Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 1 year ago
Malaysia welcomed 20.1 million tourists in 2023, and hotel occupancy has bounced back to over 62% since pandemic lockdowns — but behind the glossy exteriors, many hotel owners are barely breaking even.
Why?

Because long-term contracts, rising costs, and vague ESG requirements are quietly eroding investment value.

Dr. Timmy Ho of Pragmatique discusses how hotel asset management (HAM) can help owners regain financial control and ensure sustainable returns.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Hello and welcome to Niaga Spotlight with me Tamina Kaosji. Niaga Spotlight takes us through
00:12the week in economic analysis and future affairs. Now this week on future affairs we're spotlighting
00:17the topic of unlocking hidden value in hotel investments. Now Malaysia's hospitality industry
00:23for a little bit of context is back in full swing. Tourist arrivals surged to 20.1 million
00:29in 2023 up 100.4% from 2022 which of course were the pandemic lockdown years and now hotel occupancy
00:37is averaging 62.7% especially across key destinations. This includes Kuala Lumpur, Langkawi and Penang.
00:45Now despite this boom many hotel owners are seeing underwhelming returns. Well why is that? That is
00:52due to a quiet crisis plaguing Malaysia's hospitality sector which is mismanaged hotel assets. Now
00:59here's what every hotel owner needs to know. Profit on paper doesn't mean power. Many are locked into
01:0520-year contracts that limit control over pricing, vendors, even sustainability decisions. And while
01:12operators love metrics like occupancy and revpar, owners need to look a little bit deeper to see
01:17the real returns. And also with new ESG rules from Bursa Malaysia enforced, hotel owners could be facing
01:23up to 2 million ringgit in unplanned capital expenses over five years just to remain compliant. The
01:30solution? Asset management. It's the only way to future proof your investment from picking the right
01:35green standards to making sure every contract works for you, not against you. Now with Malaysia
01:41targeting 26.1 million tourist arrivals by 2026, the competition will intensify. But so will operational
01:49complexity, ESG obligations and regulatory scrutiny. So hotel asset management or HAM is no longer a
01:57luxury. It's a necessity for investment preservation, regulatory compliance and green growth. Today's
02:04timely discussion about HAM, long neglected in Southeast Asia, is absolutely the missing piece in protecting
02:10long-term hotel investment value. It's a pleasure now to welcome Dr. Timmy Ho, Managing Director of
02:16Pragmatic to Niagara Spotlight to get further into this very critical discussion. Dr. Timmy, a very good
02:23morning. How are you doing today? I'm fantastic. Thank you, Tamina. Fantastic. So Dr. Timmy, let's get
02:28started off. Now you of course come with about 20 years of regional experience in the arena of HAM or
02:35hotel asset management. Let's first of all get the conversation started by looking at misleading metrics
02:41in hotel performance. Now in your opinion, hotel profitability is really often framed in terms of
02:47occupancy, brand equity, right? Those are the main bayard sticks which everyone is concerned about from
02:53the owner's perspective. But isn't that slightly misleading when we look at today's really capital
03:00intensive market? I think you're absolutely right. They are part of the picture but they're not the whole
03:08picture. Occupancy itself is a very relative term. It simply denotes how many rooms in a particular
03:16hotel is occupied on a daily basis. Exactly. And on its own, it carries very little meaning. So when
03:25people ask me, is 50% occupancy good? I would say it depends. If the rest of the market is doing 40%,
03:32then 50% is fantastic. Fair enough, fair enough. Exactly, exactly. And in terms of brand, brand equity,
03:38what it actually is, it's also market-dependent. In very, very popular tourist destinations
03:46or trade centres, a rising tide raises all shapes. So whether you're branded, independent or an
03:56unaffiliated hotel, due to overwhelming demand in that location, all hotels will generally do well.
04:05However, when it comes to very competitive markets, it's where the brand, it denotes the operating
04:16history, it denotes the trading experience of the hotel. So it allows new hotels to gain instant
04:26recognition. And this is what investors and lenders enjoy, the confidence that the property is able
04:33to generate returns. Exactly. That's the advantage. And also, I think an excellent example of such a
04:40centre would perhaps be Kuala Lumpur's Golden Triangle area. So because of the overabundance of
04:46not just tourist attractions, but at the same time centrality, then how would you say hotel owners
04:53should maybe recalibrate their definition of metrics, especially in this post-pandemic hospitality rebound?
05:02The pandemic itself demonstrated how vulnerable the hospitality industry is. Speaking from experience,
05:11most hotel properties only had cash capital reserves or cash floats sufficient for about two months of
05:18operating expenses. So without any... Real reality check, yeah. Exactly. You know, so they couldn't sustain
05:24beyond a couple of months of operations. And unfortunately, a lot of hotels, they had to shut down during
05:29that period. Now, so prior to the pandemic, the focus was, as you have mentioned in the preamble, a lot on
05:38profit, a lot on the top-line metrics, the average room rates. However, that profit does not equate to value.
05:51So profit may not be sufficient to pay the mortgages, it may not be sufficient to give the required rate of
05:59return to the investors. So prior to the pandemic, the focus was very much on profit. However, after the
06:07pandemic, non-accounting terms, profit is an accounting term. So non-accounting terms, things like risk-adjusted
06:14return, inflation, extraordinary inflation, opportunity cost, the weighted average cost of
06:20capital, people were borrowing at ridiculously high rates prior to the pandemic, and all that has
06:26changed. So people are looking at more towards value, specifically investment value in the post-pandemic
06:32world. Exactly. And of course, when you mentioned accelerated costs, hotel construction costs alone
06:38have gone up by 20 to 25 percent, depending on where you're looking at and what exact building
06:43material. Very well noted, Dr. Timmy. So now going into the fact that asset management is quite often
06:51viewed as a privilege rather than a norm. Let's break that myth. And also looking at the fact that
06:57Malaysia has a rather fragmented hotel ownership landscape. There are quite a lot of properties
07:03which are still owned by and run by family or also first generation investors. So let's talk about
07:11that. And what gaps do you see over there? So to clarify, hotel asset management generally has a
07:18single principle, which is to maximize the value of the asset. Now, and when it comes to investors or
07:27hotel owners in Malaysia, there are two different distinct groups, actually. One is, of course,
07:36the institutional investors. Right. And they are fairly data-driven. They rely on numbers and figures
07:45because they have all the different boards. And they always have. So you don't really need to
07:48encourage that sector. Right. Absolutely. So they might not have what they term officially as hotel
07:54asset management. Understood. But they do have a form of it in one way or another. Now, it's a private
07:59investor group, which is a really, really mixed bag. So as you say, a lot of them are first generation
08:08hotel owner, first time hotel owners, and sometimes family business. And as such, they operate very
08:15heuristically, in a very human manner. And unfortunately, being human, it tends to introduce
08:23emotionally driven decisions and a lot of bias. So the kind of bias, in fact, it could be recency
08:31effect. It could be due to hearsay. So this kind of thing affects the decision making.
08:38So they are actually exposed to potential financial missteps due to the humanisation of the business.
08:44The human way of making decisions. I understand. Absolutely. Yeah. So sometimes they have a big
08:51pride, which alone by itself is fine. And they have, unfortunately, sometimes ignorance, which alone
08:58by itself, people who are ignorant, like myself sometimes, I tell myself, I want to learn.
09:02I walk into every room with a mindset that I want to learn. But if you combine pride and
09:07ignorance together, they become agnostic. They become a bit like ostriches. And they refuse
09:13to accept the reality of the market. They refuse to take outside perspectives. So that's where
09:19the equity gap really is. It's not that they can't access professional asset management.
09:25It's that they might not want to. Understood. And of course, that actually hinders their equitable
09:31participation in the hospitality economy. And considering the fact that about more than 80%
09:37of Malaysian hotels are actually independently owned, often by SMEs or family businesses. I think that's
09:43a huge gap in knowledge. So Dr. Timmy, moving on quickly into a really, really current topic.
09:49We hear it all the time. Now let's apply it to HEM. Let's talk ESG as a cost centre versus
09:55a value driver. And the kind of shifts that we've talked about when we look at green buildings,
10:01right? But let's be honest, in a climate of really razor thin margins, particularly when
10:06it comes to hotel operation. So how often is the sustainable hotel just a tagline rather
10:12than something which will actually deliver returns for the business owners?
10:17Now, Tamina, I think I might disappoint you and the viewers today. I would love to jump on
10:24the greenwashing bandwagon and say that, oh, you know, it's a PR exercise.
10:28No, please don't actually. Give us your expertise.
10:30No. In actual fact, that properly implemented ESG programmes generally almost always pays off
10:40if implemented properly. What people don't see is that the results are not always tangible.
10:47And the results might not be immediate or it might not be always tangible.
10:52So maybe they don't have the tools or the frameworks. What kind of tools or frameworks
10:56have you seen that actually help hotel owners to track and then, you know, document the actual
11:03value properly implemented ESG is bringing in?
11:06So the idea of ESG, what is currently really focused on right now is the E, the environment
11:15killer where a lot of the green tech comes in. So that's where the capital expenditures are.
11:23So when we're talking about that, without jargon, we are looking at the payback period of acquiring
11:30and implementing the green technology versus the investment horizon, which ties back to
11:36the owner strategy. So you have owners like YTL, Sunway and Berjaya, they are lifelong owners.
11:42You never hear of them selling off their hotel assets. But on the other hand, you have owners
11:48which sometimes they just happen to have a hotel in a mixed development and their investment horizon
11:53might be maybe a five-year period to tie in with the RPGT. So sometimes we have to look at the E period,
12:02the payback period for the green tech against their holding period, whether it fits into the strategy.
12:08But that's only when it comes to green technology, the E pillar. So let's not forget the social
12:13and governance pillar. Some of these initiatives under the governance and social pillar cost almost
12:21nothing to implement. How much does it cost to get to have female representation in the board of directors?
12:29You don't need a special chair for that. Not at all. You just need to ensure that the right talent is being
12:34recognised. Exactly. So more diversity, more inclusion. So what I'm saying is that let's not ignore the social
12:43and governance pillar. They cost almost nothing to implement, but they rate very highly in terms of credit scoring,
12:49in terms of company ratings, in terms of ESG ratings. They cost very low to implement and should not be ignored.
12:57Exactly.
12:58So we compare the, in more financial terms, we use what we call a DCF-BCA, a benefit cost analysis using
13:07discounted cash flow. We use systemic financial modelling and also a bit of a MCDA,
13:13a multi-creative decision analysis to weigh whether it's worth implementing certain initiatives or not.
13:20Exactly. Because certain initiatives such as green certifications like LEED or green RE,
13:25they can actually cost anywhere between 7% to 12% of your CAPEX. And here you are, you know,
13:30sharing the traits, the secret of HAM with the fact that when you look at S and G pillars,
13:35they can actually be already obtained within the structures of an existing company. Thanks very much
13:41for the conversation so far, Dr. Simi. It's most interesting to actually pick out and, you know,
13:46bust the myths, but at the same time also flip the script on some of these conversations we've been
13:50having. Thank you. Well, don't go anywhere. We'll be right back with Niaga Spotlight, still
13:55focusing on unlocking hotel investments with me, Tamina Kausji. See you in a while.
14:05Welcome back to Niaga Spotlight, still with me, Tamina Kausji. And today we're focusing on
14:17unlocking value in hotel investments with Dr. Timmy Ho, Managing Director of Pragmatik. So,
14:23Dr. Timmy, getting back into the conversation and looking at ESG regulatory alignment in the
14:29Malaysian context, tell me a little bit more about the way in which it has been received with Bursa
14:34Malaysia, of course, now tightening sustainability disclosures. So, are hotel owners being in that
14:40sense also pushed more into compliance strategies that weren't necessarily designed with hospitality
14:47realities in mind? Your thoughts? Traditionally, tourism itself as a whole was once thought of as an
14:57anti-thesis towards sustainability. The idea of people flying hundreds of miles across the oceans,
15:05burning up all the fuels. Indulging in every sense of the word. Exactly. So, that itself was very much
15:14against the idea of going green. However, people don't realise that hotels are actually providing gainful
15:20employment. They are serving the community around them and they are in a way contributing to the economy
15:25as well. So, if you look at it from a circular perspective, it does benefit the world as a whole.
15:32Now, when, and yes, Bursa has, ever since Bursa mandated sustainability statements to be included
15:41in annual reporting, when they lay up to it, the official Gazette was out last year, I believe, a lot of
15:49companies were still rushing to prepare. They, they were, they needed to, to obtain sustainability
15:57reporting offices. That's correct. Or sustainability offices in general, and there wasn't sufficient
16:02talent pool. There were not any dedicated courses towards sustainability or reporting for the matter.
16:08And so, what they did was, they tried to tap on what they, what they actually wanted was a journalist
16:13such as yourself. But like journalists like yourself, very well paid, you're very happy where you are.
16:18So, they couldn't get that many journalists. So, they went for the next group, being a lot of
16:24communications and marketing people. And unfortunately…
16:27But having to actually change their toolkit of skill set, it takes a bit of time, right?
16:32Exactly. They were not prepared. And in a way, what that has resulted in the early batches of
16:38hotel disclosures, hotel sustainability disclosures, they resulted in very loose and immaterial metrics.
16:46So, if a hotel owner says, oh, my building is double volume ballrooms and triple volume
16:54lobbies. So, I'm going to measure kilowatt per hour, kilowatt hours per square cube volume. And another,
17:02another hotel owner goes, oh, my, my, my hotel is next to a mall. So, I'm going to measure
17:06kilowatt hour per footfall. So, there are so many loose metrics. And that goes against the idea of
17:14having standards to allow comparison, easy comparability.
17:18Exactly. Because that actually prevents owners from then perhaps investing in
17:24unregulated ESG metrics, which may not necessarily be relevant to the hospitality industry per se.
17:29Absolutely.
17:30So, let's move along quickly from there into looking at another very interesting arena for
17:35HAM, Dr. Timmy. Let's talk structural power imbalances when it comes to operator contracts.
17:41Now, generally, also, it is true that owners are often the most unprotected party in hotel deals.
17:48So, in what way are long-term operator agreements structurally stacked against owner interests?
17:55Let's break it down. And also, how do owners then renegotiate or look at a fairer deal for themselves?
18:02Well, the basis, the foundation between an asset owner who owns the building and the brand, the hotel chain,
18:09which operates the property and places the brand on the building, the foundational agreement is generally called the HMA,
18:17the hotel management agreement. And studies have indicated there are 50 terms clauses to negotiate inside.
18:26And they largely fall across three categories. The first is what we call the explicit category.
18:32These are mostly negative commoners, which prevents the owner from doing certain things, seeking certain
18:37financing and such. So, these are explicitly stated. And the hotel chains do expect the owners to catch them
18:45and negotiate on them immediately. But sometimes one or two slip through. It's to the advantage of the chain.
18:50The next one is implicit terms. What sounds very innocent, sounds to the benefit of the owner,
18:56but actually has very serious implications and ramifications.
19:00Very simple example. The objective of the operation is to maximize revenue. Who doesn't love that?
19:07Every hotel owner loves that. But unfortunately, revenue is not paying your mortgages.
19:12Revenue is not paying your shareholders. So, they don't talk much about profit.
19:18So, these kind of innocent clauses, that's where it really catches some of the owners.
19:23And the third and the worst type is what we call the omitted clauses.
19:28Ah, interesting. Generally, a legal agreement should cover every eventuality, every plausibility.
19:35However, it's a very bad practice, but it happens that certain clauses are not placed in.
19:39So, you will find clauses, the commonly missing clauses are termination clauses.
19:44It allows the impression that the agreement can never be terminated.
19:48And if... For perpetuity in that sense.
19:50Exactly. Right.
19:52And until the end of the tenure, actually. So, having a legal expert, having a lawyer,
19:57review, the agreement may be sound legally, may be worded...
20:02Legalistically true.
20:03Correct. Accurate.
20:04Correct. But commercially, a lawyer would not be able to negotiate on the agreement.
20:08I understood. Also considering the fact that in general, such agreements, HMAs,
20:13are at least 15 to 25 years in nature.
20:15Yeah. Since some 30 years, there are indications that some have gone up to even 50 years.
20:21I understood. So, that could actually entrap the owners.
20:24Let's actually now shift the focus, Dr. Timmy, to looking at government-linked investments and
20:29white elephant risks. Now, on the positive side of things, Malaysia has a lot of state-driven
20:35pushes for more tourism-linked infrastructure. This is particularly for our second-tier cities.
20:41Let's look at maybe Kota Kinabalu in Sabah. There's also, for example, Johor Bahru.
20:45There's Malacca. So, how should maybe GLCs or state investment arms rethink their approach to hotel
20:52ownership, especially so that we can avoid these sort of white elephant infrastructure risks,
20:57which can very quickly stack up, particularly given the brand-new frameworks that you also have
21:02to comply with, ESG being just one of them.
21:04Exactly. Well, the government generally owns, we will talk about state-owned tourist attractions
21:10and hotels slightly separately. So, hotels itself, government owns either directly via their GLCs,
21:15such as Kazana, PNB, Felda, Tabonghaji, and indirectly via the GLICs, which are mostly KWOSP and Coop.
21:26So, focusing on direct ownership, we need to understand the objectives and the strategy of these
21:31GLCs. So, Kazana is pretty straightforward. They are out to make money. They are out to return
21:38investment to the government. To the best possible.
21:42Exactly. But we look at cases like Tabonghaji, with their Muslim-friendly hotels, and we look at Felda.
21:51They develop everywhere, except in main centres. They are off the beaten path. So, their objective,
21:58their strategy objective, you can observe, they are not really out to make money. Sometimes I believe
22:04that they are providing a purpose, a civic purpose, a civic sense of pride to their investors, to their
22:11unique holders. And ensuring that much lesser-known hubs in Malaysia also have the available hospitality
22:17facilities. Exactly. But sometimes they end up as white elephants, and that's where asset management
22:22comes in. I'm not saying to replace their main objective, but to support, to complement their main
22:27objective by maximising the value of the assets they have there. So, sometimes they can reposition,
22:32they can do reinvestment, and sometimes maybe even divest or dispose of the asset to pursue other
22:39objectives. So, when it comes to state-team attractions, yes, I think asset management can help.
22:46These are traditionally viewed as cost centres. How does a beach, a public beach, generate revenue?
22:52Or a set-park? They are not expected. They are expected to incur costs. But you can shift the
22:57mindset from being a cost centre into a demand generator. When I say demand, it grows the demand
23:04for hotels and rooms around these attractions. So, it's a circular economy. So, the more hotels
23:12that are occupied, the more revenue goes back to IRBs, LHDNs, coffers, and it's better to support the
23:20growth of the attraction. So, I think a mindset shift is really required in that aspect.
23:26Absolutely. And just to close out the conversation and so far, Dr Timmy, so of course, in the region,
23:32not just in Malaysia, but in ASEAN, hotel investments are quite often seen as prestige assets,
23:37not always a performance one. So, how do we ultimately, some final thoughts on shifting
23:42mindsets so that data, not just aesthetics, are driving decision-making for hotel owners?
23:48Well, I wish I knew how to do that. Because unfortunately, the rationale behind owning hotels
23:54has not always been about making profit. It's easy to calculate value and profit, but it's very much
24:01harder to understand the other rationale. So, some do it out of, as I mentioned earlier, civic pride.
24:09Sometimes, it's done out of emotional to be a trophy asset. Sometimes, it's just there to be a
24:15supporting component to a mixed development. And sometimes, people become hotel owners out of
24:22coincidence. A lot of lenders during the pandemic, they went into equity position.
24:28Correct. And that ownership passed on to whoever was able to take it on.
24:32Exactly. So, it's very difficult to change the mindset. So, what we do is, generally,
24:39we take a wider perspective. We don't take a silo mentality. We don't see every problem as a nail
24:44and use a hammer to apply. So, we need to understand the problem. And on the owner's part,
24:50they need to acknowledge that their hotels are having problems. They are not making the best use of
24:55the asset. And that's where the consultation process begins. Unfortunately…
24:59Dr. Timmy, thank you very much for the insights. And so far, such an interesting discussion.
25:05Now, in conclusion, of course, hotel ownership isn't just about breaks, brands or bookings. It's about
25:09strategy, oversight and protecting long-term value. As ESG compliance is tightening and margins are
25:15shrinking, asset management is no longer optional. It's essential. The solution? Owners must get involved
25:21earlier. Demand data transparency and treat performance like policy. Deliberate, accountable,
25:28as well as future ready. That's all we have time for today on Nyaga Spotlight with me,
25:32Tamina Khosji, featuring Dr. Timmy Ho, Managing Director with Pragmatic. We'll see you again next
25:37week with more economic analysis and insights. Here's to a productive week ahead.

Recommended