00:00Proof of charges will mean a new trial, says Court. The Atlanta Constitution, Friday, the 24th of
00:06October, 1913, page 1, column 2. Evidence against jurors, Hensley and Johenning, the most important
00:12to be introduced. Attitude of crowds will be stressed. Verdict in trial was delayed for two
00:18days on account of fear of mob violence, Roan admits. It developed Thursday during frank hearing
00:23for a new trial that the verdict in the original trial was delayed two days for fear of mob violence
00:28to the accused man. Also, that Judge Roan was prevailed upon by the editors of the three
00:33Atlanta newspapers, militia, officials, and the chief of police to make this move of continuance.
00:40It was feared if the verdict was submitted on the trial's final Saturday, during which day the crowds
00:45were largest, that violence might result. During the close of the trial, while Solicitor Dorsey was
00:51ending his historical argument, Judge Roan ordered a German at noon on Saturday, August 2. This was
00:57his action to prevent any possible outbreak of the crowds. Had court not been adjourned at that time,
01:03the solicitor's speech would have been finished before nightfall and the verdict returned by
01:07earlier than ten o'clock at night. Judge Roan certified to the conference he had held with
01:12military officials and the chief of police. In hearing section 115 of the new trial motion,
01:19the judge gave a certificate of approval to the defense's argument upon the temper of the crowds
01:24that attended the trial. He stated that, in his opinion, the attitude of the majority of the
01:29crowds was hostile to the defendant, and that it was evinced frequently both within and without the
01:35courtroom. This attitude of the crowds, it is apparent, will be one of the strongest cards of
01:40Frank's counsel in seeking for a new trial. Not less than fifteen or twenty grounds tendered at
01:46Thursday's session pertain to demonstrations and public temper. Coupled with these grounds and the
01:52evidence to be submitted against jurors Hensley and Joe Henning, the defense seems to have made
01:57decided headway. Charges sufficient if proved. Judge Roan, upon reviewing the grounds relating to
02:03Hensley and Joe Henning's alleged prejudice, said, If these facts can be proved, it would be hardly
02:09necessary to continue with the hearing. The volume of 115 grounds was finished at the close of Thursday's
02:16session. Beginning at nine o'clock this morning, a review will be made of those which were passed up
02:21because of doubt, following which will come the arguments, which are expected about ten o'clock
02:26this morning. Affidavits and other evidence will also be considered to-day. New affidavits presented.
02:32The defense sprang a surprise Thursday when they declared affidavits were in their hands,
02:37contradicting Hensley's story that he was not in Albany Gaye, at the time he is alleged to have
02:42expressed bias. Colonel Rosser declared that he had evidence of Hensley's signature upon the hotel
02:47register and of an order which the accused juror took in Albany on the date in question.
02:52Upon the establishment of this, or jury prejudice, depends the success or failure of the new trial
02:58motion. Judge Roan, in telling of the delayed verdict for fear of an outbreak, stated that he
03:03had prevailed upon continued on page seven. Page seven, column two, proof of charges will mean new trial
03:09continued from page one, by military officers and police officials to defer the end of the trial until
03:15the following Monday. This was done when it looked as though the verdict would be returned Saturday
03:20night. This was done, said the judge, because the temper of the crowd was obviously at high tension.
03:25I do not doubt that the prisoner might have suffered violence if proper steps had not been taken.
03:29Letters from editors. Judge Roan was apprised of the defense's knowledge of a personal communication
03:35which the court had received during the trial from James R. Gray of the Journal, Foster Coates of the
03:41Georgian, and Clark Howell of the Constitution, suggesting that the verdict be deferred until the
03:46following Monday. The judge was asked to certify to this. He would not, on the grounds that the
03:52communication was personal, but said that if the editors gave permission, he would make the desired
03:57certificate. Neither would he certify to the section of the motion appealing for new trial on the ground
04:03that the defense was not officially represented when the verdict was returned. This clause was the subject
04:09of a stubborn battle between the defense and prosecution. Solicitor Dorsey maintained that
04:14Stiles Hopkins, a member of the Rosser and Brandon law firm, was present in the courtroom at the time
04:19the verdict was returned and received it legally. To this, Colonel Rosser replied that Hopkins was given
04:25no instructions to represent the defendant, and that no one connected with the defense was supposed to
04:30have been in the courtroom at the time it was read. Hopkins was called to the hearing to testify.
04:35He stated that he had received no instructions, as stated by Mr. Rosser. First witnesses heard.
04:41The first witnesses were heard Thursday. Mr. Hopkins was the first. Afterwards, a newspaper reporter
04:47testified to the scenes outside the courtroom on the day of the verdict, when the solicitor was hoisted
04:52to the shoulders of a number of men in the crowd. A number of witnesses, it is said, will be
04:56put up today.
04:57An attack was made upon Judge Rohn's charge to the jury in ground 73 of the new trial motion.
05:02His failure to charge the jury to put no credence in Conley's story because of admitted falsehoods
05:08was another contention in a following section. The ground relating to the alleged illegal charge
05:13reads as follows. The court erred in charging the jury as follows. Is Leo Frank guilty? Are you
05:20satisfied with his guilt? Are you satisfied with his statement? Are you satisfied with the evidence?
05:26Is his plea of not guilty the truth? Object to picket letter. A plea is also based upon the injection
05:32into the solicitor's argument of a letter received from District Attorney C. M. Pickett of San Francisco
05:38bearing on the Durant case in California. It is alleged that the use of such material was illegal
05:44and prejudicial, and that the court was in error in not excluding it. References by Dorsey to Oscar Wilde,
05:50the Richeson and Beatle cases, were also objected to. A vigorous protest was made to the solicitor's
05:56accusation that the expert medical testimony introduced by the defense was obtained by
06:02money and influence. In answer to this, Dorsey stated that he never made such an allegation.
06:07I only intimated it, he said. Page 9, Column 3, Professional Cards.
06:12P. H. Brewster, Albert Howell Jr., Hugh M. Dorsey, Arthur Heyman, Dorsey, Brewster, Howell,
06:18and Herman, Attorneys at Law. Offices 202, 204, 205, 206, 207, 208, 210, Kaiser Building,
06:28Atlanta Gay. Long Distance Telephone 3022, 3024, and 3025, Atlanta Gay.