• 9 hours ago
The Atlanta Constitution,

Wednesday, 29th October 1913,

PAGE 1, COLUMN 3.

Advises Lawyer for

Defense

to Take Purgative to

Rid

His System of Some

of Its

Miasma.

DIRTY TACTICS

CHARGED

BY SOLICITOR

GENERAL

Dorsey's Speech Is

Concluded.

Rosser Will Make

Address

Today and the Case

Then

Goes to the Judge.

With a blistering attack upon Rube Arnold, in which the

attorney was accused not only of deliberate falsehoods, but of

having lost through his activity in the Frank case the public

esteem and appreciation of the people of Georgia, Solicitor

General Hugh M. Dorsey concluded his stirring argument in the

Frank hearing late yesterday afternoon.

Mr. Arnold has made charges against me and against Judge

Roan that are deliberate falsehoods. He happens not to be in the

room at this time. I wish he were. I therefore, ask you, Mr. Rosser,

as his colleague, to deliver to him this message which I am going

to send.

Mr. Rosser, who was sitting only a few feet distance, arose

and turning so that he faced both the solicitor and Judge Roan,

said:

I'm no tale bearer. IF you have anything to say of Mr.

Arnold, I think it would be more appropriate to say it to him in

person. Please do not consider me a slander courier.

Sends Message to Arnold.

Then, continued Mr. Dorsey heatedly, I'll say this much as

advice to Mr. Arnold. If I were in his place, I'd take a purgative and

get rid of some of the miasma and putrefaction that rankles in his

system.

he needs even more. He needs a drastic cathartic. I am

sure that if he would turn his back on a little of the money the

Brooklyn friends and relatives are putting up for Mr. Leo M. Frank,

that he would clean his mind and soul of the fire and fury therein

that are being paid to blaze.

The community will not hold the lofty opinion it has held of

Mr. Arnold until he does this. Mark my prediction! The public he

has maligned and abused knows enough, that where the defense

has been dirty in its tactics that the prosecution has been clean.

The charge that the public has lost its head, and that you,

your honor, and I , and the detectives, have lost and that a clean

and wholesome jury was perjured is so diabolical that I am sure

your honor will not even consider this motion for a new trial. The

public mind does not. I am sure you will not.

These were the final words of the solicitor's argument which

extended less than an hour more than a day.

Rosser Promises Attack.

When he had finished, Mr. Rosser arose from his seat for the

second time. As the solicitor took his seat, Rosser said:

If Dorsey means to assert that I am not going to say he has

done dirty things in this case, he is terribly mistaken, for I am

going to say it. And, it might be well to mention that I have ample

evidence to substantiate such accusation I make.

Before other words could be Judge Roan adjourned the

session until Wednesday morning at 9 o'clock,

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Arnold branded with falsehood by Hugh Dorsey. The Atlanta Constitution, Wednesday, the 29th of
00:05October, 1913, page 1, column 3, advises lawyer for defense to take purgative to rid his system
00:12of some of its miasma. Dirty tactics charged by Solicitor General Dorsey's speech is concluded.
00:18Rosser will make address today, and the case then goes to the judge. With a blistering attack upon
00:23Rube Arnold, in which the attorney was accused not only of deliberate falsehoods, but of having
00:28lost through his activity in the Frank case the public esteem and appreciation of the people of
00:33Georgia, Solicitor General Hugh M. Dorsey concluded his stirring argument in the Frank hearing late
00:38yesterday afternoon. Mr. Arnold has made charges against me and against Judge Rhone that are
00:43deliberate falsehoods. He happens not to be in the room at this time. I wish he were. I therefore
00:49ask you, Mr. Rosser, as his colleague, to deliver to him this message which I am going to send.
00:54Mr. Rosser, who was sitting only a few feet distance, arose and turning so that he faced
00:59both the Solicitor and Judge Rhone, said, I'm no tale-bearer. If you have anything to say of Mr.
01:05Arnold, I think it would be more appropriate to say it to him in person. Please do not consider
01:09me a slander courier. Sends message to Arnold. Then, continued Mr. Dorsey heatedly, I'll say this
01:15much as advice to Mr. Arnold. If I were in his place, I'd take a purgative and get rid of
01:20some of
01:20the miasma and putrefaction that rankles in his system. He needs even more. He needs a drastic
01:25cathartic. I am sure that if he would turn his back on a little of the money the Brooklyn friends
01:30and relatives are putting up for Mr. Leo M. Frank, that he would clean his mind and soul of the
01:35fire
01:36and fury therein that are being paid to blaze. The community will not hold the lofty opinion it has
01:42held of Mr. Arnold until he does this. Mark my prediction. The public he has maligned and abused
01:48knows enough. That where the defense has been dirty in its tactics, that the prosecution has
01:52been clean. The charge that the public has lost its head, and that you, your honor and I, and the
01:59detectives have lost, and that a clean and wholesome jury was perjured is so diabolical that I am sure
02:05your honor will not even consider this motion for a new trial. The public mind does not. I am sure
02:10you
02:10will not. These were the final words of the solicitor's argument which extended less than an hour more than a
02:16day. Rosser promises attack. When he had finished, Mr. Rosser arose from his seat for the second time.
02:22As the solicitor took his seat, Rosser said, If Dorsey means to assert that I am not going to say
02:27he has done dirty things in this case, he is terribly mistaken, for I am going to say it. And
02:32it
02:32might be well to mention that I have ample evidence to substantiate such accusation I make. Before other
02:38words could be Judge Rohn adjourned the session until Wednesday morning at nine o'clock, when Mr. Rosser
02:43will begin his speech. To a reporter for the Constitution, Mr. Rosser said that he hardly
02:48thought his argument would last over a day less, in all probability. The most of solicitor Dorsey's
02:53speech Tuesday was devoted to citations of law upholding his attacks upon the four, upholding
02:59his attacks upon the four grounds of the defense's motion which he chose to combat. These particular
03:05grounds were those based upon demonstrations of the crowds at the trial. Conley's testimony, Judge
03:10Rohn's charge, and upon alleged jury prejudice. The room in which the hearing was held was
03:15filled with a young law library. Not less than two hundred cases were recited during the course
03:20of his speech, each tending to uphold the solicitor in his various arguments. He was assisted by
03:26E. A. Stevens, who is associated with him in the solicitor's office. Defense accuses everybody.
03:32The defense, he said in part, finds cause to accuse almost everybody within range of everything
03:37from neglect of duty to wrongdoing of all conceivable kinds. They accuse your honor,
03:43my friend Hooper, myself, the detective department, and every man on the sheriff's staff.
03:47Why is it? It is purely this, this, and nothing more. They have lumbered all this massive stuff in
03:53here merely as some excuse to ask your honor to set aside a verdict which he conscientiously known
03:58is correct and capable of withstanding any storm that might brew in the future. But such tactics are
04:04only in keeping with every other thing. They are doing. There is absolutely no justification for
04:10this motion. They have no grounds and they know it. That is the pathetic thing about the whole business.
04:15To watch the defense beating around in the dark like snipe hunters, doing every possible thing to
04:20find something on which they might be able to base a desperate plea. Why, just look how ridiculous some
04:25of these pieces of evidence are. The Sam Borstein affidavit, for instance. Colonel Samuel Borstein,
04:31lawyer. He swears he saw a juror put his head out of a window at Kimball House. Poor juror. Poor
04:37Colonel Borstein. It is the most absurd proposition I have ever heard of. There isn't a ground in the
04:43entire motion that has to it even a semblance of merit. I know it, your honor knows it, and the
04:47poor
04:48desperate defense knows it, if the defense wasn't composed of such capable law. Continued on page five.
04:54Page five, column five, Arnold branded with falsehood. Continued from page one.
04:58Yours, as Meeser's Rosser and Arnold, why your honor wouldn't take the pains to listen to it.
05:03Sanctions red-handed crime. If you accept the kind of policy the defense would have you accept,
05:08your honor will be literally sanctioning red-handed crime and giving freedom to criminals.
05:13If they had shown credible evidence by unimpeachable witness, they might have had a
05:17chance for a new trial. But knowing the evidence and circumstances, as does your honor, you cannot
05:22possibly do anything toward granting their wish. If you disqualify jurors on such flimsy evidence as
05:28has been produced by the defendants, you will have a hard time ever getting a jury in the future.
05:33In some cases, many, I'm afraid, you'll never get one. It will be an impossibility.
05:37Let me tell you something. There isn't a man in the state more honorable and peaceful than these men,
05:42Joe Henning and Hensley. And in saying this, I include every man from the governor down.
05:47Is it any wonder that when such men as these are allowed to be attacked, that the people are growing
05:51to
05:51hold the court and law in contempt? Now let me say this much, and I say it with all sincerity
05:56and
05:57feeling. If this man, Joe Henning, and this man, Hensley, have done what the defense accused,
06:01they ought to be sent to the penitentiary. For if such is the case, justice is a fraud and court
06:07trial
06:08a farce. Consider it a moment. Then you'll agree that I am right. Militia will be necessary. If your
06:14honor would do such a thing as grant a new trial on the ground of demonstrations and outbreaks of the
06:18crowd, then he will permit things to come to such a pass, where it will be necessary to muster out
06:23the military to keep guard. We will have court in the future at the point of bayonets and loaded guns.
06:29Regarding your honor's charge, on which is based one of the grounds for a new trial,
06:33I do not think it necessary for me to dwell at all. They do not necessitate combat. I have enough
06:38confidence in your honor's knowledge of law and in his discretion. I will not give dignity to this
06:43ground by making reply. To tell the truth, I believe that this ground was inherited in the
06:48motion to give bulk, and for purely no other reason. You can readily see that such is the case
06:53in almost all the other grounds. Page 5, Column 6, Knights of Pythias will convene today. All lodges in
07:01the 5th Georgia Congressional District will gather in Atlanta. The annual convention of the Knights of
07:06Pythias of the 5th District, which includes all the lodges within the 5th Congressional District of
07:12Georgia, will be held today at the Knights of Pythias Hall in the Kaiser Building. At 3 o'clock,
07:18a meeting of the delegates from the various lodges in the district will be held for the purpose of
07:23reorganization and the election of district officers for the coming year, and to transact routine
07:29businesses. At 8 o'clock in the hall, a Pythian rally will be held, to which all Knights of Pythias
07:35have been invited, whether in good standing or not. The rally is to be a general get-together meeting,
07:41and an effort will be made to re-enlist all members who, for various reasons, have ceased to be
07:47actively connected with the order. Practically all of the grand officers of the state are expected to
07:52attend the rally, and speeches will be made by all of the grand officers present, and by several local
07:58Pythians of high rank. Supreme Chancellor Thomas J. Carling of Macon, the head of the entire order,
08:04has been invited to attend, and will probably make an address before the meeting. Past Grand Master
08:10Milan of Cartersville and Hamilton Douglas, past Chancellor and past Supreme Representative of the
08:15Order, and Troy Beatty of Athens Grand Prelate, past Chancellor Shepard Bryan, Miller Bell of
08:21Milledgeville, present Grand Chancellor, H. M. Stanley of Dublin, Grand Vice Chancellor Joseph P. Smith,
08:28past Grand Chancellor James W. Austin, Attorney Frank Hooper, and Joseph P. Smith will make short
08:34addresses. Refreshments will be served during the evening, and an orchestra has been engaged to
08:39furnish music. Page 12, Column 2, Professional Cards, P. H. Brewster, Albert Howell, Jr., Hugh M. Dorsey,
08:47Arthur Heyman, Dorsey, Brewster, Howell & Herman, Attorneys at Law, Offices 202, 204, 205, 206, 207, 208,
08:57210, Kaiser Building, Atlanta Gay, Long Distance Telephone 3022, 3024, and 3025, Atlanta Gay.

Recommended