succession,
02:35unfortunately, often become motivated sellers on someone else's timeline rather than their own.
02:41So I think that there's a number of different aspects out there. But one thing that I tell
02:46broker owners is this, is that succession planning isn't about retirement. And it's not, I'm going to die
02:54and this is why I need to do this. It's about protecting everything that you've spent the entirety of
03:00your career building. If you don't plan for it, something's going to happen to you on, unfortunately,
03:05on someone else's timeline. So I think those are probably some of the most important ones.
03:09Yeah, absolutely. I mean, there are a lot of market factors right now. And I know we've seen
03:14consolidation. We'll still see some more. There aren't a lot of more companies to be bought. I think
03:19a lot of regional acquisitions or roll-ins or where that will be happening. But like, what is,
03:27what is a timeline for planning? Like how far in advance of, you know, like your planned exit,
03:36do you think succession planning should start? Should it start at the very beginning of your
03:41brokerage operation? Should it start in the middle? Tell me what is an ideal timeline for that?
03:47Thank you. I think, Tracy, that, I mean, it varies from company to company, but
03:52it certainly can't be done at the last, you know, if you're like, oh, I'm going to do something in
03:56six months, it's, it's way too late. You're way down the river. I would generally say a good safe
04:03bet is three to five years, ideally five years. Think about it five years before you'll need it.
04:10Okay. Because then that allows you the time to actually plan strategically, right? It doesn't mean
04:15that you're leaving in five years. That's again, having a plan, having a plan and actually doing
04:21it are two totally different things, but having that plan, you've got, you have protection. It's
04:26like insurance, right? We live here in Florida. The hurricanes come, you don't have insurance.
04:30You're in big trouble. So again, it doesn't mean that you're leaving in five years. What it means
04:36is that you're giving yourself enough runway to develop leaders. That's, that's extremely important,
04:42right? It also gives you time to strengthen the business, clean up the financials, uh, transfer
04:49relationships. The, the best transitions that I've seen have at least one year of overlap, whereby
04:58the person in the role is handing off the baton to another. Um, you know, I mean, I joke with
05:06people
05:06who tell me, okay, I'm going to, I'm, I'm thinking about a succession plan in the next six months. It's
05:11like, okay, well, we need to have a private conversation. It's, it's beyond that. And so
05:17I think, you know, three to five, but the more time that you have to plan, the better off you
05:22are,
05:22because again, you don't have to enact the business succession plan just because you've started to think
05:27about it. And, and maybe it is closer to that three-year timeline, but you've started to think
05:32about very specific things and a very specific cadence and what it all means for the totality of the
05:39organization. Yeah. And I want to talk mistakes because I know from leading, um, some CEO groups,
05:45uh, from real trends that a lot of times when we're doing an office, um, analysis that we're
05:52analyzing whether the son or daughter or, you know, uncle or whatever it is, is the right person to lead
06:00the company. Um, and sometimes they just aren't. Um, but that it's really difficult to go to your
06:10kid or your family member and say, you know what, I don't think this is the role for you. Um,
06:18so
06:19that could be a possible mistake, but what are you, what do you see as some of the big mistakes
06:23that,
06:24that broker owners are, are making in their succession planning?
06:28That's a great question, Tracy. My number one is the biggest mistake. And I see everybody do
06:35this. Unfortunately, everybody making the mistake that assuming that you'll have time later, you
06:42won't, you won't. The best time to plan is now plan for the future. Now you don't plan for,
06:48I need it today. It's too late. It's too late. So the more time that you have, the better that
06:54that's
06:55number one, the second is believing that a succession plan simply means naming someone
07:01that doesn't cut it either. Right. I mean, naming a successor, isn't a succession plan.
07:09Um, and the third is building a company that's completely depending on an owner, right? If every
07:16important relationship, every recruiting effort, every difficult conversation runs through one single
07:22point of contact, that business probably isn't very transferable. So even more reason, if that's
07:29the situation where it's all running through one, that person needs five years. They do because they
07:35need to diversify. They need to establish a cadence and have different relationships because also a
07:42business that's dependent on one individual is much harder to transition. And often if you're getting
07:49acquired or selling at some point, it's worth a lot less. So those are, those are some of the big
07:55mistakes that I've, I've seen out there. Yeah. Especially if you have a very charismatic leader
08:00who, um, you know, and you're bringing in someone who may not be as charismatic, but might be better in
08:08a lot of other aspects. Um, so, so yeah, I can definitely see that as being an issue. Um, and,
08:15and where are you
08:16seeing kind of the warning signs that you waited too long? Let's say you did plan four years, five years
08:22and the person that you thought was going to be your successor really isn't, but what are some of the
08:30warning signs that, that people see? Yeah, that's a great question too. There's, there's some, there's
08:36usually some pretty obvious indicators like, um, your agents only call you that's problem. Uh, if
08:45nobody else is empowered to make decisions, major decisions, that's a problem. If your leadership has
08:53never run the company without you, that's a problem. And if you've never had your brokerage valued,
09:00that's a problem. Um, or if you honestly can't answer who would run the company, if you didn't
09:08show up tomorrow morning, that's a problem. I mean, that's a simple question to ask yourself when
09:14you go to bed, God forbid, I don't show up what's going to happen. Those are all signs that the
09:20business
09:20is more owner dependent than, than owner led. And, and, you know, I think those are all big problems as
09:28well. Well, I mean, that kind of is the same for a team, right? I mean, if you're running a
09:33team,
09:33um, you know, I know Steve Murray has valued teams before and some of them aren't worth anything
09:39because the, the CEO is the rainmaker and the name and, and everything. And if that person was gone,
09:46there really isn't anything. Um, so how do, you know, what, how can owners build that leadership team
09:53or operating structure that really allows the brokerage to succeed once they do step away?
10:00So I think about this in, in three areas. First, they've got to be able to distribute leadership
10:09responsibility instead of centralizing it. You know, a lot of people, they want to centralize
10:14things that facilitates it. Again, there's a single point of contact hub and spoke distribute it.
10:20Okay. Cream's going to rise to the top too. You're going to see how your leadership team
10:24reacts under stress and different situations. But to, to that point, number two is intentionally
10:31expose your future leaders to situations that they're going to eventually own and find themselves
10:37in. So put them in the middle that, even if they're in a completely different role, stick them
10:42in the middle of an agent recruiting thing, put them in the middle of financial reviews, put them in
10:48the middle of difficult personnel issues, put them in the middle of strategic planning. This will give
10:53you a great vantage point, a, how they react and B, whether or not they're capable, right? You're going
11:00to see them in real world situations. And because succession planning is based on people can also morph
11:07predicated on who the people are and what their strengths and what their weaknesses are. Sometimes a
11:12succession plan doesn't just lead with one leader. Sometimes it's a bifurcated role. Sometimes it's a
11:19triumvirate, right? Janie is fantastic at this aspect and, and John is wonderful at this and Susan is
11:27wonderful at that. Well, and it's not all in one and they're each tremendous assets. So you, you put it
11:32together. But last but not least, the third component is document your culture, right? Because culture can't live
11:40just in the founder's head. So future leaders really need to understand what decisions you make, but not just what
11:47decisions you make, why you're making them, right? And that the why is really, really important. And succession is
11:55really about transferring judgment, not just transferring the title.
12:00Yeah. And so in your position, when you're looking to place someone with a brokerage, tell me what that looks
12:07like as far as
12:09matching the right person to the right company. Um, is it a pretty extensive process or, um, you know, what,
12:17what, how do you, how do you do that so that you know that you're recommending the right person?
12:23That's a, that's a great question too. Often look on paper, somebody could look tremendous, right? Cause we'll go through
12:32an analysis at the beginning. Okay. What is, what are the functionalities? What is the responsibilities?
12:37What are you looking for relative to, so your once wishes aspirations relative to the role and what you want
12:43to see in the person? So we could find somebody that matches that up incredibly. And every single point is
12:50hit. Okay.
12:50Okay. But if it's a cultural misalignment, it's an abject failure. It is going to fail. And so from my
12:58perspective, first and foremost, you have to have the criteria of what the, the, what we're looking for them to
13:03accomplish, the requirements, et cetera, et cetera.
13:07But it's also knowing the people because Tracy, you know, this just as well, as well, in the sense that
13:13we go to work for people, we don't go to work for companies. And so it's like a marriage or
13:19a relationship, a business transaction. It's it, they are all akin in that if the, if the, if it's a
13:26cultural fit, you will have a success.
13:28And so it's really important for me when I'm representing a client to understand how my client's thinking and what
13:36is important to them. Again, their once wishes aspirations and the way that they communicate and what they talk about
13:42helps me help them because then I can internalize that.
13:46And when I'm interviewing somebody, I'm taking into account all of these different things. If you've got a really, uh,
13:53forward facing leader, who's extremely personable. And now I've got this candidate on the other end, who's extremely reserved and
14:00closed. I know that's not going to work. Or you flip the scenarios around. That's not going to work. Having
14:07said that, having compliments of one another, where maybe somebody might have, and I don't mean this in a negative
14:15term,
14:15a deficiency, a deficiency, if you will. So somebody is, is elevated at doing this. And this person has a
14:21little bit of a deficiency. You can compliment one another as well. But I, I would say a cultural fit
14:27Tracy is, is the paramount aspect of that.
14:30Yeah. And it helps that you've, you know, your firm has been doing this for so long that, you know,
14:34a lot of the players in the industry that helps you really, you know, them trying to explain their culture
14:39sometimes isn't the same as, is you knowing the person and seeing it play, play out. Right.
14:45Exactly. Exactly. Exactly. I mean, I've, we've known each other in this industry. I was, I was commenting to somebody
14:52early for a couple of decades. It's gone by pretty darn quick. Tracy, the, the relationships, especially in this industry,
15:00having it, while it's a large industry, there's a quarter degree of separation between us, but you learn a lot
15:09from the market.
15:11And the perception of who you are in addition to who you are. And then, you know, just getting in
15:17there and learning about it. It's, it's, we, we do have a good insight into that. But at the end
15:22of the day, those two are fluid and those changes as well. So we have to stay up with it
15:28and stay, you know, maintain our rapport, maintain our relationship with these organizations to ensure that, you know, we're still
15:35mindful of what that looks like today.
15:38Because the last decade, things have changed really dramatically. And I would even say cultures have changed in companies, you
15:45know, so companies, I don't take for granted that it's status quo. So I always want to re-engage them
15:51to ascertain, you know, is this still, is this still contemporary? And is this still a proper, a proper description
15:59of who you are and who you want to be?
16:01Yeah. Well, and for the audience listening, Stephen has great travel tips, because he's been everywhere. So if you need
16:08a travel tip, just reach out to him.
16:10I do have lots of good travel tips.
16:13You do.
16:14I often get sidetracked in a conversation. Someone talks about travel, I'm, I'm deviating quickly. And we'll have a long
16:20conversation about that, too.
16:22But we'll come back to the point as well.
16:25Oh, that's right. Oh, so what financial, operational, legal issues tend to derail succession plans once negotiations are underway?
16:40The financials are probably the biggest issue, right? Because many broker owners, I mean, they have expenses that are running
16:49through the business. It's their business. They run things through. And that, so, you know, buyers and successors, they want
16:56businesses that operate independently. They want clean books.
17:01I would say, you know, legally, too. I see owners waiting too long to establish buy-sell agreements, ownership transfer
17:10provisions, or estate planning documents. And perhaps the biggest surprise is agent retention, right?
17:17If a buyer believes the top producers are likely to leave right after the founder exits, there's very little value
17:24to that brokerage.
17:25And that brokerage valuation changes very quickly and very dramatically.
17:31So I think that, you know, having a command of, well, no one can command agents. They're independent, right?
17:40But having an understanding, I should say, is a better term. And having open, clear communication is paramount, because that
17:49way you have the ability to pivot on a dime versus being reactive. You're being proactive. So I think those
17:55are a few of them.
17:56Yeah. And that was kind of my next question was just kind of how do you retain key agents and
18:03key leadership during this type of transition? Other than transparency, are there any other things that owners can be thinking
18:12about?
18:12Yeah, I think to your point, transparency, of course. But communication is everything, Tracy. In my experience, agents don't fear
18:20change. Okay? They don't. What they fear is uncertainty. That's what they fear, right?
18:26So when I'm talking to broker owners out there or leaders, I remind them that agents follow leaders. They don't
18:36follow logos. They're not going for a logo. And again, we go back to people work for people, right?
18:41So if your top producers hear about a transition through the rumor mill instead of from you, that's a big
18:50problem. You've already lost control of the narrative. There's nothing that you can do to get back into the mix.
18:55A, they're going to be disappointed that you didn't talk to them directly. You weren't transparent, right? You didn't communicate
19:01about this. So the communication plan should answer three questions immediately. Will my business be supported?
19:10Will anything important change? And do I trust the people taking over? Those are the things that they want to
19:16know. Okay? So when those questions are answered early, retention becomes much less of an issue. But look, I mean,
19:24retention is always an issue when you're going to change something. But I think transparency and communication mitigate that significantly.
19:31And in what role does, you know, should mergers, acquisition strategic partnerships play in kind of the long-term succession
19:40strategy?
19:43I think that a lot of times, Tracy, if owners think of M&A as a last resort, in reality,
19:52it can be one of several strategic succession options, right?
19:56A merger may provide scale. An acquisition may provide liquidity. But a strategic partnership, that could allow something different. That
20:05can allow an owner to gradually step back while preserving the culture.
20:09You've got a clear handoff of a baton, right? And so I think that in these conversations, it's important to
20:21have them early on, not after when the owner is facing a crisis, they're getting ready to exit. Again, planning
20:29gives you the option. Waiting, it limits them. It not only limits them, it mitigates them.
20:36So, again, having that plan in place, that five years, even if you don't need to use it, it's good
20:42to have it. You got it in your back pocket. So when you do, you can dust it off. And
20:46then when it's time, you enact it. But you got to plan.
20:49Yeah. So this is my last question is, just for those listening who maybe have done little to no succession
20:56planning, what should they be doing in the next 12 months?
21:02So I'd keep it simple. Especially if they're looking in the next 12 months, I'd keep it simple. First, identify
21:08who could realistically lead the organization in the future, even if you're not ready to announce anything.
21:14Okay. Do that. That's first. Second, get an objective valuation of your brokerage. Call Steve Murray. You know, you can't
21:24protect what you don't understand.
21:25And third, start documenting your business, your leadership philosophy, your operating processes, your key relationships, your communication plan. Document everything.
21:37Because you don't need a perfect succession plan next year. You just need a documented plan that's better than having
21:46no plan at all.
21:47Because, look, a succession plan isn't just an exit strategy, in my opinion. It's a business continuity strategy, a value
21:56creation strategy, and ultimately an agent retention strategy.
22:00I mean, think about it. If we lose power, generally speaking, so the Internet, whatever it is, we have all
22:06of these contingency plans.
22:07It shocks me many times that something as important as this doesn't get covered. So I go back to have
22:14a plan.
22:15Yeah, yeah. I mean, it is. It's true. I guess you just figure things will work out, right? A lot
22:22of people are running on that. Things will just work out.
22:24And I've got time. Time is never on our side. I used to be the young guy in the room.
22:29I'm still not the old guy in the room in the industry, which is crazy.
22:35But everybody thinks we've got time. And time is finite. And before we know it, it's here.
22:42So, you know, planning is the key to success for continuity and the key to success for succession, in my
22:50humble opinion.
22:51Great. Well, Stephen, thanks so much for joining Real Trending. This has been a great conversation.
22:55I think that our listeners will get a lot out of it. So thanks so much.
22:59Well, thank you, Tracy. I appreciate you having me on. Very much so.