Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 19 hours ago
The US and China are racing to dominate the developing field of artificial intelligence but they may not be seeking the same results. To understand the difference in their goals, Lily LaMattina speaks with Selina Xu, China and AI policy lead at the office of former Google CEO Eric Schmidt.

Correction: This video and accompanying posts have been reposted to correct the interviewee's title.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Okay, Selena, can you start by telling us what are some of the biggest misconceptions about the U.S.-China AI
00:04race today?
00:06I think people tend to think that, you know, both the U.S. and China, when they use the race
00:11metaphor, that they're very much, one, racing down the same lane towards the frontier, and then two, that they are
00:17racing towards the same finishing line.
00:19And I think in the U.S., that finishing line is very much, whether you call it AGI, artificial general
00:24intelligence, or if you call it, you know, reaching the moment of recursive self-improvement that can unlock, you know,
00:31great gains for society and for the economy.
00:33In China, I think it's quite different.
00:36And part of it is because of export controls and compute constraints that has forced them to develop a very
00:41different kind of approach.
00:43So China, one, I think their dominant vision of AI is very much physical.
00:47So they're very focused on integrating AI into hardware.
00:52And then to accelerate that, they have very much adopted open source models to accelerate the adoption of AI across
01:00industries and across sectors.
01:02So efficiency is a huge thing because they don't have enough chips.
01:06According to Stanford's 2026 AI Index report, the gap in performance between the U.S. and China's large language models
01:13has essentially closed.
01:14Do you believe that China has truly caught up?
01:17I think the gap has definitely narrowed from a few years back.
01:22So the gap was really wide right after ChatGPT came out and China really struggled to catch up with its
01:29initial models like Baidu's Ernie.
01:31If you look at the more recent Chinese models like DeepSeq V4 or Kimi K2.6 or Z.AI's GLM
01:40models, it does seem like if you trust the benchmark reporting, it is generally somewhere around like under six months.
01:48But if the broader claim or if you want to make a bolder claim of Chinese AI is now neck
01:55and neck with U.S. frontier models, I think that is probably not true as of this point.
02:00It is not that their performance are totally on par, especially on some of the areas like coding capabilities or
02:07agentic capabilities.
02:08But it's more that, hey, maybe they have other metrics, right?
02:12Like DeepSeq is so much cheaper right now than, you know, Claude.
02:16Lastly, if you had to pick just one, whether it's chips, large language models, physical AI, infrastructure, etc.
02:22What's the most important frontier that you see determining who leads the U.S.-China AI race and why?
02:28I think the most important indicator might be which economy can first see like real productive impact from AI.
02:40So the U.S., obviously, its economy is so deeply leveraged on AI right now.
02:46Whether you can see real returns on productivity without seeing very widespread, you know, displacement of, for instance, jobs that
02:55would harm, you know, people's ability to consume and buy AI services, right?
03:00So I think that that is one thing to note in the U.S. context.
03:04In the China context, it's very much more of the Chinese government now is so all in on AI because
03:09their old growth drivers like property and like infrastructure investment no longer work that well.
03:15And they want to pivot to these what they call new quality production forces, which include AI, robotics, clean energy,
03:22batteries and everything.
03:23In the U.S., there's so much anti-AI sentiment.
03:26Token costs are going through the roof.
03:29There's a memory squeeze.
03:31Like all these problems is like before you talk about reaching, you know, super intelligence, there are these really just
03:37like real issues about negotiating just how exactly you even bring that about in the first place.
03:44That I think is very top of mind for policymakers and I actually think is the more real issue if
03:50you talk about a race, like which country can actually bring about the fruits of AI without their societies breaking
03:55down.
Comments

Recommended