Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 10 months ago
A special report details the escalating political conflict over the Election Commission's Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls. The issue has advanced to the Supreme Court after TMC MP Derek O'Brien filed a case alleging procedural irregularities and the 'mass deletion' of nearly 60 lakh voters in West Bengal. Political analyst Yogendra Yadav describes the deletion of 2.89 crore voters in Uttar Pradesh as unprecedented. The BJP has defended the exercise against opposition claims. Internationally, the program features an interview with economist Jeffrey Sachs, who critiques the 'Donald Doctrine' following the arrest of Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro, and warns that 'Iran is next'. The report also covers renewed protests in Uttarakhand for the Ankita Bhandari murder case, with public demands for a CBI probe amid allegations of 'VIP' involvement.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Welcome, you're watching News Today at 9pm. I am Preeti Chaudhary, our big talking point this evening.
00:06The TMC has taken on the Election Commission, this time going directly to the top pot of the country.
00:13The SIR back in focus in Uttar Pradesh as well, where 2 crore, 89 lakh voters have been deleted in Uttar Pradesh's SIR.
00:23SIR, Special Intensive Role Revision, leading to mass deletions.
00:28Once again, a question that we will ask during the course of this bulletin.
00:33Also, we have an exclusive lined up for you, Jeffrey Sachs on Trump's Venezuela gambit.
00:39All of that coming up. First, allow me to take you through the headlines.
00:46Showdown over SIR exercise escalates. TMC MP Derek O'Brien moves Apex Court against SIR, alleging procedural irregularities.
00:56Poll body releases draft list in UP, 2.8 crore deleted from the rolls.
01:08Controversy over provocative slogans in JNU after Supreme Court denies bail to Umar Khalid.
01:14Modi Shah Ki Kabar Khudegi slogans chanted. Disciplinary action to be taken against those involved.
01:20The student body in where new claims bid to defame the students of JNU.
01:26And they were being misrepresented.
01:31Apex Court lashes out at pollution body over worsening air in Delhi.
01:35Directs CAQM to form a panel of experts to determine cause of pollution and solve the issue.
01:41It's a setback for the Stalin government.
01:46Madras High Court upholds single-judge verdict to light Deepam in Madurai.
01:51The DMK government now to move the top court, challenging the High Court's verdict.
02:00CBI summons Vijay in Karoor stampede case.
02:03CBI summons Vijay on January 12th.
02:0541 died in the stampede at Vijay's Karoor rally.
02:09Health care for all and a question on the scheme Ayushman Bharat.
02:18Health care still a luxury for poor.
02:21Eye-opening India today.
02:23Reality check on how Ayushman scheme has not been implemented.
02:32There is no end to Hindu hate in Bangladesh.
02:3540-year-old Saraj Chakravarti dies after being attacked with sharp weapons.
02:39This comes just hours after another Hindu, Rana Prathap, was killed.
02:48The centre gives Elon Musk's ex additional time till January 7th
02:52to submit a detailed action-taken report over obscene content.
02:56Earlier, government issued a stern warning to the social media platform over misuse of Grok.
03:01And European leaders strongly oppose Trump's suggestion to take control of Greenland.
03:11Key leaders unanimously say the Arctic island, Greenland, which is rich in minerals, belongs to its people.
03:18All right, viewers.
03:28After Bihar, political heat is rising in West Bengal and Uttar Pradesh
03:33over the poll body's special intensive revision of the voter rolls.
03:38The TMC Congress, the Trinimal Congress, has approached the top court alleging errors,
03:45undisclosed algorithm and voter deletion through AI put together by the BJP's IT cell.
03:54While the EC insists the process is fair with elections around the corner,
03:59this battle over who gets to vote is turning into a full-blown political showdown.
04:04Here's the full report.
04:04Political heat over the special intensive revision of electoral rolls is rising.
04:14The Trinimal Congress has moved the Supreme Court against the Election Commission,
04:19questioning the process followed by the poll body.
04:23The petition claims voters are being deleted centrally
04:25without the knowledge of electoral registration officers.
04:29The party accuses the EC of mapping voters using undisclosed algorithms and software.
04:36The plea claims that state CEO issued instructions to officials
04:40through WhatsApp messages and oral directions.
04:44It seeks extension of deadline for submitting claims and objections
04:47from the currently fixed January 15th.
04:50The party wants EC to allow boot-level agents of parties
04:54to assist voters during hearings,
04:57allow virtual hearings through family member for migrant voters,
05:01and doorstep or telephonic verification
05:03to those above 60 with medical conditions.
05:07The West Bengal Chief Electoral Officer on December 29th halted hearings
05:36for thousands of voters who were wrongly marked as unmapped.
05:40The CEO's directive claimed that the mistake was due to error
05:44in conversion of PDF of 2002 voter list into a different format.
05:49The interview brings this to
05:49Ujjjalto hanas Yayakti
05:58if we come to know your head when,
06:02in terms of the answer,
06:03we become the last newspaper of each household
06:07who is Ôm пробi.
06:08But we get caught up in seeing the Mockash
06:08of the country's affairs for theVISO.
06:11until nine years of the years,
06:12for traditional laws,
06:13the least for the rights of Weigal
06:14and the least for the single many measures.
06:14That's where the fact that the person
06:15was going to act躍 a few years ago,
06:16functions in the city in volcanoes
06:18The BJP has rejected TMC charges.
06:48The BJP has been cleaned up in India, the government is also going to go to Bangladesh.
06:54There is no matter what they need to know, but after the 14th February,
06:58the name of a genuine voter, which is Indian, will be deleted.
07:02The document will be deleted.
07:04Meanwhile, the EC released the draft Electoral Role for Uttar Pradesh.
07:09Out of 15.44 crore voters, 12.55 crore or 81.30% submitted emuneration forms,
07:172.89 crore, that is roughly 18.70% were left out.
07:22So, Mirtak madata 46.23 lakh, 46.23 lakh.
07:28Laapta yaan upasthit rahe yaa unko field mein DLO ko mile nahin.
07:32Aise 2.17 crore madata hain.
07:362.17 crore.
07:40Or agar putishat mein kahin tohhhhada dashamlaw shunya chhe.
07:4414.06%.
07:45The special intensive revision has become an election issue in West Bengal,
07:52with the ruling TMC alleging targeted deletions.
07:56Assembly elections in Bengal are likely to be held after three months.
08:00Bureau Report, India Today.
08:03All right, so the question that we asked this evening,
08:07SIR leading to mass deletions in Uttar Pradesh in West Bengal,
08:11is SIR purification or exclusionary?
08:15Does the EC need to be more transparent?
08:18Fear mongering by opposition parties is a charge that has been laid by the government.
08:22All right, let me take all these questions first to Dr. S.Y. Qureshi, former CEC.
08:27Mr. Qureshi, thank you for taking the time out and joining us on news today.
08:31First up, the focus, Mr. Qureshi, is back on the EC's adherence to statutory procedures.
08:37Compared to the past elections in which you presided over role revisions,
08:43what is the difference?
08:45Well, there is no doubt that the purification of electoral roles
08:52is the first responsibility of the election commission.
08:55In fact, I take you back to the framing of the constitution.
08:59That was the time when the decision was being taken
09:03that since the elections will be held only once in five years,
09:06why should we have even a single officer full-time,
09:10only at the time of election we will appoint a CEC?
09:13That is when it was said that no electoral roles have to be updated every year,
09:18for which we need an officer.
09:20So let us have at least one officer, which will be the CEC,
09:23and that is how CEC institution was born.
09:27So the point here is that the focus on the purification of electoral role
09:32and that regular updation is a constitutional mandate
09:35and a legal mandate without doubt, right?
09:38At the same time, I would like to say that for the last 75 years,
09:42all of us have been making all kinds of efforts to update and purify the roles,
09:49some with success, some with lesser success,
09:52but all of us have been working on it.
09:54Now, in 2003 and 2004, we used to have an intensive revision.
09:59That is also for sure. That is true.
10:01That is true.
10:02But in 2003, it was decided by the then commission that now that you have digitized the electoral role,
10:11it is easier, better to update them every year by going door to door.
10:18Now, throwing out the existing rules into the dustbin totally and starting afresh,
10:25that leads to my question that what took us 30 years to achieve 99 perfection,
10:33these people think that they will do it in 30 days.
10:37I think if they do it, congratulations and very well done.
10:40But it's impossible.
10:41It's impossible.
10:42The kind of deletions will happen, the kind of complaints will crop up.
10:46You will see as the situation develops.
10:50All right.
10:51So you're saying to complete an exercise in 30 days, which usually have taken years,
10:57will lead to further chaos.
10:59So should, you know, one final question, Mr. Qureshi, before I let you go.
11:03So should the EC come clean with safeguards that could prevent perception of bias?
11:07Because you have the TMC and I'm going to take you through on some of the points that they want relief on.
11:13They've approached the top court of the country, the Supreme Court.
11:16While on the other hand, there have been about 2 crores, 80 lakh deletions in the state of Uttar Pradesh that has also been contested.
11:22Now, should the EC, where these concerns are concerned, and these are concerns that they have raised,
11:29that the EC should extend the deadline for submitting claims and objections,
11:33that the EC should stop issuing formal instructions through channels like WhatsApp,
11:38that the EC ensure no voter is left out because of erroneous mapping, which there is already a pause.
11:44The EC has given an explanation on that account.
11:47That the EC do away with extra statutory category described by it as a logical discrepancy.
11:55That the EC allow booth-level agents to assist voters during hearings.
11:59So there are a number of issues that the TMC has raised.
12:02Do you think the EC needs to take it in the right spirit and address them point by point?
12:06Yes, absolutely. In fact, it all boils down to transparency.
12:11Exactly everything that they do should be transparent, and they should be open to the suggestions and criticism of the public and the opposition,
12:19and address them to their satisfaction.
12:22Now, taking you to Bihar, the initial exercise was started in the name of foreigners.
12:29Oh, there are so many foreigners that we have to identify them and throw them out.
12:33Wonderful idea. You should do it.
12:36And what is it that we found? Number one, we haven't heard from the election commission how many foreigners were found.
12:43We only heard from the media that in eight crore Biharis who were made to run around from pillar to post,
12:50they were able to find 500 foreigners, of which 150 were Bangladeshis and 350 were Hindu women from Nepal,
12:59who had come by marriage to Bihar.
13:02Right. But Mr. Qureshi, the defence, the defence of the EC has been in through it all,
13:07that where Bihar is concerned, because you are using Bihar as an example,
13:10that there were no complaints that were fight by political parties and activists.
13:14Yeah, actually that's the point which is quite baffling.
13:17At the same time, I have heard only on the media, I know nothing from the hulk's mouth,
13:22that the people who went to complain to Bihar, because Bihar was the frontline person,
13:28they were shooed away.
13:30So, all 65 lakhs, just keeping quiet, and let there be an external audit even now,
13:38whether the 65 lakh deletion.
13:41Okay.
13:42After all, in the Supreme Court, people appeared, who had been declared dead,
13:47by, you know, there may have been no appeal and no complaint, but they were declared dead and deleted.
13:53They appeared before the Supreme Court,
13:54Sir, I'm alive, I'm here and I've been deleted.
13:57Okay.
13:58So, what about the explanation of all these cases?
14:00All right.
14:01So, one final point, Mr. Qureshi.
14:02You're saying the EC needs to be transparent.
14:04It needs to address all the points that have been raised by the TMC in West Bengal.
14:07You have the Samajwadi Party and the Congress in the state of Uttar Pradesh.
14:11Come clean.
14:12Give point-by-point rebuttal to all the clauses that have been raised by both parties.
14:16Correct, sir?
14:17That's what you're saying.
14:18Absolutely.
14:19And you're saying extend the timeline.
14:23Yes.
14:24Exactly.
14:25In Bihar, one could understand that there was very time available.
14:29But this is an exercise which goes on around the year.
14:32Pick up the state which are going to pour three years down the line.
14:36Why immediately which are going to pour in two months and create all the chaos
14:40and demand for extension by a week, by a fortnight.
14:45So, I still feel that the last word is yet to be heard.
14:50And even out of 65 lakhs, how many were illegally deleted.
14:54This will all come out in due course.
14:57Okay.
14:58All right, sir.
14:59Thank you for joining us and taking the time out.
15:01Let's take all these questions.
15:02Okay, yes, make your point, sir.
15:04Very quickly.
15:05If I can make...
15:06Yeah, you know, you had mentioned about artificial intelligence
15:08and the misuse of computers.
15:10That is a very serious charge.
15:12And that's a very serious possibility.
15:14We...
15:15Again, the election commission should come clean.
15:17Whether they have hired some agencies using artificial intelligence
15:20to...
15:21Okay.
15:22I would not say manipulate the role, but to manage the role.
15:24So, that also has to be clear.
15:26Okay.
15:27Now, that's a charge.
15:28You know, fair point.
15:29So, you're saying, you know, the EC needs to come clean on that
15:31because I'll just elaborate with the charges.
15:33The TMC says that the EC is using artificial intelligence
15:36via the BJP IT cell.
15:39That is deleting, you know, roles and names from the West Bengal voter list
15:45through artificial intelligence.
15:47Now, that's a charge that the TMC government and Mamata Banuji is making.
15:52Thank you, Mr. Qureshi, for taking the time out and joining us.
15:54We're going to take all these questions to our panelists this evening.
15:57This evening, joining me, Rajat Sethi, political analyst, Yogendra Yadav,
16:00co-founder Swaraj India, Pradeep Bhandari, national spokesperson, BJP,
16:04Tawseep Rehman, spokesperson, TMC.
16:07I'd like to begin with you, Mr. Bhandari.
16:09Now, with what the TMC has accused the EC of,
16:13the TMC has approached the top court of the country,
16:16we can go point by point on the apprehensions that the EC has raised.
16:20But the larger question, Pradeep Bhandari, is that maybe this whole exercise is being rushed.
16:27And why I say that is because the EC's pause on hearing for wrongly unmapped voters
16:33due to technical errors has been cited as an issue by the TMC,
16:37as evidence of what the TMC feels as acute mismanagement.
16:41Now, how does this glitch somewhere down the line reflect on the necessity of SIR
16:46to clean rolls inflated by what bogus voters is what the EC suggests,
16:52especially in the timeframe allotted?
16:55Pradeep Bhandari, first of all, the questions which are directed to the election commission
17:01would be answered by the election commission
17:03and the pension of the Tribunal Congress is in the Supreme Court,
17:06and the Supreme Court is...
17:08Pradeep Bhandari, would you correct your audio?
17:09We're having a bit of a problem with your audio.
17:11Would you correct that and we're going to come right back to you
17:13because there's a problem with your audio link.
17:15Let Pradeep correct that.
17:17I want to cut across to...
17:19Rajat, would you want to take that question?
17:21Because the EC itself has paused the hearing for wrongly unmapped voters.
17:24They are saying that there is a problem with some conversion of PDF,
17:27but there is a procedural issue.
17:30See, you know, you are operating at extensive scales.
17:35Also, you know, you need to double click into the process
17:38as to what all has the election commission done in the run-up
17:42while there was an initial deadline.
17:44The initial reports when it came about that nearly three crore voters were deleted.
17:49Then the authorities said that, okay, let us give additional time.
17:53And then, you know, more weeks were given.
17:56After, in that window, new...
17:58When it was realized that certain polling booths were crossing the threshold of 1,000 voters,
18:02around 1,500 new polling booths were also created.
18:05This was all done to revisit the exercise and to ensure that there are absolutely no voters
18:11which have been deleted just because of, you know, the overpressure on the BLO
18:15or BLO not being able to go to that household for the mandate three times.
18:20All of this was established.
18:22But, you know, I think the only problem in this analysis is that we are starting with something sinister.
18:27We are starting with that assumption.
18:29Instead of that, we are not interpreting it in a way that people have actually moved out,
18:33moved out of the state of UP.
18:35There are already around 50 lakh voters which are presumed dead here.
18:40There is also a certain set of voters which have moved out.
18:45And there is another set of voters broadly categorized where the reasons for the dip in these voters are articulated.
18:52And by the way, this is still not final.
18:55March is a timeline when you can still...
18:57First, the draft would be published.
18:59If there are voters who have been missed out, they still have the opportunity.
19:02They still have two months.
19:03But, you know, there is a method to madness.
19:06You cannot have completely ad hoc and give years and years and years of time in a day and age when we claim that things should move digital.
19:12Things should be done using the techniques and then should be in a compressed timeline.
19:17Okay.
19:18I mean, how is it normal?
19:19I was hearing Kureshi say that it is normal to do it over several years.
19:22Okay, Rajat, I am going to come back to you also because you also need to correct your internet connection.
19:27We are losing your video.
19:28Your audio is perfect, but there is a problem with your video.
19:31I want to bring in Yogendra Yadav into this conversation.
19:33With what Rajat said, Yogendra Yadav, that there are people who have moved out.
19:37So these deletions shouldn't really be surprising.
19:39But I would like to take our viewers through the deletions that have actually happened state by state.
19:43In Bihar, before SIR, there were 7.89 crores voters.
19:49Post-SIR that dropped to 7.42 crores.
19:53There was a deletion of 47 lakhs.
19:55In Uttar Pradesh, there has been a deletion now of 2.89 crores, where before SIR, the voter list had 15.44 crore voters.
20:05Now it has 12.55 crore voters.
20:08Vis-a-vis West Bengal, there has been a drop of about 58 lakh voters.
20:13Do you think it's just people have just moved out?
20:16You know, there hasn't been purification of voter rolls for so long.
20:19Or do you think this is a systematic way of undermining electoral fairness by disenfranchisement?
20:25Preeti, I wish to begin by reminding us that what we have witnessed today, namely an exclusion of 2 crore 89 lakh voters, is unprecedented in human history.
20:40Not just Indian history, not just Indian electoral history.
20:44Nowhere in the world has this scale of exclusion of voters ever taken place.
20:51We are speaking something very important.
20:55Number two, one simple way of judging, and that's something I've been saying over and over again, that, you know, the first presumption can be alright.
21:04There were too many voters.
21:05Maybe they were wrong voters.
21:06Maybe the list was originally inflated.
21:08One simple way of checking that is to ask what is the adult population of Uttar Pradesh today?
21:14Now you have those figures.
21:16Before SIR, we had 15.45 crore people there.
21:20What was the population of UP at that point?
21:2316 crore 6 lakhs.
21:25These are not my figures, Preeti.
21:27These are figures of Government of India, Population Projection Committee.
21:31So, if there was a fair SIR, the number should have gone up from 15 crore 45 lakhs to something closer to 16 crores.
21:41And what do we have?
21:42It has come down to 12.65 crores.
21:46Now, responding to what Rajat said, it would have been a fair assumption six months ago.
21:52You may say, okay, Bihar has, you know, too many people leaving Bihar.
21:55Uttar Pradesh is also an out-migration state.
21:58But fortunately, Preeti, now we have in front of us data from in-migration states.
22:03And these are not my classifications.
22:05These are classifications of Niti Aayoga of India.
22:07In-migration states are Gujarat and Tamil Nadu.
22:10Can you please show your viewers the figures from Gujarat and Tamil Nadu?
22:13In Tamil Nadu.
22:14Gujarat has had a deletion of 73, 74 lakhs.
22:1873.7 lakhs.
22:19That's right.
22:20Tamil Nadu has had a deletion of 97 lakhs.
22:23These are in-migration states.
22:25So, the argument about out-migration falls flat.
22:28And may I also mention something very, very interesting and scandalous, Preeti.
22:33At the time when ECI has conducted an extensive revision of voters list in Uttar Pradesh, exactly
22:43at that same time, another constitutional body, namely State Election Commission of Uttar Pradesh,
22:49has prepared fresh electoral rolls for panchayat elections.
22:53They also carried out extensive revision in which 1.4 crore voters were deleted, 1.8 were added.
23:00And you know, Preeti, what is the figure?
23:02According to Election Commission of India, figures released this evening,
23:06the whole of UP has 12.4 crore voters, or 12.56 crore voters.
23:12And according to State Election Commission of Uttar Pradesh, figures released on 5th of December,
23:18the rural Uttar Pradesh alone has 12.7 crore voters.
23:22Alright, so you're saying there are lots of...
23:24Okay.
23:25So, lots of anomalies and variations there, which what Yugendra Yadav is pointing out,
23:28and he's just talking about, and the number of deletions that have taken place.
23:31Okay, we have Pradeep Bhandari back with us.
23:33Pradeep Bhandari, I want to bring you back in.
23:35He's laughing, but Pradeep Bhandari, it is.
23:37You know, one really does need to look into the sheer deletion that has happened in the state of Uttar Pradesh.
23:42Nearly 3 crore voters have been deleted, which is a deletion of nearly 19%, where we are talking about the voters of the state of Uttar Pradesh.
23:50There have been deletions right from the state of Gujarat, from Tamil Nadu, Kerala, Chhattisgarh, Rajasthan.
23:56And, you know, the numbers are big.
23:59That's one aspect of it.
24:00The other, of course, is the charge that has been laid by the TMC, where, you know, the TMC has gone to the top court.
24:07It's something that the BJP always said that, you know, approach the courts.
24:10They've gone to the top court with a list, which they feel are grave anomalies in the way the EC is carrying out the SIR process.
24:17And a big charge there is that the use of artificial intelligence, where the EC is colluding with the BJP IT cell to delete names.
24:29Well, Mr. Speaker, before me, we will find everything scandalous till the time we see Rahul Gandhi becoming the Prime Minister, which will not happen in his lifetime or my lifetime.
24:40Let us just state certain facts.
24:42This is the same pattern which was followed in Bihar elections.
24:45And before the Bihar elections, where certain articles, as a speaker, by R.J.T. in the Congress was written,
24:52when the entire matter went to the Supreme Court, the primacy and the principle of the petition was that SIR should be stayed, and it was rejected in the court.
25:01And not even, not more than 20 names could be produced, where claims were made that crores of voters and lakhs of voters were deleted from Bihar.
25:08After the elections were finished in Bihar, neither the R.J.D. or the Congress could even produce a single fact,
25:15which proved that the election was rigged or the SIR was favoring the Bharti Rensa party.
25:19What is the fact right now?
25:21The fact right now is that, at present, the Tinamul Congress has 77,867 BLAs.
25:27Now, the BLAs are individuals who have been appointed by various political parties on the booth,
25:32if gentlemen here do not know about it.
25:34And the BLAs have only till now put three applications for inclusion and there have been zero applications for exclusion.
25:41The election commission has given at least more than a month of time,
25:44whereas the Tinamul Congress believes, or any party including ours,
25:48believe that the process is favoring us or the PNC, we can approach the court or we can approach the election commission.
25:54There is a whole narrative of creating a hysteria, creating doubt in the mind of voters failed in Bihar and also failed in Bengal.
26:01Now what is the truth in Bengal?
26:02The truth in Bengal is there is an electoral officer, Sipur Gan, who goes to inspect and the Tinamul Congress
26:08and Coons and Gundas try to encircle him and there is an FIR which is registered.
26:12What is the truth?
26:13The truth is that whether it is Abhishek Banerjee or Mamta Banerjee,
26:16they have claimed that the SIR process is a process which they will not allow because it favors the BJP
26:22and they will even go to the extent of breaking the nets of the electoral officer.
26:26Now the law and order is in the state subject.
26:29So what we are here saying is that if the Tinamul Congress believes that the matter is favoring us,
26:34please go to the court.
26:35Now they've gone to the court, let them present the facts in front of the court.
26:38It's the same pattern that each political party follows.
26:41They will present certain technical arguments,
26:43the technical arguments backed by technicalities without having an iota of facts.
26:47And this is why it is rejected by the court.
26:49And this is why I ask you that at the present moment in Uttakradesh,
26:54your argument is that so many voters are deleted.
26:57Voters are even deleted from places where the Bharati Janta party has won.
27:00If we believe that if one of our voters or the gentleman voters is removed,
27:05RBLM will go and apply in form 6 or in form 7.
27:08If the Samajwadi party believes that its voters is removed, it will apply in form 7.
27:12Pradeep Bhandari, when that is concerned, it's not about just the Samajwadi party voters being removed.
27:17It's a basic question of disenfranchisement.
27:20That is what is the question.
27:22My argument really is that the basic question was also putting in the Bihar electoral process,
27:27but when the entire matter went to the Supreme Court,
27:30Mr. Yadav could not even present a certain fact.
27:32Okay, I'll cut across to you again to Yadav.
27:34Before that, I want to bring in the TMC spokesperson.
27:36Allow me to do that, to bring in the TMC spokesperson into this conversation.
27:39One of the charges is also viewers that why the TMC has mooted the AI theory
27:45at the behest of the BJPIT cell colluding with the EC,
27:49is where they have given names like cricketer Muhammad Shami,
27:53who has now been called for a hearing with the EC on SIR,
27:58on Amartya Sen and some Bengali actors.
28:02But I want to bring in Tawasifur Rahman.
28:04Basically, with your petition filed today by the TMC, by your leader Derek O'Brien,
28:09seems to suggest, and if I go point by point, Mr. Rahman,
28:14that the EC, and that's huge, has acted outside the purview of the law
28:19and has followed arbitrary procedures during conducting the SIR exercise in West Bengal.
28:26That's a huge charge.
28:28Good evening, Preeti Ji, and good evening to everyone.
28:30Preeti Ji, our concern is very deep, and this concern is not coming up from the moon.
28:35I mean, it's there on the ground.
28:36Whatever the BJP wants to say, but they will not speak against the EC.
28:39Because, you know, Chor Chor Musere Bhai, so it's very simple.
28:42You know, so Derek O'Brien has moved to the Supreme Court
28:45because the election commission has become a WhatsApp commission.
28:47I've told you before as well.
28:49I mean, operating through informal channel with zero accountability.
28:52Critical instruction and warnings are being issued exclusively through WhatsApp.
28:56You tell me, who does this?
28:58From WhatsApp, you want to delete the names of Indian citizens
29:01by passing formal statutory communication system.
29:04This makes an audit, trial impossible, and observes decision-makers of the accountability, Preeti Ji.
29:09How can a constitutional body abandon formal documentation and operate like a private chat group?
29:15I'll show you the proof.
29:16I mean, I won't go away from your show.
29:18I can show you the proof.
29:19The All India Tribunal Congress has urged the Supreme Court
29:22to declare all such informal WhatsApp instruction illegal
29:26and direct the ECI to use only formal statutory channels for all the communication.
29:30I mean, are we asking much from the election commission?
29:33I mean, once upon a time, we were proud of a democracy.
29:36Now it has become a hypocrisy.
29:38The ECI deleted 58.20 lakh to be precise.
29:42Voters without any notice or personal hearing.
29:46Causing voter number to drop from 7.66 crore to 7.08 crore.
29:51Mass deletion, Preeti Ji. Mass deletion.
29:54Nearly 60 lakh citizens without notice.
29:57Violates natural...
29:59Sir, please allow.
30:01You know, there's no point talking over each other.
30:03You've got to allow, you know, time.
30:05Yes.
30:06Now, Preeti Ji, tell me this.
30:08The ECI's own memo admits their flawed digitization of 2002 roles
30:14created widespread systematic errors in voter data mapping.
30:18We don't mean it.
30:20But this is coming from ECI itself.
30:22They created an extra-saturated logical discrepancy.
30:26We don't mean it to Bengal.
30:28That will send notice to 1.36 crore.
30:30Pradeep Ji.
30:31Okay.
30:321.36 crore voters based on spelling variations and algorithm errors.
30:36Okay.
30:37All without and written guidelines.
30:39Without written guidelines.
30:40All right, okay.
30:41I'm going to come back to you, Mr. Rehman.
30:42I want to bring in Rajat Sethi back into this conversation, and we'll go to Yogindra Yadav
30:45right after that.
30:46Rajat Sethi, nobody's saying that, you know, the same argument that was applied to Bihar
30:50as well, that don't conduct the SIR.
30:52Conduct it, but conduct it fairly, give it time, so that everything gets sorted out.
30:57There's no fear-mongering, and the reason for that, and it's playing out right now in West
31:02Bengal, where the EC has paused the hearing for wrongly unmapped voters.
31:06What the EC has said, this is a technical error because of translation of a PDF file.
31:10Now, if there are technical errors, and you're dealing with a deadline of 30 days, why that?
31:16Just give more time, so every possible question, every possible apprehension can be ironed out.
31:26Preeti ji, what is comfortable time according to you?
31:31Do you have a number?
31:33And have you not gone in with a simple thing where, you know, work has a nature of filling the space that is there?
31:41Whatever timeline you will give, work will be done towards closer to the deadline.
31:45That is, we are all habitual to that.
31:48And therefore, I'm asking to you, what is an optimal timeline?
31:52Two months? Three months?
31:54Tell that, and you know, by the way, while it was being wrongly asserted by the TMC spokesperson here, these are not the final lists.
32:03These are the draft lists.
32:04Again, you can, there is a window of two, three months, which has been given around which you can file that, right?
32:10And then thereafter, also, if there are issues, you can still approach the election commission through the due process.
32:16But if you want to tear aside all due processes, and come out with your idiosyncratic view of how things should be, that is up to you.
32:24The world doesn't work by that logic. The world is not TMC, and TMC is not the world.
32:29So, all I'm saying here is, if there are alternate approaches, alternate timelines that you believe that, say, a 25 crore population or a 15, 16 crore population of UP can be dealt with, please suggest, and then I can assure you the election commission will possibly listen to it.
32:45Okay. All right. So, what's the solution? Yogendra Yadar, please come in. I have, like, little time. I want to bring in all three of you at the back of it. Mr. Yadar.
32:53The solution is what the election commission itself has done in the case of Assam. Actually, unfortunately, no one in this country has noticed.
33:01In 12 states, one method was used, SIR, which is to say, enumeration forms and all the certificates and papers.
33:09Every single state has seen massive deletions. In Assam, a different method was used, house-to-house physical verification, additions and deletions.
33:19The result is, after additions and deletions, 0% exclusion. Assam provides the answer. It's a ready-made answer. It's a classic physical verification.
33:29Yes, intensive revision is needed. Yes, serious, thorough revision of voters. This is a good idea.
33:37But SIR carries a design defect, and the defect is such that wherever you take SIR, it will always lead to exclusion.
33:46It will always lead to decline in gender ratio, something which we have established.
33:52May I point out, Preeti, that I had presented three facts. None of them have been refuted so far.
33:59Number one, that it is the largest ever exclusion in the history of the world.
34:04Number two, that this is not borne out by the population figures. It should have actually gone up instead of coming down.
34:12And number three, it is exactly the opposite of what another constitutional authority has done in the state of Uttar Pradesh.
34:18All these three point out to a massive problem that we are looking at.
34:23And in fact, it's not me. It is the chief minister of Uttar Pradesh who had expressed deep disappointment ten days ago,
34:31saying four crore voters are being deleted. I'm no fan of Mr. Yogi.
34:36But it's the chief minister, who I'm sure my two friends may not wish to disagree with, who has said that this is a problem.
34:43So, four crore voters less than the population figures would suggest is, may I suggest, a serious problem.
34:50All right, Pradeep Bhandari, there are valid questions that Yogendra Yadav has raised.
34:56And that's the reason why. Give it time so that each and every question can be answered fairly and there is satisfaction.
35:03Nobody does not want the SIR to be conducted. They just want it to be conducted in a manner which seems free of bias, even if there is no bias.
35:14Well, Pradeep, do you agree at least that neither you, me or Mr. Yadav or Rajat or Trinul Congress is the best judge out here when the Supreme Court has heard the matter or is hearing the matter?
35:24This was a precise argument, the similar arguments which were made in Bihar.
35:28What was the conclusion of Bihar? What was the elections in Bihar after the SIR was conducted?
35:33Have you seen Mr. Yadav going to the court and saying that it was a mass exclusionary exercise, it should be declared illegal, it should be declared wrong, it should not be done in this manner?
35:41No! If they believe that the exercise is being conducted wrongfully in Bengal, please go to the court, please present your arguments.
35:48Why is it that whenever you go to the court and present your arguments on a principle level, all of those stand rejected, you are not able to produce more than 20 cases where there is a procedural error?
35:58It is absolutely wrong to think that it will lead to a loss of gender ratio, please see the voting percentage in Bihar.
36:03Point number three, I'll tell you the real issue. The real issue is it is but national that SIR will have exclusion because you have so many Indian voters, you will have voters who are dead voters, you have voters who have shipments.
36:14It is but national that the revision of voters cannot lead to inclusion, it will obviously lead to exclusion.
36:19And this is not what I am saying, this is what has happened in the past. And if you do not believe me, please present the argument.
36:24And in fact, not me. It's the booth level agent of every political party who is working there with the BLO, presenting the cases at the BLO, including the Sriramul Congress, who agrees with it.
36:33This is why these metras, whose statements and studios, including my dear friend Saurseep and me, we will present the narrative which favors the party.
36:40But the ground reality is accepted by the BLO. This is why you see, we speak about 58 laps.
36:45I want to bring in Mr. Rehman. Pradeep Andari, allow me to bring in Mr. Rehman and then I'll try to go for 10 seconds to all of you.
36:50Allow me, sir. Allow me to go. Mr. Yadu, I know you want to come in but allow me to bring in Mr. Rehman and I'll try and give all of you 10 seconds after that. Mr. Rehman, go ahead.
36:58Prithi Ji, this is the problem. It's not about narrative that the BLO Congress wants to show any narrative or throw in narrative on BTP.
37:04The AITC seeks extension of the January 15 deadline for claims and objection, postponement of final role publication and elimination of this arbitrary logical disparency category.
37:15The ECI is disparency against Bengal.
37:17What are you talking about, Pradeep?
37:21Pradeep Ji, I'll come back. Allow him to make his point. He gave you unfair term.
37:24We are asking election commission for transparency. No, sir. Allow him. I'll come back to you. Please don't interrupt.
37:29Make your point. Mr. Rehman, you have 20 seconds, sir. Make your point.
37:32We are asking election commission for the transparency. The ECI is also restraining booth-level agents from assisting voters during hearings in Bengal.
37:40Despite the Supreme Court's order to the contrary in the Bihar SIR matter.
37:43He gave it to Bihar. So you are lying daylight, boss. You are on the hood boundary of TV.
37:48All right. I'm going to come up to all of you for 10 seconds each. Mr. I think Rajat Sethi, we don't have him there.
37:54But Mr. Yadav, go ahead, sir. Make your point. You wanted to come in.
37:56I just wanted to clarify that the Supreme Court of India has not given any order whatsoever on this issue.
38:04They have not rejected any of those things unless the person here happens to have some secret order, which I have not seen.
38:11And incidentally, it's a contempt of court to attribute it orders that they have not given.
38:16Okay. All right. Pradeep Bhandari.
38:20Well, Mr. Yadav, again, here is lying. Mr. Yadav and the entire applications went for a say on the SIR.
38:26The Supreme Court denied any say on the SIR.
38:29Who was the conductor of the Bihar in action?
38:31There has not been a single observation of the Supreme Court, which is contravention to what I have been saying,
38:35that the entire exercise in Bihar has been free and fair.
38:38Mr. Torsi was lying because he knows that once the SIR exercise is completed,
38:42Okay.
38:43That voter has illegal infiltrators at the SIR.
38:45Mr. Rahman.
38:4620 seconds, sir.
38:47Actually, 15 seconds.
38:48Mr. Rahman, make your point.
38:53When you are restraining both level agents from assisting voters during hearing in Bengal,
38:56despite the Supreme Court order,
38:58the ECI engaged a private vendor with a chequered contrary.
39:03Okay, I'm going to just let it be because now it's going to come into a shouting match.
39:07I appreciate all three of you for joining us.
39:10But what we will do and endeavour to do is put the spotlight on the special intensive role revision exercise
39:16that is being conducted in the state of West Bengal
39:19and the numbers that are coming in of deletion from the state of Uttar Pradesh,
39:23which by the looks of it is very, very high.
39:26Three crores.
39:27Leave it at that.
39:28But I want to touch in on a story right now that comes in from Uttarakhand.
39:32It's protests that have been taking place now for years,
39:37where a case that shook Uttarakhand is back in the spotlight.
39:40Three years after 19-year-old Ankita Bhantari was brutally murdered,
39:44protests have once again erupted across the state with political parties and people,
39:49not just demanding answers, but a CBI probe into what really happened.
39:54In fact, accusations of a VIP connection have intensified,
39:59public outrage has intensified, putting the state government on the defensive.
40:04A political storm is brewing in Uttarakhand.
40:27Public anger rising over the Ankita Bhantari murder case.
40:44Across the state, Congress workers and civil society members have hit the streets,
40:48demanding a CBI probe in the case.
40:51Ankhita Bhantari, a 19-year-old who worked as a receptionist at a resort near Rishikesh,
41:00was found dead in September 2022.
41:04Three years later, on the 19th of May 2025,
41:07the resort owner Polkid Arya and two others were convicted of murder.
41:11The police said Ankita Bhantari was targeted after she resisted Arya's attempts to push her into prostitution.
41:17Recently, actor Urmila Sanawar, wife of former BGP MLS Suresh Rathod,
41:22released recordings of a conversation with Rathod on social media,
41:25alleging that a VIP was involved in the Ankita murder case.
41:32Since then, protests are raging.
41:34Ankita, we are all the same.
41:36We are all the same.
41:37The state is that today is the entire state.
41:42People in the past,
41:49the support of the people who have been told the V.A.P.
41:52and the first day, the police work is done.
41:57We are all the same.
41:58We are all the same.
42:00We are all the same.
42:01In the ERA-DUN, hundreds including women protestors marched towards the chief minister's residence on Monday.
42:06Chief Minister Pushkar Dhami rejected the charges of a cover-up.
42:36Ankitab's father, Virendra Bhandari, broke his silence, thanking organizations for reigniting the fight for justice.
43:02The police claim no VIP was ever involved in the case.
43:06In the social media, many stakeholders have seen some names.
43:10We have worked in those names.
43:12There was no such a rallying, so that we didn't have any benefit from the VIP name.
43:19We have worked in those who we have done.
43:21As public anger simmers and trust hangs in the balance,
43:27The Ankitab Bhandari case remains a painful reminder of a family's loss
43:41and a society's demand for the truth.
43:44It has now become a political and moral test for Uttarakhand.
43:54We're going to keep a keen eye on developments in Uttarakhand and the story there.
44:11With that, let's move on.
44:12As deposed Venezuelan President Maduro pleaded not guilty in a Manhattan court,
44:18a UN Human Rights Commission official warned that the U.S. operation breached a core principle of international law.
44:24Even as the legal battle unfolds, sources say the Trump administration is preparing talks with oil companies
44:31to explore boosting Venezuelan oil production in the aftermath of Maduro's ouster.
44:38Meanwhile, European leaders have pushed back strongly against Trump's suggestion of taking control of Greenland.
44:45Leaders were unanimous in saying the mineral-rich Arctic land belongs to its people.
44:49My colleague Geetha Mohan spoke exclusively to economist Jeffrey Sachs.
44:54Here are excerpts from that interview.
45:01Do you buy the premise that the action was carried out to take out a drug lord
45:06or does it have to do with oil, power, supremacy?
45:09Many have also said that Maduro provoked him with the televised dancing and mockery of Trump.
45:14What do you think are the primary reasons of provocations over here?
45:20And we've seen visuals over here.
45:22Did you anticipate, and I've been watching your interviews, your conversations,
45:26you must have anticipated all this, the movement, the action,
45:29but picking up a president from Venezuela and bringing him to American soil.
45:36Did you anticipate that?
45:37Well, I anticipated some kind of violent action by the United States.
45:45They do kidnap presidents.
45:49President Aristide of Haiti was kidnapped by the CIA about 20 years ago.
45:57He was marched to a plane with an unmarked tail,
46:01and he was flown 23 hours to the Central African Republic where he was dumped.
46:06In this case, they kidnapped the president of Venezuela
46:11and brought him to New York City, my home, in fact.
46:16What will happen next remains to be seen.
46:19If we still have the rule of law in the United States,
46:22a judge should not look kindly on the U.S. government
46:26kidnapping the president of another country
46:28and bringing him forcibly to the United States.
46:31So we'll see what the judiciary actually does,
46:34whether there is an independent judiciary still in the United States.
46:37This is a question.
46:40But it was clear that the United States was going to take
46:43some kind of violent regime change operation.
46:47And I just would like to share an interesting anecdote as part of this.
46:52In Trump's first term, in September 2017, in his first year of office,
46:59on the margins of the U.N. General Assembly in September of 2017,
47:05Trump had dinner with a number of Latin American presidents.
47:08And he said, even then, so we're talking basically about eight years ago,
47:14he said, why don't I just invade Venezuela?
47:17Venezuela. So my point is that this is something that has been on the minds
47:23of the U.S. security state for a long time.
47:28In that dinner eight years ago, the Latin American leaders talked him down,
47:34said, Mr. President, that's not a very good idea.
47:37It could create a lot of instability.
47:39It might not be helpful for you and for the United States.
47:43Well, this time he didn't seek advice or listen to advice.
47:49He just took his foot off of the brake on our military machine and they went after it.
47:57Jeff, what's the intent here?
47:59Drug trafficking, doing away with drug traffickers, or is it oil and supremacy?
48:05It is two things.
48:06One, any left-wing government is a target of the United States.
48:13So this is decades and decades of regime change operations in the Western Hemisphere
48:19when there is a left-wing government.
48:22So this is part of it.
48:23And this is a left-wing government.
48:26But the second target is oil, obviously.
48:30Venezuela has vast oil reserves.
48:34In fact, on the official proved reserves data of the U.S. Geologic Survey and other lists,
48:41Venezuela's approved reserves are the largest in the world, even larger than Saudi Arabia's.
48:48Of course, they're not as economical.
48:50They're heavy oil.
48:52But they're nearby the United States.
48:54We have the refineries in the southeast of the U.S.
48:57Trump, he's a maniac.
48:59He looks for oil.
49:01He says, well, that's ours.
49:02It's like a child, frankly, but it is part of a deep state which has wanted to overthrow
49:10this government for a very long time.
49:13You've already warned that Greenland could be next, but I have to ask you this.
49:17What next?
49:17Panama, Colombia, Mexico, Greenland.
49:20Katie Miller, Stephen Miller's wife, had put out a post with the American flag over the
49:24Greenland map saying soon, and Trump reiterated the same thing.
49:28So is Greenland next?
49:31My fear is that Iran is next.
49:36Keep an eye on Iran.
49:39The reason is that Israel is obsessed with Iran, wants to overthrow the Iranian government
49:48and the United States for reasons that are not 100 percent clear, I have to say, is basically
49:56beholden to Israel.
49:59The United States fights wars that Israel tells the United States to fight.
50:04It's very, very dark, actually.
50:08And so when Netanyahu came to Mar-a-Lago last week, just around New Year's, they made a joint
50:18statement basically saying, Iran, you're next, or you could be next.
50:25And Trump has said that with protests in Iran, if the government cracks down on the protests,
50:33we are basically locked and loaded.
50:35We're ready to fight.
50:36Well, this is clearly, clearly a typical deep state provocation.
50:43In other words, we're lining up the arguments, the human rights argument.
50:49We're going to go in and invade Iran to protect the people of Iran.
50:54This is a standard playbook.
50:57And so this is where I would expect the possibility of a real global explosion.
51:04And I would give a warning, that one will be hotter than Venezuela if it happens.
51:11It would be potentially disastrous because while Venezuela is in the American geographic
51:18neighborhood and China and Russia don't want to take on the United States in the Western
51:26Hemisphere, Iran is in the middle of a lot of major powers.
51:32And Iran is itself with hypersonic missiles and a capacity to do a lot of harm and a lot
51:40of damage.
51:41And Israel is a nuclear-armed country.
51:44All in all, it's a recipe for potential disaster.
51:48And sound heads should be saying to the United States right now, stop it.
51:55Monroe Doctrine now, by some, has been recristened Donro Doctrine.
52:00And we're looking at a Western Hemisphere narrative that has been put out by the Trump administration.
52:07Isn't that imperialistic and expansionist in nature at a time when maybe it's not just
52:13the international laws, but Trump has also violated some of the domestic war laws by not informing
52:19the Armed Services Committee, the Congress, not being kept in the loop, sir?
52:24Look, we don't have a constitutional order right now.
52:27All of those tariffs that were put on India, for example, were the whim of the President
52:33of the United States declaring this emergency or that emergency by executive decree.
52:38Congress has the power of war, not the President, but it doesn't matter.
52:45And when a congressman complained that this is unconstitutional, Trump mocked him.
52:50Constitution?
52:51What are you whining about, he said.
52:54So we have a political crisis in the United States.
53:01It's not called that.
53:02It's not recognized like that.
53:04Congressmen still go to their office or they go to the floor of the House or the Senate,
53:11but they don't play a role.
53:13This is an executive branch that's on its own right now.
53:17And this is also very sad and very dangerous.
53:22The Western Hemisphere argument by the United States of America,
53:26does that now give room for China to play out its plans for a takeover of Taiwan at a time
53:33when they're saying, this is our region, China can say, okay, we've done nothing there.
53:38Then you do nothing here.
53:40Well, I hope that China and India, indeed the BRICS countries, will say,
53:48this is not the way we want the world to operate.
53:51We want the world to operate according to the U.N. charter, to international law.
53:57I believe that what has happened is actually an important opportunity for the BRICS,
54:03which this year has the Indian presidency, to say, no, we represent the bulk of humanity.
54:12In fact, the emerging and developing economies are 85 percent of the world population.
54:18We don't want to go down the road of rogue states.
54:23And so I hope that the BRICS actually make a real point right now.
54:27This is not how we behave.
54:29This is not how we're going to behave.
54:31We will defend the U.N. charter.
54:35All right.
54:36What you really can do is catch the full interview with my colleague Geeta Mohan
54:40with Jeffrey Sachs at 10.30 p.m. tonight in just the next half hour.
54:48All right, that's an interview you need to stay tuned for, but I'm going to end with the image of the day.
54:54Now, it's a bizarre turn of events and it happened in Kota, Rajasthan.
54:59The thief found himself in a very tight spot, literally in a very tight spot.
55:05Attempting a break-in, the man got struck headfirst in a hole meant for an exhaust fan,
55:10dangling 10 feet above the ground.
55:13Rather than giving up, he threatened the home owners, claiming accomplices nearby.
55:18The owners immediately called the police.
55:20Dramatic visuals show cops carefully pulling the man inside, wincing in pain as he struggles to his feet.
55:28A daring escape plan gone hilariously wrong.
55:31And a thief literally caught between a hole and a very hard place.
55:36Well, that's our image of the day.
55:37And I also want to add to it, the owners of the house, the residents had actually gone to the Khartu Sham temple to pray
55:44and came back to actually see the thief hanging there in that vent.
55:53Quite amazing.
55:54A bit of divine intervention with the thief getting caught.
55:57Well, that was funny.
56:06With that, a quick break to stay with us.
56:07We're going to see you tomorrow night at 9pm.
56:09Have a good evening.

Recommended