00:00Let's bring in Claire Finkelstein, Professor of Law at the University of Pennsylvania, for more on this current situation.
00:07Professor Finkelstein, thanks for being with us here in France 24. I'm looking forward to hearing your views and your analysis.
00:13What's happened in Venezuela? Is it legal?
00:17Unfortunately, it's not legal at all. It's not legal under international law, and it's not legal under U.S. law because of the failure to consult Congress under circumstances that were not emergency.
00:29So, under international law, it's a violation of Article 24 of the U.N. Charter. It's an illegal use of force.
00:40There was not a basis for engaging in a use of force under these circumstances, given that it was not an emergency self-defense situation or an emergency defense of another country.
00:53There was no universal right of self-defense being exercised.
00:57The Trump administration has said repeatedly that it had to defend against a narco-terrorist regime that was flooding the country with drugs.
01:09But, in fact, it is cocaine, not fentanyl, and our problem has been fentanyl.
01:15And the cocaine trafficking that Venezuela is arguably at the bottom of is mostly going to other countries. It's not coming into the U.S.
01:25So, there isn't really a basis for any kind of self-defense claim, and the self-defense would have to be imminent or give rise to an immediate need for the use of force.
01:37And that just wasn't the case here.
01:41And on the American side, there is no basis for not having informed Congress in advance.
01:47And so, it's really a violation of Congress's war powers, which, under the U.S. Constitution, has the sole right to declare war under the U.S. Constitution.
01:59So, Nicolas Maduro has appeared in court. He's pleaded not guilty.
02:03Is there any possibility, given what you've just told us and clearly explained to us, that one day Donald Trump might find himself in court?
02:09Well, the whole point about international law is that it's reciprocal, and that all countries are equal under international law.
02:20So, what goes for one sovereign state goes for another sovereign state.
02:25The fact that one country is more powerful and can get away with the use of force doesn't mean that they have a right to do it under international law.
02:33So, technically, if Donald Trump is going to argue, or the Trump administration is going to argue, that it has a right to kidnap presidents from another sovereign state and haul them in for trial,
02:46then, in theory, another sovereign state would have the right to do that to the United States president.
02:53And I don't think that's a direction that the Trump administration wants to go in.
02:57But is, in a sense, Professor Finkelstein, is Donald Trump thinking of himself as being above the law?
03:02Is that where we are right now?
03:05That's where we've been with this president.
03:07And, of course, as far as U.S. courts go, the U.S. Supreme Court in Trump v. United States has declared him above U.S. law
03:16and says that he has immunity for official capacity acts.
03:22And so, he does believe himself to be above the law, and I think he's really feeling his oats with this military action,
03:29which, in the first Trump administration, he was restrained from engaging in.
03:34He had people around him who were kind of guardrails on his presidency that he doesn't have in this administration.
03:41So, Marco Rubio and Pete Hegseth are really willing to aid and abet this kind of conduct.
03:48And so, in the last few hours, he's been talking about Greenland and Colombia
03:54and putting a lot of fear into those countries and into other countries.
04:00And let's not forget, of course, that Greenland is a part of Denmark, which is a member of NATO.
04:05So, he's really courting some extremely dangerous action there.
04:11Interesting that someone who himself has been convicted, and he is the first ever U.S. president to have criminal record,
04:18thinks of himself as being above the law.
04:20But you've brilliantly pointed out exactly where the situation is and why we are here.
04:25And I'm wondering with the so-called Don Roe Doctrine, as he's christened it,
04:29the sort of modern interpretation of the Monroe Doctrine,
04:31if that, too, is illegal, what he's actually sort of contemplating there?
04:35Because back in 1823, when James Monroe came up with this concept,
04:39there were, of course, a different set of laws, a different international order in many ways.
04:44You could kind of, I suppose, hit the high seas and act as you saw fit for your country's interests.
04:50We live in a very different world now, don't we? A world of so-called democracies.
04:55Yeah, let's not forget that the Monroe Doctrine is not law.
04:59It's a political doctrine about Western hegemony.
05:05And it's clearly not an acceptable doctrine in a modern world.
05:09We don't want to give the equivalent of the Monroe Doctrine to Vladimir Putin
05:14and say that he can control all the former Soviet bloc countries,
05:20even though that's exactly what he's trying to do.
05:23So we don't accept the equivalent of the Monroe Doctrine for any other part of the world.
05:29And there's no basis for us to accept it here.
05:34And when Hitler marched into the Sudetenland and took over part of Czechoslovakia,
05:42it was a similar kind of thinking.
05:45It's aggressive war.
05:46It's takeover of another sovereign nation.
05:50And you can put whatever sort of face you want on that kind of takeover.
05:58But it's a violation of international sovereignty.
06:02And the whole idea of Westphalian states and the modern era
06:06is that you can't violate another state's sovereignty
06:11without having a legal justification based in self-defense.
06:15Professor Finkelstein, I've got so many questions.
06:19I'm going to go with this one.
06:20The message clearly that has been given to the likes of Xi Jinping,
06:24the likes of Vladimir Putin,
06:26is that if Donald Trump can do exactly what he wants to do
06:30in what he sees as his own backyard,
06:32then they can do the same in theirs.
06:36Well, and that's the grave concern.
06:37That's the concern about Ukraine,
06:40which is that Donald Trump and Putin, who have been talking,
06:45may have made some sort of implicit deal.
06:48That's something, by the way, that Fiona Hill testified to
06:52in Donald Trump's first impeachment trial,
06:55that there may have been an implicit back and forth.
07:01And she even testified on that with regard to Venezuela.
07:04Don't tread on my backyard, and I won't tread on yours.
07:08So is Donald Trump pulling back on Ukraine
07:12because he's trying to make sure that Russia doesn't interfere
07:17with our takeover of Venezuela
07:19and possibly other Latin or South American countries?
07:22That's the concern, and that's really not international law.
07:26It's an anti-law doctrine.
07:29And as you pointed out, it's very antiquated.
07:32It's from a different era in our past,
07:35and it has no place in the modern world.
07:38So in terms of what happens next,
07:40Donald Trump, as you were alluding to earlier,
07:42Professor Finkelstein,
07:43talking about the possibility of taking Greenland,
07:46talking about the possibility of doing the same thing to Colombia
07:49as he's done to Venezuela, and also talking about Cuba.
07:53If that happens, what does the world do
07:56apart from hold its breath?
07:57Right, and it will be much more difficult for him to do that.
08:03So first of all, let's start with non-NATO countries.
08:06I mean, Colombia's president is not in the same position as Maduro.
08:11So he is talking about a man who has been a dictator,
08:16who has engaged in heinous acts, criminal acts,
08:20and that's where he gets a little bit of support
08:23and a little bit of color to this action.
08:25The problem will be in the way that he got into court.
08:29So the indictment that he was charged with defines real crimes.
08:37But the way that you go about that,
08:39and his administration keeps stressing that this is not a war,
08:42this is a law enforcement action,
08:44would be to demand extradition.
08:48And there is an extradition treaty with Venezuela,
08:51though Venezuela doesn't always pay attention to that
08:55and doesn't always abide by it.
08:57But normally, when you have a law enforcement matter,
09:01you should proceed by extradition, not by invasion.
09:05Once you're starting to talk about military action
09:08and kidnapping heads of states,
09:10and you're talking about people who may not have engaged in criminal action,
09:17certainly where Greenland is concerned,
09:19we're not going to have the same kind of profile by any means.
09:23He's going to have a lot more difficulty.
09:25And where it's a NATO country,
09:28the NATO countries are going to be obligated under the NATO treaty
09:33to defend Greenland.
09:36And so we're really courting World War III there.
09:39They have a solemn obligation under international law,
09:42and they can't let him ride roughshod over that agreement
09:47and over the NATO compact.
09:49So it's an extremely dangerous game that he's playing
09:52and waiting to see if anyone is going to stop him.
09:55Professor Claire Finkelstein of the University of Pennsylvania,
09:58Professor of Law,
09:59thank you very much for your very clear explanations
10:02of where we are right now
10:04regarding the situation with Venezuela and beyond
10:06and Donald Trump's ambitions.
10:08Dr. Claire Finkelstein of the University of Pennsylvania,
10:11thanks again.
10:13Thanks for having me.