00:00Idineklara ng House Committee on Justice na insufficient in substance
00:04ang dalawang impeachment complaint laban kay Pangulong Bongbong Marcos.
00:07May tuturin na nga bang patay ang dalawang reklamo?
00:11Saksi si Tina Panginiban Perez.
00:15Mahaba ang naging talakayan tungkol sa mga inilatag na grounds for impeachment
00:20laban kay Pangulong Bongbong Marcos.
00:23Sa reklamong inihain ng grupo ni dating Partylist Representative Lisa Masa,
00:27tatlong aligasyon ang nakaangkla sa betrayal of public trust.
00:32Itinatag, pinahintulutan at pinatupad ni Pangulong Bongbong Marcos Jr.
00:41ang isang opisyal napatakaran ng allocables at non-allocables
00:48sa pagbubuo ng DPWH budget.
00:53At ito ang naging batayan at bahagi ng isang buong sistema
01:00ng sentralisadong korupsyon na nagresulta sa tinatawag natin ngayong
01:07flood control corruption scandal.
01:10Ang Pangulo at tanging ang Pangulo lamang mismo
01:13ang may kapangyarihan na tuluyang mag-authorize ng release
01:18ng P213 billion pesos na unprogrammed appropriations
01:22na naging balon ng malawakang korupsyon.
01:26Kaya ito ay malinaw na pagtataksil sa tiwala ng taong bayan.
01:31Sabi ng ilang miyembro ng komite,
01:33walang naipakita sa reklamo na may direktang utos
01:36ang Pangulo kaugnay sa mga bintang.
01:38It is clear from the complaint that the President did not do
01:42any overt act that will show that he directed these three schemes.
01:48Having an imperfect policy direction is not an impeachable offense.
01:53Accusations are not factual allegations.
01:56Presidential approval of the release of these funds
01:59does not equate to discretionary indulgence.
02:04It is actually a requirement of law.
02:06Pero ang ibang mambabatas,
02:08naniwalang sapat ang mga nilalaman ng reklamo para umusa dito.
02:13Pag pinatay ang investigasyon,
02:15kung pipigilan ng komiting ito,
02:16ang pag-usat ng investigasyon,
02:18ang magiging imahe ng kamera ay may pinagtatakpan.
02:22Lalo na't maraming mambabatas
02:24ang diumanoy na kinabang.
02:27To support this charge,
02:28the complaint alleges that the
02:30quote-unquote
02:31Saldico Confession
02:33confirmed the President's personal and direct involvement.
02:39And I respectfully submit that
02:41given that standard
02:43that these allegations are assumed to be true,
02:48the complaint,
02:49insofar as the third ground is concerned,
02:52does satisfy the threshold standard
02:55of sufficiency in substance.
02:58At ng pagbatohan ng House Committee on Justice,
03:02kung sufficient in substance ito,
03:04with vote
03:05in favor
03:09of the motion
03:10seven,
03:14and those
03:15against
03:16the motion
03:17thirty-nine,
03:20with zero
03:22abstention,
03:24the Chair declares
03:25the Masa et al
03:28impeachment complaint
03:30insufficient
03:32insufficient
03:32in substance.
03:35That concludes
03:36the voting.
03:42I-declare ring
03:43insufficient
03:43in substance
03:44ang impeachment complaint
03:46na inihain ni
03:47Atty.
03:47Andre De Jesus.
03:49With a vote
03:50of
03:51forty-two
03:53in favor
03:55of the motion,
03:57one
03:59against
04:00the motion,
04:01and three
04:03abstain,
04:04the Chair
04:06therefore declares
04:08the impeachment
04:10complaint
04:11of the Jesus
04:12insufficient
04:14in substance.
04:17Base sa rules
04:18ng Kamara,
04:19kung insufficient
04:20in substance
04:20ang impeachment
04:21complaint,
04:22i-de-dismiss ito
04:23at isusumite ng
04:25Kumite
04:25ang report nito
04:26sa plenaryo.
04:27Patay na nga ba
04:28ang dalawang
04:29reklamo?
04:29As far as
04:31the proceeding
04:32today is
04:33concerned,
04:34I can consider
04:35that.
04:37However,
04:38we should be
04:39mindful
04:39that
04:41the committee
04:42report
04:43can still
04:44be reversed
04:45by at least
04:47one-third
04:48of all the
04:49members of the
04:50House of
04:51Representatives.
04:51I cannot
04:52still
04:53say it's
04:55dead
04:57because
04:58there's still
04:59a proceeding
05:00that will
05:00happen
05:01in the
05:01plenary.
05:02Ang desisyon
05:03ng Kumite
05:03ikinadismaya
05:05ni dating
05:05Congresswoman
05:06Maza.
05:06Sa palagay
05:07po namin
05:08prematurely
05:09murdered
05:10ang impeachment
05:11complaint
05:12na ito.
05:13Nakakalungkot
05:13na kung dito
05:15sa proseso
05:16na ito
05:16ng impeachment
05:17hindi
05:17natin
05:18makukuha
05:20ang
05:20katarungan
05:21talagang
05:22mapupersa
05:23ang mamamayan
05:24na lumabas
05:25sa proseso
05:26ito
05:26para makuha
05:27ang katarungan
05:29na atin pong
05:30inaasam.
05:30Ayon kay
05:31Act Teachers
05:32Partilist
05:33Representative
05:33Antonio
05:34Tinio
05:34na nag-endorso
05:35sa reklamo
05:36tila ipinagtanggol
05:38ng mga
05:38kongresista
05:39ang Pangulo.
05:40Sabi nila
05:40sa kanilang
05:41pagtigil
05:42ay
05:43hindi raw
05:44impeachable
05:45ang mga
05:46offense
05:46na nasa
05:47complaint.
05:49Hindi po yun
05:49ang tungkulin
05:50ng mga
05:51kinatawa
05:51ng Justice
05:52Committee.
05:53Hindi nala
05:53tungkulin
05:54na mag-abogado
05:55para sa
05:56Presidente.
05:58Ngunit
05:58tila yun
05:58na po
05:58ang nangyayari
05:59dahil
06:00hinuhusgahan
06:02na nila
06:03ang ebidensya.
06:04Sabi naman
06:05ang Malacanang
06:05hinayaan lang
06:07ng Pangulo
06:07na gumulong
06:08ang proseso.
06:09Kumpiyansa
06:10raw ang Pangulo
06:11noon pa man
06:11na wala siyang
06:12ginawang
06:13impeachable
06:13offense.
06:14Nagpapasalamat
06:15po tayo
06:16na nakita
06:17po
06:17na mga
06:18mababatas
06:18kung ano
06:19po talaga
06:19ang katatohanan
06:20at doon
06:21po tayo
06:22lagi sa katatohanan.
06:23Nakita po natin
06:24na talaga
06:24wala namang
06:25merito
06:25ang nasabi
06:26mga complaints
06:27at miskin
06:28na po
06:28ang Pangulo
06:28ay kumpiyansa
06:29na wala siya
06:31pong ginawang
06:31anumang
06:31impeachable
06:32offense.
06:32Hindi na raw
06:33tinutukan
06:34ang Pangulo
06:35ang naging
06:35talakayan
06:36sa House
06:36Justice
06:37Committee
06:37dahil may
06:38dalawang
06:38engagement
06:39siya
06:39sa loob
06:40ng palasyo.
06:41Nakatutok daw
06:42ang Pangulo
06:42ngayon
06:43sa pagangat
06:43ng bumagal
06:44na ekonomiya
06:45ng bansa.
06:46Ang sabi
06:46ng Pangulo
06:47let's move
06:48forward
06:48dahil ang gusto
06:49po niya
06:49ngayon
06:49ay tutukan
06:50ang ekonomiya
06:51at paano
06:52maiaangat
06:52ang buhay
06:53ng bawat
06:54Pilipino.
06:54Para sa
06:58GMA Integrated News
07:00ako si Tina
07:01Panganiban Perez
07:02ang inyong
07:03saksi.
07:05Mga kapuso
07:06maging una
07:07sa saksi.
07:08Magsubscribe
07:08sa GMA
07:09Integrated News
07:10sa YouTube
07:10para sa
07:11ibat-ibang
07:12balita.
07:12GMA
07:16People
07:16according to
07:17what
07:17the
07:18PJ
07:19P
Comments