00:00Arnold branded with falsehood by Hugh Dorsey. The Atlanta Constitution, Wednesday, the 29th of
00:05October, 1913, page 1, column 3, advises lawyer for defense to take purgative to rid his system
00:12of some of its miasma. Dirty tactics charged by Solicitor General Dorsey's speech is concluded.
00:18Rosser will make address today, and the case then goes to the judge. With a blistering attack upon
00:23Rube Arnold, in which the attorney was accused not only of deliberate falsehoods, but of having
00:28lost through his activity in the Frank case the public esteem and appreciation of the people of
00:33Georgia, Solicitor General Hugh M. Dorsey concluded his stirring argument in the Frank hearing late
00:38yesterday afternoon. Mr. Arnold has made charges against me and against Judge Rhone that are
00:43deliberate falsehoods. He happens not to be in the room at this time. I wish he were. I therefore
00:49ask you, Mr. Rosser, as his colleague, to deliver to him this message which I am going to send.
00:54Mr. Rosser, who was sitting only a few feet distance, arose and turning so that he faced
00:59both the Solicitor and Judge Rhone, said, I'm no tale-bearer. If you have anything to say of Mr.
01:05Arnold, I think it would be more appropriate to say it to him in person. Please do not consider
01:09me a slander courier. Sends message to Arnold. Then, continued Mr. Dorsey heatedly, I'll say this
01:15much as advice to Mr. Arnold. If I were in his place, I'd take a purgative and get rid of
01:20some of
01:20the miasma and putrefaction that rankles in his system. He needs even more. He needs a drastic
01:25cathartic. I am sure that if he would turn his back on a little of the money the Brooklyn friends
01:30and relatives are putting up for Mr. Leo M. Frank, that he would clean his mind and soul of the
01:35fire
01:36and fury therein that are being paid to blaze. The community will not hold the lofty opinion it has
01:42held of Mr. Arnold until he does this. Mark my prediction. The public he has maligned and abused
01:48knows enough. That where the defense has been dirty in its tactics, that the prosecution has
01:52been clean. The charge that the public has lost its head, and that you, your honor and I, and the
01:59detectives have lost, and that a clean and wholesome jury was perjured is so diabolical that I am sure
02:05your honor will not even consider this motion for a new trial. The public mind does not. I am sure
02:10you
02:10will not. These were the final words of the solicitor's argument which extended less than an hour more than a
02:16day. Rosser promises attack. When he had finished, Mr. Rosser arose from his seat for the second time.
02:22As the solicitor took his seat, Rosser said, If Dorsey means to assert that I am not going to say
02:27he has done dirty things in this case, he is terribly mistaken, for I am going to say it. And
02:32it
02:32might be well to mention that I have ample evidence to substantiate such accusation I make. Before other
02:38words could be Judge Rohn adjourned the session until Wednesday morning at nine o'clock, when Mr. Rosser
02:43will begin his speech. To a reporter for the Constitution, Mr. Rosser said that he hardly
02:48thought his argument would last over a day less, in all probability. The most of solicitor Dorsey's
02:53speech Tuesday was devoted to citations of law upholding his attacks upon the four, upholding
02:59his attacks upon the four grounds of the defense's motion which he chose to combat. These particular
03:05grounds were those based upon demonstrations of the crowds at the trial. Conley's testimony, Judge
03:10Rohn's charge, and upon alleged jury prejudice. The room in which the hearing was held was
03:15filled with a young law library. Not less than two hundred cases were recited during the course
03:20of his speech, each tending to uphold the solicitor in his various arguments. He was assisted by
03:26E. A. Stevens, who is associated with him in the solicitor's office. Defense accuses everybody.
03:32The defense, he said in part, finds cause to accuse almost everybody within range of everything
03:37from neglect of duty to wrongdoing of all conceivable kinds. They accuse your honor,
03:43my friend Hooper, myself, the detective department, and every man on the sheriff's staff.
03:47Why is it? It is purely this, this, and nothing more. They have lumbered all this massive stuff in
03:53here merely as some excuse to ask your honor to set aside a verdict which he conscientiously known
03:58is correct and capable of withstanding any storm that might brew in the future. But such tactics are
04:04only in keeping with every other thing. They are doing. There is absolutely no justification for
04:10this motion. They have no grounds and they know it. That is the pathetic thing about the whole business.
04:15To watch the defense beating around in the dark like snipe hunters, doing every possible thing to
04:20find something on which they might be able to base a desperate plea. Why, just look how ridiculous some
04:25of these pieces of evidence are. The Sam Borstein affidavit, for instance. Colonel Samuel Borstein,
04:31lawyer. He swears he saw a juror put his head out of a window at Kimball House. Poor juror. Poor
04:37Colonel Borstein. It is the most absurd proposition I have ever heard of. There isn't a ground in the
04:43entire motion that has to it even a semblance of merit. I know it, your honor knows it, and the
04:47poor
04:48desperate defense knows it, if the defense wasn't composed of such capable law. Continued on page five.
04:54Page five, column five, Arnold branded with falsehood. Continued from page one.
04:58Yours, as Meeser's Rosser and Arnold, why your honor wouldn't take the pains to listen to it.
05:03Sanctions red-handed crime. If you accept the kind of policy the defense would have you accept,
05:08your honor will be literally sanctioning red-handed crime and giving freedom to criminals.
05:13If they had shown credible evidence by unimpeachable witness, they might have had a
05:17chance for a new trial. But knowing the evidence and circumstances, as does your honor, you cannot
05:22possibly do anything toward granting their wish. If you disqualify jurors on such flimsy evidence as
05:28has been produced by the defendants, you will have a hard time ever getting a jury in the future.
05:33In some cases, many, I'm afraid, you'll never get one. It will be an impossibility.
05:37Let me tell you something. There isn't a man in the state more honorable and peaceful than these men,
05:42Joe Henning and Hensley. And in saying this, I include every man from the governor down.
05:47Is it any wonder that when such men as these are allowed to be attacked, that the people are growing
05:51to
05:51hold the court and law in contempt? Now let me say this much, and I say it with all sincerity
05:56and
05:57feeling. If this man, Joe Henning, and this man, Hensley, have done what the defense accused,
06:01they ought to be sent to the penitentiary. For if such is the case, justice is a fraud and court
06:07trial
06:08a farce. Consider it a moment. Then you'll agree that I am right. Militia will be necessary. If your
06:14honor would do such a thing as grant a new trial on the ground of demonstrations and outbreaks of the
06:18crowd, then he will permit things to come to such a pass, where it will be necessary to muster out
06:23the military to keep guard. We will have court in the future at the point of bayonets and loaded guns.
06:29Regarding your honor's charge, on which is based one of the grounds for a new trial,
06:33I do not think it necessary for me to dwell at all. They do not necessitate combat. I have enough
06:38confidence in your honor's knowledge of law and in his discretion. I will not give dignity to this
06:43ground by making reply. To tell the truth, I believe that this ground was inherited in the
06:48motion to give bulk, and for purely no other reason. You can readily see that such is the case
06:53in almost all the other grounds. Page 5, Column 6, Knights of Pythias will convene today. All lodges in
07:01the 5th Georgia Congressional District will gather in Atlanta. The annual convention of the Knights of
07:06Pythias of the 5th District, which includes all the lodges within the 5th Congressional District of
07:12Georgia, will be held today at the Knights of Pythias Hall in the Kaiser Building. At 3 o'clock,
07:18a meeting of the delegates from the various lodges in the district will be held for the purpose of
07:23reorganization and the election of district officers for the coming year, and to transact routine
07:29businesses. At 8 o'clock in the hall, a Pythian rally will be held, to which all Knights of Pythias
07:35have been invited, whether in good standing or not. The rally is to be a general get-together meeting,
07:41and an effort will be made to re-enlist all members who, for various reasons, have ceased to be
07:47actively connected with the order. Practically all of the grand officers of the state are expected to
07:52attend the rally, and speeches will be made by all of the grand officers present, and by several local
07:58Pythians of high rank. Supreme Chancellor Thomas J. Carling of Macon, the head of the entire order,
08:04has been invited to attend, and will probably make an address before the meeting. Past Grand Master
08:10Milan of Cartersville and Hamilton Douglas, past Chancellor and past Supreme Representative of the
08:15Order, and Troy Beatty of Athens Grand Prelate, past Chancellor Shepard Bryan, Miller Bell of
08:21Milledgeville, present Grand Chancellor, H. M. Stanley of Dublin, Grand Vice Chancellor Joseph P. Smith,
08:28past Grand Chancellor James W. Austin, Attorney Frank Hooper, and Joseph P. Smith will make short
08:34addresses. Refreshments will be served during the evening, and an orchestra has been engaged to
08:39furnish music. Page 12, Column 2, Professional Cards, P. H. Brewster, Albert Howell, Jr., Hugh M. Dorsey,
08:47Arthur Heyman, Dorsey, Brewster, Howell & Herman, Attorneys at Law, Offices 202, 204, 205, 206, 207, 208,
08:57210, Kaiser Building, Atlanta Gay, Long Distance Telephone 3022, 3024, and 3025, Atlanta Gay.