Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 3 years ago
Governments are falling behind when it comes to closing the gap on Indigenous disadvantage according to a new report from the Productivity Commission. The Commission reviewed a landmark 2020 agreement signed by governments and peak Aboriginal organisations. It’s found the response so far has been weak and is calling for an independent watchdog led by Aboriginal people.

Category

📺
TV
Transcript
00:00 The government's made commitments to mobilize all available avenues to overcome the entrenched
00:08 inequality faced by many Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people.
00:12 It's not that nothing's been done, but the report's making it clear that it's mostly
00:16 ineffective piecemeal changes.
00:18 For example, those 2,000 government initiatives for closing the gap are mostly old initiatives
00:22 dressed up as new ones with little explanation as to how or why they will help close the
00:28 gap.
00:29 There are four main commitments that governments agree to.
00:32 First is the commitment to shared decision-making.
00:35 This is rarely achieved in practice.
00:37 Policy partnerships relating to justice, social and emotional well-being, housing, et cetera.
00:42 The report says that they mostly function as discussion forums with little, if any,
00:46 authority.
00:47 A second commitment that was made is one to building community-controlled sector.
00:51 The report found that government policy, A, doesn't reflect that value, and in most jurisdictions,
00:57 it's unclear how much funding is allocated to those organizations.
01:00 There were also commitments to government accountability.
01:03 This is the big one.
01:05 Progress on that front has largely been small scale.
01:08 The report says it's barely begun.
01:10 And the final and fourth pillar is to have shared access to data and information.
01:15 Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander organizations are continuing to report difficulties accessing
01:19 government-held data, and when they do, it often doesn't reflect their realities.
01:23 Here's how Minister for Indigenous Affairs Linda Burney reacted to this today.
01:28 If there is ever an argument for the need for a voice, it is this draft report.
01:36 Like I say, it is difficult reading, and the important thing is to understand that what
01:44 it's talking about are real people, real families, and real communities.
01:51 It is not academic.
01:54 So Nabil, does the report include any recommendations to remedy these failings?
01:58 Yes, it does.
02:00 First is stronger accountability mechanisms.
02:02 So according to the report, as things currently stand, there are no consequences for failure.
02:06 The report reads, "Accountability is incomplete without effective consequences or sanctions."
02:12 And it says that one of the ways to do that is through Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander
02:16 bodies.
02:17 Voices to state parliaments, treaty processes, justice commissions.
02:21 These bodies could play a role in holding governments to account.
02:24 The report is also recommending embedding some of these responsibilities directly into
02:28 the public sector by designating senior leadership groups, performance assessments for all public
02:33 sector CEOs, executives, and employees.
02:37 It's a big report, so there are more recommendations, but it's also a draft report.
02:41 So it's still open for submissions until October 6th.
02:44 The final report is set to be delivered by the end of this year.
02:47 [BLANK_AUDIO]
Comments

Recommended