- 1 year ago
- #agendaawani
How can we fight cybercrime when crucial data is scattered and inconsistent? Can a new framework strike the right balance between privacy and protection? Catch the interview with Prof. Sureswaran Ramadass, Chairman of the APAC IPv6 Council, on #AgendaAWANI.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Hello, good evening and welcome to Agenda Awani. I'm Amril Aiman, your host for tonight.
00:11So tonight we dive into a critical and complex issue at the intersection of technology, privacy and national security.
00:20So the Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commissions or MCMC has proposed a new framework
00:27that would mandate the retention, preservation and disclosure of communication data for investigative purposes.
00:35Supporters say it could be a game changer in combating cyber threats, online scams and child exploitation
00:44but critics are also sounding the alarms over privacy, surveillance and the potential misuse of personal data.
00:52So how do we strike the right balance in between public safety and also personal freedom?
00:58Joining me tonight to unpack this question is Professor Sureswaran Ramadas,
01:03Chairman of the APEC IPv6 Council and also a cyber security expert.
01:08Prof, welcome to the show. Thank you so much for joining us.
01:12Good afternoon, good evening, Amir.
01:14Prof, let's start with the big picture.
01:16In plain terms, what gap is this proposed data retention framework meant to close?
01:22And why can't our current laws or our industry practices handle that today?
01:28Actually, our current laws do cover it.
01:31If you look at the CMA Act, it covers, in general, the entire scope of such data retention.
01:41However, it doesn't get into the specifics of it.
01:45So, what this new framework is doing is, it takes that law and then it goes into detail
01:53to say exactly what do we need to cover with it and framework.
01:57It's actually very interesting to see that that law was so well written that it really,
02:03it had opened up the fact that such a thing could happen in the future.
02:07That, that act was in 1998, you know, more than 20, 25 years ago.
02:12But yet, they had the, or the farsightedness to say, okay, in case of cyber security, we need to look
02:19at such issues. But they don't delve into the details. And the details have changed.
02:25As you know, the internet is an ever evolving system. And the whole internet has changed.
02:31Today, those days, you won't have cyber crimes committed at the scale that is being committed
02:40today on the internet. You have maybe 1% of crime committed to cyber crime, or even less.
02:46Today, if I'm not mistaken, the data shows that in 2024, 85% of our crimes are now cyber crime related.
02:59And so, there comes a need for not just our government, but governments around the world
03:06have started to move to say, we need to put in laws. We need to put in new frameworks to be able to
03:15effectively combat these particular issues that are arising.
03:20And then you mentioned that it is an evolving nature. That's why we need this proposed data
03:26retention framework. But let's look at the worst case scenario. If we did nothing for the next five
03:32years per se, what's the worst case scenario here? I have some data here, you know, I'll explain this.
03:39So, in 2024, 35,000 digital financial scam cases were reported. 35,000. This is a 33% increase from the
03:50previous year, 2023. Which means it's increasing, right? Think what's going to happen in 2025.
04:00You're going to get probably 60,000. There's going to probably be a 100% increase because
04:05people have realized that our laws are not really fully adequate to be able to combat such things
04:13right now. The current law that I remember people getting arrested and then there's a 50,000 or 500,000
04:20fine and then they're off. But they've cheated people for more than millions and millions of ringgit.
04:25Right? And then there comes a question of data and whether the data is valid, was it captured
04:33correctly and is it admissible in court and so on. So, the prosecution teams, our law enforcement
04:42agencies are having a difficult time putting together such cases based on our current data retention
04:50capabilities framework, right? So, with a new framework like this, it's going to see a reduction
04:59in such crimes. We hope to see a reduction. You know, I'm sure you've gotten one of those phone calls,
05:05right? It says, okay, I'm calling from EPA, you know, please give me all your information.
05:10And then you hang up on that. But there are people out there, you know, the older people,
05:15older generation, even some in the younger generation that get scammed and they're losing money.
05:20We need to do something about this. That's just one, one of the, one of the issues we're having.
05:26But that is a definite obvious issue that all of us have experienced.
05:32Prof, I'm pretty sure this is what a question that has in everyone's mind right now. Pay this
05:37scenario. How would a quick access to this data stop a fast, to this data stop a fast moving scam,
05:46a major cyber attack, or perhaps even a child exploitation ring?
05:51So, if the data is looked at correctly and analysed correctly, there is a possibility that we can be
05:58able to analyse the situation and say that yes, such an attack or such an offence is taking place or has
06:06taken place and we are able to capture the track. We're able to capture it to who used it.
06:11I mean, that's the aim, right? To be able to find out who stole your money.
06:18If we can't find out who stole your money, if we cannot add that track, then we can't prosecute
06:25the person. It becomes useless. Second, if you do find out who stole it, but if you don't have the
06:30evidence to go to court and say, look, this is the track, this is the proof, you can see the transaction
06:36went from here to here. The communication happened from here to here. This person made the phone
06:40call or this person sent that email. That proof must be there, that metadata proof, right? And that
06:47must be presented in the court. If you don't have that proof, but you know he stole your money, again,
06:51there is no case or the case becomes a very difficult case to fight. This is what this framework
06:58can actually achieve, or we are hoping that it will achieve.
07:00When MCMC proposed this, there's a confusion out there. So are we storing the content of calls and
07:08messages, or only the surrounding metadata, like who, when, and where, and why does the metadata
07:16matter so much to the investigation?
07:19So this framework looks really at metadata. So metadata is not so much the content,
07:28it is the data that is associated with the message. The time that the message was sent,
07:34who was it sent by, which IP address, where was it routed to, and so on. So this metadata information
07:41is vital because then it shows that that criminal sent the message trying to rob that old person,
07:47you know, and convincing that old person to give the money or they are in banking information to them.
07:54So that is why that metadata is important. If you are talking about general data, I think the biggest
08:03collectors of general data, it's definitely not the government, it's your social media. The social
08:10media sites are the ones that do a fantastic job in collecting people's data and storing the data.
08:16And who exactly falls under this framework? Are we literally tracking everyone with a mobile device,
08:25kids, tourists, public figures, or whether they realize it or not, Prof?
08:31I think eventually, I think for the beginning, what they're going to do is store all data,
08:36and then eventually they're going to be applying techniques, filtering techniques,
08:40even maybe artificial intelligence to start filtering the type of data that you want to keep. But for the
08:47beginning, it is possible that all forms or all people's data will be stored, or users' data.
08:56Is there anyone perhaps that is explicitly exempt under the current draft?
09:01I'm not sure. I'm not sure if anyone is currently exempt, but I think in the sense of mainly targeting the
09:10criminal element, that is what the whole act is about. The act is to really target the criminal element,
09:19the people that are communicating with the other people to get into your bank accounts and so on.
09:25You know, they're putting one-by-one steps in place so that this is reduced. I think the people need to
09:31understand our community, and most of the community understands, because very often I get, I'm in a group,
09:38and then people say, you know, what the hell is the government of the police doing about stopping
09:43these scam calls and this teeming of money from our accounts? It's continuously there. Everyone's asking
09:50about it, right? So it is important that this framework be initiated so that we can reduce that.
09:59It's really reached the point of annoyance. You know, you really pity, you know, someone who is 75
10:06or 70 and their entire savings EPF money gets stolen. And then what do they do? That was their savings for
10:12their life. Yes, you laid out why is it important because of the growing online scams and all that.
10:20But also there are some people that argue that some of the information in place, the names, IPs,
10:27live locations, it feels a bit highly sensitive. So what's the real risk if it leaks? Because lately
10:34also we have received reports, at the time of recording, we have received reports of data leak within
10:40the government itself. And so what should MCMC treat as its top cybersecurity priority right now?
10:48So if you ask me, and if I'm a cyber criminal, and I'm looking to steal data,
10:56really, this metadata is kind of useless for me. I mean, all it tells me is A communicated with B,
11:02communicated with C. That's not going to get me money. If I'm a criminal, I will go after
11:09databases which are associated with banks, databases which are on social media.
11:15These databases give me a lot of information. Honestly, that's what I will go after, real
11:22information, because I can use that. I want names of people, bank accounts, I want information,
11:27phone numbers. I want things like a lot of information about a person. Metadata really doesn't
11:33give me that. Metadata gives me just who communicated with what at what time and so on. It's really something
11:39that is only useful for people who want to know who communicated when and what. You know, that kind of
11:46information. So to me, if I'm a cyber criminal, I'll go after other sources of information, really.
11:53That's where my main goal is. That's where the goal of data is.
12:01And also, Prof, MCMC also suggested a 12 to 18-month retention window. Does that strike the right
12:10balance between investigative need and also privacy? Or could a shorter, say, six-month window
12:17could still work? To really be honest, to me, really, it's not that big a deal whether you're
12:26six months of storing of metadata or 12 months or 18 months. When you store metadata, the biggest
12:32challenge will be on the people having to store it. They will have to provide the storage page for it.
12:37But otherwise, you know, whether I keep six months of data or two years of data, it's metadata.
12:43You know, it's only valuable to people who know how to use metadata.
12:50Prof, if I could ask, how does this practice compare with other leading practices in the region itself?
12:57So all countries are now practicing. All countries are moving towards securing their internet.
13:02And there are many, many countries. I can go through details. I have some statistics here.
13:07But, you know, countries have put much more tighter provisioning than Malaysia has.
13:16So Singapore has started putting in very tight measures in their cyber security rules and regulations.
13:25The other countries, including Japan, Korea, the UK, Australia, all of them have tightened up their
13:35data monitoring. The US has always had monitoring. The US requirements are even much, much higher than
13:43any of our requirements. In fact, the interesting thing about the US requirement is it actually goes
13:48beyond the borders of their country. They are saying that any company that is registered in the US
13:54still has to adhere and give the US data. And they actually go beyond metadata.
13:59So, you know, for them, they find that monitoring this, they are mainly looking at terrorism as well,
14:07cyber terrorism and so on. So within Malaysia, if you look at the scope, what Malaysia is doing compared
14:14to what some of the other countries have implemented, it's actually pretty good. I mean, in the sense of
14:19we keep it to minimal, we keep it to a very targeted reason, you know, to really assist law enforcement and nothing more.
14:31I mean, that's the real target of this particular thing.
14:49Prof, this proposal, it will affect not just the big telcos, but also smaller non-licenses would also
15:00store the data. Do they have, do they all have the infrastructure and the cyber hygiene to keep it
15:07safe? And how do we reassure the public on that, that their data is safe with also the small,
15:14small companies as well, other than the big telcos? That's a good question that you put forth. And
15:20this is something that the smaller players have to have discussions with MCMC and the regulators
15:26who are now proposing this framework. So if they need assistance, they should ask, they should be
15:32forthcoming and say, look, we need assistance in this particular areas, or can you help us audit our
15:38security or our cyber security, where we are storing the data. So there are general guidelines,
15:43there are ISO guidelines like 17799, which is now taken over by ISO 27002. So these guidelines clearly
15:53tell you what to put into place in terms of cyber security. But physical audits are also important
16:01and such audits, I think the players can always ask MCMC for assistance, the regulators for assistance in this.
16:08case. Prof, you mentioned before that what we are collecting, what MCMC has proposed to collect is
16:16metadata, it would not be misused. But in worst case scenario, let's talk if it's like, if it's
16:23being misused, which perhaps risk is the most realistic here? Is it perhaps rogue insiders or maybe external
16:31hackers or perhaps even loopholes in the legal process and which one that might worry you the most?
16:38As I said, I find that to me, honestly, if I was a hacker, that data that they're collecting is kind
16:44of useless. But I would go after different sources where I would be, it's much more useful if I'm a hacker
16:54for me, right? And what are those sources? Those sources are things like bank accounts, credit card
16:59information. These are the people who store a lot of social media, a lot of websites, sales sites,
17:06store such data. Those are the ones that I will go after. If I'm going to put time and effort and I get
17:11metadata, what am I going to do with that, really? Unless I'm going to prosecute someone or I'm going to
17:17go after someone to say, look, you created this line of communications. I'm blaming you for it.
17:23And then the guy will say, well, what do you want to blame me for? You know, you're not an
17:28enforcement agency. So you understand what I'm saying in that sense, you know, the usefulness of that data,
17:35it all depends on what the person who's trying to get that data wants to achieve out of it.
17:42Okay, Prof. If this move forward, what concrete controls perhaps in terms of technical or procedural
17:49must be in place to keep, you know, those curious stuff or maybe overzealous officers from poking around
17:56where they shouldn't? Ah, so there must be oversight to anything we do and everything that the government
18:03does, there must be an oversight body. And from what I have read, the CMA already authorizes
18:09and looks into oversight by, there is an appeal tribunal as well as a judicial review process,
18:20which is embedded in the CMA Act of the 1998
18:24law. And it allows people to say, look, if I feel that it is being abused, I can use that to review
18:33what is happening.
18:33And it's very important. So that's a good thing that you brought up. There must always be a watchdog.
18:41So maybe MCMC can look into setting up maybe a small watchdog committee that ensures that such data
18:48is never abused. And also looking abroad, Prof, countries that you mentioned before with similar laws
18:56often built-in redress mechanism for wrongful access or leaks, which protections actually work elsewhere.
19:04And should Malaysia adopt them wholesale or perhaps customise it its own?
19:10Yeah, and we should always look at what's the biggest issue with us. So we shouldn't adopt
19:15anything wholesale. We should take what they have, learn from what they have done, and then build it
19:20more towards our needs and build it better. And do you think people deserve to know if their data was
19:31accessed during an investigation, especially if they are later found innocent? And if so,
19:37when should that notification happen? So this is metadata. That means if I'm to be notified that you're
19:46going to save my data for every call I make, imagine the amount of notifications I get. But your question
19:53was more specifically to if it is being used in an investigation. I really am not an expert to answer
20:01that question. It is more of a legal and police, I think a law enforcement thing. I don't know if law
20:09enforcement is required to tell someone that they are being investigated. If it is required, then they must
20:15tell the person. If today, if the moment the police start an investigation on a person, are they required
20:23to tell the person they are starting an investigation on you? If they are, then yes, then they must tell
20:30the person if they are extracting their data that yes, I am starting an investigation, I'm looking at your data.
20:37It must follow the bigger framework of the law.
20:39And should, in your perspective, should MCMC or relevant agencies publish transparency report
20:48showing how often their data is accessed on and for what purpose as is done in some other countries?
20:55Why not? I mean, there's no harm in disclosing information to say how useful has this framework
21:03actually been. I think it will help you, you know, for people to further support the framework to show that
21:09look, with this framework now, we've managed to reduce scam calls by 80%, and that would make people happy
21:17and support the framework better.
21:20And perhaps, Prof, if there's a breach or a wrongful disclosure, where should the bug stop at the company, or the regulator,
21:30or individual employees, and what realistic recourse should ordinary citizens have?
21:38So, again, it depends. If I'm a person and I hacked one of the ISP sites and I stole the metadata from there,
21:49then technically, the ISP's security was lackadaisical, and the ISP would have to be responsible to a certain degree.
21:59But, as I mentioned earlier, the data that is taken is really of no use to a normal person,
22:08or to a normal hacker. So, minimal use. You know, the damage that it can possibly cause is minimal.
22:18So, a person can, I mean, if it has caused damage to the person, then he has that recourse,
22:24I think under Malaysian law, from what I know, to sue, to sue and say, look, by you allowing people to breach
22:33your data, I have lost X amount of dollars.
22:37You need to compensate me for that. So, I do believe, and I do believe MCMC has such
22:48watchdogs in place, where you can probably make the report to them, and then they will have to take
22:55action against the ISP or the licensee, and recover whatever losses that you have incurred because of that breach.
23:04Prof, if you look at the talks between the people, trust in data handling is already fragile.
23:13Beyond legal safeguards, what visible steps could MCMC take?
23:18Prof, if we're convinced Malaysians that this framework won't morph into unchecked surveillance.
23:31It's a difficult question. I really don't even know how to answer that.
23:36But then, as I said, oversight, right? You need a watchdog.
23:41So, that really becomes the role of the watchdog.
23:45And the watchdog can be within MCMC, or if they prefer it to be outside MCMC,
23:51it can be parked outside MCMC. But they are the ones that should be monitoring what is happening.
23:57And if something irregular happens, they need to raise the alarm.
24:05I think it's perfectly fine for people, for the public to suggest that such a watchdog be established.
24:12Prof, in the final minute, let's zoom out a bit. So, is this framework truly granting new powers,
24:19or is it simply bringing our legal toolbox up to speed with the digital world that's already here?
24:28If you're asking me my opinion, it is something that we really need to allow law enforcement officers to go after what is happening today.
24:36What is happening today? From what I see, the scams have gone beyond, you know, control today.
24:44And they are causing a lot of unhappiness and theft among our community.
24:52And it's amazing. I mean, even I can be scammed. The way they craft it is amazingly realistic, right?
25:02You get calls which you tend to respond to. And the people are being, you're basically being robbed.
25:11And then you go to the police station, you make a complaint. Even the police are stuck. What do they do, right?
25:16So, I believe that having as much, giving the law enforcement as much mandate, as much support
25:26as they can to curb this is very important today. So, if they feel that having this framework will help reduce
25:35and will help them bring such criminals to justice, then I strongly support this.
25:41Okay. Professor, thank you for your insight. That was Professor Sureswaran Ramadas, Chairman of APEC,
25:48IPv6 Council, and Cybersecurity Expert, sharing his thoughts on the proposed data retention framework
25:55and what it could mean for digital privacy, national security, and trust in our institutions.
26:01That's all for the episode on Agenda Awani. I'm Hamil Aiman. Thank you for watching, and good night.
26:06sure.
26:13You