1
- 1 year ago
Disaster Transbian episodes 34 & 35
Category
📚
LearningTranscript
00:00You're welcome.
00:07Alright.
00:10Hey, what's in there, sir?
00:13I think I saw the other person there.
00:31Can I get something for you?
00:59I can't do that.
01:14Open the door.
01:27Open the door.
01:30Open the door.
01:34Open the door.
01:41Open the door.
01:46Open the door.
02:01Open the door.
02:04Open the door.
02:08Open the door.
02:09Open the door.
02:11Open the door.
02:12Open the door.
02:13Open the door.
02:14Open the door.
02:15Open the door.
02:16Open the window.
02:17OPEN the door.
02:23Open the door.
02:24the beam.
02:26The hinges are reinforced over here.
02:27jets out there there's also a manual bolt up here that can be thrown so even if these aren't working
02:32that would work this is a tremendous amount of holding force on the door but inside the door
02:38there's also an awful lot of resistance if you can't go around the edge you try to go through
02:42the middle well yeah the vinyl on the outside that's easy to get through maybe you can get
02:46through this layer of honeycomb material here that keeps down noise and shapes the outside door
02:51but this part in here the gray part jake the part you can't see in the middle of this door
02:55this is sort of like kevlar it's a very very tough material and you can pound away at this very hard
03:01and you're not going to break through jake what would it take tom to actually break down such a
03:06door well you mentioned 911 that's really the standard they're looking at here if you had a
03:11pistol you could shoot at this door at the joints and everything else and it still would not give
03:17way it's designed to resist that if you had a grenade and you set it off out here the shrapnel would not
03:23cut through the door let alone blow it off its hinges and if you think about a battering force
03:28if you had an nfl linebacker a guy weighed 250 pounds who's running at olympic speed and he hits
03:33this door with say 1500 pounds of force even that won't break it down
03:44german wings flight 9525 was a scheduled international passenger flight from barcelona
03:52elprat airport in spain to dusseldorf airport in germany the flight was operated by german wings low-cost
04:00carrier owned by the german airline lufthansa on march 24th 2015 the aircraft and airbus a320 211 crashed 100
04:13kilometers 62 miles northwest of nice in the french alps all 144 passengers and six crew members were
04:23killed as investigators hurried to the scene of one of the worst disasters in the history of german
04:30aviation they could not have imagined the horror of what they would learn just hours later are you ready
04:37to tell you
04:58at 10 o'clock central european time on march 24th 2015 german wings flight 9525
05:06took off from barcelona and climbed uneventfully toward its cruising altitude of 38 000 feet
05:13expected to arrive in dusseldorf in a little over 90 minutes captain sondenheimer responded
05:19normally to radio calls during the climb and contacted the marseille area control center in
05:25southern france upon reaching their cruising altitude at 10 27 at 10 30 marseille cleared the flight
05:34direct to the airmar waypoint and soddenheimer redback direct airmar merci german wings 1-8 golf marseille
05:43controllers would never again hear from flight 9525 less than one minute later unnoticed at first the
05:52flight began to descend losing altitude initially at 5 000 then 3 000 feet per minute steeper than a normal
06:00descent but shallower than would be expected in an emergency it took two minutes for the controller
06:08to notice by which time flight 9525 was already approaching 30 000 feet surprised that the flight
06:17would descend so far without calling him he keyed his mic and asked german wings what altitude they were
06:23cleared for but there was no reply beginning to worry now he asked twice more for the flight to
06:31acknowledge but it did not as flight 9525 continued its steady but rapid descent the controller kept
06:39calling to no avail watching as the flight's altitude indication dropped even lower at 10 38 with the plane
06:48flying dangerously low french air defense tried to contact on the universal emergency frequency
06:56but it didn't respond there either fearing the worst the air force scrambled a fighter to intercept the
07:02plane but it was already too late just as the order went out at 10 41 flight 9525 disappeared from radar
07:12in the marseilles control center having dropped down between the snow-capped peaks of the french alps
07:19at the time witnesses in the town of villeba caught sight of the airbus flying low overhead proceeding
07:27directly toward the nearby massif de troisgevesse clearly too low to avoid it approaching the 9 500 foot
07:362900 meter peak the plane made no effort to turn away until at last it disappeared up a remote valley
07:44never to emerge seconds later the airbus plowed nose first into a precipitous mountainside at an elevation
07:53of 5 000 feet 1500 meters obliterating the aircraft and instantly killing all 150 on board
08:01as shattered debris tumbled across the loose gray scree of a rain scoured ravine a distant boom issued forth
08:11from the mountains which was followed once more by silence rescue helicopters immediately launched to
08:19search for survivors but when they got there the rescuers were left bereft of hope what was once an
08:26airbus a320 lay shattered into countless fragments the largest of which could not have been more than a
08:33couple meters across rappelling down to the scene they were confronted with human carnage as well pieces of
08:41bodies torsos limbs hands and feet lay strewn across the mountainside within minutes they were forced to
08:51report the grim news that none of the 150 passengers and crew could possibly have survived publicly available
08:59data clearly traced the flight's long steady descent proving that the plane was under control and appeared
09:07to be operating normally at all times the plane never exceeded its normal flight envelope no distress calls
09:15were made and automated reporting systems never flagged any technical faults to the company speculation ran wild
09:23with proposed scenarios including a computer malfunction or pilot incapacitation due to lack of oxygen but if
09:32a computer error somehow locked the plane into a descent a far-fetched idea to begin with then why didn't the
09:39the pilots transmit a distress call during the nearly nine minutes before it struck the ground hypoxia
09:46was considered a more likely scenario but there was still much that did not add up for french investigators
09:52with the bureau of inquiry and analysis or bea dispatched to handle the case under international law
10:00the only answers would come from the plane's two black boxes in a stroke of luck a rescuer stumbled across
10:07the cockpit voice recorder or cvr within hours of the crash and it was immediately rushed to the bea
10:14headquarters in paris finding that the memory within was not damaged investigators were able to download
10:21the recording and listen to its contents only about 24 hours after the accident and unusually quick turnaround
10:30to this day no definitive transcript of the cvr's contents has been published
10:36but a basic outline can be gleaned from official reports and the accounts of journalists who heard the tapes
10:44according to these sources the conversations between the pilots were normal at first
10:49and confined operational matters about 12 minutes after takeoff a flight attendant entered the cockpit
10:57and the three crew members discussed the events on the ground in barcelona including their 26 minute delay
11:04at some point captain sondenheimer mentioned that he forgot to use the bathroom and during the stopover
11:10he would need to take a break to do so in flight first officer lubitz allegedly told him that he could go
11:18any time but soddenheimer prudently decided to wait until the plane was established in cruise
11:25after reaching 38 000 feet the autopilot leveled the plane and soddenheimer proposed that lubitz prepare for
11:33the descent briefing seeing as their cruise phase would be short according to various sources lubitz allegedly
11:41gave a cryptic reply hopefully he said we'll see at that moment captain sondenheimer made his final call
11:51to murciel announcing that he was going to use the restroom and handed over the radios to first officer
11:57lubitz the cvr captured the sound of a seat sliding back the sound of a cockpit door opening and finally a
12:05click as it swung closed again locking automatically the flight data recorder or fdr would later pin down
12:13the details of what happened next 19 seconds after soddenheimer left the cockpit someone used the altitude
12:21selector knob to enter a target altitude of 100 feet into the autopilot control panel the lowest altitude a
12:30pilot can select it could only have been first officer lubitz who was alone in the cockpit in response
12:38the autopilot's vertical mode changed to open descent in which the autopilot adjusts pitch attitude to
12:46maintain a target airspeed while the auto throttle holds engine power at idle the plane began to descend
12:55rapidly at first before settling on a brisk but safe value of 3 000 feet per minute in the background
13:04only minor unidentifiable sounds could be heard lubitz remained silent except for the sound of steady
13:11unhurried breathing picked up by the microphone on his headset
13:25unhurried breathing picked up by the camera
13:33any possibility that lubitz was asleep or unconscious was quickly ruled out because 43
13:40seconds into the descent the cvr captured the sound of him adjusting his chair and after a further 100
13:48seconds he began messing with the target airspeed on the autopilot control panel increasing it from
13:55273 knots to 308 knots seconds later he reduced it back to 288 knots
14:04then moved it up again to 302 knots at that moment the cvr captured the sound of the controller's first
14:12radio call asking about the altitude but lubitz did not audibly react two more calls followed coming
14:21through loud and clear but lubitz ignored those two instead he increased the selected airspeed again
14:28to 323 knots at 10 34 and 31 seconds the sound of a buzzer was heard indicating that someone was trying
14:37to enter the cockpit normally a returning crew member will type an entry code into a keypad on the door
14:45which triggers a buzzer the pilot can then glance at a live video feed of the entry area in order to
14:52determine whether the person should be permitted to enter if so the pilot should move the door lock
14:59switch from normal to unlock allowing the door to be opened from the outside but this time that didn't
15:06happen it's me soddenheimer is reported to have said but lubitz didn't let him in in fact the buzzer never
15:14sounded again which suggests that not only did lubitz not move the switch to the unlock position but that
15:21he actually moved it to the lock position instead which is used to deny unauthorized access when the
15:29switch is selected to lock all use of the keypad is disabled for five minutes on the other hand had
15:36lubitz been unconscious or otherwise unable to move the door lock switch soddenheimer could have entered an
15:43emergency override code known to all pilots causing the door to unlock by itself after 15 seconds this is
15:52the first backup method any pilot would use if they are unable to access the cockpit so the fact that
16:00soddenheimer never entered the emergency code could only mean that the keypad had been disabled by a
16:07conscious input from lubitz investigators were left speechless by all indications the first officer had
16:16deliberately locked the captain out of the cockpit and was flying the plane into the ground
16:23over the next minute the controller tried several more times to call flight 9525 his transmissions
16:30clearly recorded on the cvr but lubitz did not reply descending through 25 000 feet he used the speed
16:39knob to enter a target airspeed of 350 knots the highest value a pilot could select dutifully the autopilot
16:48pitched the nose down and the plane accelerated still further several chimes were heard as someone
16:56attempted to call the cockpit via the inner phone but lubitz didn't answer soddenheimer started knocking
17:02on the cockpit door once twice three times six times in the background the cvr picked up a muffled shout
17:11for the love of god open this door from there anger and confusion turned to desperation it was becoming
17:19obvious something was terribly wrong and soddenheimer must have decided it was time for drastic action
17:27as he allegedly told a flight attendant to bring him a crowbar although some accounts suggest he used
17:34an axe designed specifically to open jam doors in an emergency would have been more effective than a
17:40crash axe against the bulletproof cockpit door soon the cvr captured the sound of heavy blows against the
17:49door as soddenheimer frantically tried to smash his way in but time was running out mountains rose up beneath
17:56them and passengers began to panic propelled by their screams of terror soddenheimer beat pride and hammered
18:05as hard as he could but still the reinforced door refused to give away open the goddamn door he roared
18:13as mountains creaked by outside the windows the cacophony in the cabin juxtaposed against lubitz's malevolent silence
18:21stunned by what they had heard on the cvr investigators could only conclude that first officer andreas lubitz
18:32had deliberately crashed the plane in an appalling act of mass murder suicide other explanations were no
18:40doubt considered but none fit the evidence there were no malfunctions recorded on the fdr lubitz must have
18:48been alive and acting consciously throughout the descent but there was no legitimate reason for
18:54him to take the action he did no reason to lock soddenheimer out to select an altitude of 100 feet
19:02to let the autopilot fly the plane into the ground if he didn't want the plane to crash he would have
19:08tried to stop it but he didn't even try successfully or otherwise the only answer was that he wanted to
19:15crash the plane and he succeeded based on this evidence just two days after the accident the bea
19:23announced to the world that the crash of flight 9525 was a purposeful act by the first officer
19:45it takes an hour for searchers to spot the first remains of flight 9525 among the dead 16 young
19:56students who will never return home to their families in halton germany the death of opera singer maria radnor
20:04and her young family is another devastating loss you're overwhelmed by it you cannot think about anything
20:14other than the death of your children the enormity of the crash quickly sinks in it's the worst air
20:26disaster on french soil in more than three decades the hardest thing i i found personally to to find
20:32stories little dolls or or teddy bears uh you know that belong to uh to a child the deadly crash comes just
20:41two months after a terrorist killing spree claimed 17 lives in and around paris many now fear that
20:48the terrorists have struck again one of the reasons that people speculated that this might be a
20:56terrorism event was simply the proximity to the attacks on the charlie abdo newspaper that left
21:04really all of france in a state of shock
21:06mme c'est même la ligne de tout le numéro elle est super bien et les doutes en mieux qu'elle te fait
21:13mesurer comment on est passé touche pas mon pote anti-raciste et à touche pas mon mahomet ce qui est
21:19plus l'anti-racisme c'est l'anti-blasphème pour cela elle est très très bonne pourrais délivrer un message
21:26plutôt sympa un truc énorme on dirait qu'il faut savoir arrêter une vraie
21:32news le dessin est un peu bonhomme mais il faut savoir arrêter une vraie
21:37c'est dur d'être aimé par des coups
21:41ça c'est pas mal
21:43on a pas vu l'heure là on voit pas le visage comme ça
22:13oh
22:17firing a bullet through a glass door the two men left for 10 rue nicholas appart
22:24there they encountered cartoonist divine coco ray and her young daughter outside and at
22:30gunpoint forced her to enter the past code into the electronic door the men sprayed the lobby with
22:38gunfire upon entering the first victim was maintenance worker frederick boissot who was
22:44killed as he sat at the reception desk the gunman forced ray at gunpoint to lead them to a second
22:51floor office where 15 staff members were having an editorial meeting charlie hebdo's first news
22:58conference of the year the gunman burst into the meeting room the shooting lasted five to ten
23:05minutes the gunman aimed at the journalists heads and killed them during the gunfire ray survived
23:12uninjured by hiding under a desk from where she witnessed the murders of walensky and kabu
23:19leger also survived by hiding under a desk as the gunman entered 10 of the 12 people murdered were
23:27shot on the second floor past the security door one of the gunmen ran towards the police and shouted
23:34do you want to kill us the policeman answered no it's fine boss and raised his hand toward the
23:40gunman who then murdered the policeman with a fatal shot to the head at close range
23:55the gunman then left the scene shouting we have avenged the prophet muhammad we have killed charlie
24:06hebdo they and that as soon as they were separated the commandos decided that was the opportunity to
24:12act burst in uh and the kawachi brothers responded by exiting the building opening fire and uh french
24:21televisions reporting that three police officers were wounded in the week after the shooting 54
24:28anti-muslim incidents were reported in france now lisa listen to me this is important i want you to
24:35smile today but i don't feel like smiling well it doesn't matter how you feel inside you know it's what
24:42shows up on the surface accounts that's what my mother taught me take all your bad feelings and push them
24:49down all the way down past your knees until you're almost walking on them and then you'll fit in and
24:56you'll be invited to parties and boys will like you and happiness will follow
25:19look mommy there's no plane up in the sky
25:30so
25:49goodbye
26:02Blue sky, goodbye, blue sky, goodbye, goodbye.
26:24Based on this evidence, just two days after the accident, the BEA announced to the world
26:31that the crash of Flight 9525 was a purposeful act by the first officer.
26:39The sensational press conference upended the public conversation around the crash
26:44and deeply unsettled the airline industry.
26:47From that point, the investigation into the crash, conducted in parallel by safety experts
26:54and judicial authorities, began to focus on what led Andreas Lubitz to commit such an appalling
27:01act and how he was able to get away with it.
27:05And to tell that story, the investigators needed to go back to the quiet, upscale town of Montabaur
27:13in the German Rhineland where Lubitz grew up and first learned to love flying.
27:19The firstborn son of a banker and a piano teacher, Andreas Gunter Lubitz, was born on December 18,
27:271987 in the Bavarian town of Neuburg on Der Donau, although his family moved across the country
27:35to Montabaur while he was still in school.
27:37He was, by most accounts, a normal child and later a normal adult.
27:43He also expressed a desire to fly from an early age and the passion never left him.
27:49His first taste of flying came at a local gliding club at the age of 14 and he remained a regular
27:56club attendee well into adulthood.
27:59In fact, as soon as he finished high school in 2007, he applied to Lufthansa's in-house
28:05pilot training program where his passion and dedication served him well.
28:11Out of 6,530 applicants, he was one of just 384 selected to begin commercial pilot training.
28:21Everything seemed to be on track until the summer of 2008 when Lubitz suddenly fell into
28:26a deep, crushing depression.
28:28On November 5th, just two months after he started his initial training, he withdrew, citing
28:35medical reasons.
28:37In the depths of despair, he experienced suicidal ideation, made a pact with his therapist not
28:44to commit suicide, and was briefly hospitalized.
28:49In an effort to get his life back on track, he began taking antidepressants, and after some
28:55time he started to show improvement, but his own mental health was only half the battle.
29:01In April 2009, Lubitz applied for the first annual renewal of his medical certification,
29:08which is required in order to fly an airplane, but the doctors at Lufthansa's Aeromedical
29:14Center denied his application on account of his ongoing major depression and medication thereof,
29:22which rendered him unfit to fly under European and German law.
29:28At the time, EU rules prohibited anyone taking any psychoactive antidepressant from holding
29:35a medical certificate, so the only solution was to ease off the medication.
29:41With help from a psychiatrist, Lubitz was eventually able to end treatment, and in July 2009, he was
29:48declared fully recovered.
29:50After applying again, the Lufthansa Aeromedical Center decided to issue him a new medical certificate,
29:56but with strings attached.
29:58If he ever again suffered from depression, the document said, the certificate would immediately
30:03become invalid.
30:05Jesus Christ!
30:07It's not clear from the official report whether the document described this invalidation as
30:12permanent, but that was certainly the implication.
30:16With the limitation on his medical hanging in the background, Lubitz resumed initial training
30:22with Lufthansa and eventually graduated to the next phase, flight training in real light
30:29aircraft at a facility in the U.S. state of Arizona.
30:33In order to be accepted, he needed to submit his medical information to the Federal Aviation
30:39Administration and received a U.S. medical.
30:41Allegedly, he failed to disclose his history of depression on the form, but was somehow caught
30:48in the lie.
30:50The official report, however, makes no mention of any explicit rule breaking.
30:56In any case, what is known is that the FAA eventually received Lubitz's medical history
31:02certificate and issued him a U.S. medical certificate with the same limitations as the German one,
31:09and he went on to pass flight training in Arizona in 2011.
31:13For two years after that, he worked as a flight attendant for Lufthansa until a spot opened up
31:20and he was assigned to the German Wings Division.
31:23He subsequently completed an Airbus A320 type rating course, passed his proficiency check,
31:30and began flying passengers as an A320 first officer for German Wings in the fall of 2014.
31:38But all of that changed in December 2014, when Lubitz's depression suddenly returned.
31:45This time, the symptoms were different and more sinister.
31:48He complained that he was losing his vision, but multiple physicians could find nothing wrong
31:54with his eyesight.
31:56Doctors proposed that he might be suffering from a psychosomatic disorder.
32:00in which psychological factors give rise to seemingly physical symptoms.
32:05But Lubitz was allegedly resistant to the idea, possibly because the doctors wanted him to
32:11take psychoactive medications that he feared would invalidate his medical certificate.
32:17Over the first few months of 2015, with his despair deepening, he saw at least four different
32:24doctors and several psychiatrists who variously diagnosed him with depression, anxiety, and other illnesses.
32:33In February, a physician issued him eight days of sick leave, but he kept working anyway.
32:39He was prescribed Zopaclone and Mirtazepin, neither of which was approved for pilots.
32:45He took several sick days, but for the most part, he ignored his doctor's request to stop working.
32:52Under medical confidentiality laws, the only way for German Wings to find out that his doctors were
32:58issuing sick leave was for Lubitz to forward the notices to his employer.
33:04But he did not. Presumably, he feared that if he did, they would find out that he was ill,
33:10his medical would be revoked, and he would lose his career. Instead, he took the sick leave notes,
33:18ripped them up, and threw them in the trash.
33:21Mentally and physically unwell and living in constant fear, Lubitz's mind eventually veered
33:28into suicidal ideation and paranoia. Lying restless at night, he was unable to catch more than a few
33:35scattered snatches of sleep. In early March, he started searching the internet for ways to commit
33:41suicide. His physician diagnosed him with possible psychosis, a condition characterized by delusions
33:49and difficulty determining what is real, prompting a referral to a psychiatric hospital
33:55along with 19 days of sick leave. Days later, his psychiatrist prescribed him two more medications,
34:03eschatolopram and zolpidem. But still, he kept flying. On the job, he kept up a remarkable
34:11impression of normalcy. But on the inside, he was falling apart, growing more dangerous with every
34:18passing day. According to documents collected by prosecutors and seen by GQ writer Joshua Hammer,
34:25Lubitz allegedly tried to work with his psychiatrist, keeping a journal of positive thoughts,
34:31among other activities, which suggested that he wanted to recover. But his mind was descending into
34:38an impenetrable darkness. Sometime in mid-March, he began searching the internet for information about
34:46cockpit door security on the Airbus A320. Then, on Sunday, March 22nd, he allegedly wrote
34:55several notes on a scrap paper, including the letters BCN for Barcelona, the words Decision Sunday,
35:03and a series of bullet points, including find the inner will to work and continue to live,
35:10deal with stress and sleeplessness, and finally, let myself go.
35:22Oh, baby! Don't leave me now!
35:37Don't leave me now!
35:41All kids love to play with toy airplanes, but have you ever wondered what it would
36:09be like to be a real pilot? Look! There goes the airplane!
36:15Wow! What do you think of my outfit? I really feel like a pilot now.
36:19Well, I hope you've enjoyed watching and learning all about airplanes. I've had a great time pretending
36:23to be a real airplane pilot. So, until next time, this is Pilot Dave saying see you in the wild blue yonder.
36:35Running away.
36:44Oh, Baby.
36:51Why are you running away?
36:55cént'
37:00habe
37:05Terrain. Terrain. Terrain.
37:29Terrain. Terrain.
37:33Terrain. Terrain.
37:51Subscribe.
37:54According to GQ, police later found a piece of paper and the trash in his apartment,
37:59the closest he ever came to leaving a suicide note.
38:03One of the most disturbing aspects of Lubitz's story is that most of those who knew him thought he was a normal person.
38:11He loved his job. He spent time with friends. He had hobbies. He had a girlfriend.
38:16Few people in his life saw anything untoward about his behavior in the months before the crash,
38:22even though medical records showed he was falling down a spiral of despair and delusion.
38:28Nor did he display any signs that he might be capable of mass murder.
38:33In fact, some of those close to him still refuse to believe it.
38:38His parents, for instance, have angered victims' families on several occasions by very publicly protesting for their son's innocence.
38:47But even an aviation expert they hired to poke holes in the official report didn't seem to believe their assertions,
38:56even though he dutifully did what they asked.
38:58In the end, the parents can be forgiven, even in the face of overwhelming evidence.
39:05It can be all but impossible to imagine that someone so close was capable of committing such an atrocity.
39:12But Lubitz himself can receive no such mercy.
39:16His depression was not an excuse.
39:18After all, millions of people suffer from depression, including thousands of airline pilots,
39:25and hardly any of them commit mass murder-suicide.
39:29The level of delusion required to completely dismiss the lives of 149 other people
39:36in the blind pursuit of self-annihilation is difficult to comprehend and impossible to study.
39:43Many suicidal people are deeply empathetic, even refusing to take their own lives for fear of upsetting loved ones.
39:53How Lubitz, in the grip of psychosis, drifted to the opposite extreme cannot be known,
40:00although psychologists have proposed various explanations.
40:04Perhaps he was simply a murderous psychopath all along, desiring to live in infamy.
40:09Perhaps he performatively imitated empathy in times of normalcy,
40:14but in a moment of great stress, the lives of others simply did not occur to him.
40:20Or perhaps the decision to crash the plane was a form of intrusive thought,
40:26which in his psychosis he failed to counter,
40:29and having taken the decision, fear of punishment,
40:33should he reverse course, overcame any dying shreds of conscience.
40:38His medical would have been up for renewal in July,
40:42requiring an aeromedical examination, at which his condition may have been discovered.
40:47But he carried out his suicidal mission before this could occur.
40:52In the aftermath of the crash, experts proposed various measures
40:57intended to reduce the risk of pilot suicide,
41:01including a rule that there must be two crew members in the cockpit at all times.
41:06Typically, this means that a flight attendant must wait in the cockpit whenever one pilot leaves
41:13to use the bathroom, a policy which has existed in the United States for many years,
41:19but was not and still is not widespread in the rest of the world.
41:23Shortly after the crash of Flight 9525,
41:26the European Aviation Safety Agency began encouraging the policy in Europe
41:32in order to gather data about its effectiveness.
41:36But after the trial period was over, the results were not encouraging.
41:41In the opinion of EASA and the airlines themselves,
41:45the policy did not eliminate the risk of pilot suicide.
41:48After all, several high-profile cases of in-flight suicide have occurred
41:54with more than one pilot in the cockpit,
41:57and the presence of a flight attendant is even less likely to prove decisive.
42:02Furthermore, they argued,
42:04the policy leaves the cockpit door open for longer periods of time,
42:09increasing the risk of hijackings,
42:11which historically have been much more common than pilot suicides anyways.
42:16Part of the problem is that the criteria for determining who is a potential risk
42:23are out of touch with the realities of modern medicine.
42:26Several decades ago, a psychological diagnosis was rare
42:30and could usually be considered a big deal.
42:33Today, that's no longer the case.
42:35For instance, among younger generations,
42:37who tend to be more open about their mental health,
42:40it seems like almost everyone freely admits
42:42that they've suffered from depression or anxiety or ADHD or autism
42:47or any of the numerous issues
42:49that can complicate aeromedical certification.
42:52Many of these conditions are no more common now
42:55than they were 40 years ago,
42:56but the rate of diagnosis has increased,
42:59especially for low-level cases
43:01that realistically pose no danger.
43:04And yet,
43:05medical certification rules
43:06continue to treat anyone ever diagnosed with anxiety
43:09as a potential mass murderer.
43:12Although he eventually managed to get a medical certificate,
43:16it came with a clause
43:17that virtually guaranteed his career would end
43:20if he ever became depressed again.
43:23Imagine that you were in his position.
43:25If you felt your depression returning,
43:27would you admit it to an aeromedical examiner?
43:30Most people probably wouldn't.
43:32After all,
43:33his flight training had cost him 60,000 euros
43:36and he was still repaying the loan.
43:39German Wings offered insurances
43:41that would cover most of the loan
43:43if he became unfit to fly.
43:46But what about after that?
43:47He had spent years of his life
43:49working to become a pilot
43:50and flying had been his passion since childhood.
43:54If he lost his medical,
43:56he would find himself with no money,
43:58no career,
43:59no future.
44:01Furthermore,
44:02German Wings' loss of license insurance
44:04only covered loss of future income
44:07for pilots who were at least 35 years old
44:10or had worked for the company
44:13for at least 10 years
44:14while Lubitz was only 27
44:17and had been flying for German Wings
44:19for only five months.
44:21Lubitz considered purchasing
44:23a third-party insurance policy
44:25that would cover future loss of income,
44:27but according to emails left on his computer,
44:30he couldn't get insurance companies to cover him
44:33because, you guessed it,
44:35the limitation on his medical certificate
44:37made him too high-risk.
44:40The very stress of his situation
44:43might have made his depression worse,
44:45creating a destructive feedback loop
44:48that led him to the very gates of madness.
44:51But what if it didn't have to be that way?
44:53What if Lubitz had believed
44:55it was possible to temporarily ground himself
44:58and then regain his medical later
45:00if the psychiatrist testified
45:02that he had recovered?
45:05After all,
45:06he had done exactly that
45:07during training in 2008.
45:11Regardless of whether
45:12he would have actually been recertified,
45:14what if all he needed to get himself
45:16out of the cockpit
45:17was a little bit of hope
45:18that he could one day come back?
45:21We can't know for sure
45:22because this is a hypothetical,
45:24and it's always possible
45:25he was more delusional
45:27than publicly known.
45:28At the time he first received
45:29his FAA medical,
45:31Lubitz appeared to have recovered
45:33from his severe depression,
45:34a condition which afflicts
45:36one in every six men
45:38and is not necessarily recurrent.
45:41Applicants will continue to lie
45:43about their medical problems,
45:45and not only innocuous problems,
45:47but real ones too,
45:49like Lubitz's eventual psychosis,
45:51which was disqualifying
45:53by any standard.
45:55And as long as the system
45:56incentivizes hiding these problems,
45:59it will remain impossible
46:00to detect those rare individuals
46:03like Lubitz
46:04who are actually dangerous.
46:07In the grand scheme of things,
46:09pilot suicide remains rare,
46:11but means exists
46:12to make it much rarer.
46:14And if the aviation industry
46:15truly cares about safety,
46:18the topic,
46:19as touchy as it is,
46:20must not be avoided.
46:22We owe it to those
46:24who died on flight 9525,
46:26trapped aboard an airliner
46:28as their own pilot
46:29drove it unceasingly downward,
46:32possessed by demons
46:33known only to him.
46:35We owe it to Captain Patrick Sottenheimer,
46:38who died a hero,
46:40even though he could not possibly
46:41have saved the plane.
46:43And we owe it to future pilots,
46:45who should have the right
46:47to care for themselves
46:48without fear of punishment,
46:51as well as their future passengers,
46:53who would rest easier
46:54knowing that something
46:56has been done.
46:58We owe this
46:59because the German wing's tragedy
47:01was not only
47:03a senseless act of murder,
47:05but the product
47:06of a senseless system,
47:08one which must be reformed
47:10before the next Andreas Lubitz,
47:13succumbing to the siren song
47:15of oblivion,
47:16steps into a cockpit
47:17for the last time.
47:22Lisa, I apologize to you.
47:24I was wrong.
47:25I take it all back.
47:26Always be yourself.
47:27You want to be sad, honey?
47:29Be sad.
47:30We'll ride it out with you.
47:31And when you get finished
47:33feeling sad,
47:34we'll still be there.
47:36From now on,
47:37let me do the smiling
47:38for both of us.
47:40Okay, Mom.
47:41I said you could
47:43stop smiling, Lisa.
47:44I feel like smiling.
47:47Don't let go.
47:49You got the music in you.
47:51One dance left.
47:53This world is good.
47:54We're perfect.
47:56Don't give up.
47:57You got a reason to live.
48:00Can't forget.
48:02We only get what we get.
48:04Don't let go.
48:06I feel the music in you.
48:08Yeah, yeah, yeah.
48:10Who love you.
48:12Fly.
48:18I was gray.
48:24Can't die.
48:29You only get what you give.
48:36Have insurance hit by flying.
48:39F.D.A. Big Bank is buying
48:41Fake computer crashes, dying
48:43Cloning, well, they're multiplying
48:45Fashion shoots with Becky Hansen
48:48Gordy Love and Marilyn Manson
48:50You're all bitch, run to your mansions
48:52Come around, we'll kick your ass in
48:54Oh, oh, oh
48:56Oh, oh, oh, oh
48:58Oh, oh, oh, oh
49:09Tiefer, tiefer
49:14Lagenbrunner tiefer
49:17Gibt es ein Licht?