- 42 minutes ago
Experts discuss the trilateral meeting of US, China, and Russia leaders in Shenzhen, focusing on geopolitical outcomes and global security issues.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Geeta Mohan, group editor of Fine Affairs, joins me live.
00:03We have Gaurav Sawant live with us from Shenzhen, China.
00:07Rohit Sharma will be joining me in just a bit.
00:10Pranayupadhyay, editor of India Today Global, is live with us.
00:13We have Sandeep Unnithan as well, senior journalist on the show.
00:17I'm going to take forward the conversation that we had yesterday.
00:21And, you know, all of you would say that we told you so, it will be about optics.
00:25But Geeta, what did this actually deliver?
00:28Let's move beyond optics.
00:31Well, you know, Pranayupadhyay and I were discussing this just a while ago because the joint statement came.
00:39Firstly, for leaders to meet and to have a joint statement, even if it was a four-point consensus document,
00:47so to say,
00:48and if it was just peripheral in terms of UN reforms, energy security,
00:54things that the two sides are looking at when it comes to nuclear disarmament, proliferation, so on and so forth.
01:01They spoke.
01:02The fact that there was, the optics spoke volumes.
01:06The fact that they had bilateral conversations on very specific issues to do with country interests.
01:11And finally, they spoke of things that actually are important.
01:16There are no nitty-gritties, no nuanced conversation with regards to forward movement.
01:21So, we always knew there wasn't going to be a forward movement.
01:25But I didn't think that there's going to be an outcome document with four consensus points.
01:31That they're talking about, these are the countries, Mara, that veto any move of the United Nations.
01:37And they're talking about UN reforms.
01:39Energy flows, when they talk about, I know the focus for America, as Pran and I were discussing just a
01:44while ago,
01:45is to do with Venezuelan oil, American energy flowing into the world, America becoming a major supplier.
01:53But it also speaks about stability.
01:55And the opening remarks spoke of straight or foremost.
01:59So, Iran was discussed.
02:01Energy supplies and stability are key and priority.
02:04Nuclear disarmament and the nuclear race are very important.
02:09One clubbed that with what the Chinese president said, where he said,
02:11everybody should do away with nuclear weapons because you cannot have a war with nuclear weapons.
02:16That's never going to happen.
02:18Everybody will cease to exist.
02:20And this nuclear race then should stop.
02:23So, these are important points.
02:25I think they made important points.
02:26There was no separate country document that was coming.
02:29In contentious issues and countries who have differing viewpoints,
02:33forget about a chairman's summary or a joint document.
02:36They end up having country statements, particularly when we look at India and China.
02:41You can call them apples and oranges.
02:43But the fact that there was a document itself, I think, is important.
02:46Yes, I think, as Geeta said, so, Gaurav, the declaration here is calling for dialogue on reducing nuclear risks
02:55and preventing nuclear proliferation.
02:57Does it set out any concrete process, timetable or negotiating framework?
03:07Absolutely not.
03:09I mean, it's a sweet statement of intent.
03:11But when world leaders and especially the heads of three most powerful nuclear weapon states, Russia that has over 5
03:19,400 nuclear weapons,
03:21United States that has over 5,000 nuclear weapons, and China, which is desperately trying to catch up, has over
03:27700 nuclear weapons.
03:30You know, when they talk about doing away with nuclear weapons entirely, what's the roadmap?
03:35So there is a clear intent that's saying, fine, let's do away with nuclear weapons.
03:39Who will start?
03:40Who will monitor?
03:41Who will reduce the number of nuclear weapons that they have?
03:44So it's, you know, nice words being said.
03:46So, for example, they say, let's open global, you know, supply of oil.
03:52But what about the Strait of Hormuz?
03:54Even if you were to open global supply of oil, if it cannot cross the Strait of Hormuz, look at
04:00the problem countries in Asia are suffering.
04:04You know, India, ASEAN countries, China itself, unless the U.S. is trying to send out a message that they
04:10will pump out more oil.
04:12You know, Donald Trump wanted to say from the beginning of his presidency, drill, baby, drill.
04:17So they bring out more and they export more to China.
04:20And that's the other route that they want to follow.
04:24Point two, point three, you know, cutting international criminal code to size.
04:29Is the world okay with it?
04:31Will the big three decide how international criminal code decides the way it moves forward?
04:36There are multiple issues.
04:38And, you know, the big elephant in the room, Russia-Ukraine war, U.S.-Iran war.
04:42How is there forward movement on either?
04:45Perhaps some things have been decided.
04:46They haven't been put out in public domain.
04:49But the fact that both Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff, they've taken a flight to Berlin.
04:55You know, they're reaching out to both European powers and to President Zelensky.
04:59It remains to be seen whether there will be a move towards peace or an intensification of conflict.
05:05Okay.
05:06Okay.
05:06So come in now, Pranay.
05:08Xi Jinping certainly appears to be the biggest beneficiary of this meeting.
05:13Did hosting this three-way engagement strengthen China's diplomatic standing?
05:21Well, absolutely.
05:23No doubt about it.
05:24Look, the very fact that, you know, it was American idea.
05:28President Donald Trump wanted to have this G3 format.
05:31But the table was actually set in the Kiali Palace or Kiali Mention in Shenzhen of China.
05:37And in fact, China strategically, you know, posed it, strategically arranged it.
05:43And the message to the wider world is that China is one of the key player on the big table.
05:51And they are being included by the United States.
05:55Russia also recognized them as a big power.
05:58So this is their moment.
05:59But having said that, you know, as Geeta mentioned, I and Geeta had, you know, long conversation about the outcome
06:05and, you know, how this should be interpreted.
06:08My take is that, you know, the history has already been made.
06:11You know, this very fact that these three leaders have decided to sit across the table and at a time
06:18when the geopolitics is so turbulent, it's a historic moment.
06:22Though, you know, news agency Reuters, quoting the Russian news agency Interfax, citing that the Russian side declined the idea
06:29of having a successive, you know, follow-up meetings or making it a regular feature.
06:34But having said that, you know, the outcome document was in any case, you know, it had to be low
06:41on expectation only.
06:42What do you expect?
06:42This is the initial meeting.
06:44This is what they were meeting for the first time.
06:46I would summarize that this was actually a summation of the lowest common agreeable among these countries.
06:52In terms of deliverables, that will be carved out at some later point if they decide, if they agree.
06:59And I would again like to quote, you know, Prime Minister Nareen Modi highlighted the very fact during the G7
07:04meeting that the distrust and mistrust, or rather the trust deficit is the biggest issue as far as the global
07:11management is concerned.
07:12And I think to a large extent, this meeting sends out a message that there can be, you know, the
07:18bridges can be made, there can be a reach out.
07:20And in fact, these big three can also sit across and discuss uncomfortable issues.
07:26Yes, so they have managed to discuss a lot of issues, a lot of issues which were not even touched
07:32or perhaps touched, but not mentioned in the declaration.
07:35The fact that they agreed on four bullet points is an indication that this appears to be a durable formation
07:43for future.
07:44So, Rohit, how is Washington, D.C. looking at Donald Trump's achievements or, you know, presence, should I say, in
07:52this meeting?
07:54I think a lot of people are believing that it's a good step, especially if you talk to people in
08:00the administration.
08:00Look, you know, for the longest time, America had the policy of alienating the Russians and, you know, not talking
08:08to them, putting sanctions and whatnot.
08:09And we've seen what that led to.
08:11That led to two times Russia invading Ukraine, one under President Biden and the other time under President Obama.
08:17So I think President Trump is charting a new course.
08:20He wants to engage.
08:20It's something he said multiple times, that he would want to talk to these leaders.
08:24The Americans have tried to do it differently.
08:27It didn't work.
08:28You can't keep doing the same thing and expect different results.
08:30So I think it's a good step.
08:33As we all know, we do not know what tangible outcomes this would lead to.
08:37This is the intent to peace, as what we've been told.
08:40We'll look forward to what happens at G20, I think.
08:43But again, you know, as President Trump just now, he was speaking with NBC and he said he believes that
08:49the meeting was 12 on 10.
08:51His meeting with the Russian president and with the Chinese president was 12 on 10.
08:57So he believes it was a great step.
08:59We'll still await for more details to come in.
09:01I'm pretty sure he will gaggle in the next few days, speaking with all of us here, trying to explain
09:05what had happened.
09:06But I think at the end of the day, you know, I think the thought process is we want to
09:10see the end to these wars.
09:11And if this is what gets us the results, so be it.
09:15So I think this is a step in the right direction.
09:17Okay.
09:18Sandeep, you know, what's fascinating is that Donald Trump has managed to create multiple, these groupings.
09:26And as far as his own, you know, legacy will be seen, he will be seen as bringing together three
09:32powers.
09:34You know, while he may, it may not have happened in America, it has happened in China.
09:41But here are leaders who have done almost something which was unthinkable.
09:47Well, Malia, there's that idiom in English, motherhood and apple pie.
09:51You know, these are values that are so universal.
09:54There are things that everybody, nobody can really oppose.
09:58And that's precisely what this meeting has all been about.
10:02It's, you know, universal peace, brotherhood, friendship, energy security, all of these things which really have no tangible outcomes.
10:11I mean, let's face it that this meeting, right from the beginning, we've been seeing as being very high on
10:16optics and very low on deliverables.
10:18And that's exactly what's happened.
10:20We've had such low expectations out of this.
10:24And therefore, the outcomes are, you know, commensurate with that.
10:30Absolutely nothing tangible, a lot of optics.
10:33And I think that picture, of course, is historic.
10:36You have to give it to President Trump.
10:38He's a showman.
10:39He knows how to pull off a great photo op.
10:42And this is going to be his big sell to the American people.
10:46Look, I did this Yalta 2.0, whatever.
10:49This is not Yalta 2.0, firstly.
10:51You have Russia and the United States who are caught in two very difficult wars they're not being able to
10:57extricate themselves from.
10:59Yalta is a completely different, you know, time and space.
11:04And three great powers were deciding what the future of the world would look like.
11:08And they were victors.
11:09Here you have two countries that are, you know, trying to extricate themselves from wars.
11:13One has been on for nearly five years.
11:16The other one has been on for the better part of 2026, not counting what happened last year.
11:22And you have Xi Jinping in the center, very happy to play host and carry out a great photo op.
11:30So this is the ultimate photo op of the post-post-old war world.
11:33Beyond that, I don't attach anything to this.
11:35I mean, all of this is very, there is no one who will say that we want nuclear war or
11:41we don't want energy security.
11:42We don't believe in any of this.
11:44You know, so that is exactly what this has been all about.
11:47It's just been a lot of hangama and tamasha and that's it.
11:51It's a great photo op and that's what we'll remember from this.
11:54That's a lot of things.
11:55Since, you know, there is almost like a consensus here on this panel that it was photo opportunity,
12:01but Geetha says that there are some outcomes as well.
12:05So let's try and understand in terms of what was really the striking aspect of the photo opportunity for each
12:12one of you.
12:13I'm going to begin with you, Pranay.
12:15What really stood out for you in terms of imagery?
12:21I would, again, be compelled to repeat the references we made earlier as well to see the Thai color,
12:28you know, red, blue and violet, combination of red and blue.
12:31So, you know, starting with that, but the very setting of, like, you know,
12:37the emphasis of the Chinese presence there, the setting there, Russia being extra cautious,
12:42Chinese, U.S. President Donald Trump being, you know, like, trying to embrace with that moment that, you know,
12:50his idea has practified.
12:52You know, besides this optics, I kind of agree with Sandeep Arnitan that this was very high on optics,
13:00low on substance, low on deliverables.
13:02But certainly, you know, in terms of visual impact, this will be in history that, you know,
13:10the way China arranged this entire show, the way U.S. President Donald Trump conceived this show.
13:17But in terms of trust, in terms of, you know, what exactly the tangible and deliverables,
13:24that will yet to be seen because we have seen similar moments with President Donald Trump
13:29when he was there in Singapore meeting with Kim Jong-un.
13:33That was also a big event he created.
13:35Then him visiting, you know, DMZ area, crossing over the land border between South Korea and North Korea
13:43and visiting from South Korea to North Korea and stepping across the borders.
13:48That was also a big show he pulled off.
13:50But what exactly happened to those ideas?
13:54And, you know, the Russia, South Korea and North Korea are still, you know,
13:58having that the most dense zone on the planet, which is the DMZ, demilitarized zone, so-called.
14:03So it is still there.
14:05And President Donald Trump, you know, still talks about that issue.
14:08But it doesn't figure in his priority areas as yet.
14:13So, you know, he's known for pulling out big ideas, grand ideas.
14:17But when you talk about the exact deliverables, we have seen in terms of the Board of Peace,
14:22we have seen in terms of the Abraham Accords, all those good ideas, big ideas.
14:28But what exactly happened to those ideas?
14:31You know, ideas aside, would you say then, Gaurav,
14:36that this would be the biggest diplomatic imagery of 2026?
14:45Of this year?
14:46Well, it's high on optics, no doubt.
14:48But sure, of this year, it's a major event that's taken place.
14:53And end of the day, is global economy improving?
14:57End of the day, is the world getting more oil?
14:59End of the day, is the situation easing up between Russia and Ukraine?
15:02I mean, if you cry about 25,000 soldiers being lost every month,
15:06what are tangible steps that are being made to ensure that those lives are not lost?
15:10Because to a very large extent, Ukraine continues to be supplied with weapons by Europe.
15:16Europe continues to bank extensively, even if it's trying to, you know,
15:21distance itself from the United States of America.
15:23But, you know, somewhere down the line, where are solutions?
15:27There are great optics that are emerging.
15:29But beyond optics, where are solutions emerging?
15:31Great optics for Xi Jinping.
15:32If you ask me what stands out, Shenzhen stands out.
15:35Shenzhen stands out as a city of the future.
15:38Well, you know, President Xi Jinping has been able to send out that message.
15:41China is a power that's on the rise.
15:43U.S. is a power that may not be on a decline, but it's at least static and China is
15:47catching up.
15:48And Russia, well, it's a great shot in the arm for Russian President Vladimir Putin,
15:53who both America and Europe tried to isolate for four and a half years, for close to five years.
15:58They, you know, kind of the way, mannered in which he was vilified.
16:01But in the end, he's on center stage with the U.S. President and the Chinese President.
16:06But the fact that there is no repeat of this so-called G3 next time, what does it show?
16:11It was a one-off.
16:12It's not something as if the world order is changing.
16:16Multipolar world, yes, but multipolar world does not mean that USA will be replaced by China.
16:21Multipolar world actually means more democratic decision-making across the world.
16:26Okay, so what has actually changed after Shenzhen, Geetha?
16:33Well, technically nothing much, because like everybody has said, this is a letter of intent.
16:41It does not really carry the weight of action.
16:45And that certainly is something we have to look at.
16:49But having said that, and where did the leaders walk into?
16:55The leaders walked into, and that is what we are going to discuss in the other half of this hour.
17:01They walked into a room with a lot of distrust.
17:06Look, President Putin's video, telling video of his staff carrying that briefcase where one of the Russian journalists asked him,
17:13is this the nuclear briefcase?
17:15And he says, yes.
17:17And then the other aspect of America, the entire American delegation is burner phones.
17:24So where's the trust amongst these leaders if they have to carry burner phones, they have to carry their nuclear,
17:30which normally they do, the briefcase, so on and so forth.
17:34But imagery is important.
17:36They came with what they thought was a powerful message.
17:40And if you look at the initial remarks that all these leaders made, they were very good statements.
17:47If you look at the letter of intent, very good.
17:49Can this translate into real action and peace?
17:52We'll have to wait and see.
17:53Because the conversation on energy security cannot just be about Venezuela and America producing oil.
17:59It has to do with Strait of Hormuz.
18:01It has to do with Iran.
18:03And very importantly, Maria, the message over here from midterm to now is President Trump knowing that the losses were
18:12because America is not prepared to continue wars.
18:16It is a rejection of wars.
18:18So he goes back talking about peace and talking about the fact that there needs to be a resolution to
18:24Iraq.
18:24This can't continue.
18:25Come January, he will not have the money to continue it anyway.
18:30Sandeer, Puneetan, quickly, your last comments and then I'll give Rohit the last one.
18:35You know, 30 seconds.
18:36Yeah.
18:38You know, on the technology issue, the high-end technology issue, what happens to the NVIDIA case?
18:46Will China get access to high-end technology?
18:49That's where the real mistrust is in these countries.
18:52And Rohit can tell us more about this.
18:54But can I weigh in on that?
18:55Can I just say it?
18:56Because Gaurav and I had this entire conversation in a show, you know, a few hours ago, where I was
19:05mentioning that this would be maybe the first president in the history of American presidency, where to Fox News, he
19:12actually came out and said, well, we spy on China and China spies on us.
19:19I mean, what is American president?
19:21Yes, quickly.
19:22I have just enough time for final comments from everyone.
19:25I'm so sorry.
19:27I'm so sorry, but I have to ask this question.
19:29Since Rohit is here, Rohit, what will happen to the Lindsey Graham Act now?
19:33Okay, quickly.
19:33Rohit, you respond to that and then Sandeep has been very patient.
19:36Go ahead.
19:37Well, I think we've seen unprecedented, you know, gestures from the president.
19:42It's an unprecedented president we've had.
19:44So he would obviously offer comments like that, where he'd say, look, we spy on him.
19:47It's an open secret.
19:48Everybody knows that.
19:49I mean, it's, you know, but for him to say that in a candidate movement, he's been a candidate to
19:53president.
19:53As far as President Trump is concerned, I think, look, you know, a lot of people do not give him
19:57credit for, you know, taking initiative.
19:59And I think people should.
20:00Will it lead to any outcomes we'll have to wait and watch?
20:03But I will go back to what you were asked earlier, Murray.
20:05You know, what was the big takeaway from that, that big image?
20:08And I think that's the house of the dragon.
20:09I think that's what the Chinese president wanted to show.
20:13This is my area.
20:14You know, I am here sitting at the center, having these two powers talk to me and projecting a big
20:19image in front of the world, in front of his home audience.
20:22As far as President Trump is concerned, look, he'll come back.
20:25He obviously has a great, great, great advisor, Secretary Rubio, who has been a China hawk.
20:30So go back to what Pernay had asked.
20:32We'll have to take a look at it.
20:33I mean, it's not simple.
20:35The politics have changed.
20:36We'll have democratic leadership starting in January.
20:39So I think there are new realities that this presidency and administration will have to grapple with.
20:43But I think as far as this particular meeting goes, I think the big imagery in my thought process was,
20:48I think, Xi Jinping saying, this is my house.
20:51And, you know, this is my den.
20:52I've got these two leaders discussing important things with me.
20:55Big message for his domestic audience as well.
20:57Yes.
20:57And as Xi Jinping said, big nations have big responsibilities, Sandeep Unithan.
21:03But big responsibilities, yes.
21:05But when it comes to tangibles, they will put that or, you know, they will take that up perhaps later.
21:12Yes, absolutely, Maria.
21:13And, you know, just to take forward what Gaurav mentioned, and I said this on his show a little while
21:17earlier.
21:17I said the big takeaway for me is that image of those three countries over there.
21:21One is, of course, the manufacturing superpower.
21:24That's China.
21:25The other is the resource power.
21:26That's the Russian Federation.
21:27And the third is a country that used to be the sole superpower until now, which is getting used to
21:34living in a unipolar world.
21:36I cannot think of another time and space where an American president would go to China and stand between two
21:42leaders that they would consider, you know, adversaries.
21:47So this is unprecedented.
21:48And that photograph is literally the image of 2026 for me, Maria.
21:54Yes.
21:54And then President Trump saying, who is this?
21:59That's my friend referring to Vladimir Putin.
22:02I think those are really some imageries that emerged today.
22:06Really appreciate your time here on the show.
22:07And thank you for sharing your perspective and knowledge with our viewers, Geeta Mohan, Pranayopad,
22:13Sandeep Unidhan, Gaurav Savant and Rohit Sharma.
22:16We are putting out that entire discussion on our website and also on the YouTube channel.
22:20Thanks so much for watching.