- 1 hour ago
- #considerthis
The Government says it will reject applications for new manufacturing licences that perpetuate heavy reliance on low-skilled foreign labour. MITI Minister Johari Ghani says businesses must instead invest in automation, and limit foreign workers to Dirty, Dangerous and Difficult (3D) jobs. What would this mean for Malaysia’s labour landscape? Are we finally ready to change the way we create and compensate jobs? On this episode of #ConsiderThis Melisa Idris speaks with Professor Tan Sri Noor Azlan Ghazali, Director of UKM’s Malaysian Inclusive Development and Advancement Institute (MINDA-UKM).
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:10Hello and good evening, I'm Melissa Ingers. Welcome to Consider This.
00:14This is the show where we want you to consider and then reconsider what you know of the news of
00:18the day.
00:19The government has said that it will reject applications for new manufacturing licenses
00:24that perpetuate heavy reliance on low-skilled foreign workers.
00:28Mithi Minister Joharigani has said that businesses must instead invest in automation
00:34and limit foreign workers to 3D jobs or dirty, dangerous and difficult jobs.
00:41So what would this mean for Malaysia's labour landscape?
00:44Are we finally ready to change the way we create and compensate jobs?
00:50Tonight on the show, I have with me Professor Tan Sri Nur Azlan Ghazali
00:54who is the Director of UKM's Malaysian Inclusive Development and Advancement Institute,
00:59better known as Minda UKM.
01:01Prof, welcome to the show. Thank you so much for joining me.
01:04It's good to have you on the show talking about this.
01:07So when Joharigani says that no new manufacturing licenses for industries or for businesses
01:15that focus on heavy use of foreign labour, low-skilled foreign labour and when he says
01:21foreign workers should just be restricted to 3D jobs, two separate issues but I wanted to examine
01:27the economic rationale of this policy. Where do you come from?
01:31Well, now it's 2026, right? In 2006, 20 years ago, when I was at the National Economic Action Council
01:44in the 13th Malaysia Plan, 0.11, 0.34, I can even remember the page number, the same statement
01:52is out by the Prime Minister, that we would like to gradually reduce the number of foreign workers,
02:01meaning more towards the labour, you know, steadily so that we can get more job formulation and so on.
02:08At that point, I remember very well, I was there in the office, the number of foreign workforce
02:14is about 1 million and now it doubled after 20 years, right?
02:19So, for one thing, I really appreciate the statement. I mean, I'm glad that this subject
02:25appears again in the parliament as mentioned by Datuk S. Joharigani.
02:30I mean, broadly, I would strongly support for that but I still believe that that is not strong enough.
02:36Okay. Why do you say it's not strong enough?
02:39You know, I mean, because for example, like the common argument about why we need a foreign workforce,
02:46I think that is the most important thing. In many cases, everyone probably so used to say
02:53the 3D kind of dirty, dangerous, difficult, basically, kind of the main reason why we need all these people.
03:01You know, when people talk about 3D, dirty, they imagine like collecting garbage, you know,
03:07dangerous, like going to the high-rise construction, right?
03:11A difficult, maybe, something to do with more, not only dirty, dangerous, but it's difficult to do.
03:18The fact that all these jobs also appear in many other countries.
03:24I mean, there's 3D in America, there's 3D in Switzerland, there's 3D in Japan, Australia, in all countries.
03:32But their solution is not about bringing foreign workforce.
03:37Why is that Malaysia take that as a, like a well-justified reason to bring a foreign workforce in Malaysia?
03:47You know, the numbers that many heard about, probably they said that recently that there's some decline
03:52in numbers from 2.4 million to 2.19 million or something like that, right?
03:58Yeah, it was documented, but again, even honestly, without talking about those without permits,
04:05even at that numbers, I think, I seriously feel that there's something wrong about the policy framework that we have.
04:12Okay, so I wanted to challenge that, interrogate that narrative.
04:16There's a long-standing narrative that Malaysians simply will not do these jobs,
04:20because I guess there's, you know, in some countries, 3D has also expanded into 4D.
04:27So not just dirty, dangerous and difficult, but also sometimes demeaning or discriminatory.
04:31And there is a social stigma, a relationship between that and the wages and the working conditions
04:37and all of the other factors surrounding these types of jobs.
04:43Can we talk a little bit about that?
04:45Can you maybe talk to us whether or not this is fundamentally a wage problem?
04:51Is it true that Malaysians will not do this, therefore we need foreign workers?
04:55No, I seriously doubt about that.
04:56I mean, we know that every year, I mean, every morning,
05:00thousands of Malaysians are crossing the streets to Singapore, right?
05:03And doing these jobs.
05:04And doing their 3-day job.
05:05I mean, the point is, I think the idea that society look at this job as like,
05:11as you mentioned, demeaning, that thing and that,
05:14these are all excuses that come after the fact that, you know,
05:18I mean, the wages in these sectors are low, right?
05:23Trust me, if the wages goes up,
05:25I mean, I'm not trying to say that goes horribly up, but reasonably up.
05:30But I think that would be okay.
05:32I mean, there's no problem about doing that kind of work.
05:35I mean, and the stigma that we have that these are kind of a demeaning kind of job
05:39and it's like looking like you are so, I mean, being low profile and so on,
05:45it's totally wrong.
05:46It's totally wrong.
05:48I mean, fortunately, I had a chance of living abroad for quite some time, right?
05:52I remember looking from my apartment about how garbage are collected in Boston.
05:58And it's only one person working on it.
06:01He looked steady.
06:02He managed the garbage truck with a lot of technology with it.
06:06He don't even get out from the truck to pick up all the garbage, right?
06:10So it takes the society, know how to sort out their garbage and so on.
06:14And it takes the automations to do some of it.
06:17And they're okay.
06:19I mean, so that is what garbage collection is.
06:21And there's nothing dirty at all.
06:24So why is that in Malaysia, we are stuck with the idea that collecting garbage must be dirty.
06:31I mean, it is us, I think, probably need to change.
06:34It's a societal issue as well.
06:37So let's come back to what you mentioned, the fact that we've been talking about reducing reliance
06:42on low-skilled foreign labour for 20 years now.
06:46Why do you think we still haven't been able to get it right?
06:51Is Jogani's approach now in Miti the right approach to stop new licenses being issued?
06:58Yeah, I mean, the problem that we face now is not an initial problem.
07:02This is like a problem that has been there for years.
07:05As I mentioned, even in 2006, we started talking about it, right?
07:09So these are a bit deep-rooted in the society.
07:13Because the family argument is that, okay, if we take them out, then who will do the work?
07:18Right?
07:19Some will say that prices will go up, I mean, quite immediately.
07:23And we will be seeing like a lot of work, there's no one who wants to do it, and so
07:28on and so on.
07:29I think when the situation is as this bad, I mean, meaning that it has been long,
07:34the way to get out is not like an immediate abrupt something next year.
07:39We must have a clear committed plan, and we must be committed to what we laid out in our policy.
07:48For example, like in terms of restrictions of the sectors, and then there must be a clear exit.
07:55For example, that, okay, let's say, for example, a company basically got a permit to have foreign workers
08:02for whatever argument that they have.
08:04But you must have a clear exit plan, meaning that you cannot signal that you can last with this forever.
08:12So these are the kind of a plan of getting out.
08:15It's just like, you know, when someone had a severe disease or problems, and so on.
08:20So it has to be steady, but it must be a committed plan.
08:24So now we say it, so what's the plan?
08:26Do you see the plan in any of the rancangan Malaysia that we've had?
08:31I've not seen it clearly.
08:33Like this exit plan.
08:33I mean, yeah, I've not, that's the point.
08:35I mean, there is kind of a mother statement that we want to reduce that.
08:39But the problem is that, what's the plan?
08:42Where are they now?
08:43So the government has always touted automation as the way to move out of foreign labor intensive industries, right?
08:52So the idea is, invest in automation, and then you will see higher productivity,
08:56and you can pay your workers more.
08:58Is that the solution?
08:59Is that the silver bullet?
09:00It is a solution, but the problem is that, I mean, for employers, they always have the options.
09:05So long that they have an option of bringing 10 foreign workers, where should I invest in machineries?
09:12Sometimes back, I can't remember exactly, there are programs that government introduced,
09:16where especially the SMEs, you know, they can get some grant for automation.
09:21But I was told that then, that the take-up for the grant is very low.
09:26No one is interested in it.
09:28So there must be a bit more push factor.
09:30That's why what I'm saying earlier is that there must be some, like, a clear deadline of how we want
09:36to reduce it.
09:36So you have to tie that with the permission of you able to bring 10 workers,
09:42but you've got five years to get out of it.
09:44After that, no more.
09:45Then you have to do some push factor.
09:48And of course, you can facilitate them to get automation and so on.
09:53Monitor that.
09:53I mean, we cannot have that kind of policy that we're taking for granted that people will just adjust, you
10:00know, themselves.
10:01It can't be done like that.
10:02Talk to me about the thinking or the economic rationale of automation versus low-skilled foreign workers.
10:10Why would businesses choose foreign labour over automation?
10:14And who benefits from automation?
10:17Because I think about the employee as well, right?
10:19We have a challenge here, you know.
10:20Now, when we talk about our economy, many are not realizing that our economy is very much small and medium
10:29enterprise plus a micro enterprise as well, right?
10:32Concentrated.
10:3398% of our enterprises are in this class.
10:36Now, let's look at this class.
10:38I mean, they employ maybe about around, nearly maybe around 50% of Malaysian workforce.
10:44So what do they do?
10:46Are they involved in the more sophisticated activities?
10:49Are they sending out exports our products?
10:52Let's say if I'm the exporter, right?
10:55And if I go a bigger scale, I mean, I need to fulfill standard in the country, destination that I'm
11:00sending my products.
11:01I need automation.
11:02I need quality.
11:03I need standard, international standard and so on.
11:06But we know that the participation of our enterprises in the global market are very low, right?
11:12Though we are among the largest exporter in the world, but only about 12% of our exports are coming
11:19from the larger employer, which is the micro, small, medium enterprises.
11:23So the need for them is not there.
11:25I mean, they are serving a local market.
11:27It would take even more smaller enterprise, micro enterprises.
11:32Sometimes their product probably only cross for five states or maybe the most is that the whole peninsula.
11:38But you look at the market that we serve, right?
11:42That's why there are things that we produce, there are products that we produce sometimes cannot enter the market abroad,
11:50especially in a more advanced country, because of all these requirements.
11:54I mean, you need to abide to strong, strict labor law.
11:59You can't just keep on thinking that you can produce something cheap.
12:03Cheap is not the game.
12:05But I think much of our enterprises are basically cheap is what they are aiming for.
12:11Yeah, I think this is a serious, I would say, it's not an easy solution, but it's a complex situation
12:17in the country.
12:18Cheap products would also mean low costs, which also translates to lower wages for workers.
12:25Yeah, and I think when they employ foreign wages, sorry to say this, I think, sorry, I mean, I must
12:30say, I think the way we look at it beyond the work that they do, but if we look at
12:34the social side of it, how do they live, where do they live, how do we treat them, the hours
12:39of their working hours and so on.
12:41I think it's a bit more dangerous of workers, it comes close to, I mean, like, I don't want to
12:48use this word, but it's more like a slavery kind of thing, which I don't really feel good, because I
12:53think we all can see how, I mean, they live.
12:56I mean, in some countries, like even in the advanced nation, I mean, if you go to the US, there
13:00are a lot of foreign workers as well.
13:02I mean, yes, foreign workers do the lawn and do the more difficult work, but the standard that they put
13:09is very different.
13:10So, if, let's say, if I work in a factory or if I work as a garbage collector in the
13:19US, I have to go with their standards, right?
13:22I can't bring my standards to their country, but probably not in Malaysia.
13:28Is it because we don't have a strong culture of unions and collective bargaining?
13:34So, yeah, I mean, on one side, definitely, I mean, it's not them because they are foreign workers.
13:41I mean, because they are workers, their so-called welfare side, their safety side.
13:48You know, sometimes you see that foreign workers are doing a very dangerous job without proper safety.
13:54You know, we seem to accept the idea that, yeah, if it is dangerous, it means risky, chances of death
14:02or accidents is there, or give it to the foreign workers.
14:05Why is that?
14:06Why are we taking foreign workers as the right, portable men to be victim for dangerous work?
14:13We should give that assurance of safety to whoever working in Malaysia or foreign workforce.
14:18So, if we continue with this kind of working environment, then definitely foreign workforce will be cheap and probably will
14:27take as much risk because to them, what most important is that to earn as much and send to their
14:32parents and so on.
14:33So, we will continue stuck with this.
14:36So, it's not just automation.
14:38It's also come from the labor law.
14:40There's no one protecting them.
14:41I mean, well, in the right sense of labor's requirement and so on.
14:46Yeah, safety, workplace safety and welfare, right?
14:50Yeah, hours of, you know, I mean, they need some rest as well.
14:52They are human.
14:53Yeah, who's looking out for their welfare?
14:55So, talk to me, Prof, about how we think about this with the pushback coming from businesses.
15:01Businesses say that, you know, to remain competitive, we need to keep our costs low.
15:07And when they need, then they push or they push back against the limits of foreign workers, saying that local
15:15workers will not want to do these jobs.
15:18What do you say to that narrative, to that rationale?
15:21The first and foremost is that to remain competitive, you keep the price low is totally wrong.
15:29I mean, if you want to be competitive, it is not about price.
15:33I mean, the more expensive the product sometimes also reflects how good they are, right?
15:39So, the idea of keeping it low, I said that many times in some other program that it broadly, Malaysians
15:46are addicted to cheap.
15:49You know, we love something which is cheap or the extreme is free.
15:53So, in all aspects, the society, the government, the industries, everybody seems to come together, let's make it the cheapest
16:01possible.
16:01I think that is probably one of a major problem and failures in terms of assumption how to be competitive.
16:09Let's look at the other side of the coin, is that what we want cheap, but also because we're not
16:15paid enough.
16:16So, there's this argument that Malaysia workers are underpaid, that our wages are low.
16:24Can I ask you what evidence supports that?
16:28Long noon, long noon.
16:30How do we know? What evidence is there that we have determined that Malaysia workers are underpaid?
16:36Well, seriously underpaid, you know.
16:39Now, if you look at the reports of wages and salary, now the DOSOM released this report quite frequently.
16:46The latest that I've seen, for example, they will report, like, they focus on the formal sectors.
16:51There are about 10 million workers in the formal sectors, right?
16:57So, 10 million, if you cut in the middle, it's 5 million, 5 million, right?
17:03So, let's ask, what is the median wages the workers get?
17:09It's about 3,000 ringgit.
17:11So, meaning, median means in the middle.
17:15It means that 5 million of the 10 million workforce is earning below 3,000.
17:22That's enough to tell me something is wrong.
17:24It's heavily skewed downward.
17:26You know, in Malaysia, if you earn in the class of 7,000 to almost 8,000 ringgit, maybe slightly
17:32closer to 8,000 ringgit, you are already top 20.
17:35T20.
17:36So, don't ever imagine top 20 is the one with all the luxurious lifestyle.
17:41So, using the median wage at 3,000 ringgit, where half of Malaysians earn less than 3,000.
17:48In the formal workforce.
17:49In the formal workforce, yes.
17:51We yet to look into the informal sector, which is quite big themselves.
17:56Absolutely.
17:57Okay.
17:57So, what is your assessment of Malaysia's low wage problem?
18:02What have been the causes of it?
18:04Well, I mean, for one thing, I mean, what we have discussed earlier, basically, that the orientation want to keep
18:10it cheap, right?
18:12There is no motivation of going abroad, meeting higher standards that requires more automations.
18:20And possibly also the lack of policies that would allow you to do it.
18:25And pretty much you can do it.
18:28I mean, I remember that when I was there at Economic Action Council, during the COVID time, you know that
18:36since 1990, since 1990, 30 years, I have the charts with me.
18:41That's the only episode where you see the decline in foreign workforce.
18:46If not, it would be increased every year.
18:49If I may quote the number, 2.3 million, it goes to 1.66 million.
18:54You know, when I was there, I was thinking that, wow, this crisis is good in the sense that it
18:59brings down foreign workforce.
19:01And we thought that would be a good trending downward.
19:05At the same time, there are digitalizations and all sorts of things, right?
19:09Probably then people talk about automation and so on.
19:11But unfortunately, it reversed back again to 2.4.
19:15Of course, now they say reduced a bit by a few hundred thousands.
19:18But I yet to see the trend downward.
19:20I think with the nation being flooded by foreign workforce, I will say that if it is not number one,
19:32it will be at my top three that will assure whether Malaysia can move forward or not.
19:40I mean, if we really want to be an advanced nation, high-income nation, all the sorts of things.
19:46If you read the NIMP 2030, right, the new industrial master plan, what is that?
19:51A complexity of industries, high-skilled workforce and all sorts of advancement that we see in the high growth, high
20:00value, the 30th miniature plan.
20:01And if these problems are not attended, trust me, we will not be able to reach them.
20:06Okay, so you say foreign workers is one of the three main reasons for you.
20:11What are the other two?
20:12Well, of course, I mean, maybe if we take PM side, it's about the so-called governance issues and so
20:19on.
20:19I will take that as something very serious as well.
20:22But that alone will not do it because you need to address the real situations on the ground there.
20:28And the other one is about education, trainings and so on.
20:32Okay, so let's talk about one of the reasons for the low-wage problem in Malaysia, you say, is education.
20:39And I wanted to talk to you about that because I think we have huge, one-third of tertiary educated
20:45workers are under-employed.
20:47Under-employed, yeah.
20:47In jobs that don't match their skills.
20:51A lot of this has been framed as a skills mismatch problem, as a generalist degree problem.
20:58What are you thinking?
21:00What does it tell us about the quality of the jobs that we are producing?
21:03On one side, let's not deny there are challenges and problems in terms of producing the right quality, right?
21:10There's a problem that I agree with that.
21:12I mean, it resides in some of the institutions that I'm very familiar with, right?
21:16So there's a problem there.
21:18But we can talk about that later.
21:20But on the other side, there's a demand side.
21:22You know, while you heard about there's not enough engineers, there's not enough scientists and so on, let's talk about
21:30what the kind of jobs that we have in our economy.
21:3330% of our jobs, if you look through the MASCO's criteria, are considered high-skilled jobs.
21:40Only 30%?
21:41Only 30%.
21:42But how many are they created?
21:44You know, if you look at the World Bank's Malaysian Economic Motoring, April 2026, they show that the number of
21:52graduates that we produce, of course, we can challenge the quality, right?
21:55But it cannot be all the 300,000 are useless, right?
21:59So 300,000 plus.
22:00But the number of vacancies that requires this kind of talent is only not more than 50,000.
22:09These are the numbers reported.
22:11I mean, these are official numbers.
22:13Job creations in the high-skilled workforce is declining.
22:18And simultaneously, you know that there are about 1.9 million Malaysians living abroad, the so-called diaspora, right?
22:27Of course, not all of them are moving out because of the job per se.
22:30But in the report, this is a World Bank report, right?
22:35About half of that, or slightly more than half of 1.8, maybe around 900,000 Malaysians who are working
22:42abroad, are working in the high-skilled job and the semi-skilled job.
22:46Okay, let's take half of it, right?
22:48400,000 of high-skilled Malaysians are working abroad.
22:52And in the country, we say that there's not enough talent.
22:57So what is the problem?
22:59So it's not a talent problem, it's a jobs problem.
23:02Though yes, we do have room to improve the quality of talents.
23:06But even if you take stock of today, if there are about, my very kind of minimal estimate, 400,000
23:14Malaysian talents who fill up the skilled job abroad.
23:21You don't know how many people are unemployed today in Malaysia?
23:25400,000, 409,000.
23:28And that cut across all layers of skill.
23:31And we have 400,000 skilled workforce Malaysians working abroad.
23:36Okay, well in the time that we have left, Prof, I have to ask you.
23:39So I don't want to, in 20 years, be asking you why we have the same problem still.
23:45So what have you seen?
23:47What's the one thing you've seen that shows you that perhaps we are on the right trajectory?
23:52That what should I be keeping my eye on to make sure that we're not going to be talking about
23:58this 10, 20 years down the road?
24:00All the documented launch plan, I love it.
24:05The wording are nice, description are nice, vision are fantastic, the jargon is very sophisticated.
24:13Some of them I'm involved with.
24:15What I hope, Malaysia's problem is truly, it's not that we do not know what to do.
24:20We know our problem, we know what need to do.
24:23And we laid that out in our plan.
24:25But our challenge is to commit to the plan and execute it well.
24:30Commitment meaning that, is this political will or is this business lobby?
24:36Well, I mean, of course, one is about the government doing it, committed to that, regardless of political siding or
24:44whatsoever.
24:45But at the same time, the industries have to also to come forward.
24:48And not only that, the society even, who love foreign workforce a lot.
24:52I mean, so all three parties have to come together, agree what we want to do and move forward.
24:58And get Malaysia to move forward, solve all that many problems that are related to the influx of foreign workforce.
25:05We just have to commit to what we've put on paper.
25:08And please report, I mean, and if I may, create an independent council, non-governmental maybe, to come out and
25:17say,
25:17okay, this is the plan, you give the plan, okay, we agree with it and we monitor that and report
25:23that.
25:23It has to be independent.
25:24I love to be in that committee.
25:26All right, well, I hope to see that as a development in the future.
25:29Thank you so much for being on the show.
25:31I appreciate your insights.
25:32That's all the time we have for you on this episode of Consider This.
25:35I'm Melissa Idris signing off for the evening.
25:37Thank you so much for watching and good night.
25:54I'll see you next time.