- 3 months ago
We all make mistakes, it's true. I once bit into a bar of baker's chocolate, nobody's perfect. Even if their hair implies otherwise. Talking about you and your perfectly slicked back head, Pat Riley.
Because even the multi-champion coach makes mistakes-- one so bad it cost the New York Knicks the title.
Game 7 of the 1994 NBA Finals, John Starks was ice-cold. He went 2-for-18! And Riley never took him out of the game! The coach had fresh shooters on the bench! What was he thinking?! We may never know, but we gotta try to figure it out.
Written and Produced by: Clara Morris
Directed and Edited by: Jiazhen Zhang
Subscribe: http://goo.gl/Nbabae
Join us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/secretbase
Follow us on Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/secretbase.bsky.social
Follow us on Tiktok: https://www.tiktok.com/@secretbasesbn?
Check out our full video catalog: http://goo.gl/9pMHRV
Visit our playlists: http://goo.gl/NvpZFF
Explore SB Nation: http://www.sbnation.com
Because even the multi-champion coach makes mistakes-- one so bad it cost the New York Knicks the title.
Game 7 of the 1994 NBA Finals, John Starks was ice-cold. He went 2-for-18! And Riley never took him out of the game! The coach had fresh shooters on the bench! What was he thinking?! We may never know, but we gotta try to figure it out.
Written and Produced by: Clara Morris
Directed and Edited by: Jiazhen Zhang
Subscribe: http://goo.gl/Nbabae
Join us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/secretbase
Follow us on Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/secretbase.bsky.social
Follow us on Tiktok: https://www.tiktok.com/@secretbasesbn?
Check out our full video catalog: http://goo.gl/9pMHRV
Visit our playlists: http://goo.gl/NvpZFF
Explore SB Nation: http://www.sbnation.com
Category
🥇
SportsTranscript
00:00Pat? Uh, Mr. O'Reilly?
00:03Uh, John Starks is still on the floor.
00:06I don't think he heard you call him out.
00:09Oh, you didn't.
00:10On purpose.
00:13Huh.
00:14Pat Riley's decision cost the Knicks a championship.
00:18It was a big deal.
00:22While I have you, gonna plug the Patreon real quick.
00:25We're giving you new cool stuff every week.
00:27I'd like to see Santa pull that off.
00:31Pat Riley was a good coach.
00:33I'm not the first person to say it.
00:35And he was very good for the Knicks.
00:37He came on in 91 and took over a stagnant playoff team,
00:41failing to capitalize on Patrick Ewing before he got too old.
00:44And three years later, they were in the finals.
00:48So yeah, good coach.
00:50He transformed the Knicks into a bruising, hustling,
00:53work-harder, foul-harder, blue-collar team.
00:56They were defensive specialists operating under a
00:59no-layups-allowed rule, aka smash him.
01:03Another thing Riley did to bring the Knicks success,
01:05he elevated this guy.
01:08Before Riley took over, John Starks was a fringe player
01:11who many thought should be cut.
01:13But the coach liked how hard John Starks played,
01:16and he knew how to bring the guards' talents to the forefront,
01:20minutes and freedom with the ball.
01:22It was risky.
01:24Starks had obvious limitations.
01:26In particular, he was a streaky shooter.
01:28But hey, that just meant he could get hot quick,
01:31hit one, and go on a streak.
01:33Riley took the risk.
01:35In 92, Starks saw increased minutes.
01:38In 93, he was a starter, the second leading scorer,
01:41and legitimately challenged Michael Jordan
01:43in the Eastern Conference Finals.
01:44In 94, our year in question, he was an all-star
01:48and the beating heart of the Eastern Conference champion Knicks.
01:52Accordingly, he stepped up in these finals
01:54when Patrick Ewing, New York's first leading scorer,
01:57struggled to produce against Houston's all-star center,
02:00Hakeem Olajuwon.
02:01I mean, okay, game one wasn't Stark's best,
02:04but his uncle had just passed away,
02:06and games two through six were incredible.
02:10He was Mr. Fourth Quarter.
02:12I'm talking about games two through six, remember?
02:14He nearly won the title with a buzzer beater in game six,
02:18but Olajuwon got a piece.
02:20However, we are now talking about game seven.
02:23And in game seven, Pat Riley was faced with a problem.
02:28Mr. Fourth Quarter was ice cold,
02:31displaying the unfortunate side of being a streaky shooter.
02:35With six minutes left and the Knicks down five,
02:39Starks bricked two good looks in a row,
02:41or three good looks in a row.
02:43That last one giving Houston an easy transition bucket,
02:46a seven-point lead, and momentum.
02:49Meanwhile, look at Stark's face.
02:52He looks like someone who needs to come out of the game.
02:56The other team was wondering why he was still in.
02:59Everyone at home was wondering why he was still in.
03:02So why was he still in?
03:06What was Pat Riley thinking?
03:09Let's try to find out.
03:11My first hypothesis, Pat believed in blind loyalty to his guys.
03:16Riley has written about choking in a book, very official.
03:20And he seems to think that the antidote to choking
03:23is screeching loud confidence that drowns out any possible doubts
03:27your brain might try to think up.
03:28And if we look to Riley's past,
03:31his philosophies seem to be stick to your guys in a shooting slump.
03:35He said this of James Worthy's shooting dip in the 86 Western Conference Finals.
03:40And that's how he'd coached John Starks thus far.
03:44In those early days when he decided he wanted to give Starks more minutes,
03:47he accepted that sometimes the streaky shooter would lose the game.
03:51He called him feast or famine,
03:53and thought the feast was worth the occasional famine.
03:57Probably didn't think the famine would come during Game 7 of the NBA Finals,
04:01but here we are.
04:02And although I'm the one who proposed this hypothesis,
04:05I don't really think it's correct.
04:07Riley might really like blind confidence,
04:10but he's adaptable like a good coach should be.
04:14Earlier in the 94 season, he switched up his starting backcourt,
04:17including moving Starks to the bench,
04:19because his team was in a funk.
04:21And by the way, it worked.
04:23So the guy's not impossibly rigid as a rule.
04:26And Riley isn't blindly going with Starks.
04:29There are reasons to stick with him.
04:31Mainly games 4, 5, and 6.
04:33Which brings me to my second hypothesis.
04:36Riley is loyal to his guys with his eyes wide, wide open,
04:41seeing clearly not blind at all.
04:43There's that good part of being a streaky shooter.
04:46One shot can be the domino to becoming Mr. Fourth Quarter.
04:49We saw it in games 4, 5, and 6.
04:52In the years since losing the title, Riley has defended himself,
04:56saying at the time, he felt Starks was on the verge of knocking down that first domino.
05:01And come on, Starks almost single-handedly won game 6.
05:04That's a guy to stick with.
05:06And look, on a zoomed-out scale,
05:08sticking with Starks worked this very series.
05:11He had one bad game, Riley didn't bench him,
05:15and then he had good games 2 through 6.
05:18The kid can bounce back.
05:20Devil's Advocates slash Angry Knicks fans might say
05:23it's hard to compare game-to-game recovery
05:25with the pressure of recovering during a Game 7.
05:28And also, why didn't Riley rest him at least a few minutes?
05:33He did that in Game 1.
05:35Let's look to hypothesis number 3.
05:38Riley didn't have good options to sub in for John Starks.
05:42Doc Rivers would have been good, but Riley literally didn't have him.
05:46Rivers was still injured when Riley had to freeze his playoff roster,
05:50so Rivers was left off.
05:52Even though by the time the finals rolled around, he was healthy.
05:56Bummer.
05:57Well, how about Hubert Davis?
06:00The second-year guard had started in place of Starks in the regular season
06:04when the team needed that refresh,
06:06and when Starks was injured.
06:08Oh, did I mention that those great playoff performances
06:11were not long after a knee injury?
06:13The kid's got heart.
06:15Is that why Pat Riley left him in?
06:18Back to Davis.
06:19He shot really well in the regular season.
06:22And he hit clutch free throws to win Game 5 in the Chicago series,
06:26so why not get him in this Game 7?
06:30Well, his shooting percentage dipped in the playoffs,
06:33and also he made a mistake that made Riley turn his back on him
06:37for the rest of the year.
06:39Even with his scoring dipping, Davis still got big minutes until...
06:44Game 4.
06:45Eastern Conference Finals against Indiana.
06:486.8 seconds left.
06:49Pacers up 6.
06:51Hubie lets a pass through his fingers.
06:53Season over for Davis.
06:54Blind or not, Davis earned no sort of loyalty from Riley.
06:59In Game 7, while the commentators are marveling at Pat leaving Starks out there,
07:04they mention that Davis had lost the coach's trust.
07:07So, who else was around?
07:10Rolando Blackman.
07:11This is who teammates, critics, fans, analysts, and at this point, even Pat Riley himself think
07:18should have gone in the game for John Starks.
07:21The Knicks traded for Blackman in the summer of 92.
07:23He had had a great career with the Mavericks before that,
07:27and he was best known as a shooter.
07:29Upon his acquisition, Riley himself said Blackman could deliver relief jumpers on command.
07:38Blackman didn't end up getting huge minutes on the Knicks.
07:41He was more of a finesse player and less of a bruiser, and Riley preferred Rivers and Davis.
07:47Blackman was 35 in these finals, but, uh, he could still shoot.
07:52Had a game winner in the 93 Eastern Conference Semis.
07:55So, why didn't Pat Riley play him?
08:00There is a theory that it was personal.
08:03Blackman had asked to bring his wife on the road for the finals, which is against Riley's rules.
08:08He asked in front of the team.
08:10It was an awkward, tense situation and likely pissed off Riley.
08:14But, come on, that can't really be the reason.
08:18Right?
08:19Listen, this sucks about him, but Pat Riley really took his no-wives-allowed rule seriously.
08:26Riley referred to players' wives and children as peripheral opponents.
08:32That's rude.
08:33He'd have meetings with the families before the season,
08:35essentially telling the wives to leave their husbands alone.
08:38Take out the trash yourself and let them sleep around on the road.
08:41In 1986, when Byron Scott got married over All-Star break, Riley benched him for 12 games.
08:47In 1987, the Lakers lost Game 3 to Boston by 6 points, and Riley was like,
08:53it's cause two of your wives paid their own way and sat in the stands.
08:57So, Riley is very weird about the wife thing.
09:02Weird enough to leave a brick-laying Starks in Game 7 to finish making a fucking Eiffel Tower out of
09:09bricks?
09:09I don't know.
09:11Blackman didn't even break the rule, he just pushed back on it.
09:14And there is another possible reason Riley didn't play Blackman.
09:20And it's the one Riley says is true.
09:22Simply, the coach got stuck in a short playoff rotation.
09:27Historically, Riley had a short playoff rotation philosophy.
09:30In 93, he explained it as such.
09:33You rotate 8, you play 7, you use 6, you trust 5.
09:39This year, working backwards, we have his 5, his 6, his 7 and 8.
09:45There was even a 9 when Ewing needed a breather.
09:48But there was no Rolando Blackman.
09:51I mean, superficial minutes, sure, but compared to the regular season, Blackman was not playing.
09:56He hadn't played since Game 3 of the conference finals, and he only played 4 minutes then.
10:01Now, assistant at the time, Jeff Van Gundy, said Blackman was injured and not good anymore.
10:06Blackman refutes that.
10:08The injury was over and done with.
10:09And actually, that theory of Van Gundy's kind of cost him his career.
10:13And there's reason to believe Blackman here.
10:16Riley admits the mistake.
10:18The biggest one of his career.
10:20He should have played Rolando.
10:23He's handwritten letters to Blackman explaining such sentiment.
10:26But Blackman's not about to write back.
10:29And I don't blame him.
10:31So, did the coach really just get stuck in his short rotation philosophy?
10:37Look over at the bench, see a shooter, and say, no, no, he's not for playoffs?
10:41I don't buy it, and I don't think Riley does either.
10:45Because he also said years later that he knew Rolando was fresh,
10:49but something made him still believe Starks was about to get hot.
10:54I still don't think we've hit on what that something was.
10:57Like, even though it's painful, let's look at Starks' face again.
11:01He does not look like someone who's about to get hot.
11:04He looks like someone who is about to cry.
11:07I feel a lump in my throat just looking at him.
11:09Though I am famously empathetic.
11:12That's my dog.
11:13The broadcasters are saying it's not Starks' night,
11:16which is the nicest possible way of saying what was happening.
11:19Fans at home were screaming much more vile things at their televisions.
11:23But Riley still believed?
11:25Why?
11:27Hypothesis number four.
11:29Riley loved John Starks like a son and could not turn his back on him.
11:33Riley and Starks had a special relationship.
11:36The coach has said Starks reminded him of himself as a player more than anyone else ever has.
11:41He said he'd want John Starks in a foxhole with him,
11:44which is one of the few more dire situations than a Game 7.
11:48And Pat Riley, famously hard-nosed coach one might even call a jerk,
11:52was nice to John Starks at practice.
11:55To the extent that Starks' teammates called him Riley's son.
12:00On his way to Game 7, Riley turned to his close friend and said,
12:03I know three people who are showing up for this game.
12:07You, me, and John.
12:09He really liked John Starks.
12:12So, could Riley not bear to give up on...
12:16his son?
12:18While he clunked shot after shot?
12:21Maybe?
12:23Look, it's impossible to be inside Riley's head in the moment.
12:27My time machine doesn't work, I'm a different consciousness, there's all kinds of reasons.
12:31But I imagine his decision was a combination of all these hypotheses.
12:36All this stuff was rattling around in his oiled-up head while he watched Game 7 fly away.
12:42His philosophies of overconfidence and loyalty to his players,
12:46Stark's recent performances and his general ability to get hot quick,
12:50his own short rotation strategy, Hubie Davis' drop ball,
12:54and the fatherly feelings he had toward Starks.
12:57And I'm not sure what carried the most weight, but we all saw the result.
13:02Letting Starks shoot and miss until New York was dead.
13:07Pat Riley's decision to leave John Starks in the game was a big deal.
13:18Thanks for watching, everyone.
13:20I hope you enjoyed watching this as much as I enjoyed making it.
13:23Or, as much as I enjoy sitting on the stoop when it's not too hot, nor too cold.
13:30For Secret Base, I'm Clara Morris.
13:32Good night and good game.
13:34Good night and good day and good day and good day and good day and good day and good day
13:42and good day and good day and good day and good day and good day and good day and good
13:42day and good day and good day and good day and good day and good day and good day and
13:42good day and good day and good day and good day and good day and good day and good day
13:43and good day and good day and good day and good day and good day and good day and good
13:43day and good day and good day and good day and good day and good day and good day and
13:43good day and good day and good day and good day and good day and good day and good day
13:43and good day and good day and good day and good day and good day and good day and good
13:43day and good day and good day and good day and good day and good day and good day and
13:43good day and good day and good day and good day and good day and good day and good day
13:43and good day and good day and good day and good day and good day and good day and good
13:43day