• 11 minutes ago
The Atlanta Constitution,

Monday, 6th October 1913,

PAGE 1, COLUMN 2.



SPARTA CITIZENS
INSIST HENSLEE
WAS PREJUDICED

“You Said Frank Was Guilty,” They Tell Juror in Letter Sent to Him, and Furnish Copies to the Press.

“WE PRACTICALLY TRIED
HIM BEFORE THE TRIAL”

Say They Will Not Allow Henslee to Call Them Liars to Protect Himself From Criticism “He Deserved.”

Declaring that they had “practically tried” Leo M. Frank for the murder of Mary Phagan before the case was called, the three men who made affidavits against A. H. Henslee, a Frank juror, charging him with bias, yesterday mailed a sensational letter to the Atlanta newspapers presenting their side of the case. The writers of the letter are John M. Holmes, of Holmes & Walker, an insurance and buggy firm, S. M. Johnson, cashier of the concern, and Shi Gray, all of Sparta, Ga., who declares he was in the Holmes & Walker office when Henslee made his alleged statements, say in their communication that they cannot believe that Henslee’s reply to their forced affidavits has been correctly quoted.

The writers also say that they believe it impossible that Henslee could have forgotten the discussion of the Frank case in the office of the concern and recalled the “intense feeling manifested” by Henslee against Frank at the time.

The letter then says:

“You must recall in Mr. Holmes’ office, on the day stated, and in the presence of the undersigned, we all discussed the Frank case and practically tried him, as it were, and that, in the discussion, you not only said that Frank was as guilty as —— but you had much to say about Frank’s being a moral degenerate—your exact language we cannot use—and further stated that you were drawn as a juror.

“We have no disposition to injure you or to make public your statement as two of the writers, Gray and Holmes, have known you and your family for many years and we do not know how the attorneys were acquainted with the fact of this conversation but your remark was common talk in the town where there are a number of people who could have given the information to the attorneys.

“We declined to make a voluntary affidavit in the matter and said nothing until forced to by the court, but let us assure you that the reluctance to testify in no way changes the fact and you shall not be permitted to make statements in the public press denouncing us as liars in order to protect yourself from the criticism you have justly deserved.

“We await your answer.

(Signed)

“J. M. HOLMES,
“S. M. JOHNSON
“SHI GRAY.”

References

The Atlanta Constitution. (1913, October 6). “Sparta Citizens Insist Henslee Was Prejudiced,” p. 1. MaryPhagan.com.

https://www.maryphagan.com/1913-10-06-sparta-citizens-insist-henslee-was-prejudiced-the-atlanta-constitution/

Frank v. State. (1913). New-trial record. Reproduction of the letter from H. Shi Gray, John M. Holmes, and S. M. Johnson, including the wording “as guilty as H---l.”

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Sparta citizens insist Hensley was prejudiced. The Atlanta Constitution, Monday, the 6th of October,
00:051913, page 1, column 2. You said Frank was guilt-eye, they tell juror in letter sent to him,
00:12and furnish copies to the press. We practically tried him before the trial, say they will not
00:17allow Hensley to call them liars to protect himself from criticism he deserved. Declaring
00:22that they had practically tried Leo M. Frank for the murder of Mary Fagan before the case was called,
00:26the three men who made affidavits against A. H. Hensley, a Frank juror, charging him with bias,
00:33yesterday mailed a sensational letter to the Atlanta newspapers, presenting their side of
00:37the case. The writers of the letter are John M. Holmes of Holmes and Walker, an insurance and
00:43buggy firm, S. M. Johnson, cashier of the concern, and She Gray, all of Sparta, J.A., who declares he
00:49was in the Holmes and Walker office when Hensley made his alleged statements, say in their communication
00:54that they cannot believe that Hensley's reply to their forced affidavits has been correctly quoted.
00:59The writers also say that they believe it impossible that Hensley could have forgotten
01:03the discussion of the Frank case in the office of the concern, and recalled the intense feeling
01:08manifested by Hensley against Frank at the time. The letter then says,
01:13You must recall in Mr. Holmes's office, on the day stated, and in the presence of the undersigned,
01:19we all discussed the Frank case and practically tried him, as it were, and that in the discussion
01:25you are not only said that Frank was as guilty as, but you had much to say about Frank's being
01:29a moral degenerate. Your exact language we cannot use further stated that you were drawn as a juror.
01:36We have no disposition to injure you or to make public your statement, as two of the writers,
01:40Gray and Holmes, have known you and your family for many years, and we do not know how the attorneys
01:45were acquainted with the fact of this conversation, but your remark was common talk in the town where
01:50there are a number of people who could have given the information to the attorneys. We declined to
01:55make voluntary affidavit in the matter and said nothing until forced to by the court, but let us
02:00assure you that the reluctance to testify in no way changes the fact, and you shall not be permitted
02:06to make statements in the public press, denouncing us as liars in order to protect yourself from
02:11the criticism you have justly deserved. We await your answer. Signed, J.M. Holmes, S.M. Johnson,
02:19Shy Gray.

Recommended