Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 1 hour ago
On today’s episode, Editor in Chief Sarah Wheeler talks with Lead Analyst Logan Mohtashami about the Federal Reserve, inflation and mortgage rates.

Related to this episode:

Today's Mortgage Rates
https://www.housingwire.com/mortgage-rates/
HousingWire | YouTube⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCXDD_3y3LvU60vac7eki-6Q
More info about HousingWire
https://lnk.bio/housingwire

Top 5 Trending:

Compass sues 15 MLSs over office exclusive rules
https://www.housingwire.com/articles/compass-15-mls-lawsuits/
Take Care of America’s Veterans Act advances with VA mortgage fee hikes
https://www.housingwire.com/articles/house-bill-veterans-act-va-refi-fees/
Builders are looking for a bottom. 2027 plans can’t wait that long
https://www.housingwire.com/articles/resale-rental-competition-builders/
California cities get firm notice: follow new housing laws, or else
https://www.housingwire.com/articles/calhdf-pre-vote-letters/
Reverse mortgage executives read the tea leaves to decipher the industry’s next chapter
https://www.housingwire.com/articles/reverse-forward-lo-distribution/

Want more from Sarah? Don’t forget to subscribe!
https://www.housingwire.com/subscribe/

The HousingWire Daily podcast brings the full picture of the most compelling stories in the housing market reported across HousingWire. Each morning, listen to editor in chief Sarah Wheeler talk to leading industry voices and get a deeper look behind the scenes of the top mortgage and real estate.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Welcome, everyone. I'm joined today by lead analyst Logan Motoshami to talk about inflation, the Federal Reserve, and mortgage rates.
00:07Before we dive in, here are the top five trending stories on HousingWire.com.
00:11First, we have Compass sues 15 MLSs over office-exclusive rules, followed by Veterans Act advances with VA mortgage fee
00:20hikes.
00:20Then we have Builders are looking for a bottom, but 2027 plans can't wait that long.
00:25And, California cities get firm notice, follow new housing laws or else.
00:31Finally, we have Reverse Mortgage Executives read the tea leaves to decipher industry's next chapter.
00:50Logan, welcome back to the podcast.
00:51It is wonderful to be here, and so far, we're still surviving Friday the 13th of this morning.
01:01We had hawkish-fed presidents.
01:04We had no kind of discussion of the conflict ending anytime soon.
01:11The PPI report was, even though it missed estimates, it was still hot, but the bond market for what it's
01:19worth is somewhat tame today.
01:23Core Weave stock price is down 10% in the morning, and NVIDIA stock was down.
01:30So, it was a crazy week, but I thought for the Federal Reserve, they kind of got what they wanted.
01:36They wanted to maintain that hawkish kind of stance, even with the market selling off on those AI stocks.
01:46I thought they achieved what they wanted to do this week.
01:49Let's talk about the PPI inflation report and how it amplified or differed from the CPI inflation.
01:56Like, what's the overall inflation picture now that we are done with the inflation week?
02:01So, CPI inflation has a very, very heavy shelter rents, and it does look like the disinflation in rents are
02:10winding down, and that might stabilize.
02:13I don't see the ability for it to re-accelerate higher, but the advantage you had on that is gone.
02:21Now, the PPI inflation, you know, the core goods, it's much different than CPI.
02:26That really filters itself into the PCE inflation, personal consumption expenditures, which is what the Fed really tracks.
02:34And that, after today's report, it looks like we're still going to have above 3% PCE year-over-year
02:41inflation.
02:42And, you know, I know some people go, well, 3% or 2%, it's not.
02:46No, for the Federal Reserve, it matters as their 2% target.
02:49So, of course, it's not the 6% to 8% inflation that we saw during COVID.
02:54But Austin Goolsbee, I thought, said it well on TV.
02:59We're getting inflation in places that aren't tied to energy, but also the energy diesel impact is starting to go
03:07into food.
03:08And I think that's the one thing we talked about many, many months ago, that diesel has the ability, if
03:13it stays elevated, because transportation and harvest and everything goes on that, the cost of food can go up.
03:21And the conflict is not over.
03:23And the trade war.
03:25Apparently, we're going to do 100% tariffs on Mexico.
03:27So, these things are keeping the Federal Reserve, I thought, as a team, they did a good job of, we're
03:33still hiking.
03:34And, you know, it's most likely going to be two more rate hikes, and then we'll see where it's at.
03:41But you've got a clock now on the Fed.
03:45And if they don't see any more improvements, then that 10-year yield can go above 5.35%.
03:52And the term premium can go higher, and real rates can go up in that regard.
03:59But definitely, I thought, a week that the Federal Reserve felt comfortable with.
04:05Well, let's talk about the 10-year yield and the critical level that it has touched several times and come
04:12back down from that 5.35%.
04:14Where are we compared to that right now?
04:17We are at another key level, not as important as that.
04:21But you really don't want to see the 10-year yield close above 5.15%.
04:25I mean, we'll see what happens on Friday.
04:27This is why I said, let's wait until Friday close after the PPI inflation reports and see where the 10
04:34-year yield is.
04:35So, we've had a very, very vicious move from 4.82% to 5.16% last time I checked.
04:42If it gets above there, it looks like we're going to go test that level again.
04:46So, again, you need resolution on two things that you have somewhat of the ability to control.
04:54And then when you come out and talk about 100% tariffs, you know, these things in this environment are
05:04not useful anymore.
05:07So, I know when Congress comes in on January 3rd, you know, people say that Congress can't really do too
05:13much because they don't have a veto proof.
05:17Who knows what the Republicans will think at that point, but there are things that Congress can do to go
05:26after the conflict and go after the trade war as well.
05:30So, it doesn't necessarily have to be veto proof either.
05:36But there's a clock here.
05:38And the Federal Reserve is, I thought, this week made sure that even with the AI stocks selling off, they
05:45still held firm to their belief.
05:48I think, you know, we thought about like, okay, after the midterms, we will know some other things, right?
05:53Of course, nobody really anticipated the extent of the blue wave that actually ended up happening.
05:57But I think we do know a couple of things.
06:00And one of those things is that President Trump is not changing his stance on some of the things that
06:05maybe he could, right?
06:07Because we were like, okay, well, we might get more of a resolution with the Iran conflict or more of
06:13a desire for a peace deal or something after the midterms.
06:16And that's not happened.
06:17I think that's the most surprising thing to me.
06:20Well, I mean, Trump's got his own clock until the Democrats get in power.
06:27I mean, he did talk about there's going to be a deal after the midterms.
06:30I mean, I don't think anybody takes a lot of things he says seriously off the cuff.
06:34But you can't have both at the same time.
06:40Now, of course, oil prices are lower than what they used to be.
06:45And if oil could trade just between 67 and 82, that's an acceptable level to keep inflation.
06:52But you need oil and diesel to come down and you can't accelerate the trade war in that regards.
06:58And who knows what happens with the AI companies at this point.
07:01But again, there's a lot of spending and things that are in place.
07:04And this is not like this technology is going away anytime soon.
07:08But the Federal Reserve has really harped on that being the data centers being a very, very overheated portion of
07:17the economy.
07:17You can see that with construction workers and the spending that goes into non-residential.
07:24It's literally off the charts when you look at it, when you compare them both.
07:29I think since the last time we talked, which has only been – it's been less than 24 hours because
07:34we did a late one yesterday.
07:35There have been more revelations about the NVIDIA CEO, right?
07:39So – and he resigned and –
07:43Yeah, that really doesn't have a big impact because he's just one guy.
07:49Anyway, to me, core weave – oddly enough, core weave stock really matters.
07:57Now, you could say that NVIDIA is going to have less growth because whatever they're going to do with China.
08:03But when you have debt issuant problems, that means that rates, wherever they are, the market can change.
08:12And that has more of a bigger impact than what happens with the former CEO of NVIDIA because NVIDIA is
08:20this unbelievable powerhouse in the AI thing.
08:24They're simply too big for it to really matter.
08:27But when the smaller ones have problems, there's where you start to think, is the growth going to be impacted?
08:33Because you are going to get moratoriums on data centers going out.
08:37But does that mean they go build in other places?
08:41Do they build their energy in other areas?
08:46Time will tell on that.
08:48But it's been interesting with AI because it's just – to me, it was just the god king could bleed.
08:55You know, and for a while there, a lot of people – and Kevin Warsh even brought this up,
09:01that he doesn't believe the theory that there's nothing you could do to slow down AI.
09:05That, you know, there are things that could slow them down.
09:09Of course, some of them are going to be done by Congress, and some of them are going to be
09:13done by the markets.
09:14Okay, so we're coming up on the weekend.
09:16One of our favorite times because we get the data for the week, and you write the tracker.
09:21So what are you going to be looking for this weekend?
09:24Just if there is some stabilization continuation in the data line.
09:30You know, one of the reasons why we created the tracker was for everybody to understand the supply and demand
09:36equilibrium live months ahead of the existing home sales report.
09:41So if you go back to when rates started to escalate, you can see for the first time this year,
09:46weekly pending sales, which were positive most of the year, flat while rates were getting elevated.
09:51But when rates went up to 760, you saw a noticeable deviation.
09:56And also the year-over-year comps are much difficult because last year, mortgage rates were heading towards 6%.
10:03But over the last three years and 11 months, you get to see the, you know, when demand just stabilizes,
10:09our weekly pending sales data stabilizes.
10:11If our demand starts to grow, our forward-looking weekly pending sales grows.
10:16So I would say we've just stabilized.
10:19I know the purchase application data had a big week-to-week positive print.
10:24But I just think of it as stabilization and now rates have elevated.
10:28So I want to see, does this change anything?
10:30Because we are toward the end of the year and the seasonality of all of our data lines are going
10:36down just because activity goes down.
10:40And Thanksgiving's coming up, so that's shot.
10:43And then Christmas and New Year's comes, that's shot.
10:45And then you prep yourself up for what happens in January, February, and March.
10:52Yeah, kind of tough timing, right?
10:53The last couple of years, we've seen like, oh, okay, this is when rates go down a little bit.
10:58Then we get a little bit of a pickup at the end of the year.
11:01That doesn't seem like that's going to happen this year.
11:02It isn't.
11:04And it doesn't also look good for my price forecast also.
11:09I, you know, even with this last report, home prices were up year over year, barely.
11:14You know, I'm anticipating a slowdown.
11:16But for my price forecast to be right, I need more negative data.
11:23I'm not off by a lot, but when you go into a year with a negative forecast, you have to
11:28create, why is this going to occur?
11:31To me, it's just affordability and inventory was going to pick up just a smidge.
11:37So then you just work off the softening of pricing from last year.
11:41But rates stayed lower early on, longer, and demand picked up.
11:45So now you get to see it, but even if I get the forecast 100% correct, it was wrong
11:51because I needed mortgage rates to get up to 7.6.
11:54And it would be a very slight decline.
11:56But I think there was a lot of questions that, you know, prices were up year over year and prices
12:02are at all time.
12:03I said, guys, this isn't that market.
12:05I think you're thinking something else, you know.
12:09Wait, explain that.
12:10What do you mean this isn't that market?
12:11Well, when people say home sales are at the lowest level, lower than the monthly print at least, well, they
12:19go, well, shouldn't prices be falling in the same fashion?
12:23And I go, look at the inventory back then.
12:27There was a lot more.
12:28Not only there was a lot more inventory, distressed sales as a percentage of sales were much higher than normal.
12:33So that's like one of the biggest things about why it's very difficult to have nominal national home price.
12:39Like we don't have that in the data unless you have this.
12:43You could have them in local states or certain cities.
12:47But on the national side, you just don't have that type of marketplace.
12:51But, you know, I was anticipating a little bit weaker.
12:54And we'll see what happens by the time the Case-Shiller Index takes this data.
12:58It's going to be many, many months out.
12:59But it's still roughly close to the forecast.
13:03And I always say that every year that wages are outpacing home prices is a positive in my mind.
13:09Unlike 2023, where 2023 we had record low level sales, mortgage rates went up to 8 percent, and home prices
13:17were up 6 percent.
13:18That was not a good healthy outcome.
13:20Here, you know, prices are up barely.
13:23Wages out.
13:24You're creating a better base for the future.
13:28And if you look at the history of existing home sales and prices and everything, this has actually happened before.
13:35This is more common than what happened in 2007 to 11.
13:40I think that one of the points that you always bring up is the fact that, like you just mentioned,
13:44distressed sellers.
13:45People who are homeowners right now, they do not need to sell.
13:49They're, generally speaking, in very good shape.
13:51They've got lots of equity.
13:53Many of them have really good mortgage terms.
13:56And I think that's part of this discussion on, like, why haven't home prices fallen more?
14:00It's like people don't have to sell.
14:02Now, people do sell.
14:03A certain number of people do want to move and sell every year.
14:07But people are staying in their homes longer.
14:09There's no distress coming that's going to force people to sell that we can see.
14:13So it's like inventory is just always going to keep it at a certain level.
14:18You know, one of the things I always highlight is that we've had 13 recessions since 1942.
14:24And we only had one foreclosure crisis of scale, right?
14:29And a lot of it is that there's always, like, 1% to 4% of mortgages in distress.
14:34That's very common.
14:36It's when it deviates and sales are falling or not growing and you get a higher percentage.
14:44That's why we always like to focus on our new listings data because those are not going to be sellers.
14:50I think one of the biggest things that a lot of doomers don't understand is the new listings data because,
14:56to be honest, they're not trained analysts.
14:58So they wouldn't even understand what it means.
15:01They keep on saying that doesn't mean anything.
15:03That's not true.
15:03During the housing bubble crash years, new listings data was running at $250,000 to $400,000 per week.
15:09It's the last week was, I know, I compared it.
15:12You know, last week was like $54,000, but it was like $350,000 in 2010.
15:18Those were sellers that were not going to be buyers.
15:21So that's what I said.
15:22When the new listings data breaks out, that's a negative sign because it's not like this is a surge of
15:28demand that's coming, right?
15:29And we've had data going up to 5 million existing home sales by itself, and usually it's 80,000 to
15:35100,000 per week.
15:36And we're getting closer to normal, but nothing in that matter.
15:40So hopefully that makes sense.
15:42But I just think I don't have enough time for my forecast to be correct.
15:47And again, 2024, the forecast was for 2.33% growth.
15:51We ended up at 4.
15:52Rates going lower toward the end of that period gave home prices a little bit of kick.
15:58Last year was 1.77%.
16:00We ended up at 1.3%, so that roughly looks right.
16:03But here, a lot of the home price indexes were about 1% to 2% roughly on a year
16:09-over-year basis, case-child and all.
16:10I know some of the data had 2.4%, but that's where we're going to look like it's going to
16:13end.
16:14But to me, a positive.
16:15If wages were running underneath that, no benefit, but that's not the case.
16:20You know, I wasn't at Housing Mar until 2013, so I wasn't covering housing.
16:25But I was, of course, living through the foreclosure crisis.
16:29And what I could tell, you know, in my neighborhood, which was a pretty new neighborhood around the time of
16:352008,
16:36is just the number of people who were having to give up their homes and, like, boarded up homes.
16:41That's what happened.
16:42But I think that stat that you say, every time I read it in the tracker, it just shocks me.
16:48Because, like you said, like right now, new listings, $55,000 around that per week.
16:53You know, per week.
16:54And back then, $258,000 to $400,000 every single week for years.
17:01Like, that's just wild.
17:02I mean, the big part is we had a major credit boom from 2002 to 2005.
17:08And we never had that.
17:09In fact, one of the charts I like to show people on X, because I think traders and Wall Street
17:14understands it.
17:14I'll take the mortgage purchase application data.
17:16I'll draw a line from 2002 all the way to 2005.
17:20And then I'll take the peak level of COVID, which had 3% mortgage rates.
17:26And I'll just draw a line all the way.
17:28We never even got to the starting level of 2002 in 16 years.
17:34All right.
17:34So, we had 3.25 to 4.75 mortgage rates for 10 years in the last decade.
17:39We never had a sales or credit boom back then.
17:43And here, during COVID, we never even got there.
17:45So, it's the amount of supply of debt coming into the system was never that.
17:50But it's also, there was no toxic loans into the system as well.
17:54So, pretty much, you have, it's like a very normal housing cycle in that regard.
17:58So, you have to wait for a job loss recession or something like that to change the curve where then
18:05it takes a long, then it takes like 9 to 18 months from that.
18:08So, you're looking at, you know, 2029 in that.
18:13And that's a very long, slow, and it's a very boring process.
18:17So, it's better to keep on saying 30, 60, 90-day late, HELOCs, credit cards in it, and then we're
18:22sitting here November of 22, November of 2026.
18:27We've been dealing with that since, you know, 2020, since the forbearance crash bros of 2020.
18:33It's been six years.
18:34And, again, one thing that I could see is these are not trained analysts.
18:37They have no forecast.
18:39They have no working models.
18:40And they're never, they never talk about what's wrong.
18:43They just keep on harping on the same things over here.
18:46So, you have to teach people this.
18:48I think we never had a credit boom, credit bust.
18:50So, naturally, here we are heading toward Thanksgiving.
18:53Nothing happened, right?
18:55And when it happens, we'll be able to see it in our data line.
18:58Friday night, I'll be able to see it.
19:00I'll be the first person to go, okay, we've broken out of this.
19:03But until then, chill.
19:08Chill and keep your fingers crossed that some of these variables that are in our control,
19:13the Iran conflict, the trade point 2.0, that we get some sanity in both of those things,
19:19which would benefit housing greatly.
19:23It doesn't take much.
19:25Like, if I needed 3% to 4% or 5% mortgage rates to grow sales, we are having
19:30a different,
19:31totally different conversation.
19:34But the last three years and 11 months, 6.64 and under, hedge worth 6, demand gross.
19:38Right?
19:39Above 6.4.
19:40Now, over time, you don't need that lower rate to grow sales because wages are outpacing home.
19:46But for now, you just stick with the data that's proven.
19:49So, it isn't something out of the realm, but it does need work.
19:54And hopefully, by now, everyone can understand why I don't forecast below 5.75% mortgage rates.
20:00Because unless you have a recession, rates don't really belong in there.
20:04Only time we ever get near 6% is when there's a growth scare and every time it reverses here.
20:11Here, we have a very unique situation.
20:13We created another rate-height cycle, and we're figuring out where they're going to hold and stop at that point.
20:21Amazing.
20:22Okay.
20:22Well, we are going into the weekend.
20:24What do we always say?
20:25No telling what's going to happen between now and the next podcast.
20:28Hopefully, only good things for housing.
20:30Logan, thank you so much.
20:32Pleasure, Sarah.
Comments

Recommended