• 2 years ago

Visit our website:
http://www.france24.com

Like us on Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/FRANCE24.English

Follow us on Twitter:
https://twitter.com/France24_en

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00UNESCO insists that being placed on its list of endangered sites isn't a black mark but some of
00:06those facing the prospect of being added to the list are fiercely opposed to their possible inclusion
00:12among them Venice, Stonehenge and Australia's Great Barrier Reef. The battle is set to play
00:17out in New Delhi where UNESCO diplomats are meeting from this Sunday. To discuss we're
00:24joined now by Maria Gravari Barbast, Chair of the UNESCO Culture, Tourism and Development Research
00:31Programme at the Sorbonne University here in Paris. Thank you so much for being with us on
00:36the programme. Firstly just tell us who is currently on this UNESCO list of endangered
00:43sites and why do cities like Venice not want to be included? The endangered list for
00:50today 56 sites which are in mostly in the big south we would say 20 out of these 56 sites are
01:02located in Africa and 16 are located in the middle and near east. Few sites are in the endangered
01:11list are located in Europe and in fact the European and Western more generally states
01:17react against the inscription on the list which as you said is not a black mark on the opposite
01:23I mean it's not a disgrace for a state, it's not a punishment for the state party. It is in fact
01:30a way to attract the attention of the international community to the endangered site. However
01:38for western sites it is considered as if the side the state party did not give the necessary
01:47attention to the site and the opposite of some sites in the south which are facing major wars
01:56geopolitical conflicts in most cases in Europe the endangered list includes sites where the
02:04state parties did not take the necessary measures in order to protect them and this
02:10is typically the case of Venice because Venice was threatened last year in July 2023 from the
02:17inscription on the endangered list. Finally this was avoided because at the very last moment I mean
02:24during the discussions with UNESCO the Italian state decided and the city of Venice they decided
02:31to in fact introduce on a kind of trial basis a tax of five measures of five euros which is
02:38nothing in fact it's a very how can I say symbolic in fact a measure so starting from 2024 and
02:46onwards. This is supposed in fact to concern only day trippers in order to discourage people who
02:53come to Venice only for one day. But we can understand why Italy does not want Venice
03:00on the UNESCO list because we know that during the last years Italy and the city of Venice clearly
03:07did not take the necessary measures to fight against over tourism or against the Aqua Alta
03:14this problem Venice faces until decades. And this is also the case for Stonehenge that you mentioned
03:22before because in Stonehenge also is the state party that envisages to create a road tunnel
03:32located only 220 meters from the property from Stonehenge 220 meters and of course all the
03:41experts they understand that this is really problematic for the protection of the site.
03:46They consider that half a million of archaeological in fact remains can be destroyed
03:53by this tunnel that UK wants to build in order in fact to organize the landscape around
04:01Stonehenge because for the moment in fact the road is visible from the site and also in order
04:08to fluidify the access. And this is also the case for the coral barrier that also you mentioned
04:16before because Australia did not take the necessary measures. The coral barrier was threatened
04:23from the inscription on the endangered list several years ago and in 2021 this was really
04:30discussed on the committee. Finally it was avoided because Australia decided to take these measures
04:38which are for example to create no fishing zones to completely ban the gill netting starting from
04:452027 or also to achieve very ambitious water quality targets by 2025-2026. And we can see that
04:56all these measures are political so they need in fact from the side of the state party to negotiate
05:03with all these people who have interest from fishing for example so they have a political
05:09in fact impact and also a very huge economic impact. So this is why in fact some of the states
05:17are really reluctant in order to inscribe their sites and we have only few exceptions of state
05:25parties who ask themselves for their properties to be listed on the endangered list with as a
05:33major example Everglades which is located in the southern tip of Florida which was listed from 1993
05:42to 2007 and then again on demand of the United States listed again on the endangered list in 2010
05:51because in this case the state party recognizes that cannot solve the problem by itself and that
05:59the help of international community is necessary. Maria are there any sites that are likely to move
06:04in the opposite direction this year and get themselves off the endangered list?
06:09Well yeah some sites are I mean the idea of the endangered list is not to stay there forever the
06:13idea is to stay as less time as possible and some sites they manage to get off the endangered list
06:20quite quickly. This of course needs a real project needs also that sometimes real problems
06:27such as wars are solved and this obviously does not depend only on the state party so sometimes
06:34it's much more complex than measures which are mainly economic and political as I mentioned
06:39before but the idea yes and we do have success stories is that a site I mean gets off the
06:46endangered list as soon as all these threats are in a way solved. And Maria separately UNESCO is
06:54set to consider 25 new candidates for inclusion on its prestigious world heritage list including
07:01the Marquesas Islands in French Polynesia. Why does it take some places so long to get onto this
07:06list and what benefits do they reap when they do get onto it? Well this it takes long because it's
07:12a really long process it's a long process because this means that you needed to bring together all
07:18the stakeholders you need also to bring in this project the local communities and this is important
07:24this now becomes crucial I mean it's not that it's not anymore a top-down process it is supposed to be
07:30a bottom-up process that comes from the community itself and it's very interesting because for the
07:36Marquesas the president of French Polynesia said that he's really delighted about the fact that
07:42the Marquesas in fact project is really a project that comes from the Marquesan community
07:51and this is really really important symbolically important. So yes it takes a lot of time because
07:56some properties are very complex and this is typically the case of the Marquesas because
08:04in fact are a mixed site this means that they will be listed with both cultural and natural
08:10criteria so two cultural and three natural criteria which makes a kind of exceptional site
08:17and that's a politically very important site because the idea is also to symbolize this
08:24rebirth of the Marquesan population in the 20th century after decades of
08:33how can I say of endangered situation because we know that in the time of contact with Europeans
08:41at the end of the starting from the end of the 18th century the population of the Marquesas
08:49I mean enormously they were in the end of the 18th century between 50,000 and 80,000 people
08:57and they were in the beginning of the 20th century only 2,000. So this is also very symbolic
09:04rebirth which is extremely important in fact for the local populations. Maria we'll have to leave
09:09it there for now but thank you so much for your time on the program. That is Maria Guevara-Bobaras
09:14chair of the UNESCO culture tourism and development research program at Sorbonne University here in
09:20Paris.

Recommended