00:21Presiding Officer
00:30Saksi, si Sandra Aguinaldo
00:35Sinimulan na kanina ang unang beses pa lang nangyayari sa kasaysayan
00:39ang pagsalang sa paglilitis ng isang vice-presidente ng Pilipinas
00:44Hindi dumulo si Vice President Sara Duterte
00:48Karapatan ng sambayanan na malaman kung may katotohanan ang mga paratang laban sa pangalawang panggol
00:54Tumpulin natin timbangin ang mga ebidensyang ihaharap
00:59at iakin ang ating magiging pasya ay nakabatay lamang sa batas at sa mga katotohanan mapatutunayan sa paglilitis
01:10Tatlong senador ang hindi nakadalo
01:12Si Senador Ronald De La Rosa na nagtatago
01:16at mga nakakulong na sina Senador Jingoy Estrada at Rodante Marcoleta
01:21Agad naging mainit ang talakayan ng tutula ng ilang minority senators
01:26ang binuksang proseso para sa pagboto ng bagong presiding officer
01:31Argumenta ni Senador Alan Peter Cayetano, Senate President, ang dapat tumayong presiding officer
01:37Pagaman hindi daw ito nakasulat sa saligang batas
01:41Ito naman daw ang intensyon ng framers ng 1987 Constitution
01:45base sa transcript ng kanilang deliberasyon noon
01:49Institutional integrity
01:51We need to protect the legitimacy of these proceedings
01:55Even with the substitute presiding officer acts fairly
01:59a conviction or acquittal reached under constitutionally defective process
02:03would invite judicial challenge
02:06and cast doubt on the validity of the entire trial
02:09Punto ni Cayetano, nagugat ang issue
02:12sa kinokwestiyon niyang sasyon noong Hunyo
02:15kung saan inamiandahan ang impeachment rules
02:17para payagan ang eleksyon ng presiding officer ng impeachment
02:21Sagot ni Gatchalian, dumaan ito sa tamang proseso
02:25at ang tamang lugar daw para talakayin ang issue
02:28ay kapag nasa sasyon ang Senado
02:30No one objected to that resolution
02:32and it was duly approved by the body
02:35So any discussion regarding this resolution
02:43should be discussed in plenary
02:47when the Senate convenes as a legislative body
02:51We did not follow our rules
02:53So a rule that was passed that did not follow our rules
02:57or amendment that was passed that did not follow our rules
03:01Sinigundan si Cayetano ng kanyang kapatid
03:03We looked at what the constitutional framers said
03:07What did they say?
03:08This is the foundation of this trial
03:11na tama yung nakaupong presiding officer
03:13Si Sen. Kiko Pakilinan
03:15Nagpuntong dinala na ni Cayetano
03:18ang usapin sa Supreme Court
03:19sa pawamagitan ng petisyong
03:21ipawalang visa ang June 3 session
03:24The matter is pending before the Supreme Court
03:26There is no temporary restraining order
03:29There was a request for a status quo anti-order
03:33It was not granted
03:34The point of order is improper
03:40In fact, the debate on this matter
03:45here in the impeachment court is out of order
03:48Sa huli, nagkaroon ng potohan
03:50Pursuant to rule 2
03:51of the rules of procedures on impeachment trials
03:55as amended
03:56I move to elect
03:58Senator Judge Francis
04:01Joseph Guevara Escudero
04:04as the presiding officer
04:05of this impeachment court
04:07Objection, Mr. President
04:09and may allow to
04:10We proceed
04:10We proceed
04:11Objection, Mr. President
04:12I'm allowed to object
04:13and I'm allowed to explain my objection
04:15You are allowed to object
04:16but we will proceed
04:17with the division of the House
04:1912 Senador
04:20ang bumoto kay Escudero
04:228 ang tumutol
04:23Hindi bumoto
04:24si Escudero
04:25Sa pagpupaliwanag
04:27ng kanyang pagtutol
04:28may patama
04:29si Cayetano
04:30kay Escudero
04:31I have information
04:32that the 20 years
04:34AMLA records
04:36of Senator Escudero
04:38and his credit cards
04:39and bank accounts
04:40were all opened up
04:42in the office
04:42of the Senate President
04:43where members
04:45of the Blue Ribbon Committee
04:46was here
04:46Then we're going to ask him
04:48to preside
04:50So there's a problem
04:51This is my explanation
04:53This is my explanation
04:54To the gentleman
04:55To the gentleman
04:56This is factual
04:57With all due respect
04:59your statements
05:00are already out of order
05:01It has nothing to do
05:03with the topic on hand
05:04No, Mr. President
05:05And the presiding officer
05:07will strike off
05:08It has all to do
05:09with this
05:10It has all to do
05:12I do not
05:13Mr. President
05:14Pertaining to
05:15Senator Escudero
05:16Dahil umiinit na
05:17ang usapan
05:18Sandaling sinuspend
05:20ang trial
05:20Dito na umakyat
05:22sa podium
05:22si Escudero
05:23sa tabi ni Quechalian
05:25para pamunuan
05:26ang impeachment court
05:27Sa kanyang opening statement
05:29may paalala
05:30si Escudero
05:31sa kapas
05:32Senator Judges
05:59Pertaining to the merits
06:03of this trial
06:03as mandated
06:04by the impeachment
06:05rules itself
06:06Narito tayo
06:07upang alamin
06:08ang katotohanan
06:09at sa pamamagitan nito
06:10mapaira lang
06:11hostisyang
06:12walang kinikilingan
06:13Tinalaki rin ni Escudero
06:15ang issue
06:16kung ilang boto
06:17ang kailangan
06:18para
06:18ma-convict
06:20ang respondent
06:21na si Vice President
06:22Duterte
06:22The Constitution
06:24provides
06:25that no person
06:26shall be convicted
06:27without the concurrence
06:28of two-thirds
06:29of all
06:30the members
06:31of the Senate
06:31With 24 members
06:34of the Senate
06:35a literal interpretation
06:36of this means
06:37that conviction
06:38requires the affirmative
06:39vote of at least
06:4016 Senator Judges
06:42This is the prevailing
06:43law today
06:44If we agree with it
06:46or not
06:46we must abide
06:47by it
06:48However
06:50those who disagree
06:51are not without
06:52recourse
06:53because this
06:54without prejudice
06:55to the right
06:55of any party
06:56who holds a different
06:57view
06:57to seek judicial relief
06:59G.T. Escudero
07:01sakaling maglabas
07:03ng pasya
07:03ang Korte Suprema
07:04na iba sa kanyang sinabi
07:06masusunod
07:07ang pasya
07:07ng Korte Suprema
07:09I think you saw
07:10after si Senator Cayetano
07:11tried to put it on record
07:13na it's the decision
07:14of the court
07:14by 16
07:15I don't think
07:16legally that is
07:17the case
07:18right now
07:19in the sense that
07:20it can be brought up
07:21again
07:21it still depends
07:22how yung trial
07:23will go on
07:24and are there
07:25additional arrests
07:26that will be made
07:27are there senators
07:28who cannot participate
07:28etc.
07:30Ang House
07:30Panel of Prosecutors
07:32nagmosyon
07:33nabasahin
07:34ang apat
07:34na articles
07:35of impeachment
07:36at mag-enter
07:37ng tugon
07:37ni Duterte
07:38o kanyang plea
07:39na guilty
07:40or not guilty
07:41sa bawat
07:42article of impeachment
07:43Tinutulan nito
07:44ng depensa
07:45sa huli
07:46tinanggihan
07:47na impeachment
07:48court
07:48na
07:48i-arrange
07:49si Duterte
07:50we understand
07:51the position
07:52of the impeachment
07:53court
07:54that
07:55an entry
07:56of plea
07:57of not guilty
07:58is dimmed
08:00from the filing
08:01of the answer
08:02of the respondent
08:03we understand that
08:04but it was
08:04our intention
08:05really
08:06to place it
08:07on record
08:07regardless
08:08of the decision
08:09of the impeachment
08:10court
08:10to make it
08:11more organized
08:12to make it
08:13more responsive
08:14to the mandate
08:16of the constitution
08:16and to make it
08:18consistent
08:18tinalakay
08:20na rin
08:20ang iba
08:21pang pending
08:21na issue
08:22kaugnay
08:23sa magiging
08:24takbo
08:24ng paglilitis
08:25kaugnay
08:27naman
08:27sa selyadong
08:28kahaw
08:28naglalaman
08:28ng tax
08:29records
08:29ni Vice
08:30President
08:31Duterte
08:31at
08:32Mr.
08:33Attorney
08:33Manasse
08:34Scarpio
08:34nagpa siyang
08:35impeachment
08:36court
08:36na ibalik
08:37ito
08:38sa Bureau
08:38of Internal
08:39Revenue
08:39o BIR
08:40katwira nila
08:41hindi nila
08:42iniutos
08:43ang pagsusumite
08:44nito
08:44tungkol
08:45dito
08:46sa BIR
08:46box
08:47yes
08:47totoo
08:48binalik
08:48ang BIR
08:49box
08:50but this
08:50does not
08:51mean
08:51na nawala
08:52na yung
08:53evidentiary
08:54value
08:54nitong
08:55evidentiyang
08:56ito
08:56because
08:56at the
08:57proper
08:57time
08:57ibabalik
08:59po ito
08:59i-offer
09:00po ulit
09:00ito
09:00ng ating
09:01prosecution
09:02at hopefully
09:03the court
09:04will admit
09:05this
09:05as an
09:05evidence
09:06so sa
09:07ngayon
09:07ay
09:08nandyan
09:08lang yan
09:09we will
09:09reserve
09:10our
09:10comments
09:10for
09:10when
09:11that
09:11time
09:11happens
09:12or
09:12when
09:12it
09:12actually
09:13happens
09:13humiling
09:14naman
09:15ang
09:15prosecution
09:15na
09:16ipasabpina
09:16ang halos
09:17sampung
09:18bank
09:18managers
09:19mula
09:19sa iba't
09:20ibang
09:20banko
09:21at branches
09:21mula
09:22Davao
09:23hanggang
09:23Metro
09:23Manila
09:24pinalagan
09:25ito
09:25ng
09:25depensa
09:25bagaman
09:26ipinagutos
09:27pa rin
09:27ng
09:28impeachment
09:28court
09:28ang mga
09:29sampina
09:30para
09:30rito
09:30we will
09:32include
09:32all our
09:33position
09:33and as
09:34well as
09:35our
09:35objections
09:35on the
09:36request
09:37made
09:37today
09:38with respect
09:38to these
09:39documents
09:39and
09:40what
09:41it would
09:42seem
09:42to the
09:43defense
09:43would be
09:44another
09:472.0
09:49version
09:49of a
09:50fishing
09:50expedition
09:50ang
09:52minority
09:52senators
09:53naman
09:53hindi pa rin
09:54isinusuko
09:55ang dapat
09:55anilang
09:56pagsali
09:57ni na
09:57Senador
09:58Estrada
09:58at
09:58Marculeta
09:59na
10:00makasali
10:01sa
10:01impeachment
10:01court
10:02baka raw
10:03pwede itong
10:03hingin
10:04sa
10:04sandigan
10:04bayan
10:05walang
10:06nag-object
10:06sa mga
10:07senator
10:08judge
10:08mula
10:09sa
10:09mayurya
10:10pero
10:10para
10:11kay
10:11Senador
10:11Rafi
10:12Tulfo
10:12pwede
10:13kung
10:13manonood
10:14lang
10:14naman
10:15sa
10:15TV
10:15ang
10:16hinihingi
10:17po namin
10:17ay
10:18makapunta
10:18po sila
10:19dito
10:19bilang
10:19observer
10:20hindi
10:21lang po
10:22basta
10:22monitor
10:23ipinag-utos
10:25naman
10:25ni
10:25presiding
10:26officer
10:26escudero
10:27sa
10:27secretariat
10:28na i-upload
10:29online
10:30lahat
10:30ng dokumento
10:31memo
10:32at
10:32evidencia
10:33sa
10:33kaso
10:34para
10:34sa
10:34transparency
10:35if
10:36if
10:36a
10:37evidence
10:38presented
10:39is a
10:39fruit
10:39of
10:40the
10:40poisonous
10:40tree
10:41will
10:42we
10:42upload
10:43that
10:43in
10:43so
10:44far
10:44as
10:44documentary
10:45evidence
10:46is
10:46concerned
10:47it
10:47will
10:48only
10:48be
10:48admitted
10:49and
10:50if at
10:50all
10:50admitted
10:51by
10:51the
10:51court
10:51and
10:52published
10:52once
10:53formal
10:53offer
10:54has
10:54been
10:54made
10:55until
10:56such
10:56time
10:56we
10:57will
10:57not
10:58publish
10:58any
10:58documentary
10:59evidence
11:00even
11:00after
11:01being
11:01identified
11:02by a
11:02witness
11:03because
11:03it
11:03is
11:03the
11:04formal
11:04offer
11:04that
11:04will
11:04determine
11:05its
11:06admission
11:06by
11:06the
11:06court
11:07after
11:07Ako
11:08si
11:08Sandra
11:08Aguinaldo
11:09ang
11:09inyong
11:10saksi
Comments