- 11 months ago
The big talking point of this episode of News Today is the escalating political war over the Election Commission's Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Welcome, you're watching News Today at 9pm. I am Preeti Chaudhary, our big talking point this evening.
00:06The TMC has taken on the Election Commission, this time going directly to the top pot of the country.
00:13The SIR back in focus in Uttar Pradesh as well, where 2 crore, 89 lakh voters have been deleted in Uttar Pradesh's SIR.
00:23SIR, Special Intensive Role Revision, leading to mass deletions.
00:28Once again, a question that we will ask during the course of this bulletin.
00:33Also, we have an exclusive lined up for you, Jeffrey Sachs on Trump's Venezuela gambit.
00:39All of that coming up. First, allow me to take you through the headlines.
00:46Showdown over SIR exercise escalates. TMC MP Derek O'Brien moves Apex Court against SIR, alleging procedural irregularities.
00:56Poll body releases draft list in UP, 2.8 crore deleted from the rolls.
01:08Controversy over provocative slogans in JNU after Supreme Court denies bail to Umar Khalid.
01:14Modi Shah Ki Kabar Khudegi slogans chanted. Disciplinary action to be taken against those involved.
01:20The student body in where new claims bid to defame the students of JNU.
01:26And they were being misrepresented.
01:31Apex Court lashes out at pollution body over worsening air in Delhi.
01:35Directs CAQM to form a panel of experts to determine cause of pollution and solve the issue.
01:41It's a setback for the Stalin government.
01:46Madras High Court upholds single-judge verdict to light Deepam in Madurai.
01:51The DMK government now to move the top court, challenging the High Court's verdict.
02:00CBI summons Vijay in Karoor stampede case.
02:03CBI summons Vijay on January 12th.
02:0541 died in the stampede at Vijay's Karoor rally.
02:09Health care for all and a question on the scheme Ayushman Bharat.
02:18Health care still a luxury for poor.
02:21Eye-opening India today.
02:23Reality check on how Ayushman scheme has not been implemented.
02:32There is no end to Hindu hate in Bangladesh.
02:3540-year-old Saraj Chakravarti dies after being attacked with sharp weapons.
02:39This comes just hours after another Hindu, Rana Prathap, was killed.
02:48The centre gives Elon Musk's ex additional time till January 7th
02:52to submit a detailed action-taken report over obscene content.
02:56Earlier, government issued a stern warning to the social media platform over misuse of Grok.
03:01And European leaders strongly oppose Trump's suggestion to take control of Greenland.
03:11Key leaders unanimously say the Arctic island, Greenland, which is rich in minerals, belongs to its people.
03:18All right, viewers.
03:28After Bihar, political heat is rising in West Bengal and Uttar Pradesh
03:33over the poll body's special intensive revision of the voter rolls.
03:38The TMC Congress, the Trinimal Congress, has approached the top court alleging errors,
03:45undisclosed algorithm and voter deletion through AI put together by the BJP's IT cell.
03:54While the EC insists the process is fair with elections around the corner,
03:59this battle over who gets to vote is turning into a full-blown political showdown.
04:04Here's the full report.
04:04Political heat over the special intensive revision of electoral rolls is rising.
04:14The Trinimal Congress has moved the Supreme Court against the Election Commission,
04:19questioning the process followed by the poll body.
04:23The petition claims voters are being deleted centrally
04:25without the knowledge of electoral registration officers.
04:29The party accuses the EC of mapping voters using undisclosed algorithms and software.
04:36The plea claims that state CEO issued instructions to officials
04:40through WhatsApp messages and oral directions.
04:44It seeks extension of deadline for submitting claims and objections
04:47from the currently fixed January 15th.
04:50The party wants EC to allow boot-level agents of parties
04:54to assist voters during hearings,
04:57allow virtual hearings through family member for migrant voters,
05:01and doorstep or telephonic verification
05:03to those above 60 with medical conditions.
05:07The West Bengal Chief Electoral Officer on December 29th halted hearings
05:36for thousands of voters who were wrongly marked as unmapped.
05:40The CEO's directive claimed that the mistake was due to error
05:44in conversion of PDF of 2002 voter list into a different format.
05:49A message of meaning of a message of disclosure.
05:54With Porat Kapal, αν co- ph comentarios have written a number of sources
06:14The BJP has rejected TMC charges.
06:44Meanwhile, the EC released the draft Electoral Role for Uttar Pradesh.
07:09Out of 15.44 crore voters, 12.55 crore or 81.30% submitted amuneration forms.
07:172.89 crore, that is roughly 18.70%, were left out.
07:22So, Mirtak maddata 46.23 lakhs, 46.23 lakhs.
07:28Lapata, Anupasthit, Rahehaa, Unko, Field-Mei, BLO-Ko, Milenae, Aisee 2.17 crore maddata hain.
07:362.17 crore.
07:40The special intensive revision has become an election issue in West Bengal, with the ruling TMC alleging targeted deletions.
07:56Assembly elections in Bengal are likely to be held after three months.
08:00Bureau Report, India Today.
08:04All right, so the question that we asked this evening, SIR leading to mass deletions in Uttar Pradesh in West Bengal, is SIR purification or exclusionary?
08:16Does the EC need to be more transparent?
08:18Fear-mongering by opposition parties is a charge that has been laid by the government.
08:23All right, let me take all these questions first to Dr. S.Y. Qureshi, former CEC.
08:27Mr. Qureshi, thank you for taking the time out and joining us on News Today.
08:31First up, the focus, Mr. Qureshi, is back on the EC's adherence to statutory procedures.
08:38Compared to the past elections in which you presided over role revisions, what is the difference?
08:46Well, there is no doubt that the purification of electoral roles is the first responsibility of the Election Commission.
08:54In fact, I take you back to the framing of the Constitution.
09:00That was the time when the decision was being taken that since the elections will be held only once in five years,
09:06why should we have a single officer full-time?
09:10Only at the time of election we will appoint a CEC.
09:13See, that is when it was said that no electoral roles have to be updated every year, for which we need an officer.
09:20So let us have at least one officer, which will be the CEC, and that is how CEC institution was born.
09:27So the point here is that the focus on the purification of electoral role and regular updation
09:33is a constitutional mandate and a legal mandate without doubt, right?
09:38At the same time, I would like to say that for the last 75 years,
09:42all of us have been making all kinds of efforts to update and purify their roles,
09:49some with success, some with lesser success, but all of us have been working on it.
09:54Now, in 2003 and 2004, we used to have an intensive revision.
09:59That is also for sure, that is true, but in 2003, it was decided by the then commission
10:06that now that we have digitized the electoral roll,
10:10it is easier, better to update them every year by going door to door.
10:17Now, throwing out the existing roll into the dustbin totally and starting afresh,
10:24that leads to my question, that what took us 30 years to achieve 99 perfection,
10:33these people think that they will do it in 30 days.
10:36Fantastic if they do it, congratulations and very well done, but it's impossible.
10:42It's impossible, the kind of deletions will happen, the kind of complaints will crop up,
10:46you will see the situation develops.
10:51All right, so you're saying to complete an exercise in 30 days,
10:54which usually have taken years, will lead to further chaos.
10:59So, should, you know, one final question, Mr. Qureshi, before I let you go.
11:03So, should the EC come clean with safeguards that could prevent perception of bias?
11:07Because you have the TMC, and I'm going to take you through
11:09on some of the points that they want relief on.
11:13They've approached the top court of the country, the Supreme Court,
11:16while on the other hand, there have been about 2 crores, 80 lakh deletions
11:19in the state of Uttar Pradesh that has also been contested.
11:22Now, should the EC, where these concerns are concerned,
11:27and these are concerns that they have raised,
11:29that the EC should extend the deadline for submitting claims and objections,
11:33that the EC should stop issuing formal instructions through channels like WhatsApp,
11:38that the EC ensure no voter is left out because of erroneous mapping,
11:42which there is already a pause.
11:44The EC has given an explanation on that account,
11:47that the EC do away with extra statutory category described by it
11:52as a logical discrepancy,
11:55that the EC allow booth-level agents to assist voters during hearings.
11:59So, there are a number of issues that the TMC has raised.
12:02Do you think the EC needs to take it in the right spirit
12:04and address them point by point?
12:06Yes, absolutely.
12:08In fact, it all boils down to transparency.
12:11Exactly everything that they do should be transparent,
12:14and they should be open to the suggestions and criticism of the public
12:18and the opposition,
12:19and address them to their satisfaction.
12:22Now, taking you to Bihar,
12:25the initial exercise was started in the name of foreigners.
12:29Oh, there are so many foreigners,
12:30and we have to identify them and throw them out.
12:33Wonderful idea.
12:34You should do it.
12:36And what is it that we found?
12:38Number one,
12:39we haven't heard from the Election Commission
12:41how many foreigners were found.
12:43We only heard from the media
12:44that in eight crore Biharis
12:47who were made to run around from pillar to post,
12:50they were able to find 500 foreigners,
12:53of which 150 were Bangladeshis,
12:55and 350 were Hindu women from Nepal
12:59who had come by marriage to Bihar.
13:02But Mr. Qureshi,
13:03the defense,
13:03the defense of the EC
13:05has been in through it all,
13:07that where Bihar is concerned,
13:08because you're using Bihar as an example,
13:10that there were no complaints
13:11that were fight by political parties and activists.
13:14Yeah,
13:14actually,
13:15that's the point
13:16which is quite baffling.
13:17At the same time,
13:18I have heard only in the media,
13:19I know nothing
13:20from the horse's mouth,
13:23that the people
13:24who went to complain to Bihar
13:25because Bihar was the front-line person,
13:29they were shooed away.
13:30So,
13:31all 65 lakhs,
13:33just keeping quiet,
13:34and let there be an external audit even now,
13:38whether the 65 lakh deletion,
13:41after all,
13:42in the Supreme Court,
13:43people appeared
13:44who had been declared dead
13:46by, you know,
13:47there may have been no appeal
13:49and no complaint.
13:50But they're declared dead
13:51and deleted.
13:52They appeared before the Supreme Court,
13:54Sir,
13:54I'm alive,
13:54I'm here,
13:55and I've been deleted.
13:57So,
13:57what about the explanation
13:58of all these cases?
14:00All right.
14:00So,
14:00one final point,
14:01Mr. Qureshi.
14:02You're saying the EC needs to be transparent.
14:04It needs to address all the points
14:05that have been raised
14:06by the TMC in West Bengal.
14:07You have the Samajwadi Party
14:09and the Congress
14:09in the state of Uttar Pradesh.
14:11Come clean.
14:12Give point-by-point rebuttal
14:14to all the clauses
14:15that have been raised
14:15by both parties.
14:16Correct, sir?
14:17That's what you're saying.
14:18Absolutely.
14:19And also,
14:19extend the timeline.
14:23Yes,
14:24exactly.
14:25In Bihar,
14:26one could understand
14:27that there was very time available.
14:29But this is an exercise
14:30which goes on around the year.
14:32Pick up the state
14:33which are going to pour
14:33three years down the line.
14:36Why?
14:36Immediately,
14:37which are going to pour in two months
14:38and create all the chaos
14:40and demand for extension
14:42by a week,
14:42by a fortnight.
14:44I still feel that the last word
14:48is yet to be heard
14:49and even out of 65 lakhs,
14:53how many were illegally deleted.
14:54This will all come out
14:55in due course.
14:56All right, sir.
14:58Thank you for joining us
14:59and taking the time out.
15:00Let's take all these questions.
15:02Okay,
15:03let's make your point, sir.
15:04Very quickly.
15:04If I can make...
15:05Yeah,
15:06you know,
15:06you had mentioned
15:07about artificial intelligence
15:08and the misuse of computers.
15:10That is a very serious charge.
15:12And that's a very serious possibility.
15:14We, again,
15:15the election commission
15:16should come clean
15:16whether they have hired
15:18some agencies
15:18using artificial intelligence
15:20to,
15:21I would not say
15:22manipulate the role
15:23but to manage the role.
15:24So,
15:25that also has to be clear
15:26and clarified to the people.
15:27that's a charge,
15:27you know,
15:28fair point.
15:28So,
15:28you're saying,
15:29you know,
15:29the EC needs to come clean on that
15:30because I'll just elaborate
15:31what the charge is.
15:32The TMC says that
15:33the EC is using
15:34artificial intelligence
15:36via the BJP IT cell
15:38that is deleting,
15:40you know,
15:41roles and names
15:43from the West Bengal voter list
15:45through artificial intelligence.
15:47Now,
15:47that's a charge
15:47that the TMC government
15:50and Mamata Banerjee
15:51is making.
15:52Thank you,
15:52Mr. Qureshi,
15:53for taking the time out
15:54and joining us.
15:54We're going to take
15:55all these questions
15:55to our panelists this evening.
15:57Joining me,
15:57Rajat Sethi,
15:58political analyst,
15:59Yogendra Yadav,
16:00co-founder,
16:00Swaraj India,
16:01Pradeep Bhandari,
16:02national spokesperson,
16:03BJP,
16:04Tawseep Rehman,
16:05spokesperson,
16:06TMC.
16:07I'd like to begin with you,
16:08Mr. Bhandari.
16:09Now,
16:09with what the TMC
16:12has accused
16:12the EC of the TMC
16:14has approached
16:15the top court
16:15of the country,
16:16we can go point by point
16:17on the apprehensions
16:19that the EC has raised.
16:20But,
16:21the larger question,
16:22Pradeep Bhandari,
16:23is that maybe
16:24this whole exercise
16:26is being rushed
16:26and why I say that
16:28is because
16:29the EC's
16:30pause on hearing
16:31for wrongly
16:32unmapped voters
16:33due to technical errors
16:35has been cited
16:36as an issue
16:37by the TMC
16:37as evidence
16:38of what the TMC
16:39feels as acute mismanagement.
16:41Now,
16:42how does this glitch
16:43somewhere down the line
16:43reflect
16:44on the necessity
16:45of SIR
16:46to clean roles
16:47inflated
16:48by what bogus voters
16:50is what the EC suggests,
16:52especially in the time frame
16:53allotted.
16:54Pradeep Bhandari,
16:56first of all,
16:58the questions
16:58which are directed
16:59to the Election Commission
17:01would be answered
17:01by the Election Commission
17:02and the pension
17:03of the Tribunal Congress
17:05is in the Supreme Court
17:06and the Supreme Court
17:07is very...
17:07Pradeep Bhandari,
17:08would you correct your audio?
17:09We are having a bit of a problem
17:10with your audio.
17:11Would you correct that
17:12and we are going to come
17:12right back to you
17:13because there is a problem
17:14with your audio link.
17:15Let Pradeep correct that.
17:17I want to cut across
17:18to...
17:19Rajat,
17:19would you want to take
17:19that question?
17:20Because the EC itself
17:22has paused the hearing
17:23for wrongly unmapped voters.
17:24They are saying
17:24that there is a problem
17:25with some conversion of PDF
17:26but there is
17:27a procedural issue.
17:30See,
17:31you know,
17:32you are operating
17:33at extensive scales also.
17:35You know,
17:36you need to double click
17:37into the process
17:37as to what all
17:39has the Election Commission
17:40done in the run-up
17:42while there was
17:43an initial deadline.
17:44The initial reports
17:46when it came about
17:46that nearly
17:47three crore voters
17:48were deleted.
17:49Then the authorities
17:50said that,
17:51okay,
17:51let us give additional time
17:52and then,
17:53you know,
17:54more weeks were given.
17:56After,
17:56in that window,
17:57new,
17:58when it was realized
17:59that certain polling booths
18:00were crossing the threshold
18:01of a thousand voters,
18:02around 1,500 new polling booths
18:04were also created.
18:05This was all done
18:06to revisit the exercise
18:08and to ensure
18:09that there are absolutely
18:10no voters
18:11which have been deleted
18:12just because of,
18:13you know,
18:14the overpressure
18:15on the BLO
18:15or BLO not being able
18:16to go to that household
18:18for the mandatory
18:19three times.
18:20All of this
18:21was established.
18:22But,
18:22you know,
18:23I think the only problem
18:24in this analysis
18:25is that we are starting
18:26with something sinister.
18:27We are starting
18:27with that assumption.
18:29Instead of that,
18:29we are not interpreting
18:30it in a way
18:31that people have actually
18:32moved out,
18:33moved out of the state
18:34of UP.
18:35There are already
18:35around 50 lakh voters
18:37which are,
18:38which are presumed dead
18:39here.
18:40There is also
18:41a certain set of voters
18:42which,
18:42which have moved out
18:45and there is another
18:45set of voters
18:46broadly categorized
18:47where the reasons
18:48for the dip
18:50in these voters
18:51are articulated.
18:52And by the way,
18:53when it,
18:53this is still not final.
18:55March is a timeline
18:55when you can still,
18:57first the draft
18:58would be published,
18:59if there are voters
19:00who have been missed out,
19:01they still have the opportunity,
19:02they still have two months.
19:03But,
19:04you know,
19:04there is a method
19:05to madness.
19:06You cannot have
19:06completely ad hoc
19:07and give years
19:08and years
19:09and years of time
19:09in a day and age
19:10when we claim
19:11that things should move
19:12digital,
19:12things should be done
19:13using the techniques
19:15and then should be
19:15in a compressed timeline.
19:17Okay.
19:17I mean,
19:17how is it normal?
19:18I was hearing Kureshi
19:19say that it is normal
19:20to do it over several years.
19:21Okay,
19:22Raja,
19:22I'm going to come back
19:23to you also
19:23because you also need
19:24to correct your
19:25internet connection.
19:27We are losing your video,
19:28your audio is perfect,
19:29but there's a problem
19:30with your video.
19:31I want to bring in
19:31Yogendra Yadav
19:32into this conversation
19:33with what Rajat said,
19:35Yogendra Yadav,
19:35that there are people
19:36who have moved out
19:37so these deletions
19:38shouldn't really be surprising.
19:39But I'd like to take
19:40our viewers
19:40through the deletions
19:41that have actually happened
19:42state by state.
19:43In Bihar,
19:44before SIR,
19:45there were 7.89 crores
19:49voters.
19:50Post-SIR,
19:50that dropped
19:52to 7.42 crores.
19:53There was a deletion
19:54of 47 lakhs.
19:55In Uttar Pradesh,
19:56there has been
19:57a deletion now
19:57of 2.89 crores
19:59where before SIR,
20:02the voter list
20:03had 15.44 crores
20:05voters.
20:06Now it has
20:0612.55 crores
20:08voters.
20:09Vis-a-vis
20:09West Bengal,
20:10there's been a drop
20:11of about 58 lakh voters.
20:13Do you think
20:14it's just people
20:15have just moved out,
20:17you know,
20:17there hasn't been
20:17purification of voter rolls
20:19for so long,
20:19or do you think
20:20this is a systematic
20:21way of undermining
20:22electoral fairness
20:23by disenfranchisement?
20:25Preeti,
20:27I wish to begin
20:28by reminding us
20:29that what we have
20:30witnessed today,
20:32namely,
20:33an exclusion
20:33of 2 crore
20:3589 lakh
20:36voters
20:37is unprecedented
20:38in human history,
20:40not just Indian history,
20:41not just
20:42Indian electoral
20:43history.
20:44Nowhere in the world
20:46has this scale
20:48of exclusion
20:49of voters
20:49ever taken place.
20:51We are speaking
20:52something very important.
20:54Number two,
20:56one simple way
20:58of judging,
20:59and that's something
20:59I've been saying
21:00over and over again,
21:02that, you know,
21:02the first presumption
21:03can be all right,
21:04there were too many voters,
21:05maybe there were
21:05wrong voters,
21:06maybe the list
21:07was originally inflated.
21:09One simple way
21:09of checking that
21:10is to ask,
21:11what is the adult population
21:12of Uttar Pradesh today?
21:14Now you have those figures.
21:16Before SIR,
21:17we had 15.45 crore
21:19people there.
21:20What was the population
21:21of UP at that point?
21:2316 crore 6 lakhs.
21:25These are not my figures,
21:26Preeti,
21:27these are figures
21:27of Government of India
21:29Population Projection Committee.
21:31So,
21:32if there was a fair SIR,
21:34the number should have gone
21:35up from 15 crore 45 lakhs
21:38to something closer
21:39to 16 crores.
21:41And what do we have?
21:42It has come down
21:43to 12.65 crores.
21:45Now responding
21:46to what Rajat said,
21:48it would have been
21:48a fair assumption.
21:51Six months ago,
21:52you may say,
21:53okay,
21:53Bihar has,
21:54you know,
21:54too many people
21:54leaving Bihar.
21:55Uttar Pradesh
21:56is also out-migration state.
21:58But fortunately,
21:59Preeti,
21:59now we have in front of us
22:01data from in-migration states,
22:02which are the in-
22:03and these are not
22:04my classification,
22:05these are classifications
22:05of Niti Aayoga of India.
22:07In-migration states
22:08are Gujarat
22:09and Tamil Nadu.
22:10Can you please show
22:11your viewers
22:11the figures
22:12from Gujarat
22:12and Tamil Nadu?
22:14Gujarat has had
22:15a deletion
22:15of 73,
22:1673.7 lakhs.
22:19That's right.
22:20Tamil Nadu
22:20has had a deletion
22:21of 97 lakhs.
22:23These are in-migration states.
22:25So the argument
22:26about out-migration
22:27falls flat.
22:29And may I also mention
22:30something very,
22:31very interesting
22:31and scandalous,
22:32Preeti.
22:33At the time
22:34when ECI
22:35has conducted
22:36an intensive revision
22:39of voters' list
22:40in Uttar Pradesh.
22:42Exactly at that same time,
22:44another constitutional body,
22:46namely State Election Commission
22:47of Uttar Pradesh,
22:49has prepared
22:50fresh electoral rolls
22:51for panchayat elections.
22:53They also carried out
22:54extensive revision
22:55in which 1.4 crore voters
22:57were deleted,
22:581.8 were added.
23:00And you know,
23:00Preeti,
23:00what is the figure?
23:02According to
23:02Election Commission
23:03of India,
23:04figures released
23:04this evening
23:05the whole of UP
23:07has 12.4 crore voters
23:09or 12.56 crore voters.
23:12And according
23:13to State Election Commission
23:14of Uttar Pradesh,
23:15figures released
23:16on 5th of December,
23:18the rural Uttar Pradesh
23:19alone has
23:2012.7 crore voters.
23:22All right.
23:22So you're saying
23:23there are lots of...
23:23Okay.
23:24So lots of anomalies
23:25and variations there
23:26which what Yugendra Yadav
23:27is pointing out
23:28and he's just talking about
23:29and the number of deletions
23:31that have taken place.
23:31Okay, we have Pradeep Bhandari
23:32back with us.
23:33Pradeep Bhandari,
23:34I want to bring you back in.
23:35He's laughing
23:36but Pradeep Bhandari,
23:36it is.
23:38You know,
23:38one really does need
23:39to look into
23:40the sheer deletion
23:41that has happened
23:41in the state of Uttar Pradesh.
23:43Nearly 3 crore voters
23:44have been deleted
23:45which is a deletion
23:45of nearly 19%
23:47where we are talking
23:48about the voters
23:49of the state of Uttar Pradesh.
23:51There have been deletions
23:52right from the state
23:52of Gujarat,
23:53from Tamil Nadu,
23:54Kerala,
23:54Chattisgarh, Rajasthan
23:55and, you know,
23:57the numbers are big.
23:59That's one aspect of it.
24:00The other, of course,
24:01is the charge
24:02that has been laid
24:03by the TMC
24:04where, you know,
24:06the TMC has gone
24:06to the top court.
24:07It's something
24:07that the BJP always said
24:09that, you know,
24:09approach the courts.
24:10They've gone to the top court
24:11with a list
24:12which they feel
24:13are grave anomalies
24:14in the way
24:15the EC is carrying out
24:16the SIR process
24:17and a big charge there
24:19is that the use
24:21of artificial intelligence
24:23where the EC is colluding
24:25with the BJP IT cell
24:28to delete names.
24:31Well, the speaker
24:32before me
24:33will find everything
24:34scandalous
24:34till the time
24:35we see Rahul Gandhi
24:36becoming the Prime Minister
24:37which will not happen
24:38in his lifetime
24:39or my lifetime.
24:40Let us just state
24:41certain facts.
24:42This is the same pattern
24:43which was followed
24:44in Bihar elections
24:45and before the Bihar elections
24:47where certain articles
24:48as a speaker
24:49by RJD
24:51in the Congress
24:51was written
24:52when the entire matter
24:53went to the Supreme Court
24:54the primacy
24:55and the principle
24:56of the petition
24:57was that SIR
24:58should be stayed
24:58and it was rejected
25:00in the court
25:00and not more than
25:0220 names
25:02could be produced
25:03where claims
25:04were made
25:04that crores of voters
25:05and lakhs of voters
25:06were deleted from Bihar.
25:08After the elections
25:09were finished in Bihar
25:10neither the RJD
25:11or the Congress
25:12could even produce
25:13a single fact
25:14which proved
25:15that the election
25:16was rigged
25:16or the SIR
25:17was favoring
25:17the Bharti Rensa party.
25:19What is the fact
25:20right now?
25:20The fact right now
25:21is that
25:22at present
25:23the Tinamul Congress
25:24has 77,867 BLAs.
25:27Now the BLAs
25:28are individuals
25:28who have been appointed
25:29by various political parties
25:31on the booth
25:31if gentlemen here
25:33do not know about it
25:34and the BLAs
25:35have only till now
25:36put three applications
25:38for inclusion
25:39and there have been
25:39zero applications
25:40for exclusion.
25:41The election commission
25:42has given
25:42at least more than
25:43a month of time
25:44whereas the Tinamul Congress
25:45believes
25:46or any party
25:47including ours
25:48believes that
25:48the process
25:48is favoring us
25:49or the PNC
25:50we can approach
25:51the court
25:51or we can approach
25:52the election commission.
25:53So this whole narrative
25:55of creating
25:55a hysteria
25:56creating doubt
25:57in the mind of voters
25:58failed in Bihar
25:59and also failed in Bengal.
26:00Now what is the truth
26:01in Bengal?
26:02The truth in Bengal
26:03is there is an
26:03electoral officer
26:04Sipurgan
26:05who goes to inspect
26:06in the Tinamul Congress
26:07spoons and gundas
26:09try to encircle him
26:10and there is an FIR
26:11which is registered.
26:12What is the truth?
26:13The truth is that
26:14whether it is
26:14Abhishek Banerjee
26:15or Mamta Banerjee
26:16they have claimed
26:16that the SIR process
26:18is a process
26:19which they will not allow
26:21because it favors
26:21the BJP
26:22and they will even
26:23go to the extent
26:24of breaking
26:24the length
26:25of the electoral officer.
26:26Now the law and order
26:27is in the state subject.
26:29So what we are here
26:30saying is that
26:30if the Tinamul Congress
26:31believes that the matter
26:32is favoring us
26:34please go to the court
26:34now they have gone
26:35to the court
26:36let them present
26:36the facts in front
26:37of the court.
26:38It is the same pattern
26:39that each political
26:39party follows.
26:41They will present
26:41certain technical arguments
26:43the technical arguments
26:44backed by technicalities
26:45without having
26:46an iota of facts
26:47and this is why
26:48it is rejected
26:48by the court
26:49and this is why
26:50I ask you
26:51that at the present moment
26:53in Uttar Pradesh
26:54your argument
26:55is that so many voters
26:56are deleted
26:56voters are even
26:57deleted from places
26:58where the Bharti Janta
26:59party has won.
27:01We believe that
27:02one of our voters
27:03or the gentleman
27:04voters is removed
27:05RBLN will go
27:06and apply in form 6
27:07or in form 7
27:08if the Samajwadi
27:09party believes
27:10that its voters
27:10is removed
27:11it will apply in form 7
27:12Pradeep Bhandari
27:12but that is concerned
27:13it's not about
27:14just the Samajwadi
27:16party voters
27:16being removed
27:17it's a basic question
27:18of disenfranchisement
27:20that is what
27:20is the question.
27:22My argument
27:23really is
27:23that the basic
27:24question
27:25we are also
27:25putting
27:25in the Bihar
27:26electoral process
27:27but when the
27:28entire matter
27:29went to the Supreme
27:30Court
27:30Mr. Yadav
27:30could not even
27:31present a certain
27:32fact
27:32Okay I'll cut
27:33across to you
27:33before that
27:34I want to bring
27:35in the TMC
27:35spokesperson
27:36allow me to do
27:37that
27:37to bring in
27:38the TMC
27:38spokesperson
27:38into this
27:39conversation
27:39one of the
27:40charges
27:40is also
27:41viewers
27:41that
27:42why the TMC
27:43has mooted
27:44the AI
27:44theory
27:45at the behest
27:46of the BJPIT
27:47cell
27:47colluding with
27:48the EC
27:49is where they
27:50have given
27:50names like
27:51cricketer
27:52Mohammed Shami
27:53who's now been
27:53called for a
27:54hearing
27:54with the EC
27:56on SIR
27:58on Amartya Sen
28:00and some
28:01Bengali actors
28:02but I want to
28:02bring in
28:03Tosifu Rahman
28:04basically
28:04with your
28:05petition filed
28:06today by the
28:07TMC
28:07by your leader
28:08Derek O'Brien
28:09seems to
28:10suggest
28:10and if I go
28:11point by point
28:12Mr. Rahman
28:14that the EC
28:15and that's huge
28:16has acted
28:17outside the
28:18purview of the
28:18law
28:19and has
28:19followed
28:20arbitrary
28:21procedures
28:21during
28:22conducting
28:23the SIR
28:24exercise
28:24in West
28:25Bengal
28:25that's a
28:26huge
28:26charge
28:27good evening
28:28Priti ji
28:29and good
28:29evening
28:29to everyone
28:30Priti ji
28:31our concern
28:31is very
28:31deep
28:32and this
28:33concern
28:33is not
28:33coming up
28:34from the
28:34moon
28:34I mean
28:35it's
28:35there
28:35on the
28:36ground
28:36whatever
28:36the BJP
28:37wants to
28:37say
28:37but they
28:37will not
28:38speak
28:38against
28:38the EC
28:39because
28:39you know
28:40it's
28:40so it's
28:41very simple
28:42you know
28:43so Derek
28:43O'Brien
28:44has moved
28:44to the
28:44Supreme
28:45Court
28:45because
28:45the
28:45election
28:45commission
28:46has
28:46become
28:46a
28:49I mean
28:49operating
28:49through
28:50informal
28:50channel
28:51with
28:51zero
28:51accountability
28:52critical
28:53instruction
28:53and warnings
28:54are being
28:54issued
28:55exclusively
28:55through
28:55whatsapp
28:56you tell
28:56me
28:57who
28:57does
28:57this
28:57from whatsapp
28:59you want
28:59to delete
28:59the names
29:00of Indian
29:00citizens
29:01by passing
29:02formal
29:02statutory
29:03communication
29:03system
29:04this makes
29:05an audit
29:06trial
29:06impossible
29:06and observes
29:07decision makers
29:08of the
29:08accountability
29:09Priti ji
29:09how can
29:10a constitutional
29:11body
29:11abandon
29:11formal
29:12documentation
29:13and operate
29:13like a
29:13private chat
29:14group
29:14I'll show
29:15you the
29:15proof
29:15I mean
29:16I won't
29:17go away
29:17from your
29:18show
29:18I can
29:18show you
29:19the proof
29:19the All
29:20India
29:20Tribunal
29:20Congress
29:20has urged
29:21the Supreme
29:22Court
29:22to declare
29:22all such
29:23informal
29:24whatsapp
29:24instruction
29:25illegal
29:25and direct
29:26the ECI
29:27to use
29:27only formal
29:28statutory
29:28channels
29:29for all
29:29the
29:29communication
29:30I mean
29:30are we
29:31asking
29:31much
29:32from the
29:32election
29:32commission
29:33I mean
29:33once upon
29:34a time
29:34we were
29:34proud
29:35of a
29:35democracy
29:36now it
29:36has become
29:37a hypocrisy
29:37the ECI
29:39deleted
29:3958.20
29:41lakh
29:41to be
29:41precise
29:42voters
29:43without any
29:43notice
29:44or personal
29:45hearing
29:45causing
29:46voter number
29:47to drop
29:47from 7.66
29:48crore
29:49to 7.08
29:50crore
29:51mass deletion
29:52Prithi ji
29:52mass deletion
29:53nearly 60 lakh
29:55citizen
29:55without notice
29:56violence
29:57natural
29:58digital
29:58people
29:59tell
29:59many
29:59ideas
30:00sir
30:00please
30:00allow
30:01there is
30:01no point
30:02talking
30:02over
30:02each
30:02other
30:03you
30:03are
30:03allowed
30:03time
30:04give
30:05the
30:05same
30:06courtesy
30:06half
30:08the
30:08ECI's
30:09own
30:09memo
30:10admits
30:11their
30:11flawed
30:12digitization
30:13of
30:132002
30:13roles
30:14created
30:15widespread
30:15systematic
30:16errors
30:16in
30:17voter
30:17data
30:18mapping
30:18but this
30:20is coming
30:20from
30:20ECI
30:21itself
30:21they created an extrasaturial
30:23logical discrepancy, category
30:25unique to Bengal that will send
30:27notice to 1.36
30:29crore. Pradeep ji, 1.36
30:32crore voters based on
30:33spelling variations and
30:35algorithm errors, all without
30:37and written guidelines.
30:39Alright, okay. I'm going to come back
30:41to you Mr. Rehman. I want to bring in Rajat Sethi back
30:43into this conversation and we'll go to Yogindra Yadav
30:45right after that. Rajat Sethi, nobody is saying
30:47that, you know, the same argument that
30:49was applied to Bihar as well, that
30:51don't conduct the SIR. Conduct it, but
30:53conduct it fairly, give it time
30:55so that everything gets sorted out, there's no
30:57fear-mongering and the reason
30:59for that, and it's playing out right now in
31:01West Bengal where the EC has paused the
31:03hearing for wrongly unmapped
31:05voters. What the EC has said, this is
31:07a technical error because of translation
31:09of a PDF file. Now,
31:11if there are technical errors and you're
31:13dealing with a deadline of 30 days,
31:15why that? Just give more time
31:17so every possible
31:19question, every possible
31:21apprehension can be ironed out.
31:23Preeti ji, what is
31:28comfortable time according to you?
31:31Do you have a number?
31:33And have you not gone in
31:35with a simple thing where, you know,
31:37work has a nature of filling
31:39the space that is there?
31:41Whatever timeline you will give, work
31:43will be done towards closer to the deadline.
31:44That is, we are all habitual to that.
31:48Therefore, I'm asking to you, what is an optimal
31:51timeline? Two months? Three months?
31:54Tell that.
31:55And, you know, by the way, while it was being
31:57wrongly asserted by the TMC spokesperson
31:59here, these are not the final
32:01lists.
32:03These are the draft lists. Again, you can,
32:06there is a window of
32:07two, three months which has been given around which
32:09you can file that, right?
32:11And then thereafter, also, if there are issues, you can
32:13still approach the Election Commission through
32:15the due process. But if you want to tear
32:17aside all due processes
32:19and come out with your idiosyncratic
32:21view of how things should be,
32:23that is up to you. The world doesn't
32:25work by that logic. The world is not
32:27TMC, and TMC is not the world.
32:29So, all I'm saying
32:31here is, if there are
32:33alternate approaches, alternate timelines
32:35that you believe that, say, a 25-crow
32:37population or a 15-16-crow population
32:39of UP can be dealt with, please
32:41suggest, and then I can assure you the
32:43Election Commission will possibly listen to it.
32:45Okay, all right. So, what's the solution?
32:47Yogendra Yadar, please come in. I have, like, little time.
32:49I want to bring in all three of you at the back of it.
32:51Mr. Yadar.
32:53The solution is what the
32:55Election Commission itself has done in the
32:57case of Assam. Actually,
32:59unfortunately, no one in this country has noticed.
33:01In 12 states, one method
33:03was used, SIR, which is to say,
33:05enumeration forms and
33:06all the certificates and papers.
33:09Every single state
33:11has seen massive deletions.
33:12In Assam, a different
33:14method was used, house-to-house
33:16physical verification, additions
33:18and deletions. The result is
33:20after additions and deletions,
33:230% exclusion.
33:25Assam provides the answer.
33:26It's a ready-made answer.
33:27It's a classic physical verification.
33:30Yes, intensive revision is needed.
33:32Yes, serious, thorough revision
33:35of voter's list is a good idea.
33:36But SIR carries
33:38a design defect, and the defect
33:40is such that wherever you
33:42take SIR, it will
33:44always lead to exclusion.
33:46It will always lead to
33:48decline in gender ratio,
33:50something which we have established.
33:52May I point out,
33:53Preeti, that
33:54I had presented three facts.
33:56None of them have been refuted so far.
33:58Number one, that it is the
34:00largest ever exclusion
34:02in the history of the world.
34:04Number two, that this is not
34:06borne out by the population figures.
34:09It should have actually gone up
34:10instead of coming down.
34:11And number three,
34:12it is exactly the opposite
34:14of what another
34:15constitutional authority
34:16has done in the state
34:17of Uttar Pradesh.
34:18All these three point out
34:19to a massive problem
34:21that we are looking at.
34:23And in fact, it's not me.
34:24It is the chief minister
34:25of Uttar Pradesh
34:26who had expressed
34:27deep disappointment
34:2910 days ago,
34:31saying four crore voters
34:32are being deleted.
34:33I'm no fan of Mr. Yogi.
34:36But it's the chief minister
34:37who I'm sure my two friends
34:39may not wish to disagree with
34:40who has said
34:42that this is a problem.
34:43So four crore voters
34:45less than the population figures
34:47would suggest
34:48is, may I suggest,
34:49a serious problem.
34:51All right.
34:52Pradeep Bhandari,
34:52there are valid questions
34:54that Yogendra Yadav has raised.
34:56And that's the reason why
34:58give it time
34:59so that each and every question
35:01can be answered fairly
35:02and there is satisfaction.
35:04Nobody does not want
35:05the SIR to be conducted.
35:07They just want it
35:08to be conducted
35:08in a manner
35:09which seems free of bias.
35:11Even if there is no bias.
35:12Well, Pradeep,
35:14do you agree
35:15at least that
35:16neither you,
35:17me or Mr. Yadav
35:18or Rajas
35:19or Trinul
35:19Congress
35:20is the best judge
35:20out here
35:21when the Supreme Court
35:22has heard the matter
35:23or is hearing the matter?
35:24This was a precise argument,
35:25the similar arguments
35:26which were made in Bihar.
35:28What was the conclusion
35:29of Bihar?
35:30What was the elections
35:31in Bihar
35:31after the SIR
35:32was conducted?
35:33Have you seen Mr. Yadav
35:34going to the court
35:34and saying that
35:35it was a mass
35:36exclusionary exercise?
35:37It should be declared
35:37illegal?
35:38It should be declared wrong?
35:39It should not be done
35:40in this manner?
35:41No.
35:42If they believe
35:43that the exercise
35:43is being conducted
35:44wrongfully in Bengal,
35:46please go to the court.
35:47Please present your arguments.
35:48Why is it that
35:49whenever you go to the court
35:50and present your arguments
35:51on a principal level,
35:52all of those stand rejected?
35:53You are not able
35:54to produce more than
35:5520 cases
35:56where there is
35:57a procedural error?
35:58It is absolutely wrong
35:59to think that it will lead
36:00to a loss of gender ratio.
36:01Please see the voting
36:02percentage in Bihar.
36:03Point number three,
36:04I'll tell you the real issues.
36:06The real issues,
36:06it is but national
36:07that SIR will have exclusion
36:08because you have
36:09so many illegal infotors,
36:10you will have voters
36:11who are dead voters,
36:13you have voters
36:13who are shipments.
36:14It is but national
36:15that the division of voters
36:16cannot lead to inclusion,
36:17it will obviously lead to exclusion.
36:19And this is not what I am saying,
36:20this is what has happened
36:21in the past.
36:22And if you do not believe me,
36:23please present the argument.
36:24And in fact, not me,
36:25it is the booth level agent
36:26of every political party
36:27who is working there
36:28with the VLO,
36:29presenting the cases
36:30at the VLO,
36:31including the Sirmal Congress
36:32who agrees with it.
36:33This is why these metras
36:34whose statements and studios,
36:35including my dear friend
36:36Saurseep and me,
36:38we will present a narrative
36:39which favors our party,
36:40but the ground reality
36:41is accepted by the DLAs.
36:43This is why you see,
36:43he speaks about 58...
36:45I want to bring in Mr. Rehman.
36:46Pradeep Anari,
36:47allow me to bring in Mr. Rehman
36:48and then I'll try to go
36:49for 10 seconds to all of you.
36:51Allow me, sir,
36:52allow me to go to...
36:52Mr. Yadu,
36:53I know you want to comment,
36:54but allow me to bring in
36:54Mr. Rehman
36:55and I'll try and give
36:55all of you 10 seconds after that.
36:57Mr. Rehman, go ahead.
36:59Pritheeji,
36:59this is the problem.
37:00It's not about narrative
37:01if the Plainville Congress
37:01wants to show an narrative
37:03or throw a narrative on BCHP.
37:04The AITC seeks extension
37:06of the January 15 deadline
37:08for claims and objection,
37:09postponement of final role
37:10publication and elimination
37:11of this arbitrary
37:12logical disprensely category.
37:15The ECI is disprensely
37:16against Bengal.
37:17So you are lying daylight, boss.
37:47All right,
37:49I'm going to come
37:49to all of you
37:50for 10 seconds each.
37:52Mr. I think Rajat Sethi,
37:53we don't have him there,
37:54but Mr. Yadav,
37:55go ahead, sir.
37:55Make your point.
37:56You wanted to come in.
37:57I just wanted to clarify
37:58that the Supreme Court of India
38:00has not given any order
38:02whatsoever on this issue.
38:04They have not rejected
38:05any of those things
38:07unless the person here
38:08happens to have
38:09some secret order
38:10which I have not seen.
38:11And incidentally,
38:12it's a contempt of court
38:13to attribute it orders
38:15that they have not given.
38:17Okay.
38:18All right.
38:18Pradeep Bhandari.
38:20Well, Mr. Yadav again,
38:21here is lying.
38:22Mr. Yadav and the entire
38:24applications went
38:25for a say on the SIR.
38:26The Supreme Court denied
38:27any say on the SIR.
38:29For the conduct
38:30of the BR in action,
38:31there has not been
38:32a single observation
38:32of the Supreme Court
38:33which is contravention
38:34to what I have been saying
38:35that the entire exercise
38:37in BR is being free and fair.
38:38Mr. Tawthi was lying
38:39because he knows
38:40that once the SIR exercise
38:41is completed,
38:42that voter has illegal
38:43infiltrators that
38:44the Supreme Court
38:45will be out of the water.
38:46Mr. Rahman, 20 seconds, sir.
38:47Actually, 15 seconds.
38:48Mr. Rahman, make your point.
38:50No, no.
38:52When you are restraining
38:54booth-level agents
38:54from assisting voters
38:55during hearing in Bengal
38:56despite the Supreme Court order,
38:58the ECI engaged
38:59a private vendor
39:00with a checkered contrary...
39:01Okay, I'm going to just let it be
39:05because now it's going to come
39:06into a shouting match.
39:07I'm going to let it be.
39:07I appreciate all three of you
39:08for joining us.
39:10But what we will do
39:10and endeavor to do
39:11is put the spotlight
39:13on the special intensive role
39:15revision exercise
39:16that is being conducted
39:17in the state of West Bengal
39:19and the numbers
39:20that are coming in
39:21of deletion
39:21from the state of Uttar Pradesh
39:23which by the looks of it
39:24is very, very high.
39:26Three crores.
39:27Leave it at that.
39:27But I want to touch in
39:28on a story right now
39:29that comes in from Uttarakhand.
39:31It's a protest
39:33that have been taking place
39:35now for years
39:36where a case
39:37that shook Uttarakhand
39:38is back in the spotlight.
39:40Three years
39:40after 19-year-old
39:42Ankita Bhantari
39:43was brutally murdered.
39:44Protests have once again
39:45erupted across the state
39:47with political parties
39:48and people
39:49not just demanding answers
39:51but a CBI probe
39:52into what really happened.
39:55In fact,
39:55accusations
39:56of a VIP connection
39:58have intensified.
40:00Public outrage
40:01has intensified
40:02putting the state
40:03government
40:03on the defensive.
40:08A political storm
40:25is brewing
40:26in Uttarakhand.
40:35Public anger
40:36rising over
40:37the Ankita Bhantari
40:38murder case.
40:44Across the state,
40:45Congress workers
40:46and civil society members
40:47have hit the streets
40:48demanding a CBI probe
40:50in the case.
40:55Ankita Bhantari,
40:56a 19-year-old
40:57who worked as a receptionist
40:58at a resort near Rishikesh
41:00was found dead
41:01in September 2022.
41:04Three years later,
41:05on the 19th of May 2025,
41:07the resort owner
41:08Polkid Arya
41:09and two others
41:09were convicted of murder.
41:11The police said
41:11Ankita Bhantari
41:12was targeted
41:13after she resisted
41:14Arya's attempts
41:15to push her
41:15into prostitution.
41:17Recently,
41:17actor Urmila Sanawar,
41:19wife of former
41:20BGP MLS
41:20Suresh Rathod,
41:21released recordings
41:22of a conversation
41:23with Rathod
41:24on social media
41:25alleging that
41:26a VIP was involved
41:27in the Ankita murder case.
41:32Since then,
41:33protests are raging.
41:33Ankita Bhantari,
42:01hundreds including
42:02women protesters,
42:03marched towards the Chief Minister's residence on Monday.
42:10Chief Minister Pushkar Dhami rejected the charges of a cover-up.
42:33Ankitab's father, Virendra Bhandari, broke his silence, thanking organizations for reigniting the fight for justice.
42:48The police claim no VIP was ever involved in the case.
43:18But as public anger simmers and trust hangs in the balance,
43:37the Ankitabhandari case remains a painful reminder of a family's loss and a society's demand for the truth.
43:48It has now become a political and moral test for Uttarakhand.
43:59Vira Report, India Today.
44:07We're going to keep a keen eye on developments in Uttarakhand and the story there.
44:11With that, let's move on.
44:12As deposed Venezuelan President Maduro pleaded not guilty in a Manhattan court,
44:18a UN Human Rights Commission official warned that the U.S. operation breached a core principle of international law.
44:24Even as the legal battle unfolds, sources say the Trump administration is preparing talks with oil companies
44:31to explore boosting Venezuelan oil production in the aftermath of Maduro's ouster.
44:38Meanwhile, European leaders have pushed back strongly against Trump's suggestion of taking control of Greenland.
44:44Leaders were unanimous in saying the mineral-rich Arctic land belongs to its people.
44:49My colleague Geetha Mohan spoke exclusively to economist Jeffrey Sachs.
44:54Here are excerpts from that interview.
44:55Do you buy the premise that the action was carried out to take out a drug lord, or does it have to do with oil, power, supremacy?
45:09Many have also said that Maduro provoked him with the televised dancing and mockery of Trump.
45:14What do you think are the primary reasons of provocations over here?
45:20And we've seen visuals over here.
45:22Did you anticipate, and I've been watching your interviews, your conversations,
45:26you must have anticipated all this, the movement, the action,
45:29but picking up a president from Venezuela and bringing him to American soil.
45:36Did you anticipate that?
45:37Well, I anticipated some kind of violent action by the United States.
45:45They do kidnap presidents.
45:49President Aristide of Haiti was kidnapped by the CIA about 20 years ago.
45:57He was marched to a plane with an unmarked tail,
46:01and he was flown 23 hours to the Central African Republic where he was dumped.
46:06In this case, they kidnapped the president of Venezuela and brought him to New York City, my home.
46:14In fact, what will happen next remains to be seen.
46:19If we still have the rule of law in the United States,
46:22a judge should not look kindly on the U.S. government kidnapping the president of another country
46:28and bringing him forcibly to the United States.
46:31So we'll see what the judiciary actually does,
46:35whether there is an independent judiciary still in the United States.
46:38This is a question.
46:40But it was clear that the United States was going to take some kind of violent regime change operation.
46:47And I just would like to share an interesting anecdote as part of this.
46:52In Trump's first term, in September 2017, in his first year of office,
46:59on the margins of the U.N. General Assembly in September of 2017,
47:05Trump had dinner with a number of Latin American presidents.
47:08And he said even then, so we're talking basically about eight years ago,
47:14he said, why don't I just invade Venezuela?
47:17Venezuela. So my point is that this is something that has been on the minds of the U.S. security state
47:26for a long time. In that dinner eight years ago, the Latin American leaders talked him down,
47:34said, Mr. President, that's not a very good idea. It could create a lot of instability.
47:39It might not be helpful for you and for the United States.
47:44Well, this time he didn't seek advice or listen to advice.
47:49He just took his foot off of the brake on our military machine and they went after it.
47:57But Jeff, what's the intent here? Drug trafficking, doing away with drug traffickers,
48:02or is it oil and supremacy? It is two things. One, any left-wing government
48:09is a target of the United States. So this is decades and decades of regime change operations
48:17in the Western Hemisphere when there is a left-wing government. So this is part of it.
48:23And this is a left-wing government. But the second target is oil, obviously. Venezuela has vast oil
48:33reserves. In fact, on the official proved reserves data of the U.S. Geologic Survey and other lists,
48:41Venezuela's approved reserves are the largest in the world, even larger than Saudi Arabia's.
48:48Of course, they're not as economical. They're heavy oil. But they're nearby the United States.
48:54We have the refineries in the southeast of the U.S. Trump, he's a maniac. He looks for oil. He says,
49:01well, that's ours. It's like a child, frankly. But it is part of a deep state which has wanted to
49:09overthrow this government for a very long time. You've already warned that Greenland could be next,
49:15but I have to ask you this. What next? Panama, Colombia, Mexico, Greenland. Katie Miller,
49:20Stephen Miller's wife, had put out a post with the American flag over the Greenland map,
49:25saying, soon. And Trump reiterated the same thing. So is Greenland next?
49:31My fear is that Iran is next. Keep an eye on Iran. The reason is that Israel is obsessed
49:44with Iran, wants to overthrow the Iranian government and the United States for reasons that are not 100%
49:54clear, I have to say, is basically beholden to Israel. The United States fights wars that Israel
50:02tells the United States to fight. It's very, very dark, actually. And so when Netanyahu came to
50:12Mar-a-Lago last week, just around New Year's, they made a joint statement, basically saying, Iran,
50:20you're next, or you could be next. And Trump has said that with protests in Iran, if the government
50:30cracks down on the protests, we are basically locked and loaded. We're ready to fight.
50:36Well, this is clearly, clearly a typical deep state provocation. In other words,
50:45we're lining up the arguments, the human rights argument. We're going to go in and invade Iran
50:51to protect the people of Iran. This is a standard playbook. And so this is where I would expect
51:00the possibility of a real global explosion. And I would give a warning. That one will be hotter than
51:09Venezuela if it happens. It would be potentially disastrous because while Venezuela is in the
51:17American geographic neighborhood and China and Russia don't want to take on the United States
51:24in the Western Hemisphere, Iran is in the middle of a lot of major powers. And Iran is itself with
51:34hypersonic missiles and a capacity to do a lot of harm and a lot of damage. And Israel is a nuclear
51:43armed country. All in all, it's a recipe for potential disaster. And sound heads should be saying to the
51:52United States right now, stop it. Monro doctrine now by some has been recristened Donro doctrine.
52:00And we're looking at a Western Hemisphere narrative that has been put out by the Trump
52:06administration. Isn't that imperialistic and expansionist in nature at a time when maybe it's
52:13not just the international laws, but Trump has also violated some of the domestic war laws by not
52:18informing the Armed Services Committee, the Congress not being kept in the loop, sir?
52:24Look, we don't have a constitutional order right now. All of those tariffs that were put on India,
52:30for example, were the whim of the President of the United States declaring this emergency or that
52:36emergency by executive decree. Congress has the power of war, not the President. But it doesn't matter.
52:44And when a congressman complained that this is unconstitutional, Trump mocked him. Constitution?
52:51What are you whining about, he said. So we have a political crisis in the United States.
53:01It's not called that. It's not recognized like that. Congressmen still go to their office or they
53:08go to the floor of the House or the Senate, but they don't play a role. This is an executive branch
53:15that's on its own right now. And this is also very sad and very dangerous.
53:21The Western Hemisphere argument by the United States of America, does that now give
53:27room for China to play out its plans for a takeover of Taiwan at a time when they're saying,
53:34this is our region, China can say, okay, we've done nothing there, then you do nothing here?
53:40Well, I hope that China and India, indeed the BRICS countries, will say this is not the way
53:49we want the world to operate. We want the world to operate according to the UN charter,
53:55to international law. I believe that what has happened is actually an important opportunity
54:01for the BRICS, which this year has the Indian presidency, to say, no, we represent the bulk
54:11of humanity. In fact, the emerging and developing economies are 85 percent of the world population.
54:18We don't want to go down the road of rogue states. And so I hope that the BRICS actually make
54:26a real point right now. This is not how we behave. This is not how we're going to behave.
54:31We will defend the UN charter.
54:35All right. What you really can do is catch the full interview with my colleague Geeta Mohan
54:40with Jeffrey Sachs at 10.30 p.m. tonight in just the next half hour.
54:44All right. That's an interview you need to stay tuned for, but I'm going to end with the image
54:53of the day. Now, it's a bizarre turn of events and it happened in Kota Rajasthan. The thief
54:59found himself in a very tight spot, literally in a very tight spot. Attempting a break-in,
55:06the man got struck headfirst in a hole meant for an exhaust fan dangling 10 feet above the ground.
55:12Rather than giving up, he threatened the homeowners, claiming accomplices nearby.
55:18The owners immediately called the police. Dramatic visuals show cops carefully pulling the man
55:24inside, wincing in pain as he struggles to his feet. A daring escape plan gone hilariously wrong
55:31and a thief literally caught between a hole had a very hard place. Well, that's our image of the
55:37day. And I also want to add to it, the owners of the house, the residents had actually gone to the
55:42Khartu-Sham temple to pray and came back to actually see the thief hanging there in that vent.
55:53Quite amazing. A bit of divine intervention with the thief getting caught.
55:57Well, that was funny. With that, a quick break to stay with us. We're going to see you tomorrow
56:08night at 9pm. Have a good evening.