- há 1 ano
Eurodeputados entram em disputa sobre alargamento da UE na estreia no programa “The Ring”
No primeiro episódio de “The Ring”, debatemos o tema altamente político do alargamento da União Europeia, que se tornou um objetivo geopolítico da Comissão Europeia sob a liderança de Ursula von der Leyen.
LEIA MAIS : http://pt.euronews.com/2025/11/07/eurodeputados-entram-em-confronto-sobre-alargamento-da-ue-na-estreia-de-the-ring
Subscreva, euronews está disponível em 12 línguas.
No primeiro episódio de “The Ring”, debatemos o tema altamente político do alargamento da União Europeia, que se tornou um objetivo geopolítico da Comissão Europeia sob a liderança de Ursula von der Leyen.
LEIA MAIS : http://pt.euronews.com/2025/11/07/eurodeputados-entram-em-confronto-sobre-alargamento-da-ue-na-estreia-de-the-ring
Subscreva, euronews está disponível em 12 línguas.
Categoria
🗞
NotíciasTranscrição
00:00Transcrição e Legendas Pedro Negri
00:30Transcrição e Legendas Pedro Negri
01:00Transcrição e Legendas Pedro Negri
01:02Transcrição e Legendas Pedro Negri
01:04Europe was built on a promise
01:06that unity can transform
01:08a history of conflict into a
01:10future of peace.
01:13Now
01:14the drums of war sound again,
01:16countries from Ukraine to Montenegro
01:18and northern Macedonia are
01:19reaching for that promise, not
01:21just for prosperity, but also
01:24for security.
01:25Supporters argue
01:30enlargement of the Union will
01:32amplify Europe's global voice,
01:34reinforce its defenses and
01:36uphold its values.
01:38Critics warn it could stretch institutions
01:40and deepen all its divides.
01:43So the real question
01:44is, will Europe rise to
01:46the challenge and open its doors
01:47or close them at a defining
01:49moment in its history?
01:51And we're thrilled
01:54to be joined by two
01:55members of the European Parliament,
01:58David McAllister
01:58and Mark Bottenga.
02:00Let's get to know them more
02:01in this clip.
02:06David McAllister,
02:08veteran member of the European Parliament,
02:11chair of foreign affairs,
02:13vice president of the
02:14centre-right EPP group,
02:16a leading voice in European
02:18and transatlantic affairs.
02:20And when enlargement talks
02:21with Albania and
02:22North Macedonia were delayed,
02:24he didn't hold back.
02:26The EU
02:27failed to show leadership,
02:29courage
02:29and strategic vision,
02:31he said.
02:35Mark Bottenga,
02:36Belgian MEP.
02:38A fierce defender
02:39of workers' rights
02:40and public services,
02:42he's one of the European Parliament's
02:44strongest critics of austerity
02:46and corporate power.
02:48He voted against
02:49the EU's economic aid package
02:51for the Western Balkans,
02:52warning it comes loaded
02:54with neoliberal conditions
02:55that, in his words,
02:58would deepen the crisis
02:59instead of solving it.
03:04We have, of course,
03:05a lot to discuss,
03:06so let's kick off
03:06with yourself,
03:07David McAllister.
03:09Croatia was the last country
03:10to join back in 2013.
03:12Who will be the next
03:13to join and by when?
03:14Well, there are
03:1610 candidate countries
03:18and I'm very sure
03:19one of the 10 will be
03:20in the moment.
03:21Montenegro is the frontrunner,
03:23then comes Albania.
03:24But, apart from these 10,
03:26there are also some developments
03:27in the High North,
03:28there are new debates
03:29in Iceland,
03:30in Norway
03:30and even in Greenland
03:31who perhaps might also
03:33want to join the European Union.
03:34Indeed, as we're hearing
03:35EU enlargement,
03:36the momentum is indeed there.
03:37Is it for you?
03:38Are you in favour
03:39of EU enlargement,
03:40Mark Bottenga?
03:40Well, we don't,
03:41I mean,
03:41I'm not against
03:42or in favour
03:43of EU enlargement.
03:44I think we need to see
03:45why we do it
03:46and what we want to obtain,
03:47what's going to be
03:47the consequences
03:48because there have been
03:49consequences
03:49for working class people
03:51of previous enlargements
03:53and we've seen that
03:54today as well.
03:54You know,
03:55there have been protests
03:55of farmers
03:56against liberalisation
03:57of trade,
03:58for example,
03:58with Ukraine.
03:59There have been victims.
04:00We've seen social dumping
04:01practices that have made
04:02people very sceptical
04:03of these enlargements.
04:05So what I would say
04:06is we need to get
04:07our house in order
04:08socially
04:09before we risk
04:10having the same effects again.
04:12Can we afford
04:12EU enlargement?
04:14The history
04:15of the European integration
04:16has always been
04:16the history of enlargement.
04:17We started with six,
04:18we became nine,
04:1912, 15, 25, 27,
04:22even 28 members.
04:23There are 48,
04:2449 countries in Europe
04:25and 10 out of these
04:26want to become members
04:27of the European Union
04:28and we should support
04:30these countries
04:30in their aspirations.
04:32But of course,
04:32in the end,
04:33all the necessary criteria
04:35need to be met
04:36politically,
04:36financially,
04:37economically,
04:38that's clear.
04:39but I am happy
04:40to see that
04:41further countries
04:42want to join
04:43our family of nations
04:44because they share
04:45our values
04:46and they believe
04:47that they are stronger
04:48and better off
04:48together with us.
04:50And we saw the
04:50so-called report cards
04:51or progress reports
04:52coming out today
04:53from the European Commission
04:54this week in Brussels.
04:55What are your views
04:57on them?
04:58Well, obviously,
04:59we've received
05:00these hundreds of pages
05:01just recently
05:02so we're not going
05:02to pretend
05:03any one of us,
05:04I think,
05:04to have read
05:04or studied them in depth.
05:06However,
05:06one thing I looked at
05:07and which I'm disappointed by
05:09is that,
05:11of course,
05:11we know this is no longer
05:12just a merit-based process.
05:14I mean,
05:14there's a geopolitical
05:15dimension to it now.
05:17No one's going to deny that.
05:18But what I have seen
05:19is that over the last years,
05:21I've seen a lot of protests
05:23from trade unions,
05:25international trade unions,
05:25confederation,
05:26European trade union confederation,
05:28saying there's a clear
05:29backsliding
05:30on working-class democracy
05:32in Ukraine.
05:33There have been new laws.
05:35There's been even
05:35the secretary general
05:36of the federation
05:38of trade unions of Ukraine
05:39that's been put
05:40under house arrest, right?
05:41And the commission
05:42doesn't seem to take
05:43that seriously.
05:44And I think, you know,
05:45you already have a martial law
05:47and you're attacking
05:48civil society in this way.
05:50That needs to be on the agenda.
05:51And what I'm seeing
05:52is that we're abandoning
05:53basically the criteria
05:54just because of
05:55geopolitics.
05:56Is that a point
05:57that you could address,
05:58David McAllister?
05:58Many feel that the EU
05:59is not working for them,
06:00those that are in the club already.
06:03There are 10 candidate
06:04countries in the moment,
06:06but the big difference
06:07between Ukraine
06:07and the other nine
06:08is Ukraine
06:09is going through
06:10a fully-fledged war,
06:12a Russian war of aggression.
06:13And of course,
06:14you need to always consider
06:16under which enormous pressure
06:18and challenges
06:18Ukraine lies.
06:20Yes, Ukraine is far,
06:22is still far away
06:23from meeting
06:24all the necessary EU criteria.
06:26Ukraine is on the way,
06:28it's a marathon.
06:29And of course,
06:30also the commission
06:30has been very outspoken
06:32in also criticizing
06:33what is not going well
06:35in Ukraine.
06:35But my impression
06:36is that the Ukraine government
06:38usually responds
06:39in a positive way
06:40to the criticism
06:41coming from the commission
06:42and the European Parliament.
06:44That's why we need
06:45to also work
06:46on social standards
06:46and workers' rights
06:47in Ukraine,
06:48just like in any other
06:49candidate country.
06:50But please,
06:51we need to bear in mind
06:52this country is under attack
06:54by a vicious regime
06:56in the Russian Federation.
06:57If you are under attack,
06:58is your priority
06:59to crack down
07:00on trade unionists?
07:01Is your priority then
07:02to say we need
07:03to liberalize
07:04the energy sector,
07:05the banking sector?
07:06No, I mean,
07:06your priority should be
07:08to bring back peace,
07:09to get back your sovereignty
07:10and so on.
07:11So this argument
07:12of war
07:14in order to justify
07:15social repression
07:16I think is just
07:17out of scope.
07:18Mark, I'm very sorry.
07:19I didn't say that.
07:20I said that,
07:21of course,
07:21Ukraine has to also
07:23meet all the necessary
07:24criteria.
07:25And there are a lot
07:25of things where Ukraine
07:26still has to do
07:27a lot of homework.
07:28But in general,
07:29we need to just consider
07:30under which enormous
07:31challenge they are
07:32fighting a war
07:33against Russia
07:34on the one hand
07:34and on the other hand
07:36preparing to join
07:38the European Union.
07:39that is very impressive
07:40and that deserves
07:41respect.
07:41But once again,
07:42I am not arguing,
07:44I'm not defending this.
07:45In the end,
07:45they will have to need
07:46all the criteria,
07:47including the social
07:48criteria you have
07:49mentioned.
07:49So we agree being
07:50disappointed for the
07:51Commission.
07:52What about internal
07:52reforms, David McAllister?
07:54What kind of internal
07:55reforms does the EU
07:56need to do?
07:57Its own homework,
07:58perhaps?
07:59Well, the one thing
08:00is that further
08:01countries will at one
08:02day probably join
08:03our European Union.
08:05It depends,
08:05of course,
08:06when.
08:06On the other hand,
08:07we need to prepare
08:08in the meantime.
08:09We are operating
08:10with a set of rules
08:11and institutions
08:12which stem from a time
08:13where we are 9,
08:1412,
08:1415 members.
08:15We have to reform.
08:17We have to get ready
08:18for enlargement
08:18ourselves.
08:19That means we need
08:21to strengthen the
08:22European Parliament.
08:23We have to,
08:24in the Council,
08:25introduce further
08:26qualified majority
08:27voting.
08:28Unanimity is
08:29something which
08:30comes from the time
08:31where we were 6 or 9
08:32or 12 member states.
08:33It doesn't work
08:34with 27.
08:35It will not work
08:35with 28,
08:3629 or 30.
08:37And also,
08:38we need to discuss
08:39can this system
08:41continue that every
08:42single member state
08:43has a known commissioner.
08:44Already,
08:45the commission in the
08:46moment is rather large.
08:47I'm sure that's
08:48something you'd agree
08:48with too,
08:49Mark Butenga.
08:50Well,
08:50the commission is
08:50rather large.
08:51This is one thing.
08:52But what I would be
08:53saying is if we want,
08:54first of all,
08:55to avoid a social,
08:57you know,
08:57massive negative
08:58social impact
08:59on our societies,
09:00there's a number
09:01of rules,
09:02European rules
09:02that we need
09:03to revise
09:04in a very ambitious
09:05way.
09:06And I'm thinking
09:06about subcontracting.
09:08I'm thinking
09:08about posted workers.
09:10I'm thinking
09:10about pluriactivity.
09:12And I'm thinking
09:12about leatherbox
09:13companies.
09:14Because if we do
09:14not tackle this
09:15socially,
09:16you know,
09:16we're going to
09:17have a massive
09:18backlash.
09:18And we've seen
09:19these protests.
09:20We've seen protests
09:20of farmers in
09:21Poland and Italy.
09:22We've seen protests
09:23of truckers from
09:24Poland and the
09:24Slovak Republic.
09:25What about the
09:26backlash from
09:26countries in the
09:27Western Balkans
09:27who've been waiting
09:28for so long
09:29to enter the...
09:29Absolutely.
09:30And I really
09:31understand the
09:31frustration of the
09:32Western Balkans
09:33and of these
09:33countries.
09:34Because indeed,
09:35they've been waiting
09:35for a long time,
09:36other countries
09:36perhaps even longer.
09:38And they feel
09:40disrespected.
09:41They feel disrespected
09:42when they see,
09:44you know,
09:44that certain other
09:44countries get a pass.
09:46And now they're
09:47hearing about this
09:48potential probation
09:49period.
09:49What are your
09:50thoughts on this?
09:50Well, until now we
09:52have argued you are
09:53either in or out.
09:55You're a fully
09:55fledged member of
09:56the European Union
09:57or not.
09:57I think that we
09:58have to get away
09:59from this black
10:00and white debate.
10:01And that means
10:01that the solution
10:02is the gradual
10:04integration of
10:05candidate countries
10:06into the European
10:07Union.
10:07So we begin with
10:08the gradual
10:09integration in the
10:10single market and
10:11in other important
10:12policy fields.
10:13And then the next
10:13step is the EU
10:14membership.
10:15And after EU
10:16membership, the
10:16next step is then
10:17to join the core
10:18zone of the
10:19European Union.
10:19That means the
10:20Euro and the
10:21Schengen
10:21cooperation area.
10:22I think that is
10:23the way.
10:24And also we need
10:25to perhaps think
10:25out of the box
10:26how can we
10:27address the
10:28concerns of some
10:29of our member
10:30states that
10:30additional members
10:31might at the
10:32beginning be
10:33hampering the
10:34further integration
10:36process.
10:37But I mean we've
10:37managed that until
10:38now and I'm very
10:39sure with candidate
10:40countries 28, 29
10:42and 30 joining
10:43we will be able
10:44to do so.
10:45Do you agree with
10:45that or do you
10:46think it could be
10:46completely
10:47dysfunctional?
10:48Well it could
10:49obviously be
10:49completely
10:49dysfunctional.
10:50That's why I'm
10:51saying we need
10:51the social
10:52guarantees very
10:53clearly.
10:53We need upwards
10:54convergence not a
10:55downward spiral of
10:56dumping on the
10:57one hand.
10:58And secondly if we
10:59do not involve the
11:01people if we think
11:02this is all going to
11:03be decided in
11:03Brussels in
11:04Strasbourg there
11:05will be a backlash
11:06democratically as
11:07well because people
11:08will not take it.
11:08People will be like
11:09hey my working life
11:10my salary is being
11:11affected.
11:12And so that is
11:13something we need
11:13to deal with.
11:14I don't always
11:14necessarily agree with
11:15Mark but on this
11:16point he's right.
11:17yes indeed we have
11:18to convince our
11:19citizens we have to
11:20convince the people
11:21but the social
11:22standards which are so
11:23important to you and
11:24they're just as
11:24important to me.
11:25I think one way to
11:27guarantee these social
11:28standards in the
11:29candidate countries is
11:30that we go through a
11:31thorough enlargement
11:32process because in the
11:33end all the criteria
11:34needs to need to be
11:35met and that's why
11:36enlargement is a huge
11:38opportunity not only for
11:39the people but also for
11:41the businesses and the
11:42employers and the
11:44employees in these
11:45countries.
11:45focusing on this very
11:46first edition of the
11:47ring you're starting to
11:47agree with each other
11:48because politicians it's
11:49all about building
11:50compromises of course.
11:51A German Christian
11:52Democrat and a
11:53Belgian Socialist.
11:54I mean we're
11:54wide apart usually.
11:56And now it is time in
11:57fact to show our
11:58viewers a little taste of
11:59what it's like inside the
12:00hemicycle.
12:02As some of you may have
12:03seen MEPs get the
12:04chance to pose questions
12:05to each other sometimes
12:07very provocative.
12:09David McAllister
12:10please start with your
12:11question for Mark
12:11Patanga.
12:12Mark if I understood
12:14you correctly you're
12:14rather enlargement
12:15sceptical and you want
12:17to not accelerate the
12:18process.
12:19You believe that we need
12:19to take our time.
12:21On the other hand grey
12:22zones will exist.
12:24Grey zones will be
12:25created and China and
12:27the Russian federations
12:28are just there to fill
12:29these grey zones.
12:30Why do you do that?
12:32Well it's an interesting
12:34question.
12:34I would send you back
12:36the question.
12:36You know Russia and
12:38European Parliament we've
12:39criticized that very long
12:40that Russia thinks in terms
12:41of spheres of influence.
12:43You know and they try to
12:44influence other countries
12:45to do what they want to
12:46copy their model or impose
12:48their model.
12:49The way I hear you speak
12:51sometimes about enlargement
12:52is very similar.
12:54When I'm saying should the
12:56European Union then enter
12:57in this logic of spheres of
12:58influence.
12:59I don't think we should.
13:00You know and I don't think
13:01we should be interfering in
13:02other countries.
13:03They have their democratic
13:03processes their local
13:05evolutions and we should
13:06respect this.
13:07And this might indeed end up
13:09in enlargement.
13:10You know I'm not principally
13:11against but what we should not
13:12be doing is copying a model
13:14of countries that we
13:15criticize.
13:17Mark Buttenga you now have
13:18the opportunity to pose a
13:19question to David McAllister.
13:20Well let me let me come back
13:21to what we were discussing
13:22before.
13:23I mean you said that indeed
13:24social convergence upward is
13:27important.
13:28Then I'm going to ask you
13:29why is EPP systematically
13:31opposing you know ambitious
13:33social proposals that could
13:36basically end or limit
13:37social dumping.
13:39I'm thinking for example of
13:41banning subcontracting below
13:43one or two levels.
13:44I'm thinking of for example
13:46forcing letterbox companies to
13:47have real activity in the
13:49country they're officially
13:50based.
13:51Think of Slovenia.
13:52Think of a number of other
13:52countries.
13:53Why doesn't EPP take that
13:55social agenda seriously aside
13:57when we're discussing very
13:58abstractly about enlargement?
13:59Okay thank you for your
14:01question not directly related
14:02to the enlargement countries I
14:03understand.
14:04But it's always close to your
14:05heart of course.
14:06Well look first of all the EPP
14:08has always been the leading
14:09party when it comes to further
14:11developing the social market
14:12economy.
14:13We are not supporters of free
14:16capitalism.
14:17We support the social market
14:19economy which Ludwig Erhard for
14:21instance in Germany created and
14:23this is our model for Europe and
14:25this includes of course social
14:28standards, workers rights, labor
14:29rights.
14:30We have always been at the
14:31forefront of this and I strongly
14:32believe by the way we also need
14:34a strong social pillar within the
14:36European Union because we need
14:37the citizens on board and the
14:39European integration project
14:40should not be an elitist project
14:42of the well-off but of all and
14:44this of course includes the
14:46hard-working people we have in
14:47Europe.
14:48That's why we can have a more
14:49detailed discussion on these
14:51matters but I have to add but I
14:53have to add one point Mark I do
14:55not agree what you said that EU
14:57enlargement is interfering in third
14:59countries.
15:00These countries have voluntarily
15:02taken the decision to join our
15:05family because they believe in
15:06democracy, the rule of law and
15:08human rights and I will always
15:10support countries and governments
15:11and parliaments who want to go
15:12exactly this way.
15:14Answer that one.
15:14Let me just reply to that.
15:16That is a very naive vision and you
15:18know you don't share that of how
15:19these processes go.
15:21You know the European Union has been
15:22very active in sponsoring NGOs and
15:25media to influence public debate
15:27you know in these countries.
15:28We've done this in Ukraine, we've
15:29done it in Georgia, we've done it in
15:31many countries and you can say this
15:32is legitimate and we could argue
15:33about this saying it is legitimate,
15:35it's not legitimate but the other
15:36side you know the Russians that want
15:38their sphere of influence are doing
15:39very similar things.
15:40What I'm saying is that we need to
15:42listen to social movements over there
15:44and not prioritize our own corporate
15:47interests because what we're seeing
15:48today honestly if you see the what is
15:50the Finnish minister going to Georgia
15:52to protest with the protesters you
15:55can say you know if a Russian would
15:56do that we would consider it
15:58unacceptable interference and
15:59rightly so.
16:00If we're doing it we're saying well
16:02you know it's a support for
16:03democracy so this thin line and there
16:06we need to be very clear that there
16:07might be double standards in the way
16:09we look at things.
16:10Well Mark I think here we have some
16:11clear differences between the two of
16:13us.
16:14When it comes to interfering in
16:16candidate countries I wouldn't at first
16:19think of EU member states these countries
16:22are being flooded by malign Russian
16:25influence.
16:26Fake news, propaganda, they are trying to
16:29destabilize democracy Mark I think the
16:31socialists, your party, you should deal
16:33more with this horrific Russian foreign
16:36malign influence we have in Europe.
16:38Just to make clear because otherwise
16:39we're going to get some problems with
16:40colleagues I'm not from the socialist
16:42group.
16:43Well how do I call you then?
16:44It's the SND, it's the way the left
16:45group but okay I mean just to in order for
16:47our socialist colleagues not to get a
16:48harder time.
16:48Okay well what are you then?
16:50We're the left group.
16:51We're just the lefty okay well when
16:53it's like Mark the leftist okay.
16:55I'm glad you're getting to know each
16:56other here on the ring and let's
16:58perhaps bring in another voice on this
17:00very important discussion of EU
17:02enlargement that has made a political
17:04comeback.
17:06That is the voice of the Ukrainian
17:08president Volodymyr Zelensky who spoke
17:10at the Euronews enlargement summit here in
17:12Brussels and he said that Donald Trump
17:15is supporting Ukraine in becoming a
17:18member of the European Union.
17:19That Trump understands that this is the
17:21will of the Ukrainian people.
17:23But my question is what do you think of
17:24this statement and do we really need the
17:26approval of the White House for this
17:28kind of thing?
17:29The brave women and men in Ukraine are
17:31not only defending their territorial
17:32sovereignty and integrity every day.
17:35They are also defending our European
17:38values.
17:38They are defending the European peace and
17:40security architecture.
17:41And if there's one people in Europe who
17:44has shown how they committed they are to
17:47the European integration progress, then
17:49it's the brave women and men from
17:51Ukraine.
17:52They deserve all our support.
17:54Mark Buttenger.
17:55Well, I think Donald Trump has launched
17:56one of the most aggressive attacks on
17:59Ukraine's sovereignty we have seen over
18:01the last years.
18:02I mean, you've seen obviously the horrible
18:04war of Russia, you know, occupying, what is
18:08it one, one, one fifth of the of the country.
18:10But what has Donald Trump done?
18:13He's come saying, you know, you want
18:14peace.
18:15I can guarantee that.
18:16But in exchange, I want your natural
18:17resources.
18:18Now, that is a direct attack on the
18:20economic sovereignty of the Ukrainian
18:22people.
18:22So I don't think he should be giving
18:24lessons on what sovereignty means.
18:26And what about Moldova?
18:27We also heard from Maya Sandu, the
18:29president of Moldova, saying that she also
18:30one day wants to be a member of the
18:32European Union.
18:33Can the EU afford a poor country like
18:35Moldova?
18:35David McAllister.
18:36Moldova, who's ever been there knows
18:38great people, great country, and they
18:41are on their way.
18:42I urge the council to open the accession
18:45negotiations with Moldova now in autumn.
18:48They are they are waiting for this
18:50just desperately.
18:52And the Moldovans have shown their
18:54European commitment, despite all the
18:57aggressive malign Russian influence.
18:59The people in Moldova stood strong and
19:02voted three times in favor of the pro
19:05European orientation at the referendum, at
19:07the presidential elections, and just
19:09most recently at the parliamentary
19:10elections.
19:11Mark Patenga?
19:12Why not?
19:12Let's talk.
19:13I mean, I'm in favor of talks.
19:14Moldova, as you know, is not an easy
19:16situation with the Transnistrian
19:17situation.
19:18So that will need to be solved.
19:20Let's not pretend that doesn't exist.
19:22But we always need to keep talking.
19:23What I'm saying is let's keep talking
19:25with respect of local democracy.
19:27You know, let's keep talking and let's not
19:29accelerate things beyond that in the hope
19:31to, you know, eat them up quicker than the
19:34others, because that's not what Europe
19:35should be.
19:36Well, now we've heard the view of the MEPs.
19:38I'm curious also to get the view of the
19:40European public to hear how they feel
19:42about EU enlargement.
19:43We've been digging into the latest Euro
19:51barometer, and according to the latest
19:53data, 56% of Europeans are in favor of
19:57EU enlargement.
19:5839% show mistrust.
20:01The pros of those polled were that the
20:03EU could benefit from larger markets.
20:06There'd be more work and more skilled
20:07labor, and the cons, many said, the cost
20:10for the taxpayers, the risk of corruption,
20:12organized crime and terrorism, and also
20:15uncontrolled migration.
20:17One of the very interesting points is
20:21as well that most people don't believe
20:23they will benefit themselves from
20:25enlargement.
20:26The idea is nice, and the idea, this is
20:28also why in the EU bubble, it's so you
20:29speak about enlargement, because it's nice
20:31like Europe expanding.
20:32But many people are afraid and know they
20:33will not benefit if we do not have the
20:36strong internal social measures.
20:39And apparently EPP would be open to
20:40that, so that's the news of the day.
20:41then we cannot do this enlargement.
20:44I take very seriously that 39% are
20:47against, and we have to work on this.
20:49We have to improve our communication.
20:51We have to explain to our citizens that
20:54further enlargement, if we do it properly,
20:56I am not advocating enlargement for
20:58enlargement.
20:59I am advocating an enlargement process which
21:03is merit-based, where each country is
21:06individually judged, and that in the end
21:09all the necessary criteria are met.
21:11And by the way, enlargement is a regatta, not a convoy.
21:16But in the end, if these countries, where their economies join, it is beneficial for both sides,
21:22because it means new markets, new business opportunities, and the enlargement until now has shown,
21:28especially the big enlargement in 2004, but it was beneficial for everyone in Europe.
21:34Is the big bank enlargement successful in your view, Mark Potenga?
21:37Many people in, you know, older member states, France, Germany as well, Belgium,
21:42saw this as an opening for social dumping, which was reality for many people.
21:46And many people in the more eastern, the more newer member states left their countries.
21:50But it did create structural, you know, aggravate perhaps structural problems
21:55within the European, let's say, the subcontinent of Europe.
21:58And if we're going to do that again, with now one, at least, very big member states,
22:02you know, demographically, economically, as Ukraine,
22:05we might have that in a much, much stronger version.
22:09I think the solution to the problem of social dumping is what we have seen in other cases,
22:13transitional periods, that we go and go from one extreme immediately to the other,
22:18but we have these transitional agreements, these transitional periods,
22:22is for the free movement of labor, as we had with some eastern European countries after 2004.
22:27What about some of the cons there that we listed?
22:29We need to better communicate.
22:31It is our duty, not only in the candidate countries, but also in the 27 member states,
22:36to convince our citizens that this is beneficial.
22:41And I would see there are 48, 49 countries in Europe.
22:4627 are in the European Union.
22:48But the European project has always been open to all countries who lie geographically in Europe,
22:55who share our values and are ready to go through a very challenging negotiation process.
23:01That's where we are.
23:02And the EU does need a success story.
23:04Okay, but I'm not particularly concerned with the PR needs of the European Union.
23:09That is a different thing.
23:10What I do think is...
23:11But otherwise it could break up.
23:11I mean...
23:11Yeah, but we need to watch out with the communication aspect of it.
23:14Because I've heard this on many things.
23:15Also development cooperation, because it always has the same undertone of like,
23:19we're doing great things.
23:21We're just not explaining them well enough to the people.
23:24I think people have real concerns.
23:26And we need to take that seriously and adapt policies, not just adapt, you know, propaganda.
23:31Sorry, PR strategies.
23:32So I think this is really important.
23:35And secondly, let's, on the other hand, not stigmatize potential member states.
23:40Mark, if we had applied your attitude, the enlargement in 2004 wouldn't have been possible.
23:44And I'm happy to live in a European...
23:46Why not?
23:46I would have been happy.
23:47I'm happy to live in a European Union where Poland, the Baltic countries, the Czech Republic,
23:52and others are also fully fledged members.
23:55The Europe is more than old Western Europe.
23:57Europe is Western, Central and Eastern Europe.
23:59And I think that if these countries, these candidate countries, are on their way to fulfill all the necessary criteria,
24:06and I have been the rapporteur for one of the candidate countries for five years,
24:09I know what hard work it is.
24:12We should give them all the support.
24:14And you are playing with fears because all these arguments you have mentioned today,
24:18I remember were exactly the same ones I heard before 2004 when the 10 Eastern and 7 European countries joined
24:24and also when Romania and Bulgaria joined in 2007 and Croatia in 2013.
24:28And we didn't deal with them.
24:31Sorry, that's the point.
24:33We didn't deal with them.
24:34And this created fears.
24:35This created also a backlash in certain of these countries because we didn't take them seriously.
24:41And that is the point.
24:42I will give you a good example.
24:43Croatia joined in 2013 and 12 years later.
24:46Croatia is not only a fully fledged member of the European Union,
24:49but also a fully fledged member of the Schengen area and introduced the European Union.
24:52How many Croatians are forced to leave their country to get a decent work in Germany?
24:57Croatians now feel forced.
24:59You know, the German courses are big business in Croatia
25:01because there's not enough investment in the Croatian productive economy.
25:05And so this is something that the Croatians struggle with.
25:07And I want to hear, I want to listen to the Bulgarian trade unions,
25:10to the Romanian trade unions, to the Polish trade unions,
25:13that are saying we are not getting out of this what we as workers deserve.
25:16And here we're getting a real glimpse of what the debates inside the European hemicycle are like.
25:21That was the view of Mark Batenga, the view of David McAllister.
25:24I'd like to hear your view.
25:25Please reach out to us here, the ring at euronews.com.
25:30Before we come to a close, we have a bit of a rapid buzzer round for our two contenders.
25:36I will pose a very short question and I require a very short answer, just yes or no.
25:41Mark Batenga, is the future of the European Union bright, yes or no?
25:49If we fundamentally change policies, yes.
25:51Yes or no?
25:52Yes.
25:53Are opt-outs a good idea for joining member states?
25:56Yes.
25:57We've already seen this, can be an option.
26:00Should Turkey join the EU one day, Mark Batenga?
26:02I think for the moment, neither the EU nor Turkey is asking that.
26:05Yes or no?
26:06Under the given circumstances, no.
26:08Should countries with anti-LGBTQI plus laws be blocked from joining the EU, Mark Batenga?
26:14I think that's one of the fundamental rights that should be a condition indeed.
26:17Mark Batenga, really struggling there with the yes or no answers?
26:19No, sorry, yes.
26:21Dave McAllister, in your view.
26:23And should geopolitical considerations like countering Russian or Chinese influence justify faster EU enlargement?
26:29Yes.
26:32Very dangerous, and I'm going to continue struggling with yes or no.
26:36What Russian and Chinese influence, you're struggling?
26:39No, I'm not struggling with Russia or Chinese influence.
26:41What I'm saying is, should we – that's always a disadvantage, speaking to a Eurobubble audience, of course.
26:50But what I'm saying is that the best way to deal with that is not necessarily by an unfair enlargement process.
26:57Final question.
26:58Have you agreed with anything you've heard from your opponent today?
27:01Look, I know Mark Batenga.
27:02He's a member of our committee.
27:04And I would say he's a staunch fighter for social rights.
27:07And that's where I would give him credit.
27:09And what about you, Mark Batenga?
27:11No, absolutely.
27:12I think we share certain ideas of that Europe should become more democratic and clearly also more social.
27:18So I'm going to take the EPP up on this.
27:20I mean, this is going to be a starting point for a new cooperation.
27:23And that point brings this very special first edition of The Ring to an End.
27:27A round of applause.
27:27Thank you.
27:39Thank you.
27:40Thank you.