Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 2 days ago
Tuesday, June 24, 1913

Dorsey, Beavers and Lanford Summoned to Appear June 30 With All Affidavits They Have Secured Relative to the Phagan Slaying Case.

Just before the conference with both sides in the Frank case started Judge Roan intimated strongly that he would set the case for July 14 or July 28 and hold it in some more commodious court room than the one in which he sits on the fourth floor of the Thrower building. Judge Roan's personal inclination leans to a date in July, and it is not likely that the State or defense will object to acceding to his wishes.

The date was definitely fixed for July 28 at the conference.

The first important legal move by the defense in the battle for the life and freedom of Leo Frank, accused of the strangling of Mary Phagan, was made Tuesday in the issuance of subpenas duces tecum for the prime movers in the prosecution of the factory superintendent.

The following have been subpenaed to appear:

Solicitor General Hugh M. Dorsey, who will prosecute the prisoner.

Chief of Police James L. Beavers, who was the leader in obtaining incriminating affidavits.

Pinkerton Detective Harry Scott, to whom is generally given credit for the admissions gained from Conley.

All other city detectives who have worked on the case.

All of them are ordered to produce any affidavits they may have bearing on the case in court June 30, indicating that the defense will be prepared to go on with the trial at that time.

Judge Roan, however, had called a conference of the attorneys on both sides of the case for 2 o'clock in the afternoon, when he announced that he would set the date definitely after the attorneys had been given an opportunity to say whether or not their cases would be in shape to present if the trial were called the last of this month.

Plan to Use Same Evidence.

The startling move on the part of the defense was taken to mean that Frank's lawyers propose to use to free their client the very evidence the detectives and Solicitor General have collected to send him to the gallows.

The most significant demand is made upon Chief Beavers, who is commanded to bring into court the famed series of affidavits made by the negro sweeper, Jim Conley. It is evident that Attorneys Rosser and Arnold, who are conducting the defense, intend to tear the contradictory stories of the negro to tatters and make his statements so utterly ridiculous and improbable that the jury not only will refuse to accept them, but will interpret them as an effort of Conley to get from under the blame for a crime that he committed himself.
Transcript
00:00Both sides called in conference by Judge. Trial set for July 28th, the Atlanta Georgian Tuesday,
00:06June 24th, 1913. Dorsey, Beavers, and Lanford summoned to appear June 30th with all affidavits
00:12they have secured relative to the Fagan slaying case. Just before the conference with both sides
00:17in the Frank case started, Judge Rohn intimated strongly that he would set the case for July 14th
00:22or July 28th and hold it in some more commodious courtroom than the one in which he sits on the
00:28fourth floor of the thrower building. Judge Rohn's personal inclination leans to a date in July,
00:33and it is not likely that the state or defense will object to acceding to his wishes.
00:38The date was definitely fixed for July 28th at the conference. The first important legal move by the
00:44defense in the battle for the life and freedom of Leo Frank, accused of the strangling of Mary Fagan,
00:50was made Tuesday in the issuance of subpenas duce tecum for the prime movers in the prosecution of
00:56the factory superintendent. The following have been subpoenaed to appear. Solicitor General Hugh M.
01:02Dorsey, who will prosecute the prisoner. Chief of Police James L. Beavers, who was the leader in
01:08obtaining incriminating affidavits. Pinkerton Detective Harry Scott, to whom is generally given
01:13credit for the admissions gained from Conley. All other city detectives who have worked on the case.
01:19All of them are ordered to produce any affidavits they may have bearing on the case in court June 30th,
01:24indicating that the defense will be prepared to go on with the trial at that time.
01:29Judge Rohn, however, had called a conference of the attorneys on both sides of the case for two
01:33o'clock in the afternoon, when he announced that he would set the date definitely after the attorneys
01:38had been given an opportunity to say whether or not their cases would be in shape to present,
01:43if the trial were called the last of this month, plan to use same evidence. The startling move on the
01:50part of the defense was taken to mean that Frank's lawyers proposed to use to free their client the
01:55very evidence the detectives and Solicitor General have collected to send him to the gallows.
02:00The most significant demand is made upon Chief Beavers, who is commanded to bring into court the
02:05famed series of affidavits made by the Negro sweeper Jim Conley. It is evident that attorneys
02:11Rosser and Arnold, who are conducting the defense, intend to tear the contradictory stories of the Negro to
02:17tatters, and make his statements so utterly ridiculous and improbable that the jury not only
02:23will refuse to accept them, but will interpret them as an effort of Conley to get from under the
02:28blame for a crime that he committed himself. Chief Beavers is asked to bring into court the written
02:33statement made by Conley May 18th in the presence of Detective John R. Black and Pinkerton Detective
02:38Harry Scott. Also, the affidavit sworn to by Conley before G.C. February in the presence of Chief
02:44Lanford and Detectives Black and Scott May 24th. The affidavit made by Conley May 28th. The affidavit
02:51made by the Negro May 29th in the presence of Lanford, Campbell, and Scott, and all other written
02:57statements of the Negro in the possession or control of the Chief. Girls also are called.
03:03Chief Beavers is asked in addition to bring all the statements of Newt Lee, the Negro night watchman,
03:08Monteen Stover, the girl who testified that Frank was not in his office when she went for her money,
03:14W.M. Matthews, and Miss Grace Hicks, the girl who first identified the dead body as that of Mary
03:20Fagan. The defense has persistently ridiculed the stories of Jim Conley and characterized them as
03:26cunning fabrications to shift the blame on Frank's shoulders. With the other affidavits, which for the
03:32most part are given credence by the defense, the attempt will be merely to show that the evidence
03:38which the prosecution holds to point toward the guilt of Frank only more firmly places it on the
03:44shoulders of the Negro sweeper, and that the state from time to time has shifted the ground on which
03:49it based its theory that Frank was guilty. Hooper calls move a trick. Frank A. Hooper, associated with
03:57solicitor Dorsey in the prosecution, branded the move of the defense as a thinly veiled trick to
04:03impeach the testimony of the witnesses called by the state, and said that it was not at all unlikely
04:08that the subpenies would be resisted. He intimated his belief that it was the intention of the defense
04:13to use the affidavits as a comparison with the testimony of the affiance when took the stand in an
04:19effort to pick out every discrepancy and thus seek to discredit the witnesses. Before the conference
04:25between Judge Roan and the attorneys on the opposing sides began in the afternoon, the judge
04:30announced that he would be the one who would set the date for the trial, after consulting the
04:35convenience of the attorneys. He said that he desired to preclude the possibility that the case
04:40would be called for June 30th, and the witnesses summoned, and then one or another of the attorneys
04:46ask for a postponement. He expressed it as his purpose to carry the case through to its completion
04:52once it was started. The judge said that he did not believe it right, in view of the warm weather,
04:57to call an umber of witnesses, and then delay the case further. He said that after the attorneys on
05:03the two sides had been heard, he would set the date himself. Arnold not decided. Reuben Arnold,
05:10one of the attorneys for the defense, said that he did not see how the defense could make any definite
05:15agreement on the date at this time because of the possible contingencies that might arise before the
05:20trial. Solicitor Dorsey has announced that he was prepared to go ahead with the trial at any time,
05:25that Leo M. Frank will go at once on trial for his life next Monday when he is brought before
05:30the
05:30court of the charge of strangling little Mary Fagan was the strong probability discussed in court circles
05:36Tuesday. The prosecution has announced that Fagan defense calls state's leaders, Frank's counsel
05:42Sue Pinas Dorsey, Beavers, and Lanford. Trick, says Hooper, continued from page one. Its case has been
05:49practically complete for days. The defense has said that all its vital witnesses have been found.
05:54There has been no intimation that a continuance will be asked unless it be for some contingency
06:00as the illness of Frank or of an important witness. The defense has been non-committal.
06:05The attorneys have not said that they would ask for a postponement. They also have refused to say
06:10that they would not seek a delay. Rosser-Reticent Luther Z. Rosser, Frank's attorney, has carefully
06:17avoided answering the direct question whether he would be ready for trial on that day.
06:21Ruben R. Arnold, associated with him, said the case was complete, but he too evaded a statement
06:27as to whether they would consent for the trial to begin next week. Solicitor Hugh M. Dorsey is making
06:33his preparations for the trial on the supposition that the defense will be ready, and he will urge
06:38before the court that the case be tried on the date set. He summoned the first witnesses Monday and
06:43Tuesday, and when court opens next Monday, he will have the corridors filled with persons who will
06:48testify against Frank. His preparations could not be more complete if he had received an announcement
06:54from the defense that no continuance would be asked. Both the prosecution and the defense will
06:59have at least twelve vital witnesses. The inability of one to attend the trial, unless by death or removal
07:06from the jurisdiction of the court, would necessitate a continuance until this witness could
07:11attend the trial. Arnold's stand. Attorney Arnold openly admitted that if one of his important
07:17witnesses was not able to appear in Frank's behalf when the case was called, he would move for a
07:22continuance and would not consider going to trial on the chance of the witness appearing later.
07:27J. M. Gant, one of the first to be arrested as a suspect, will be one of the most important
07:31witnesses for the state. Development, since he testified at the coroner's inquest, it is understood,
07:37have made his evidence of the utmost importance. He was one of the few witnesses to go before the
07:43grand jury when Frank was indicted, and he was closely questioned by the solicitor Monday afternoon
07:48when he finished questioning Conley. It is said that evidence that could have been given by him
07:53in the examinations before the Conley affidavit was made, but was considered of no relative importance
07:59then, is now of vital interest to the state and he will be one of the star witnesses.
08:04Jury panel drawn. Here is the first panel of jurors drawn.
08:08L. Knight, J. M. Clayton, C. G. Childs, J. S. Ball, Joseph H. Horacek, C. T. Neurl, T. J. Cheshire,
08:14C. L. Neer, W. T. Meters, T. L. Hindman, L. H. Walter, J. C. Roberts, L. P. Baker, H. D.
08:19Riley,
08:19C. T. Beaumar, J. D. Cloudman, G. H. Rowellator, W. G. Griffin, W. T. Waddell, T. C. Berggren,
08:24W. S. Reiser, W. F. Wesley, W. F. Stewart, W. R. Smith, H. S. Broadnax, D. A. White, J. Reid,
08:31J. R. Bailey,
08:31J. C. Clayton, H. C. Bentley, H. M. Robinson, E. M. Landrum, M. F. Rogers, Morris Frankel,
08:36W. W. Jones, R. S. Johnson, W. A. Wethington, A. R. Smith, Freeman Hiscox, John D. Wing, C. E. Long,
08:42W. T. McCullough, Leon McCandless, J. H. Rosie, L. Florence, G. H. Cathcart, L. H. Bartlett,
08:48P. Pound, S. W. Power, J. W. West, John C. Percy, J. C. McKenzie, J. T. Fair, D. T. Burson,
08:53T. F. Connelly, C. C. Bowling, J. C. Ball, C. W. Heary, W. M. Morgan, W. H. Patree,
08:58D. P. Pace, C. W. Puckett, J. A. Bankston, Johnston Miller, C. B. Mitchell, J. W. Delbeck,
09:03P. L. Sudan, H. M. Christie, At McNeely, John M. Green, W. W. Grabbit, J. H. Graham.
Comments
VERDICT VOYAGER
Creator
#MurderofMaryPhagan

Recommended