- 1 day ago
Category
🐳
AnimalsTranscript
00:00:28Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:58CastingWords
00:01:14CastingWords
00:01:24CastingWords
00:01:41CastingWords
00:01:49CastingWords
00:02:01CastingWords
00:02:12CastingWords
00:02:23CastingWords
00:02:35CastingWords
00:02:54CastingWords
00:03:12CastingWords
00:03:40CastingWords
00:03:46I'm a black man aник.
00:03:52I'm a black man.
00:03:52I'm a black man.
00:03:55Bye bye.
00:03:55I don't know where I get him.
00:03:57Do you have any relationship between him and him and him?
00:04:01No, I don't think he's a person.
00:04:05If he's a judge, he doesn't want to be a judge.
00:04:09If you're lucky enough, he'll come back to the police department.
00:04:14Yes.
00:04:16Okay.
00:04:29Kim Jong-un.
00:04:32강요민 변호사님 오셨습니다.
00:04:35맞네.
00:04:37말씀들 나누시죠.
00:04:38Okay.
00:04:52우리가 만난 적이 있던가요?
00:04:57기억 못 할 줄 알았어.
00:05:00네?
00:05:02내가 이렇게 된 데는 당신 책임도 있어요.
00:05:07그러니까 내 변호를 맡아줘요.
00:05:24모르겠는데.
00:05:27나 명미라는 이름이 흔하긴 해서 들어본 것 같긴 한데.
00:05:31너 얼굴 봤는데도 기억 안 나?
00:05:33응.
00:05:34너 우리 모르는 친구 없잖아.
00:05:36우리도 모르는 거 보면 고등학교 친구인가?
00:05:39아무래도 그렇겠지.
00:05:41우리 고등학교만 따로 다녔잖아.
00:05:43친구는 아닌 것 같던데?
00:05:44나보다 나이도 많고.
00:05:46중졸이던데?
00:05:47그럼 혹시 피해자를 아는 거 아니야?
00:05:50혹시 몰라서 한번 확인해 봤는데 피해자도 중졸.
00:05:53그런데 우리랑은 다른 학교?
00:05:55둘 다 중졸이요?
00:05:56아.
00:05:57피해자는 고등학교를 미국에서 나왔더라고?
00:06:00중학교 졸업 후에 미국 간대?
00:06:02응.
00:06:05그래서 어떻게 할 거야?
00:06:07사건 맡을 거야?
00:06:09안 맡자니, 찜찜하고.
00:06:11맡자고 하니 형사소송이라 부담스럽고.
00:06:14게다가 회사에서 프로분호 처리가 어렵다고 해서.
00:06:16수입료 받아야 되는데.
00:06:19김영미 씨가 그런 큰돈이 있을 리가 없잖아.
00:06:26그런데 우리 언제 들어가는 거야?
00:06:28너 오늘 무슨 시술 받는다고 그랬지?
00:06:30얘 한 거.
00:06:32그거 효과 진짜 좋아.
00:06:37강효미 님.
00:06:49이거 많이 아파요?
00:06:52아니요.
00:06:53편하게 받으시면 돼요.
00:06:56시작할게요.
00:06:57네.
00:07:05너 왜 피부 탱탱해진 것 좀 봐?
00:07:08그치?
00:07:09진짜 좋다니까.
00:07:11나도 받아 봐야겠다.
00:07:12셋이 같이 하면 할인 안 해주나?
00:07:14그러게.
00:07:15너 할 때 한 번 물어봐봐.
00:07:17나도 같이 가, 셋이.
00:07:18괜찮아요.
00:07:19아瑔
00:07:21엔
00:07:21애
00:07:21애
00:07:47aux
00:07:59Don't worry about it.
00:08:17최 변호사 왔나 보네요.
00:08:19최 변호사 왔나 보네요.
00:08:21최 변호사 왔나 보네요.
00:08:23최 변호사 왔나 보네요.
00:08:39최 변호사 왔나 보네요.
00:09:34최 변호사 왔나 보네요.
00:09:53최 변호사 왔나 보네요.
00:10:05최 변호사 왔나 보네요.
00:10:13최 변호사 왔나 보네요.
00:10:35왜 그렇게 보십니까?
00:10:39아니, 뭐 지난번에도 그렇고 허민정 변호사가 팀워크에 대한 책임감이 느슨해지는 것 같다는 생각이 드니까 동기지만 동기로서 동기 2기에 가끔하게 혼
00:10:57좀 내주려고 하는데요.
00:10:59어떻게 생각하세요?
00:11:03장소 정해지면 공지해 주세요.
00:11:07네.
00:11:08바로 진행하겠습니다.
00:11:10먼저 진행.
00:11:12죽었어.
00:11:17고생하셨습니다.
00:11:23고생하셨습니다.
00:11:36고생하셨습니다.
00:11:45고생하셨습니다.
00:11:45고생하셨습니다.
00:11:46고생하셨습니다.
00:11:47저의 제 RJ pag Autom % 도 non.
00:12:04앵쪽 81,000개,000개의 조선가.
00:12:08Let's try it.
00:12:10Then I can buy some.
00:12:10Yes, I'll drink some.
00:12:14Oh, you don't eat it, too?
00:12:19Is it on?
00:12:20Yes, everybody will be good good.
00:12:25It's about a good taste.
00:12:27It's really awesome.
00:12:28Yeah, yeah, yeah.
00:12:29It's a lot of juice.
00:12:30What a lot of juice does it have to get?
00:12:31Yeah, yeah.
00:12:32Yeah, just sit down.
00:12:32Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
00:12:35I'm not going to get this.
00:12:37I am going to go.
00:12:46What're you doing?
00:12:49Uh...
00:12:49It is so disgusting.
00:12:51I'm not going to be scared.
00:12:53It's okay.
00:12:55It's not going to be managed.
00:13:00You're not worried about it.
00:13:03I'm not worried about it.
00:13:05I'm just wondering about it.
00:13:11What's going on?
00:13:13What's wrong with you?
00:13:13My sister is wrong.
00:13:18Because he was only a good man.
00:13:20He was a very, nice boy.
00:13:22He was a man.
00:13:24I wish a guy was a good actor.
00:13:29But the
00:13:30I'm going to trust You, my parents are definitely going to believe in this person.
00:13:34When someone asked if we had a dozen thousand money, she told me only because I'm sorry.
00:13:40People pay for insurance in my money.
00:13:44I'm going to know how to go.
00:13:49But we didn't have a U.S., so don't leave it.
00:14:00I was just going to have to go out for 20-대를.
00:14:01I'm going to have to go out to 20-대를.
00:14:04설마...
00:14:05그 돈으로 합의하려는 건 아니죠?
00:14:10그럼요?
00:14:12그건 오히려...
00:14:14엄마에 대한 도리가 아니라고 생각해요.
00:14:18나중에 더 큰 범죄로 이어질 수도 있어요.
00:14:23My family.
00:14:26My family.
00:14:27My family.
00:14:27I'm sorry to be here.
00:14:32My family.
00:14:32I think it's a good time to get back to my mom.
00:14:36It's a new point.
00:14:39I'm going to go ahead and go.
00:14:53Yeah, yeah.
00:14:54It's a car.
00:14:55It's a car.
00:14:56It's a car.
00:14:57It's a car.
00:14:58It's a car.
00:14:58It's a car.
00:14:59It's a car.
00:15:01Even there's a car.
00:15:02I don't want to stop for him.
00:15:07I'm sorry, I just want to stop production.
00:15:12I'll keep doing that.
00:15:12Did you talk about it?
00:15:15Did you Давайте.
00:15:17How can I take всегда?
00:15:18Yes!
00:15:19Try your parties.
00:15:20Try your part.
00:15:21I'll be back.
00:15:21That's right.
00:15:22I'll be back.
00:15:22I'll be back.
00:15:25I'll be back.
00:15:28I'll be back.
00:15:31I'll be back.
00:15:33You can get me.
00:15:34Put it on the phone.
00:15:35Yes?
00:15:37Yes.
00:15:38Yes.
00:15:42Yes.
00:15:44That's...
00:15:45...
00:15:48...
00:15:49...
00:15:52...
00:15:54...
00:15:54...
00:15:54...
00:15:54...
00:15:55...
00:15:55...
00:15:55What're you doing?
00:15:56I hope it's not too good.
00:15:56Oh, my God.
00:16:00You have a price deal?
00:16:04I will keep you $13,000.
00:16:05I will continue to do this in your own business.
00:16:11Oh, okay.
00:16:12I hope you kunnen down the $14,000.
00:16:14If you don't get to miss the table,
00:16:15I'll give you a deal.
00:16:18I promise you this one.
00:16:20Yes, thank you very much.
00:16:25Ah...
00:16:26What can you do if you can't do it?
00:16:29Ah, yes.
00:16:30I know.
00:16:32But...
00:16:34But...
00:16:35I don't know if you're going to be there.
00:16:37I don't know.
00:16:39I don't know.
00:16:44I don't know.
00:17:05I don't know.
00:17:07Ah, you're true.
00:17:08Ah, you're fine.
00:17:10Yeah.
00:17:10Yeah.
00:17:14Do you want to drink water?
00:17:15Do you want to drink water?
00:17:17I'm going to drink water.
00:17:19I'm going to drink water.
00:17:22Then I'll drink water.
00:17:46Do you want to drink water?
00:17:47잘 들어.
00:17:49너 친한 누나니까 하는 말이야.
00:17:52이 여자는 절대 안 돼.
00:17:54왜?
00:17:55너보다 나이도 많고.
00:17:56상관없어.
00:17:58결혼도 했었고.
00:17:59I don't care.
00:18:00애도 있어.
00:18:01다 컸잖아.
00:18:03애도 못 나.
00:18:05삼신할머니가 정할 일이야.
00:18:06올 거냐, 그거.
00:18:08안 나.
00:18:09강요 안 해.
00:18:12뭐.
00:18:14또 다른 건 없어?
00:18:15내가 너랑 왜 이런 얘기라고 했니?
00:18:24그럼 연애만 해.
00:18:28그래.
00:18:29나는 뭐 결혼 안 한다 치고 넌.
00:18:31너는 뭐 시간이 무한대니?
00:18:34기회비용 생각 안 해?
00:18:35너 결혼 안 해?
00:18:37할 거야.
00:18:38하고 싶어.
00:18:39내가 사랑하는 사람이랑.
00:18:40아, 그러니까.
00:18:41내가 지금 사랑하는 사람 누나야.
00:18:43누나를 두고 다른 사람이랑 결혼하라는 게 말이 돼?
00:18:52너.
00:18:56나 죽기 아까워.
00:19:01그래?
00:19:05그럼 우리 취한 사람들이 하는 거 하자.
00:19:07뭐?
00:19:09실수.
00:19:20실수다.
00:19:24뭐든.
00:19:32그렇죠.
00:19:54수고하자.
00:19:56I don't know.
00:19:58It's okay.
00:20:00I'll let you know.
00:20:00It's okay.
00:20:05It's okay.
00:20:14I can't wait.
00:20:15It's okay.
00:20:16I can't wait.
00:20:16Oh, yeah.
00:20:18I know.
00:20:19Yeah, great.
00:20:20Maybe.
00:20:21I know, eh.
00:20:22Yeah, you know.
00:20:25Oh, my God, my God, my God.
00:20:29I got to see you next time.
00:20:39It's time for us.
00:20:39See you next time.
00:20:42I'm going to get you next time.
00:20:43.
00:20:49I'm not a good guy.
00:20:51What the hell are you doing?
00:20:54You're like, you're like, you're like, you're like, you're like, you're like, you're like...
00:21:41Stop.
00:21:43I can't believe that you're going to go to the house.
00:21:46I can't believe that you're going to go to the house.
00:22:13I've got a...
00:22:14You know what I'm saying?
00:22:18What the hell is that I'm saying?
00:22:19PTSD, yes?
00:22:20Yes, so that's right.
00:22:23This is a bad thing.
00:22:26I'm sorry to me, but I am sorry to myself.
00:22:28It's a bad thing.
00:22:29I'm sorry to talk about it.
00:22:31It's a bad thing and it's a bad thing.
00:22:33I'm sorry to hear you, it's a bad thing.
00:22:36I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I'm sorry.
00:23:07My father?
00:23:12He was the only one in my class, when it was in college.
00:23:15When I was in college, I was in high school.
00:23:16So it's not good.
00:23:19When I was in college, it was still in college.
00:23:23But for school 2nd class of 1st was family.
00:23:28It's been a long time for me.
00:23:30It's been a long time for me.
00:23:32It's been a long time for me.
00:23:43I'm not going to be a long time for me.
00:23:51I'm not going to be a long time for me.
00:23:53Yes.
00:23:55It's been a long time for me.
00:23:58It's been a long time for me.
00:24:07I'm not going to go to college.
00:24:10I was looking for a long time for me to go to college.
00:24:13I'm not going to go to college.
00:24:13But my pain was my mind and my mind completely.
00:24:21It was just a moment of pain.
00:24:23It was a long time for me.
00:24:26I was so tired.
00:24:27So I'm going to go to college.
00:24:29I'm going to go to college.
00:24:33I'm going to go to college.
00:24:34I'm not going to go to college.
00:24:37I'm not going to go to college.
00:24:38I'm going to go to college.
00:24:40I was like, I was like, I don't know.
00:24:44I was like, I was like, I'm like, you know?
00:24:49I was like, you know, I'm so sorry.
00:24:50When you eat the first meeting, you have been a responsibility.
00:24:54We met you in a lot of time?
00:25:06Now I'm going to sleep.
00:25:09I'm going to sleep now.
00:25:11I'm going to sleep now.
00:25:24I'll go.
00:25:25Okay.
00:25:28Who will win?
00:25:31I'll go.
00:25:32Yes.
00:25:33Yes.
00:25:36You're welcome.
00:25:37Yes, you're welcome.
00:25:40Okay.
00:25:43Yes, you're welcome.
00:25:44Yes.
00:25:46It's good.
00:25:47I'm sorry.
00:25:47Yes, I'm sorry.
00:25:49Yes, I'm not sure.
00:25:49Yes?
00:25:51If you ask me, I'd like to ask you.
00:25:53No?
00:25:55Yes.
00:25:55Yes.
00:25:55Yes.
00:25:58Yes.
00:25:59There is a source of 독 and so on.
00:26:02If we have a law firm, we can make an option for a call option.
00:26:07So, if you have a company of the company's high-end core,
00:26:12then you can have a company of high-end core to take credit.
00:26:19Then you have a company of the company's high-end core.
00:26:22That's amazing.
00:26:24Very, very ridiculous.
00:26:25He is кров다.
00:26:26What's the following?
00:26:27It's just amazing.
00:26:28He gave us the idea for a good price, and wouldn't be able to do with this statement?
00:26:38The security company has been making it faster than others.
00:26:41And it wasn't just that the concept of a.
00:26:43Pijol's wife, and he also took a lot of money from custody and peace from the state.
00:26:47But it was really the CEO of Yulim, Yulim, and Yulim, and Yulim, and Yulim, and Yulim, and Yulim.
00:27:10It's only the following.
00:27:11If you think about driving, it's not a case, that's why you Area has a business.
00:27:16I've been the CEO, and me raising my hand on it.
00:27:20So I'm so excited to be brought up to Marc H Rose.
00:27:21Who's 285 right now.
00:27:24So you can, without saying it, there's no way.
00:27:27But I'd no longer run up for the money against the estate website but no long term this.
00:27:33If you take this money, you have a $145 right now.
00:27:40They will never have fonctionzna.
00:27:42And the company is just a business owner.
00:27:46And yet, the company is a investment owner.
00:27:49And it's a competition owner.
00:27:51And it's a competition owner.
00:27:52And it's an interesting thing to get to the company.
00:27:58And it's a competition owner.
00:28:04It's not a competition owner.
00:28:10I'm not sure how much money is, but I don't think that's enough.
00:28:15I will tell you.
00:28:21Okay.
00:28:25Alright, I'll see you later, later.
00:28:27I will go to school.
00:28:32Yes, I'll see you later.
00:28:34See you later.
00:29:05I am lying to you.
00:29:06I am lying to you.
00:29:35You know what I mean?
00:29:45Yeah.
00:29:46I don't know what to do.
00:29:46You can't leave me alone.
00:29:46You can't leave me alone.
00:29:51I can't leave you alone.
00:29:57Hyaminah.
00:29:59Kim Jong-mi.
00:30:01She was about to get into a crime.
00:30:02She was a victim of being killed by Kim So-Yun.
00:30:05She was被죽 hit by Kim So-Yun.
00:30:08He was a victim of a crime in the case of Kim So-Yun.
00:30:15Her body was amusing.
00:30:17She was the one that was the ending.
00:30:22So...
00:30:23They're about to watch the girls' house.
00:30:26After all, my sister, I've been asking myself to wait for a couple of years on the interviewee I've seen.
00:30:28If I was to go back and return, I'm going to return to my life.
00:30:32Do you know what to do with my sister?
00:30:35I'm not sure.
00:30:39I don't think that's it.
00:30:41I've been to the past.
00:30:41I'm going to go back to my partner, not even to the past.
00:30:45I'll do the same thing.
00:30:50I don't think that's it.
00:30:51I'll do it.
00:30:53I'll do it.
00:30:54I'll do it.
00:30:56He is an open man, and he is a crime for him.
00:30:59He is a guilty standpoint, and he is a crime for the entire life.
00:31:02He is a crime for his and his parents.
00:31:06He is a crime forever, and I will not leave him.
00:31:11I'm not a fact, but it's a way that I find the worst in my life.
00:31:12I'm not a mistake, but I can't believe it.
00:31:29So, I can't believe this.
00:31:36More information.
00:31:38The name of the bandconnet, was Kim Youngmi and wrote, he didn't make much money.
00:31:41Yes.
00:31:43I didn't know his name.
00:31:47He didn't give us a little bit.
00:31:50He's so good at this point?
00:31:53Or...
00:31:56Or...
00:31:58Or...
00:31:58No, no, there's nothing.
00:32:06There's no reason there can be a thing.
00:32:08It's not possible.
00:32:09It's not possible.
00:32:11I've had a time to get into it.
00:32:12It's all right.
00:32:15But I don't have to be able to get into it.
00:32:21It's because of the child's being a hypocrite.
00:32:28But it's not that one's not that one's going to be a joke.
00:32:36You're not doing the wrong with your actions.
00:32:39I'm not doing the wrong with your actions.
00:32:42I want you to make it happen?
00:32:47It's a crime-making decision.
00:32:53Yes?
00:32:55You can't make a crime.
00:32:57But it's not going to be a crime.
00:33:02No.
00:33:03It's not going to do anything.
00:33:08I have to do it.
00:33:10I have to do it.
00:33:15But it's been a crime to do it.
00:33:20It's only a crime to do it.
00:33:20But it's a crime to get to it.
00:33:22The only other person in his mind is that I'd be able to get him.
00:33:28I can't believe that I can't.
00:33:33I'll be at your age.
00:33:36I know then.
00:33:40I'm going to let you know what I'm going to do.
00:33:43I'm going to let you know what I'm going to do.
00:33:55Are you okay?
00:34:19I'm going to let you know what I'm going to do.
00:34:28Yes.
00:34:28Are you okay?
00:34:29I'm already done.
00:34:33I'm sorry.
00:34:35I'm so grateful for you.
00:34:41Yes.
00:34:43Yes.
00:34:44Yes.
00:34:45Yes.
00:34:46I didn't know the case when I was in high school, but I was in the same high school.
00:34:52He was a violent victim of the victim, and he was a victim of the victim of the victim.
00:35:01Yes.
00:35:03You will have to get the murder of the murder of me.
00:35:05I have to take responsibility for you.
00:35:09What do you have to take care of?
00:35:53I'm sorry.
00:36:00You're not going to get out of here.
00:36:02What are you doing?
00:36:04You're not going to get out of here.
00:36:05If you don't get out of here, you'll get out of here.
00:36:08No, I'm not going to get out of here.
00:36:17I'm not going to get out of here.
00:36:47I'm not going to get out of here.
00:37:17I'm not going to get out of here.
00:37:19But I'll do the same thing.
00:37:20Is it I'll get out of here.
00:37:22I'll do that in a minute.
00:37:23Well, I'll get out of here.
00:37:27Then we'll get out of here from the recording.
00:37:36I'll get out of here.
00:37:44Based on I wanted to get out.
00:37:45Yes, it's hard to get.
00:37:49The student's name is Kim Soyun.
00:37:53You have a name.
00:37:58Kim Soyun?
00:37:59Yes, he's a junior.
00:38:02He's a junior, Kim Soyun.
00:38:03He's a junior, he's a junior.
00:38:11My daughter is a part of my daughter.
00:38:12I don't know who else.
00:38:16It's a part of my daughter.
00:38:20My daughter is a part of my daughter.
00:38:24She's a daughter.
00:38:26She's a daughter.
00:38:30She's a daughter.
00:38:30I'm sorry, I'm sorry.
00:38:34I'm sorry.
00:38:44I'm sorry.
00:38:44And we're going to live in the house.
00:38:49If she's a girl, she's a girl.
00:38:51She's a girl.
00:38:53She's a girl.
00:38:54I'm not going to go back to your daughter.
00:38:57It's not going to be close to your house.
00:39:01I'm not going to go back to my house.
00:39:05I was just going to go back to my house.
00:39:09I didn't have any time for Kim Soyun.
00:39:13She was just going to go to the United States.
00:39:18How can I get to my mind?
00:39:20I think I'm a victim of a victim of a victim.
00:39:26I would like to be a victim of a victim.
00:39:30I'm a victim of a victim.
00:39:32I'm a victim of a victim.
00:39:35I can't do it.
00:39:37I can't do it.
00:39:38Yes, I'll be able to do it.
00:39:42Yes, I'll be able to do it.
00:39:44Yes.
00:39:46Thank you very much.
00:39:51You have to do a lot of people.
00:39:57Yes, I do?
00:39:59Yes, I do.
00:40:01Yes then, of course, один could be really perfect.
00:40:04Of course, 사람이 너무 완벽하면 오히려 매력이 좀 벌해질 때가 있는데 대표님은 모든 걸 다 가져주면서도 묘한 여백이 느껴진다고 해야
00:40:18하나.
00:40:18그런데 그 여백이 오히려 더 큰 매력을 만들어내는 것 같아요.
00:40:27What's your favorite?
00:40:29What's your favorite?
00:40:30What's your favorite?
00:40:36So...
00:40:37So, I'm going to fill you up with that.
00:40:38So, I'm going to fill you up with that.
00:41:08So, I'm going to fill you up with that.
00:41:22변호인, 다시 말씀해 주시겠어요?
00:41:25피고인의 무죄를 주장합니다.
00:41:28그게 무슨 소리야?
00:41:30어떻게 무죄야?
00:41:32내 딸이 살해 다녔는데!
00:41:33방청석, 정숙하세요.
00:41:39변호인, 살인죄 무죄를 주장하는 것은 이 사건의 전체적인 맥락에서 피고인에게 매우 불리하게 작용될 수 있습니다.
00:41:47그 점 충분히 고려하셨습니까?
00:41:49네, 그 점은 충분히 고려하였습니다.
00:41:52그러나 본 사건에서 피고인의 행위는 법적으로 살인죄에 해당하지 않는다고 판단합니다.
00:41:58살인죄는 주관적 요소와 객관적 요소가 동시에 존재하여 성립합니다.
00:42:03다시 말해 죽이고자 하는 의식과 죽이려는 행동이 동시에 일어나야 되는데 본 사건에서는 그러지 않았습니다.
00:42:10간단히 예를 들어 설명해 보겠습니다.
00:42:12A라는 사람이 B를 죽이고 싶다고 생각을 했지만 실제로 아무런 행동을 하지 않았다면 살인죄는 성립하지 않습니다.
00:42:20다음 날 A가 마음을 바꿔 B를 죽이려는 의도가 사라진 상태에서 실수로 무언가를 떨어뜨려 사망에 이르렀다면 이 역시도 살인죄는 성립하지 않습니다.
00:42:33그 이유는 의식과 행위가 동시에 일어나지 않았기 때문입니다.
00:42:40피고인 김영미의 경우도 마찬가지입니다.
00:42:42첫 번째 행위인 둔기로 피해자를 가격했을 당시에는 상해의 고의가 있었으나 이로 인해 피해자는 사망에 이르지 않았습니다.
00:42:52두 번째 차량 충돌로 인해 피해자가 사망에 이르게 된 사고는 어떠한 고의를 가지고 행한 것이 아니라 예측 불가능한 상황에서 발생한
00:43:01사고였습니다.
00:43:02따라서 이 사건은 두 가지로 나누어서 판단을 해야 됩니다.
00:43:07첫 번째 행위로는 상위죄를.
00:43:09두 번째는 교통사고 처리 특례법에 따른 치사 혐의로 다루어야 됩니다.
00:43:14알겠습니다.
00:43:15검사 측.
00:43:17역시 강요민.
00:43:18공소사실 변경하시겠습니까?
00:43:23재판장님, 검찰은 피고인이 둔기로 피해자를 가격한 행위가 명백히 살인의 고의를 가지고 있다 판단하여
00:43:32기존의 살인죄를 주의적 공소사실로 유지하겠습니다.
00:43:36다만, 법원이 살인죄 성립 요건을 충족하지 못한다고 판단할 경우를 대비해 예비적 공소사실로 살인미수죄와 상해치사죄를 추가하고,
00:43:46나아가 상해죄 및 교통사고 처리 특례법에 따른 치사 혐의도 포함하겠습니다.
00:43:52변호인, 공소장 변경에 이의 있으십니까?
00:43:56이의 없습니다.
00:44:00질러났으니 이제 결정적 한방을 찾아야죠.
00:44:04네, 막막하지만 최선을 다해보려고요.
00:44:09아무리 의견서 잘 쓰고 결론 잘해봐야 그것만으로는 승소할 수 없어요.
00:44:14좋은 원석으로 가공을 해야 좋은 결과물이 나옵니다.
00:44:17원석에 해당하는 유리한 사실관계를 찾아내는 게 핵심이에요.
00:44:21가공에 해당하는 변론은 주장의 근거를 효과적으로 제시할 뿐 실체적 근거를 만들어낼 수는 없으니까요.
00:44:28네, 알겠습니다.
00:44:31나는 일정이 있어서.
00:44:37오늘 뭐 있었다?
00:44:41강요민 변호사.
00:44:43진짜 멋있었어요.
00:44:45강요민 변호사.
00:44:47감사해요.
00:44:48저는 사고 현장에 한번 가봐야겠어요.
00:44:51지난번에 갔다 왔잖아.
00:44:53놓치고 있는 게 있을 수도 있지.
00:44:55아니, 수사기관도 아닌데 뭘 그렇게까지 해?
00:44:57좋은 원석 찾으러 한번 가봐야지.
00:45:01변호사 수입료도 대신 내주기로 했다면서요.
00:45:04진짜?
00:45:06왜 그렇게까지?
00:45:10우리가 도와줄게.
00:45:11응.
00:45:12우리가 도와주자.
00:45:12말만 해.
00:45:13뭐 도와줄까?
00:45:14좋은 원석을 찾아줘.
00:45:35참고할 만한 자료 이메일로 보냈으니 살펴봐라.
00:45:39그리고 김영미 수입료는 네 계좌로 입금했다.
00:45:44지은이한테 들었어.
00:45:46얘는 왜 엄마한테 얘기해가지고.
00:45:51그리고 그걸 왜 엄마가 안 해?
00:46:30이거야.
00:46:32이거야.
00:46:50어.
00:46:57미안해.
00:46:58사무실이 아니라 이런 데서 회의하자고 해서.
00:47:00Why?
00:47:01I'm trying to get it.
00:47:03I'm trying to find that I'm not good.
00:47:06I'll tell you that I'm not sure.
00:47:10No.
00:47:13You're going to eat it.
00:47:20I'm sorry.
00:47:24I'm going to sit on this.
00:47:26What are you doing here?
00:47:28It is just the fact of what you're saying.
00:47:29I'm trying.
00:47:30There she is.
00:47:33What are you crying?
00:47:36You are lying!
00:47:38You are lying!
00:47:40You are lying!
00:47:40Yourldigt baby, What do you say?
00:47:43I'll see you!
00:47:45I'm lying!
00:47:46No, that's not working!
00:47:48I'm lying!
00:47:49You're lying!
00:47:50You are lying!
00:47:51I'm lying!
00:47:53You're lying!
00:47:53You're lying!
00:47:54It's a big deal, huh?
00:47:56Well, you know, you're getting to your job, right?
00:47:59Oh, your job is hard to try and keep an eye on your job.
00:48:03And you're just a cafe, it's an industry company.
00:48:06You're in the company's shop.
00:48:09You're you?
00:48:11You're you!
00:48:13I'm a really good job!
00:48:13Yeah, I'm so grateful to you.
00:48:15I think I'll get you a lot.
00:48:17I'm so glad to be here.
00:48:18Oh!
00:48:19I'm so glad to be here!
00:48:25There is no way for the stock.
00:48:26Do you want to buy it here?
00:48:28No.
00:48:28Why are you doing it?
00:48:30I'm so scared.
00:48:35I'm not talking about what...
00:48:36I'm not talking about this stuff.
00:48:39I'm not talking about that.
00:48:40What are you doing?
00:48:42What are you doing here?
00:48:43I'm here at the manager.
00:48:44I'm here at the end of the day.
00:48:47I'm here at the end of the day.
00:48:49What do you do?
00:48:51I'm here at the end of the day.
00:48:53You know, you don't even know what the hell is, you know?
00:48:58I don't know.
00:49:00We just go to the office.
00:49:01I'm going to go to the hospital.
00:49:03I'm going to go to the hospital.
00:49:05I'm going to go to the hospital.
00:49:14I'm going to go to the hospital.
00:49:15Why don't you go to the hospital?
00:49:19내가 해결할 수 있는데 왜 함부로 나서냐고.
00:49:24너여서 나선 거 아니야.
00:49:26생각하지 마.
00:49:36너 근데 이렇게 따지는 이유가 뭐야?
00:49:39다른 사람이 도와줬어도 이렇게 따질래?
00:49:41아니, 고맙다고 했겠지.
00:49:46자식들은 부모가 무슨 전생의 죄인이라도 되는 줄 알아?
00:49:49부모는 자식이 상처 주면 바로 치유되는 성자라도 되는 줄 아는 거야?
00:49:53아니야.
00:49:55우리도 생책이 나면 잘 극복 안 돼.
00:49:59지금 부모한테 난리치는 게 지들 벌린 줄 알아.
00:50:03엄마.
00:50:10왜?
00:50:13연락해도 돼?
00:50:16어.
00:50:17번호가 뭔데?
00:50:32자진아 안 할게.
00:50:35어.
00:50:36어.
00:50:58예쁘네요.
00:51:01곱째 지는지 피는지도 모르고 지냈는데.
00:51:04가끔 저랑 이렇게 나오시면 되겠네요.
00:51:09같이 일하는 변호사들한테 얘기 들었어요.
00:51:12눈에 띄게 실력이 늘었다 그러던데?
00:51:14아유, 아니요, 아닙니다.
00:51:16아직 한참 멀었죠, 뭐.
00:51:17그래도 노력은 많이 한 것 같아요.
00:51:23처음 M&A팀에 들어왔을 때는 전문 용어가 너무 어려워가지고 진짜 반도 못 알아들었거든요.
00:51:30이게 분명히 한국말을 하고 있는데 프렌치를 하는 건지 뭔지.
00:51:35그럴 수 있죠, 맞아요.
00:51:37로스쿨에서 또 가르치는 건 또 아니라서.
00:51:40맞아요.
00:51:41그래서 녹음하는 습관을 들었어요.
00:51:45그리고 완벽하게 이해가 될 때까지 듣고 또 듣고.
00:51:51아유, 그랬죠.
00:51:53좋은 방법인데?
00:51:57추워도 돼요?
00:51:58아니에요, 아니에요.
00:52:34그래서 사진을 찍었다는 거야, 못 찍었다는 거야?
00:52:38예, 그.
00:52:40찍긴 찍었는데요.
00:52:43실수로 삭제가 돼가지고.
00:52:45야!
00:52:45너 인마 무슨 일을 그따구로 해.
00:52:49수요일 밤에 또 만나기로 했습니다.
00:52:52호텔에서요.
00:52:53아, 그래?
00:52:54아유, 그럼 젠장 얘기하지.
00:52:57권대표.
00:52:58급했네, 급했어?
00:53:00이번에 실수하지 마.
00:53:02예, 알겠습니다.
00:53:05수요일.
00:53:23그게 무슨 소리야?
00:53:24윤림의 인여 인력 중에 고대표가 과거에 신세진 사람들도 있습니다.
00:53:30자기 손으로 직접 자르기는 어려웠을 거고 고대표 입장에서는 권나연이라는 도구를 이용해 구조조정을 한 다음 일이 끝나면 대표직에서 내칠 명분을 만들려고
00:53:39하겠죠.
00:53:40그렇게까지 한다고?
00:53:42일리 있는 얘기 같은데요.
00:53:45조만간 고대표 밑에 있는 누군가가 권나연을 쳐내기 위한 밑작업을 할 겁니다.
00:53:51고승철 대표는 자기 손이 더러워지는 걸 극도로 싫어하기 때문에 직접 나서지는 않을 거예요.
00:53:57하두식이 며칠 전에 점심 같이 하자고 연락하긴 했는데.
00:54:02하두식이 고대표 행동대장인 거 아시죠?
00:54:05그 정도는 알지.
00:54:07하두식은 고승철과 결이 다른 사람입니다.
00:54:09음지에 있는 사람이죠.
00:54:11상대의 약점을 잡을 때 털어서 안 나오면 만들어서라도 잡죠.
00:54:15그것도 아주 지저분한 방식으로.
00:54:17지저분한 방식?
00:54:20여자부처, 적대, 불륜, 성상납 그런 거요.
00:54:24대표님한테도 그런 식의 접근을 할 겁니다.
00:54:27아는 게 그것밖에 없으니.
00:54:29설마 나한테 남자라도 붙인다는 거야?
00:54:32그럴 수 있어요.
00:54:33수준이 거기까지니 방법도 그 정도일 수밖에 없죠.
00:54:36망치를 들면 모든 게 못으로 보이는 법이니까요.
00:54:40하...
00:54:54재판장님.
00:54:55피고인은 둔기로 피해자의 머리를 가격했고 이는 피해자를 사망의 위험에 빠뜨린 초기 행위였습니다.
00:55:01대법원 판례에서도 피고인이 피해자를 구타한 후 사망했다고 오인하여 매장에 지식사에 이르게 한 경우 전 과정을 개괄적으로 하나의 살인 행위로 인정했습니다.
00:55:14검사가 인용한 대법원 판례는 본 사건과 본질적으로 다릅니다.
00:55:19판례에서의 피해자의 피고인은 피해자가 사망했다고 오인해 매장이라는 후속 행위를 시도하였고 그 행위가 직접적인 사망 원인이었습니다.
00:55:28그러나 본 사건에서는 피해자의 새로운 독립적 개입이 있었습니다.
00:55:32이로 인해 검사가 주장하는 행위의 연속성은 단절되었습니다.
00:55:36독립적 개입이라니 구체적으로 뭘 말하는 거죠?
00:55:41피해자의 상습적인 무단 횡단 습관입니다.
00:55:48피해자 최소윤은 평소 교통법규를 자주 위반했습니다.
00:55:53사망 3개월 전에도 무단 횡단을 하다가 차량에 치여 통원 치료를 받은 기록이 있으며 최근 3년간 12건의 교통법규 위반 기록이 있습니다.
00:56:02그리고 결정적으로.
00:56:16다음 공판에서 검사는 둔기로 가격한 행위와 차량 충돌로 인한 행위를 연속적인 하나의 행위로 간주해야 한다는 주장을 할 거야.
00:56:25이를 반박하기 위해서는 행위와 사망 사이의 인과관계가 단절되어 있음을 입증해야 해.
00:56:32즉 독립적인 개입을 통해 인과관계의 연속성을 끊어야만 검사의 주장은 효과적으로 반박할 수 있어.
00:56:39최소윤 고등학생 때 내가 차를 칠 뻔한 적 있어.
00:56:44내 차는 녹색 신호에 따라 정상적으로 주행 중이었는데 최소윤이 갑자기 도로 한가운데로 뛰어들었지.
00:56:52그 도로는 왕복 4차선으로 보행자가 건너기엔 매우 위험했어.
00:56:57주변에 육교와 지하보도가 있었지만 최소윤은 무단 횡단을 선택했어.
00:57:02사람은 쉽게 변하지 않아.
00:57:06이거야.
00:57:10나 좀 도와줘요.
00:57:13우선 사고 현장 CCTV부터 확보해야 돼요.
00:57:166개월치 정도?
00:57:18아, 증거보전 청구부터 해야 되지?
00:57:21피해자의 교통법규 위반 기록도 필요해요.
00:57:25피고인이 피해자를 둔기로 가격한 장소는 피해자의 단골 술집 근처로 해당 술집의 주차장은 도로 건너편에 위치해 있습니다.
00:57:36사고 현장은 보행자가 건너기 위험한 왕복 6차선 도로임에도 불구하고 피해자는 무단 횡단을 선택했습니다.
00:57:44뿐만 아니라 피해자는 사망 전 6개월 동안 해당 술집을 34번 방문하면서 매번 동일한 방식으로 무단 횡단을 반복했습니다.
00:57:56두 번 결과 둥기로 인한 외상은 생명에 지장을 주지 않은 뇌진탕이었고 사망 사인은 차량 충돌로 인한 흉부 압박에 의한 심장
00:58:05파열로 확인되었습니다.
00:58:06지금 내 딸 죽음이 내 딸 책임이라는 거야?
00:58:14그게 말이 돼?
00:58:17정숙하세요.
00:58:18자꾸만 소란 피우면 퇴정 조치 시키겠습니다.
00:58:22아니.
00:58:23야, 명숙아.
00:58:24야, 하지마, 하지마, 하지마.
00:58:25진정해.
00:58:26진정해.
00:58:27아...
00:58:27진정해.
00:58:30아...
00:58:32검사 측 주장을 받아들인다면 피고인의 행위와 피해자의 사망 간의 인과관계를 지나치게 포괄적으로 해석하는 결과를 초래합니다.
00:58:41본 사건은 살인죄가 아닌 둥기로 인한 상해죄와 차량 사고로 인한 사망이라는 두 개의 독립된 사건으로 분리시켜 판단되어야 됩니다.
00:58:50이 주장을 빗발침할 증거 자료 제출하겠습니다.
00:58:58검사, 구형하시죠.
00:59:03피고인에게 징역 25년을 선고해 주시길 바랍니다.
00:59:08변호인 최후 변론해 주세요.
00:59:18재판장님, 저는 오늘 이 자리에서 피고인의 변호인이 아닌 이 사건의 책임을 통감하는 한 사람으로서 말씀드리고자 합니다.
00:59:28피고인 김영민은 과거 심각한 학교폭력의 피해자였습니다.
00:59:34그리고 저는 그 폭력을 외면했던 방관자 중 한 명이었습니다.
00:59:40그게 무슨 뜻이죠?
00:59:4412년 전 피고인이 학교폭력을 당했던 당시의 영상을 증거로 제출하고자 합니다.
00:59:49재판장님, 해당 영상의 출처가 불분명하고 이 사건과의 직접적인 연관성도 없습니다.
00:59:54또한 피해자와 유족들에게 심각한 2차 피해를 초래할 가능성이 큽니다.
00:59:58맞습니다.
00:59:59검사 측 주장대로 이 영상은 본 사건과 직접적인 관련이 없습니다.
01:00:05그러나 피고인의 양형 판단에 있어서 중요한 자료입니다.
01:00:10학폭 피해로 인한 피고인의 고통이 현재 그녀의 정신적 상태와 범행에 미친 역량을 보여주는 증거이기 때문입니다.
01:00:18피고인의 양형 자료로 제출된 증거라면 제한적으로 인정할 수 있습니다.
01:00:27영상 공개 허가합니다.
01:00:30뭐야?
01:00:31내 딸은 죽었는데 지금 학폭 영상을 틀겠다고?
01:00:35그깟 학폭 영상이 뭔데?
01:00:39방청석 정숙하세요.
01:00:41당신이 그러고도 판사야?
01:00:44왜?
01:00:46왜!
01:00:48살인자를 두고 사는데!
01:00:50경희 퇴장 시키세요.
01:00:51놔!
01:00:53놔!
01:00:54놔!
01:00:55놔!
01:00:56놔!
01:00:57내가 사과를 버릴 거야!
01:00:58너를 다시 죽여버릴 거야!
01:01:01변호인, 계속 진행하세요.
01:01:04재판장님, 영상을 공개하기 전 피고인의 트라우마를 최소화하기 위해 영상상영 중 피고인이 내게 되었습니다.
01:01:12눈 가리개와 소음을 차단하는 헤드폰을 착용해도 될런지요.
01:01:16네, 허락합니다.
01:01:22눈 가리시고 음악 좀 듣고 계시겠어요?
01:01:25변호사님.
01:01:41변호사님.
01:01:44네, 너.
01:01:54저 тоже.
01:02:02진짜, 저.
01:02:04어떻게.
01:02:07우리.
01:02:08우리.
01:02:10하나, 둘, 셋, 둘, 셋.
01:02:11I'll go.
01:02:12I'll go.
01:02:37I'll go.
01:02:42I can't believe it.
01:02:43No, I can't believe it.
01:03:10One, two, three!
01:03:14Stop it, stop it, stop it!
01:03:19Her son is in the class of the middle school and middle school of school.
01:03:26She was a child for a while.
01:03:28She was a good girl.
01:03:37I am an actress for a long time.
01:03:38If he wants to be an actress, he's a patron.
01:03:45He was a man who was in prison.
01:03:54I'm for the case of justice now.
01:03:56I don't know if I was a young man who was 봤 yet.
01:04:04He said that he is a young man who has been surrounded by a young man.
01:04:10However, if we were to end this case, we'd be able to make this happen.
01:04:13But if we're going to end this case, we're going to have another life that we can do.
01:04:18But if we're going to end this case, we're going to end this life.
01:04:27We're going to end this life.
01:04:37The real human life is a public life that is a personal life that has been formed without our own
01:04:41human rights.
01:04:44It's a new system of high-class life that is part of the world.
01:04:46That's how we will be done.
01:04:51I will process an entire life that will discuss.
01:05:23This part of the
01:05:30We'll see you later.
01:05:31I did not know what the problem was.
01:05:37I will pay attention.
01:05:41I will pay attention.
01:05:53Thank you very much.
01:06:28Thank you very much.
01:07:04Thank you very much.
01:07:43Thank you very much.
01:07:44Thank you very much.
01:07:44Thank you very much.
01:08:03Thank you very much.
01:08:12Thank you very much.
01:08:15Thank you very much.
01:08:25Thank you very much.
01:08:39Thank you very much.
01:09:05Thank you very much.
01:09:17Thank you very much.
01:09:40Thank you very much.
01:09:42Thank you very much.
01:09:49Thank you very much.
01:09:51Thank you very much.
01:09:54Thank you very much.
01:10:02Thank you very much.
01:10:04Thank you very much.
01:10:06Thank you very much.
01:10:10Thank you very much.
01:10:12Thank you very much.
01:10:18Thank you very much.
01:10:19Thank you very much.
01:10:27Thank you very much.
01:10:39He was also a judge, and he was a judge.
01:10:40It's all good.
01:10:45It was a judge of the court,
01:10:46I think it was very good.
01:10:53Really?
01:10:57He was a judge of the opinion,
01:11:01and he was a judge of the opinion.
01:11:03He was a judge of the gift.
01:11:05That is actually not a problem at all.
01:11:09Well, it won't be good.
01:11:15I'll be well past, but it's not a great deal.
01:11:16Okay.
01:11:18Very good.
01:11:22What should I say?
01:11:26What are you talking about?
01:11:30She has looked at her and saw her osteoporаты.
01:11:33She looks blind for me.
01:11:39She looks blind for me.
01:11:42She looks blind for me.
01:11:44I made a bunch of different pieces.
01:11:46I had to guess.
01:11:48I could not to think I was going to be like the best, but kind of like I said.
01:11:51I can't think about it.
01:11:53It's amazing.
01:11:56You've been able to do certain part of it.
01:11:59You've made a number of three carbohydrate years?
01:12:12It's a lot.
01:12:13Have you seen that?
01:12:14I don't know.
01:12:18I don't know.
01:12:22I'm not sure...
01:12:23You're just so happy.
01:12:24I'm not sure.
01:12:25Yes, I will.
01:12:58You get me home, no matter where we are.
01:13:07You make me whore, in your love I don't sorrow.
01:13:17You get me home, no matter where you are.
01:13:21You help me close in your arms.
01:13:26With you, I'm safe for more tears.
01:13:32You got me home.
01:13:37How are you doing?
01:13:38First of all, you can do all the rules.
01:13:41What are you doing?
01:13:42What are you doing?
01:13:43Hey, you got me too.
01:13:46I can't get mine.
01:13:49This time you can't tell me about me.
01:13:50I will go for a good time.
01:13:52And I'll have a chance to talk.
01:13:54And I can tell you what are you doing?
01:13:56What do you decide to do?
01:13:57Is it?
01:13:58There's a judge.
01:13:58There's a judge.
01:14:01I'll be in front of you.
01:14:03I'll have a task to excuse me.
01:14:04You'll find me.
01:14:05I can't find you.
01:14:12you
01:14:59you
Comments