Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 6 minutes ago
Von der Leyen 'acting outside of competence' on Iran war, former France ambassador Araud says

Gérard Araud told Euronews Ursula von der Leyen is overstepping her mandate on foreign policy as Commission chief and pushing a German line on the 27. While not historically a competence of the Commission, von der Leyen is establishing her own line on geopolitics - not without friction.

READ MORE : http://www.euronews.com/2026/03/10/von-der-leyen-acting-outside-of-competence-on-iran-war-former-france-ambassador-araud-says

Subscribe to our channel. Euronews is available on Dailymotion in 12 languages

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:08Ambassador, thank you very much for joining us on Euronews.
00:12The war is ongoing, but the president of the U.S. seems to be changing the goalpost.
00:17First, you said this is a four to five weeks war, and now he says it's almost practically done.
00:22Is there really a plan?
00:23Well, that's a question that we are all, you know, really, it's a general question.
00:30What is the goal of this operation?
00:33And is it going to change?
00:35Because at the beginning of the operation, Donald Trump, President Trump, was saying that he wanted to change the regime
00:43to this, really, in Iran.
00:45After that, it was the question, the nuclear question, which was raised by the Americans.
00:50And now it's a question of, in a sense, destroying the military Iranian apparatus.
00:58Well, the general impression is that Trump really thought that Iran would react the way that Venezuela reacted.
01:07Apparently, it didn't work.
01:09Apparently, the Iranians really have made the choice of waiting.
01:15I'm sure that they believe that sooner or later, the president, President Trump, went, as the Americans say, taco.
01:25You know that they taco, the American president is going, in a sense, to chicken out.
01:31And really, to say, considering the price of the oil, considering the situation in the Gulf, that basically, at some
01:40moment, Trump is going to say, I am the winner, and it's the end of the story.
01:46I think that's what we are facing right now.
01:49I've got to ask you, of course, this is a very different President Trump, because he always said he didn't
01:54want to force changes in countries.
01:56And now we're seeing a very different foreign policy agenda.
01:59So I've got to ask you, is this really an American war, or is this really Israel dragging the U
02:04.S. into war?
02:05I think it's a good question, because you know that Trump, really, even before he entered the political life, actually
02:13was criticizing the presidents, the American presidents before him, because he was opposed to these military endeavors throughout the world.
02:23And for the MAGA crowd, I think it was an important element that the Americans, you know, really were not
02:30going to waste their money while, you know, while, you know, the U.S. itself, there are a lot of
02:37things to change.
02:40Apparently, and it's quite a surprise, and frankly, personally, I didn't expect it, suddenly you have Donald Trump, who is
02:48engaged into a sort of neoconservative policy.
02:51The only difference right now with George H. Bush was, at the time, George H. Bush was dreaming of bringing
02:58democracy.
02:59He was using American military force to export democracy.
03:05While with Trump, Trump doesn't care about democracy.
03:09So, the question is, and it's a question which is raised by a lot of Americans, is whether it's a
03:17decision that really Netanyahu has succeeded to convince Trump to enter into this war.
03:26I think it's a very negative question for the future of Israel, because it's going to be raised, really, it's
03:34going to feed in the MAGA crowd, where anti-Semitism has always been, you know, really torment.
03:41Really, I think it could be, it could have very negative consequences on the relationship between the U.S. and
03:49Israel.
03:50Of course, and we talked about anti-Semitism here, too, in Europe, but I've got to ask you then, if
03:55this is really an effort pushed by Israel, what is the goal for Prime Minister Netanyahu?
04:00I think for Israel, in a sense, everything has changed October the 7th.
04:06Still, October the 7th, there is a sort of balance in the Middle East, really, and the border with Lebanon
04:15is still, and with Hamas, actually, there is, you know, also a modular event between Israel and Hamas, since Israel
04:25was accepting Qatar to send money, to bring money to Hamas.
04:30So, there is a sort of balance.
04:33October the 7th was such a trauma for the Israelis, and also was so serious that Israel had decided that
04:43we couldn't go down, go back to the situation of October the 6th.
04:48We wanted to really to change the geopolitical situation in the Middle East, in a sense, to impose a sort
04:58of hegemony in the Middle East, and have been quite successful with the Hezbollah, really quite successful.
05:07So, the last obstacle to the Israeli military supremacy is Iran.
05:15So, sooner or later, really, Israel and Iran would confront really regularly and very directly.
05:26So, I think for the Israelis right now, the question is to get rid of Iran as a great power
05:33in the Middle East.
05:34In the region?
05:35And that's what they are trying to do.
05:37So, if tomorrow, I think Trump is tackle, if Trump is really saying, I'm leaving, I've won the war, this
05:46time, I'm not convinced that Israel will stop, to stop the bombings.
05:50Of course, the message that we get with the line of succession is that the hardliners are still in place
05:56in Tehran.
05:57How do you see this playing out?
05:58Is there a scenario in which, ultimately, they have no other choice but to get on the phone and talk
06:03to President Trump, even if, until now, it's just been retaliation, and they've not picked up the phone that we
06:08know, to Washington?
06:09No, I think, unfortunately, I think that if I were, you know, I tried to be, if I were an
06:14ayatollah, I would certainly do what the Iranians are doing right now.
06:18And I think that right now, they hope, again, as I have said, that Trump will leave, saying, I've won,
06:26I've killed Khamenei, and I have destroyed all the military capabilities of Iran, I'm leaving.
06:32And the result would be to have the bold states suddenly facing, I think, a revenge, a full of, really,
06:43an Islamic republic full of revenge.
06:46And, really, look at Khamenei, the sovereign, you know, the new, apparently, the new supreme leader.
06:53Really, you have to imagine, his father, his mother, his son, his brother, his sister-in-law, his nephew, have
07:02been killed in a few days by the Americans.
07:05Really, he's a human being, whatever you think of him, he's going to make, I think, if the Americans leave,
07:12and I think they don't have the choice at the end of the day, he will want to have a
07:16revenge.
07:17And the gold stage will be actually very vulnerable.
07:21Of course, there's a question around the security himself for this individual.
07:24But I've got to ask you about the Europeans.
07:27Where is Europe in this crisis?
07:29And the fact I've got to ask you says a lot.
07:30When I was teaching international relations in Paris, I was always saying, if you have a question about Europeans, the
07:37first sentence that you should use is, the Europeans will be divided.
07:42We are, by definition, divided because we are, you know, we have different powers, different geography, with different history.
07:50Obviously, you see, for instance, that Germany is sticking to the U.S. and sticking to Israel.
07:57It's really, it's obvious.
07:58Most of the Europeans, I would say, are trying to hide themselves.
08:03They don't want to be taken between the American hammer and, again, maybe the Israeli handrail or the Iranian handrail.
08:14So most of Europeans are looking the other way and waiting for the end of the crisis.
08:21You have some countries which are more active, Spain, Spain has been really on the front line of really, really,
08:29really sticking to the international law and has been very active.
08:36Some say Spain has now taken the part of France.
08:39If there was an echo to the Iran invasion, some would say Spain is now the French voice at the
08:44time.
08:44Would you agree?
08:45I think, I think, in a sense, to be frank, I think the Spanish prime minister was on the front
08:50line.
08:51The French have rejoined, really have rejoined the Spaniards.
08:55And now, one by one, the European countries are really assessing that the operation is in a dead end and
09:05also assessing that their public opinion is more and more moved by the suffering of the civilian population in Iran,
09:16but also in Lebanon.
09:16And if I may, just lastly, of course, the one woman who seems to want to be very active is
09:23the head of the European Commission.
09:24Are you surprised by the role that the head of the Commission is playing and wants to play?
09:28Is she in the wrong or ultimately is she a smart operator?
09:31I am a bit, you know, really, I'm a bit surprised because she's out of her competence.
09:36You know, the treaty, the European treaty, which is the basis of the European Union, doesn't give her any special
09:45competence in foreign policy.
09:48On the top of that, she's she's sticking to a line, which, again, it's not the line of Spain.
09:54It's not the line of France.
09:56It's a German line, really, so especially which is more important, in a sense, than the treaties, is the fact
10:06that the Europeans are the last flag bearer of international law.
10:12So, really, it's, I should say, the DNA of the European Union is the international law.
10:20And to hear the president of the European Commission saying that, which really, it's not that important, the way the
10:29Germans actually are saying what the Germans are saying.
10:33Frankly, you can really, you can ask a lot of questions about that.
10:38Yes, I think there is a division in the European Union, not at a very bad moment.
10:45But again, as I've told you, with the Europeans, they're always divided.
10:49But on this point, just very briefly, what she did say is that the EU stands for international law, but
10:54it cannot be the custodian of a world that no longer exists.
10:58Does she have a point or is she in the wrong?
11:00Is this the wrong time to make that statement?
11:02You know, frankly, to be for, it's a bit like somebody who is, well, it's very French, who is somebody
11:10who is in the middle of adultery and is going and is saying, oh, actually, I am in favor of
11:16the principle of marital fidelity while committing adultery.
11:23It's not, it's not, the international law is not only a principle, you know, really coming from heaven, but it's
11:31a policy.
11:33And which means that it should have consequences.
11:37And we should, the Europeans, really, in a sense, saying we have to react, to react against Israel and against
11:47the U.S.
11:48Well, Ambassador, thank you so much on the geopolitics and marriage, too.
11:52Thank you for joining us.
11:53Always great to see you.
11:55A pleasure.
11:56A pleasure.
Comments

Recommended