- 8 months ago
- #iwd2026
- #thefutureisfemale
Civil society groups have drafted a Gender Parity Political Representation Act to push parties to field at least 30% women candidates. But beyond legislation, the real question is what happens inside political parties as that’s where candidates are ultimately chosen. To celebrate International Women’s Day #IWD2026 Melisa Idris steps outside the studio for a special episode of #TheFutureIsFemale, a panel discussion recorded at an event organised by EMPOWER, MalaysiaKini, and the Canadian High Commission in Malaysia.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:10Hello and good evening. I'm Melissa Idris. Welcome to The Future is Female. This is the
00:15show where we find the extraordinary in every woman. Now to celebrate International Women's
00:20Day this year, we're stepping outside the studio to bring you a special episode where we have a
00:27forum discussion, a panel discussion at a forum to discuss the Gender Parity in Political
00:34Representation Act. It's an event organized by Malaysia Kini and Empower supported by the
00:40Canadian High Commission and it's going to be an exciting panel discussion. Let's find out more.
00:47What's wonderful is we have some politicians, elected representatives and political insiders
00:53here with us today that we can pose this question too. So let's begin, shall we? And if I may
00:58put YB
01:01Shukie on the spot. Sorry, you knew I was going to begin with you. So DAP has, as Gopal mentioned,
01:10is the one of the parties, or I think it's the only parties committed to fielding 30%
01:16women candidates in the next general elections. Walk us through the process actually. For all of us who
01:21are not politicians, who may not know what goes on behind the scenes, what is that process like
01:27when a party determines who they're fielding in elections? Walk us through what they're considering
01:35and who makes that decision.
01:39Thank you, Melissa. Can you hear me? Yes. Okay. Thank you, Melissa and all my panelists and thank you for
01:45inviting me here. So for DAP, there is no specific rule saying that how we select a candidate, but
01:53basically two different routes. The first one, capitalization. So you need to rise up from grass
02:00route along the rank and file, then reach the status of candidates. That is the first route. The normal
02:07route, just like any other ordinary member. Another one is of course parachuted, handpicked. I wouldn't
02:13should say parachuted, but handpicked. For example, I myself was handpicked by Anthony Locke many years ago
02:20to join a party because nobody wanted to join an opposition, a perpetuate opposition party then.
02:29So he engaged me, asked me to join. And within about two, I think within three years,
02:36yeah, I get the candidature after two years. Compared to many other veterans or members who joined much
02:43earlier, a longer time, but never gotten the chance to be fielded. I am the one who considered
02:49fast track, but yeah, not parachuted. I go back to my kampong anyway. Yeah. So, but it was considered
02:58another route. So basically it's two different routes. Okay. All right. So, so having said that,
03:03that's the different ways to get there, but who makes that determination? Who's the one deciding?
03:11Is it the party president? Is there a committee? Who decides in DAP? Depends. So a decade ago,
03:20Anthony Locke was not even the number two or number three in the party. He was only director of the
03:27political
03:28education department in the party. So it was a very junior rank position in DAPCC. However, he decided that
03:38he needed to engage young candidates and not only him alone, many other leaders then, I'm sure you heard
03:44about Tony Pua. So Tony Pua aggressively engaged young female candidates and recruit them to join the
03:53party and eventually fielded them as candidates. For example, Dionian Qing, YP Dionian Qing, now the
03:59deputy minister for communication. She was fielded as candidate 2008, when she was only 26 or 28 years old.
04:07So he was engaged by Tony Pua. And beside her, Hannah Young, also 2008, engaged by Tony Pua. And beside
04:16that,
04:16my badge, Yobin, engaged by Tony Pua 2013. And after that, there are many, many other people. So I will
04:25say
04:25that not necessarily a high ranking leaders who can deliver the job, but I'm sure you'd notice, it was
04:34actually the man who took up the initiative. And especially within my party, I would thank the
04:41few male leaders who took the initiative and really proactively engage the potential,
04:48get the women in, and groom them, nurture them to become a candidate.
04:54Okay, so you need an ally within the, kind of, who is already sat at the table, who may have
05:01the
05:01source of power that you were talking about. Let's, we'll come back to DAP, but let's find out the PKR
05:07experience. YB Rosia, talk to me a little bit about the PKR process. What, is it similar to DAP,
05:14is it different, and your journey, personally? Okay, um, thank you very much. Actually, um,
05:20uh, PKR, we have, uh, a little bit structured, uh, procedures, yeah? We can go through division level,
05:28we can propose our name from division, or from the women's wing, we can propose a candidate,
05:35or we open for the public to, uh, we open to the public to, um, to propose their name, their
05:42own name,
05:42by certain, certain criteria they need to put in. So we have three ways, uh, opening the candidacy,
05:50so everybody can, can, uh, propose, and they themselves can propose as well to be a candidate.
05:56After that, what will happen, I'm talking about recent, uh, I don't know what, what will happen next
06:03here. Okay, because I am the, a part of the, uh, the committee that, uh, in charge of the candidates,
06:10in charge of the candidate to back through, to screening and everything, and then, uh, we shortlisted
06:16the name. After that, the committee will shortlisted, um, hit by the, uh, uh, deputy president,
06:25and then we have, uh, shortlisted three names. And then, for sure, I have benefit there, because I'm a
06:32lady, I'm a woman, you know? I always, uh, I always, um, remind them, we don't have enough candidate,
06:39a women's candidate. We should find, find. If the name is not from the party list, then we have the
06:46people that can, that already, um, uh, voluntary, uh, want to be the candidates. Why not we, uh, we scooping
07:09that. But, uh, consider, after we shortlist the three names, the three candidates, for sure, we have
07:15the incumbent, you know? Sometimes we have, um, we want more young leaders to be in. So, actually,
07:23we screening a lot of levels. Okay, can you, um, elaborate more? So, when you, that vetting process,
07:30that screening process, I am curious to know what makes the cut and where gender sits in that list.
07:36Ah, okay. So, because we have the mapping, uh, let's say, uh, um, Parti Park Keadilan,
07:42we're contesting about 106. Then, uh, 106 means we need to have 30 names, yeah, minimum. By right,
07:51you should put more, because we don't know whether it can win winnable or not. The problem is,
07:57we fight for the winnable six, but sometimes we cannot get it, yeah? Or just, uh, okay, enough for the
08:05numbers. Now you have, you're getting 30 names, but it's okay, it's enough. So, can you imagine
08:12me alone as a lady, a woman in there, and then we, we need to fight with the leadership that
08:18all men,
08:19you know? Uh, so sometimes we, if we say that, let's say the, my, my, like my constituency before,
08:26I am from Batu Tiga for the, for the, uh, uh, state's level, not even, we ask for the, to
08:34replace,
08:35the replacement for the women candidate, but sometimes the seat is no more. It's given to other
08:41party. You know? It's something like, uh, it's, sometimes it's not our level, there's an upper level to decide.
08:49Because coalition politics requires that kind of negotiation as well. So, a lot of, uh, level we
08:54need to consider. Okay. I want to come back later to your experience in Ampang, which I think is
09:00fascinating. We all remember that, but I will refresh your memory shortly. I want to come to Muda. Muda
09:07famously once said that they are, um, egalitarian and want to be equal in terms of, um, its commitment to
09:14gender. Talk to me about your experience and how Muda approaches gender equality when it comes to
09:22who runs or who is fielded. Okay. Thank you very much, Mel. Um, I think we only had been through
09:30three, um, elections. Um, the first one was Joho and then after that the GE in 2022, uh, both in
09:372022.
09:37And then the, the, the recent one is of course the six state elections. Um, I think throughout these
09:43three, um, the most remarkable or like something that we can really remember is actually the, the,
09:48the, the very recent election, which is the six state election where we, um, we successfully put
09:54in or, or, um, yeah, actually successfully put in 51% of women candidates. Um, yeah, 51% candidates.
10:03But it wasn't an easy journey, obviously, because, um, number one, um, we don't put in like 50 candidates
10:08overall. Um, of course we do not have such capacity with such small, small party, number one.
10:13Number two, um, the fact that I think, uh, I remember vividly, um, it was me, YB Amira,
10:20and also Cikgu Rahayu, um, who were like just, um, sitting down with, um, side side at that point
10:26of time and tell him that, you know what, um, you're just gonna take what we ask you and that's
10:32it.
10:32And then, and then obviously, um, this is what we demand, um, at that point of time. And obviously,
10:38he was like being, um, the male politician and him, and of course, why do we need this? Like,
10:44why? And so, of course, you have to educate and tell him, and not just him, of course,
10:49the central, um, executive committee to tell them, like, what's it needs, et cetera. That's,
10:53that's one thing. But obviously, throughout this, um, past four years, um, in Moda, I think, um,
11:01the most important thing to also acknowledge the fact that, um, not everyone actually understand
11:06what is gender equality. Why do we need such thing? Even, even if you are in such a small
11:12or very young party. So, and even in 2026. Exactly, exactly. So you, you, you actually have to
11:19make them understand, like, okay, um, why do you need such, um, policy in the party? Why do you actually
11:26put, um, certain parties have to put that in constitution, for example. So these are,
11:31which still are the struggle in the party. But obviously, one thing for sure is that once we
11:36have put the cap of, like, um, um, fielding in that 51%, um, in our last, um, election,
11:42we can never go down. You know, like, everyone would just go on and on that Moda, you put like
11:4851%, even though it's just like, I think, okay, I can't remember in total, but yeah, there is already
11:54that kind of percentage put. And obviously, people will just come to you and say that,
11:58are you going to put below 50%? You've set the threshold, you've set the benchmark,
12:04you can't go back. Dr. Shaza, next to me. So, um, YB Rosia mentioned a bit earlier that it's also,
12:11it's not just about fielding a woman candidate, it's about fielding her in a winnable seat. So
12:17she's not just a number on a checklist that makes up the, the quota. Um, in your experience,
12:23your observations, talking to political parties and, um, observing the political landscape in the
12:28country, what seems to, where is the bottleneck? Where do you see the bottleneck? Is it in getting
12:34women candidates to be fielded? Or is it in fielding them in winnable seats? Why is it that our
12:42women representation in terms of elected representatives sangat, sangat dismal?
12:50Thank you. Thank you. Um, so where's the bottleneck? Maybe, okay. Maybe I'll just start by saying that my
12:57research is mostly on political sociology, so I'm looking on the ground. So I see there's like this
13:03two level. Um, we're talking firstly about getting these women into politics, I think was discussed
13:08earlier, right? We all agree that women are competent. In fact, we have more women that, not more,
13:15I should not say more, right? But we have equally good women that could join politics. But I think
13:21that was mentioned earlier, they are not motivated to join politics. So that's number one. When you don't
13:27have enough women in political parties in the first place, where are you going to get this candidate?
13:33So then we get the parachutes that YB Rozia kept mentioning earlier. So that's number one. How do we get
13:39them? So there was the 17 year old, is it you? Yeah, that I was saying that, you know, younger
13:45generation,
13:47they are interested and whatnot. But sometimes if I may say this, we have this kind of bubble where we're
13:54looking maybe at certain groups within Malaysia, right? Have we thought about those in Trengganu,
14:00in Kelantan? Are they interested? Are they that motivated? Do they understand this gender parity
14:06that we're talking about? If Muda also has an issue with it, I'm not sure how it is out there
14:11in the,
14:12we're not talking in the Kampungs, but just outside of KL, outside of Selangor, right? So that's one thing.
14:18So the second, I think, is what all the YBs have mentioned is the party itself. Yes, the GPPR wants
14:25to put 30%,
14:26but our fear is that it's just in numbers, right? Are they going to put in winnable seats? So that's
14:32what discussed earlier, the incumbency issue. Will these men let go of these seats? I'm not going to,
14:39I'm not going to touch the retirement age thing, but so that is that the bottleneck. Will the parties
14:46really put them in winnable seats? And besides just winnable seats, sometimes we have to think of the
14:52marginal seats. I think in marginal seats, they like to put men, right? Because there is this
14:57expectation that men are more likely to win, right? What do you mean marginal seats? Those that are
15:0250-50% chance that they're going to win or, you know, they're going to lose it. So in those
15:07kind of
15:07seats that are risky for these parties, they like to put men. Okay. The understanding is that we live in
15:13a patriarchal society that prefers men. I really like this point. So let's expand on this point.
15:20Let's think this through whether women are deployed differently from men in electoral strategy.
15:27YB Rosia, can I get you to share the Ampang experience? So I'm just going to refresh for
15:34anyone who has forgotten, okay? The Ampang seat in GE15 was one of the most closely watched seats.
15:41It was an eight corner fight. There were eight candidates. No, I'm sorry.
15:47My apologies, nine because there were independents as well, right? Yes. Okay. It was a nine corner
15:53fight and I think it was five women, five women, five women ran for that. The incumbent was Datuk Zoraida
16:01Kamaruddin. And it was fascinating to watch because out of, I did some numbers in terms of all the seats
16:11in
16:11that were, that had one female candidate, 20 seats had more than one women candidate. So out of every 100,
16:22there'll be 20 that's, that has more than one. So my question really is, are women more likely to be
16:29fielded
16:30against other women? Is there this dynamic where you have to have a woman against another woman,
16:38especially if the incumbent is a woman? Do political parties consciously or unconsciously
16:44match a woman with a woman? And can you tell us more? Actually, when the party proposing a candidate,
16:52candidate, it is a very, very normal that they will say that like something like this. We foresee the,
17:02our opponent will be a women candidate. We put a women candidate. But I didn't, didn't agree about
17:09that. I didn't agree. Because myself, three terms in Batuti Girl, I contested with men. You know? So I think
17:16that
17:17shouldn't be the, shouldn't be the, shouldn't be the, the variable that we, we put in. Women's must,
17:27if there is a women candidate, we put women to contest against women. You know? So for me,
17:34it shouldn't be like that. But what, why is it like that? Why, why is that the prevailing thinking?
17:41Um, I, I think that is only something that they feel that is better men, a women contest against women.
17:50But actually, the party should come up with the, with the, um, research, you know, as a, as a political
18:00party. You want to win. This is not about men or women. It's about, is it the state is actually
18:06for the
18:06party. That should be the way. So when we fight for it, we should fight. It's not, it's not about
18:13gender. But some people said, men, women candidate, more chance to win certain, certain area.
18:20Certain, certain area. I did agree that. I did agree that. More chance to win. More chance to win.
18:25And, and what increases her chances to win? Um, is it the voter? Is it, is it, is it, is
18:31it her legacy?
18:32What, what is it? I think the voters, because, uh, let's say, this is my fact findings. I don't know
18:37about, uh, this is not peer reviewed yet. It's not theory. Like sometimes when the, when the candidates,
18:46they have the reputation is different, but we have candidate that no reputation at all. They are
18:52newcomers, you know, but actually it's stable for me, for the rural area, because approaches,
18:59the approaching, uh, women, uh, looks like be more, uh, uh, will be chosen by the voters.
19:08I, I, I, this is my facts finding as a, uh, as a women, uh, uh, political, uh, election committee.
19:16I feel that certain, certain area suitable for women candidate, but men still feel that no,
19:22this is the place we should put in. So, so you, you mean there's resistance, internal resistance.
19:28What, my point is, even though we come up with the facts and figures, this is a potential
19:36candidate that come from our party, it's a ladies, and then, even though we have that facts and
19:45figures, sometimes the resistance is there by the political, our own political party.
19:51Okay. Okay. Why be, should I, I, I see. Especially, especially if the name that we propose is not the
19:58head of division or somebody in the, that vision. Okay. Hierarchy matters. Okay.
20:05Okay. Why be? Now, who to deploy and where the gender plays a role, uh, in the process,
20:12I would say to DAP, it is not so much in terms of gender. Uh, to DAP, it is very
20:19clear that, uh,
20:20we just sent whoever we think is the most winnable candidate. And most of the time, gender is not a
20:28key factor in our final decision. So, in 2008, uh, we witnessed Tony Pua defeated MCA candidate,
20:35who was a female, uh, Tato Chu Mei Fan. So, we sent male candidates to, uh, contest against, uh, women
20:46incumbent. And in 2013, the first, my first election in my state, we basically, we, we, we, we, we had
20:55only
20:56four, four incumbent seats there in Johor. So, all the newbies, including myself, especially women,
21:04we contest against male candidates or incumbents. So, I will say that in the last one decade,
21:11my party actually has a strategy that sent women to contest against male incumbents. And we find it
21:19quite impactful. From the both of you, what I'm curious to know is your, how do you think the
21:28gender parity bill might be accepted by, um, by politicians and the public?
21:35What needs to happen next? If you, if you were to advise, um, empower and, uh, project 30%,
21:44what advice would you give them to make sure that this, there's progress on this,
21:48that we're moving forward?
21:50Well, I think I had the same kind of, like, question while sitting, um, and listening just
21:54now. Because, like, you know, a lot of, like, the questions were, like, uh, what's the timeline
21:58like? Um, what's next? You know, sending in, um, all this, uh, memorandum, like, what's next?
22:04What's next? And it's also important to know, like, what, what, what that timeline is. Because
22:08at the end of the day, uh, we able to achieve, uh, before G16, which is obviously by next year.
22:15All right. Or, like, what's the aim? Like, it's good to have the aim before G16. But I think
22:20most importantly, as for political party, as mentioned by many just now, I think, I think at the
22:25end of the day, we have to understand that it's the political will comes from political party.
22:31All right. We can have like this, for example. But at the end of the day, if political party can't
22:36even adopt domestically on how they want to run in their own political party, then, you know, things will just
22:42be there. I was just speaking to, like, my friend just now, uh, earlier on. I said that, you see,
22:46this incentive, um, fund, right? Um, my take is that, um, big, for big political parties, why would
22:55they, why would they care about it? Because, like, they don't need such funds because they're big
23:00party, they have lots of funds, etc. But for small political party like us, I need it, we need it.
23:06So, uh, maybe we want to look at that angle as well, because there is no, we're not going to
23:10penalize
23:11them if, let's say, they're, they're not going to achieve that, right? But, so, why would they care?
23:16Like, you, as mentioned earlier, generally how Malaysians, uh, Malaysians vote is how strategically
23:22we put in campaign, number one. Number two, generally, Malaysians just, just don't see between
23:26men and women on who to vote. So, at the end of the day, if nothing happens to political party
23:31who does
23:31not follow such law that we, um, enact at the end of the day, then what's the purpose of doing
23:36it?
23:36So, I think, um, well, I'm also figuring out, still, I'm going to go back and think,
23:40but I'm also figuring out, like, if, let's say, we don't penalize, and if we do penalize,
23:44what will happen? Because we are here to actually encourage participation of women in political
23:49party, and we also do not want to scare political party before they filled in all these women.
23:56Yeah, I think it's a tireless lawyer, I actually want to mention, she has a legal background.
24:02Right, I like that point, because I was thinking the same thing, actually. While I was sitting there,
24:06I was thinking exactly the same thing, that, because there's this differentiation between big
24:11parties and small parties, and you put it there that, um, there's no restriction for small parties,
24:16okay, fine, but it's not just there's no restriction. I feel like smaller parties will be more incentivized,
24:21right, because of what you just said. Bigger parties, and you were saying that it's much more
24:25difficult to get through the door of this, some bigger parties. I think because of that, why would
24:30they care? It doesn't affect them. They have the funding wherever they are, so it's not a top priority.
24:37Okay, but going back to Mel's question about how to, I don't know, advise, to be honest,
24:43the three YBs have talked about political parties. I'm not going to touch that, so I will go back
24:49to the grassroots, unfortunately. I have to say that because politicians vote based on what they
24:55think their constituents want, so if, and what they think will get them to be voted again in the next
25:02coming election and future elections, so this is at the top of their mind. So again, I have to repeat
25:09myself what I said earlier, if this is not important, it's not important for their constituents, it's not
25:15important to them. So we have to go back, at the end of the day, go back to the people.
25:19And I know
25:20we've done this for decades already in Malaysia. We've gone here and they're everywhere, all levels
25:25of society, but somehow it doesn't reach them. I think that's where we have to look at. I mean,
25:31I can talk more about the Malay psyche, Malay social, sociology and whatnot, but basically, because that's my
25:37specialization on the Malays, and they are the majority, we can't ignore that. So if you want to
25:43get this through, we have to get through them as well. Sorry Malik, I just want to add a little
25:48bit
25:48when I said about like how domestic law or ataupun domestic policy in political party can actually
25:55impact such decision when we do this. Actually, because if I'd say like, macam YB Rosia sebutkan
26:02earlier on, right? She was the only one there, for example, in the committee. So her voice just
26:08represent like one voice. Imagine if, let's say domestically, we can put in like more women
26:14leadership, you know, to actually put forward, like what's the need, right? Like I was having
26:20that such tough time to actually explain to all like the members, etc. So then putting in very important
26:25key women leaders in political party to make decision is also important. I agree with Honey. Honey?
26:37Okay. Actually, I think we need to. We need the political party to do the structural reform. It means
26:46that we cannot only mention about, we must put generally 30%. Maybe we need to define, let's say, the
26:55deputy president, we have seven. So you must have three out of that. If not, no way.
27:02Lagi granular. So every level first, we must put like that. And then inside the central
27:09committee or division committee or the election committee must have the minimum quota 30% and
27:19the Rang Undang-Undang-Undang. The act is very important. For me, we already mentioned about this
27:27years and years. And yet we are the lowest in ASEAN. You know? So it's high time. We must have
27:33the
27:34negative reinforcement. It means Rang Undang-Undang lah. Election Rang Undang-Undang. Maybe we need to say that some,
27:41I think a few ASEAN or international country mentioned about is there are no 30% women representation.
27:52It means you cannot enter the election. I think Indonesia is more strengthened. It's more strengthened.
27:58I mean, and then the political party, maybe they have no choice. They have no choice. Sometimes I think
28:06it's not sometime. High time. High time. High time to do this. Okay. I hope you enjoyed that panel
28:13discussion. That's all we have for you on this episode of The Future Is Female. I'm Melissa Idris,
28:18signing off for the evening, wanting to wish all of you happy International Women's Day. Goodbye, folks.