• 11 months ago
A massive power outage affecting 130,000 San Francisco homes didn't just leave residents in the dark—it completely disabled Google's Waymo robo-taxi fleet, causing vehicles to freeze mid-intersection and creating dangerous traffic conditions. Automotive expert Lauren Fix breaks down what went wrong and why this is "far from prime time."

Waymo Robo-Taxis FROZEN in SF Blackout — What Went Wrong?
-
SUBSCRIBE HERE:
http://www.youtube.com/subscription_center?add_user=THERUNLISTCHANNEL

--
👉 Original Documentary Library:
https://vimeo.com/user109504031/vod_pages
-
🍀 Support NTD: https://donorbox.org/ntd

--
© All Rights Reserved.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00And as we just saw, that storm caused San Francisco to totally lose power, affecting 130,000 homes.
00:08And we also saw that the Google robo-taxi service called Waymo, as a result, went down.
00:14Those vehicles stalled out right in the middle of the city, forcing drivers to have to weave around those stalled vehicles at traffic intersections,
00:23which caused dangerous road conditions as well as a traffic buildup.
00:27Joining us to discuss what happened is Lauren Fick. She's an automotive expert with Car Coach Reports.
00:32Always great to see you, Lauren. What happened to the Waymos?
00:35Well, they work off of the grid. So the grid means they need power, which is traffic lights and all the lights that you need to get places.
00:43So if they can't see and they can't connect to the system, and the system, of course, is completely dark, they just stop.
00:51So it would be like if the lights went out in your house, instead of you going, OK, let's get some candles and flashlights or whatever it might be, you just stop and freeze.
00:59And that's exactly what they do because they're computers. So when there's no power, your computer doesn't work.
01:05And there's no cell phone backup and there's no satellite backup because they didn't set it up that way.
01:10And that's also true with the power grid in San Francisco and across California.
01:13There's no backup. And that doesn't make sense. You're talking about a major city like San Francisco, you know, the number two state in the country.
01:21Well, the number one, if you're talking about total income and they don't have a backup power supply, partly because they told those that do natural gas and coal to get out of their state.
01:29And so now if you want to rely 100 percent on electricity, that means if you don't own a car, because it is very expensive on a car in California and in San Francisco, and you rely on Waymo, you're not going anywhere unless you want to walk.
01:41Yeah, I mean, it exposes, as you say, a couple of dimensions here because the cars run on electric, so they would have eventually lost all power.
01:51But their ability to know what to do went down from their programming because the traffic lights went down.
01:57So what further does this expose about sort of these automated systems that rely on sort of remote controls and computer programming?
02:07Well, many of the comments, if you look on social media, pretty much say it all.
02:12Have your own vehicle. Have your own escape route.
02:15I mean, what if there were fires?
02:17And they've had plenty of those in San Francisco and across California.
02:20How do you escape?
02:21You're not going to call a Waymo because it's not coming.
02:23You're not going to be able to call an Uber.
02:24Again, all of this stuff works not just on cell service, but they also work on electricity.
02:29And that means the computers that control those Waymo's or any other robo-taxi puts you in a tough position, which means you need a way to escape.
02:37You need to have your own protections.
02:39And when you listen to the mayor get on social media to say, hey, we don't know what's going to happen on Tuesday.
02:45You might lose power again.
02:46We're coming up on the holidays.
02:48You would think that the mayor of the town would have said, listen, we need to invest in the infrastructure.
02:54That would make sense because many of those substations haven't been updated since the 40s.
02:59And if they do go down, they're going to replace them with the same old components, not the same, but new version of the old components in those substations.
03:07And they're going to be right back in the same situation.
03:09Did they overheat because of the draw from electric cars?
03:12Did they just overheat because of age?
03:14You don't know that until someone does the investigation.
03:16By that time, you should have had a backup plan in place a long time ago, much like that of the fires where they didn't have any water in any of the reservoirs that they needed.
03:24This sounds like a Gavin Newsom problem and certainly something that the country doesn't want to deal with because you have to remember, if Gavin Newsom wants to run for president, this is what he plans to do to the entire country.
03:35Now, in terms of the dangers that these stalled out vehicles caused, you know, vehicles had to weave around them.
03:42Sometimes they were right near an intersection and then the traffic built up as a result during an emergency, no less.
03:49And so this is kind of the worst case scenario, an extreme example, a corner case.
03:56But most of the feedback on these robo taxis for the function that they perform is that people actually like them.
04:04So, you know, what does this say about the potential in the future for these programs to scale to other cities?
04:11Is it just about creating better, you know, backup plans, as you're talking about, or do you think there are flaws in the program itself?
04:18There's a lot of flaws, actually, and I've been in robo taxis myself, but I think one of the things that people like is you don't have a driver that you're forced to talk to, you don't have to communicate with a stranger, you're not getting in a car with someone you don't know.
04:31But then comes the backside of that, when you're in the middle of a ride and the vehicle stops suddenly because of a power outage or whatever it might be, a computer glitch.
04:41Can you get out of the car?
04:42There's a panic involved.
04:44You're in a vehicle in the middle of an intersection and then you start thinking, oh, boy, this is not good.
04:49And so having a manned driver is the best choice.
04:52But then again, you do have other ramifications.
04:55Obviously, driving yourself is good, but there is a parking problem in San Francisco.
04:59Not everyone has a garage, most people don't, and parking on the street is always a challenge.
05:03And so people are thinking robo taxis are an answer versus owning your own vehicle and paying for insurance.
05:08But I think the bigger picture is relying 100% on autonomous vehicles is not going to work.
05:14We've been riding in them, believe it or not, since 2007.
05:17It was the first time I was in a robo car.
05:19It wasn't that brand.
05:20It was actually an Audi.
05:21We went from Palo Alto to the Consumer Electronics Show, and they proved to us that it works.
05:25And I've also been in Volvo's and Georgetown.
05:27The problem is other drivers on the road, and the problem is there's still hacking involved.
05:33And now we have another problem to add, power outages, which means they can't communicate, so they stop.
05:39And that puts a danger for everybody else on the road or any other system that may have a backup, but Waymo doesn't.
05:46I'm sure that they're working on that.
05:47But the fact is, at this point, we are far from prime time, and that's why only certain cities see it.
05:52I mean, Tesla's working with robo taxis in Austin, Texas.
05:55I think they're starting to expand that into bigger areas.
05:59But we really have to realize that there's no backup plan, whether it be cell service, any type of backup plan.
06:06If they can't communicate, you put yourself in danger.
06:09The car can be replaced.
06:10You can't be.
06:12Well, as Mike Tyson famously says, everybody's got a plan until they get punched in the face.
06:16Lauren Fix, automotive expert, great to talk to you.
06:18Appreciate it.

Recommended