Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 4 hours ago
Does The Kid Mero have what it takes to become an editor at Pitchfork? He's done the work and gotten in the necessary reps but how do his scores stack up against the official Pitchfork.com reviews of albums by A$AP Rocky, Oasis, Tool, Jamiroquai, Addison Rae, Earl Sweatshirt, Bladee, and Los Thuthanaka?
Transcript
00:00I used to actually review music for another place that I'm not going to name.
00:04I got some reps in.
00:07I'm going to do so good that y'all are going to actually probably hire me on the spot and
00:10then be like, yo, listen, before we hire you, you got to get your nose pierced first.
00:13Join the Polycule and we in there full time.
00:17Pitchfork, I don't know.
00:27Pow, Don't Be Dumb by A$AP Rocky.
00:29This one bangs.
00:30Shout out to Rocky.
00:31It's been a while since you put out music.
00:33I feel like you did a lot of weird stuff in this rollout, which was cool because you're
00:37a fashion guy and things like that.
00:39But there's a couple of bangers on there.
00:416.9, good record, a few issues, but worth your attention if you're into the genre.
00:45That is exactly this.
00:46Wow.
00:46Shout out to Pitchfork for having a very specific rating system.
00:50It's not like a front to back flawless album, but there's some joints on there.
00:58Pitchfork gave it a 6.8.
01:01Pow!
01:02See?
01:02Look at that, y'all.
01:04See?
01:05That was me pulling up for the logo.
01:07That's the sound of me.
01:09Nothing but net.
01:10Splash.
01:11I'm ready.
01:12Just listen.
01:13Just stop putting shit in my office.
01:14I like Funko Pops.
01:16Put it in my office right now because I start tomorrow here at Pitchfork.
01:18This is Oasis, Be Here Now.
01:21Shout out to Oasis because they are seminal UK rock bands.
01:27You know what they used to sound like, you know?
01:29Maybe you're gonna be the one that saves me.
01:32Can we hear it?
01:38That sounds like a Nintendo game.
01:42All old men.
01:43Very old and crotchety and they got beef with each other.
01:46Noel and the other guy.
01:48They don't like each other at all, you know?
01:50Sometimes they do, but most of the time they don't fuck with each other at all.
01:53It's reflected in the music.
01:55As a Pitchfork editor, just put Deceptive Piercing in post.
01:59I'm gonna give this a 5.
02:00Not a total disaster, but very, you know, kind of like run-of-the-mill guitar rock.
02:05You know, does the job.
02:07Like Jersey Mike's or something.
02:08It's not great, but you know, fuck it.
02:13Pitchfork, give it a 5.3.
02:16Right there.
02:17Right there.
02:185, 5.3.
02:19I think I took off the .3 because I myself have a brother.
02:22And sometimes we get along, sometimes we don't.
02:25Much like Noel and Liam.
02:29Lateralis by Tool.
02:30You know what I'm saying?
02:32Tool.
02:33I am going to go right ahead and give that a 1.5.
02:37Because I hate motherfucking Tool.
02:39God damn them motherfuckers suck, boy.
02:41Have you ever listened to any shit?
02:43Like for real, for real?
02:44If I gave you a Pokemon and I was like, eat this shit alive, try to enjoy it.
02:48You'd be like, no, there's no way I can enjoy this, man.
02:50This is Tool, man.
02:53Bad name says it all.
02:54I hope y'all also gave Tool a 1.
02:571.9.
02:58Ah!
03:00See?
03:01Keeper P.
03:01Whoever did that was being nice.
03:03They might know Scott Stapp.
03:06You know what I'm saying?
03:06Oh no, that's the guy from Creed.
03:07My bad.
03:08See?
03:09They're so ass that they are interchangeable in my mind.
03:12Creed and Tool are both interchangeable in my mind because they're so ass.
03:15It's Maynard.
03:16Maynard.
03:17Maynard James Keenan, some shit like that.
03:19He has a weird ass Civil War era name.
03:21I'm sorry, man.
03:21If you put your heart and soul into this shit, I apologize.
03:24But this shit is ass.
03:26Ho ho!
03:27Pow!
03:28This is Jamiroquai Automaton.
03:30Let me hear this real quick.
03:38I knew that beat drop was going to be crazy.
03:40That's what Jamiroquai does, bro.
03:41They wear silly hats and they have ill beat drops.
03:44I want to keep a pitchfork.
03:45You know, when I say keep a P, I mean keep a pitchfork.
03:47Keep a P?
03:48We got seven.
03:49Very good record.
03:50You know?
03:51Recommend checking it out.
03:52Pitchfork.
03:53Keep it a 7.0.
03:55Pow!
03:56Look at that!
03:56Come on.
03:57Lucky seven.
03:58This is what I do.
03:59Keep a P.
04:00Yo, listen.
04:00I'm playing lotto after I get out of here.
04:03You understand what I'm saying?
04:04I'm killing it right now.
04:05Oh.
04:07Addison Rae.
04:08You know what I'm saying?
04:09It's called Addison.
04:10Self-titled.
04:12Eponymous.
04:13I kind of want to hear the vocals.
04:14I want to be reminded of the vocals real quick.
04:16Because also, there's Tate McRae out there in the world, right?
04:22And there's a lot of rays.
04:35It was very like funky.
04:37But like funky, like I'm at Forever 21 going crazy.
04:40You know what I'm saying?
04:41I'm just sitting there buying like merchandise.
04:44Oh, they got a Wu-Tang crop top.
04:45Ooh, that's hard.
04:47You know what I'm saying?
04:47Like, and this is playing in the background.
04:48You know what I mean?
04:49I'm asking people for help.
04:50They're like, I don't work here.
04:51It's giving that.
04:52I give it like a, a 5.6.
04:57Decent record.
04:58A few things going for it.
05:00This is very kind of like innocuous type of music.
05:04Like, I'm not going to turn this on and like crash the car.
05:07Because it's so ill.
05:08But I am also, you know, just going to be transported to a mall.
05:13We gave it an 8.
05:17What the fuck?
05:21Y'all threw me a curveball.
05:23Okay.
05:23All right.
05:24Okay.
05:25Uh, cool.
05:27I guess, listen, a lot of y'all must shop for denim at, uh, you know, Charlotte Russe.
05:32All right.
05:33Oh, yeah.
05:35This is some rap songs about Earl Sweatshirt.
05:38Earl, what up, baby?
05:39You know what I'm saying?
05:40Listen, I'm gonna tell you right now.
05:43That goes crazy.
05:45Earl is a rapper.
05:46You know what I mean?
05:47Earl be rapping his ass off.
05:48And I am going to give this album a 9.1.
05:52A monument.
05:53An instant classic.
05:54It sounds ahead of its time.
05:55It sounds timeless.
05:56Even though he still sounds like Earl, Earl is forever.
06:00You know what I'm saying?
06:02The sweatshirt is eternal.
06:04Pitchfork gave it an 8.8.
06:07Ah, see?
06:08You know what I mean?
06:09They gave it an 8.8 so they could keep you humble.
06:11You know what I'm saying?
06:12But you know what?
06:13I'm gonna give you your flowers, champ.
06:15This is a banger.
06:16This is a classic.
06:17This is canon.
06:18All right?
06:18Get me your Earl Sweatshirt Funko Pop.
06:21Oh.
06:23This is...
06:25Cold Visions.
06:28Blade?
06:29Bloody?
06:30Bloody?
06:31It's Blade.
06:32Blade.
06:32With two E's.
06:34The last one.
06:34Both of them are silent.
06:35You thought it was one that was silent.
06:37Both of them are silent.
06:38I am familiar with Blade.
06:39The Marvel character.
06:43He's a rapper from Sweden.
06:45A rapper from Sweden?
06:48Yo!
06:48Look at this cover.
06:50I was very much expecting to hear some heavy guitar.
06:54You know what I'm saying?
06:55Type of energy.
06:56But this is a rapper from Sweden.
06:58Okay.
06:58So let's hear Swedish bars.
07:02Wake up, filthy.
07:07Oh, shit.
07:08Okay.
07:10Okay, Sweden.
07:11All right.
07:12I was not familiar with your game.
07:14That was tough.
07:14That was tough.
07:15I like that.
07:16It sounded kind of like fried-ish.
07:18My trade pitchfork here is telling me that this is somewhere between an 8.6 and a 9.
07:24Pitchfork gave it an 8.3.
07:26See?
07:27There you go.
07:28Okay.
07:28Easy money.
07:29That's not that big of a spread.
07:31Okay?
07:31So I think with Blade, we did what we had to do.
07:35Shout out to Blade.
07:36Maybe drop one E off.
07:37Actually, no.
07:38Add another.
07:38Keep the E's.
07:39That's why you did the two E's.
07:41For SEO.
07:42That's what it was.
07:43Because the motherfuckers type in Blade, anything could come up.
07:45Just regular with one E.
07:47You could get a knife.
07:49You could get Wesley Snipes as a vampire hunter.
07:51You could get a lot of different shit.
07:52But if you put two E's, you get the Swedish rapper.
07:54So shout out to him.
07:56Or her.
07:56Or them.
07:57You know what I'm saying?
07:57I don't know.
07:58This is Los Tutanacas.
08:02With their self-titled album, Los Tutanacas.
08:06Listen, since I'm a Pitchfork employee, I went to the Pitchfork holiday party.
08:10Where the Tutanacas was performing live.
08:13And when I walked in there, I was like, what the fuck is going on here?
08:20I was like, yo, you know what?
08:21I did some of the drugs.
08:22I do all the drugs.
08:23So I'm having a hard time understanding this.
08:25But after a while, I was there standing next to my good friend Ben Tran on one side.
08:31And on the other side, John Karamanica of the New York Times.
08:34And then over there, there was a guy who seemed to be leaning on fentanyl.
08:37And I was like, yo, you know what?
08:39I totally understand this now.
08:42Totally understand this now.
08:43So as a Pitchfork employee, I'm going to give this a 9.1.
08:47A Monuments.
08:48An instant classic.
08:49Sounds ahead of its time.
08:50I don't understand it.
08:51So therefore, it is ahead of its time.
08:53And this is the type of album that you give a 10 to.
08:56Because you never know what's going to happen in music.
08:58You know?
08:59You never know what's going to trend up or trend down or what's going to blow up.
09:01And the weirder and more abstract the shit is, the higher it goes.
09:06You know what I'm saying?
09:07That's what we do over here, Pitchfork.
09:08Keep repeat.
09:09This is so fucking weird that you could just roll the dice on this.
09:12Hey.
09:14Oh, shit.
09:15Jackpot.
09:15Yo, I have very good taste.
09:19Pitchfork gave it a 9.3.
09:24You know why Pitchfork gave that shit almost a 10, bro?
09:26Because you got to go to Bolivia and buy it out of a trunk of a car.
09:29You can't hear them on any streaming services because they're that cool.
09:33They're not on Apple Music.
09:34They're not on Spotify.
09:35None of that shit.
09:35Not Tidal.
09:36Fuck you, Jay-Z.
09:37They don't want to go on Tidal either.
09:38You got to go buy a hard copy of a CD in Bolivia out of a trunk.
09:42What I listen to on a daily basis probably changes from day to day.
09:46You know what I mean?
09:46Sometimes I'm into like, yo, I want to hear some house music, man.
09:49Some UK Garage, Jack Marlowe.
09:51Sometimes I'm like, yo, I want to listen to French Montana talk about strippers for hours on end.
09:55Music critics are very important.
09:57Art critics in general.
09:58But especially music critics.
10:00Because you might sit down with an album that has a run time of like an hour.
10:04And if it's ass, you just wasted an hour every time.
10:07You know, you don't got time to do all that.
10:09So, you know, you want to curate your music and listen to people that know what they're talking about.
10:14You feel me?
10:14Like, my drunk uncle, I don't go to him for financial advice.
10:17I go to my accountant.
10:18So for music advice, I go to Pitchfork.
10:20I do not go to my drunk uncle.
10:21Because he just says BDP every time.
10:24No, we do not have free Mountain Dew at the Pitchfork office.
10:28I quit.
10:29I quit.
10:30I put my two-week notice in right now.
10:33Tyson, wrap me up.
10:35Take this mic off me.
10:35I'm out of here.
10:36No free Mountain Dew.
10:38What are we doing?
10:39Hott et g1o �1.
10:40I quit.
10:40I'ts.
10:42I quit.
10:43I quit.
10:43I quit.
10:43Hey, man, I quit.
10:43I quitique.
10:43I quit.
10:43You keep.
10:43It's Mr.
10:43One way.
10:43Mate.
Comments

Recommended